Free Essay

Children's Upbringing

In: Novels

Submitted By Droodika
Words 813
Pages 4
Children's upbringing
We start in the first text called Why I love my strict Chinese mom from a newspaper. It is an inter-view from The New York Post interviewing Sophia Chua-Rubenfeld who describes her up-bringing as a child. She had a very strict mother who used methods as not letting the children attend sleep-overs, have play dates, be in school plays, complain about not being in a school play. The daughter goes on telling the interviewer that she does not think that her mother rose her badly, as most of society does. She thinks that the mother did a really good job and that she in no way have lost any possibilities of friendship and fun. The method the mother uses is to have a strict scheme of what the children can and cannot do which, in the end, turned out great for her kids who says "If I died tomorrow, I would die feeling I've lived my whole life at 110 percent."
The second text is called Let them eat pizza: parenting guru's recipe for bringing up children. Dr Bryan Caplan claims that activities such as music lessons, organized sports and educational games are a waste of time as they do not make the slightest difference to children when they mature. Parents should relax and give the children more slack and take a backseat role in the children's lives. Although he does subtly state that parents should make an effort to interact with their children until the age of 12 where after "it has no effect"
The third and last text is a general policy statement from the Summerhill School. The schools policy is that "Learning should come after play" They state that learning is less important than playing. They give the example of Nijinsky, a famous ballet dancer, who failed to get the grade he needed to attend the ballet school he wished. They say that other schools have too narrow out-look due to classroom walls and the National Curriculum. They believe that children are good and not evil beings, which is why they should have free reins instead of letting the children bow to the social pressure from their parents and schoolteachers to be someone they are not.
I will go on to discuss how A.S. Neill is engaging the reader in the text. He makes the example of Nijinsky which makes the reader think if they really are right and would have happened if he had not gotten help. He engages the reader to think in saying that people think that if a child is not learning something the child is wasting time, even though the readers may not think that. He uses examples such as Jane, Peter and Ivan who cannot live up to the social expectations and suffers for it.
I will try to discuss how I feel children should be raised by taking a starting point in all three texts. Actually I believe that all three methods are viable to an extent. Every text have some good points and some have outright wrong opinions in my vision on how children should be raised. I believe that children should be both held with a tight grip and loose chains in moderation. Children should get several boundaries that cannot cross until a certain age or until a certain accomplishment is achieved. For example if a kid is not allowed to go to a friend's house until their homework are done. In a way I feel the opposite of the third text saying "play before learning". I feel that children should make their homework or sometimes lie about having made their homework before they can play with friends. I believe that social activities physical or non-physical are a very important factor in the children's upbringing especially later in their lives. They have to have been trained in the skill of small-talking and making friends for without them they are not enjoying life to its full extent.
In reference to the tiger mother text I do not believe that kids should be kept under such strict rules prohibiting the children in entering school plays and never having or attending sleep overs. The fact that they are not allowed to play video games is neither something I think as the right way to go. Today video games can have a very big and good impact on children's methods of learning and they learn how many different things that are available to learn and can in that way dig into what they think they will occupy their lives with. Traveling the world or sitting behind a desk is completely the children's choice and not something the parents are to decide.

--------------------------------------------
[ 1 ]. Why I love my Chinese mom. Page 4, bottom.
[ 2 ]. Let them eat pizza. Page 2, bottom.
[ 3 ]. Summerhill. Page 1, top.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior

...Many Westerns people describe the Chinese mothers methods of upbringing as strict, pushy and some times directly cruel. The article “Why Chinese Mothers are Superior” deals with these differences between methods of upbringing, written by the 48-year-old Chinese-American mother Amy Chua and it is thereby seen from her point of view. The author Amy Chua is a professor at Yale Law School and has two daughters herself, whom she is raising very strictly with lots of rules and big demands. Chua claims that the way that Chinese mothers are upbringing their children, is superior compared to the Western mothers methods of upbringing. She underlines than in order to achieve success, the children must focus on certain priority areas, and therefore they are forced to give up other things. This is why her own daughters are not allowed to attend to sleepovers, choose their own extracurricular activities and they are demand to be the very best in every subject except gym and drama. This is only a few of the rules, which Chua’s daughters must live by. Chua underlines that one of the most important parts of upbringing in Chinese manner, is to make the child feel confident. “Once a child starts to excel at something – whether its math, piano, pitching or ballet – he or she gets praise, admiration and satisfaction....

Words: 1057 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

English Chinese Mothers

...Amy Chua wrote this article about upbringing and parenting with a focus on her own children and her own parenting. The main purpose of this article is to explain to the readers why this strict upbringing method is a good and normal way of raising children in particularly China. The structure of this article is a lot more different than...

Words: 952 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Veldt

...George and Lydia Hadley, the parents in Ray Bradbury’s “The Veldt”, made many bad choices that had great effect on their children’s personalities. Since the Hadley family lives in a futuristic house that does everything for the children, Peter and Wendy, they started to grow apart from their parents. As a consequence, the children noticed they didn’t need their “real” parents any longer and developed a plan to get rid of them. Nonetheless, George and Lydia Hadley are self-responsible for their murder. George and Lydia disregarded their parental responsibility to a high degree. Instead of caring for Wendy and Peter, they had their house to care for everything and everybody. The house cooked, comforted and even played with the children. According to Lydia, the house has become “wife and mother now, and nursemaid.” It took over the role of the parents:”You’ve let this room and this house replace you and your wife in your children’s affections.” George was often too busy to spend time with his children. These examples show that George and Lydia didn’t care too much for their children and missed out on the children’s nurturing. Further, the psychological care of the children was too long handed over to the nursery. Although the nursery was supposed to help the children “work off their neuroses in a healthful way”, they developed other bad behaviors. Instead of “release” the room caused only “destructive thoughts”....

Words: 501 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Conto

...But is the paternity leave so important, and does the British government make changes in children’s childhood by letting the fathers get leave? In the article “Parenting: From Boys To Men To Fatherhood” written by Shirley Henderson, studies conducted by the National Fatherhood Initiative in Gaithersburg, Md., indicate that Black males who grow up fatherless are more likely to have problems in school, to become violent criminals and are more likely to commit suicide. These statements are completely in common with Karl Zinsmeister’s, and furthermore he points at problems which causes the family. Zinmeister is from the American Enterprise Institute and said that crisis dealing with drugs, early pregnancy and education crisis is because of broken families. While these problems are indicated Professor Charlie Lewis of Lancaster University, who has been studying...

Words: 994 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Role of Parents and Schools

...Parents in the basic sense are their children’s first teachers. Through all the activities they are engaged in together as the child develops up to the pre-school level, parents help the child participate in cooking, cleaning and gardening, the child is slowly eased into the world of learning. The parents also provide the link to formal education by actively participating in their children’s schooling activities and thus making an easy transition for the children into the formal learning structures. Schools are charged with the huge role of moulding their charges from the moment they are enrolled with no or little formal education into a productive person in the society. This is a mammoth task which when not taken up keenly may irreparably damage the lives of many individuals in their adulthood. Parents and schools hold the role of ensuring adequate intellectual development of the individuals placed under their watch. Parents do this right from birth with the basic knowledge they instil in their children. When the children attain school going age, the participation of parents in this...

Words: 1022 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Issue 130

...Issue 130 At stake are the polemics over the extent of impact children’s socialization brings to the society and that whether we have gripped the pith of effective upbringing of children. In my view, however, I am hard pressed to consent with the speaker’s claim; the fruition of the destiny of society springs from multiple factors and that if the socialization of children is the sole litmus test dominating the well-being of the society, then we all prove well in raising our children based on the underlying status quo of the society. Consider the speaker’s first claim about the significance of children’s socialization. Admittedly, at first blush, hardly can we deny the profound contribution children’s socialization bestows to the whole society. By complying with the mores and rules stipulated by a certain culture, which by definition illustrates the core meaning of socialization, children have unintentionally shunned the potential pitfalls which might mire them and render themselves canker to the society. This is especially true when it comes to the college life. A fitting example which aptly supports my claim is the campus shooting crimes. Ill-bred and totally secluded from the outside world, those brutal criminals were somehow insulated from any sort of socialization, thereby rendering themselves mavericks and ultimately resulted in these adversities....

Words: 605 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Sv: City-Profil Snart Tilbage

...In this essay, she is writing about her mother’s upbringing from her point of view and that she is very thankful for her, because her strict parenting has forced her to be more independent. In the essay, she tells us some of the childraising principles her mother used on her. When she got to high school, her mother realized that she needed to grow up. All the girls in her school started using makeups and that is why she took Sophia to a drugstore to buy some makeup and taught her to use it. Another thing is that the mother taught Sophia to live life to the fullest. She was not satisfied, when Sophia did not do her best at something and therefore she taught her to push her body, to the limits of her potential. Her father has also had an impact on her upbringing. He taught her not to speculate about people’s opinion and to make her own decisions. The other text is the one called "Let them eat pizza: Parenting guru's recipe for bringing up children", by Kate Loveys. Dr Bryan Caplan is the opposite of “Tiger Mum”. When it comes to parenting children, Dr Bryan Caplan thinks that parents often try to control every side of their children’s lives. He claims that they are overcharging themselves for their kids, and he easily thinks that they can improve their children’s development without harming them. He states that parents should “cut themselves some slack” with means be less critical or harsh against someone. Then he also calls for a relaxed and style of...

Words: 480 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior

...When it comes to a successful upbringing for their children, Amy Chua believes that the Western way has it deficiencies. As a parent, you might have some sort of blindness when it comes to seeing your own mistakes about raising your children. Amy Chua therefore tries to explain what can be changed, in order to achieve a more successful child. By revealing these differences in the way of raising a child, respectively in a Chinese way and in a Western way, Amy Chua makes the reader consider, if the Western way really is the way to prefer. The article expounds the Chinese way of raising children in contrast to the Western way. According to Amy Chua, mother of two Chinese girls, the main problem is the Western parent’s mentality. The parent’s apprehension of emotionally hurting their children prevents the children to fully shape in to a successful person. Chinese parents on the other hand do not have that sort of filter. They are willing to be strict towards their children, even giving them a negative nickname such as “fatty”, or directly demanding them to lose weight because they have become too fat. As Amy Chua enlarge on: “Western parents are concerned about their children’s psyches. Chinese parents aren’t.”(Page 8). Furthermore, Amy Chua...

Words: 1011 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Yeah

...This parenting style emphasizes parental high control and children’s obedience to parents (Kang & Moore, 2011). As children have any misbehaviors or rebellions, scolding and physical punishment are usually used to discipline children (Chan, 2010). However, this explanation is the stereotyped recognition different from the Chinese’s perception. A large number of Chinese parents tend to believe that the strict caretaking is suitable and effective for Chinese. The authoritarian parenting is used by many Chinese parents, and they think that it is beneficial for Chinese children in terms of the unique Chinese ideological and the academic aspects. The authoritarian parenting style implies a distinctive notion for Chinese in acquiring the Chinese special qualities. After analyzing the data about the parenting styles collected from 100 mothers who are immigrated Chinese and European-American, Chao (1994) finds that this parenting is mainly used by Chinese mothers and Chao further claims that they aim to provide designed ‘training’ specifically appropriate for Chinese children. This sort of ‘training’ is summarized to be able to embody the ideologies of the ancient Confucianism, meaning “… that children must show loyalty and respect to their elders…” (Chao, 1994, p.1117). These important virtues can be traced back to the traditional Chinese Confucian doctrines....

Words: 988 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Chineese Mothers

...Nevertheless, the article makes the reader ponder about which way of upbringing is most preferable? Kommentar [P91]: En god tragtindledning, der går fra noget generelt til det konkrete i artiklen. Fint, at du får nævnt de faktuelle oplysninger som skribent, genre, titel og udgivelsestidspunkt. Chua builds up the article to persuade the reader into believing that Chinese mothers are not as cruel as they are represented in everyday life. Firstly, she commences the article by telling briefly about herself, thus building up her ethos. Thereupon, she anticipates potential arguments, e.g. “I’m using the term “Chinese mother” loosely.” (page 6, line 22) and, “I’m also using the term “Western parents” loosely. Western parents come in all varieties.” (page 6, lines 25-26). By doing so, she manages to beat the reader to it, thus making sure to approach the reader about the fact that she is going to be generalizing. Furthermore, statistics are utilized in order to show how the parents prioritize their children’s discretion, i.e. the Western American mothers are of the opinion that, “stressing academic success is not good for children” (page 7, lines 35-36), and that “academic achievement reflects successful parenting” (page 7, line 39). By virtue of this, the reader is more inclined to agree...

Words: 1468 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior

...Of course her upbringing way seems very unreal but she arrange it in a more understandable way. One of the statements Amy Chua uses is: “All the same, even when Western parents think they’re being strict, they usually don’t come close to being Chinese mothers” (P. 6 ll. 27-28) In this...

Words: 1140 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Influence of the Father on His Child

...The purpose of this research is to examine the role of the father and his child’s upbringing and to determine whether that role has a positive or negative effect. The findings will support the eight recurrent themes evolving from the 12 master themes of the eight participants. In accordance to the overall field of Psychology, this review relates to Chapter 8, Friendship and Love Relationships of our textbook. The section titled Links between Attachment in Childhood and Close Relationships in adults clearly correlates to how children’s upbringing influences how they handle relationships.This article is different and similar from articles in non-scholar periodicals such as magazines and newspapers in that all three are the most commonly used. And,...

Words: 1057 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Grandparents and Kids

...Also, the act of grandparents being an important contribution to a grandchild’s birth and upbringing is seen to be a trend that is universal among humans. A normal family comprises of grandparents, parents and children. It may also include aunts and uncles. In a family where both parents go to work, it’s the grandparents who take care of the kids during the time when the kids’ parents are away on duty; thus, the parents can comfortably work with no cause of alarm over their children’s safety. For the grandparents, their sunset years need not to be spent living in solitude and therefore an advantage to their well-being. They thus play a crucial role in the upbringing of their grandchildren. It has been proved via studies that children from families where grandparents are part of their lives have good social skills. They interact better with other kids. They also have a better feeling of security and have a lesser probability of involving themselves in bad behaviors or falling into depression. Grandparents are also significant role-players in maintaining the children’s observance of their culture(s) and values. For instance, in India, it’s a common thing for children to grow up founded on myths taught to them by their grandparents; these stories build their character. It is common knowledge that grandparents symbolize wisdom; they speak based on experience and teach their grandchildren on ways to go about where they were and/or have been to....

Words: 608 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Lit 210 Week 8 Dqs

...If you could change any of the major agents of socialization in your own upbringing, what would you change and why? Do you think thi...

Words: 367 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Chinese Mothers Are Superior

...Another intention is to defend the Chinese way of upbringing their children. At last, she wants to contrast Chinese parenting and Western parenting and explain how and why Chinese parenting, in her opinion, is more effective. A way to get the author’s attention across is by using anaphora. Numerous times throughout the essay Chua repeats “By contrast…” at the beginning of a sentence. By this, she is making it very clear, that there is a great difference between the Western and Chinese way of parenting. This is an effective move, because the reader is constantly reminded that these two types of parenting are not comparable in Chua’s mind. We also experience a repetition in terms of actions of the author. It seems like there is a cycle of Chinese parenting in Chua’s life. She raised her...

Words: 1233 - Pages: 5