Free Essay

Cisco Case Analysis

In: Business and Management

Submitted By regman89
Words 1141
Pages 5
| | Assignment: Enterprise IT at Cisco Case Write-Up |
Summary:
Enterprise IT at Cisco Systems is an interesting case that demonstrates what happens when a company’s IT infrastructure is decentralized. In the case of Cisco, the word decentralized was demonstrated in how the individual departments conducted business in their own ways and not in conjunction with other business functions. At one point, this approach was encouraged as it was believed to allow departments, and the people running them, the ability to avoid company politics, to ensure their priorities were met, and to encourage each department and individual the opportunity to be creative and innovative, which is a fundamental component of Cisco’s company style. Brad Boston, CIO of Cisco, believed that it was possible to retain that company attitude of innovation in a more centralized manner to decrease redundancy and formally integrate systems. While there was a great deal of pushback from employees, and the full centralization will take a great bit of time, Boston was making the best choices for the company.

1. How did Cisco find itself in such trouble with regard to its internal IT in 2001? Why didn’t the single ERP system help more? Why didn’t this ensure more consistency? As briefly mentioned above, Cisco found itself in such trouble as a result of allowing every department and employee operate freely and with little regard for what others were doing. As stated on page 4 of the case study, “Boston also discovered that IT decisions were made in functional silos, with no centralized group checking for conflicts and redundancies.” If employees had checked to see if specific applications had been created to measure various areas, they would have seen multiple applications already in existence. Instead, each time a particular function or application was needed, a new one was created that added to the build-up within the system. Not only did it add to the build-up within the system, but also it wasted money on repeating functions.

The single ERP system did not help Cisco’s troubles or ensure more consistency. Cisco had a single ERP system that housed and stored all of the data inputted company-wide and was chosen primarily to manage inventory and manufacturing. The data included custom reports, applications, and more. However, the single ERP did not turn the information inputted into data that was usable or consistent for everyone. As a result, reports measuring similar data would yield different results. This led to initial studies providing some value for the person or team who requested the information, but when information was needed from a “big picture” viewpoint, the numbers did not add up. 2. Would you approve the call center project? Why or why not? The call center project certainly has an appeal and should be approved, but it should only be approved on a contingent basis. The goal of the call center is to fully integrate Cisco’s technology to be able to take calls, route them, and escalate them to the necessary personnel. In order for this to work, Cisco must be fully centralized and have all of the tangled webs from the old system undone and fully worked out. This would then support customer input in a measurable and easily attainable way that can be tracked company-wide. Boston’s new system is a massive overhaul and one that costs significant money and time to roll out. Part of his proposed changes is to centralize project management, as well, in terms of funding, board-member involvement, project importance, and expected results of each project. Once Boston’s work is done and assuming the requests are not met as a result of the e-customer solution, and if the customer advocacy group can support their request, then it is absolutely a viable project to consider and one that will benefit Cisco. 3. What was Pete Solvik’s approach to IT decision making at Cisco? Did he think that line managers should get to make all IT decisions? If not, which ones did he want the IT function to make, and which did he want the business units to make? Peter Solvik’s approach was the opposite of what Boston was seeking: a decentralized IT decision maker. But, he made necessary changes at a time when Cisco’s operations were vastly different from the point in time of the study. His approach was to change the notion that IT was considered overhead. As noted on page 3 of the case, he did this by moving IT to the customer advocacy group, reallocating the IT budget to the individual department or function, and made it so that IT investment decisions on application projects were “pushed out to the line organization but still executed by the centralized IT organization.” Solvik did believe that line managers should get to make all the decisions. This was evidenced by the creation of the silos, which led to no one checking for redundancy or inefficiency. What this created was a buildup of information that did not allow for cross-department utilization. Additionally, it led to overspending on redundant application needs and an increased difficulty for Boston when it cam to sorting out the sizeable data in the legacy ERP. 4. What is ‘shadow IT’? Why would a CIO want to control/minimize it? Are there effective ways to do so? Do you think Boston’s amnesty program will work? Does it stand a good chance of uncovering all or most of Cisco’s shadow IT projects? The “shadow IT” projects mentioned in the case refer to the teams and employees who were averse to the change initiative Boston was performing. Rather than comply with his request to cease any new application development until things got sorted out, some teams continued to call on IT employees to develop their needs. These shadow projects typically came out of the shadows when the projects grew too large for one person’s capabilities. The existence of the shadow IT makes the change initiative Boston sought more difficult to implement, and thus he would want to minimize it so that the problems do not continue to worsen. Once Boston’s goals of a company-wide fully integrated system become clearer to staff, the amnesty program should work. As with most situations, change is not generally handled well. Thus, it is up to Boston and his supporting staff to communicate effectively to all employees at all levels, and work with those who express significant resistance to open their mind to the new idea and show them how the new measures will benefit. Additionally, the amnesty program will work as long as it is enforced and violation of the program results in clear consequences and is strongly enforced.

Works Cited McAfee, Andrew; McFarlan, F. Warren; and Wagonfeld, Alison. “Enterprise IT at Cisco (2004).” HBS No. 9-605-015. Boston: Harvard Business School Publishing, 2007.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Cisco Case Analysis

...CISCO PRELIMINARY CASE ANALYSIS Using manual processes for sales orders The success of Cisco business adventures brought them a good, but difficult problem to handle. With an increasing amount of orders to fulfill and manufacture, Cisco understood that it needed to automate and scale their process in order to continue their growth and sustain their market dominance. The company used only manual processes, such as receiving orders that were faxed, or entering them individually on a web portal. These processes are very time consuming for both, the service provider and the customer. Both parties needed to keep track of a lot of paperwork which included: the submission of orders, specific requirements for those orders, level of inventories, invoices, receipts, delivery instructions… Companies would spend a lot of time and money to keep good track of all of this information being exchanged; which in return decreased their speed, profits and quality of service provided. Large orders could cost Cisco up to $500,000; which decreased their bargaining power with their buyers and opened opportunities for industry competitors that could provide a better service. In the late 1990’s, Cisco developed the Cisco B2B Operations group to automate data links, processes, improve sales orders, inventory management; and allow partners to place their own orders, giving them more up-to-date information on the status of their orders. This challenge allowed Cisco to keep the competition from...

Words: 1109 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Hp Merced

...MSIS604/OMIS378 Information Systems Policy & Strategy Spring Quarter, 2013—2 April/13 June Instructor: Dr. Darrel A. (Del) Mank dmank@scu.edu Cell Phone: 408-605-3983 Office Hours: By appointment Office: Room 321W Lucas Hall Class Days: TTh Class Period: 5:45pm—7:00pm Class Room: 310 Lucas Hall Text: Schilling, Melissa A.; STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT of TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATION, McGraw-Hill/Irwin, 4th Edition, 2013 ISBN 978-0-07-802923-3 Cases* Hewlett-Packard Merced Division SAP America VMware Inc., 2008 IBM and Eclipse (A) Oracle vs. salesforce.com Enterprise IT at Cisco (2004) Google Inc. *All Cases are from the Harvard Business Review and are available at the SCU Bookstore Course Objectives: • To develop an awareness of the range, scope, and complexity of the issues and problems related to the strategic management of ISTs. • To develop an understanding of the “state of the art” of the strategic management of IST and IST innovation. • To develop a conceptual framework for assessing IST capabilities. • To develop insight concerning the skills necessary to be effective as an IST manager. • To offer some practice in defining and working out strategic management problems related IST innovation and implementation. Course Description/Perspective: The course focuses on the strategic management and deployment of information systems and technologies (ISTs) to improve business competitiveness. The...

Words: 3892 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Knlkn35Mowih5By Oihjn Knhgi3Mhe5U

...Unique #04780 | Professor John N. Doggett Class Days Monday and Wednesdays from 12:30 to 2:00 p.m. Class Room UTC 4.104 Office CBA 5.124k Office Hours Wednesdays, 5:30 to 6:30 p.m. or by appointment Phone 512-232-7671 E-Mail john.doggett@mccombs.utexas.edu Course Web Page via Canvas ------------------------------------------------- Teaching Assistants Grant Garlinghouse (grant.garlinghouse@mba14.mccombs.utexas.edu) Course Objectives I have taught this course since late in the last century. Today, as we approach a second global recession, helping people learn how to grow firms as astutely as possible will play a role in speeding the beginning of a new recovery. When companies like Cisco and HP abandon major market segments, it is even more important to think critically about how to grow a firm’s products. Given the chaotic period that we are entering, I have made several significant changes to this course. First, I have done away with the individual midterm. The “next” recovery will be a group effort. So will your midterm. Second, I have assigned three books. These are some of the best books out there on how to think about innovation, competition and how to grow a business. They will become “let me read that again” go-to books that you will use long after you graduate from UT. To compensate for the heavy reading load, I have eliminated most of the background notes from the course. Third, we are going to take...

Words: 4864 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Ibc Case

...Management s374: General Management & Strategy The University of Texas at Austin - Summer 2015 Dennis S. Passovoy (Professor) (512) 471-2195 GSB 5.124G (in McCombs) via Canvas INBOX Davit Davtyan (TA) Phone: Office: E-Mail: Office Hours: M T W TH 1:00 – 1:45pm, or by appointment M T W TH 9:00 – 9:45am, or by appointment Class: #72305 (July 13 – August 14) M T W TH 2:00 – 3:45pm CBA 4.328 CBA 4.304A (in McCombs) via Canvas INBOX Prerequisites • • • • • • Upper-division standing Seventy-five semester hours of coursework, including: Management 336 or 336H Credit or registration for Finance 357 or 357H, and Marketing 337 or 337H And credit or registration for one of the following: Accounting 353J, 366P, Business Administration 353H, Finance 353, 366P, Management 353, 366P, Management Information Systems 353, 366P, Marketing 353, 366P, Operations Management 353, or 366P. May be counted toward the writing flag requirement. May be counted toward the independent inquiry flag requirement. Course Description This course is restricted to students in a McCombs School of Business major. It is designed to enable students to analyze business situations from the point of view of the practicing general manager. Addresses key tasks involved in general management, including strategic decisions that ensure the longterm health of the entire firm or a major division. Writing Flag This course carries the Writing Flag as well as the Independent...

Words: 4994 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Ob, Arctic Minings Consultants, Case Study

...ARCTIC MINING CONSULTANTS Case Synopsis Arctic Mining Consultants is a mining company that deals with mineral exploration. In this case study, the project given is staking 15 claims in Eagle Lake, Alaska. The project Manager was Tom Parker, who has a wide experience and specialized knowledge in all nontechnical aspects of mineral exploration. He is a geological field technician and field coordinator for Arctic Mining Consultants. He assigned his previous field assistants John Talbot, Greg Boyce and Brian Millar to help him complete the project. The job required them to stake at least 7 lengths each day in order to be completed on time. However, the whole team has became very tense and agitated, especially Tom Parker, as the deadline was just around the corner and there’s still many to be finished within the limited time. The problem became worse with the way Tom managed and treated his team. The only motivation to the team was the $300 bonuses promised by the company when the job is done on time, otherwise, they might wished to give up already. This happened because working as a field assistant and in long-working hours only giving them low wages, which is considered unreasonable compared to what they have to do. During the eight hard days, everything had actually proved the strengths and weaknesses of each of the team members, including Tom. Case analysis symptoms 1) What symptom(s) exist in this case to suggest that something has gone wrong? The symptom(s) to suggest...

Words: 2346 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Imp Case Analysis

...1. Would a TNA be needed in this situation? Why or why not? If yes, who would you want to talk to? Training Needs Analysis is a formal process required for the purpose of identifying the training gap that is in existence and its related training need. Considering the IMP case analysis, training needs analysis is required since there are different sectors within the organization which require an individual to possess the necessary skills to perform the expected work within that department. In addition, training is also offered to people working within the ‘different sectors’ in that organization despite the fact that equality is not displayed while offering that form of training. Talking to the HR manager at North America International Airport’s about training needs analysis is a good idea since the HR manager is the one with the authority over the individual’s directly concerned with training such as Mr. Pettipas. 2. Based on the case as presented above, what KSAs need to be trained? From the case analysis at IMP, it is evident that there are several knowledge, skills and abilities that have to be addressed during training to all the employees within those departments. Leadership skills need to be addressed since the HR was not able to assist Ms. Dillman in her case which portrayed that he lacked the leadership skills. Technician skills required for the metal sheet shop needs to be trained since Ms. Dillman lacked knowledge on the requirement of a metal sheet shop technician...

Words: 733 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Craddock Cup

...✓ Materials Needed Performance Measurement & Control Systems for Implementing Strategy: Text and Cases, by Simons, Robert. Prentice Hall, ISBN #0-13-234006-2 Cases in Management Accounting & Control Systems 4th Edition, by Allen, Brownlee, Haskins and Lynch, Pearson-Prentice Hall, ISBN #0-13-570425-1 Freakonomics: A Rouge Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything, by Steven D. Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner, Harper Collins, ISBN#0-06-073132-X ✓ University Communication with Students All email communication from the University is sent to the student’s wsu.edu address. Please be sure that you have set up the link to forward your personal email address (aol, hotmail, etc.) or you will miss announcements and information that is very important to you. This is the email I use to contact you regarding class matters. If you change your email address, be sure to update again. ✓ Catalog Course Description with Prerequisitites 3credits: Managerial evaluation of budgeting, cost accounting, and financial analysis techniques; their utilization in control of operations. (pre-requisite acctg 550 or equivalent). Please note that pre-requisites are strictly enforced and that students will be disenrolled if they do not have course pre-requisites). ✓ Instructor Course Objectives Knowledge and Skill Expectations: Students should have the knowledge and skill level to record economic events, read and analyze financial information through the topic areas covered...

Words: 3504 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Ritz-Carlton Case

...Title Page Course – MKTG 6300 Fall 2007 Service Marketing Student Name: Maria E. Kobayashi Individual Case Analysis Individual Case Summary: Ritz – Carlton Hotels 1. Key issues Ritz – Carlton (RC) wants to be perceived as the premier luxury hotel, with differentiated and personalized service, high levels of guest retention and guest recovery rates, and low levels of service defect incidence. The group wants to achieve this goal by optimizing the balance between human relationships and the systems. Nevertheless, the systems and databases RC had in place at the time of the case do not deliver the level of information needed to reach their objective. Moreover, they do not allow for smooth interaction with the RC team, who are able to gather highly valuable information regarding customers’ preferences, dislikes, or potential problems experimented by the guests. 2. Recommendations First of all, the Encore system should be modified to include real-time updating of customers’ preferences and of potential problems the guests might have experimented during their stay. This should be standardized across all RC properties. Guest categorization should also be standardized and input into the system. This system should be available in a user-friendly way to any member of the RC staff in convenient locations. It should also include a common defect reporting module with the functionality to cross data between different locations. After all these processes...

Words: 382 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Moto Case Analysis

...In the case, a man who goes by the name Moto is sent to Chicago to do business. Here his “responsibility was to hire a contracting company and check on the pricing details.” He works for an auto parts supplier, KKD, who had been researching American contracting companies for the past year and a half. They decided to use Allmack due to it having the best track record. Moto went to meet with a man who worked for the company and was shocked by his rudeness and unprofessional manner. He wasn’t prepared for this and had no idea what to think of it. Also, he was not so used to moving so quickly and rushing around. In America, people are very fast passed and try to get things done as quickly as possible. He presented Mr. Crowell with a gift and he just stated that his daughter would love it. When Crowell said this, Moto should have gone in to a discussion explaining what the dolls meant and the importance of them. This way he could have shown Crowell the value in the gift he was giving him and he would have taken back the comment about his daughter loving them. Throughout the case there are many differences that Moto is shocked by. One of these is the fact that he is used to being called by his last name. He was surprised when Crowell asked for his first name and began calling him by that instead. Also, he wanted proof that the Allmack group was actually as good as they say they are. He asked for records and one of the workers got offended and was wondering why he did not trust them...

Words: 415 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

469362181

...to time to write a good CAR. So, once you “get” the Big Picture of the Case, and recognize the major analysis elements (focal system(s), main problem/Alternatives, etc.): o focus on analyzing those Alternatives and coming up with some significant Findings, and especially Recommendations. o As your analysis results “solidify,” focus more and more on Writing a Good CAR and submitting by the Due Date! • Cases can contain more than 1 major “track” for their analysis, allowing for alternative versions of a CAR. So, do NOT simply imitate this Example CAR blindly for its “specific content.” Worse, DO NOT simply copy any of its parts. • Instead, use this Example CAR by way of “Reverse Engineering:” See how its contents arise logically if our Case Analysis Method (Guide) is applied to the Case. This will help you understand how our analysis method works! Then, use the same general analysis method (actually, the Approach) on the Case assigned for your CAR. • Don’t just imitate the pattern of alternative found here! Analyse and find out what alternatives make most sense in the particular Case you are working on. • No Case contains ALL the facts you want to know for its analysis. So, when analyzing Cases, be pragmatic! Do not worry about any facts beyond the Case (unless specifically instructed). Instead, conduct the “best possible” analysis using available Case-facts. • Leave Enough Time to Write a GOOD REPORT based on your...

Words: 1972 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Power and Influece

...discussing “case” materials in light of theoretical arguments advanced in “readings.” Case materials include standard Harvard Business School cases, book chapters about individuals (Robert Moses and Henry Kissinger), corporations (e.g., Lehman Brothers and Time Warner), and industries (e.g., the auto industry), and in-class videos (e.g., a “Bill Moyer’s Journal” segment on David Rockefeller). COURSE REQUIREMENTS Final course grades will be based on student performance on three written assignments and on student participation in class discussions. Written Assignments. Each student will be expected to submit two individual case analyses that indicate what the student learned from reading and discussing the case in question. The case analyses should be one single spaced typewritten page long and should be submitted the week after the case that they address is discussed in class. Individual case analyses will be graded on a scale from 1-3 and together will comprise 10% of a student’s final grade. Each student should also form a group with three to four other students to complete a case study of a real organization. The research for this case study can be carried out using primary sources (e.g., participation observation and/or interviews) or secondary sources (e.g., books, articles, or prepared cases about a target organization). Thus, group members need not have worked in an organization to use it as the subject of their final case analysis. Other case analysis topics...

Words: 1326 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Ase Analysis Research – Striving for Best Academic Practice

...ZhiQing | Student ID No.: | 22012511 | Unit Code & Name: | MNG91002 | Campus: | MDIS | Tutor’s Name: | Frankie-Lim | Assignment No: | 1 | Assignment Title: | Case Analysis Research – Striving for Best Academic Practice | Word Count: | 1193 | Due Date: | 21 Apr 2014 | Date submitted: | 20 Apr 2014 | Declaration: I declare that this assignment is my own original work and has not been submitted for assessment elsewhere. I acknowledge and irrevocably agree that the assessor of this assignment may, for the purpose of assessing this assignment: * Reproduce this assignment and provide a copy to another member of faculty for review and comment, including whether the work is an original work; and/or * Provide a copy of this assignment to a plagiarism checking service for review so that it may determine whether the assignment is an original work. The checking service may retain a copy of the assignment on its database for the purpose of future plagiarism checking. I have read and understand the Rules relating to Awards (Rule 3.17) as contained in the University Handbook. I understand the penalties that apply for plagiarism and agree to be bound by these rules. CHEN ZHIQING 20 Apr 2014 Signature (please type) Date Tutor's comments: Paper Title: Case Analysis Research –...

Words: 1822 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Northco Case

...Northco Case Analysis Johannes Röder, 154BB14B 1. How should Michaels think about the costs of over and under-stocking? Identify the elements of over and under-stocking cost in this case. These two cost factors result from the lack of the ability to match supply with demand. The costs of overstocking depict the cost per unit that arise if actual demand is lower than the expected one. In this particular case the elements of overstocking are the orders of customers in advance without payment, the obsolescence of the goods owing to seasonally and frequently changing trends, the large number of variants and variety in fabrics as well as the requirement to order in considerable quantities. The costs of understocking show the loss of profit per unit if actual demand is higher than the quantity ordered. The components of understocking are the significant variation and the high uncertainty in demand, which lead to difficulties with the forecasts in the beginning of the season. Moreover, the fitting processes and managerial actions to avoid leftover inventory are influencing the understock. The shortcomings in delivery are substantially important in this special case, since the failure for one product could result in the loss of a whole account. With a relatively small customer base of 91 schools as well as the two largest clients representing 14 percent of the sales a loss of a customer would result in sharp decrease in profits. In addition, the defect of a...

Words: 546 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Hallington Case Study

...Connor Ferguson Admin 351 Jo-anne Goodpipe January 29, 2016 Full Case Analysis of Hallington Utilities Services Company Case Analysis: Case overview 1. Summary of the situation Hallington Utilities Services is first introduced as a utility that distributes electrical power to customers in the municipality of Hallington. In the mid-1990s, the Ontario government decided it should move to deregulate the electrical power market because residents and businesses in Ontario were drastically overpaying for services and were considered the third-highest electricity generation rates in Canada, with no choice of suppliers. HUS was reorganized. It now responded to a Board of Directors. This Board adopted the vision: Excellence in customer service with competitive electricity rates and knowledge of power that is 1st class, which meant focus, was now going to be mainly on providing second to none customer service in attempt to please the public. After this shift there became the growing concern that HUS would face major restructuring and reorientation challenges Hallington employees were beginning to be concerned about their future within the organization. With this growing uncertainty, employee’s morale can be greatly affected. After this introduction about what HUS was and the new regulations facing the company, the case shifts focus on to the human resource specialist, Marion Forbes. Forbes starts by meeting with CEO J. Swatridge. He highlighted three major concerns that have...

Words: 3681 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Manager

...handle the numbers in case analyses. It contains hints and tips to guide such analyses, and it is intended for all functional areas of business analysis. The hints and tips range from the conceptual to the practical, from the complex to the blatantly obvious. The note's underlying philosophy is that, in case analysis, it is not true that there are people who are good at numbers and people who are bad at numbers. Ability to do numbers is not innate; it's all a matter of approach. How you attack numbers is what counts. There are good numbers habits and bad numbers habits. This note has been written to help the reader develop good numbers habits. Part One: The Essentials • Take it slowly: more haste, less speed. • Never pick up your calculator until you know why you are doing a calculation— what you intend to do with the result, how you plan to interpret it. • Always seek a reaction to the calculation's result by asking questions such as: What does this mean? What does it imply? Am I surprised? Is it good, bad, or indifferent? • One useful trick is to guess at the answer before you perform the calculation. Then, when you do it, you can see whether you are surprised or not. If you are surprised, you have found something to think about. Is your intuition just off, or is the result sending you a message? Either way you benefit: you make progress with the case and/or you train your business intuition. • In the final analysis (pun intended), calculations...

Words: 2323 - Pages: 10