Free Essay

Crime Story Analysis

In: Social Issues

Submitted By shakv
Words 1546
Pages 7
Homicide Crime Story Analysis – The Tattoo Man
Course Code: SOC*2760
Course Name: Homicide
Number of Pages (not including title page and references): 5

Peter John Peters is one of Canada’s most dangerous fugitives. Peter was given the name the Tattoo Man because of his numerous tattoos and his affinity to showing them off. Peters murdered a 25 year old woman named Charlene Brittain and left her in his basement apartment naked with a plastic bag over her head. Thus triggered the beginning of his five-day crime spree. Peters then fled to Toronto where he beat a 63 year old man named Albert Philip and stole his station wagon in order to escape. Philips later died in the hospital after undergoing emergency surgery. He then took hostage a young woman named Sandie Bellows and used her car to escape with her. He threatened and proceeded to rape, beat and stab the young woman until a retired police officer noticed what was going on and intervened. Peters escaped and went on to break into an elderly woman’s home and threatened her into providing him with a vehicle. He then held up a local bank in Paris, Ontario. Peters continues to attempt to take more hostages, break into homes and steal more vehicles in order to escape. Finally on the fifth day Peters was caught by the police and surrendered when he realized he was outnumbered. The crimes committed by Peter John Peters were accurately represented in accordance to the course material by the documentary “Crime Stories: The Tattoo Man”.

It was very apparent throughout the crime story that the documentary was very fact based. It did not delve into motives and theories as much as it explained what occurred during the Tattoo man incident. However when looking at what had been said it aligned with the course material provided throughout the semester. Right off the bat the narrator gave the audience a statistic. He had stated that on average there was over 500 homicides in Canada per year most of which involving a single victim. Statistics show that there were 543 reported homicide cases in 2012 and 598 the year before (Boyce & Cotter, 2013). On average there are approximately 504 homicide cases in Canada. It has also been stated that since 1991 94% of intimate partner homicides occur only with single victims. The Juristat Article also states that the majority of accused in homicide cases are young males between the ages 18 and 34, which was the case for Peter John Peters (Boyce & Cotter, 2013). Most homicides in Canada are committed by acquaintances. It was noted in the crime story that Charlene was acquainted with Peters. She had told her close friend that she was meeting him on a date (Boyce & Cotter, 2013). This was when the murder had occurred. There are many different situations that could occur in homicide cases. However this particular case coincides with many Canadian statistics collected.

One of the most obvious points brought up in the crime story is the identification of Peter John Peters as a spree killer. The course describes spree killers as someone who kills two or more people in a short period of time. This is typically done in more than one location. There is no cooling off periods between the crimes (Fox & Levin, 2005). Peters had begun his crime spree when he murdered Charlene Brattain in his basement apartment. He then fled to Toronto where he ultimately killed Albert Philip before continuing his crime spree of rape, robbery, breaking and entering, and attempted murder. As there were two deaths and the crime spree was done over a period of 5 days Peter John Peters can be classified as a spree killer. There are many theories on multiple homicide. One theory that seems to come to play is the Social Learning Theory, which states that the propensity to kill comes from what an individual learns early on in life by close family and/or friends (Fox & Levin, 2005). It was stated in the crime story that Peters had a troubled past. There had been plenty of conflict within his household and from a very young age Peters had had a criminal record that showed an increase in violent behavior. The control theory also states that many people stop themselves from committing violent crimes for fear of losing their relationship with important people in their lives (Fox & Levin, 2005). As it was indicated in the crime story Peters did not have a very nurturing household growing up. He was also romantically involved with his parole officer who broke off their relationship two months before the crime spree began. It was theorized in the documentary that the crime spree might have occurred because of failure of this relationship. This coincides with the findings in the control theory. Since Peters already lost the only significant relationship in his life he was more inclined to committing these crimes (Fox & Levin, 2005).

Sexual homicide can be defined as a homicide committed during act of a sexual crime. A sexual crime can be sexual harassment or sexual assault (Shearer, 2015). Charlene Brittain was murdered and found completely naked with a bag over her head. This can clearly by identified as a sexual homicide. Charlene was also found in a room that was filled with soft pornography presumably owned by Peters. Studies have found that in sexual murders the majority of offenders were between the ages 22 and 38. Most studies state that the murderers were not in a relationship at the time of murder as was the case with Charlene (Beauregard & Martineau, 2012). Most sexual murderers were also found to be Caucasian. The majority of female victims were either strangers or casual acquaintances. All of these factors coincide with the Tattoo Man case in regard to Charlene’s murder. Another factor that should be brought up is the mode of operation. Typically strangulation is at the top of the list for most common method. However beatings and stabbings seem to be a close second (Beauregard & Martineau, 2012). As stated in the crime story Charlene Brittain had been stabbed in the back and likely strangulated by the plastic bag. Both of which are the most common methods in sexual homicides.

The victim-offender relationship is also one to look into with Peter John Peters crime spree. Decker’s article states that there are five different types of victim-offender relationships. Peters relationships can be classified as acquaintances for Charlene Brittain and strangers for Sandie Bellows and Albert Philips. It is important to understand that in a stranger relationship there is no protection from fatal interactions (Decker, 1993). The “moral bonds” that serve, as an inhibitor for violent behavior is not there and as a result the offender is more likely to be fatally violent towards the victim as was the case with all three victims. Studies showed that nearly 46% of homicides were involved an acquaintance relationship. A stranger relationship came second with approximately 19% of all homicides (Decker, 1993). Victim facilitation is when the victims unknowingly and carelessly make it easier for the offender to commit a crime. As was the case for Charlene Brittain. Charlene had only been acquainted with Peters at the time of her death. She did not know much about this man however she willingly went to his basement apartment. This made it a lot easier for the offender to gain access to the victim resulting in fatal violence (Decker, 1993).
The Tattoo Man crime spree was a gruesome and terrifying ordeal that occurred in Ontario, Canada. Peter John Peters, a 28-year-old man classified as spree killer, killed 2 people and assaulted and threatened many more. The crime story depicting his story accurately represented most of what was learned in this Homicide course. Many aspects of the crime itself corresponded with statistics presented in the course material. Young males are among the most accused in homicide cases in Canada and the victim’s ages all correspond with statistics. Peters was very clearly classified as a spree killer because he had murdered 2 people within the span of 5 days. Peters troubled youth was also mentioned which made it easy to apply the social learning theory. The sexual homicide of Charlene Brittain was also clearly classified. The MO, the victim-offender relationship, age and race were all consistent with the statistics presented throughout the course.

Reference:

Boyce, J., & Cotter, A. (2013). Homicide in Canada, 2012 (Vol. 85-002-X). Ottawa, Ont.: Statistics Canada.

Beauregard, E., & Martineau, M. (n.d.). A Descriptive Study of Sexual Homicide in Canada: Implications for Police Investigation. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 1454-1476.

Brookman, Fiona. 2005. Psychological explanations of homicide. Chapter 3 in Understanding Homicide. London: Sage

Brookman, Fiona. 2005. Sociological explanations of homicide. Chapter 5 in Understanding Homicide. London: Sage

Decker, S. (n.d.). Exploring victim-offender relationships in homicide: The role of individual and event characteristics. Justice Quarterly, 585-612.

Fox, J., & Levin, J. (2005). Extreme killing: Understanding serial and mass murder. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.

Shearer, R. (2015). SOC*2760 Homicide Course Notes. Retrieved November 20, from https://courselink.uoguelph.ca/d2l/le/content/345637/viewContent/1147636/View

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Save Me

...Crime analysts are always trying to find new ways to apply their skills and hone their craft. The vast majority of us are thinkers; we are curious problem solvers who believe that our ability to benefit our agencies is limited only by the latitude we are given. It is understandable then that we should seek out more opportunities to apply our skills and make more positive impacts within our jurisdictions. It is this general attitude that led us to get involved in investigating cold cases. How We Got Started Mark had, for several years, been consulting with our Coroner’s Division as a forensic anthropologist. During this time he came to learn that there were numerous coroners’ cases in which the identity of the decedent was unknown. These cases were kept in three-ring binders on a shelf in the Sergeant’s office. Over the years, in the course of this forensic work, we would discuss these cases and the progress that was being made on them. The conversation usually ran along the lines of us asking “any luck with that 1980 homicide victim?” and the sergeant answering “well, we’ve gotten so many new cases that I haven’t been able to even look at it yet.” This went on for a few years and through two different sergeants. One day we, as a crime analysis unit, were brainstorming about how we could broaden our “client base”, as it were. We had been successful in integrating ourselves into our Investigations Bureau and had been involved in numerous...

Words: 412 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Model Millionaire

...The model millionaire – Oscar Wilde The model millionaire is a short story written by Oscar Wilde in 1871. The theme of the short story deals with a very materialistic aspect of life in a mercantile world in which the protagonist Hughie Erskine is a complete misfit. Despite of the attractive appearance and charming personality, his lack of money prohibits him from marrying the girl he loves – Laura. Her father demands a total of £10.000 to prove his worth to him and accept him as a son in law. The demand is only of economical character, because of the fact that Hughie quick and easily achieved the acceptance of the father as a person. This issue defines the very essence of the short story, of which it becomes clear that "romance is the privilege of the rich, not the profession of the unemployed." But is that so in the real, contemporary world? Is love only appropriate in the world of the privileged or is it achievable for anyone? This attitude is quite an old fashion way of thinking which is very appropriate of the time period in which the text is written and so the modern man would probably controvert the statement. A controversy claiming that love is a spirit with ability to posses anyone and so the modern expression “Love is for everyone” manifests itself. A second theme in the short story is represented in terms of kindness. It is expressed to its fullest that being kind pays out in the end. Hughie shows his kind side when he generously offers the ‘beggar’ his last money...

Words: 655 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Roles

...The comprehensive roles of crime and intelligence analysis they relate to the future of policing and homeland security. The role of the criminal intelligence analyst is to help predict and prevent crimes and also monitor ongoing criminal activity. Analysts do this by gathering information from surveillance, databases, technology (such as GIS geographic information systems), informants, financial records, telephone and other communication records and public information sources. A criminal intelligence analyst takes all of this information, evaluates it, verifies its accuracy and transforms it into viable intelligence to assist law enforcement officers in preventing crime, making arrests or gathering essential evidence for prosecution down the road. Law enforcement intelligence analysts must be capable of finding relationships among the information they are analyzing; at the same time they must understand the criminal mind to create suspect profiles and also discover connections between several suspects. Thus criminal intelligence analysts must have logical, technical, investigative and criminology skills. Intelligence analysts assist with a variety of cases included those related to terrorism, weapons of mass destruction, auto theft rings, narcotics, gangs, money laundering, child pornography rings and other organized crimes, as well as homicides, sexual assaults, burglaries, and so forth. Criminal intelligence, as a process, offers the law enforcement a coherent, rational,...

Words: 1201 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Deez Nuts

...For this project, you will need to observe the amount and type of crime being reported, as well as the characteristics of those individuals involved in the crime. In your write up, you should identify the dates and networks of your media sources. First, you should report: 1. The percentage of stories dealing with crime 2. The proportion of different categories of crime presented (violent vs. non-violent, street crime vs. white-collar, et cetera) 3. Pertinent demographic characteristics of the offender(s) and victim(s) Next, you should assess and critically reflect on the representation of crime in the media: 1. Do the media present an accurate picture of the overall crime rate? 2. Do the media tend to focus on a particular type of crime? If so, why might this be the case? 3. Do the media present an accurate picture of offenders? Of victims? What notable differences exist between media representations and official data for these two groups? 4. What are the possible implications of media (mis)representations of crime in society? You may choose to review official statistics on crime here: http://www.albany.edu/sourcebook. This is a resource to be used in writing your response, at your discretion. It is not required. GRADING Your project will be graded on the strength and clarity with which you communicate your analysis of the data. This will be broken down the following ways: · Use of course material · Organization of ideas · Formatting of paper · Quality of conceptual...

Words: 1379 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Bibliography

...Capote’s “In Cold Blood” conveys true crime and the portrayal of the killers. Throughout the novel, Perry and Dick are transformed from heartless, cold-blooded monsters, whose actions seem to be motiveless evil, into the troubled, pitiful, and human individuals they are at the end of the book. The crime itself is reduced to many emotional responses. Preliminary Bibliography Capote, Truman. In Cold Blood: Random House. Alan. U. Schwartz. New York, 1965. Print. ------------------------------------------------- Primary Source Corregido, Jeronimo. "A Study of Genre in In Cold Blood: A Formal Perspective." A Study of Genre in “In Cold Blood”: A Formal Perspective. N.p., n.d. Web. 21 Jan. 2015:Academia.edu. swales, john. M. Massachusetts, 1990. Cambridge University. ------------------------------------------------- This essay conveys the death and crime which the book portrays. This relates to my primary source, “In Cold Blood” which portrays sudden death and crime upon the family. "In Cold Blood :: Character Analysis, Perry Smith. "In Cold Blood :: Character Analysis, Perry Smith. N.p., n.d. Web. 23 Jan. 2015. ------------------------------------------------- This essay “Cold Blood” shows the traumatic story from the killers’ perspective. It also conveys how the killers’ background effected how they proceeded in life. Hemingway, Ernest. "Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway Study Guide: “The Killers” Summary and Analysis." Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway Study Guide:...

Words: 378 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Essay On Media Bias

...One of the articles evaluated is, “Illegal Aliens and Violent Crime: Some Amazing Facts”. This article was written in 2017 by Tom Tancredo of Breitbart, an online media source. It was presented as a national news story. The second article to be evaluated is a peer reviewed article titled, “Immigrants Commit Less Crime than Native-Born Americans”. It was written by Veronika Bondarenko and Skye Gould in 2017. This article was a national news story and appeared in Business Insider Magazine. Analysis of Article from Breitbart Before reading one word of this article it can be determined from the article’s accompanying photograph that it will play towards social conventions and sets the tone of the content. The picture is one of many poorly dressed individuals who look like immigrants packed into a room, small in size, some with their arms raised high in the air in what encourages the reader to envision thoughts of defiance. This picture serves the purpose of “priming the mind” for what is to come. This is only the first example of sociocentric thinking which is evident throughout the article. Lack of Supporting Facts It is clear that this story is written to appeal to a group possessing specific...

Words: 1549 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Bibliography

...Capote’s “In Cold Blood” conveys true crime and the portrayal of the killers. Throughout the novel, Perry and Dick are transformed from heartless, cold-blooded monsters, whose actions seem to be motiveless evil, into the troubled, pitiful, and human individuals they are at the end of the book. The crime itself is reduced to many emotional responses. Preliminary Bibliography Capote, Truman. In Cold Blood: Random House. Alan. U. Schwartz. New York, 1965. Print. ------------------------------------------------- Primary Source Corregido, Jeronimo. "A Study of Genre in In Cold Blood: A Formal Perspective." A Study of Genre in “In Cold Blood”: A Formal Perspective. N.p., n.d. Web. 21 Jan. 2015:Academia.edu. swales, john. M. Massachusetts, 1990. Cambridge University. ------------------------------------------------- This essay conveys the death and crime which the book portrays. This relates to my primary source, “In Cold Blood” which portrays sudden death and crime upon the family. "In Cold Blood :: Character Analysis, Perry Smith. "In Cold Blood :: Character Analysis, Perry Smith. N.p., n.d. Web. 23 Jan. 2015. ------------------------------------------------- This essay “Cold Blood” shows the traumatic story from the killers’ perspective. It also conveys how the killers’ background effected how they proceeded in life. Hemingway, Ernest. "Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway Study Guide: “The Killers” Summary and Analysis." Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway Study Guide:...

Words: 378 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Shepard Paper

...Analysis Paper #1 Professor Krutzch 09/27/14 In the essay, The Politics of Negotiating Public Tragedy, written by Brian Ott and Eric Aoki, it discusses how public tragedy is carefully framed in the media to alleviate the public’s guilt and rid the public of any social responsibility. The essay talks about how the drama surrounding the Matthew Shepard incident was careful structured by the media from start to finish, in order to maximize its newsworthiness and profits. For example, Washington Post, New York Times, and Los Angeles Times, all did not post any articles involving the Matthew Shepard case, until October 10, 1998, which was three days after he was discovered. Furthermore, with little information from the Sheriff of Laramie involving the Shepard case, reporters instantly constructed the case around the anti-gay aspect and correlated the scarecrow image to the crucifix symbol, which created attention and attracted viewers. The media transformed Matthew Shepard into a national symbol for hate crimes and anti-gay violence. The drama surrounding Shepard’s case would ultimately lead the story and it will end with the trail of McKinney and Henderson. The trail of McKinney and Henderson was necessary to put an end to the story, in order to punish those responsible for the crimes and regain social order. In my analysis I found the section, Restoring Social Order, to be most interesting. This section talks about how the Matthew Shepard case created such a disruption...

Words: 481 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Police Powers (2)

...of Media on Fear of Crime among University Students: A Cross-National Comparison Article Summary This article comparatively examines the impact of media on fear of crime among university students in United States and Canada. Survey Data based on samples of university students has been used to study the relationship between media and fear of crime. The fear of crime refers to the fear of being a victim of crime as opposed to the actual probability of being a victim of crime (Hale C., 1996).Behaviors induced by fear include avoidance , movement restrictions and constraints on socialization. Fear of crime has three dimensions: * Cognitive (Focuses on citizens ’estimation of their likelihood of victimization; * Behavioral (which focuses on how people respond to fear of perceived risk of victimization) * Emotional (which focuses on individuals’ feelings about crime) A different approach towards understanding fear of crime includes vulnerability (i.e. Ability of the individual to escape or defend himself/herself from an attacker). However, several researchers argue that fear of crime is a distinctly affective – thus emotional – and physiologic response to perceived danger (Ferraro 1995; Warr 2000). Studies suggest that fear levels have not changed among citizens of both the countries despite decreases in crime rates. It is assumed that increased levels of fear are the result of individuals’ perception about his/her vulnerability to crime which can be attributed...

Words: 2134 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Collateral Book Exam

...is a former columnist for the Arts and Leisure Section of The New York Times. He is the son of a Polish immigrant-clothing buyer. Rosen is originally from Brooklyn and is Jewish. Rosen is a known true crime author in the United States. His wife and daughter (who is seven) now currently reside with him in New York, New York. B. Rosen teaches criminal justice and film at Ulster County Community college. Mr. Rosen author attended the University of Southern California film school. He then moved back to New York and found work as a technical writer, specializing in photography where he met his wife. He edited Studio Photography magazine and wrote a photography column for the New York Times. This led to an eight-year job as a journalism professor at Hofstra University. C. Fred Rosen is the winner of Library Journal’s Best Reference Source 2005 award for The Historical Atlas of American Crime. His published works in the genre include the true crime classic, Lobster Boy. In that case it was Mr. Rosen’s detective work that led to the conviction of the killer. This proves Rosen’s competence to write a book about historical murders as his evidence helped solve the case. Rosen has a lot of experience writing about true crime having published over twelve books on the subject of true crime. 2. A. Fred Rosen has published thirteen or fourteen books related to criminal justice some include: There But For the Grace: Survivors of the 20th Century’s Infamous Serial Killers, Body Dump...

Words: 2474 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Media's Influence On Fear Of Crime

...the on the media for any information regarding crime (Surette, 1998, cited in Dowler, 2003), which will influence the public’s perception of crime. Research shows that as a society we are exposed to 7,000 crimes reported in the media per year (Howitt, 1998, cited in Ainsworth, 2000). The purpose of this essay is to examine the impact of the media on fear of crime. In order for a crime to be reported by the media it must be considered newsworthy, which is determined by several factors. These factors have been defined by Chibnall (1977, cited in Newburn, 2012) as immediacy, drama, the involvement of celebrities, simplicity, spectacular acts, access to experts, novelty, and sexual or political connotations....

Words: 1090 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Killings

...Killings Analysis Style and Technique “Killings,” one of Dubus’s best-known and most respected stories, was the basis for the film In the Bedroom (2001). Although the story revolves around passion and violence, Dubus tells the tale in a flat, calm way. The first two acts of violence are dropped into the story unexpectedly and without emotion. The story opens with Frank’s funeral, then moves on to the conversation between Willis and Matt about how Matt wishes he could kill the man who murdered his son, but the reader does not know who killed Frank, how, or why. Next, in a long descriptive paragraph, Richard is introduced. He is first connected to Frank by the flat opening line of the next paragraph: “One night he beat Frank.” Only then does the reader learn about Mary Ann, and Matt’s and Ruth’s differing feelings about her. In a lovely, lyrical scene, Mary Ann joins the Fowlers for a barbeque after a day at the beach. Matt’s love for his son is mixed with a wistful attraction to Mary Ann. She is beautiful, but Matt sees in her eyes a sadness and pain that he and his family have been spared, and he wishes he could help and comfort her. The next paragraph starts with, “Richard Strout shot Frank in front of the children.” Such jarring shifts of mood are used to emphasize how quickly life can turn from sunny to violent and how swiftly the good things in life can be taken away. The story’s point of view is that of the limited omniscient narrator. The reader sees the events through...

Words: 3107 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Quatitative Methods for Business

...combined to bring about a diverse methods method to business research. Philosophies are the main head to scientific investigation and we will consider their configuration in terms of essential concepts, constructs and variables and how these are correlated to proposals. Finally, we take a look at the framing of inquiry hypotheses and the ways in which that progression differs from producing research questions. Scale of data measurement: Glaser and Strauss’s unique conceptualization of beached theory has undergone some changes. While numerous disparities of the innovative idea exist, as Charmaz notes, they all have the following apparatuses in mutual: (a) Immediate data collection and scrutiny; (b) search of growing themes through early data analysis, (c) discovery of basic social methods within the data, (d) inductive construction of nonconcrete categories that clarify and manufacture these procedures, (e) selection to improve the classes through relative procedures, and (f) addition of groups into a hypothetical framework that specifies causes, circumstances, and penalties of the studied processes. Grounded theory gives the two most important ideas. The...

Words: 1918 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Com3703

...Vercueil STUDENT NUMBER: 42068711 DATE: 08/10/2015 WITNESS: Sheree Gloss 2     42068711     COM  3703   TABLE OF CONTENT 08  October  2015   PAGE DECLARATION 2 1. INTRODUCTION 4 2. QUANTITATIVE CONTENT ANALYSIS 2.1 The research problem 4 2.2 Research question or hypothesis 4 2.3 Method 5 2.4 Findings 6 2.5 Analysis 7 3. FIELD RESEARCH IN MEDIA STUDIES 8 4. MEASURING MEDIA AUDIENCES 11 5. FILM THEORY AND CRITICISM 14 5.1 Film: An overview 14 5.2 Theoretical discussion 14 5.3 A German expressionist analysis of film 15 6. PSYCHOANALYSIS AND TELEVISION 17 7. CONCLUSION 20 8. SELF-EVALUATION AND SELF-REFLECTION 21 SOURCES 23 Addendum 24 3     42068711     COM  3703   08  October  2015   Portfolio Examination Option 01 1. INTRODUCTION In this portfolio examination I will conduct my own quantitative content analysis, conduct a focus group interview to explain field research in media studies. This analysis will give greater insight into the frequency of stories published about women and other related stories, as well as how they are portrayed...

Words: 9121 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay

Ethnicity Essay

...cause of this moral panic: The state and the ruling class were suffering a ‘crisis of hegemony’ and that there was a decline in the dominance of the ruling class due to ‘Black Power’ demonstrations, the oil crisis and strikes and power cuts. The second reason was the ruling classes needed to regain control and making mugging a moral panic achieved this by portraying violent crimes as a threat to society, which lead to the justified use of a police crackdown, muggers were portrayed as black and justified the targeting of black people by police. Hall also explains how the labelling of black people as criminals then leads to a self-fulfilling prophecy as they are stopped and searched more and arrested more, making them appear in official statistics and committing more crime than other races, Hall says this demonstrates how the ruling class use the justice system to criminalise groups in society who oppose them and portray them in negative stereotypical ways. The film ‘Boyz N The Hood (1991)’ supports this view of criminalising black people and leading them into a self-fulfilling prophecy of thinking that crime is the only option...

Words: 1282 - Pages: 6