Free Essay

City of God

In: Film and Music

Submitted By mpdavis4
Words 1497
Pages 6
Fernando Meirelles’ City of God transcends the typical gangster film dynamic. All of the gangsters, or “hoods” as they are referred to in this film, are no older than late teens or early twenties. Seen through the eyes of a young teenager attempting to become a photographer in the hoods of Rio de Janeiro, the film concentrates on the emergence, rise, war, and collapse of the infamous hood Li’l Zé. For the majority of the film Li’l Zé stands as the smartest and most powerful hood in the slums. This is pervasive not only in his dominance, but also during Li’l Zé’s climb to the top. One of the most significant scenes of this film is the transformation of Li’l Dice into Li’l Zé. Early in the film Li’l Dice stands look-out at the motel hold-up, but the viewer remains uninformed what happened to him until about twenty minutes later in the film when Li’l Zé’s story is revealed. These two points of the film are separated by the conclusion of the story of the Tender Trio. For this essay I will examine the filmmaking significance of splitting the introduction and conclusion of this scene by over twenty minutes. The first portion of this sequence begins with Li’l Dice as a young child of no more than ten years old giving a brilliant criminal idea to the Tender Trio. Li’l Dice is then told against his desire that he is not allowed to take part in the plan, but instead must stand guard and shoot out a window if the police show up as to warn Clipper, Shaggy and Goose. The shot of Clipper stealthily stealing from a sleeping couple is that last image viewers see before the fire of a gun and the sound of a breaking window. From this shot on no one knows what happened to Li’l Dice, that is, until his story is told in full by Rocket. The closure to this sequence is not given until upwards of half an hour after it began. It begins with a shot from behind Rocket and his friend, Blacky, as Li’l Dice (now Li’l Zé) and his gang flood into Blacky’s apartment. After a small exchange, the camera stops on a close-up shot of Li’l Zé’s face. Along with this still shot is a line of text which reads “The story of Li’l Zé”. At this point a flashback begins where we are finally shown the motel sequence from Li’l Zé’s point of view. Moments later, the sequence is consumed with shots from the perspective of those being killed by Li’l Zé. These shots not only give the viewer the dramatic effect of being shot at, but also allow the viewers to examine the feelings of happiness and pleasure expressed by Li’l Zé. Although there are many aspects of this memorable scene that are thought provoking, I think none stand out more than the fact that the sequence maintains no linear order. Mierelles prominently exemplifies this by a break of almost thirty minutes between when the murders occur and when he reveals to the viewers what happened. This break between telling the Tender Trio’s story of the motel incident and Li’l Zé’s story is simply because the beginning of the film is structured as a few continuous narratives. The film begins with the story of the Tender Trio. For this reason, viewers remain uninformed of Li’l Zé’s story until the entire narrative on the Tender Trio concluded. This specific sequence is comprised of two separate scenes. The first scene, while giving all information pertaining to the deterioration of the Tender Trio, raises questions about Li’l Zé. The scene contains sounds of gunfire and a window breaking, but includes no visuals. As a viewer, it caused question as to why no sirens or police cars were never heard or seen. Even more simplistically; where could Li’l Zé have gone and if he was even the one who shot the window. By not answering any of these questions to both viewers and the Tender Trio themselves, Meirelles easily designed their collapse. Suspense, although not in the most stereotypically frightening way, plays a significant role in City of God. A primary example of that suspense permeates throughout the first scene of this sequence. The mystery of Li’l Zé disappearing while the police were searching for the culprits of the motel murders was something that could not be overlooked. Uninformed viewers are forced to question and worry about Li’l Zé. Framing the sequence in two separate scenes allows for this suspense and mystery to remain, and perhaps grow, in the minds of viewers for an extended period of time. Propelling this uncertainty about Li’l Zé to the forefront of the minds of viewers allows for there to be a time lapse between the two scenes without anyone forgetting the significance of the reappearance of Li’l Zé. The latter portion of this sequence examines the life of Li’l Zé. It scans through his rise ever since the moment the Tender Trio left him to stand guard at the motel all the way to his slum boss status when he walks into Blacky’s apartment. In just a matter of minutes, this scene shows the transformation of Li’l Zé from a young kid, unable to attain any power, to one of the smartest and most powerful hoods the City of God has to offer. His transformation begins as he stands outside the motel and states, “They’re having all the fun, and not me?” before shooting the window to get the Tender Trio to leave the motel. We then see the pleasure expressed by Li’l Zé as he goes through his killing spree. The shots of him killing in the motel are framed with a close-up on the face of a young Li’l Zé with only a black door frame and hallway behind him. This idea of darkness becomes a recurring symbol we see when it comes to Li’l Zé and his new life. The main consequence for this scene of the sequence, the fact that Li’l Zé began his rise to the top of the hood hierarchy, is conveyed through his sinister laughter in front of the black backdrop. This emphasizes the transformation of Li’l Zé’s life and personality; he literally walks away from all other people and into the darkness of the hallway, while figuratively transforming his life into one of darkness, crime, and corruption. He does not wait more than another minute before going to the lobby and gunning down everyone who had been previously tied up. The filmmaking technique exemplified by splitting the motel murder sequence into two scenes is one that, while watching, causes questioning. In hindsight, when examining this split sequence, the reasoning becomes a little less cloudy; it provides our introduction to all of the ways that Li’l Zé ruins lives throughout the film. He wrongfully imposes himself into the lives of others without their consent. It is evident in this split sequence as we are shown the result of his shooting the window; his actions cause the Tender Trio crumbles to pieces and even gets Shaggy killed. This area between the two portions of the sequence is filled with the first taste of the results of the actions of Li’l Zé. In City of God, Li’l Zé spends his whole life thriving to become the most successful, powerful and admired boss in the slums. This obsession perhaps fulfills his semiconscious struggle to replace the emptiness he maintained when it came to relationships. From the moment the first scene ends and the second scene of this sequence begins, Li’l Zé has lost all relationships, with the exception of Benny, of which he was a part. From that point on, Li’l Zé had to be in control of any relationship he formed. For this reason he struggled in all large, uncontrollable social settings. This appeared most prominently in the social settings attended by both Li’l Zé and Benny. Mierelles portrays this struggle by utilizing alternating shots of Benny and Li’l Zé. We see Benny in a shot at the dance party as the center of attention and friendly with everyone. This shot is immediately followed by a darker, bleaker shot of Li’l Zé walking around the party looking for someone to interact with, but ends left with no one. This bilateral sequence struck me in a similar manner to that of the motel murder split sequence. It contains two different, split perspectives of the same event. Not only that, but, as with the motel split sequence, Li’l Zé again seems to find the darkness. The irony here remains that Li’l Zé worked his whole life raising his reputation as a hood or boss in the slums, but at this exact moment, he is nothing more than that lonely child in the dark hallway, still searching for a way to complete the life he lost as a child in that motel murder sequence.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

City of God

...Lee Brazil Professor Maya Matos Intro to Film 16 February 2015 Cinema Aesthetics in City of God: A Study of Editing and the Cosmetics of Hunger This paper will focus on editing in the initial sequences of the film City of God. It will also show how the editing choices place this film in context with a movement, which is disaffectionately referred to as the Cosmetics of Hunger. City of God is a 2002 Brazilian film set in the favela, or slum of the same name. The film tells the story of a young photographer (Rocket) played by Alexandre Rodrigues, growing up in an environment of gangs and violence during a period from the 1960s up to the 1980s. The story begins with the protagonist literally in the middle of a gang war and reviewing the life events that brought his story to this point in a series of flashbacks. In the first images, a knife is rhythmically sharpened in a tempo that matches several quick, fixed cuts to and from the chicken’s point-of view. The knife accentuates the cuts in editing as the knife sounds rise in tempo, intensity and volume. Several of these juxtaposed shots create heightened meaning and awareness for the viewer and seemingly the chicken. The chicken appears increasingly more anxious as the editor creates a Kuleshovian continuity. Each successive chicken shot is blended with the rhythm of a frantic samba playing while people are dancing, cutting carrots, killing and de-feathering fated chickens for a stew that symbolizes the mise-en-scene. The...

Words: 1600 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The City of God

...beliefs and would be threatened with death. If they didn’t give up the beliefs then they would be executed. Pliny then details the practices of the Christians saying they’d sing hymns to Christ as god. They all blind themselves by oath. Romans would use torture in interrogations of slaves Nero- Corrupt emperor with lavish parties with prostitutes. Had one crazy party Fire set in Rome, and many people had thought that Nero set the fire during the time of the fire he wasn’t in Rome but during the conflagration he was singing a song about the destruction of Troy. Nero was blamed. People are angry but he tries to make up for it. He offered gardens for spectacles of torture. Augustine “City Of God” pg 59- Refute the pagan charges that said that the Christian’s brought the fall of Rome. Pagans said that people should worship old gods in order to achieve material advantages in this world. Augustine attacks the pagans and says that misfortune happens to all. He says that Rome had fallen before even when their gods were worshipped. 2 cities are brought in constant contrast 1. City of God 2. Earthly City Key Ideas: LOVE IS THE CENTER OF LIFE But love has to be correctly ordered- priorities GRACE IS NECESSARY EVEN AFTER CONVERSION Humans are weak and need gods help EVIL HAS NO POSITIVE EXISTANCE Evil is a corruption of the good...

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

City of God

...The foreign film that I viewed was “City of God”. It is a Brazilian film based on a true story in Rio de Janeiro. The movie followed Rocket and Li’l Dice as they grow up and decide who they would like to be. Rocket’s family sold fish and his dad was a fish monger. His brother Goose, who was against selling fish, decides that he would be a hood also know as a hoodlum. Rocket, also didn’t want to be a fishmonger, decides that he wants to be a photographer and knows that would be his only way out of the slums. Throughout the movie, Rocket has to find ways to dodge Li’l Ze. He never wanted to be a hood and always maintained his goal of becoming a photographer. He started working for a newspaper delivering papers and worked his way up. Li’l Dice was a street kid who also grew up in the same slums as Rocket. His only goal was to be the top hood. His best friend, Benny, and Li’l Dice grew up wanting to hang around the Tender Trio, which consisted of Goose, Shaggy (Benny’s brother), and Clipper. After a robbery at the local motel done by the Tender Trio and Li’l Dice, the Tender Trio all end up having to go into hiding. It was later revealed that everyone in the motel had been killed by Li’l Dice, who was only suppose to be a lookout but he was thirsty for blood. After the massacre at the motel, Li’l Dice ran off with Benny and began to rob people for money. Eventually he came back to the City of God, and ran into Goose. He shot Goose who was the last hood in the trio...

Words: 1829 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

City of God

...degree rotational shot of Rocket in the centre of a face off between the gangsters and the police, unsure of where to turn. This is symbolic of the story of the film in that his life can take one of either direction. The narrative is then broken down into a series of vignettes which tell the story of the favela and the central characters, and ultimately which path Rocket decides to take. I argue that this film was imperative in raising awareness of both the existence of as well as the issues within the favelas in Rio de Janeiro, and was one of the first cultural representations to emerge from Brazil to show the darker side of the city and an alternate reality to what is commonly perceived about Rio, that is postcard images of beaches, sunsets and samba. Via this cultural vehicle I argue that it was possible to begin to conduct businesses in the city such as 'favela tour' and 'favela party' due to interest from foreigners in seeing and experiencing a slice of life in the favelas. Which raises the question: Did this film glorify life in the favelas, or did it depict a realistic perspective of reality? How has consciousness raising of the foreign public since affected the inhabitants of these urban spaces and has this effect been positive or negative? I argue that one of the key strengths of the film is realism. The actors are amateurs recruited from the favelas, and the central character Rocket (Alexandre Rodrigues) is from the Cidade de Deus favela itself, which lends authenticity...

Words: 699 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

City Of God Essay

...City of God/Liberating God of Life Critical Analysis Essay: The Decision You Make Determines Your Fate The cinematography was impressive and magnificent. Even though it’s fast paced the story doesn’t lose its meaning. Shocking and uplifting the movie shows the decision of two kids that take them on two different paths. The film shows hope when Rocket makes a decision to become a Photographer to get out of the slums. Lil Ze becomes mesmerized by power to be the boss of the slums, he’s obsessed using violence to gain respect. The actors played their roles well for first time actors. From opening scene the story is stunning and intense. The documentary style and compelling photography is amazing. Acting style are impressive. City of God leaves you feeling sympathy for kids that are in this cycle of violence and wrong decisions and turns. It opens to reality of the true lives of the kids who live in these areas. The opening scene of the film shows what is to come using the camera to tell the story, without dialog, a chicken looks on...

Words: 1547 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

City Of God Comparison

...The city is laden with war, drugs and murder as Rocket tries to survive and his depiction captures the world for what it really is in favelas. The story of AKIRA has a similar tone; however, we are given an alternate futuristic setting where World War III ended 31 years ago, we are in Neo Tokyo instead of the Brazilian favelas, but the killing and violence remain constant. In this film, we begin with two sequences: a biker gang called The Capsules, led by Kaneda, going against The Clowns and a little boy and a man running from the police in another. The man is gunned down by the police and the boy appears to have telekinetic powers he runs away. Even after most of the Capsules ended their pursuit of the Clowns, Capsule member Tetsuo continues on,...

Words: 1905 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Bus 174" and "City of God

...The city of god, was a fictionalized version of several true stories the plot. The film revolves around following the lives of two characters, Rocket and Li’l Dice, from their childhood, under authority of the previous generation, until the generation following them takes the reigns of power.  It’s a storytelling method that prioritizes powerful and compelling characters with the explicit purpose of illuminating the world of Rio de Janeiro, a place where that generational spread occurs in only twenty years, violence dictates success, and success represents a spiraling downward of the city. In this world, poverty is implicit.  The people have only a few viable career options (work low level jobs for low wages, farm for self-sustenance, or join with a gang through which all economic and military power in the city is derived). The film shows how they would steal but also try selling fish in the streets as a way of making money. The film didn't show any real jobs or ways teenagers and/or adults could possibly make good money. Li’l Dice, representing all the most negative qualities that result from mistreatment, lack of education, poor environment and lack of support structure. He grew up to see only two motivations in life (money and power).  As Rio de Janeiro expands and its need for thievery to survive dissipates, the criminal lifestyle stays intact and expands along with the city due to the criminal culture and way of life that’s already been established.  Li’l Dice overthrows...

Words: 924 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

City of God Theory Application

...Theory Application - City of God City of God is based on the true story of slum gangs outside of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil during the 1960’s and 1970’s. The movie is told from the viewpoint of Rocket, a poor fishmonger’s son, who longs to become a photographer one day and leave the violent and corrupt area. The film opens with Rocket standing in the street between the police and a gang. The movie then flashes back 10 years to tell the story of how he got there. Three hoods called “The Tender Trio” rob local businesses in a Robin Hood-type fashion, giving some of the loot to citizens of the City of God. One boy named Li’l Dice suggests they rob a local motel and all of its guests. He serves as lookout and ends up firing a phony warning shot, sending the rest of them fleeing while he goes in and slaughters the staff and occupants with a gun. The police’s presence quiets them down and all but one of the Tender Trio meets their death. The movie then fast forwards a number of years to show that Li’l Dice is now named Li’l Ze and he and his friend Benny run the drug empire in town by eliminating all but one drug dealer named Carrot. Li’l Ze is infatuated with killing and believes it is the simplest way to end his problems and take control. Benny decides to leave the gang life and move to a farm with his girlfriend and is shot and killed at his going away party by someone aiming for Li’l Ze. With Benny gone, nothing is stopping Li’l Ze from taking out the last remaining dealer, Carrot...

Words: 1826 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Cidade de Deus

...CIDADE DE DEUS : A Review of City of God Kimbel Westerson Jose Konde Grand Canyon University- ENG 105 As a Portuguese speaker, it is with happiness and proudness that I see a beautiful work of art made in a luso-country; a work that makes the difference not just in luso-countries but in the eyes of all the world. City of God (Brazil, 2002 directed by Fernando Meirelles) is like that. Pop, polemic, tough and funny, it was the new pearl of the Brazilian cinema. Ironically, the movie is amazing because it explores one of the biggest issues in Brazil: the violence. The violence in Brazil is well known around the world. And this movie was filmed literally in the ghettos cariocas of the Cidade Alta, Nova Sepetiba and Cidade de Deus, and the movie was born with controversy, because those places are controlled by the drug lords. Therefore, they needed authorization of the bosses of the crime of that time to film the movie. By good fortune, they said yes, with a condition that they should contract the largest number possible of people that lived in those ghettos to act on the movie. Because of that, the director Fernando Meirelles and the co-director Katia Lund, who had already experienced work in the ghetto when producing the video clip “They Don’t Care About Us” by Michael Jackson, (who began as a director of TV commercials which gave him a command of technique and trained him to work quickly) created an organization named “We Are Cinema”, that prepared and selected...

Words: 809 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Seeing, Filming, and Imagining Space

...films, the city can be used for multiple purposes and makes up the ‘cinematic city plot’, comprised of the city’s buildings, streets, cars, and the actions of the people within the city using these structures for travel, self-reflection, and escape (7). In the essay, the authors dissect how the city plays a role in Brazilian film, particularly exploring films with that are set in Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo. They analyze how films make use of urban space and what these spaces represent and function as in each particular film, especially those that mimic the classical Hollywood film aesthetic. Throughout the essay, Braga and Costa go into great detail on the connection between Hollywood cinema and the “’urban-oriented’ Brazilian films that emerged later in the 1980s” (9). During this period, a lot of films emerged with a primary focus on the urban problem of the country, particularly violence. Through the incorporation of real lived space in the films, an aesthetic of realism was created. The authors note, “Rather than being an accidental setting, the city in any given film functions as a particularly privileged site for representing an important alternative to the dominant discourses of and about the culture they represent” (8). The city is used as more of a character in itself, incorporating buildings, landmarks, and views that have meaning to the country. Even further, they go on to explain that “‘objects’, buildings for instance, or even the entire city, …have meanings...

Words: 377 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

An Explanation of Augustine’s Conception of the City of God, a Dichotomy Between the Heavenly City and Earthly City.

...AN EXPLANATION OF AUGUSTINE’S CONCEPTION OF THE CITY OF GOD, A DICHOTOMY BETWEEN THE HEAVENLY CITY AND EARTHLY CITY. St. Augustine was an influential philosopher who lived in the fourth and fifth century AD. He conceived the world to be made up of two cities namely the earthly city and the heavenly city (the city of God). The city of God as conceived by Augustine is founded on the hope of heavenly peace and spiritual salvation. The main purpose of the city of God is to save mankind from sin and sufferings. This city is inhabited by holy persons and angels sacrificing self-interest and worshiping God only. These angels and holy persons do not look after their personal interest and have great regard for morality and ethics. The earthly city on the other hand was conceived by Augustine to be founded on appetitive and possessive impulses that are found in the lower categories of animals. The inhabitants of the earthly city are basically concerned with their personal interest. They do not have regard for morality, virtue and ethics. The inhabitants of the earthly city are usually willing to do anything so long as their parochial interest will be served. The inhabitants of the earthly city are more or less slaves of their desires and thus forget the will and wishes of God. They also forget to worship him. The behavior and attitude of the inhabitants of the heavenly city is that of goodliness and sacrifice. Because the heavenly city is inhabited by angels and holy persons, goodliness...

Words: 799 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Compare And Contrast Rocket And Lil Ze In The City Of God

...In the City of God, the two main characters Rocket and Lil Dice, later known as Lil Ze, grow up in the same favela but become two completely different people. At a young age, Lil Ze wanted to be a part of a gang. He always tried to get in with the bigger boys. On the other hand, Rocket never participated in gang activities. He wanted to become a photographer. One night, Lil Ze and the older boys robbed a motel. After the other boys left, Lil Ze smiled and laughed as he killed all the guests of the hotel. Lil Ze became more violent as time continued. However, when Rocket tried to rob people, he could not bring himself to hurt them and never followed through. Although he was surrounded by violence and theft, he ultimately did not take part in...

Words: 336 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Discuss the Extent to Which Roman Ideas About Their Gods and the Foundation of Their City Were Influenced by Greek Mythology.

...Discuss the extent to which Roman ideas about their gods and the foundation of their city were influenced by Greek mythology. Ancient Rome is filled with history of great wars and heroes, the mighty and the fallen. They were renowned conquers becoming one of the largest empires of their time. The romans were skilled finding their strengths in the engineering industry as well as the law. Although this ancient civilisation existed millenniums ago, they still effect the times of today. A prime example of this is the language, English. Romans spoke Latin and as they conquered and settled through Europe, “Latin fused with the native languages,” creating the romance languages of today; “Italian, French, Spanish, Portuguese… and Catalan.” The vocabulary of English has also largely derived from the Latin language. Although the current times of today have been influenced by the times of the ancients, the Romans however were influenced to an extent by the ancient Greek’s civilisation. By the 2nd century BC, Rome had a very evident impact from the culture of the Greeks. Greeks had begun to settle on the south then later migrating further north of Italy’s peninsula, and occupying the city of Sicily. There is neither exact date nor event that stipulates the cross of two nations however events such as the Macedonian and Carthage wars of Roman conquest would have aided in the direct contact to Greek colonization. The influence of Greece can be seen throughout every aspect of a Romans...

Words: 1929 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Live For The Eternal Cities Of Rome Analysis

... could ever prove to be the real eternal city on Earth. In 410 AD, Visigoth leader Alaric and his armies sacked Rome. This defeat was a momentous event in Rome’s downfall, as it put an end to the “Eternal” Roman Empire. Christian convert and author Augustine wrote City of God, which described his reaction to the fall of Rome and his view of Rome being a corrupted city, when compared to the infinite and eternal City of God. While Augustine believed that the City of God and City of Man were independent of each other, his former pupil, Orosius, believed that the City of God worked within the City of Man. Orosius, although he was taught by Augustine, held a different view than his teacher. Orosius viewed Rome to be an eternal city that was favored by the City of God and he believed that the City of God and City of Man were connected. Augustine's ideas...

Words: 933 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Beginning

...In the beginning God create the heavens and the earth. At the time the earth was like a void, darkness everywhere consuming the planet, and God said four words, “and let there be light.” Then there on that planet earth God separated light from dark. He blessed the light and called the light day, and he cursed the dark and called it night. The second day has arrived. God then said the waters from waters, and called to the expansion of heaven. The third day came. God wanted to fill the gap in the water, so God created dry land, and made the gathered water seas. Now he said there should be vegetation on the earth. The third day has passed. God said let there is the expansion of time telling from the seasons, and let there be light at night call it stars. The fourth day has passed. God then created every living creature to roam the earth, and blessed the bird. The fifth day has passed. God said I must make man I will make man in my own image of me, and blessed these creatures. The sixth day has passed. On the day of Creation God rested. God made a deal with man everything you see on earth is yours, for this is Eve’s garden. You may take any fruit, except the tree of knowing good and evil. If you eat the tree of knowing of good from evil you will surely die. Later the serpent temps Eve to go and eat the forbidden apple. At first she said no put in the serpents crafty ways, he convinced Eve into eating the apple. Not only was he able to trick Eve but also he made Eve convince Adam...

Words: 1606 - Pages: 7