Free Essay

Comparing Job Descriptions

In: Business and Management

Submitted By mirandamc
Words 444
Pages 2
Comparing Job Descriptions

8/18/2012

In writing a job description, it is important for the job description to be clear and specific. In comparing different job descriptions, you will notice the differences. If a clear meaning is not shown, the employee will not have a clear understanding what is expected of them. I compared two job descriptions, and this is what I came up with. In Managing Human Resources (Snell, Bohlander 2013 pg.153) job descriptions should have the job title and location section, a jobs identification section, and a job duties section. Both, job descriptions did include this information, but the title headings were labeled differently. In the identification section, the job of retail manager, listed online, lacked the information of who the employee reports to and the date the information was last revised. There is no way of knowing if the information is up to date, as job duties tend to change in the ever changing business industry. In the Employment Assistant job description there is two sections, one titled “job statement” and the other titled “essential functions” (Snell, Bohlander 2013 pg. 154) that list the job duties, functions, and responsibilities. There is much more of a description listed of what is to be expected of the employee on this job description. On the retail store manager description it is titled “your role” (Lifetouch Portrait Studios, Inc.), and it contains much less information and less of a clearer picture of what is to be expected of you. While both job descriptions have included the necessary information for a job description, the retail manager job description included some additional sections that told you about their company and why should work for them. I found the information to be appealing and beneficial and knowing more about the company as a whole. But, overall, the other job description was much more specific and gave a clearer picture of what was expected by the employee in that job position. While both job descriptions included the three essential parts of a good job description, the retail manager job description was vague in comparison to the employment assistant job description. The lack of more specific information and missing last revision date left room for error and clarity of the actual job to be performed. The added sections about the company and why you should work there did add attractiveness, but overall I think the employee assistant job description was better.

References
Lifetouch Portrait Studios, Inc. N/A http://jobview.monster.com/Retail-Store-Manager-Job-Youngstown-OH-US-112854456.aspx

Bohlander, G. & Snell, S. (2013,2010). Managing Human Resources 16th Edition. Mason: South-Western Cengage Learning.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Job Analysis

...Job Analysis The Samsung in Macau is not a big company with a few positions, so job analysis doesn’t take important part in their human resource department daily affair. The supervisor told us actually they seldom do job analysis because of no need if the company doesn’t make a big change. However, this Samsung company makes some changes last year. Before last year, their company salespersons didn’t have a satisfying performance because the sales manager is almost in charge of this part. Although the company ran well at most of times, sometimes they may meet problems especially when the sales manager was busy dealing with other affairs. Therefore the company decide to adjust and planned to define the salespersons’ duties and the evaluation criterion clearly for compensation. To conduct the job analysis, Samsung reviewed relevant background and select a sample of 5 to analyze the job. And after the analyzing, they confirmed those information with the sales manager, their direct supervisor to ensure it was correct. Similarity 1. Types of information The types of information they are trying to collect are all mentioned in textbook, for example, work activities, performance standards and human requirements 2. Uses The reason they conduct job analysis is also approximately same as what we learned as those following uses, recruitment and selection, performance appraisal, compensation and training. Differences We found two main differences through this...

Words: 333 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Essay Unit 13 M1

...M1 In this section of the assignment I will be comparing the purpose of the different recruitment and selection documents that were used by the selection panel at Warwick Castle.The different documents that were involved were: Job description and person specification CV and application form Job advert The short listing form Contract (post interview) Job description and person specification Job Description The job description document was used by Warwick Castle during the recruitment and selection process and this document is generally a summary of the duties that would need to be done by the potential candidate who is hired for the retail supervisor role. Unlike a person specification, a job description tells the Warwick Castle candidates what they must do when they are...

Words: 1100 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Job Analysis

... | | | | | | | |Job |4 | | |Analysis | | | |Lecture Outline | | | |Strategic Overview |In Brief: In this chapter, Dessler explains the uses of | | |The Nature of Job Analysis |job analysis information and carefully describes the | | |Uses of Job Analysis Information |methods of conducting a job analysis. The tasks of | | |Steps in Job Analysis |writing job descriptions and job specifications are also | | |Methods of Collecting Job Analysis Information |outlined. Finally, he discusses the trends of enlarging | | |The Interview |and...

Words: 4966 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Business Management

...The market appears to be, culturally diverse, which can open new doors, of growth and enhancement, concerning the vision of the product. A strategic plan of operation is in order, concerning a fresh approach, with in the hiring process. The legal team has been contacted, in reference to Virginia law requirements and concerns. Analysis (Job): Key roles must be filled, along with choosing top of the line employees to fill these positions. New staff cannot be appointed, without organization, along with planning the recruitment process. A chief human resource officer must be aware, of the first steps within this process. They include; understanding the needs of the department, number of employees needed, skills required and the type of people to accomplish these objectives, mission and goals. Understanding the needs of each department will work to ensure that long term goals are successful. Job analysis is also important, while also providing collected information, in reference to the open position and description used for recruitment. This provides a solid foundation, concerning what is required from the employees. Three phases of job analysis should be...

Words: 2026 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Resourcing Talent

...least 3 organisation benefits of attracting and retaining a diverse workforce. * Describe at least 3 factors that affect an organisation’s approach to recruitment and selection. * Prepare a Recruitment Authorisation Request to the MD comparing and contrasting the benefits of at least 3 different recruitment methods and three different selection methods. Methodology In preparing this report, research was done through books and the internet and was based on the workings of the company I am employed by. Findings The Identification and Assessment of 4 Factors Which Can Affect an Organisation’s Approach to Attracting Talent The main factor here is Supply and Demand: * Is there a vacancy? The first point to consider is whether or not there is actually a vacancy to fill. If a current member of staff has left or is intending to leave, could the vacancy be filled by splitting the job between other current employees? This could be resolved by carrying out a job analysis gaining information from the leaver (through an exit interview) and the line manager. The opportunity could arise at this point to consider restructuring the company by promoting someone to take on more responsibility – thereby affording that employee greater job satisfaction and self-esteem and at the same time providing the company with the knowledge that they are less likely to lose further valued staff. * Can the company afford to fill the role? It may be, given the current economic climate...

Words: 2079 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Recruitment

...and size but also it is possible to identify essential stages. The recruitment process depends on the job that is available and mostly it uses the internal recruiting method. Most jobs look for an Internal Talent plan to fill the vacancies; which lists the current employees that are looking for a move either at same level or promotion. If there isn’t any suitable person internal management develop a training and development program and use internal E-recruitment method to advertise post in the organisation. Organisations often use external recruitment methods used to advertise in their public web site. They also use the external vacancy board and made applicant online for managerial positions, chosen applicants must have an interview followed by attendance centre. People interested in store-based jobs, usually approach the store with their CV / register through the job centre. Identifying company needs All companies should have staffing plan giving numbers of staff within the organisation. When a vacancy arises the impact of the vacancy is considered against the staffing plan this is because the post’s nature should change or is no longer needed. Due to changes in the business, major restructurings sometimes take place without a vacancy.eg taking over of another company or a major economic downturn. Job description, in general this is a statement that shows the description of the work that you are supposed to do as an employee. It shows the duties responsibilities, most important...

Words: 1560 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Job Decription

...Job Description Job analysis is a crucial stage of the recruitment and selection process as it identifies the nature and scope of responsibilities expected of new staff. The purpose of job analysis is to break down the job into specific knowledge, skills and attitude (KSA) requirements for effective performance which can be subsequently assessed. (Robinson, 2006, p. 157) For the role of the Sales Manager we have identified a purpose and shown the main duties required of the candidate. Job title: Sales Manager Reporting to the: Sales & Marketing Director Location: Portsmouth Office Purpose of the post: The Sales Manager will be required to develop and manage a Sales Team to take the organisation into the next stage of growth by establishing new sales regions to maximise the manufacturing capabilities of the factory. Main Duties: • Setting and Managing Department Budgets • Setting and Managing Sales Targets • Managing and Developing Sales Team • Mentoring and Coaching Sales Team • Report Sales Targets Performance • Update Forecast Outturns Monthly • Plan and Manage Sales Training • Recruitment • Manage Appraisals and Bonuses • Plan and Organise Trade Fairs and Exhibitions • Manage Major Accounts • Liaise with Production, Marketing and Accounts Departments. Person Specification The person specification outlines the characteristics and abilities needed for effective job performance. Two frameworks still widely used are Rodgers...

Words: 4176 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Recruitment and Selection

...Summer Training Project Report ON Recruitment And Selection Submitted in Partial fulfillment of requirement of award of MBA degree of GGSIPU, New Delhi Submitted By: priyanka 015 2010-2012 Northern India Engineering College (Affiliated to GGSIPU) FC-26, Shastri Park, Delhi-110053 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Connection, dedication and application are necessary but not sufficient to achieve any goal. These must be awarded by guidance. This is to express my earnest gratitude & extreme joy on being bestowed with an opportunity to work in an organization as respected and reputed as BHL, Noida. It is impossible to thank personally all the people who have helped me in completion of this informative project, but it would avail this opportunity to express my profound gratitude and indebtedness to the following people:- I am indebted to Mr. Mohan Kumar Sharma (Officer – Group HR, BAJAJ HINDUSTHAN LIMITED) who gave me the opportunity to work with the organization. I am extremely grateful to my guide and project coordinator Mr. Mohan Kumar Sharma (officer– HR) & Mr. Shankar Singh (Sr.Officer –HR) who removed every stumbling block in my endeavor to complete my project successfully. They proved to be a constant...

Words: 3485 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Hello New Year

...designed to provide corporate therapy or as social health-and -happiness retreats. HR professionals must create the practices that make employees more competitive, not more comfortable. | Anyone can do HR. | HR activities are based on theory and research. HR professionals must master both theory and practice. | HR deals with the soft side of a business and is therefore not accountable. | The impact of HR practices on business results can and must be measured. HR professionals must learn how to translate their work into financial performance. | HR focuses on costs, which must be controlled. | HR practices must create value by increasing the intellectual capital within the firm. HR professionals must add value, not reduce costs. | HR’s job is to be the policy police and the health-and-happiness patrol. | The HR function does not own compliance...

Words: 8657 - Pages: 35

Premium Essay

Credit

...A PROJECT REPORT ON RECRUITMENT AND SELECTION PROCESS AT HCL SUBMITTED IN THE PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF MASTER IN BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION SUBMITTED BY AVINASH KUMAR MASTER IN BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION- IVTH SEM ROLL NO- 1208007298 (2012-2014) UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF: External Guide: Mr. Akshat Kapoor (HR Manager) Submitted To: Internal Guide: Mr. Shakti Tiwari (MBABR0017) Sikkim Manipal University, Sasaram ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Knowledge must be confined to ivory power but must step out and find practical application. This becomes possible with summer training stepping into provide grounding professional career. Two months of training in HCL Technologies Limited really fulfill this objective. I would like to express my sincere gratitude to Mr. Akshat Kapoor, (HR-Manager) HCL Technologies Limited for providing me an opportunity to undertake this project work. Last but not the least; I would like to thank those who were directly or indirectly responsible for the successful completion of the project. 1 DECLARATION I hereby declare that the project entitled on the Recruitment and Selection process at HCL Technologies Limited submitted to the SIKKIM MANIPAL UNIVERSITY, in partial fulfillment of the degree of Master Of Business Administration (MBA) is my original and not submitted for award of any other degree, diploma or other similar award. Date :-02-06-2014 AVINASH KUMAR Roll No 1208007298 Place :-Sasaram 2 CONTENTS  INTRODUCTION  PROFILE OF HISTORICAL...

Words: 15095 - Pages: 61

Premium Essay

Talent

...Resourcing Talent – Talent Planning in an Organisation 1. Four factors that affect an organisations approach to attracting talent are: * Expansion – A company that keeps expanding attracts a lot of new talent who want job security and promotion prospects. * Development opportunities – A company who offer learning and development opportunities will attract a lot of talent who want to learn new skills to better their career. Without training prospects a lot of talent will be lost. * Salary – A company with lower levels of salary wouldn’t attract as much talent as higher levels of pay. Workers want their hard work to reflect in their wages. * Benefits packages – A company with good benefits package also attracts talent. People want to see what the company offers to safeguard and assist their employees. 2. Three organisation benefits of attracting and retaining a diverse workforce are: * A varied array of employees means different levels of skills and knowledge, enabling each sector of an organisation to excel. * A diverse workforce means people possess different attitudes and values whether these values are derived from race, religion or even nationality. When all brought together can benefit the company when dealing with a wide range of people and even internationally. * Creativity and productivity would increase. People with different backgrounds have different ways of thinking. Enabling different views and ideas to emerge. 3....

Words: 1831 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Attracting and Retaining Talent in Corporate America

...employers are currently facing is finding excellent and talented employees to work for their companies. For one, resume falsifications has become notoriously rampant in the employment world. Moreover, it is now hard to find people with integrity, people whom you can have absolute trust in. An equally difficult task is to keep the bad kinds of employees out of your company. You may be very cautious with your hiring process but you will still sometimes end up with employees that give you nothing but bouts of headaches which creates employee discontent and morale issues. To help you attract and retain good employees and repel bad ones, the organization should have in place the following characteristics: a. solid reputation; b. provide clear job objectives; c. present challenges and learning opportunities; d. create a culture of accountability; e. offer attractive compensation; and f. create a culture of diversity and inclusion. Solid Reputation One of the best ways to attract superior employees is to be a top company. Needless to say, high achievers want to work for companies that have excellent reputation, exemplary management and top of the line products and services. “The global war...

Words: 1163 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Determining Who and Why

...need to hire new employees. Selecting the wrong person could be a costly mistake when considering the amount of money involved in recruiting and training new employees. According to (Wienclaw, 2010), “the tools used to select new employees need to be demonstrably related to the job and must help the organization select those employees with the appropriate knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics necessary for job success” (p. 1). To identify the recruitment and selection methods at Wal-Mart, a job description for a Senior Manager in Marketing-Promotions was selected from their website. This particular job description was selected because it includes position details, job duties, performance standards and job factors. In this paper, a concept map and associated discussion summarize the steps of the recruiting and selection process using the chosen job description. Dialogue surrounding performance standards and rationale for included components are offered as well. The recruitment process begins when Wal-Mart recognizes a human resource need within the company that is not being met by current employees. Once the position is determined to be necessary, upper management is able to conduct a job analysis...

Words: 2170 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Zihad Al Amin

...Introduction: Dessler(2008) claimed that, developing an organizational structure results in jobs that have to be staffed. Job analysis is a procedure through which we find out what the job entails and what kind of qualities a person should have to be hired by an organization. Human resource is a very important asset for any organization and jab analysis and position description is the crown jewel of all. We have analyzed what type of information is included in job description and person specification in order to create job analysis and position description of an HRM lecturer in North South University, a medicine doctor of Square Hospitals and a financial officer of BRAC Bank ltd. We tried to show how that is done through this project report. Over view of the organizations: It was a privilege for us to conduct a research and prepare a term paper on these three reputed organization in Bangladesh. Here is a brief overview of all the three institutions. i. North South University (North South University, n.d.) North South University (NSU), the first private university in Bangladesh, was established in 1992 with the goals of providing high quality higher education, developing human resources, and providing well paying jobs to highly qualified faculty members with foreign degrees. Another key objective was to provide the training and opportunity to students and graduates for higher study abroad, either with a recognized degree or with transfer credits from NSU. This institution...

Words: 2508 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Buisness

...task to do. There are many challenges that need to be addressed such as advertising for a replacement, interviewing many candidates, reviewing their qualifications, hiring and training. A thorough job analysis is needed to complete the process along with information about the different theories of human resources. It will be discussed in this research project, the measures used to hire, interview, train, and create a title for the replacement employee. This discussion will include the offering salary for the replacement, hiring requirements, training tools used, what is expected of the replacement and a performance evaluation to score the new employee. I do have an advantage in my favor from previously training new hires in the same department as me. Although I was not part of the hiring staff, knowing what was needed from the replacement having done the job for 5 years gave me a comfortable advantage. To begin the search for a replacement, a description is needed to clarify to the candidates who and what is needed to fill the position. Job descriptions are written statements that describe the duties, responsibilities, required qualifications, and reporting relationships of a particular job. Employee job descriptions are based on objective information obtained through job analysis, an understanding of the competencies and skills required to accomplish needed tasks, and the needs of the organization to produce work...

Words: 1871 - Pages: 8