Free Essay

Collective Agreement Simulation

In: Business and Management

Submitted By sardels
Words 510
Pages 3
Collective Agreement Simulation Evaluation

Collective Agreement Simulation Evaluation

1. Describe your position: (Union, Employer, Conciliator group 1 or group 2)

My team was the employer in Group 1.

2. What were the main reasons that an agreement was reached/not reached?

The main reason that an agreement was finally reached was because we agreed not to cut the staff by 25% as we had originally proposed. In our initial offer, we had laid off 12 employees and offered very generous packages to 18 employees. This seemed to be a big concern for the union team. They wanted to keep the job losses down to 10% vs. our 25% cuts. They also wanted job security for the remaining employees, which we did agree to. Had we continued to push with our original numbers for job cuts, an agreement would not have been reached.

3. Who in your opinion won the negotiation? Explain.

I believe the union team won the negotiation because now that I have simulated the agreement in the spreadsheet, Business Windows Inc. is at a loss over the four year collective agreement. Also, the only demand that they did not get was the salary increase that they had requested. They had originally requested an 18% increase over the four years, with a 12% increase occurring in the first year. This high of an increase is typically unheard of. I think they came in with an extremely high request knowing that they would have settled for something much lower than that. With regards to all their other demands (cut all overtime hours, add health care plan, keep job losses down to 10% of employees and add extra holidays), the management team gave them all that they requested. The only demand that they ceded was the increase in pension. It was agreed upon by both teams to leave the pension at 6%.

4. Describe the 3 main things that you have learned from the simulation.

One thing I have learned from the simulation is that it is extremely difficult to make smart decisions under pressure. Having only limited time to make decisions that will impact the bottom line of a company was not easy. Secondly, I learned that the union will come in with very high demands and it is the job of management to make sure that those demands are kept realistic. I realized during this exercise that, at first ,we gave in to most of the union’s demands but when we, the management team, remained firm and refused to give in on the salary increases, the union ceded. Had we remained firm with some other demands, the agreement could have been in our favor. Lastly, I learned that negotiations such as these can really impact the human resource costs of a business and can make a substantial difference with regards to whether or not a business comes out with a profit. We began the negotiations with an offer that had Business Windows showing a decent profit but once the agreement was reached, that profit was no longer there.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Work Breakdown Structure

...The National Hockey League (NHL), established in 1917, had not experienced a power struggle like it did when negotiating a new collective bargaining agreement (CBA) for the 2004-2005 season. Gary Bettman, Commissioner of the NHL, announced on February 16, 2005 that due to the inability to negotiate a new CBA with the National Hockey League Players’ Association (NHLPA), the 2004-2005 NHL season would be cancelled (Malhotra & Hout, 2006). The consequences of a lockout would be significant, including lost revenue for cities and the teams (an estimated two billion from ticket sales, media, sponsorship, concessions, and stadium bookings), employee layoffs, loss of fans who redirected their attention and spending to other avenues, and lost player salaries estimated at one billion. Regardless of the consequences, the reason to reach an agreement should have been for the fans who so faithfully followed the game and supported the players and the owners (Staudohar, 2005). The fans were out of luck; there were too many barriers to reaching a negotiated agreement prior to the start of the season. The main barrier to the negotiations was not having the wrong people negotiating, but the agenda of issues (Watkins, 2000). The powerhouses were power struggling, each unwilling to listen to or concede to the others views. For example, one barrier was NHL’s desire to address operating losses and what they viewed as an unstable financial condition by establishing a cap in salaries and linking salaries...

Words: 391 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Business

...Developing Negotiation Skills in the Classroom: A Case Simulation Maureen Hannay Troy University ABSTRACT Effective negotiation skills are required in all positions and at all levels of modern organizations. Employees in the human resources department utilize these skills on a daily basis when they deal with such items as new hire packages, salary increases, performance issues, labor contracts, and terminations. Research indicates that by using practical, real-life simulated negotiation scenarios, learners can develop more effective negotiating skills. This paper introduces a case where students can be assigned to a management team or a union team to negotiate a mock collective bargaining agreement. Guidance is provided on how to apply the case in the classroom and facilitate the discussion at the conclusion of the exercise. INTRODUCTION Employees in every organization utilize negotiating skills on a daily basis. From negotiating deadlines and workloads to prices of supplies and contracts with unions, negotiations range from the small and mundane to the large and exceptional. A company with effective negotiating capabilities can gain a competitive advantage, reduce costs, increase profits and improve relationships (Masters, Albright & Irr, 2003). When identifying the ten managerial roles that leaders perform to accomplish organizational objectives, Mintzberg (1973) classified the role of “Negotiator” as one of the essential decisional roles that must be executed by managers...

Words: 5699 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Mhr 522

...hours: Monday 12.00pm-1.00pm, 2.00pm–3 .00pm 5. Methods of Posting Grades: ▪ Tests and assignments will be returned to students in class 2.7 E-mail Usage & Limits: Students may email questions to the professor but may expect some delay in responses to emails. 3.0 CALENDAR COURSE DESCRIPTION: The course examines theories of industrial relations; union organization and structure; labour legislation in Canada; negotiating and administering the collective agreement; among other topics. The aim is to introduce the student to the complexities of the labour management relationship and to explore various techniques for successfully managing this critical area of business. 4.0 COURSE OVERVIEW: The goal of the course is to make students aware of the inherent presence of potential conflict, particularly in a collective sense, within workplaces. The intent is to acquaint students with the measures and procedures that have emerged to deal with this conflict, and particularly to position the practice of Collective Bargaining within this context. The interests of both employers and employees are acknowledged. The emergence of the labour movement and of labour legislation are presented as a social response to the self-promotion of employer interests within free markets. 5.0 COURSE OBJECTIVES: Articulate the role of labour unions as organizations and labour market actors. Develop awareness of Industrial Relations theory, and use...

Words: 2081 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Law 000

...Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Summary Brandon P. Cabico LAW 421 February 23, 2015 joe smith Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Summary International transactions and dispute resolutions require both the knowledge of the law and awareness to unfamiliar culture, politics, formal and informal power structures and decision-making approaches. Whether collecting assets in the U.S., assembling a collective venture with an Asian organization, or implementing a contract provision with a European supplier, businesses need lawyers who have displayed their experience and knowledge of all the aspects that can construct or deconstruct a business opportunity. (White and Williams LLP, 2013) While exercising the possibility of foreign business relationships some of the things lawyers and businesses need to take into consideration are the laws that are governing the other countries. The laws in other countries may have a direct impact on whether it is wise to consider or continue a legal course of action. Another situation to consider is where both countries currently are financially, if one of the two is suffering from a major economic crisis it may be best to opt out of taking legal action and come to an agreement elsewhere or another time. Also, is taking legal action always necessary and will the country who is considering this benefit in the long run? That is a question that should be asked to help justify and determine...

Words: 257 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Eco/21

...International Trade Simulation and Report ECO/212 April 17, 2011 University of Phoenix In our world economic system today import and export can be the heart and soul. Most all the states throughout the world export and import merchandises and goods based on their necessities. The governments exercise their studies with in-depth consideration, restrictions and limitations. In this report we will discuss the benefits and restrictions of global trade. We will also produce the evaluation of real and relative benefits and impact affecting foreign currency rates. We will also evaluate the team concept summary outcomes and focus on collected critic as the result of government policy on monetary policy. List at least one advantage and one limitation of International Trade as identified in the simulation One advantage of International Trade as identified in the simulation is opening the countries borders to international trade and investments allows for greater benefits. The greater benefits are, they can import products that are more efficiently produced in other countries. Importing of these goods allows customers to receive more choices for price and quality. At the same time, domestic producers can expand their markets to other countries, while the country’s capital gets new avenues for investments. All these factors allows for the country’s economy to become more vibrant and the country wealthier. The possibilities for growth are endless when a country’s borders are opened...

Words: 1652 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Functions of Hrm

...Discipline Administration * Grievance Handling * Labour Relations Job Design (JD) JD can be defined as the function of arranging tasks duties and responsibilities in to an organizational unit of work for the purpose of accomplishing a certain objective. Techniques of JD Scientific Techniques: This is done by observing past performances. Job Enlargement: Adding more duties to a job that is related to the current duties of involved (Horizontal Loading) Job Rotation: Shifting an employee from one job to another periodically. Job enrichment: Increasing the depth of a job by increasing authority and responsibility for planning Group Technique: The job ids designed so that a group of individuals can perform it, the job being a collective job. Job Analysis This includes the systematic analysis of the job and the characteristics of the desired job holders. The information collected through a Job Analysis is of two forms; Job Description: Describes the job, its tasks, responsibilities and service conditions of a job. Job Specification: Describes the requirements of the person for the job, including abilities, educational qualifications, special physical and mental skills, training, experience etc. Human Resource Planning (HRP) HRP can be identifies as the strategy forecasting the organizations future requirements for different types of workers, their acquisitions, utilization, improvement, employee cost control, retention and supply to meet these needs. The HR Planning...

Words: 1296 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Eco 212

...International Trade Simulation and Report The global economy is based on international import and export of goods and services between countries. International Trade brings the opportunity to expand local markets in order to get greater competition and therefore more competitive prices. It is very important that governments develop smarts strategies that produce good results of exchanges while enabling them to comply with International Trade regulations to ensure that market function properly. As part of this paper Team A will discuss advantages, limitations and regulations of such important system. In addition it will analyze some factors that influence affecting foreign exchange rates. For a better analysis of International Trade Simulation and Report, Team A will evaluate concept summary results for the assessment and indentify the effects of government policy on economy behavior. One of the most important international trade advantages mention on the simulation is the free trade agreements between countries that tend to specialize in comparative products allowing each country to stimulate economic growth and the consumer’s benefits from the variety of quality products to choose from in bigger markets. Trade agreements, lower customs tariffs, and other trade barriers between countries which consequently benefit by the increase of the amount of goods that it could be trade, while at the same offers the benefit of creating new jobs. Equally important, international trade...

Words: 2350 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Ankta

...Assessment Task Outcome 2& 3 Ankita Sharma Student ID:11153624 1.Four Activities for the Human Resource Management for Escape to Wild For the Escape to the wild company ,my job role is HR Management advisor to introduce the HR Functions and also explain the new procedures and policies which make the company succeed. (1)Human Resource Planning (HRP) HRP can be identifies as the strategy forecasting the organizations future requirements for different types of workers, their acquisitions, utilization, improvement, employee cost control, retention and supply to meet these needs. The HR Planning Process HRM Planing Process Factors considered when forecasting future HR requirements. * Demand for the organization’s good/services * Plans goals and objectives * Method of productions * Retirement, transfers, resignations * Death * Retrenchments (2)Recruitment This is the initial attraction and screening of the supply of prospective Human Resources available to fill a given position/s. In other words, it is the process of involving the attraction of suitable candidates to vacant positions from both internal and external sources of the organization. Eg: INTERNAL | EXTERNAL | Job posting | Advertising | Intranet | Job Placement Agencies | Succession plans | Internet | Referrals | Placement through Colleges and Universities | * Selection This is a systematic process of selecting the most appropriate and suitable person...

Words: 1676 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Administration

...|[pic] |Syllabus | | |School of Business | | |MGT/434 | | |Employment Law | Copyright © 2009, 2007, 2006, 2004 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. Course Description This course provides an overview of federal statutes and state-regulated areas that affect the personnel function. Among topics addressed are EEO and affirmative action, OSHA, ERISA, FMLA, and ADA; employee privacy issues (polygraph testing, drug and alcohol testing, employer searching and monitoring); and wrongful discharge. Policies Faculty and students/learners will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents: University policies: You must be logged into the student website to view this document. Instructor policies: This document is posted in the Course Materials forum. University policies are subject to change. Be sure to read the policies at the beginning of each class. Policies may be slightly...

Words: 2454 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Arctic Survival – from Success to Failure

...From Success to Failure Contrary to the outcome exhibited by most other groups during the Arctic Survival exercise, our team score (34) was lower than my individual score (64). This is not to suggest that group collaboration is detrimental; in fact, our outcome was unique among the class and of great surprise to the professor and entire class section. To be sure, pooling resources, elaboration of material, and support and motivation, while perhaps more time consuming, typically offer improved results. In theory, this model implies that a team’s collective knowledge can maximize utility and ensure the best outcome given the available information and perspectives. In our case, our group dynamics were such that we did not effectively utilize the resources we had, and consequently pooled a very limited amount of information. Rather than minimizing our risk, we increased it. I attribute much of our group’s failure at this simulation to process loss, which is defined as the problems that arise from lack of effective coordination among group members. A number of factors at play could explain the process loss which led to our counterintuitive results. First and foremost, one must consider the way in which group dynamics impact the overall productivity of group collaboration. Our team consisted of K, R, W, J and myself. K and W were quite opinionated, and in contrast, both R and J were quiet – I did not have a sense of what their true opinions were. K dominated the group by putting...

Words: 1695 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mt Everest Simulation

...Mt. Everest Simulation- Personal Reflection Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction to Mount Everest team and Leadership simulation 2 2.0 Our Team Process Efficacy 3 2.1 The role of the leader 3 2.2 Psychological Safety 5 2.3 Group Thinking 7 3.0 Conclusions 8 4.0 Reference 9 1.0 Introduction to Mount Everest team and Leadership simulation Climbing Mount Everest is a dangerous undertaking, a Herculean task fraught with difficulties, danger, complexities and volatile weather conditions. Disaster can strike without warning, leaving the most competent and experienced professional high altitude mountain climber gasping for breath, and desperately fighting to stay alive. Death is not uncommon to mountaineers who ascend Mt. Everest, a simple mistake, faulty judgments, miscommunication, wrong decisions or complacency can lead to disastrous consequences. Indeed, climbing Mt. Everest cannot be accomplished alone, individuals need to work together as a team, cooperate and collaborate with one another, and rely on one another's capabilities to ascend the mountain summit successfully. Everest leadership and team multimedia simulation is an attempt to help the participants experience and understand team dynamics and leadership. It requires participants to work as a unit, a cohesive entity, collaborating and communicating essential information in order to make effective decisions that will benefit individuals and the group in achieving their goals. The interactive...

Words: 3700 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

...The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been one of the most important issues that the United Nations has focused on since its founding in 1945. It has been the central topic for many resolutions, special committees, and peacekeeping efforts over the last sixty years. The United Nations has served as a platform for discussion about this conflict and has been used as a mediator between the opposing groups as a peaceful resolution to the issues is sought. Its main interest is in creating a peaceful end to this conflict and ensuring that both sides are just in their actions. At the time that the United Nations was founded, Great Britain administered the area of Palestine as a result of a mandate that had been assigned to them by the League of Nations. The British supported the establishment of a Jewish state in the area and Jewish immigration was greatly increasing especially following the Holocaust during World War II. This was met by opposition from the Arab population in Palestine and, as violence between the groups increased, the British were forced to turn the region over to the United Nations. On 28 April 1947 a special session of the UN General Assembly established the Special Committee on Palestine (UNSCOP), which had the task of investigating all of the questions surrounding the problems in Palestine and to recommend solutions to be considered by the General Assembly later that year. UNSCOP recommended two solutions. The first was that the area be divided...

Words: 3595 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Hccw Management

...HCC Management Team Bargaining Information Your team represents HCC management in bargaining sessions with the UCPW Local 14. The team is expected to negotiate an agreement that will allow the company to achieve its strategic goals over the next three years. Your team will use the following items to formulate its initial demands and for negotiating a new collective bargaining agreement: Item 1. Strategic Goals and Forecast of Factors Affecting the Firm’s Competitive Position Strategic Goals Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Incentive Materials cost reduction 2% 3% 4% 4% Labor cost reduction 4% 4% 5% 5% Current Ratio 2.25 2.5 2.75 2% Quick Ratio 1.0 1.2 1.5 3% Inventory turnover 5.0 5.5 5.75 3% Collection period 40 35 30 3% Forecast Item Current Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Gross sales (no strikes) NA +3% +4% +5% Material costs increase NA +2% +3% +4% Marketing costs increase NA +10% +12% +15% Non-union overhead NA +10% +10% +10% Short-term interest rates 7% 8% 9% 10% Long-term interest rates 4% 5% 6% 7% Corporate income tax rate 38% 38% 38% 38% Common share price target 21.00 22.50 23.00 24.00 (The items above are factors in the internal calculations used to produce the results in the Management Bargaining Calculator.) Item 2. Managerial Compensation HCC managers received 5% across-the-board annual raises for the past three years which has caused considerable resentment among the union rank-and-file. Future managerial compensation increases will take the form...

Words: 1211 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Oil Pricing Negotiation

...decision can have a negative effect not only on the manager’s career, but also on the company’s survival. Even the most successful executives make mistakes from time to time. This is in many cases due to the way in which executives process information coming from the outside world. Managers and business students study psychology and negotiation to avoid mind traps. Particular techniques can be used to facilitate the decision‐making process (brainstorming, simulations, etc). Oil Pricing is a so‐called ʺsocial trapʺ exercise, in which long‐term maximization requires mutual trust where significant short‐term gains are possible by breaking that trust. In most rounds, communication must be implicit, and is hence highly ambiguous and subject to misinterpretation, usually by the pro‐ jection of negative and adversarial intentions that donʹt actually exist. At certain points, the parties are given the opportunity to communicate explicitly, and may choose to reach pricing agreements or not (and subsequently, to honor those agreements or not). The exercise highlights the frequency with which we make imprecise and inadequately supported assumptions, suggesting the importance of making and keeping assumptions explicit and testing them periodically. The danger of self‐fulfilling assumptions is also illustrated. Parties can turn cautious competitors into the cut‐throat adversaries they...

Words: 2075 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Hr Terms

...|Term |Definition | |4/5ths rule: |Rule stating that discrimination generally is considered to occur if the selection rate for a protected group | | |is less than 80% (4/5ths) of the selection rate for the majority group or less than 80% of the group’s | | |representation in the relevant labor market | |401(k) plan: |An agreement in which a percentage of an employee’s pay is withheld and invested in a tax deferred account | |Absolute |Measuring an employee’s performance against some established standards | |standards | | |Accept errors |Accepting candidates who would later prove to be poor performers | |Action |A training technique by which management trainees are allowed to work full time analyzing and solving problems| |learning |in other departments | |Active |The performance of job-related tasks and duties by trainees during training | |practice: | ...

Words: 9818 - Pages: 40