Premium Essay

Comparing Sustainability Checks

In: Social Issues

Submitted By taitken
Words 1731
Pages 7
Thomas Aitken 48636120
Poli 320 term 1
Comparative paper, Plan B, Option 1
“Cross-national Comparisons”Sustainability Checks
A sustainablity check is defined as an assessment which looks to analyse the costs and benefits of regulations and thus assess whether more or less regulations should be implemented; according to the SGI codebook, a high quality sustainability assesses the short and long-term impact on social, economic and environmental issues when regulations are implemented.. The 2014 Country Report of the United States concedes that "there is no separate check required for “sustainability” per se" (p34 Quirk, 2014) since the definition of the term sustainabilty can be interpreted in many ways. According to other Country Reports, Germany, Canada and the United Kingdom don't have a seperate check for 'sustainability' either, only it is written less blatently due to the different authors involved in the reports. What is initially peculiar about this is that all four countries were awarded a score of at least 7 out of 10 for the criteria of sustainability checks despite none of them actually having a seperate check. This is because the scores are derived from the quality of each country's regulatory impact assessment (RIA) which assess a regulation’s impacts on socioeconomic and other indicators; according to the SGI codebook, a strong RIA "analyses consistently involve stakeholders by means of consultation or collaboration, results are transparently communicated to the public and assessments are effectively evaluated by an independent body on a regular basis" ( p57 Codebook, 2014). RIAs can include cost assesments of social, economic and environmental issues, thus implying that a seperate check is not necessary as it is already included in the RIA, as stated in the US 2014 country report "one could argue the U.S. regulatory impact assessment process...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Project Review

...Interim report 2.1 identify and describe required sustainability initiatives for MacVille •MacVille need to make it eco-efficiency by using less energy, material and water, more recycling. •By re-programming of all the air-conditioning services and switching off the lights at night MacVille can reduce the environmental licence fees, as well as by encouraging staff use of dual-flush capability of toilets. •Better sorting the recyclable paper from general rubbish helps MacVille cut down cost on waste management. 2.2 research and describe best practice models relevant to the business sector, especially as it relates to this case study •train the new staff to use the coffee making machine to help save electricity and water. •set harsh penalties for incorrect disposal of waste •use electricity saving machine to lower the usage of energy •use environmental cups for coffee or encourage customers to bring their own cups •lights off when it is unnecessary 2.3 identify and describe shortfalls •the new environment approach for MacVille doesn’t reference any legislation or comply with any relevant environmental law. •it should be signed up by the manager or chairman to show commitment from the highest level of the company. •it doesn’t specifically point out who is responsible for the implementation of the new approach. 2.4 Make recommendations for the exiting policy options...

Words: 1214 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Miss

...Please check your Course Information Booklet or contact your School Office for assignment submission locations. Name: Xueying Sha | Student ID |  1 | 1  | 0  | 0  | 5  | 9  | 7  | 2  | 1 | Email: shaxy008@mymail.unisa.edu.au | Course code and title: CONTEMPORARY ISSUES IN ACCOUNTING M | School: | Program Code: | Course Coordinator: Dr. ELVIA SHAUKI | Tutor: Elvia Shauki/Haniff Zainuldin | Day, Time, Location of Tutorial/Practical: | Assignment number: | Due date: May 6, 2013 | Assignment topic: The incorporation of social and environmental factors within external reporting | Further Information: (e.g. state if extension was granted and attach evidence of approval, Revised Submission Date)   | I declare that the work contained in this assignment is my own, except where acknowledgement of sources is made. I authorise the University to test any work submitted by me, using text comparison software, for instances of plagiarism. I understand this will involve the University or its contractor copying my work and storing it on a database to be used in future to test work submitted by others. I understand that I can obtain further information on this matter at http://www.unisa.edu.au/learningadvice/integrity/default.asp Note: The attachment of this statement on any electronically submitted assignments will be deemed to have the same authority as a signed statement. Signed: PLEASE DO NOT...

Words: 2918 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

State of Sustainability in the Aruban Fine Dining Industry

...Faculty of Hospitality, Tourism Management & International Business Studies University of Aruba State of Sustainability in the Aruban Fine Dining industry Course: MBA 2015 Module 2: Sustainability & Innovation Instructor: Prof. Dr. Ryan R. Peterson, PhD, Msc., Bsc., CHE Team: 6 Cavril Rombley Ryan Falconi Executive summary This state of sustainability report of the Fine dining industry in Aruba describes the challenging landscape of the local and international fine dining industry. An Economic industry analysis using Porters five forces analysis on sustainability in the fine dining industry is provided and data analysis of the conducted surveys. For this report a combination of qualitative and quantitative research was used. The data collection was based on interviews held with managers and owners of the restaurants and analysis of the survey, literature review and desk research. March 4, 2015 2 Table of Contents Executive summary......................................................................................................................... 2 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 4 2....

Words: 4674 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Nice One

...False 1.5 ___________________ is a network-based organisation which develops the framework for voluntary sustainability reporting. a. Global Reporting Initiative b. Global Sustainability Reporting c. Global Environmental Reporting d. Global Voluntary Reporting Questions continued over… Page 1 of 5 1.6 Which of these are the qualitative characteristics of financial information? I. Comparability II. Consistency III. Accountability IV. Understandability a. b. c. d. I and II I and III I, II and IV all of the above 1.7 Functionalists believe that the accounting profession is here to make money. a. True b. False 1.8 The financial...

Words: 1259 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Bhp Biliton Mid Term Case

...They have developed the BHP Billiton charter, which commits the company to core values of sustainability, which is written down in their Group Level Documents (GLDs) with minimum mandatory performance requirements on health, safety,...

Words: 2792 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Sustainability in Hr

...For example, 82% of companies noted that good corporate citizenship helps the bottom line and 74% said the public has the right to expect good corporate citizenship.1 As the concept of sustainability is gaining speed, it is important to realise that there is a gradual change in the mentality of organizations (Annexure...

Words: 2201 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Analysis of Micro Finance Institutions in India

...15 Key recommendation 16 PROFIT AND NON PROFIT ORGANIZATION 21 Differences between for-profit MFI’s and non-profit MFI’s 23 For Profit MFI 23 Non Profit MFI 24 METHODOLOGY 25 CAPITAL STRUCTURE AND ASSET ALLOCATION 25 DEPTH AND BREADTH OF OUTREACH 27 EFFICIENCY 28 PRODUCTIVITY 29 QUALITY OF THE PORTFOLIO 31 ANALYSIS OF NUMBER OF ACTIVE BORROWERS 33 PROFITABILITY AND SUSTAINABILITY 35 CONCLUSION 36 REFERENCES 36 LIST OF TABLES Table 1 Table of Comparision 12 Table 2 Comparison of Debt Equity Ratio 25 Table 3 Debt Equity Ratio 26 Table 4 Comparison of Depth and Breadth of MFIs for the year 2012 with 2010 27 Table 5 Comparison of Depth and Breadth of MFIs for the year 2011 with 2010 27 Table 6 Operating Expense / Loan Portfolio 28 Table 7 Industry Standard for Operating Expense / Loan Portfolio 29 Table 8 Productivity of MFI’s for the year 2010 29 Table 9 Productivity of MFI’s for the year 2011 30 Table 10 Industry standards for year 2010 30 Table 11 Quality of portfolio for the year 2010 31 Table 12 Quality of Portfolio for year 2011 31 Table 13 Quality of Portfolio for year 2012 32 Table 14 Quality of Portfolio for Industry 33 Table 15 RETURN ON ASSETS AND RETURN ON EQUITY FOR MFI’S 35 Table 16 BENCHMARK FOR 2010 35 Table 17 Sustainablility 35 INTRODUCTION A range of institutions in public sector as well as private sector offers the microfinance services in India. They can...

Words: 9019 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay

Solid Waste Management Case Study

...Abstract —To study the effect of serious games on teaching and learning aspect through a game for solid waste management. Also to promote ideal waste management practices in real world to simulate different scenarios of different types of waste and their proper disposal. It is a pedagogical approach for students to learn effectively a subject. The evaluation result will be shown through a graphical simulation. Keywords—Game based learning, Solid Waste Management, Segregation, Processing sites. I. INTRODUCTION With increasing population the quantum of municipal waste has also increased many fold and there is an urgent need to implement appropriate waste management methods. Waste materials can be classified into hazardous and Non-hazardous....

Words: 1313 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Retailing

...Retailers have an indispensable role to play in terms of advancing the cause of sustainability. They function as both the industry’s interface with the community, and at least potentially, as the consumer conscience of the community. They are positioned to acquaint their customers with...

Words: 3731 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Asd Pty Ltd

...A sound MIS is the key to achieve sustainability as it helps in providing the right type of information in achieving sustainability. It helps in reducing default, optimal rotation of portfolio, establishing sustainable interest rates, improving operational efficiency, generating reports at various levels for various stakeholders and review the progress. (Box 1). Common Shortcomings observed in the Information Management Practices: 1.) The basis formats are not comprehensive of them could be combined. 2) The flow and logistic aspects of transfer of information from Society to Federation to HQs and vice versa is not very efficient. 3) The reports produced by the MIS are not in line with the best practices information required. 4) There is no accurate aging analysis of all loans including the past due loans....

Words: 3379 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Kia Motor Fraud

...Firstly, a BSC that was developed using Kia Motors’ mission, vision and strategies that were identified and inferred from online research and Kia Motors’ financial statements and sustainability reports. Key information that was included in the BSC were Kia Motors’ performance and risk-based goals, initiatives, measures and their performance target. Secondly, a DFD was created to reflect one of Kia Motors’ key operations. The diagram that was drawn up was based on Kia Motors’ expenditure cycle. It showcased a detailed description of the relevant source documents involved, as well as their flow throughout the business process. The report further highlighted the key internal control strengths, the risk of material misstatements they serve to prevent as well as how the internal controls can be tested. The other thing that the report highlights is the control deficiencies within the business process and recommendations on internal controls that should be in placed to mitigate these deficiencies. Lastly, focus was placed on the Kia Motor’s accountant, Cecile Campbell and the scheme she used to perpetrate a fraud on Kia...

Words: 4866 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Busu Ge

...Background Analysis This report will deliver its fair share of analysis with organizational problems that need to be addressed, this report seeks to apply the theories of OB and apply the principles to the military Addressing relevant issues with the design and implementation of military customs and traditions established working conditions of night check versus day, working at night or during normal working hours. People who put in more work hours versus people who work less hours and receive the same compensation. The issues of group dynamics between the aviation mechanic and the aviation technician such as exploring the foundations of group’s behavior, to include shop fighting/unequal treatment/ to policies and procedures! Gender issues, preferential treatment/roles and relationships and crying to the senior management to get what they want (unethical behavior). This example includes the Navy with discussing a squadron, which was facing operational problems, in not meeting the achievable goals they set out to do, because of long work days that brought them to exhaustion, because of lack of...

Words: 2518 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Urban Development

...Third, we examine the relationship between strategic and statutory plans, to see how sustainability is actually implemented. Finally, we compare how the emerging issues are affecting sustainable planning in Australia and in countries with different planning and SEA tradition. Considering how SEA is globally evolving and...

Words: 5661 - Pages: 23

Free Essay

Hart Kruez

...Guidelines for Programme Design, Monitoring and Evaluation Table of contents KEY TERMS 1. BASIC PRINCIPLES 1.1. Development cooperation as part of foreign policy • • • • • 1.1.1 Increasing coordination and coherence 1.1.2 Strategic planning sets the framework 1.1.3 Cooperation has various forms 1.1.4 Policies require action 1.1.5 Finland as a partner 1.2. Towards a common language • • • 1.2.1 An integrated approach improves learning 1.2.2 Project cycle - the life of a development intervention 1.2.3 Level of participation varies 1. 3. Achieving sustainable development • • • • • • • • 1.3.1 Policies must match 1.3.2 Better value for money 1.3.3 Institutional capacity makes a difference 1.3.4 People-centered development emphasises socio-cultural aspects 1.3.5 Participation enhances ownership 1.3.6 Gender equality and participatory development 1.3.7 Environment - not only ecology 1.3.8 Technology must meet the needs 2. PROJECT DESIGN 2. Situation analysis - the cornerstone of project planning • • • • 2.1.1 Background studies and the analysis of stakeholders 2.1.2 Problem analysis - key to the project’s framework 2.1.3 Objectives reflect an ideal future 2.1.4 Strategic choices begin by fixing the project purpose 2.2. Planning with logic • • • • • • • • 2.2.1 Logical framework is a practical tool 2.2.2 Intervention logic states the strategy 2.2.3 Assumptions must hold 2.2.4 Indicators make the plan concrete 2.2.5 Approach describes how 2.2.6 Organisation determines......

Words: 26009 - Pages: 105

Premium Essay

Freight Transport as an Environmental Problem

...1.0 Significant of Study This study is significant on discussing about how freight transport would bring to critical environmental issue to the society. 2.0 Problem Statement Freight transport has been identified that are causing three major problems, which are stated as below, (1) Increases of the road freight transport increase environmental issues along, (2) Some controversy relationship issue between transport growth and economic development, environmental and political factors, (3) Emission rise of Nitrogen Oxides (NOx), Hydrocarbons (HC), Carbon Monoxide (CO), and Carbon Dioxide (CO²) worsen the greenhouse effect. 2.1 Road freight transport and environmental issues. The freight transport in Europe by road, rail and waterway together has grown by about 60 per cent since 1970; especially road transport has more than doubled, while rail and waterway still remained static. In this case, there is involving an increasing number of road freight traffic that could cause towards the increasing of environmental problem. For a case in point, when heavy goods vehicles are being used to transfer goods from a point of origin to another destination, it could be leaking out pollutant material and energy emission that would be harmful to humans as well as flora and fauna. 2.2 Controversy relationship issue The relationships between transport growth and economic development are significantly different from those linking the economy to the energy sector generally. The......

Words: 6771 - Pages: 28