Free Essay

Compare Between Concrete and Steel

In:

Submitted By sara3abdallah
Words 933
Pages 4
How do concrete and steel compare in the construction of large commercial buildings? Office buildings, Hotels, Sports Complexes, and other buildings have the purpose of bringing people inside. The goal is to keep occupants comfortable and safe, while keeping the cost associated withe the construction and maintenance of the building low. Both materials have advantages and disadvantages. However, when it comes right to it, the differences between the tow materials balance themselves out . There is no truly better building material.

There are many advantages in using steel as a building material. Steel is a very structurally stable material. It is also eco-friendly and energy efficient. construction steel is recyclable with the rates of over 90 perce there’s no need to worry about the material rotting or damages caused by insects. It is very durable and can withstand most weather conditions. There’s also no need for deforestation that are harmful to the environment. Steel frame compared to wood is stronger and sturdier. It is also lighter and flame resistant. With the advancement of technology, steel can be form and bend to the user’s need. Constructing steel is faster than most materials, thus making it more cost-effective.

Though steel contains many advantages, there will always be a few disadvantages along with it. Steel may be more resistant than wood, but it can also develop molding during the winter. Since steel also contain metal material, if not treated carefully it can be toxic to the environment as well. It may also have a tendency for corrosion and rust if not maintain correctly, thus it might not be as cost effective due to constant maintenance.

Concrete can handle the compression stresses 10 times more than the tension and the most of loads in our life is compression. and its better resistance to fire. also it is a britile material which gives the advantage to make a rigid structure. and it is easy to handle over specially now there is plants that give you ready mix concrete. But it is also weak in handling tension and concrete always needs another material to reinforce it against exssive shear.67

compare between concrete and steel advantages and disadvantegs : aesthetics steel is a very flexible material and it gives a very clean shapes but it is very hard to shape. concrete can cast to take shape required but aesthetically steel is better. sustainability concrete is the material of choice to resist severe exposure conditions without maintenance but it also cause environmental impact. Steel is the most recycle material in the world but it needs maintaining. Steel is ahead of concrete since its recyclable properties can be recovered, melted and use again by future generation in any type of application, and at the end this is what sustainability means; it is creating a balance between our present needs and the use of natural resources by limiting the environmental impact for our future generations.

robustness
Steel buildings have better strength and flexibility to protect in natural disasters like earthquakes, tsunamis and hurricanes. Stronger, more flexible steel buildings can withstand much of the pressure that topples traditional structures, and save lives in the process.
A collapsed concrete structure is often the cause of fatalities and injuries. Under high winds, a lightweight, tilt-up building roof can become compromised, adversely affecting its connection

to its concrete panels.

But, concrete can resist fire for extended lengths of time better than steel. Because of this, concrete structures are less likely to collapse in the event of a fire. Steel will both soften and melt when exposed to high temperatures for longer time periods. But builders can improve safety by using spray-on fireproofing spray to strengthen the steel.

foundations
For many years the foundation repair industry has primarily used concrete piers. While concrete is effective it does have it's short comings. The primary problem with concrete piers is the lack of depth. On average concrete piers are installed 6 to 10 feet and less in the summer months. To get the best results the piers need to be installed deeper. The advantage of a Steel Pier is 16 to 25 feet and sometimes deeper. The deeper the piers the better results can be expected.
The Steel Pier will support 10 times the weight of a concrete pressed piling and will not break under the weight of the load. The actual weight of the house can change due to weather conditions such as sleet and snow on the roof of the structure. The additional weight can undermine the concrete method.
The sole purpose of any foundation repair method is to re-support the foundation in the area of settlement. This support can only be effective if the support piers are installed below the weather effective zone. Only Steel Piers can achieve this because they are installed deeper than the other methods.

Often, depending on the design needs, buildings are built with both concrete and steel for the best possibilities. It is not uncommon for buildings to incorporate concrete tilt-up in their lower portion and steel in the upper.

A hybrid type building using steel column and roof system is a great way to go. A full tilt-up with open web joist is very technically difficult to build. It takes experience to form, pour and tilt the panels especially if they have openings for doors or windows. But with a pre-engineered metal building combined with a partial tilt-up system, even though the expertise is still needed to lift the panels, the panels have a weld point and together they complement each other.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Concrete Research Paper

...SYNOPSIS ON DEVELOPMENT AND PERFORMACE OF CONCRETE USING SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS SUBMITTED BY: RAGHAV M Tech (STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING) DEVELOPMENT AND PERFORMACE OF CONCRETE USING SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS OBJECTIVE: 1.The main objective of this study is to investigate the use of various supplementary materials for preparing concrete. 2.To compare...

Words: 1309 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Should Attendance Be Mandatory in College Essay

...INTRODUCTION Buildings come in various types and shapes, frequently determined by their functions. Unfortunately, there are many types of building defect that may occur in most of the building. Building defect is one of the major components of building that needed attention. Building defect refer to the results in a failure of a component part of a building or structure and causes damage to person or property, usually resulting in financial harm to the owner. Building defect will also reduce the value and the function of a building. There are many types of building defect such as cracking, dampness, spalling, peeling paint, insect or termite attack, corrosion, fungus stain and so on. These building defect can affect the performance and the appearance of the building. Building defect can occur either because of poor design, or low quality workmanship, or because the building was not constructed according to the design, or use of inferior materials. When a building facing defects, the causes of that defect have to identified before any remedial work can be undertaken to remedial it. Therefore, we are required to investigate the building defect of a building. We also have to identify the possible cause of the building defect which occur in that building. We have choose the building of Guest House to make our case study and survey. This building is located at Universiti Sains Malaysia, Pulau Pinang. Guest House is one of the famous hospitality choices for USM visitors...

Words: 2747 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Bleser Park Pedestrian Bridge Design Project

...Senior Design Project Submittal May 4 2012 Bleser Park Pedestrian Bridge The following is a 2011-2012 Senior Design Project report for the Fenn College of Engineering at Cleveland State University. Senior Design Project Submittal 2012 Table of Contents 1.0.0 Introduction........................................................................................................................................ 5 1.1.0 1.2.0 2.0.0 2.1.0 2.2.0 2.3.0 2.4.0 Objective .................................................................................................................................. 5 Group Members ...................................................................................................................... 5 Project Description ..................................................................................................................... 6 Assignment .............................................................................................................................. 6 Existing Bridge ........................................................................................................................ 7 Proposed Bridge ..................................................................................................................... 8 Owner Requirements ............................................................................................................. 9 2.4.1 Safety .....................................................

Words: 13525 - Pages: 55

Premium Essay

Seismic Evaluation

...2.1 General Seismic evaluation and retrofitting strategies are mainly focused in this thesis. However, there are many good references that can be used as a starting point for research such as ATC40 manual for seismic evaluation and retrofitting of concrete buildings. This chapter focuses on recent contributions related to seismic evaluation and various retrofitting schemes and past efforts most closely related to the needs of the present work. For, the purpose of the present investigation, the literature is break down into following areas: a) Seismic evaluation. b) Retrofitting strategies. 2.2 Seismic Evaluation This section describes previous contributions made in the field of seismic evaluation of buildings. Also, highlights various research...

Words: 7169 - Pages: 29

Free Essay

Hjstys

...In any tomography system, the image is reconstructed using image reconstruction algorithm which requires sensitivity maps. There are three methods of acquiring sensitivity maps; finite element technique, analytically or experimentally. During reconstruction both the forward solution and the Jacobian matrix need to be calculated.[1] 1.2 Overview For industrial tomography, the emphasis is usually on high speed data acquisition, rather than resolution. This lends itself to electrical tomography techniques, which although lacking the resolution of x-ray and MRI tomography, are nearly instantaneous. Examples of electrical tomographic imaging methods are Magnetic Induction Tomography (MIT), in which multiple measurements of coupling between magnetic excitation Sensitivity maps reconstruction of Magnetic Induction Tomography real data measurement technique through and sensing coils are used to determine the internal resistivity of an object. Object Image Figure 1.1: Object and imaged with electrical capacitance tomography Sensitivity maps reconstruction of Magnetic Induction Tomography real data measurement technique through 1.2.1 Magnetic Induction Tomography (MIT) Magnetic induction tomography (MIT) is a new and emerging type of tomography technique that is able to map the passive electromagnetic properties (in particular conductivity) of an object. Excitation coils are used to induce eddy currents in the medium, and the...

Words: 1931 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Industrialists Vs Pyramids

...The Egyptian Pharaohs ordered architects, builders, and slaves to erect pyramids because they needed an eternal resting chamber which peacefully guided the soul to the afterlife. Further, the pyramids served as memorial sites; citizens gallantly gathered around the marvel to pay homage and respect to their fallen leader. In addition, the pyramids entranced the public eye because it balanced craftsmanship with nature. For example, architects chose regional resources such as limestone and sandstone which artisans than formed, shaped, and polished. In other words, the structure’s material blended with the environment. Compare that to the skyscraper, a structure which the Industrial Revolution birthed. Industrialists and Capitalists alike prioritized...

Words: 314 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Concrete

...(2005) Reactive Powder Concrete N.P. Lee & D.H. Chisholm The work reported here was funded by Building Research Levy. © BRANZ 2006 ISSN: 0113-3675 Preface The low flexural tensile strength of concrete has a number of undesirable consequences for its performance as an effective building material. These include the necessity for auxiliary steel reinforcement and the requirement for thick-sectioned members that are both aesthetically unappealing and consume significant quantities of aggregates. The aggregates are an increasingly scarce resource in many urban areas. An emerging technology with the potential to overcome these limitations is reactive powder concrete (RPC). RPC is a cold-cast cementitious material in which the mechanical properties of the composite matrix are improved by (i) suppression of the weak interfacial transition zone normally developed around the aggregate through improved particle packing and (ii) refinement of the hydrated paste microstructure by extensive use of pozzolanic silica and elevated temperature curing. Tensile capacity is provided by steel micro-fibres rather than conventional reinforcement. The result is a material with the potential for flexural strength up to 50 MPa and ductility and energy absorption values approaching those of steel. The low and non-connected porosity of RPC also render it extremely durable. RPC offers the possibility of building with concrete using slender members in a ‘steel-like’ fashion with improved...

Words: 10592 - Pages: 43

Premium Essay

Steel

...Light steel construction and modular homes as alternative building methods in South Africa. By: Dewald Barnard 26144362 Submitted in fulfilment of part of the requirements for the degree of B.Sc(Hons)(Construction Management) In the faculty of Engineering, Built Environment and information technology University of Pretoria 1. Chapter 1......................................................................................................................................... 7 1.1Research Proposal.......................................................................................................................... 7 1.2. Problem ........................................................................................................................................ 7 1.2.1 Chapter 2................................................................................................................................ 7 1.2.2 Chapter 3................................................................................................................................ 7 1.2.3 Chapter 4................................................................................................................................ 8 1.2.4 Chapter 5................................................................................................................................ 8 1.3. Research methodology ..........................................................................................................

Words: 10715 - Pages: 43

Free Essay

Han Guo

...SRTP Essay 1: A Statistical Analysis Report on the Seismic Appraisal of Classroom Buildings in Primary and High Schools Located in Shapingba . Zhou Shuyi, Meng Fei, Guo Han (College of Civil Engineering, Chongqing University, Chongqing, 401331) Abstract: This paper statistically analyses the earthquake resistance capacities of 107 Classroom Buildings in 107 primary and high schools located in Chongqing's Shapingba District; it further makes an analysis of various indicators, summarizes the most serious hidden risks of the buildings, and finally provides a statistical basis for seismic design. Key Words: Classroom Buildings, Seismic Appraisal, Reinforcement . Introduction In the 2008 Sichuan Earthquake, numerous buildings in the stricken area fell down, and many people died. As primary and high schools were generally located in heavily traveled high populated areas, Classroom Buildings in them were public ones with very high population density. So if a building collapsed, a considerable number of students and teachers would die and a large amount of property would be damaged. After the Earthquake, the State Council and the Ministry of Education immediately orders local governments to undertake an earthquake resistance appraisal of each building in each primary and each high school, and to take corrective measures with regard to the buildings that failed to meet the earthquake resistance standards correspondingly. In response thereto, in September 2009, the...

Words: 3986 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Stakeholder Roles Project: Shadab And Company

...Architectural work will contain of brick work in foundation, ground level and first floor. After the achievement of brick work plaster will start on the brick work. After that connection of wooden door frames, aluminium frames and wooden doors will start. Therefore the carpeting will also start. Finishing work We will start the brick work as quickly the base and concrete work gets finished. The brick work will give a form to the erection. The bricks will be obtained from an accepted source. The brick work will be done by the expert labour. The fixing of door edges will also start. The plaster work will start after the brick work gets completed. The plaster work will be done by mix machine and expert labour. All the events will be done as per calendar acquiesced by the contractor. Face work will be started after when building construction is accomplished. This work will be done by special labourers of face work. All the materials will be obtained from the accepted cradle. Electrical and Plumbing...

Words: 2903 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Gw Project Report

...GEORGE WASHGON UNIVERISTY Tacheng Wind Power Plant Project Plan School of Engineering & Applied Science Team Member: Shiyue Jiang, Ruiyu Liu, Kufre Essiet, Juan Wang, Mengpei Jia Project Report Table of Content 1. General description of project activity ..................................................................................... 4 1.1 Title of the project ............................................................................................................. 4 1.2 Description of the project ................................................................................................... 4 1.3 Detail of physical location ................................................................................................. 5 2. Understanding of scope of work .............................................................................................. 6 2.1 Scope of work ................................................................................................................... 6 3. Technical Approach ................................................................................................................ 7 3.1 Basic Construction part ...................................................................................................... 7 3.2 Basic Construction for fan ................................................................................................. 9 3.3 Fan Installation .......................................................

Words: 6914 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Multi Span Bridges

...A DISSERTATION ON SCHEDULING OF MULTI SPAN BRIDGES: AN APPLICATION OF REPETITIVE SCHEDULING METHOD Submitted to Rajiv Gandhi Prodhyogiki Vishwavidhyalaya, Bhopal (MP) For Partial fulfilment of requirements of Master of Engineering (Civil) with specialization in Construction Technology and Management * 2009 Submitted by KAVI PRAKASH Department of Civil Engineering MADHAV INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE (An autonomous Institute under R.G.P.V., Bhopal) Gwalior (MP) MADHAV INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE (An autonomous Institute under R.G.P.V., Bhopal) Gwalior (MP) * * * * * 2009 * Recommendation This dissertation work entitled “SCHEDULING OF MULTISPAN BRIDGES: AN APPLICATION OF REPETITIVE SCHEDULING METHOD” submitted by KAVI PRAKASH for partial fulfilment of the requirement of Master of Engineering Civil with Specialization in Construction Technology and Management is satisfactory account of his dissertation work and recommended for the award of degree Dr. M.M. Pande Professor Department of Civil Engineering and Dean (Academic) M.I.T.S., Gwalior-5 Dr. S.K. Jain Professor and Head Department of Civil Engineering M.I.T.S., Gwalior-5 Prof. Y P Singh Director M.I.T.S., Gwalior-5 * CANDIDATES DECLARATION I hereby declare that the work, presented in the dissertation entitled “ Scheduling of Multispan Bridges : An Application of Repetitive Scheduling...

Words: 17038 - Pages: 69

Free Essay

Concrete

...Standard® Concrete structures Accessed by NEWCREST MINING LIMITED on 14 Jul 2010 This Australian Standard® was prepared by Committee BD-002, Concrete Structures. It was approved on behalf of the Council of Standards Australia on 8 October 2009. This Standard was published on 23 December 2009. The following are represented on Committee BD-002: • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • AUSTROADS Association of Consulting Engineers Australia Australian Building Codes Board Bureau of Steel Manufacturers of Australia Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia—Cement Cement Concrete & Aggregates Australia—Concrete Concrete Institute of Australia Engineers Australia La Trobe University Master Builders Australia National Precast Concrete Association Australia Steel Reinforcement Institute of Australia University of Adelaide University of Melbourne University of New South Wales University of Western Sydney This Standard was issued in draft form for comment as DR 05252. Standards Australia wishes to acknowledge the participation of the expert individuals that contributed to the development of this Standard through their representation on the Committee and through the public comment period. Keeping Standards up-to-date Accessed by NEWCREST MINING LIMITED on 14 Jul 2010 Australian Standards® are living documents that reflect progress in science, technology and systems. To maintain their currency, all Standards are periodically reviewed, and new editions are published. Between editions...

Words: 70634 - Pages: 283

Premium Essay

Thermal Physics

... The temperature also controls the direction of flow of Heat Energy. Heat Energy always flows from a higher temperature to a lower temperature. S.I. Unit of temperature is Kelvin. The Kelvin scale and the kelvin are named after the Scottish physicist and engineer William Thomson, 1st Baron Kelvin (1824–1907). Unlike the degree Fahrenheit and degree Celsius, the kelvin is not referred to as a "degree" it is written K. The Kelvin and the degree Celsius are often used together, as they have the same interval, and 0 Kelvin is -273.15 degrees Celsius. Thermometer. A thermometer is an instrument for measuring temperature. To calibrate a thermometer two temperature called FIXED POINTS are chosen and the interval in between them is divided into a number of equal spaces called DEGREES. In this way we obtain a temperature scale. The lower fixed point called the ICE POINT is the temperature of pure melting ice a standard pressure i.e. 0 0C The upper fixed point called the MELTING POINT is the temperature of steam from pure boiling water at standard pressure i.e. 100 oC On the...

Words: 2312 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Export

...Chapter 4 Concentrating Solar Power Clean energy for the electric Grid Gary Gereffi and Kristen Dubay Jess Robinson and Yuber Romero Contributing CGGC researchers: by Summary Concentrating solar power (CSP), also referred to as concentrating solar thermal power, represents a powerful, clean, endless, and reliable source of energy with the capacity to entirely satisfy the present and future electricity needs of the United States. Concentrating solar power plants produce no carbon dioxide (CO2), thus reducing carbon emissions from electricity generation by approximately 600 pounds per megawatt-hour (BrightSource Energy, 2008).4 The evolution of CO2 emissions regulations, the pressure of international fossil fuel prices, and the experience, knowledge, and technological readiness amassed during several decades of CSP research have launched the technology into a new era of commercial reality. The United States and Spain have integrated CSP into their national electricity supply grids through large-scale commercial plants. Eight of the 13 biggest planned CSP projects in the world will be located in California and Arizona. The Sun Belt region of the United States, particularly the Southwest, is one of the largest areas in the world for CSP exploitation because of its abundant sunshine. In addition to generating a new clean source of energy, expansion of the industry promises to create economic opportunity for many different businesses along multiple stages of the value...

Words: 4528 - Pages: 19