Premium Essay

Csi Effect

In: Business and Management

Submitted By kgang
Words 560
Pages 3
Running Head: CSI EFFECT 1

CSI Effect
Karen Choisser
Grantham University

What is the “CSI Effect” and does it really exist. Some people think watching television shows such as CSI and Law & Order have an effect on how jurors will convict or not convict a criminal, then there are some who don’t feel this way. Continue reading to decide for yourself.

CSI Effect What is the “CSI Effect”? Is it anything more than a myth? Actual jurors in real cases are wrongly acquitting criminals who they would have convicted if the television show CSI was not aired, as people see it as real. Prosecutors say the CSI effect forces them to explain why they have no forensic evidence, and jury selection takes longer as the people who seem to be influenced by the show are removed. Defense attorney’s agree about the effects of the television show. Producers of CSI say their show has an educational effect on the public(teaches them science). Some police feel that CSI helps educate criminals on how not to get caught. Educators think CSI attracts students to want a career in forensic science.(Knight,2010). The CSI effect does have some benefits such as understanding the use of resources to investigate cold cases and for people who have information about a crime to come forward. Donald Shelton, Greg Barak and Young Kim randomly chose 1,027 jurors in Ann Arbor, Michigan to participate in a study. First, they got demographic information, asked what they watched on television, how often and if…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Does the Csi Effect Exist? blur with crime magazine television shows such as 48 Hours Mystery and American Justice. These programs portray actual cases, but only after extreme and lengthy editing of the content and incorporating a narration voice over for dramatic effect. Other shows that are even more popular that are helping the media to blur the fine line between reality and fiction, even further, are the forensic dramas like: CSI: Crime Scene Investigation, Cold Case and Bones. These shows however, are not reality and create what is commonly known as “the CSI effect” and in my opinion have caused jurors to wrongly acquit guilty offenders when no scientific evidence has been presented to the jury by the prosecutors. 
 The CSI effect is a phenomenon brought about by popular television shows such as: CSI: Crime Scene Investigation, Cold Case and Bones. and other forensic shows that are raising crime victims' and jury members' real-world expectations of the field of forensic science and type of forensic evidence that is presented by the prosecution. Much of these concerns come from the writers of forensic science television glamorizing the field, overstating the accuracy of forensic techniques, and exaggerating the abilities of forensic science. The CSI effect seems to skew public perceptions of real-world forensic science, as well as the behavior of criminal justice system actors; this is of particular concern in the courtroom setting, where many prosecutors feel pressured to deliver more......

Words: 1313 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Forensic Science in the 21st Century

...Forensic Science in the 21st Century By: Crystal Lyle AJS/584 - FORENSIC SCIENCE AND PSYCHOLOGICAL PROFILING STEVEN HOENIG 2-29-16 This paper will examine my perception and concept of forensic science in the 21st century. It will also examine the importance of forensic science to policing criminal investigation court process, and the efforts of various levels in security. In addition to analyzing the importance of forensic science, I will give a historical approach. I will discuss the accuracy of the media representation of forensic science and how issues. Lastly, I will discuss the influence the CSI effect have on the judicial process. Forensic Science is the application of science to criminal and civil laws that are enforced by law enforcement agencies in a criminal justice system. Another definition of forensic science is principles and techniques to matters of criminal justice, especially as it relates to the collection, examination, and analysis of physical evidence. In 1929, a Los Angeles police department establish the first American forensic lab. Forensic science has been around over 300 years or more and it continues to improve and emerge today as science and technical knowledge find more improved and accurate techniques. Forensic science has come to be a critical instrument in allowing guilt or demonstrating innocence in the system of criminal justice. In the late 80’s (DNA), society was accepting of (DNA) and forensic science continues to develop and......

Words: 1265 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

How to Succeed in Becoming a Crime Scene Investigatorr

...Robin B. Arslanian Professor Long English 122 12 October 2011 How to Succeed in Becoming a Crime Scene Investigator (CSI) The career as a Crime Scene Investigator, better known as CSI, can be very rewarding. To help catch the “bad guys”, to me, can be very satisfying. My goal is by the end of this paper you will learn how to become a CSI, the first steps to take once you get to a crime scene, what to expect in the courtroom and hopefully how much fun a career as a CSI can be. Being a CSI is definitely not for the faint at heart, some crime scenes can be gruesome. If you think being a CSI is like you watch on television you are sadly mistaken. Television glamorizes the long hours it takes to get DNA results or fingerprint identification. These types of results can take days to weeks. This can be very frustrating to the investigator who is being pressured by the prosecutors, the lead detective on the case and by the families for information. How you analyze the crime scene and what you find out in the lab can mean the difference between a conviction and an acquittal. Your education is the most important quality and resource you can have in any career. However, for a CSI it is of utmost importance. You will need at the very least an Associate’s degree in either Criminal Justice with a forensics background, or better yet a Bachelor’s degree in Forensic Science. It is suggested that if you have a Bachelor’s degree you should go for your Masters; it will make you......

Words: 2085 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Csi vs. Ncis

...The main difference of the two TV shows, CSI and NCIS, is that CSI consists murders of the general public and NCIS consists of only military based murders. Both TV shows are unrealistic compared to the real world. CSI shows how dangerous the job can be by agents getting killed in a crime scene, which also shows how it can affects the investigations. NCIS (Naval Criminal Investigation Service), on the other hand, is a real government agency that only focuses on crimes that involve the military and the show NCIS is deals with many of the same cases as the real life agency. In my opinion, the more realistic show between CSI and NCIS would be NCIS. The show CSI is unrealistic to the real world because the crime scenes are really convenient, such as figuring out the time of death as quickly as they do and finding evidence that is scattered across the scene, which is very rare realistically. Each episode of the show the cases are very unique, where in real life, investigators are handed a lot of paperwork and the cases are always very similar. The fingerprint information and DNA comparisons are matched and returned to the investigators very quickly, which in reality it takes weeks to make a fingerprint match to a suspect that is unknown and breaking things down to genetic material will take even longer. Teams are usually very small and move very slow in investigations, in the show, they have teams of five or six to solve a crime and they move much quicker in solving the case.......

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Compare and Contrast the Ways in Which Csi and the X Factor Attract Audiences?

...Both, CSI and X Factor have been huge successes in their own respective genres. This essay will examine the similarities and differences in the ways and techniques that X Factor and CSI use to attract their audiences. Both texts attract a worldwide audience with over 30 countries having their own version of ‘X Factor’, and in 2006, CSI was named the most popular show in the world in a study of ratings in over 20 countries. These stats connote a measure of the popularity and dominance of these shows within their genres, and generally within the TV industry. The Uses and Gratifications theory can be applied to both these texts to show how they attract audience using the 4 stages. Firstly, personal identity, as X Factor is a contestant based show, and the people start the show as average everyday people, and this is connoted in their interview before their audition where they talk about their current life, and have very casual dress codes in a public and busy mise-en-scene. As the show progresses some of these contestants start to turn into ‘celebrities’ by gaining publicity, and this is connoted due to their change in dress codes, which is now smart and classy compared to casual before. Also connoted through their confidence, as at the start they are very nervous and modest, and as the competition progresses, depending on good results a person will gain self-confidence and gain more and more fans. An example of contestants that used the X Factor as a way to gain fame is One......

Words: 1523 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Lost Leaf

...What is Cognitive Strategy Instruction? Cognitive strategy instruction (CSI) is an explicit instructional approach that teaches students specific and general cognitive strategies to improve learning and perfor- mance by facilitating information processing. CSI embeds metacognitive or self-regulation strategies in structured cognitive routines that help students monitor and evalu- ate their comprehension. The ability to identify and utilize effective strategies is a necessary skill for academic success. Many students, especially students with learning disabilities (LD), are ineffective and inefficient strategic learners. CSI enables students to become strategic and self-regulated learners (Dole, Nokes, & Drits, 2009; Pressley, Woloshyn, Lysynchuk, Martin, Wood, & Willoughby, 1990). Using proven procedures associated with explicit instruction including process modeling, verbal rehearsal, scaffolded instruction, guided and distributed practice, and self-monitoring, students learn, apply, and internalize a cognitive routine and develop the ability to use it automatically and flexibly (Montague & Dietz, 2009). The metacognitive component of CSI helps students focus on the task and regulate and monitor their performance (Palincsar & Brown, 1984). Instruction in self-regulation strategies promotes strategy maintenance and generalization. Although CSI has been applied to a variety of academic tasks, this Current Practice Alert will highlight...

Words: 1024 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Csi Miami vs Csi Real Life

...For this assignment I chose Double Jeopardy from CSI Miami, season four episode eighteen. In this episode a husband is found innocent of his wife's murder just as her missing body is being pulled from the ocean by a fisherman. March 26 Mr. Rowe discovered his wife’s racial status and she disappeared on October 5th but the husband waited 3 days to report her death. During this time he practiced killing Terisa Matherdy. Losing four twenty lb weight set in the process. The CSI team must try to find new evidence linking the husband to the deed since he can't be tried again with the same it is considered "Double Jeopardy." A little evidence and timely confessions shows that the husband and his girlfriend did, indeed, kill the wife Melisa Rowe. My uncle Lieutenant Steve Helm stated that he has seen CSI more often driving a 1990's pickup truck rather than a $60,000 Hummer, as seen on the show CSI. But when you’re a movie star you can drive whatever company is paying the advertising bills. In Hollywood’s depicture of real life organizations this type of flashy brand new equipment is expected. Forensic scientists are rarely actually involved in solving cases, as the show depicts. A team of scientists is usually called out once a month to a crime scene to investigate fingerprints, firearms, trace evidence, document blood splatter patterns, collect footprints and tire prints, footwear patterns, and other evidence. My uncle said, “Forensic scientists rarely go to most...

Words: 1062 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Theories About the Relation Between Flow, Habit and Addiction

...while the fine line between habit and addiction is already settled. The new CSI model describe the different roles of Challenge, Skill and Interest in this topic. I am still trying to find a way to add a fourth property to this model which may lead to the generation of a four-dimensional model. 1. The introduction of the new CSI model The new model is based on a fundamental model covered in the material from the lectures: CS model or Flow Chart. The old CS model pointed out a clear area when Challenge and Skill reached a balance spot which is known as “flow area”. Above the “flow” section where Challenge is high and the Skill of individual is low indicates the part that individual gets anxiety and below the “flow” section where Challenge is low and the Skill of individual is high shows the part that individual gets boredom. So here is when an idea came to my mind that there should be a third variable considering this model. Otherwise there should not be anyone who is really excited about doing the work he/she is familiar to, since the Challenge is low and Skill of individual is high. In my point of view, there are a few personalities should be considered. However, what matters more among those characteristics is Personal Interest. Therefore, I am adding the third axis to the original Flow Chart: Interest, which makes the model to become a three-dimensional model. Above is an example of the CSI Model after I put some theoretical data in the chart. The data should......

Words: 2425 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Media vs the World

...main problem, lies many problems that interfere with the American idea of justice. Are we craving, and striving to find entertainment, or justice? One problem that stems from media that could possibly add to jury bias and court outcomes, it is what lawyers refer to as the “CSI Effect.” Named after the hit television show, this phenomenon describes the distorted view crime investigation shows cast upon forensics and criminal evidence. If a juror is an avid fan of CSI, then the case they are apart of, better be as “realistic” as CSI. This distorted view influences the outcome of a court case, simply because these television shows are giving us an unrealistic view of the court process and the American justice system. The general public needs to face it, the real courtroom is the farthest you can get from CSI. General courtroom evidence takes months to collect, gather, and study; CSI, on the other hand, takes an hour to do it all. Due to the popularity of these shows, there are jury members that bring in their preconceived ideas of what the law should look like due to the media surrounding them.  OK, so CSI is a hit television series, and millions watch it on a weekly basis, so, how do we stop its effect? The entertainment industry needs to require these shows to be more realistic. By doing this, the general public will be much more educated in the ways of the justice system. I am not saying take out all the drama, just refine the drama to fit the reality of the courtroom.......

Words: 1829 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...then their heart rate and adrenaline increase which could cause hostility. Sometimes, people actually get desensitized to killing because they do it in video games. Fagin, Claire, Pam Maraldo, and Dianna Mason. "Increasing Public Understanding of Nursing." N.p., 4 Jan. 2007. Web. 19 July 2010. . This article expresses that shows like House M.D., E.R. and Grey’s Anatomy give people a skewed perception of how doctors and nurses actually work. It makes people think that doctors just sit around all day and work on a single case or that nurses don’t really do anything useful. Shelton, Donald E. "The 'CSI Effect': Does It Really Exist?." N.p., 17 Mar. 2008. Web. 19 July 2010. . This article explains what is called the CSI Effect. It is an increase of expectations in jurors due to watching too many CSI and Law and Order type shows. This supports my theory because it means that guilty suspects could and possibly are being set free due to the police not doing everything that the police on TV do such as fingerprinting an entire lawn....

Words: 268 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...2010 / 2011 CSI Computer Crime and Security Survey 15th annual 2010/2011 Computer CrIme and SeCurIty Survey 1 2010 / 2011 CSI Computer Crime and Security Survey by Robert Richardson, CSI Director 2010 / 2011 CSI Computer Crime and Security Survey With this document, the CSI Survey achieves its fifteen-year mark. Both the aims and format of the survey continue to evolve. As you’ll see in the findings that follow, many of the results reported by our respondents easily could have been predicted based on looking at results from the past several years. There has always been an almost surprising stability to answers about tools and methodology in this survey and this year is not an exception. What is different, broadly speaking, is that there is considerably more context within which these results may be interpreted. There are a number of very good reports of various kinds now available on the Web. All of them that we’re aware of, with the exception of this one, are either provided by vendors or are offered by analyst firms. That’s not to say that there’s anything wrong with these sources. A tremendous amount of useful information is offered in these various reports. But independent research seems fundamental and we believe the survey provides this. Beginning last year, there were three important changes to this survey. The first was that a “Comprehensive” edition was offered, one of its key objectives being to attempt to take other report......

Words: 16095 - Pages: 65

Premium Essay


...CORPORATE SOCIAL INVESTMENT BUSINESS CONGRESS 2008 Presented by THE HELPING HAND NETWORK CSI Business Congress 2008 Page 1 THE CALL TO DIALOGUE – SOCIAL REFORMATION CONGRESS REPORT & SUPPLEMENT CONGRESS DATE: 15­16 JULY 2008 CONGRESS VENUE: SIBAYA CASINO, 1 SIBAYA DRIVE, UMHLANGA, KWA­ZULU NATAL OVERALL FEEDBACK “For the first time CSI will tread where no man has trod before, and pave the way to the social reformation of South Africa.” The congress has become a reality and manifested a resounding success as we received excellent feedback from delegates who attended this event. The demand of our country has definitely changed from conferencing and workshops to active dialogues and practical outputs. This was accurately displayed when the panel discussions and dialogues superseded the conventional manner of conferencing. There was a remarkable shift from proclamation to accurate application. The CSI Congress has provided a moral order and accurately confronted specifics that will result in the eradication of systems in which the exploitation of resources leads to the poverty of the country. The CSI Congress primarily identified both the theoretical and practical strengths and weaknesses of alternative approaches to measuring freedom, and clarified on which techniques are most suited for building sustainable systems towards excellence and to chart concrete directions for future research that will add value to SA`s sustainable corporate social development.......

Words: 8382 - Pages: 34

Free Essay

Forensic Science in the 21st Century

...are two of the most important elements in crime-solving. Consequently, technological advances are relevant to the limited and challenging forensic science field. Also, it is a field wherein technical aptitude is attained only by the amalgamation of various dynamics. For example, supervision, continuing education, proficiency, training, experience, coupled with appreciativeness of scientific protocols and methods proposed against a setting of harsh professional beliefs. This submission delves into forensic science’s contributions to policing and criminal investigations, court processes, and security efforts. Also it explores the media’s representation of forensic science, influence on popular opinion for justice-related issues, and “CSI” effect on the judicial process. Forensic Science Contributions to Policing and Criminal Investigations The geneses of criminalistics or forensic science are mainly European. Forensic science is an amalgamation of various disciplines, such as chemistry, mathematics, geology, physics, and biology to examine physical evidence associated with crime. Previously, the employment of forensic science methods was focused mainly on severe crimes like homicide and rape. However, forensic methods are being positioned throughout a broader spectrum of crime groupings. Additionally, it is routinely being used to assist the investigation of volume crimes such as robbery, vehicle crime, and burglary (Bradbury & Feist, 2007). Forensic Science......

Words: 1778 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Vase Study Solution

...19 114,500.00 143,945.31 173,437.50 202,835.94 232,000.00 260,789.06 289,062.50 316,679.69 343,500.00 369,382.81 394,187.50 417,773.44 440,000.00 460,726.56 479,812.50 497,117.19 512,500.00 B. Based on the CSI table or spreadsheet, the optimal price-advertising combination that will maximize the number of units sold is the analytical solution P = $40 and A = $5,000. Notice that quantity rises until this point is reached, but then falls as both price and advertising climb beyond this point. C. The negative quantities and sales revenues observed at very high price-advertising combinations have a simple analytical interpretation. The quadratic expressions for both price and advertising are negative in the CSI demand function. At very high levels for price and advertising, the importance of these negative quadratic terms will outweigh positive first-order effects. Therefore, at very high levels for price and advertising, both quantity and sales revenue turn negative. However, negative values for quantity and sales revenue have no economic interpretation. Remember that price-quantity-advertising relations are clearly sensitive to the price and advertising levels considered. The nonlinear relation described in the CSI demand function would undoubtedly change dramatically with dramatic changes in the price-advertising levels considered. ...

Words: 417 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Forensic Science in the 21st Century

...component is now incorporated into homeland Security, A pattern of legal instances benefiting from this type of scientific study would be medical malpractice litigation, probate proceedings, complex and commercial legal action and contract lawsuits. According to Shelton (2010), “Forensic Science in Court explores the legal implications of forensic science--an increasingly important and complex part of the justice system. Judge Donald Shelton provides an accessible overview of the legal issues, from the history of evidence in court, to gatekeeper judges determining what evidence can be allowed, to the CSI effect in juries.” The media has the potential of affecting the way people think. People disregard their perception based on scenarios presented. Popular media representation of forensic science and influential presence on the public’s opinion on justice-related issues, the effect that impeccable synchronicity of the investigator and successful outcomes portrayed in fictional arenas are contemporaneous with the public’s feelings. Dissatisfied with the criminal justice system not solving cases fast enough, the public then places astronomical expectations on medical examiners. Real life investigators believing that a lack of competency may be at play when in reality, society has been provided a distorted view of the lengthy, painstaking process involved. According to Nurse Advocacy (2007), “People disregard all messages in advertising, since ads commonly present actors......

Words: 1454 - Pages: 6