Premium Essay

Commanding Heights

In: Social Issues

Submitted By ladybirdlorie
Words 1326
Pages 6
Commanding Heights
Commanding Heights is a six hour PBS television program. This program was based on the book The Commanding Heights, The Battle for the World Economy, by Daniel Yergin and Joseph Stanislaw (1998). The program consistently discusses the importance of globalization, without really giving a definition of globalization. The term of globalization is not neutral, it can mean different things to different people. As stated by The Globalization Website:
“Globalization broadly refers to the expansion of global linkages, the organization of social life on a global scale, and the growth of a global consciousness, hence to the consolidation of world society. Such an ecumenical definition captures much of what the term commonly means, but its meaning is disputed. It encompasses several large processes; definitions differ in what they emphasize. Globalization is historically complex; definitions vary in the particular driving force they identify. The meaning of the term is itself a topic in global discussion; it may refer to "real" processes, to ideas that justify them, or to a way of thinking about them. The term is not neutral; definitions express different assessments of global change. Among critics of capitalism and global inequality, globalization now has an especially pejorative ring” (Lechner, 2000-2001).
Episode 1
The first hour of episode 1, The Battle of Ideas, covered various aspects of different world economies and why globalization was important to the world. The video took the watcher through a tour of the decades, from 1917 to 1947 and the economic changes that happened during the various wars around the globe. The Commanding Heights video covers the several aspects of Marxism, socialism, communism, capitalism, Bolshevism, fascism, and totalitarianism. At the hour mark in the video, India is looking at the “communist countries…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

The Commanding Heights

...The Commanding Heights After World War I broke through, people in the world feared globalization. Ignorance was taking over people, fearing of what they didn’t know. They were skeptical, specially when terrorist attacks and depressions begin to happen. What people needed, and some still do, is to understand that globalization doesn’t make is dependent but interdependent. After War World II, the world economy was down as well as the trust people had in their governments. Governments and the marketplace both wanted to take over and reinvent the world’s economic order. The main question everyone wanted, and needed to know was “Which one is the best option? Which is the best style of economy for our economy and the rest the world? Which one is the best for every country, understanding that globalization was something that was meant to happen? John Maynard Kaynes was an educated, unconventional English man. He thought the government was there to defend people’s freedom. After going to school in Cambridge, he became friends with artists and economists. He made a fortune in the stock market, lost it all but made it all back again. He was a with the business man, people in congress and helping the government out by analyzing and giving solutions on how to organize and manage their economy. Later on in his life, Friedman, who had strong critiques on Keynes’ ideas of the government being a protector of the people and their freedom, made him step back, re-thinking his......

Words: 2131 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Commanding Heights Reaction

...In that part, it was more focused on the battle of ideas between John Maynard Keynes and Friedrich von Hayek, two of the most well-known economists of their time. Keynes could see the faults of free market in the time after the war and that all of those errors could be fixed if the government regulated the economy. However, Hayek thought that the free market would fix itself, with no government control. World War I laid a whole continent to waste and drew attention to the problems of political organization. People were looking for something better during this time and that something came in the form of socialism and communism. Western civilization was fascinated by this idea and started owning or regulating the so-called ‘commanding heights’ of the economy. During the period between two World Wars, the world experienced the collapse of capitalism and each part of the world tried to manage through by adopting either socialism or communism. Socialism promised a more just society, Hayek was more concerned for the poor and equity. He believed that people needed to be free from government interference and that markets work and governments don’t. His ideas were based on a fully functioning function free market system without regulations, which were also the ideas of Ludwig Von Mises. Mises was a libertarian who believed that markets always needed to be free from government meddling and he argued that socialist states cannot be successful because they lack a functioning......

Words: 837 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Commanding Heights Reaction Paper

...but you're in some other kind of time, then things won't work as well, and priorities will be elsewhere as well (Commanding Heights)”. The United States was about to go into a recession and President Bush wanted to rebuild an economy that will put the United States back to economic freedom. Bush had a plan and want to seek out new ventures to make his plan come to life. “Out of the sorrow of September 11, I see opportunity, a chance for nations to strengthen and rethink and reinvigorate their relationships. When nations open their markets to the world, they find in America a trading partner, an investor, and a friend (Commanding Heights)”, Bush explained. He wanted to make sure that the world would have confidence in America, but technology was a barrier that couldn’t be suppressed. Richard Cheney explained it as, “ I don't think there is any one overnight solution. I don't know anyone who's smart enough to sit down and write a brand-new set of rules that we should all then adhere to. I think it is a process for negotiation among solvent and independent nations, and that's probably as it should be. And it will evolve over time. And I do think we learn from our mistakes. But I the idea that there's some sort of basic right way to do it out there, and there's one individual or group that have got all the answers, I'd be deeply suspicious of that notion (Commanding Heights).” While the United States economy seems vastly improved, it was on a road to recovery. Daniel Yergin......

Words: 709 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Commanding Heights: the New Rules to the Game Reaction

...Commanding Heights: The New Rules to the Game Reaction The Economic Environment ECO 5003 Master’s Science in Management Southern Nazarene University Professor Jeff Seyfert LaToya Anderson December 16, 2013 Summary The video Commanding Heights Episode Three, The New Rules to the Game focuses on the United States economy during the early 1990’s. The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) was a significant part of the introduction into The New Rules to the Game. The NAFTA was signed on January 1, 1994 between the United States of America, Canada, and Mexico. The NAFTA was entered as an agreement to reduce barrier trade between the three countries. The United States Economy was declining significantly while other economies such as Japan were booming. NAFTA became a subject during the 1992 elections further separating Democrats from Republicans. President Bill Clinton supported NAFTA but like many policies believed that it need provisions by forcing Mexico to increase standards in the labor force and pollution. Labor unions were for Clinton’s proposal and provided support for him to win the election. Once NAFTA was enacted trade among the three countries increased significantly. The Gross Domestic Product of each country also increased, however Mexico had the largest growth. The development of Mexico had a negative impact on some parts of North America by opportunities shifting to workers south of the border. After NAFTA, Clinton began to......

Words: 534 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Commanding Heights Part 1 and 2 Q/a

...Commanding Heights - Part 1 - 2 Hours The Battle of Ideas Isiah Bullock Note: The City of London is the place in London where the stock market functions. The phrase “the City of London” or just “the City” very often means the stock market. 1. The question is: which would control the commanding heights of the world’s economies: governments or markets. 2. In the 1940's, the two most important economists of the age are: John Maynard Keynes and Friedrich von Hayek. 3. WWI ended the first global conflict and it would be 21 years before it returned. 4. Friedrich Von Hayek served in the Austrian artillery during WWI, and he sensed the problems of political organization. 5. In 1917, the Russian revolution was based on the economic theories of Karl and Lenin sought to smash capitalism. 6. Keynes was a delegate to the Versailles peace negotiations and when he saw the level of crippling social, political, and economic reparations demanded by the victors he resigned and predicted the final war would destroy the civilization and progress of their generation. 7. After the study of economics, Hayek described himself as a socialist but as a ____________________________. 8. Much of Vienna’s intellectual life took place outside the university, in the coffee houses across the Ringstrasse. 9. Hayek joined the circle of a passionate libertarian Ludwig von Mises,who thought that markets should be free from government meddling. And the distinguishing......

Words: 1481 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Battle of Ideas

...Battle of the Ideas: A review of economic concepts ECON-101 Amara Henderson-Graham Grandview University Professor David W. Hannum October 9th, 2012 Commanding Heights: Battle of Ideas The neoclassical counterrevolution was a response to the interventionist dependence revolution of the 1970’s which has diagnosed the problem of underdevelopment to be due to the predatory behavior of the developed world. The neoliberal school of thought redefined underdevelopment instead to be a result of poor allocation of resources brought about by the distortionary price controls and regulations used as tools of state intervention. It posited that too much state involvement in the economy is at the root of slow economic growth. The fundamental assumption in this perspective is that an unregulated market performs better than one with government regulation. It is convinced that although markets also run the risk of failing; market failure is much less costly than government failure. Where the dependency theorists advocated the reform in the international economic system, the counterrevolution thinkers insist that the speedy solution is the promotion of free markets that are supported by permissive governments that allow the market to perform its self-regulating functions. The prescription of the neoliberals to stimulate economic growth include not only the promotion of competitive free markets but also the privatization of state-owned enterprises, the promotion of ......

Words: 749 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How to Describe a Nation’s Economy?

...Trade and capital flows: Is the nation characterized by almost completely free trade or incomplete free trade and is it part of a trading bloc? 4. The commanding heights: (e.g. the transportation, communications and energy sectors) Are these sectors state owned and operated? Is there a mix of state and private ownership? Are they all private, with or without controlled prices? 5. Services provided by the state and funded through taxes: Are pensions health care and education provided? Do privatized systems dominate? 6. Institutions: Is the nation characterized by transparency, standards, the absence of corruption, and the presence of a free press and strong courts? Or is corruption a fact of life and the press controlled by the government? Are standards ignored and the court system compromised? 7. Markets: Does the nation have a free market system characterized by high-risk/high-reward entrepreneurial dynamics? Is it a socialized market with cooperation among business, government, and labor? Or is planning, including price and wage controls dominated by the government? Example: United States * Type of economy: Advanced industrial state * Type of government: Democracy with a multi-party system * Trade and capital flows: Incomplete free trade and part of trading bloc * The commanding heights: Mix of state and private ownership * Services provided by the state and funded through taxes: Pensions and education but some health care *......

Words: 441 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Factors Influencing and the Rationale Behind the Establishment of Public Enterprises Within Caribbean States

...lead to neocolonialism and finally to independence (Dominquez, Pastor and Worrel 1993). The post colonial era was the most active in relation to political thought and transformation as the social and economic issues of the “riot times” were examined. The minimal participation of the government in the laisser- faire ideological infrastructure that governed that period was the major purpose for change and as the full political responsibility for government was localized and the drive to industrialization spearheaded the drive for economic development trough the passage of Public Enterprises in Caribbean states. Caribbean governments wanted full participation in the commercial markets; what Mr. Norman Manly avidly describes as “commanding the heights of economy”. This thirst was quenched as some countries took steps toward the socialist perspective of controlling economies; this step caught the attention of other Caribbean governments and evoked further participation in the commercial and industrial development undertaken by governments. Social welfare is not to be forgotten. Vivid memories of harsh treatment, prejudice, hard labour only to suffice the needs of metropolitan powers is an important element in the adaptation of public enterprises. “Man needs material security, because he has physical needs, access to homes, jobs and education…” (Manley 1990). It can be clearly seen that the creation of the relevant Public enterprises achieved these factors as governments......

Words: 2247 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Personal Dilemma

...main focus was on, that this was the profession chosen and as difficult and physical demanding this experience might be moving forward and excelling was the objective. Until people are faced with so many challenges physically we become unaware of our abilities. There were no exceptions in the training, so whether the person was a female at fifty-nine inches in height or a male at seventy-two inches in height they better carry their own weight with full gear for twelve miles. In the end the feeling of completion was the best reward. Soldiers are trained physically and mentally to prepare for war, become proficient in their job occupation and most importantly learn to lead. It began to get difficult once placed in an environment where you are the minority. Having a commander that views the military as a job that is done only by men, became a conflict. At that moment is when one realizes that even though we do live in a world of diversity, equal opportunity, and ethic values, not all people have accepted the change. In this case the perception of women in the military was seen as a distraction. This commanding officer strongly felt that women were incapable of becoming a good soldier. A soldier was a strong figure, someone that will be a dependable comrade in battle fields, a male who lived the army values day by day. As a commander the ability to see everyone as a soldier, not become bias, and help is essential, since it is a reflection of your leadership. For......

Words: 874 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...Commanding the Heights: the Battle of Ideas This essay starts with an introduction of the documentary Commanding the Heights: the Battle of Ideas made by PBS, then conducts the analysis on the two competing economic ideas of Keyes vs. Hayek, and finally presents a detailed illustration of their impacts on the America’s economic policies since 1980. Introduction The PBS-made documentary ‘Commanding the Heights’ is to promote better understanding of globalization, economic development and world trade, featured with specific examples of different countries and interviews with related parties. Episode One "The Battle of Ideas," gives an overview of the battle between two major competing ideas about the world economy over the course of last century. On the one hand, the English economist Keynes believes in the ‘planned economy’ and advocates the government intervention to mitigate the risk during economic recession or depression; On the other hand, the Australian economist Hayek favors the free market mechanism and believes in minimum government intervention as market will eventually take care of itself and the prices system is at the heart of what makes a functioning economy work. The episode tracks the root of these ideas and explains how the world moved toward the government controlled economy during the 20th century in a chronological order summarized as below. The Russian Revolution in 1917 marked the beginning of communism economy, in which government is very......

Words: 1913 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Role of the Government in Recent

...economies. These economy types base on the question that who should control the economy: the government or the marketplace? Ideally, the kind of economy adopted by the government should cater for the needs of the inhabitants of a country. Purposely, the analysis will look at various argument on ideas put across on the various types of economies the correctness of the arguments, how the topic is related to the issues in Episode one and Episode two through the theory of John Maynard Keynes and Fried Von Hayek, and also apply it to our current economy to know how it works. First of all, we must know what the theory of Keynes and Hayek are, and also the different point of view between them. On the Episode 1- “ The Battle of Ideas” of Commanding Heights, Fried Von Hayek, who is a Britain economist, believed that “the government intervention is a threat to the freedom”. He mentions that the market should be “free”. It means that the government does not issues some policies for controlling the market, and the “players” in the marketplace are controlled by other factors in the market, including the price of goods. However, John Maynard Keynes, who is an Austrian economist, thinks that the government should intervene and play an important role on the economy in order to help stabilize the economy. For example, the government intervention can control inflation or bubble on economy. Applying to our contemporary economic conditions, as we know, we are still in a recession of economy. ......

Words: 1160 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Battle of Saratoga Fpr Us and Uk

...Putnam's forces defending the New York highlands to join Gates' army, and also sent some of the best forces from his own army: Colonel Daniel Morgan and the newly formed Provisional Rifle Corps, which comprised about 500 specially selected riflemen from Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Virginia, chosen for their sharpshooting ability.[23] Map showing the movements of the opposing armies in the Saratoga campaign, and plan of the Battles of Saratoga (inset) On September 7, Gates ordered his army to march north. A site known as Bemis Heights, just north of Stillwater and about 10 miles (16 km) south of Saratoga, was selected for its defensive potential, and the army spent about a week constructing defensive works designed by Polish engineer Thaddeus Kosciusko. The heights had a commanding view of the area and commanded the only road to Albany, where it passed through a defile between the heights and the Hudson. To the west of the heights lay more heavily forested bluffs that would present a significant challenge to any heavily equipped army.[24] (From, Wikipedia. no copyrights intended)...

Words: 727 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Common Heights

...In the video “ The Commanding Heights”, episode 1 shows the world with a global economy that is then crippled by World War 1. Following World War 1 two young economists by the name of John Meynard Keynes and Friederich Hayek commence to solve the economic difficulties the world was currently situated in. Each economist had a different vision about the approach the world should therefore take to resolve the world’s economic dilemmas. John Meynard Keynes who first suggested the argument that the economy should be a government controlled. Keynes contemplated the idea that in an event of economic despair the government should allocate their economic resources and go into a state of paucity in order to restore the economy back to normal, “ Keynes felt that the market economy would go to excesses, and when things were in difficulty the market wouldn’t work. Therefore the government had to step in”, (Chapter 2, The Old Order Fails). Therefore, when the economy began to amplify and become stable, a surplus would arise. A profuse amount of people and governments supported this principle. The President of the United States, Franklin Roosevelt when establishing his New Deal, used Keynes theory during the Great Depression. He constituted new government agencies to put the unemployed citizens back to work, “Keynes’s solution to unemployment was for the government to spend its money to restore and maintain full employment”, (Chapter 5, Global Depression). Hayek......

Words: 687 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


... Week 4 started off with watching the video The Commanding Heights. A very boring film if you asked me but as I spoke up in class I said the video was filled with Propaganda. Propaganda is never good. It was basically speakers who owned big corporations and third-world sweatshops with horrible working conditions. If you enjoy globalization and economics well then this is the video for them. Personally, I feel like people who watch this film can learn a lot more from walking out of their own house and reading up on new things. This documentary left out on a lot of issues. The people speaking who owned the corporations only worried about themselves and that’s how the documentary started. It was basically a paid documentary by those corporations to promote propaganda. Week 5 and 6 we defined and gave examples of our midterm terms and we began to talk about Introduction to Globalization and Business. They both go hand in hand. The impact of the business depends on the effects of the economy. There will always be pros and cons. The conversation in class confused me a little bit. There is so much to Globalization that I didn’t know about. We had a short week 7 but in class we discussed two articles: "More or Less" and "Black Gold,". Black Gold talked about one of the most disturbing things people could sell on the black market …hair. Nonetheless hair that is rat infested, had lice, even sweat and blood. Sad to say, women in India were touching this hair in the worst working......

Words: 355 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...are material objects consisting of physical and mental properties. (Hasker, 1983) Physical properties examples are height, weight, color, shape or size and mental properties are awareness, consciousness, feeling, thinking, emotions and senses. The problem arises because these properties interact where intentional or unintentional continuously. (Hasker, 1983) Hasker discusses several mind/body solutions such as idealism, materialism, behaviorism, dualism, and emergentism. Data is an android that was assembled to resemble a human being. In this episode Commander Maddox has orders for Data to transfer to his unit for disassemble with a goal to learn more about him or as Maddox referred to him as “it”, so an arm of androids can serve the Starfleet. Data refuses and has his Captain Picard supporting him. Maddox’s stand is Data has no rights and his characteristics were developed by man to resemble humans so we can direct him. Hasker talks about Behaviorism which states mental properties are special categories of physical properties. (Hasker, 1983) The mind/body solution could be used due to Maddox’ thinking that Data is a physical representation of a dream, conceived in the mind of man. Man collected neural nets and heuristic algorithms to develop the software to complete the android and that man controls it, thus behavior. Captain Picard is Data’s commanding officer and supports his refusal because he feels he has rights. The Mind/Body solution presented is idealism. ......

Words: 692 - Pages: 3