Free Essay

Criminal Justice Case Study

In: Other Topics

Submitted By mstrsplntr
Words 1900
Pages 8
Robbery case study

I have chosen to write about the robbery case. The synopsis of the case is: Two people, after conducting some surveillance on a small shoe store robbed a man while he was transporting money from his business to the bank. The two people later identified as Bertha Bloutt and William Bloutt, used the ruse of a broken down vehicle to get the victim to stop to render assistance at which time the robbed him at gun point. The usual process that these two offenders would go through is known as the criminal justice process. The criminal justice system is comprised of three major institutions which process a case from inception, through trial, to punishment. A case begins with law enforcement officials, who investigate a crime and gather evidence to identify and use against the presumed perpetrator. The case continues with the court system, which weighs the evidence to determine if the defendant is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. If so, the corrections system will use the means at their disposal, namely incarceration and probation, to punish and correct the behavior of the offender. Throughout each stage of the process, constitutional protections exist to ensure that the rights of the accused and convicted are respected. These protections balance the need of the criminal justice system to investigate and prosecute criminals with the fundamental rights of the accused (who are presumed innocent). Though a number of rights derived from the Constitution protect the accused from abuses and overreaching from law enforcement officers, the arguably most important of these rights are the Miranda advisement and the Fourth Amendment prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures. Miranda rights are the familiar refrain of police dramas. "You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be held against you in the court of law. You have the right to an attorney. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be provided for you." Though we are all familiar with these rights, officers are nevertheless required to remind arrestees of these rights before they are questioned. The other major restriction on the investigative stage of a case is the prohibition on unreasonable searches and seizures. This prevents officers from searching a suspect or his home without a warrant. There are exceptions for extenuating circumstances, such as when an officer is in "hot pursuit" of a suspect or where evidence might be destroyed, such as when a suspected drug dealer runs into a restroom. Much like the law enforcement stage of a case, there are dozens of restrictions on the court's ability to prosecute a case, including the right to confront one's accusers, the right against incriminating one's self, the right to counsel, and the right to a jury trial. The primary purpose of all of these protections is to ensure a fair trial for the accused. The defendant has a right to be represented by either an attorney of their choosing, or, if they cannot afford one, court-appointed counsel. The jury must be a fair cross-section of the community, which in most cases will not lead to a jury composed of a single race or gender. If the defendant is convicted and the charges merit jail time, they will be sent to the corrections system for punishment. Typically, this involves probation, incarceration, or both. Probation can be either supervised or unsupervised. Supervised probation requires the offender to check in regularly with an officer to ensure compliance with the terms of his probation. Unsupervised probation means that a person only faces jail time or other punishment if they run further afoul of the law. Incarceration is also a common outcome of criminal trials, especially in more serious cases. The convict is housed in either jail or prison. Jails are usually located in each county and are for less serious offenses. Jail terms usually do not exceed one year. Prison terms are usually for longer than a year and almost always involve serious felony offenses. The primary constraint on abuses in the correctional system is the right to be free of cruel and unusual punishment. There are many ways in which this prohibition has come into play in our corrections system, including jail overcrowding, improper medical care, and in physical abuses at the hands of corrections officers. Though violations do occur, they usually will not result in a suspension of one's sentence. Rather, the remedy is typically injunctive relief and/or monetary damages obtained via a civil rights lawsuit. The criminal justice process is like a funnel, wide at the top and narrow at the bottom. Early in the criminal justice process, there are many cases, but the number of cases dwindles as decision makers remove cases from the process. Some cases are dismissed, while others are referred for treatment or counseling. Another way of expressing the funnel effect is to say that there are many more suspects and defendants than inmates. As criminal justice scholar Joel Samaha notes, the U.S. Constitution requires the government to support every deprivation of privacy, life, liberty, or property with facts. The greater the deprivation, the more facts that government agents are required to produce. A stop on the street requires fewer facts than an arrest; an arrest requires fewer facts than an indictment; an indictment requires fewer facts than a criminal conviction. Criticizing the criminal justice system is easy, with the list of grievances long and familiar. Criminal cases are often processed on an assembly line, leaving too little time and attention for each matter. The high volume puts enormous pressure on all the players to resolve cases through negotiation, leading at times to either under-punishment of serious criminality, or over-punishment of those who might be innocent or less guilty than charged, but who still plead guilty to avoid a trial. Police have enormous discretion in investigating and arresting, but the quality of the police work is uneven and hard to monitor. Many defendants need appointed counsel, but funding for public defenders is so low that only the bare minimum of an accused’s needs are likely to be met. The constitutional requirements of criminal procedure are developed case-by-case by the judiciary, making it very hard to predict where the next turn in the road will be. We incarcerate a very high number of citizens, and the burdens of imprisonment do not fall equally on all groups. And so on. Being critical is not only easy, but important. The impact of a single, serious crime on the victim, the accused, and their families is often profound, and the long-term consequences can stretch beyond our ability to measure. Anything that is this central to the quality of our lives must be constantly monitored, and when the people and institutions fall short, we darn well ought to criticize. We probably could alleviate a lot of the problems with the criminal justice system with a massive inflow of money, for example, and we could reduce the overflowing prison population by reducing harsh sentences and shifting our approach to drug crimes. But there are few signs on the horizon that these kinds of dramatic changes are imminent. And so while there is nothing wrong and much to appreciate about bold, thoughtful, and unrealistic reform ideas, in the short term we know they will do little to change the status quo. Serious problems for citizens and the criminal justice system can result from the politicization of criminal justice, a process through which political leaders seize opportunities to use criminal justice issues to enhance their own popularity, electability, or power. Politicization can be observed most readily in political campaigns in which law‐and‐order rhetoric is prevalent. When criminal justice issues become too politicized, politicians are tempted to engage in demagoguery, appealing to people's emotions, passions, and prejudices rather than to people's minds. Political demagoguery is the enemy of clear thinking about solutions to the crime problem. I would argue that the strongest part of our criminal justice system is the rule based system it is structured on. In order to have ongoing public support and trust, criminal justice systems need to operate in a rule-based and accountable fashion. Arbitrary, corrupt or oppressive measures will ultimately undermine the authority and credibility of the system and, in turn, the rule of law generally. The Irish criminal justice system is founded on Constitutional and common law principles of fairness and respect for individual liberty, and, in particular, the right to a fair trial and a presumption of innocence. It is also essential, however, in the interests of efficiency and in order to instill public confidence, that the system functions effectively and protects the public. Key overall components of a fair and credible system are: * Effectiveness in detecting, deterring and punishing offending behaviour * Fairness to all involved including victims, witnesses and accused * Efficiency in the use of time and resources * Transparency and prompt service delivery
People look to the criminal justice system for personal security. They are rightly concerned about crime and they want to be safe. Unquestioning reliance on the system, however, creates problems of its own. The state run bureaucracy of justice consumes billions of tax dollars every year, responds poorly to victims' needs, and resists every effort at reform. In some neighborhoods, the apparatus of justice actually causes more problems than it solves.
The oversized criminal justice system siphons money that could be better spent on other civic endeavors. The nation spends $100 billion every year on crime control. Spending on corrections at the state level has increased faster than any other spending category. While new prisons are being built, schools are crumbling, highways are growing potholed, parks are left to decay, and opportunity-generating programs are being cut. These conditions breed crime in the long run. Most crime is local. Kids make too much noise, individuals suffer from drug addictions, dealers convert a vacant property into a crack house, and convenience stores lose inventory to shoplifters. The solutions to such problems are also local: parks and community gardens so kids have something positive to do with their time, drug treatment facilities, neighborhood patrols, and sentences that require shoplifters to sweep the sidewalks in the business district. These innovative, small scale approaches to crime control are best designed and implemented by people closest to the problem. The very best crime control arises from informal neighborhood relations. Crime thrives when people are indoors and afraid. A healthy neighborhood is one where people walk outdoors and neighbors watch each other's homes. Big government solutions like prison projects do little to foster such conditions.

References:
Adler, F., Mueller, G.O.W. and Laufer, W. (2007). Criminology. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Bohm, R. M. and Jeffery T. Walker (Eds). (2006). Demystifying Crime and Criminal Justice. Los Angeles: Roxbury.
Currie, E. (1998). Crime and Punishment in America.
Garland, D. (2001). The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Miller, J. M., Schreck, C.J., and Tewksbury, R. (2008). Criminological theory: A brief introduction. 2nd edition. Boston: Pearson.
Smith, P. and Natalier, K. (2005). Understanding Criminal Justice.

The Criminal Justice System (2008). National Center for Victims of Crime. Retrieved from: http://www.victimsofcrime.org/help-for-crime-victims/get-help-bulletins-for-crime-victims/the-criminal-justice-system

The Probation Service (2010) Annual Report 2009. Available at http://www.probation.ie

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Traditional Criminal Justice Case Study

...The “justice as a human problem” worldwide accentuates that the type of justice adopted in a society heavily depends on the cultural norms and social values regarding human behaviours. For example, western societies mostly focus on the retributive justice as means for demonstrating justice through the infliction of punishment against those who violated the laws. The victims are often emotionally devastated, but they also suffer severe hardships in the criminal justice process during testimonies or sentence hearings (Herman, 2005). For example, the victims are negatively stigmatized in society due to the infliction of certain crimes like sexual assault, which increases fear and anxiety (Herman, 2005). It remains imperative that the criminal justice system actively takes steps to fulfill the victim’s needs in order to gain strong cooperation (Herman, 2005)....

Words: 904 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Egan Criminal Justice Organization Case Study

...Societies in this century and the previous ones have been victims to unlawful, racial discriminated unrests. Unrests which have been known to be quite damaging not only to the victims of the act but rather the community as well. Regardless of the government’s ability to control and manage any offensive events in the community, cases still seem to arise in the community. It’s evident for a need communication and an understanding of crisis management, peaceful resolutions to the crisis in order to obtain a community fracas and hostile free. As a professional in the at Egan criminal justice organization, in a crime ridden community. The case study addresses the flawed emergency response to the 1992 Los Angeles Riots. This study, however experienced challenges that come with gathering and interpretation of information from the sites of study. The study suffered from financial constraints. The expenses for the study eventually were significantly lower than the estimated budget. This was from factors such as insufficient resources from local station. The institution had a misalignment...

Words: 1687 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice Case Study Susie Louise

... The agency has strict guidelines that are to be abided by to determine a client’s eligibility and how much can be offered. Even though Mrs. Louise fit the criteria to receive emergency services when she called for an appointment, she did not have the needed documents when she first came to the agency so there was a delay in her receiving the emergency services requested. After moving into their new apartment, Mrs. Louise had all the required documents needed to receive assistance on her rent and her utility bill. The fund amount that was previously discussed in the first meeting was not available anymore so she was given a lower amount due to the time gap between meetings. The social welfare policy that is pertinent to Mrs. Louise’s case While working with Mrs. Louise I demonstrated many social work skills that I have accumulated while working toward my degree such as social perceptiveness, self-awareness, coordination, boundaries and empathy. At our first meeting, I established our worker and client boundaries. As our meetings continued, I was able to emphasize with her rather than sympathize with her. Mrs. Louise did not want me to feel sorry for her but understand how she was feeling and where she was coming from because of the incident. My communication skills allowed me to reach out to another agency and receive additional funds to assist Mrs. Louise and her husband with. ...

Words: 824 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice And Sentencing Reform Case Study

...In 2015, after the Illinois Governor Bruce Rauner had attended several Summit of Hope Events which are put on IDOC and Illinois Department of Public Health( IDPH), he signed a executive order to create the Illinois State Commission on Criminal Justice and Sentencing Reform. “The Illinois State Commission on Criminal Justice and Sentencing Reform will review of the State of Illinois current criminal justice and sentencing structure, sentencing practices, community supervision, and the use of alternatives to incarceration, including, but not limited to, a review and evaluation of”( Illinois Executive Order 15-14): • “The existing statutory provisions by which an offender is sentenced to or can be released from incarceration; • The existing statutory...

Words: 278 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Research Process and Terminology Paper

...the criminal justice system today. Effective research methods have the ability to open and close cases. Those interested in the criminal justice field have a wide range of research methods at their disposal. The terminology involved is also a very important aspect when used in the study of criminology and criminal justice. This paper will explore some of the various research methods that are applied to the criminal justice system and explain how the knowledge of the terminology involved can be a valuable tool within these methods of research. Empirical Research in Criminal Justice Although research in criminal justice varies considerably, there are five general steps that are followed in order to conduct research. The first step is called problem formulation. This is the selection and specification of the area that will be investigated. The next step is research design which is the type of experimental or non-experimental approach, with the use of control groups and studying group(s) at one time or over a period of time. The third step is data collection methods which give a choice of various methods to be used such as observation, questionnaires, or interviews. The fourth step is analysis and presentation of findings which is to summarize report and when necessary statistically analyze and present findings. The fifth step is conclusions, interpretations, and limitations which is what the researcher believes the study explains. Quantitative Research in criminal Justice ...

Words: 1362 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Research Methods

...Introduction An effective research method in the criminal justice system is essential and using these methods gives the ability to successfully open and close cases. People who work in criminal justice system have a wide selection of research methods and tools at their disposal. Throughout this paper we will discuss various research methods that are used within the criminal justice system as well as the terminology associated with the research. We will discuss the importance of knowing the proper terminology for research in the criminal justice system and how not knowing the proper terminology affects you as you conduct criminal justice research. We will also look at the benefits of knowing the terminology when evaluating and analyzing research. Research Process In order to properly grasp the importance of research and the terminology within the criminal justice system we must first ask, what is research? Research is the systematic investigation into the study of materials and sources to establish facts and reach new conclusions (Press, 2010). The process of research can vary significantly, but there are five steps generally followed when conducting research. Formulation is the first step and this is when the selection and specification of an area to be investigated. The second step in the research process is research design this is the type of approach will be used, such as experimental or non-experimental using study groups or controlled groups. The third step is where...

Words: 1117 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Case Study Term 2 Unit 4 Assignment

...CASE STUDY 2 Criminal Justice professionals have certain responsibilities and duties in order to fulfill the needs of society. Criminal justice professionals are the backbone to any society and they are given certain authority and power by the government to protect its citizens. This sets them apart from the general population. They are expected to fulfill the vast amount of duties expected of them in a professional manner. Criminal justice professionals are expected to have very high moral standard therefore in order for the citizens to feel safe they have to remain vigilant and professional; they are not expected to be any discrimination or biasness at all, during the commission of their duties. Law enforcement, correctional system and legal system are a few of the criminal justice professions that are entrusted by the government with the powers to protect and serve the citizens of the country. Law enforcement officer’s role is public safety, which can officially be broken down in different functions, enforcing the law, keeping the peace and protection of life and property. In carrying out the function law enforcement officer have to exercise discretion. Without law enforcement we would have anarchy and crime would be more prevalent. Policing is as much as helping people and maintaining community quality of life as it is about enforcing the law and apprehending criminals. In today’s multicultural and diverse society...

Words: 739 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Research Process and Terminology

... Research Methods in Criminal Justice July 24, 2012 Abstract When people are learning about the criminal justice, they learn that research method and terminology plays a major role in the academic and law enforcement field. These research methods and terminologies used daily with the police officers or detectives for investigation cases. Effective research methods and terminologies also used by attorneys or paralegals in criminal justice field to open and close cases in the court. Research methods are the tools that identify the issues in criminal justice from its point of view and base on the nonscientific problem or issue. “Knowledge is why people create reality and describe by Comte. This paper tells different type of research methods that are applied in the criminal justice field and how the terminology involved with these types of research methods. Scientific Research in Criminal Justice In many criminal justice fields, the law enforcements start to gather the documents and data information. They begin to observe the information or facts about the crime. Many of them use a systematic method to check the information such as asking questions about who, what, where, when, why, and how of the crime. They begin to gathering the piece together, by the facts and determining if there is enough evidence for the case. The hypothesis takes a part of the case to help gathering the information for the crime. The...

Words: 1041 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Accountability Has Become Hostage of Plea Bargain. Does Plea Bargaining Undermine the Criminal Justice System? Legal and Social Impacts on Society.

...Accountability has become Hostage of Plea Bargain. Does Plea Bargaining Undermine the Criminal Justice System? Legal and Social Impacts on Society. Student’s Name Institution Contents 1.1 Background to the Study...............................................................................................4 1.2 Purpose of the Study.....................................................................................................5 1.3 Research Objectives......................................................................................................5 1.4 Research Questions.......................................................................................................6 1.5 Significance of the Study..............................................................................................6 2.0 Methodology/ Research Design.....................................................................................6 2.1 Sampling Design............................................................................................................7 2.2 Sample Size....................................................................................................................7 2.3 Data Collection and Analysis.........................................................................................7 2.4 Validity and Reliability..................................................................................................8 2.5 Skills Required......................

Words: 1643 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Procedural Justice: Cruel Or Harmful Victim?

...has suggested that this is no longer the most desired outcome the victim wishes to achieve, with procedural justice being the most important aspect of the victims Criminal Justice process. Procedural Justice suggests that both parties (the victim and the offender) are to be treated fairly and consistently. Murphy and Barkworth (2014) have portrayed procedural justice by the following main ideas; Respect, Trustworthiness and Voice, with other researchers such as Miller and...

Words: 1933 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Thesis Proposal

...Accountability has become Hostage of Plea Bargain. Does Plea Bargaining Undermine the Criminal Justice System? Legal and Social Impacts on Society. Student’s Name Institution Contents 1.1 Background to the Study...............................................................................................4 1.2 Purpose of the Study.....................................................................................................5 1.3 Research Objectives......................................................................................................5 1.4 Research Questions.......................................................................................................6 1.5 Significance of the Study..............................................................................................6 2.0 Methodology/ Research Design.....................................................................................6 2.1 Sampling Design............................................................................................................7 2.2 Sample Size....................................................................................................................7 2.3 Data Collection and Analysis.........................................................................................7 2.4 Validity and Reliability..................................................................................................8 2.5 Skills Required......................

Words: 1646 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Restorative Justice Paper

...Restorative Justice Paper Luis Sanchez Life is about making wrong and bad choices, there is not a single individual on earth that was born with the appropriated knowledge of what is right and was wrong. No individual is perfect they are all equal and all go through struggle, and by struggling choices are being made whether are choices with appropriate behavior or inappropriate behavior. Some individuals know how to control themselves before a tragedy occurs, but most fail to control their temper and they violate the law, and by violating the law consequences are implement because justice must be obtain. Once an offender commits crime then it is more likely for the case to go to trial. The criminal justice system is the practices and institutions of governments directed at upholding social control. So when crime occurs the defendant will receive either a punishment or sentence. The criminal justice system and other systems that are against crime and inappropriate behavior are always on the side of the victim, because their goal is to obtain justice. The restorative justice is an approach to justice that focus on the needs of the victims and offenders, as well as the involved community instead of satisfying abstract legal principles or punishing the offender. Restorative justices involve both victim and offender and focuses on the personal needs. It is based on a theory of justice that considers crime and wrongdoing to be an offence against an individual...

Words: 1181 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Restorative Justice

...Restorative Justice Paper Joseph R. Bain CJA 224 July 05, 2014 Aileen Azadian Introduction Among many basic human qualities is the fundamental need to assign blame and punish wrongdoers. With the framing of the U.S. Constitution the people and the government sought to stress the importance of law in order to maintain among many things, moral principles which were vital to human life, justice and liberty. The expectation being of course that laws would help maintain social order which would ensure life, liberty and justice. To highlight this fact, violating the law carries with it certain consequences. Perhaps the most significant of these consequences is the concept of punishment. The idea and purpose of this concept is to assign the deserved punishment relative to the violation. The mechanism of punishment helps to discourage and deter others in society from committing such behavior. There are 5 rationales that exist, operate and support the idea of punishment in today’s criminal justice system. They are retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation, restoration and incapacitation. Retribution centers solely on the punishment of the offender. Almost as a bi-product of retribution comes deterrence. Deterrence, as stated before helps to discourage others in society from committing criminal behavior. Rehabilitation helps to reform offenders in the hopes of eventually reintegrating offenders back into society as productive members. Restoration seeks to make the victim and...

Words: 1107 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice Problems

...Problems within the Criminal Justice System In the United States Abstract: This research paper explores some problems faced within the criminal system justice in the United States. Larry J. Siegel’s book “Criminology” gives us a history of the criminal justice system, how it operates, and some of the problems we experience with this system. Some of the problems detailed in this paper include the right to equal justice; which he explained the different kind of judgment that people receive based on their race, gender and class, the criminal justice system spends more money on criminals instead of improving technology for the police apprehending them, the criminal justice system lacks of sentencing disparity, reliance on eyewitness and modern technology can lead to conviction of innocent citizen, and finally the rehabilitation model which is set up to educate criminals and eventually let them free because of the belief that they are changed people and have been rehabilitated. According to the definition from the text “Criminology”, the term criminal justice system refers to “the components of government charged with enforcing law, adjudicating criminals, and correcting criminal conduct” (Siegel, 2009, p. 558). According to Siegel, the criminal justice system is essentially “an instrument of social control: society considers some behaviors so dangerous and destructive that it either strictly controls their occurrence...

Words: 4821 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Is Justice Truly Blind

...Running head: IS JUSTICE TRULY BLIND? Is Justice Truly Blind The structure by which offenders are detained and reprimanded is one of the supports of any democratic system. However in order for that arrangement to remain feasible, the community must be convinced that individuals in resembling circumstances are treated the same and with consistency, from the original exploration of the offense, to the hearing and penalty of that crime, down to the prosecutors and the judges. This process is not optional, but rather guaranteed by the Constitution of law despite race, gender or ethnicity (Justice on Trial, 2012). As we know our criminal justice system today, it appears to be operating far from this principle. Somehow in the arena of criminal justice, racial discrimination is increasing instead of diminishing. Disparate treatment of minorities differentiates every point in the course of action. Black and Hispanic Americans, as well as other minority groups, are mistreated by inconsistent targeting and unreasonable treatment by the police and other law enforcement officials; by the racially distorted charging and plea bargaining resolutions offered by prosecutors, biased punishments, and by the letdown of judges, nominated officials and other criminal justice guidelines used to remedy the unfairness of justice that has become more obvious as time goes on (Justice on Trial, 2012). All of these issues add to the opinion that lawlessness is a colored and minority...

Words: 1344 - Pages: 6