Free Essay

Craniology

In:

Submitted By ryanisawesome
Words 689
Pages 3
Craniology In God, Women, and the New Physics, Wertheim reports that craniology is a scientific discipline. So what is it? Craniology is the measurement of the skull. Craniology has two functions: (1) measure the size, shape, and the proportion of the skull comparing to body size; (2) interpretation of the data from measuring the skull. In the middle of the eighteenth century, "masculine mien" thought that women should not freely mix with men in science. They claimed that men must stay away from women in order to attain serious intellectual engagement. According to Pythagoras's Trousers, Wertheim wrote, “The science and femininity were being constructed as opposites whereas science was associated with reason, objectivity, and facts, women were associated with feeling, subjectivity, and literary allusion” (147-148). Men and women are created to serve different purposes. Since women are associated with feeling, subjectivity, and literary allusion, they were not meant for science. The anatomists discovered the way to measure the various sizes, shapes, and the proportion of the skull comparing to body size which is called craniology. The anatomists wanted to find the scientific evidence to support their claim that women are intellectually inferior to men. According to Pythagoras's Trousers, she wrote, "After careful measurement, anatomists "discovered" that women's skulls were smaller in proportion to their bodies than men's (Wertheim 148)." This concluded that intellect is lower with the skull size which is smaller proportion to the body size. Since women's skull is smaller in proportion to the body size compared to men's, therefore, women are intellectually inferior. However, Wertheim continued, "The problem with this deduction was that women's head are actually larger in proportion to their bodies than men's” (148). The anatomists then claim that since women are closer to the children whose heads are also proportions larger to their body size; they do not grow completely yet as children. The women also have their heads which are proportions larger to their body size. Since the children's intellectual capacities are inferior to men, which also make the women mentally inferior. Then the anatomists reclaim that intellect is higher if the skull size is smaller in proportion to body size. Because the women's skull is larger in proportion to their body's size, this makes women intellectually inferior to those of men. However, there are many flaws in those arguments. First, the sizes of the skull do not necessary indicate the quality of the brain. Some people may have thicker skull which makes them have a smaller brain than others. Second, children's intellectual capacities are inferior to men because men have more opportunity to engage in real life experience. In the other hand, children usually stay at home eating and sleeping all day long. They do not engage in real life experience. So do women. Back in the day, many women were not allowed to learn. There is no way they can perform in science as well as men do. Intellect is gaining from learning and experience. As people grow up, they learn new things; that makes them more intelligent. For example, if someone is isolated from all other people since little, he or she will not be much smarter than that child. He or she will not be able to speak. Even though the skull will get smaller in proportion to the body size, which does not make him or her smarter than when he or she was the little child. As a scientific discipline, craniology appears to be misguided because the claims that those scientists made contradicts themselves. First, they claim that intellect is lower with the skull smaller in proportion to the body size, and then they claim the opposite when being attacked by the fact that the women's skulls are actually larger in proportion to their body size. There is no real evidence to support their claims. From the beginning, their discovery of craniology was driven by the look down on women's learning capacity. Their observation was driven by expectation that women are intellectual inferior to men, so the outcome of the observation is not scientifically accurate. Those anatomists simply use an opinion for their claims.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Anthropology

...Ryan Smith Anth 204-500 Dr. Graf 10/10/15 The Politics of Culture: How societies are influenced How a modern society perceives itself and other societies is directly correlated with its historical past. The way government, politics, and culture reacts to prejudice, war, and controversy, all ties to past events that molded into a sense of nationalism and tolerance of other societies. As history changes overtime our views of ourselves and others also change, creating our societies “narratives of origin” (Moscovici, 1988). A fundamental representation of our nation’s origin and aspirations are influenced by the changing circumstances, which guides modern society’s response to new challenges. Change in civilizations is sparked from societal wrongs that cause a civil up-roar. Court cases provide the best historical evidence of how the past can redefine present culture. Since the civil war, African Americans role within the nation has changed drastically from a slave to the President of the United States. Monumental cases like Dred Scott v. Sanford, Plessy v. Ferguson, Brown v. Board of Education, along with mass protests across the United States; all influenced the civil rights of African Americans. Another case that shaped our civilization was from the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire. Due to negligence of the factory owners, Max Blanck and Isaac Harris, one hundred and forty-five people died in a factory fire because of inaccessibility to fire escapes. This devastation sparked...

Words: 1207 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Pt Notes

...|Prefix/suffix |Meaning |Example(s) | |balano- |Of the glans penis or glans clitoridis |Balanitis | |bi- |twice, double |Binary[disambiguation needed [pic]] | |bio- |life |Biology | |blast(o)- |germ or bud |Blastomere | |blephar(o)- |Of or pertaining to the eyelid |Blepharoplast | |brachi(o)- |Of or relating to the arm |Brachium of inferior colliculus | |brachy- |Indicating 'short' or less commonly 'little' |brachycephalic | |brady- |'slow' |Bradycardia | |bronch(i)-...

Words: 3541 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Sciece!

...What does the average person think when they hear that an idea is supported by science? Often, it makes people assume that this idea must be objectively true, and will necessarily be more right than a theory that doesn’t have the backing of “science.” While in many cases, objective science really does produce better results than mere conjecture, there have also been influential movements in history that were justified by “science,” but which we see today as unjustifiable. These include biometrical methods like phrenology and craniology, the empirical definitions of racial difference in the 19th century, and the “scientifically” racist ideology of the Nazis, among many others. In many of these situations, biology has been used to support conceptions that were already accepted in the society of the time. However, they seemed stronger with scientific support, even if the scientific support was weak enough that it was eventually proven to be untrue. Considering this, why were these “scientific” conclusions seen as objective when, with the benefit of hindsight, it is clear that they were not? Additionally, why did the supporters of these ideologies want to use science as support? If science were seen as merely a collection of useless knowledge, it would not have been relied upon in the way that it was, so it is clear that the scientific method was trusted to add some additional level of truth to the given conclusions. The interactions between these systems of classifying groups...

Words: 4512 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Women in Science

...History of Women in Science Women have continually played a part in scientific endeavor, even prior to invention of the term ‘scientist’. Nevertheless, in Western culture, science and femininity lacked unity and the masculine painting of science revealed not only that more males did science, but that science itself was seen as an integrally masculine venture. The notion that mathematics and science were unsuitable or ‘hard’ for women, and even ‘at odds’ with real femininity, can be trailed back to the beginning of modern science and the commencement of the Royal Society in the seventeenth century. Then ‘femininity’ became the exact opposite of the new, masculine, experimental science of Newton and his colleagues who needed to break from the passive, reflective analytical style of outdated ‘natural philosophy’, the former word for science. (Schiebinger, 1996). This divide that detached women from the new experimental science, was made a lot wider by the Nature’s tradition being embodied in female form only. The masculine scientists made ‘mother nature’ their goal of research, and branded her as a female muse who could trick them, but if trained would also permit them to ‘enter her secrets’. This entire trap cast femininity as the inactive, topic of investigation and the male as the virile, enthusiastic investigator; a dualism that just increased the difference between science and femininity (Jordanova, 1991). Regardless of this, there existed women scientists— botanists, mathematicians...

Words: 5185 - Pages: 21

Free Essay

Understanding the Aryans

...UNDERSTANDING THE ARYANS A roadmap for students and beginners Burjor Avari (Manchester Metropolitan University) It is a known fact of history that the British curiosity and interest in Indian cultures increased phenomenally after the East India Company came to acquire a territorial hold on Bengal from the late 1750s onwards. Their paramountcy over India’s millions depended upon their thorough understanding of the cultures of the sub-continent which required a mastery in its languages.[i] The small circle of dedicated and assiduous students of India’s languages included Sir William Jones, the eminent jurist and polymath who resided in India between 1783 and 1794.[ii] After studying Sanskrit for just under three years he observed, in 1786, that Sanskrit, Greek and Latin and Old Persian had all descended from an original speech. His observation has proved correct; and, since his time, most learned philological opinion has accepted that, in terms of language classifications, the common source of these tongues was what is now called proto-Indo-European. Its geographical focus was presumed to be the area around the Caspian Sea. It is also generally accepted that the eastern branch of the Indo-European family of languages is known as the Indo-Iranian whose first speakers called themselves Aryans. Whether the Aryans, speaking some variety of Indo-European languages, invaded or migrated into Iran and India from their original trans-Caspian homeland or...

Words: 11691 - Pages: 47

Free Essay

Jjjjjj

...Volume 10 Number 6 June 4, 2007 Black Intellectual Genocide: An Essay Review of IQ and the Wealth of Nations Girma Berhanu Göteborg University Sweden Lynn, Richard & Vanhanen, Tatu. (2002). IQ and the Wealth of Nations. Westport, CT: Praeger. Citation: Berhanu, Girma. (2007). Black intellectual genocide: An essay review of IQ and the Wealth of Nations. Education Review, 10(6). Retrieved [date] from http://edrev.asu.edu/essays/v10n6index.html. Abstract I review the book IQ and the Wealth of Nations, written by Richard Lynn and Tatu Vanhanen. I critique the authors’ major assertion that a significant part of the gap between rich and poor countries is due to differences in national intelligence. The authors claim that they have evidence that differences in national IQ account for substantial variation in per capita income and growth of a nation. This essay review debunks their assumptions that intellectual and income differences between nations stem from genetic differences. This critique provides an extended review of the research literature that argues against these assumptions and presents a different picture from that presented by Lynn and Vanhanen about the concept of intelligence, what IQ measures and does not measure. The essay exposes the racist, sexist, and antihuman nature of the research tradition in which the authors anchored their studies and the deep methodological flaws and theoretical assumptions that appear in their book. The low standards of scholarship...

Words: 13913 - Pages: 56