Free Essay

Compare and Contrast: Multiple Meanings of Money

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ybelaya10
Words 1331
Pages 6
Compare and Contrast Paper: Multiple Meanings of Money
Instructor: Eric Hinderliter
ECO 442—Development Economics
LCC International University
Yanina Belaya
October 24, 2013

The book ‘Multiple meanings of money’ written by Smita Premchander, V. Prameela, M. Chidambaranathan and L.Jeyaseelan analyses what microfinance money means to women, in particular it examines the viewpoints of individual women and women-only groups from India. These groups, called SHG (self-helped groups) represent the community of 15-20 women involved into savings and credit activities. Usually these groups are formed on voluntarily basis, but with encouragement of an external agency (NGO, MFI, government). The case study about the Grameen Bank of Bangladesh, presented in the economic development textbook, written by M.P. Todaro and S. C. Smith, is a good practical illustration of how credits can be provided to the groups of poor women. Considering that both sources emphasize microfinance programs delivered through women-only groups, it is interesting to analyze this emerging trend of the microfinance market. While both sources, book and textbook, bear some superficial similarities about the characteristics of SHG’s, benefits that involvement in SHG’s provides for women, and the reasons why ‘external’ agencies choose to target SHG’s, differences through investigation of these two sources are also noticed.

The book ‘Multiple meanings of money’ and case study on Grameen Bank represent the self-helped groups as mechanisms of delivery of microcredit to the poor(Premchander, Prameela, Chidambaranathan, & Jeyaseelan, 2009, p.59). They mention that this approach to the poor is reasonable, as most of villagers are skeptical about dealing with banks (Todaro, & Smith, 2006, p.242). For rural women, self-helped groups mediate and create a bridge between individual women and local institutions (Premchander et al., p.157). Moreover, both sources mention that this approach is important for women, as it creates the possibility to use another source of money – their own savings. From ‘Multiple Meanings of Money’ it is known that women use their own savings differently, from the loan provided by the ‘external agencies (Premchander et al., p.58). The book explains that most of women get involved into borrowing with the purpose to sustain themselves and their family members at a bare minimum level of living. Considering the fact that MFI’s and NGO’s tend to encourage ‘production’ usage of loans, rather than ‘consumption’ or ‘medical treatment’ usage of loans, saving their own funds though the self-helped groups appears to be a better way for women to receive money for their own needs. (Premchander et al., p.150). For example, members of the group in Ganjam prefer only to engage into the credit-saving activity of their SHG. They state that they would not take NGO loans, as NGO’s fail to offer them money to meet their social needs and charge too high interest rates (Premchander et al., p.50). The case study in the textbook also mentioned that Grameen Bank works to facilitate the accumulation of savings among its members, which already means that Grameen bank realizes and accepts the importance and role of savings for women (Todaro, p.243).

Analyzing SHG’s from the perspective of external’ agencies, both sources emphasize that targeting SHG’s is better than individuals. Primary benefit of it is that it helps to reduce risk and cost for credit-supplying organizations. Reducing risk is about improving expectations about repayment. If one member of SHG is not able to pay, others will repay the NGO/MFI (Premchander et al., pp.53-54). The book mentions that this process is encouraged by ‘joint liability’ characteristic of the group, while textbook mentions the same under the ‘mutual responsibility’ title. Moreover, Grameen bank states that it also saves time to control the use and repayment of the loan, because of informal peer-to-peer monitoring, or as it also called ‘collateral of peer pressure’ (Todaro, p.242). In the book peer-to-peer monitoring is showed though the different loan histories of groups. One of the examples would be the Baramalingeshwara group, which practiced regular meetings and constantly encouraged savings inside the group. The group managed stability and flexibility of loan repayments from savings. To explain their success, they stated that they all know each other, thus the collection of savings was easy (Premchander et al., p.169). This group practiced peer-to-peer monitoring on the regular basis, but besides that they emphasized the importance of trust inside the group. The textbook also underlines that “members know the character of other group members and generally only join groups with those they believe are likely to repay the loans” (Todaro, p.242). This mutual trust and support is also known as ‘group cohesion’. These mentioned above SHG’s characteristics, as well as the encouraged by NGO’s and MFI’s trainings, regular meetings and savings of SHG’s, contributed to the high repayment rates of MFI’s and NGO’s targeting women. In the case of Grameen bank, the rate is known to be over 90% (Todaro, p.243).

While both sources bear some superficial similarities about the characteristics of SHG, benefits that SHG provide to women, and to ‘external’ agencies, differences in these sources regarding this information are noticeable. First of all, it is important to mention that the concept of self-helped group in the ‘Multiple meanings of money’ represented not just as mechanisms of delivery of microcredit to the poor, but also as the broader strategy of empowerment (Premchander et al., p.59). Actually, it suggests that SFG’s should be treated as the institutions, which have their own character and processes, which are very important in order to understand how women actually deal with finance. It leads to the conclusion, that textbook talks about SHG’s only from the perspective of external agency, i.e. the Grameen bank, thus doesn’t provide much information about the relationships inside the group and it’s possible difficulties. The book provides a larger insight of the social costs of group processes, that is, constraints to group borrowing and joint liability approaches. For example, the case study of Grameen bank doesn’t mention that ‘joint liability’ characteristic of the group may not occur. In contrast, the book underlines that those people that don’t pay may have demonstrational effect and cause non-repayment or splitting of the group into two or more branches. It also talks about coercive peer pressure, loss of trust inside the group, and the likelihood that the poorest and most vulnerable will be excluded or further humiliated (Premchander et al., p.54). Basically, the limited information of the case study provides only positive view of SHG and explores the benefits, which SHG creates for MFI, while the book explores deeper the characteristics of SHG and shares significant for understanding issues related to the inner-relations of SHG’s. In conclusion, I want to admit that both sources provide almost similar information regarding the benefits and characteristics of self-helped groups. However, the book offers to the reader a much broader explanation of why and how SHG institutions became an important trend in microcredit activities. It carefully explains how women actually borrow, use and repay the loans, which I consider to be important information for those who seek to improve lives of women in India and encourage economic development of the country. Moreover, the book includes not only the positive description of SHG, but mentions negative sides of SHG’s internal processes. Thus, I can say that I find the book to be more complete and knowledgeable regarding the reality of self-helped groups as institutions with their own character and processes.

Premchander, S., Prameela, V., Chidambaranathan, M. & Jeyaseelan, L. (2009). Multiple meanings of money: How women see microfinance. Artxel, New Delhi: Vivek Mehra for SAGE publications India Pvt Ltd.
Todaro, M. P. & Smith, S.C.(2006). Making Microfinance Work for the Poor: The GramBank of Bangladesh. Economic Development (9th ed.), (pp. 241-247). United States of America: The Addison-Wesley series in economics.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay


... one should not consider that the question might appear on the test. 7. Short Answer. Explain how studying with people can be effective. Studying with friends is fine, but if your common interests are pizza and jokes, you might find it hard to focus. 8. List three suggestions for forming a study group and five suggestions for conducting a study group. To Form a study group: • Choose a focus for your group • Look for dedicated students • Hold a planning session To conduct a study group: • Set an agenda for each meeting • Assign roles • Teach each other • Test one another • Compare notes 9. Fill-in-the-blank. For test preparation, one should arrive _early________ so he/she has time to do a __relaxation____________ exercise. 10. Multiple Choice. Which should one answer first? a. essay questions b. short answer c. hardest questions d. easiest questions 11. T/F Absolute qualifiers generally indicate a false statement. 12. Short Answer. List five key words used in true/false test questions. • Always • Never • All • Most • Sometimes 13. Short Answer / Fill-in-the-blank questions generally concentrate on one of two things. List them both. 14. Short Answer. List the limitations of cramming. • It won’t work if you’ve neglected all of the reading assignments, or skipped most of the lectures......

Words: 1145 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Rhetorical Examples

...effect due its harsh, rough sounding words and phrases. 5. Euphony: lonely island - a series of pleasant sounds - The effect of euphony is positive due its use of nice flowy words. The words give off a calm smooth sound. 6. Onomatopoeia: I got that boom boom pow - words that sound like their meanings - Depending on which type of word a phrase uses, onomatopoeia can give off both positive and negative effects depending on how its used. 7. Repetition: Yeah I wish I’d been a, wish I’d been a teen, teen idle - the re-use of words and phrases - The effect of repetition can be both negative and positive depending on its context. Authors usually use repetition to give certain emphasis and importance of a word or phrase. The Meanings of Words (tropes) 8. Allegory: Do What U Want - Lady Gaga - the song can be taken very sexually but talks about how critics and haters can say and do whatever they want but it will never affect her - symbolic narrative with a hidden meaning. - Allegory often has negative effect. Since an allegory has a hidden meaning, the author tries to hide it with figurative language so the reader can figure out its true meaning and symbol. 9. Allusion - I want your psycho, your vertigo shtick, want you in my rear window baby you're sick - from Lady Gaga’s “Bad Romance”, she makes references to Hitchcock movies like “Physco” “Vertigo” and “Rear Window” - a reference to someone, historical event, art or mythology. - Many......

Words: 2012 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Mm255: Business Math and Statistical Measures

...course about personal money management. Students will apply critical-thinking skills to analyze personal financial decisions based on current and projected economic factors. (4) Financial Mathematics will integrate career and postsecondary education planning into financial decision making. (5)(4) The mathematical process standards describe ways in which students are expected to engage in the content. The placement of the process standards at the beginning of the knowledge and skills listed for each grade and course is intentional. The process standards weave the other knowledge and skills together so that students may be successful problem solvers and use mathematics efficiently and effectively in daily life. The process standards are integrated at every grade level and course. When possible, students will apply mathematics to problems arising in everyday life, society, and the workplace. Students will use a problem-solving model that incorporates analyzing given information, formulating a plan or strategy, determining a solution, justifying the solution, and evaluating the problem-solving process and the reasonableness of the solution. Students will select appropriate tools such as real objects, manipulatives, paper and pencil, and technology and techniques such as mental math, estimation, and number sense to solve problems. Students will effectively communicate mathematical ideas, reasoning, and their implications using multiple representations......

Words: 3027 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Consumer Behaviour

...consumer value and compare and contrast two key types of value Value: What you get – What you give up eg. 7/11 convenience of opening 24/7 allows the company to introduce a higher premium Utilitarian: utility aspect (product, functionally, does something for you) Hedonic: facebook updates on your phone Learning Outcome 3: Apply the concepts of marketing strategy and marketing tactics to describe the way firms go about creating value for consumers basic benefits, plus augmented benefits, plus 'feel' (hedonic) benefits value co-creation: customers play a part, interaction with each other C2C Learning Outcome 4: Explain the way market characteristics like market segmentation and product differentiation affect marketing strategy Learning Outcome 5: Analyse consumer markets using elementary perceptual maps Learning Outcome 6: Justify consumers' lifetime value as an effective focus for long-term business success Chapter 3, Consumer Learning Starts Here: Perception Learning Outcome 1: Define learning and perception and how the two are connected Learning: change in behaviour resulting from the interaction between entity and a stimulus Perception: consumer's awareness and interpretation of reality Value involves learning – learning begins with perception Perception: Exposure – Attention – Comprehension Learning Outcome 2: List and define phases of the consumer perception process Sensing – Organising (Assimilation, Accommodation, Contrast) –......

Words: 2168 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Understanding Student Miscoceptions

...determining what information is relevant to answer the problem. In the journal Research & Practice for Persons with Severe Disabilities by Copeland & Cosbey it states that students with special needs have a difficult time with the “skills needed to complete activities composed of multiple components” (Copeland & Cosbey, 2008-2009, p.215). Generally if a student is given a word problem such as “Kathy has 4, 143 blocks. She gave 316 blocks away to her friend. How many blocks does Kathy have left?” They would be perplexed by the understanding of what they had to do because of the multiple components it contains. A teacher may have to reiterate that Kathy owns the 4, 143 blocks and compare that scenario to a child owning a bucket of Lego’s. She then may have to talk about having a friend over and giving them some blocks to play with while explaining the word “give” means the same as “subtract.” Another problem she may have is explaining what exactly the question is asking the students to do. In this case the question wants to know how many blocks are left over from the amount that Kathy started with. In order to help these students better understand the question, teachers may want to transfer the information into a money problem where the student can purchase items as if they were shopping in a mall (Copeland & Cosbey). We have to remember that our basic goal in education is to teach children knowledge that can be used for further learning which they can use later in life to......

Words: 1851 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Generally Accepted Accounting Principles

...Principles Introduction In the past, the financial statements of health care organizations’ were fairly easy to compare. Historically, members of the healthcare community had applied similar sets of accounting rules without regard to their business structure. This meant that whether an organization was a for-profit, nonprofit, or a government owned, every healthcare entity was considered to be in the same industry and the accounting procedures they were forced to follow were similar, thus increasing the level of comparability between organizations. However, today’s standard setting environment requires these similar organizations to apply different sets of accounting standards based of their business model. Resulting in similar transactions being accounted for differently and reducing the level of comparability between financial statements. This has led to the need and implementations of Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, or GAAP, are a framework of accounting standards, rules and procedures defined by the professional accounting industry, which have been adopted by nearly all publicly traded companies in the United States, and allow for the recording and reporting of financial information in a uniform manner (Investing Answers, 2015). The benefit to companies using GAAP is that it makes it easier to compare the financial statements of different companies. GAAP aids in health care to establish the creditworthiness of......

Words: 998 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...States of America 987654321 ISBN 1-57685-532-5 For more information or to place an order, contact LearningExpress at: 55 Broadway 8th Floor New York, NY 10006 Or visit us at: About the Author Lauren Starkey is a writer and editor who specializes in educational and reference works. Her thirteen years of experience include eight years on the editorial staff of the Oxford English Dictionary. The author of more than ten volumes, Lauren lives in Essex, Vermont, with her husband and three children. v Contents CHAPTER 1 Getting to Know the Writing Section of the New SAT Old versus New Strategies for Test Taking Scoring SAT Study Timetable 1 1 2 4 5 11 12 32 45 55 56 58 59 59 65 68 69 CHAPTER 2 The Multiple-Choice Section Identifying Sentence Errors Improving Sentences Improving Paragraphs CHAPTER 3 The Essay Strategies for Timed Essays Understanding the Prompts The Art of Persuasion Anatomy of an Essay Planning Your Essay Drafting Your Essay Essay Writing Workshop vii – CONTENTS – CHAPTER 4 CHAPTER 5 CHAPTER 6 Practice Test 1 Practice Test 2 Practice Test 3 75 103 133 viii SAT WRITING ESSENTIALS C H A P T E R 1 Old versus New Getting to Know the Writing Section of the New SAT For over 80 years, high school juniors and seniors have faced the SAT on their paths to college. During that time, the test has undergone some changes. However, the new SAT, offered for the first time in March 2005,......

Words: 56306 - Pages: 226

Free Essay

Writing Workout

...LearningExpress at: 55 Broadway 8th Floor New York, NY 10006 Or visit us at: About the Author Lauren Starkey is a writer and editor who specializes in educational and reference works. Her thirteen years of experience include eight years on the editorial staff of the Oxford English Dictionary. The author of more than ten volumes, Lauren lives in Essex, Vermont, with her husband and three children. v Contents CHAPTER 1 1 Old versus New 1 Strategies for Test Taking 2 Scoring 4 SAT Study Timetable CHAPTER 2 Getting to Know the Writing Section of the New SAT 5 11 Identifying Sentence Errors 12 Improving Sentences 32 Improving Paragraphs CHAPTER 3 The Multiple-Choice Section 45 The Essay 55 Strategies for Timed Essays 56 Understanding the Prompts 58 The Art of Persuasion 59 Anatomy of an Essay 59 Planning Your Essay 65 Drafting Your Essay 68 Essay Writing Workshop 69 vii – CONTENTS – CHAPTER 4 Practice Test 1 75 CHAPTER 5 Practice Test 2 103 CHAPTER 6 Practice Test 3 133 viii SAT WRITING ESSENTIALS C H A P T E R 1 Getting to Know the Writing Section of the New SAT For over 80 years, high school juniors and seniors have faced the SAT on their paths to college. During that time, the test has undergone some changes. However, the new SAT, offered for the first time in March 2005,......

Words: 55651 - Pages: 223

Free Essay

Google'Control Mechanisims

...& Snell, 2009, P. 560). In 2009 the company’s revenue is $23.651 billion. Compare and Contrast and Determining the Effectiveness of Controls Comparing and contrasting Google’s control mechanisms, the comparison begins with Google’s balance sheet. The balance sheet shows the financial picture of Google at a given time (Bateman & Shell, 2009). Google’s balance sheet consists of the company’s assets, liabilities, and stockholders equity. Comparing the balance sheet to the profit and loss statement, the balance sheet gives a financial look of Google’s assets, where the profit and loss statement shows the itemized financial statement of the income and expenses of Google’s operations. The profit and loss statement is standard for measuring a department’s performance. The two control mechanisms are essential to the overall success of Google. Both Google’s balance sheet and profit and loss statement shows how effective Google’s activities are going as planned or not. To complete the financial control the financial ratio are included. Google’s financial ratio consists of the overall performance of the company measured in ratios. Key ratios are calculated from specific items on the profit and loss statement and the company’s balance sheets. These ratios mainly consist of liquidity ratios, leverage ratios, and profitability ratios. The major contrasts between financial ratios and balance sheets or profit and loss statements are financial......

Words: 1451 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Intro to Business Chapter 2,3,4

...Chapter 2: Economics: The Framework for Business 1. How does economics relate to business? Can an understanding of economics help business people succeed? If so how? Economics relates to business because it teaches business people how to make choices that can get their business the most revenue with the least amount of cost. The understanding of economics can help business people succeed, economics can teach you things like marginal cost and revenues and this is essential to an type of business. Economics can teach you statistics that if used properly can provide you with an upper hand against competition. 2. Compare and contrast microeconomics and macroeconomics. How do the 2 approaches interrelate? Use a specific example to explain. Macroeconomics and Microeconomics are both dealing with economics but indifferent levels, Macroeconomics is the study of a country's overall economic issues and Microeconomics deals with economics on an individual consumer,families and individual businesses. They can affect how much you can purchase for your family and what is available for you to purchase for your family. 3. What are the fundamental elements of the free market economic system? How can businesses thrive within this system? 1. The rights to own a business and keep after-tax profits 2. The right to private property 3. The right to free choice 4. The right to fair competition Free Market economies allows businesses to......

Words: 1540 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Intelligence Software, the Software of the Future more efficiently. In the last 10 years, a number of companies have been investing in software that will provide a better understanding of metrics to foretell their future performance. This same software can help companies make the most of their resources by turning stacks of data into stacks of opportunity. Knowing which software is most effective for specific business solutions can help you in choosing the best business intelligence software. The purpose of this report is to compare and contrast the Cognos and Tableau business software as well as give you insight on business intelligence software and how it is being used. Business intelligence software is implemented to help with challenges that might be faced within a company. The software can provide answers to specific business questions because spending time to read through piles of printed reports is time consuming and unnecessary. It is also designed to provide businesses with business metrics, reports and dashboards from multiple devices so that important information can be accessed in a moments notice anywhere that you can access a computer or smart device. It provides companies with customer insight, letting you know what customers are buying and what customers are refraining to buy, thus giving a company the knowledge to turn this data into revenue. The software also helps increase prediction precision because as Ken Dixon puts it, “Running a business shouldn't be like gambling.” Business......

Words: 1458 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay


...asset inversely follows the market; the asset generally decreases in value if the market goes up and vice versa.[2] The beta coefficient is a key parameter in the capital asset pricing model (CAPM). It measures the part of the asset's statistical variance that cannot be mitigated by the diversification provided by the portfolio of many risky assets, because it is correlated with the return of the other assets that are in the portfolio. Beta can be estimated for individual companies using regression analysis against a stock market index. Contents [hide] * 1 Definition o 1.1 Securities market line * 2 Beta volatility and correlation * 3 Choice of benchmark * 4 Investing * 5 Academic theory * 6 Multiple beta model * 7 Estimation of beta * 8 Extreme and interesting cases * 9 Criticism * 10 See also * 11 Notes * 12 External links [edit] Definition The formula for the beta of an asset within a portfolio is \beta_a = \frac {\mathrm{Cov}(r_a,r_p)}{\mathrm{Var}(r_p)} , where ra measures the rate of return of the asset, rp measures the rate of return of the portfolio, and Cov(ra,rp) is the covariance between the rates of return. The portfolio of interest in the CAPM formulation is the market portfolio that contains all risky assets, and so the rp terms in the formula are replaced by rm, the rate of return of the market. Beta is also referred to as financial elasticity or correlated relative......

Words: 2667 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

How to Eat

...our enemies, but the silence of our friends. Martin Luther King, Jr. TEST OVERVIEW:  Time: 65 minutes  The test consists of fiction and nonfiction readings. • Fiction excerpts include readings from novels, short stories, folk tales, poetry, and plays. • Nonfiction excerpts include readings from reviews, essays, articles, speeches, biographies, business documents, and articles about the visual arts.  The test consists of 40 multiple-choice questions. • 30 of the questions come from fiction readings. • 10 of the questions come from nonfiction readings.  There are seven passages. • Three of the passages are from prose fiction (novels, short stories, and folk tales). • Poetry and plays have one passage each. • Nonfiction has two passages.  There are three literary time periods. One passage comes from each of these periods: • Before 1920 • 1920-1960 • After 1960  The following reading skills are tested: • Comprehension—identifying the main idea, the purpose of a selection, supporting details, and using context clues to discover the meaning of unknown words 2 • • • Application—applying ideas to a new context Analysis—recognizing the way material is organized, including identifying inferences, figurative language, and knowing an author’s style or tone Synthesis—combining understanding of passage with extra information you bring to the passage, looking at an author’s style, tone, point of view, and purpose  The number of questions you answer in......

Words: 5677 - Pages: 23

Free Essay


...Japanese language had no written form at the time Chinese characters were introduced, and texts were written and read only in Chinese. Later, during the Heian period, however, a system known as kanbun emerged, which involved using Chinese text with diacritical marks to allow Japanese speakers to restructure and read Chinese sentences, by changing word order and adding particles and verb endings, in accordance with the rules of Japanese grammar. Chinese characters also came to be used to write Japanese words, resulting in the modern kana syllabaries. Around 650 CE, a writing system called man'yōgana (used in the ancient poetry anthology Man'yōshū) evolved that used a number of Chinese characters for their sound, rather than for their meaning. Man'yōgana written in cursive style evolved into hiragana, a writing system that was accessible to women (who were denied higher education). Major works of Heian era literature by women were written in hiragana. Katakana emerged via a parallel path: monastery students simplified man'yōgana to a single constituent element. Thus the two other writing systems, hiragana and katakana, referred to collectively as kana, are actually descended from kanji. In modern Japanese, kanji are used to write parts of the language such as nouns, adjective stems, and verb stems, while hiragana are used to write inflected verb and adjective endings and as phonetic complements to disambiguate readings (okurigana), particles, and miscellaneous words which...

Words: 9330 - Pages: 38

Free Essay


...precisely how everything works? After all, as long as we can drive a car, why do we need to know how its engine works? The individual who desires to become truly proficient in basic writing skills needs to look under the “hood” to better understand how the writing engine works. How do we navigate this magnificent ensemble — the act of accurately stringing words and word groups into sentences? The answer is part science and part art. First, we review the common categories that capture the vast 5 majority of recurring grammar problems. Next, we familiarize ourselves with the names of grammatical terms that describe the words and word groups used in building sentences. Lastly, we see how these parts interact as a whole by testing them through multiple-choice problems that integrate key concepts. Our journey would not be complete without coverage of a few areas that closely impact “grammar.” These include: diction and idioms, editing tips, American English versus British English, and traditional writing versus digital writing. This book is your “grammar mechanic’s” guide to writing. Let’s get started. Chapter 1 The 100-Question Quiz The following 100-question quiz (Q1 to Q100) provides a highly distilled review of grammar, diction, and idioms. The first segment of this quiz addresses grammar and is built on the “big six” grammar categories: subject-verb agreement, modification, pronoun usage, parallelism, comparisons, and verb tenses. The “big six” grammar categories......

Words: 42042 - Pages: 169