Free Essay

Creative Voice

In: English and Literature

Submitted By Karyalba69
Words 981
Pages 4
Kary Alba
ENG 102
Professor Brackett
Essay 2: M. Butterfly
One of the most outstanding questions that arises throughout the plot of David Henry
Hwang’s play, Butterfly
M
, is that of how Gallimard did not know that Song Liling was a man throughout the entirety of their affair.
Gallimard falls in love with Song, whom he believes to be a woman, during his time as a diplomat in Beijing. Unlucky and awkward, Gallimard is an unlikely candidate for the attentions of a beautiful woman.
Indeed, how is it that this affair, that spanned several years and was accomplished, enabled Song to disguise himself as a woman for so long, and so completely? The relationship between Gallimard and Song was allowed to continue without breaking the illusion simply, because people do see what they want to (or that people will refuse to see something that they do not, no matter how much evidence there is to the contrary). Gallimard is influenced by the stereotypes associated with oriental women.
He is particularly attached to a vision of Asian women as being modest, submissive, and extremely loyal to their men.
Throughout the play Gallimard associates oriental women with various stereotypes that aren’t necessarily true. “It’s true what they say about Oriental girls. They want to be treated bad!” (Act 1, Scene 3) Gallimard knows that he isn’t the best bachelor for women and cherishes every bit of Song’s love and the feeling of power and masculinity she gives him. This is a major reason why Gallimard was blinded by the fact that Song was actually a man.
The role of the

Butterfly is representative of the “ideal woman” and more so embodies for Western audiences, especially Western men, the optimal Asian woman. Butterfly is the submissive, feminine woman ready to give everything up for the powerful Western man. Gallimard truly believes most of these stereotypes to be true and is completely oblivious to the fact that his lover is a man.
In the courtroom scene in the opening of Act Three, Scene One, Song explains to the judge how he was able to pass a woman to Gallimard for so long. He says: “As soon as a
Western man comes into contact with the East—he’s already confused. The West has a sort of an international rape mentality towards the East…The West thinks of itself as masculine, big guns, big industry, big money whereas the East is feminine, weak, delicate, and poor. The West believes that the East, deep down, wants to be dominated—because a woman can’t think for herself. When Gallimard finally met his fantasy woman, Song, he wanted more than anything to believe that she was, in fact, a woman. I am an Oriental. And being an Oriental, I could never completely be a man.” (Act 3, Scene 1) Gallimard essentially believes that if you are a Westerner you can never see the East as equal. He believes that if you are from the East you cannot be masculine or powerful. This is how Song was so easily able to fool Gallimard into thinking she was a woman. Gallimard already had a preconceived notion about orientals and was blinded by his own thoughts.
Gallimard so readily accepted Song as a woman because he was Asian. He first saw Song in the role of the Butterfly, the pre­accepted concept of Asian women by Western men. If he ever noticed something different while he was with Song, Gallimard associated Song’s behavior or differences in anatomy as some form of “Chinese modesty” or the fact that Song was Asian.
More so, if Gallimard recognized Song as a man in terms of biology, he himself would never see

Song as an actual man; a man that could be powerful and strong, because that violates the stereotype of the inferiority of Asians. Gallimard’s mind simply rejected the idea that Song was indeed a man and persisted that Song was his Butterfly and that any anomalies were merely the fact that Asian “women” were just different from the women he was used to. Furthermore,
Gallimard as a symbol of the West demonstrates the severe bias and assumption that the West has towards the East and foreign policy in Asia. In order for the West to feel superior, to feel that they have the “big guns,” it is necessary that the West deny Eastern power or individuality. G gggggggg Gallimard refuses to admit that Song is a man, even when deep down inside he knows the truth. Just like in the Vietnam War, where the West refused to pull out and admit defeat.
Because defeat at the hands of an “Asian woman”is intolerable. This persistence in Eastern inferiority continues to this day. Maybe this view is merely the West projecting its own inferiorities on to an easier “target.” Perhaps the West is the true Butterfly, and simply needs to see the East as it really is, an equal. Gallimard allows himself to be oblivious to Song’s true identity because he relies on the stereotypes applied to Asians and women, to define a Chinese woman. For Gallimard, admitting that Butterfly did not really exist means admitting that his own power over a woman also did not exist. This strips Gallimard of his manhood as defined by the rules expressed throughout the play. Finally in scene two while Song finally strips for Gallimard, the reluctant Gallimard admits, “I knew all the time somewhere that my happiness was temporary, my love a deception. But my mind kept the knowledge at bay. To make the weight bearable” (Act 3, Scene 2). This is interesting because we wonder if Gallimard knew he was being tricked, perhaps subconsciously.

"The LitCharts Study Guide to M. Butterfly."
LitCharts
. N.p., n.d. Web. 04 Apr. 2016. Hwang, David Henry, and Giacomo Puccini. . Butterfly
M
. New York, NY: New American
Library, 1989. Print.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Tops

...Explain how sentence style affects emphasis within your message List five ways to develop coherent paragraphs COMMUNICATION CLOSE-UP AT CREATIVE COMMONS www.creativecommons.org Have you ever noticed that tiny © symbol on books, DVDs, music CDs, and other media products? It means that the person or organization who created the item is granted copyright protection, the exclusive legal right to produce, distribute, and sell that creation. Anyone who wants to resell, redistribute, or adapt such works usually needs to secure permission from the current copyright holder. However, what if you want people to remix the song you just recorded? Or suppose you need a few photos for a website? Other than for limited personal and educational use, a conventional copyright requires every person to negotiate a contract for every application or adaptation of every piece of work he or she wants to use. The search for some middle ground between “all rights reserved” and simply giving your work away led Stanford University law professor Lawrence Lessig to co-found Creative Commons. This nonprofit organization’s goal is to provide a simple, free, and legal way for musicians, artists, writers, teachers, scientists, and others to collaborate and benefit through the sharing of art and ideas. Instead of the everything-or-nothing approach of traditional copyright, Creative Commons offers a more...

Words: 17291 - Pages: 70

Free Essay

Functional Areas of Business

...MGT/521 Management Professor Daniel Kearney Week Two August 24, 2013 Problem solving is a very large part of a managers job. The manager who can utilize the four functions of management and be creative and lead will be a successful manager. Planning, organizing, leading and [in academic writing, if this is a series, place a comma before the final conjunction (and)] organizing is the primary goal and functions of the manager. Henry Mintzberg wrote about and studied manager’s style came up with a very unique [Unclear. Unique means there is nothing like it--from the French word "un" (one). Something is unique or it is not. Terms like very, more, less, or slightly do not apply. Use something like "very unusual," "very distinctive," "very different," etc.] way of assessing the managerial roles. His first assessment discussed the interpersonal roles which [Use "that" for a restrictive phrase (or place a comma before "which")] involves interacting with others, the informational role was assessed by the manager giving and receiving information, being [Doctoral rule (but good advice for any academic writer)--If not a noun (as in "human being"), the word "Being" is hard to imagine; it means "existing." Try to rewrite this without using "being"--with action words like "attending," "working," "living," "experiencing," simply "as"--or even removing "being" completely] able to facilitate to...

Words: 1676 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Cognitive Learning

...Welcome to WritePoint, the automated review system that recognizes errors most commonly made by university students in academic essays. The system embeds comments into your paper and suggests possible changes in grammar and style. Please evaluate each comment carefully to ensure that the suggested change is appropriate for your paper, but remember that your instructor's preferences for style and format prevail. You will also need to review your own citations and references since WritePoint capability in this area is limited. NOTE: WritePoint comments are computer-generated writing and grammar suggestions inviting the consideration and analysis of the writer; they are not infallible statements of right/wrong, and they should not be used as grading elements. Also, at present, WritePoint cannot detect quotations or block-quotes, so comments in those areas should be ignored. Please see the other helpful writing resources in the Tutorials and Guides section of the Center for Writing Excellence. Thank you for using WritePoint. Cognitive Dissonance PSY400 April 16, 2012 Cognitive Dissonance Leon Festinger made his way into the world of psychology by introducing the theory of cognitive dissonance (Myers, 2010). Cognitive Dissonance is a reduction in...

Words: 2444 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Cross-Cultural Ethics and Social Responsibility

...Good Business ethics and social responsibility contributes to the success and profitability of a company and is good for society. Funco Toy World Incorporated (Funco) is a toy store that operates in the United States. After extensive research the owners of Funco decided to expand into China. According to Orfield (2006) in 2002, for the first time, China attracted more foreign investment than the United States. The world’s fastest-growing economy is the second largest behind the United States, and by mid-century, it is expected [The passive voice is a form of "be" (is) and a participle (expected). Over-use of the passive voice can make paragraphs officious and tedious to read. Try to use the active voice most often; for example, passive voice = The paper was completed on time. Active voice = the student completed the paper on time--(Note: the Plain Writing Act of 2010 makes avoidance of the passive voice in official writing a requirement for government employees)] to be number one. “The moral challenge is even more intense for multinational companies who need to live up to moral expectations both in the US and in host foreign countries. In developed countries, the moral expectations of the host country are as stringent as our own. With third world host countries, though, the moral expectations often more lax, and multinationals are tempted to lower their...

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Accounting

...Writing Report Writing Reports 2 A report is a statement of the results of an investigation or of any matter on which definite information is required. (Oxford English Dictionary) Reports are a highly structured form of writing often following conventions that have been laid down to produce a common format. Structure and convention in written reports stress the process by which the information was gathered as much as the information itself. Different types of report During my time at university it was asked towrite different types of reports, depending upon the subject area, which the course instructor have chosen. These could include laboratory reports, technical reports, reports of a work placement or industrial visit, reports of a field trip or fieldwork. Reports vary in their purpose, but all of them will require a formal structure and careful planning, presenting the material in a logical manner using clear and concise language. The following section explores each stage in the development of my report, making recommendations for structure and technique. Stages in report writing The following stages are involved in writing a report: • clarifying the terms of reference • planning the work • collecting related information • organising and structuring related information • writing the first draft • checking and re-drafting. Terms of reference The terms of reference of a report are a guiding statement used to define the scope of...

Words: 2231 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Process

...Creative Process Michael May PHL/458 June 5, 2013 John Smith Creative Process The creative process is one that people use every day, (Passive voice – suggest “People use the creative process every day, “) whether they realize it or not. The creative process includes four stages: searching for challenges, expressing the problem or issue, investigating the problem or issue, and then producing ideas (Ruggiero, V. R. (2009). (Repeated error – do not include author initials or first names with in-text citations – use “(Ruggiero, 2009)”. In personal experience, I have noticed that I used the creative process while trying to improve conditions at the various places in which I was (word tense – use “have been”) employed. A big thing at Gateway Cold Storage was that the pick path, or the way in which products were arranged on the warehouse floor was not conducive in creating a path that was conducive to generating speed and getting more items loaded in a more efficient manner. (some informal language, vague pronouns, missing commas, and passive voice – try “At Gateway Cold Storage, the pick path, or how products are arranged on the warehouse floor, was not conductive. A quicker and more efficient system for loading items was needed.”) Searching for challenges would be to (passive voice – try “involves”) going out and looking for ways to improve the way you live life. The book states that the first stage of the creative process represents the habit of searching for challenges...

Words: 3176 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Fafafafa

...The 500-word Essay: Some Thoughts Gordon Thompson The 500-word length is consistent with many other kinds of professional writing, from blogs to book reviews. Moreover, if you want to capture and hold your audience's attention, the three-section statement maximizes your opportunity. The statements below provide ideas on how you might successfully write. The short essays for this seminar have several goals. 1. They provide you with an opportunity to explore a topic we have covered in our discussions and readings and to formulate an opinion about some aspect of those ideas. 2. These essays also provide me with a sense of your engagement and understanding of the material we cover, as well as your ability to explain your position. 3. Each essay offers you a focused opportunity to improve your writing skills. Grammar, punctuation, spelling, and citation all figure in the act of scholarly writing. A short essay allows me to work with you on these details. 4. The 500-word essay represents a miniature paper that includes all of the same features of a longer paper. Indeed, the longer papers you will write as Skidmore students will often consist of subsections consistent with the goals of these shorter essays. That is, you can form a large paper by organizing your ideas into short subsections that address the different issues comprising your topic. Finally, you should have writing clearly as your unambiguous goal. Consult the The Skidmore Guide to Writing for examples of how to cite, to...

Words: 1108 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Vulnerable

...Welcome to WritePoint, the automated review system that recognizes errors most commonly made by university students in academic essays. The system embeds comments into your paper and suggests possible changes in grammar and style. Please evaluate each comment carefully to ensure that the suggested change is appropriate for your paper, but remember that your instructor's preferences for style and format prevail. You will also need to review your own citations and references since WritePoint capability in this area is limited. NOTE: WritePoint comments are computer-generated writing and grammar suggestions inviting the consideration and analysis of the writer; they are not infallible statements of right/wrong, and they should not be used as grading elements. Also, at present, WritePoint cannot detect quotations or block-quotes, so comments in those areas should be ignored. Please see the other helpful writing resources in the Tutorials and Guides section of the Center for Writing Excellence. Thank you for using WritePoint. Vulnerable Paper [This title could be more inspiring. Labeling it a "paper" or an "essay" is redundant (what else could it be?), and only a few words as a title are not very explanatory (or intriguing to the reader). An ideal title has between six and a dozen words ] -Part ll Legy George HCS/531 May 7, 12 Doris Chimera Vulnerable Population- Part ll ...

Words: 1670 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Decision in Paradise

...Running head: DECISIONS IN PARADISE 1 Decisions in Paradise 1 Carolyn Joseph University of Phoenix Critical Thinking: Strategies in Decision Making MGT/350 Orlando Santana July 29, 2010 Decisions in Paradise 1 The New Beginning Nik Joseph a soon to be college graduate interviewed and landed a job of a lifetime. His decision was made under uncertainty because consequences occur in the in the failure and thus depend not only on the decisions makers choice (2008). He would be an assistant to the director of strategic planning of a large investment company, Grand Bahamas Industries. This company is located in the Bahamas, China, Canada, Mexico, and St. Thomas, and all over the United States. The Bahamas Industries an environmental friendly company focuses on helping disaster stricken countries clean up, and help to create jobs for natives. Nik position will take him to the South Pacific a small island name Kava. His major concern was whether he will obtain home sick and miss his family and friends. Nik’s brief introduction of the island during training excited him even more. He would be moving to Kava known as the land of paradise with beautiful beaches, white sand, large palm trees, tropical breeze, and fun in the sun. Current Issues Landing on the small pacific island, he was amaze to find the condition of the island totally different from his expectations Kava was a paradise lost. This island had experienced many natural disasters, earthquakes, tornadoes, tsunamis...

Words: 3631 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Mcdo

...Writing Reports By the end of this section you should be able to : O BJECTIVES • • • • • • • • Understand the purposes of a report Plan a report Understand the structure of a report Collect information for your report Organise your information Use an appropriate style of writing Present data effectively Understand how to lay out your information in an appropriate way C ONTENTS • • • • • • • • • • • • • Writing reports Different types of reports Stages in report writing Terms of reference Planning your report Collecting information Organising information Structuring your report Style of writing Layout Presentation Redrafting and checking Checklist W riting reports A report is a statement of the results of an investigation or of any matter on which definite information is required. (Oxford English Dictionary) Reports are a highly structured form of writing often following conventions that have been laid down to produce a common format. Structure and convention in written reports stress the process by which the information was gathered as much as the information itself. Different types of reports During your time at university you may be asked to write different types of reports, depending upon the subject area which you have chosen. These could include laboratory reports, technical reports, reports of a work placement or industrial visit, reports of a field trip or field work. Reports vary in their purpose, but all of them will require a formal...

Words: 2372 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

The Importance of Head Start

...Welcome to WritePoint, the automated review system that recognizes errors most commonly made by university students in academic essays. The system embeds comments into your paper and suggests possible changes in grammar and style. Please evaluate each comment carefully to ensure that the suggested change is appropriate for your paper, but remember that your instructor's preferences for style and format prevail. You will also need to review your own citations and references since WritePoint capability in this area is limited. NOTE: WritePoint comments are computer-generated writing and grammar suggestions inviting the consideration and analysis of the writer; they are not infallible statements of right/wrong, and they should not be used as grading elements. Also, at present, WritePoint cannot detect quotations or block-quotes, so comments in those areas should be ignored. Please see the other helpful writing resources in the Tutorials and Guides section of the Center for Writing Excellence. Thank you for using WritePoint. The benefits of early head start [If referring to the child care program, this should be capitalized] Shanta Denard PHL/458 Febrary 21, 2013 Joan Middleton The benefits of early head start Many people have different opinions regarding...

Words: 1977 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Spoken English Stages

...STAGE-1 PRESENT TENSE ACTIVE VOICE ` ø£ s ¡ Ô ] Á|ü j Ó ÷ >∑ e TT 1. I am walking. 2. I have been walking. 3. I have walked. 4. I walk. PASSIVE VOICE H˚qT q&ÉTdüTÔHêïqT. H˚qT (#ê˝≤ùd|ü{ÏqT+∫) q&ÉTdü÷ÔH˚ e⁄HêïqT. H˚qT (Ç|ü&˚) q&ç#êqT. H˚qT (Ç|ü&ÉT/s√E) q&ÉTkÕÔqT. ` ø£s¡àDÏ Á|üjÓ÷>∑eTT 5. I am advised. 6. I have been advised. 7. I am being advised. Hê≈£î dü\Vü‰ Ç#êÃs¡T (ás√E). Hê≈£î (Ç|ü&˚) dü\Vü‰ Ç#êÃs¡T. Hê≈£î (Á|üdüTÔ‘·+) dü\Vü‰ Çdü÷Ô e⁄Hêïs¡T. PAST TENSE ACTIVE VOICE ` es¡ Ô e ÷q ø±\eTT ` uÛÑ÷‘· ø±\eTT ` ø£ s ¡ Ô ] Á|ü j Ó ÷ >∑ e TT 1. I was walking. 2. I had been walking. 3. I had walked (yesterday before he came) 4. I walked. (V2) PASSIVE VOICE H˚qT q&ÉTdü÷Ô e⁄+{Ïì. H˚qT (ìqï #ê˝≤ùd|ü{ÏqT+∫ á düeTj·÷ìøÏ ≈£L&Ü) q&ÉTdü÷ÔH˚ e⁄+{Ïì. H˚qT (ìqï n‘·qT e#˚ÃeTT+∑eTT 5. I was advised (Yesterday). 6. I had been advised (Yesterday before he came) 7. I was being advised (yesterday). FUTURE TENSE ACTIVE VOICE 1. 2. 3. 4. 6. ` uÛÑ$wü´‘Y ø±\eTT ` ø£ s ¡ Ô ] Á|ü j Ó ÷ >∑ e TT I will be walking tomorrow. H˚qT πs|ü⁄ q&ÉTdü÷Ô e⁄+{≤qT. I will have been walking tomorrow. H˚qT πs|ü⁄ (#ê˝≤ùd|ü{Ï qT+∫ á düeTj·÷ìøÏ ≈£L&Ü) q&ÉTdü÷ÔH˚ e⁄+{≤qT. I will have walked tomorrow at this time. H˚qT πs|ü⁄ á düeTj·÷ìø£˝≤¢ q&ç#˚dæ e⁄+{≤qT. I will walk tomorrow. H˚qT πs|ü⁄ q&ÉTkÕÔqT. PASSIVE VOICE 5. Hê≈£î dü\Vü‰ Ç#êÃs¡T. (ìqï) (ìqï n‘·qT e#˚ÃeTT+∑eTT ...

Words: 743 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Organizational Development

...approach to improve worker and company effectiveness by mindful interventions in those processes and structures that have an immediate impact on the human aspect of the company. This definition focuses the obvious correlation among the creation and the accomplishment of the organization’s mission. The Organization Development process is based [The passive voice is a form of "be" (is) and a participle (based). Over-use of the passive voice can make paragraphs officious and tedious to read. Prefer the active voice. For example, passive voice = The paper was completed on time. Active voice = the student completed the paper on time. See Center for Writing Excellence > Tutorials & Guides > Grammar & Writing Guides > Active & passive voice] on the action research model which [Use "that" for a restrictive phrase (or place a comma before "which")] begins with an identified problem or the need for a change. The process begins through an assortment of assessments, intervention planning, intervention implementation, the gathering of the data to evaluate the intervention, and determining if reasonable progress has been made [Passive voice ] or if further intervention is need. There are ["There are" is an awkward phrase...

Words: 849 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Reports

...Writing Reports By the end of this section you should be able to : O BJECTIVES • • • • • • • • Understand the purposes of a report Plan a report Understand the structure of a report Collect information for your report Organise your information Use an appropriate style of writing Present data effectively Understand how to lay out your information in an appropriate way C ONTENTS • • • • • • • • • • • • • Writing reports Different types of reports Stages in report writing Terms of reference Planning your report Collecting information Organising information Structuring your report Style of writing Layout Presentation Redrafting and checking Checklist W riting reports A report is a statement of the results of an investigation or of any matter on which definite information is required. (Oxford English Dictionary) Reports are a highly structured form of writing often following conventions that have been laid down to produce a common format. Structure and convention in written reports stress the process by which the information was gathered as much as the information itself. Different types of reports During your time at university you may be asked to write different types of reports, depending upon the subject area which you have chosen. These could include laboratory reports, technical reports, reports of a work placement or industrial visit, reports of a field trip or field work. Reports vary in their purpose, but all of them will require a formal...

Words: 2377 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Week 3 Journal Entry

...1. What is the song’s title and artist? The name of the song is BBQ Stain by Tim McGraw. 2. What emotional mental responses did you have to the song the first time you listened to it? Why do you think you had this response? Initially, my response was “Uh-oh. Corny alert. Change station”. If I were to pin point why I had that response, I would probably say it’s the voice of all country singers. 3. While listening to the song, what happened to your appreciation level? Did it increase or decrease? Why? On some levels my appreciation has gone up due to the fact that I am listening to genuine music. What I mean about genuine music is that these apparently sing about everything and anything that goes through their mind. 4. In your opinion, what was the message (theme) of the song? If they really must know, the message is about getting a barbeque stain on his white T-shirt. 5. What about the song that most surprised you? The lyrics? The actual music? Your like or dislike of the song? The artists voice? When I first heard this song, I thought, “Wow! Country has run out of ideas.” But of all things that surprised me it was the fact that this song became really famous, and made number one. 6. If you HAD to say that you gained or learned one positive thing from this song, what would that be? Country singers, no matter what song they sing about, sing real songs from their heart. 7. From memory, list at least two, statements, comments, or quotes...

Words: 429 - Pages: 2