Free Essay

Conflict Handling Styles

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By jayaramgkrishna
Words 1350
Pages 6
Understanding Conflict Handling Styles
In a dispute, it's often easier to describe how others respond then to how we respond. Each of us has a predominant conflict style that we use to meet our own needs. By examining conflict styles and the consequences of those behaviors, we can gain a better understanding of the impact that our personal conflict style has on other people. With a better understanding, you then can make a conscious choice on how to respond to others in a conflict situation to help reduce work conflict and stress.
Behavioral scientists Kenneth Thomas and Ralph Kilmann, who developed the Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument, have identified five styles to responding to conflict—competition, collaboration, compromise, avoidance, and accommodation. No conflict style is inherently right or wrong, but one or more styles could be inappropriate for a given situation and the impact could result in a situation quickly spiraling out of control.
1. Competing
Value of own issue/goal: High
Value of relationship: Low
Goal: I win, you lose
People who consistently use a competitive style come across as aggressive, autocratic, confrontational, and intimidating. A competitive style is an attempt to gain power and pressure a change at the other person’s expense. A competitive style of managing conflict can be appropriate when you have to implement an unpopular decision, make a quick decision, the decision is vital in a crisis, or it is important to let others know how important an issue is to you – "standing up for your right." The biggest disadvantage of using this style is that relationships can be harmed beyond repair and may encourage other parties to use covert methods to get their needs met because conflict with these people are reduced to – "if you are not with me, you are against me."
2. Accommodating
Value of own issue/goal: Low
Value relationship: High
Goal: I lose, you win
By accommodating you set aside your own personal needs because you want to please others in order to keep the peace. The emphasis is on preserving the relationship. Smoothing or harmonizing can result in a false solution to a problem and can create feelings in a person that range from anger to pleasure. Accommodators are unassertive and cooperative and may play the role of a martyr, complainer, or saboteur. However, accommodation can be useful when one is wrong or when you want to minimize losses when you are going to lose anyway because it preserves relationships. If you use it all the time it can become competitive – "I am nicer than you are" – and may result in reduced creativity in conflict situations and increased power imbalances.
3. Avoiding
Value of own issue/goal: Low
Value of relationship: Low
Goal: I lose, you lose
Avoidance is characterized by deliberately ignoring or withdrawing from a conflict rather than facing it. This style may be perceived as not caring about your own issue or the issues of others. People who avoid the situation hope the problem will go away, resolve itself without their involvement, or think that others are ready to take the responsibility. There are situations where avoidance is appropriate such as when you need more time to think of how to respond, time constraints demand a delay, confrontation will hurt a working relationship, or there is little chance of satisfying your needs. However, avoidance can be destructive if the other person perceives that you don’t care enough to engage. By not dealing with the conflict, this style allows the conflict to simmer and heat up unnecessarily, resulting in anger or a negative outburst.
4. Compromising
Value of own issue/goal: Medium
Value of relationship: Medium
Goal: I win some, you win some
The compromising style demonstrates that you are willing to sacrifice some of your goals while persuading others to give up part of theirs – give a little, get a little. Compromising maintains the relationship and can take less time than collaboration and resolutions might mean splitting the difference or seeking a middle ground position. The downside to compromising is that it can be an easy way out and reduces new creative options. If you constantly split the difference or “straddle the fence,” game playing can result and the outcome could be less than ideal.
5. Collaborating
Value of own issue/goal: High
Value of relationship: High
Goal: I win, you win
The collaborative style views conflicts as problems to be solved and finding creative solutions that satisfy all the parties’ concerns. You don’t give up your self interest; you dig into the issue to identify the underlying concerns, test your own assumptions, and understand the views of others. Collaboration takes time and if the relationship among the parties is not important, then it may not be worth the time and energy to create a win-win solution. However, collaboration fosters respect, trust, and builds relationships. To make an environment more collaborative, address the conflict directly and in a way that expresses willingness for all parties to get what they need.
Although all of the approaches have their time and place, you need to ask yourself the basic question, "Is my preferred conflict handling style the very best I can use to resolve this conflict or solve this problem?"
Focus on Interests (Needs), Not Positions (Wants)
Understanding people's interests is not a simple task because we tend to communicate our positions – things that are likely to be concrete and explicit. It is helpful to learn to recognize the difference between person’s positions and interests to assist in creative problem solving. * Positions are predetermined solutions or demands that people use to describe what they want – what the person wants to happen on a particular issue.
For example: "I want the report." * Interests define the problem and may be intangible, unexpressed, or not consistent. They are the main reasons why you say what you want – the motivation behind the position. The conflict is usually between each person's needs, desire, concern, or fear.
For example: "I need to receive the report by Friday, so I can have time to review and edit before the due date next Wednesday."
Remember that figuring out your interests is just as important as figuring out their interests.
How to Identify Interests
To identify interests of the other person, you need to ask questions to determine what the person believes he or she truly needs. When you ask, be sure to clarify that you are not asking questions for justification of their position, but for a better understanding of their needs, fears, hopes, and desires.
Using open-ended questions that encourage a person to "tell their story" helps you begin to understand their interest. Open ended questions are opposite of closed-ended questions, which require a response of "yes" or "no." To illustrate the difference, consider the following example: * Did you have a good relationship with your supervisor? (closed-ended) * Tell me about your relationship with your supervisor. (open-ended)
Examples of open-ended questions: * What’s your basic concern about …? * Tell me about … * What do you think about …? * How could we fix …? * What would happen if …? * How else could you do …? * What could you tell me about …? * Then what? * Could you help me understand …? * What do you think you will lose if you …? * What have you tried before? * What do you want to do next? * How can I be of help?
The most powerful interests for you to consider are the basic human needs for security, economic well-being, sense of belonging to an organization, identify, recognition of contribution or efforts, and autonomy or control over decisions or work. It is not uncommon for you or the other person to have multiple interests and it would be helpful for you to write them down as they occur to help you sort them out. This list may be helpful to think through ideas that may meet these interests.
Problem solving on your interests and the other person’s interests leads to more creative and successful resolutions because you meet not only your need but theirs as well.
Source: Fisher, Ury, and Patton, Getting to Yes, 1991

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Conflict Handling Style

...II.C.5 What’s My Preferred Conflict-Handling Style? Instrument When you differ with someone, how do you respond? Use the following rating scale to record your answers : 1= Practically never 2= Once in a great while 3= Sometimes 4= Fairly often 5= Very often 1. I work to come out victorious, no matter what. 1 2 3 4 5 2. I try to put the needs of other before myself. 1 2 3 4 5 3. I look for a mutually satisfactory solution. 1 2 3 4 5 4. I try not to get involved in conflicts. 1 2 3 4 5 5. I strive to investigate issues thoroughly and jointly. 1 2 3 4 5 6. I never back away from a good argument. 1 2 3 4 5 7. I strive to foster harmony. 1 2 3 4 5 8. I negotiate to get a portion of what I propose. 1 2 3 4 5 9. I avoid open discussions of controversial subjects. 1 2 3 4 5 10. I openly share information with others in resolving 1 2 3 4 5 disagreements. 11. I would rather win than end up compromising. 1 2 3 4 5 12. I got along with suggestions of others. 1 2 3 4 5 13. I look for middle...

Words: 726 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Intercultural Conflict Management

...Intercultural Conflict Management How should we define an intercultural conflict? Is there any difference between a conflict and an intercultural one? The following chapter, which is a summary of the chapter “Constructive Intercultural Conflict Management” (Stella Ting-Toomey, Communicating Across Cultures, 1999, pages 194-197), attempts to answer these two questions. At the end of the chapter, we also include an extract of the “Intercultural Conflict Style Inventory” (Mitchell Hammer, 2002) 1. Definition of intercultural conflicts “Intercultural conflict is defined as the perceived or actual incompatibility of values, norms, processes, or goals between a minimum of two cultural parties over content, identity, relational, and procedural issues. Intercultural conflict often starts off with different expectations concerning appropriate or inappropriate behavior in an interaction episode.” (Ting-Toomey, 1999, p.194). Another author holds a similar view: “Conflicts are always cultural, since we are all cultural beings. Yet the very definition of conflict is challenging because of our cultural ways of seeing”. (Michelle Le Baron and Venashri Pillay, Conflict across Cultures, 2006, page 13). According to Le Baron, conflict occurs at ← the material level, or the “what” of the conflict; ← the symbolic level, the meaning of issues to the people involved, especially those meanings that resonate with peoples' identities, values, and worldviews; ← and......

Words: 1761 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Conflict

...Personal Conflict Style Inventory How Do I Respond to Conflict? Instructions. Consider your response in situations where your wishes differ from those of another person. Note that statements A-J (Part One) deal with your initial response to disagreement; statements K-T (Part Two) deal with your response after the disagreement has gotten stronger. If you find it easier, you may choose one particular conflict setting and use it as a background for all the questions. Please Note. The reflection this inventory can create is more important— and more reliable — than the numbers the tally sheet yields. There are no "right" or "wrong" answers, nor have we "standardized" this instrument. Some takers agree with the results; others disagree. Whether you like the results or not, you should rely on them for an accurate picture of yourself only after further self-scrutiny and discussion with others. The inventory is merely a tool to enable these larger tasks. Part One Circle one number on the line below each statement. A. WHEN I FIRST DISCOVER THAT DIFFERENCES EXIST, I make sure that all views are out in the open and treated with equal consideration, even if there seems to be substantial disagreement. Not at all Characteristic Very 1 2 3 4 5 6 Characteristic B. WHEN I FIRST DISCOVER THAT DIFFERENCES EXIST, I devote more attention to making sure others understand the logic and benefits of my position than I do to pleasing them. Not at......

Words: 1362 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Project

...N 1;1 ~OF CONFLICT HANDLING STYLES AND PROJECT MANAGER EFFECTIVENESS THESIS Stephen P. Wardlaw, Captain, USAF AFIT/GSM/LSY/88S-28 TC nc21A9 88 DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE AIR UNIVERSITY AIR FORCE INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio - .m.l i -. . . . 88 12 21 026 AFIT/GSMILSY/88S-28 CONFLICT HANDLING STYLES AND PROJECT MANAGER EFFECTIVENESS THESIS Stephen P. Wardlaw, Captain, UJSAF AFIT/GSMILSY/88S-28 Approved for public release; distribution unlimited . -! -- U II - U PU E I ~ E 1 I 1 - m . . The contents of the document are technically accurate, and no sensitive items, detrimental ideas, or deleterious information is contained therein. Furthermore, the views expressed in the document are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the School of Systems and Logistics, the Air University, the United States Air Force, or the Department of Defense. Aceession For NTIS GRA&I LTIC TAB Unannounced JustificationBy l ,i Distribution/_ AvailtbilitY Codes A-7 U ,' o Dist 1pecial L .... AFIT/GSM/LSY/88S-28 CONFLICT HANDLING STYLES AND PROJECT MANAGER EFFECTIVENESS THESIS Presented to the Faculty of the School of Systems and Logistics of the Air Force Institute of Technology Air University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Systems......

Words: 3520 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Operation Management

...professor’s notes. Working through this week I learned about the organization culture and conflict resolution. There are many ways to handle the conflict, and the ways mentioned in the lecture were Yielding, Compromising, Forcing, Problem – Solving and Avoiding. The “What is your primary conflict – handling style?” exercise in the textbook provides an opportunity to see one’s conflict – handling style by asking one’s decision in the given scenario. This exercise helped me to understand how to handle the conflict. I’ve scored the highest in the Forcing style. This result means that imposing my wills on the other party is my primary conflict – handling style and trying to reach an agreement that would satisfy both parties would be my fallback intention. This exercise provided me an opportunity to know my personal conflict – handling style and with the research I’ve done, I now know the strengths and weaknesses in the conflict resolving style and may still be able to find a new style of handling conflict. As a manager in the future, to solve the conflict is a key to success, therefore, I will use my conflict resolution style to handle any other conflicts which exist in the organization. However, I need to get more skills to solve the conflicts and to make everyone satisfied with the final decision. As the scenarios in the exercise also provided examples of what kind of conflict – handling style one uses. In the future, I may use these examples as a reference to......

Words: 1441 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Orginaizationl Behavier

...dispute resolution (ADR) | A conflict resolution strategy that involves assistance from a third party; used when both parties are unable to find resolution on their own. | | Conflict | One party perceives its interests are being opposed or set back by another party. | | Day of contemplation | A one-time-only day off with pay to allow a problem employee to reflect and recommit to the organization's values and mission. | | Distributive negotiation | Two interdependent parties, each with their own opposite preference, seek to make a decision that will result in one party winning at the expense of the other. | | Dysfunctional conflict | Threatens the interests of an organization. | | Functional conflict | Serves an organization's interests. | | Integrative negotiation | Two interdependent parties with their own preferences and values seek a win-win resolution through greater dialogue and cooperation. | | Personality conflict | Interpersonal opposition driven by personal dislike or disagreement. | Outline: Chapter 8CONFLICT AND NEGOTIATIONLearning Outcomes 1.      Define conflict, functional conflict, and dysfunctional conflict 2.      Identify the various antecedents (causes) of conflict 3.      List two approaches an employee or manager can take to respond to each of the following: personality conflicts, intergroup conflict, and cross-cultural conflict 4.      Compare and contrast the five alternative styles for handling conflict 5.      Assess the......

Words: 2212 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Reflective Leadership Plan

...Reflective Leadership Plan Donald Graham University of Phoenix Reflective Leadership Plan I have had many leadership courses throughout my life, this course Leadership Theories and Practice has been the most profound for me. The theories and self-assessments have caused me to reflect on my current knowledge and application of leadership style and theories. I have discovered that my skills and mind set as it relates to leadership needs to develop and grow into the person and the leader I wish to be. I have developed the following action plan for the development and improvement of my leadership skills. Leadership Theory The assessment of my current leadership style or theory is the situational approach. Clawson (2006) described a situational leader as one who is concerned about the contextual factors of the nature of work required (p. 386). According to Hersey and Blanchard as quoted by (Clawson, 2006) the situational theory can be identified using a two dimensional grid of task orientation and people orientation. The situational approach used a contingent pattern of task and relations behavior with little evidence that this approached increased the effectiveness of the leader (Yukl, 2006). I have been an action or task orientated leader to this point in my life. I want to become a transformational leader to realize effective leadership. Yukl (2006) described a transformational leader as a leader that affects their followers to make necessary......

Words: 1696 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Interpersonal Berhaviour

...2006, p.77). In the Waki oil company issues of interpersonal relationships have proved to be quiet a big challenge for the organization over the past few years. The management has at various occasions experienced difficulties in trying to come up with better and appropriate solutions to conflicts between and among the employees, as well as those that involve interaction between the managers and the employees. Basically conflict refers to a state of whereby individuals do not agree with another or rather do not share the same ideas as the other. Such situations necessitate that there be a place good and appropriate ways through which the conflict between individuals may be solved promoting fairness with the parties involved having full satisfaction and in support of the resolution reached at regarding the conflict (Blake and Mouton 2002, p. 50). Within the Waki oil organization there are different department which in a weekly basis need to come together giving reports and sharing issues regarding how the company is progressing. It is within these weekly meeting that managers from different department come into conflict with one another in regards to ideas that each holds. Worse enough the conflict extends out of the meeting discussions to the day to day activities of the company. Such that even the employees themselves see what is happening with their senior staffs. The disunity among them, lack of cohesion, among others individualistic characteristic traits are......

Words: 1678 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Aloha

...368 Academy of Management Journal June Levy, P., & Pugh, D. Scaling and multivariate analysis in the study of organizational variables. Sociology, 1969, 3(2), 193-213. Litwin, G. H., & Stringer, R. A., Jr. Motivation and organizational climate. Boston: Harvard University Press, 1968. Mohr, L. B. Determinants of innovation in organizations. American Political Science Review, 1969, 63, 111-126. Palumbo, D. Power and role speciflcity in organization theory. Public Administration Review, 1969, 29, 237-248. Paolillo, J. G. Technological innovation in organizational R&D subsystems. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. University of Oregon, 1977. Paolillo, J. G., & Brown, W. B. How organizational factors affect R and D innovation. Research Management, 1978, 7, 12-15. Pritchard, R. D., & Karasick, B. W. The effects of organizational climate on managerial job performance and job satisfaction. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1973, 9, 126-146. Rogers, E. M., & Eveland, J. D. Diffusion: Communication and innovation in organizations. In P. Kelly & M. Kranzbert (Eds.), Aspects of technological innovation. Atlanta: Advanced Technology and Science Studies, Georgia Institute of Technology, 1975, 301-368. Sapolsky, H. M. Organizational structure and innovation. The Journal of Business, 1967,40, 497-510. Vegso, R. W. Organizational characteristics that influence innovative behavior. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. University of Cincinnati, 1976. Zaltman, G., Duncan, R., & Holbeck,......

Words: 3679 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Comm 105

...lengths each day. Parker was not impressed with either of their work efforts but only proceeded to torment Miller. Parker’s constant yelling caused Miller to subconsciously exert less effort towards his work. Parker failed to effectively use his legitimate power correctly, instead it appeared that he was resorting to the use of cohesive power. Although Parker expected seven lengths of each team member, he should have consulted the other members and created solidified team norms to ensure this expectation could be a reality. When dealing with this conflict, Parker had a very forceful approach to dealing with his and Miller’s conflict. Both Parker, Miller needed to be aware of the other possibilities to deal with conflict; with the implementation of such courses and training programs that specify in conflict resolution, this issue could be avoided for future workers. The improper use of power and the ineffective use of conflict handling styles lead to this team’s lack of cohesion and bitter feelings when parting with the project. Analysis The power that Tom Parker exercised was a large part of why the Artic Mining Consultants’ crew hadn’t completed their work by the budgeted time. Tom Parker held legitimate...

Words: 2112 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Studying the Role of Age in the Relationship of Emotional Intelligence and Conflict Resolution Styles in the It Profession

...“STUDYING THE ROLE OF AGE IN THE RELATIONSHIP OF EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE AND CONFLICT RESOLUTION STYLES IN THE IT PROFESSION” A PROJECT REPORT SUBMITTED BY SHRUTI SIAG FOR THE PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT OF THE AWARD OF THE DEGREE OF M.A. IN PSYCHOLOGY AT FERGUSSON COLLEGE PUNE - 411004 (2010-11) Declaration I, Ms Shruti Siag a student of M.A. from the Department of Psychology, Fergusson College, Pune University, declare that the following report of a project titled “STUDYING THE ROLE OF AGE IN THE RELATIONSHIP OF EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE AND CONFLICT RESOLUTION STYLES IN THE IT PROFESSION” is an independent work done by me and submitted as the partial fulfilment of the requirement for the award of the degree of M.A. in Psychology under the University of Pune. Signature: Name: Shruti Siag D.E. Society’s Fergusson College, Pune Certificate This is to certify that Shruti Siag has successfully completed the project named “Studying the role of Age in the relationship of Emotional Intelligence and Conflict Resolution Styles in the IT profession” Towards the partial completion of M. A. (Psychology) Course of the University of Pune, in the academic year 2009-2010. Dr. Shobhana AbhayankarHead of the DepartmentDept. of PsychologyFergusson CollegePune-411004 | Prof. Anand. S. GodseProject In-chargeDept. of PsychologyFergusson......

Words: 13801 - Pages: 56

Premium Essay

Learning Team B Leadership Analysis

...researchers have studied the means, methods, and models of building and leading teams. The research on leadership models and behaviors emerged through the modernization of manufacturing and production of goods and services. Studies included the study of biographical characteristics of members, such as sex, age, education, marital status, race, religious affiliation, geographic region of birth, weight, and height are some of the data collected (Bass, 2010, p. 7). Moreover, the purpose of this essay is to give an overview of the team’s online assessment scores and how each team member’s leadership style translates into specific leadership behaviors and practices. In addition to the overview, Learning Team B will describe how each team member’s style reflects one or more leadership theories, while explaining team member’s leadership style, use of power, conflict-handling style, and team skills that potentially affect team effectiveness. Learning Team B leadership analysis is based on members’ self-assessment scores from the Pearson-Prentice Hall Self-Assessment Library...

Words: 3419 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Organizational Behavior

...Organizational Behavior Summary Paper Nancy Simmons AOL9 October 2, 2012 The purpose of this summary paper is to discuss three major themes in which I have demonstrated knowledge of and made application. The themes that I have chosen are • Systems Approach • Conflict resolution vs. Conflict management • Relationship between conflict handling modes (Thomas-Kilmann) According to Tubbs ‘the systems approach advanced the idea that all the various component parts of the model are interrelated and that a change in one often creates change in the other parts of the system (Tubbs, 2012)’. There are three major categories to the systems approach, which include: (1) relevant background factors, (2) internal influences, and (3) consequences. Relevant background factors are attributes of the individual participants that existed prior to the group’s formation that will endure in some modified form after the group no longer exists. These background factors influence the group’s functioning; in turn, the group process affects the group’s outcome or results (Tubbs, 2012). We all were born into this world with different personalities, with no two persons alike. The personalities we instill will have an influence on said, “chemistry” or working relationships within a group, no matter the setting. It could be a setting of all women, all men or maybe even a mixed setting with different genders. This creates a very fickle situation. ......

Words: 2665 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Conflict Management

...Conflict Management Conflict Management Yamil Little Strayer University BUS520 Dr. Anthony Hughes 02/27/11 Conflict Management Introduction In today’s ever-changing business environment organizations encounter varying levels of intrapersonal, interpersonal, intragroup, and intergroup conflicts. Intrapersonal conflict is a battle within oneself, which usually involves a life goal and/or change. Interpersonal conflict is when two or more people have opposing perspectives to a given situation. Intragroup conflict is when disagreements occur amongst some or all members of a group and ultimately affects productivity. Intergroup conflict is when disagreements occur between different teams or groups. The success and efficiency of an organization depends a great deal on how well individuals handle conflict. Each person handles interpersonal conflict differently and generally falls under the collaborating, compromising, forcing, accommodating, and avoiding styles of conflict handling. The collaborating style addresses conflicts with a win-win approach presented to opposing perspectives. The goal is to find a mutually beneficial solution to organizational conflicts. For a collaborating style of conflict management to be successful a high level of cooperation and assertiveness amongst the group is needed. The compromising style of conflict management addresses issues with a give-and-take approach. In comparison to the collaborating...

Words: 1475 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

To Manage Group Conflict

...and resolve conflict successfully. Conflict management is a skill that can be learned. The human relationship is a complex and dynamic inter-action. As living creatures, we need and crave the opportunity to interact with other humans by speaking, listening, and spending time with them. Most of this interaction tends to be mutual and cordial. Yet, at times, the interaction can be laced with tension and discord. If left alone, the tension can lead to conflict that may damage the relationship or even become volatile. Conflict between individuals and within groups often occurs because people have differences of opinion, have different values and goals, or receive inaccurate information. Conflict is not always a bad thing. In many cases, conflict can lead to a better understanding of and response to issues. Conflict also can lead to creative problem solving and the initiation of innovative ideas. However, if conflict is sup-pressed and not addressed, it can lead to distrust and greater discord within the group. For a group to be productive and successful, group members and leaders need to be able to identify, address, and resolve conflict successfully. Like any other leadership skill, conflict management can be learned. The overall goal for conflict management is to find common ground (mutual goals and interests that all parties share) within the issue and use that as the foundation for resolution. Source: Trautman K. ,Kriesel C.B. Rice T. Mnanging Group Conflict,g2115.......

Words: 5768 - Pages: 24