Free Essay

Compulsory Education Should Be Eliminated

In: Social Issues

Submitted By dgarges
Words 1697
Pages 7
March 25, 2012

Compulsory Education Should be Eliminated

Compulsory education has a long-standing history in the United States. Many people in our society, especially public school teachers, administrators, and education association officials, believe it should remain in place. However, many parents and students would agree that forcing students to attend school, especially poorly run public schools, creates more problems than it is worth. It costs our state and its taxpayers billions of dollars each year, and many critics claim that students graduate unprepared for higher education and employment. For these, and several other reasons, compulsory education laws should be repealed, and compulsory education should be banned. The history of compulsory education dates back to the colonization of North America; in 1642 the Massachusetts Bay Colony had a compulsory literacy law for all children. If parents weren’t providing the “proper” education, colony officials could remove the children and assign them as apprentices to state-appointees (Rothbard, Compulsory Education in the United States section, ¶ 2). After the Revolutionary War, Massachusetts again started the country in the direction of compulsory education by including it in the state constitution. In 1789, compulsory school attendance was law in Massachusetts. The state of Connecticut followed suit in 1805, and in 1842 expanded the law by requiring all children under the age of 15 who had jobs to attend school for three months each year. In 1852, Massachusetts broadened the law, and required all children between eight and fourteen to go to school at least thirteen weeks per year. The other states followed Massachusetts’ lead – by 1850, all of the states had public schools, and by 1900 all states had compulsory education laws. In 1895, after several attempts during the terms of at least two different governors, Governor Hasting of Pennsylvania finally signed compulsory education into law in our state. It is interesting to note that in 1849, only about 5% of Boston’s children were truant from school without compulsory attendance laws. Most of the children were attending school even though they were not forced to (Blumenfield, Part 2). One of the earliest objections to compulsory education was voiced by Thomas Jefferson, who stated: “It is better to tolerate the rare instance of a parent refusing to let his child be educated, than to shock the common feelings and ideas by the forcible transportation and education of the infant against the will of the father” (in Rothbard, Arguments For and Against sections, ¶ 1). Many others also believed it was the parents’ right to educate their children as they saw fit, and government should not interfere. The fight for compulsory education in Pennsylvania took at least three attempts over five years, because the governors believed that forcing parents to educate their children in public schools was un-American. Some of the goals of compulsory education provided by the state were controversial. Many people wanted their children to receive a religion-based education, which was prohibited early on in public schools. Some early supporters of compulsory education believed that children should be considered the property of the State, not their parents, and therefore should be educated by the state. Many people objected to the idea of teaching children conformity and obedience to authority, which was part of the plan of many of the educational leaders of the time, such as Archibald D. Murphey of North Carolina and Reverend Jeremy Belknap of New Hampshire. On the extreme edge of the egalitarian push for education were Francis Wright and Robert Dale Owen, who were early Socialists in the United States. They wanted to remove children from their families at the age of two and place them in educational institutions, where they would reside twenty-four hours a day. Parents would have visiting rights, but the children would be completely raised at the state-run institution (Rothbard). While listening to the media in today’s society, it is clear that public schools are not meeting the earlier goals of literacy for all students. Many people believe, in fact, that public education is actually harming our young people. Samuel Blumenfield states: “…the present situation in which the state has assumed the function of educator, at great expense to the taxpayer, with…laws and regulations forcing population to patronize a system that is turning out functional illiterates by the millions” (Part 1, ¶ 11). He reports that approximately 26 million Americans are illiterate. The American education system is plagued with issues: SAT scores are dropping, students aren’t interested in science and math, dropout rates are increasing dramatically, and many students are apathetic about school and their future. There are many reasons that public education is not successfully educating America’s children. Most schools are filled with teachers who cannot teach. They are unable to connect with students and don’t know how to make the information “stick” with their students. They teach information that isn’t important to students, and cannot explain to students why this information is needed. And most students spend most of their days in school bored and wanting to be somewhere else. Part of this problem comes from the rise of teacher’s unions and the protection of tenure. Once teachers have passed an exam, and have been teaching for a few years, it is almost impossible to get rid of them. Rothbard uses the term “foisted” to describe this, and Blumenthal goes so far as to state “The sorry fact is that in America’s public schools, the educators pretend to teach and the pupils pretend to learn” (Part 1, ¶ 18) and says of compulsory education laws, “these laws have merely increased the amount of time children spend in school, not the amount of learning or knowledge they acquire” (Part 1, ¶3). When students spend a year, or more, in a class with an incompetent teacher, it can have a huge impact on their knowledge and skills. Another issue that plagues public education is that they must accept all students, and many of these students disrupt the learning process on a regular basis. All schools, and most classes, have a class clown who would rather goof off than learn. While many students are amused by their actions and even encourage them, the learning of the group is affected when the teacher has to stop to address the clown. Teachers also have to waste educational time dealing with angry, disruptive students and impulsive, talkative students. Every interruption leads to tension and a break in the concentration of the teacher and other students, and frustrates both the teacher and the students. Some students are even violent and dangerous, and pose a threat to themselves and/or others – the cases of Columbine and the more recent school shooting in Chardon, Ohio, where a former student returned and killed three students and injured six others demonstrate this. Many students don’t want to go to school because they are being bullied by others. Until public schools can find a way to ensure the physical and emotional safety of all students, it should not be compulsory to attend them. Many famous people did not complete a traditional education. Franklin Delano Roosevelt, Adlai Stevenson, Will Rogers, Henry Ford, Thomas Edison, and Albert Einstein were all very successful individuals who did not complete secondary education. Samuel Clemens quit school at the age of eleven but went on to be one of the most famous American authors. Woodrow Wilson didn’t learn how to read until the age of eleven, but went on to be an American president. A traditional education may not be needed for everyone. In this day and age, information is readily available for people of average, or above, intelligence. Once someone knows how to read and do basic math, any needed information is easily available on-line…almost everything is posted on YouTube! Anyone with a smart phone and internet access can almost instantly answer any question they come across. Once a student knows the basics, compulsory education becomes unnecessary. Barry Loberfeld proposes that students who do not want to learn or go to school should be dealt with by their parents. He says, “what will parents do with an unschoolable child? The most likely option: provide him with an education in the value of hard work, a wise choice for those youths who will find a paycheck more motivating than a report card” (Compulsion vs. Education section, ¶ 1). Schools could offer the opportunity for students who left school early to return to take desired courses or learn necessary skills. Americans for a Society Free from Age Restrictions proposes allowing adults to enroll in public school classes under a system where a certain amount of public education was guaranteed, but there is no restriction on when in a person’s life they have to use their public education. Compulsory education laws are creating a mess in the public education system. If they were repealed, only students who wanted to learn would be present in public schools, which would improve the situation for all students in public schools. Students, much like myself, would have the freedom to decide when to access their education, and would have more control over the courses they took. This would improve behavior in the classroom, since all of the students in the class would actually want to be in the class. As the aforementioned influential people prove; one does not need a formal education to be successful or influential. Therefore, compulsory education should be eliminated.
Works Cited
Blumenthal, Samuel L. “Are Compulsory School Attendance Laws Necessary? Part 1.” Freedom Daily, Mar 1991. Web. 22 Mar 2012.
Blumenthal, Samuel L. “Are Compulsory School Attendance Laws Necessary? Part 2.” Freedom Daily, Mar 1991. Web. 22 Mar 2012.
Blumenthal, Samuel L. “Are Compulsory School Attendance Laws Necessary? Part 3.” Freedom Daily, Mar 1991. Web. 22 Mar 2012.
“Educational Freedom.” Americans for a Society Free from Age Restrictions, n.d. Web. 22 Mar 2012.
Loberfeld, Barry. “ ‘Compulsory Education’: A Contradiction of Realities.” Libertarian Party News, July 2003. Web. 22 Mar 2012.
McGhan, Barry. “School Choice and the Death of Compulsory Education.” The Center for Public School Renewal. n.d. Web. 22 Mar 2012.
Rothbard, Murray. “Education: Free and Compulsory.” Mises Daily, 9 Sep 2006. Web. 25 Mar 2012.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Education

...OUTLINE Topic: Sex education. Purpose of writing: To inform my audience on the three reasons why sex education should be made compulsory. Introduction: Sex education is a process that begins at birth and continues until the day you die. It is a process of building a strong foundation for sexual health. It includes sexual development, reproduction, intimacy, gender roles and relationships. Thus, instead of informal education, why not make it compulsory in a formal education. Central idea: Sex education should be made compulsory as: (Preview) A. Sex education helps in exposing the students to appropriate information about sex. B. Sex education helps in reducing sexual related social problem among adolescent. C. Sex education did a great favor in case where the child lacks of parental guidance. Body: Main Point I. Sex education helps in exposing the students to appropriate information about sex Sub-point A. Sex education in schools can helps the young to understands the impact of sex in their lives. It dispels the myth related to sex and broadens their horizons. 1. eg: Bleeding on the first intercourse is the sign of virginity. (Dr. Vithal Prabhu, n.d) 2. Woman becomes impure during menstruation. (Dr. Vithal Prabhu, n.d) ...

Words: 395 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Have Social Policies and Changes to the Australian Welfare State Affected the Aged Population.

...How have social policies and changes to the Australian welfare state affected the aged population. In 1901 just 4.0% of the Australian population were older people and after two decades this has increased to 6.4%. In 2011 the aged population continued to increase and reached 14%. The Australian Bureau of Statistics (Abs.gov.au, 2012) indicates that since the baby boomers are now becoming old, there has been a decrease in fertility rates and an increase in life expectancy. The population of people over 65 years has continued to increase and it is predicted that it will continue to increase for the next 50 years. As people become older they are more susceptible to becoming sick and in need of government benefits. Since there is a major growth in the percentage of older people there have been major concerns that this will place more stress on our economic, social and health resources. (Jamrozik, 2009) explains that a social policy is intended to increase the standard of living and provide access to services through the means of sharing society’s resources. A wide range of social policies have been introduced in the last 20 years to support our aging population. Our Government provides income support and various concessions for those eligible (Humanservices.gov.au, 2014). As people retire they are no longer able to earn income and are in need of this income security in order to survive. A person to be eligible for this type of support depends on their income, assets and age...

Words: 1181 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Socialism vs.Capitalism

...Miranda Collins Dr. Jeff Kersh English 1010 March 10, 2016 Bernie vs Trump: A Contrast and Comparison of Capitalism and Socialism Getting the right ideas of how an economy should be run is a significant challenge. However, two systems can be used: socialism or capitalism. The United States continues to face this challenge. The current presidential campaign illustrates this important issue. Two candidates exemplify the two economic ideologies. Bernie Sanders adheres to the idea of democratic socialism, while Donald Trump follows capitalism. Capitalism is seen as a system that is mostly based on entrepreneurship, market allocation, and private ownership (Friedman 15). Socialism, on the other hand, is a structure where the control of factors of production is moved from individuals to the state. In light of these issues, below is a comparison and contrast between capitalism and socialism. While socialism helps to even out and equally distribute wealth in the society so that no particular person has control over production except the government, Capitalism does not allow for an evening out, and equal distribution of resources in the society. Also, the government has no control over production. According to Walter (7), Capitalism is “the economic system under which the ownership of goods and services are privately owned, and decisions concerning pricing, investments, and distribution are determined in a free-market system, primarily on the basis of competition among businesses”...

Words: 1148 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Retirement

...ECO 6191A Labor Economics Human Capital and Education -----------The use of IV based on AK-91’s paper Content 1. Overview of the Human Capital……………………………………………3 (1) Origin of Human Capital…………………………………………………..3 (2) Theory of Human Capital………………………………………………….4 2. The methodology used in the paper………………………………………...5 (1) Ability Bias/Selection Bias………………………………………………….5 (2) Instrument Variables……………………………………………………….6 3. AK-91’s Paper………………………………………………………………...9 (1) Seansonal Pattern………………………………………….…………………….9 (2) Estimating the Return to Education………………..…………………….……….12 4. Conclusion……………………………………………………..……………...15 5. Reference……………………………………………………………………...16 1. Overview of the Human Capital It is obvious that human capital becomes a vital part in our real life. In order to improve the productivity, people want to invest in the human capital more than before. From the Wikipedia, it defines human capital as the stock of competencies, knowledge, social and personality attributes, including creativity, embodied in the ability to perform labor so as to produce economic value. In a simply word, I think human capital is the set of skills which an employee acquires on the job, through training and experience, and which increase that employee's value in the market place. (1) Origin of Human Capital In fact, no one realized the human capital before A.W.Lewis wrote his paper "Economic Development with...

Words: 2918 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Child Labor in Pakistan

...through their innocence. | | But there are also other children, those who cannot go to schools due to financial problems, they only watch others go to schools and can merely wish to seek knowledge. It is due to many hindrances and difficulties; desperate conditions that they face in life. Having been forced to kill their aspirations, dreams and other wishes, they are pressed to earn a living for themselves and for their families. It is also a fact that there are many children who play a key role in sustaining the economically life of their family without which, their families would not be able to make ends meet. These are also part of our society who have forgotten the pleasures of their childhood. When a child in addition to getting education, earns his livelihood, this act of earning a livelihood is called as child Labour. The concept of child Labour got much attention during the 1990s when European countries announced a...

Words: 1980 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Problems Caused by Poverty Were Mainly Responsible for Social Reform 1880-1980

...“The problems caused by poverty were mainly responsible for Social reform, 1880-1980.” Discuss Poverty has certainly been a key factor in causing social reform between 1880 and 1980. However it has not been the only influence and along with other causal factors like war, political ideology, economic policy and political self-interest, it has played a lesser or greater part at different times over this one hundred year period. Poverty was rife in 1880 but there was little interest from the government in reforming social conditions. The prevailing attitude of the government was “laissez faire”. Samuel Smiles a social commentator championed the ideal of ‘self-help’. If poverty did influence social reform at this time, its influence was negative. The belief that helping the poor would make them lazy and dependant was a key reason why many politicians opposed the introduction of social reform. They were happy to stay with the hopelessly outdated Poor Law which punished poverty with the workhouse, believing that the poor, chose to be poor and were feckless. Charles Booth was of this opinion until he carried out a study of the poor in London between 1889 and 1903.In his book “Life and Labour of the people in London” he concluded that despite working hard, 30% of London’s population was in poverty. This shocked the public and the government. When a similar study on the city of York was published by Seebohm Rowntree it simply confirmed what Booth had found; poverty was endemic. This...

Words: 1807 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Education

...Ministry of Education and Science Stockholm, Sweden The Development of Education National Report of Sweden by The Ministry of Education and Science and The National Agency for Education Spring 2001 2 NATIONAL REPORT ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF EDUCATION – SWEDEN ........................................................................................................3 1 The Swedish education system at the end of the 20th century ..................... 3 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Major reforms and innovations introduced in the education system during the past decade...................................................................................................... 6 Major achievements attained over the past decade ............................................ 16 The lessons learned in the process of changing and reforming education systems............................................................................................................... 21 The main problems and challenges facing national education as we enter the 21st century .................................................................................................. 22 Curriculum development, principles and assumptions ...................................... 24 Changing and adapting educational content ...................................................... 26 2. Educational content and learning strategies for the 21st century ......... 24 2.1 2.2 References..................................................

Words: 10108 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

Social Factors

...Education in the People's Republic of China is a state-run system of public education run by the Ministry of Education. All citizens must attend school for at least nine years. The government provides primary education for six years, starting at age six or seven, followed by six years of secondary education for ages 12 to 18. Some provinces may have five years of primary school but four years for middle school. There are three years of middle school and three years of high school. The Ministry of Education reported a 99 percent attendance rate for primary school and an 80 percent rate for both primary and middle schools. In 1985, the government abolished tax-funded higher education, requiring university applicants to compete for scholarships based on academic ability. In the early 1980s the government allowed the establishment of the first private schools. The population has had on average only 6.2 years of schooling, but in 1986 the government set the goal of nine years of compulsory education for students by the year 2000. The United Nations Development Program reported that in 2003 China had 116,390 kindergarten classes with 613,000 teachers and 20 million students. At that time, there were 425,846 primary schools with 5.7 million teachers and 116.8 million students. General secondary education had 79,490 institutions, 4.5 million teachers, and 85.8 million students. There also were 3,065 specialized secondary schools with 199,000 teachers and 5 million students. Among these...

Words: 13191 - Pages: 53

Premium Essay

Innovation

...household chores for more than 28 hours in a week’ (UNICEF. 2011). Child labour is a major global issue, with ‘an estimated 158 million children aged 5-14 engaging in child labour’ (UNICEF. 2011). Organisations employ children to work in unfit environments and hazardous conditions, for example working in mines and many children are employed to work in agriculture where they are surrounded by dangerous chemicals used in pesticides and forced to operate the dangerous agricultural machinery. One of the main areas of employment is often the most overlooked; domestic employment. Children are employed to work within houses to do domestic chores, but entirely overworked. ‘Child labour not only prevents children from acquiring the skills and education they need for a better future, it also perpetuates poverty and affects national economies through losses in competitiveness, productivity and...

Words: 3718 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Illiteracy

...obstacle to effectiveness in their jobs and home life. Illiteracy comes from lots of reasons, but mostly it comes from the country’s weak situation economically and culturally, educationally, and from its people choices and decision. Ignoring it just causes more problems. First, one of the problems is that illiteracy plays a role in threating the culture and the economy in any country especially Egypt. Culture plays an important role to determine the rights and responsibilities and what the appropriate behavior is for the people. As Lyndon, Selvadurai, Er, Moorthy state that people should recognize that the problem of illiteracy before it destroys the culture of a country; it would put the country in a bad position between others. Recognizing and knowing our culture and our history helps destroying a part of illiteracy. An illiterate person is usually a drop out student who didn’t complete his education this affects the person himself as it jeopardize his career and the way of his living and by that it affects the economy and...

Words: 1518 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Persuasive Essay On Year Round School

...limit the number of families that could travel during the summer months but also restrict the number of teenagers and young adults eligible to work these jobs. States like North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Indiana, and Texas have already been forced to cut hours and close off areas of their parks, which they claim is a direct result of the shrinking summers due to the newly extended school year (O’Sullivan). Another opponent to year round school is the belief that summer is a time for non formalized summer learning, or in other words a time for students to learn through example instead of forced studying. This belief is especially shared among parents, and with more and more future employers looking for work experience over grades, summers should be a time for students to go to summer camps or pursue internships and...

Words: 1540 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Operations Management, Hrm

...American Business Law Journal Volume 45, Issue 2, 283–330, Summer 2008 The Impact of Compulsory Licensing on Foreign Direct Investment: A Collective Bargaining Approach Robert Birdn and Daniel R. Cahoynn I. INTRODUCTION The need to facilitate access to essential medicines for those with lifethreatening or fatal diseases like HIV, tuberculosis, and malaria has generated significant interest. Yet, an inevitable tension exists between the need for pharmaceutical companies to profit from their patented inventions and the desire to provide access for impoverished persons. Developing nations have attempted to resolve this tension through the issuance of patent compulsory licensesFauthorizations for government-approved generic copies1Fso that those in need of the n Assistant Professor of Business Law, School of Business, University of Connecticut. This article received the Holmes-Cardozo Award for Outstanding Submitted Conference Paper as well as the Ralph J. Bunche Best Paper Award at the Academy of Legal Studies in Business Annual Meeting, Indianapolis, IN, August 2007. Our thanks for comments and support go to Jayashree Watal, Peter Yu, Douglas Lippoldt, and the other participants at the University of Connecticut’s Center for International Business Education and Research Conference, ‘‘The Impact of Intellectual Property Rights on Innovation, Knowledge Diffusion, and Foreign Direct Investment in the Global Economy,’’ Storrs, CT, May 2007. Additional thanks to Anthony Kwasnica and...

Words: 20568 - Pages: 83

Premium Essay

Special Measures for Australian Indigenous

...Workplace and Employment Discrimination Issues in respect to Indigenous Australians Social indicators measuring wellbeing have shown that, as a group, indigenous Australians are the most vulnerable group of people who have the lowest economic status. The high unemployment rate is one of the main contributing factors to indigenous Australian’s poverty. In 1996, Australian indigenous unemployment rate was nearly 23 per cent in contrast to the non-indigenous rate of 9 per cent. Indigenous Australians suffer discrimination and face prejudices that are often perpetuated within Societies especially in the area of employment. In 1965 Australia signed the International Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination (CERD). In order to fulfill the requirements of the Convention the federal Parliament passed the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) (RDA) and the States have passed the RDA’s equivalent Acts to protect all culture groups and races from discrimination. However, in Queensland the RDA and Anti- Discrimination Act can not adequately protect the interest of indigenous people. In order to achieve true equality among all human races, special measures are needed to protect indigenous people from unfair discrimination. 184 words Part one: Anti- Discrimination Act of Queensland 1.1 Indirect discrimination Section 11 of the Act states indirect discrimination happens if a person imposes or proposes to impose, a term- a) With which an attribute...

Words: 3364 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Child Labor

... (Baylis, Smith, & Owens, 2011) Nevertheless, severe poverty, human rights violations, as well as child labor issues are still prevalent in many developing countries. Worst of all, women and children are victims of governmental apathy and corruption in most persecuted communities. Children in developing countries with ill-constructed welfare system undergo extreme poverty and malnourishment. For their families’ survival, children under the age of fourteen work for the whole day, and they do not have any spare time to go to schools. Pakrashi (2009) has demonstrated a vicious cycle of child labor trap in Sub-Saharan Africa and Asia: “Despite the high private rate of return to primary education, in Sub-Saharan Africa and Asia, many families are unable to afford their children’s education because of the prevalence of credit constraints. The inability of the parents to defray even a small amount of money may give rise to child labor.” Poverty and child labor issues are not problems that have newly emerged in the contemporary era. Developed nations have experienced these issues during a process of their development in the 19th...

Words: 4285 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Arab Minority Education Facts

...Arab & Israeli Arab Women Minority Education Dilemma Facts The Arab minority education in Israel had been a dilemma for the ages. The Israeli educational system was built on inequality between the Arabs and the Jews and between the center and periphery. Generally. There are variations between all the categories at all levels, Jews and Arabs. Mainly, the increasing disparities between the ethical and the various social groups in Israel, besides the absence of an appropriate educational policy lead to difficulties and stress, which face the Arab minority women`s education. Additionally, other contributing factors worsened the situation such as the lack or the absence of the Arab communities within the state of Israel. Consequently, the Israeli...

Words: 1638 - Pages: 7