Free Essay

Cultural Context

In: English and Literature

Submitted By emmaodx
Words 1880
Pages 8
Cultural Context

The cultural context refers to the type of society in which a text is set-it’s structures, values and day-to-day rituals. Comparing the texts I have studied under Cultural Context mode involves entering the world of each text and comparing the ways in which the lives of the central characters are influenced by the worlds in which they live.
The three texts I have studied are Lies of Silence (LS) by Brian Moore, Plough and the Stars (PS) playwrite by Sean O’Casey and Il Postino (IP) directed by Micheal Radford. These novelists, dramatists and film directors obviously employ their own distinctive narrative techniques. I was interested in studying a significant range of similarities in the way LS, PS and IP deliver their respective tales.

The setting is easily comparable in all texts. IP was set in a small island off the coast of Italy around the 1950’s. Communism was the main political headline in this text, where a famous Italian poet, Pablo Neruda, was exiled from his own country and forced to live elsewhere for a short while due to the fact he was a communist. During this time also, Europe was struggling to cope from World War II. PS was set in Dublin, 1916. The Easter Rising was at stake. We receive an insight into the lives of the Irish people during The Troubles. There was also a feud between Socialism and Republicanism. LS is set in Belfast in the 1950’s when the Northern Troubles were at its climax. The setting in this text is dominated by the deep-rooted political and religious conflict in the North of Ireland.

The roles of women in all texts have their equal comparisons and similarities. In IP, it had come to my mind that Mario and Beatrice’s marriage had little true strength. I got the impression that Mario seemed more keen on the Italian poet, Neruda, than for his unborn child. However, the women are strongly independent throughout the film. They are able to make their own living by working in a local restaurant. Women also seem eager to please their husbands. Pablo Neruda’s wife tried to thrill him by putting on music he enjoyed. Contrastingly, in PS, Jack Clitheroe showed little or no respect to his wife, Nora, when the army arrived at his home. It was clear that Clitheroe placed his country before his wife. This demonstrates the position of women in society during these times. Juxtaposed to IP, the women in PS are less independent. They refuse to work and therefore depend on their husbands to support them financially as well as emotionally. Nora constantly urges and pleads with Jack to stay by her side. Similar to IP, Nora makes an effort to better herself in an attempt to please Jack. Unlike IP, LS contains strong women characters. Moira courageously defies the IRA during the hostage.

As in the case in both LS and PS, IP is set in a male-dominated world. While all three texts present us with strong female characters, such as Donna Rosa, they are subordinate to men. Real power exists with the men in each text. In IP, most male inhabitants are fishermen. However, they are greatly exploited. The chief authority figures in IP are the politician, Di Cosimo and the priest. Di Cosimo fails to keep his promise to the local people that he will ensure that a waterworks supply will be working on the island. Politics is particularly evident in the lives of men in the three texts. Neruda was exiled from his own country due to the fact he was a communist. Correspondingly, the Northern Troubles in PS prompt the men to protect their country. In LS, the IRA is an organisation dominated by men. I was interested to see the men are the power figures in each text.

Religion plays an important role in the worlds of all three texts, but only in IP is religion portrayed positively and without rebellion, unlike what happens in LS and PS, which is the cause of division and abruption. However, religion brings the people of IP together. They come in unity for the blessing of the fishing boats and for a religious ceremony. They also appoint the priest a position of respect at Mario and Beatrice’s wedding. What a contrast to LS and PS, where both texts highlight the depth of the religious split leading to the bitterness and bloodshed in Northern Ireland. Sectarianism is typical in both LS and PS. In LS, Moira’s father, Joe, demonstrates this in a key moment at the dinner table. “A Catholic would never get a job if there was a Protestant up for it.” Even though religion was the principal root of Northern Irelands problems, it still remained strong and important to the people. This is particularly important in PS, where Captain Brennan placed rosary beads on Jack Clitheroes hands at the moment of his death. In both LS and PS, religion is present in the everyday, conversational language of the people. “God bless us.” This underlines the importance of religion on all three texts.

Violence also has a huge impact on people’s lives in all three texts. Violence and social turmoil were never far from intruding on the daily lives of people. I can see this clearly in LS and PS. Similar attitudes prevail in both texts, where the IRA fought a war of bombing and killing that became a routine of life. In LS, hotel bombing was seen as a means of destroying the tourism industry and one method of bringing the economy of the province to its knees. The Clarence was already bombed the year before and Dillon, as the manager, was involved with the daily task of security. This is displayed in a key moment where the occupants at the gates were waiting to be searched before entering. On the street, police travelled in armoured cars and more “combat jackets” to protect themselves from sniper bullets. This attitude is mirrored in PS, where the political culture was the dominant issue for violence. From the beginning of the text, I noticed the influence of this culture in the lives of the tenement people. A key moment of this would be when Jack is killed, leaving Nora a widow but insane. Bessie Burgess sacrifices a son and dies as a result of a sniper bullet. The failure of the rising leaves the central characters in a claustrophobic room trying to protect themselves from the horrifying events outside. However, the similarities we see in LS and PS are different in IP. Mario’s death is particularly tragic because he dies in a violent crush after leaving his peaceful island home to deliver a poem dedicated to Pablo Neruda at a communist rally on the mainland. From the points I outlined above, violence is clearly seen in the worlds of each text.

The lives of all three texts were dominated by poverty. However in LS, money was the motivation for the middle class to work because that meant constructing an efficient society and creating a lifestyle that provided comfort. I immediately see a contrast of this idea with PS, where the tenants lived in grim, overcrowded conditions with little or no privacy or comfort. Unemployment is high. Similar to IP, where people also struggle to find work and living conditions are poor. There is no running water on the island and people have to make do with a supply brought from the mainland. A key moment to demonstrate this is when Neruda asks Mario about the islands lack of running water and tells him that the islanders should make a stand to change the situation. Mario shrugs as if he feels there is nothing he can do. In Ls, the paramilitaries are associated with the poorer working-class parts of Belfast. The root of the violence, apart from sectarianism, is clear to be the competition for jobs. Northern Ireland is an economic slump in this text. This reminded me of PS, where The Troubles lead to poverty. This is demonstrated in a key moment where Rosie Redmond who lives in a single room and had to scrape a living as a prostitute. Bessie Burgess lives in a tiny attic room with its “unmistakable air of poverty”. Poverty was the reality of the everyday lives of the people in the worlds of the three texts.

Social divisions are a feature in all three worlds of the text, particularly in LS and PS where the divisions are both religious/political and class based. In IP, they are not very pronounced as the majority of people are occupied trying to make a basic living. The only time we are shown a class division between Capri and the wider community is displayed in a key moment when Di Cosimo comes in with wealth, suits and smoking. I realise that his attitude is very condescending. Pablo represents a dignified class and educated wealth. In his home, he has new technology, which is a clear comparison to Mario’s house.

The attitude of three individual characters prevails similarly in each of the three texts. A feeling of escapism and isolation is dominant within each of the characters. In IP, there are two worlds in the film that influence Mario’s behaviour. The first is the island itself and the second is the world that exists beyond the island. Mario admires this ideal world in contrast with his own simple island life. This is particularly shown in a key moment when Mario becomes animated when a postcard arrives from America. To him, this world is paradise. Similar to IP, PS acts in the same manner. Nora feels isolated as she cares little for the political situation. She is indifferent to the fight of independence and for better conditions. Personally, Nora’s perfect situation would be on the island of Capri in IP along with her husband Jack, where no political disagreements would endanger him and take him away from her. There is also a sense of escapism and a new start is set against descriptions of a sectarian Belfast that he hates and cannot wait to get out of. This feeling of pessimism is shown effectively when he sees students who have graduated and is reminded of his own hopes of being a poet, a failed dream. As a result, he is forced to fall back on the family’s hotel tradition for economic survival. It is interesting for me to see the effect on the individual in the society they live in.

In conclusion, I was interested in studying that the behaviour of the protagonists in the comparative texts is significantly influenced, in both positive and negative ways, by the cultural context of a particular text. Cultural influences prompt Michael Dillon to defy the IRA in LS, an action that costs him his life. The lives of those in the tenement that are directly affected by the Rising in PS. We also see how the culture inspires Mario to grow in self-awareness and achieve happiness in IP. If asked to choose which life I would want to live in, I would pick Il Postino without hesitation. The beautiful landscape of stunning beauty, rich cultural conditions and romance all appeal to me.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Historical Cultural Context

...In the assigned reading related to your Discussion Board Forum, Duvall & Hays discussed the importance of the historical-cultural context (Chapter 5). Throughout the chapter, they identify the key aspects you should consider related to the historical-cultural context when you study Scripture. Pulling specifically from the Duvall & Hays text and synthesizing into your own words, write a 250–300-word response to the 3 prompts below. In addition, in the second part of first question you are asked, "Do you care to share any examples from your own experience?" based upon what we have learned in the reading. Answer the three prompts in 3 separate paragraphs. 1. What can happen when people approach the Bible without any concern for the historical-cultural context? Do you care to share any examples from your own experience? 2. Can you think of an example of the historical-cultural context shedding significant light on the meaning of a biblical text? 3. For people living in an “instant application” society such as ours, what can persuade them to put forth effort to study the historical-cultural context? “Historical-cultural context relates to just about anything outside the text that will help you understand the text itself.” (Duval & Hayes, pg. 51) Historical-cultural context is imperatively important when reading God’s word. When people approach the Bible without concern for the historical-cultural context it can lead to gross misunderstanding of the divine text....

Words: 853 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Cultural Context in Advt

...CULTURAL CONTEXT IN ADVERTISEMENTS Effective advertising is possible only when the advertisement conveys the intended message, giving consideration to underlying cultural codes. Semiotics, the study of signs and symbols and their meaning, offers valuable tools for analyzing advertising to uncover strengths or weaknesses of ad campaigns. In general, advertising can communicate either a solution narrative (i.e. buy our product and it will solve your problems), or an enhancement narrative (your life is already good, but if you use our product it will be that much better). Below is the comparison of the message being conveyed in both the Western and the Chinese context: * Motorcycle: Whereas in a Western context a motorcycle represents freedom, adventure, and speed, in a Chinese context it is considered dangerous, noisy, and low status.  * Open Landscape: For Westerners, the open landscape portrays independence and lifestyle enhancement. From the Chinese view, the countryside may be perceived as dirty and dusty. The codes present in the advertisement convey a very different message when translated into the a different cultural context, and do not result in communicating the message which was actually intended....

Words: 375 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cultural Context of Ihrm

...Cultural Context of IHRM Intercultural Management Studies Our world is filled with many different and unique countries, all with their own customs and cultures. In International Human Resources Management, it is the IHRM Department’s job to educate any expatriate about the foreign country they will be moving too. The main reason to do this is preventing cultural shock causing a smoother transition for the expatriate. Culture can be defined as “the beliefs, customs, arts, etc., of a particular society, group, place, or time” or is a more business related sense “a way of thinking, behaving, or working that exists in a place or organization.” Throughout the years there have been many intercultural management studies and there are four most widely accepted theories: The Hofstede study, The GLOBE study, The Trompenaars & Hampden-Turner study, and Hall & Hall’s cultural dimensions. These studies broke down cultures and behaviors around the world and are valued resources for IHRM departments. First, there is the Hofstede study. Geert Hofstede was a professor who conducted an extremely comprehensive study of how different cultures place value in the workplace. It was Hofstede who first made an empirical model and had different dimensions of national culture. These dimensions were: power distance, uncertainty avoidance, femininity vs. masculinity, individualism vs. collectivism, and long-term orientation....

Words: 2331 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Historical-Cultural Context

...When reading the Bible, knowing the historical-cultural context regarding what is being read is very important. The Bible is God’s word, and it is important to understand, as best we can, His message to us. When people approach the Bible without any concern for the historical-cultural context, the message that God is relaying to us can often be misunderstood. The reader will be unable to apply the message to their lives in ways that will be relevant to us today. If readers do not understand the relevance of a particular passage to the biblical audience, they will be on the wrong track to understanding the relevance of that passage to the audience of today. There are many examples of how understanding the historical-cultural context can shed light on the meaning of a specific biblical text. One example is found in Matthew 18:20, “For where two or three are gathered in My name, I am among them.” Many people associate this verse with attending church. Although church attendance is important, Jesus is actually speaking of the process of church discipline. Jesus said that if anyone has a brother who has sinned against you, then you are to go to him and attempt to work it out. If he refuses to acknowledge his fault, you are to bring one or more witnesses to help work the matter out. Living in an “instant application” society, such as ours, can be very damaging to our understanding of God’s word....

Words: 332 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Historical Cultural Context

...Animation Questions: Digestive System Overview (23 Questions) 1. What are the four main functions of the digestive system? Ingestion Absorption Elimination of wastes 2. Name the types of digestion. Mechanical Chemical 3. Where does digestion begin? How does this occur? Mouth. Where the teeth breaks food into smaller particles during mastication. 4. Another name for chewing is Mastication. 5. What is the function of the salivary glands? Of saliva? Located near the oral cavity secrete saliva, which begins chemical digestion and keeps the food moist. 6. What prevents food from entering the nasal cavity while swallowing? Soft palate 7. What muscles push food particles into the pharynx? Multiple voluntary muscle in the face, neck and tongue. 8. Name the structure that prevents food from entering the respiratory system? Epiglottis 9. Name the structure that connects the pharynx to the stomach. Esophagus 10. Once it has been swallowed, the food mass is called a Bolus. 11. What is the term for involuntary wavelike contractions that propel the bolus to the stomach? Peristalsis 12. What are rugae? What are their functions? Folds in the stomach. Allow for expansion as the stomach fills, and also increases surfaces area. 13. The stomach cells secrete hydrochloric acid, pepsinogen and various regulatory hormones that chemically digest the bolus. 14. What effect do these secretions have on the bolus? Muscular......

Words: 1175 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Historical Cultural Context

...In the historical context it is very important that we must have an understanding of the events that occurred during that time in history, the message they were trying to convey during that time period, and how it applied to their lives during that time in history. When reading the Epistles it is very important that you must have an understanding of the audience that the author is speaking to, but with as with any biblical story in order to understand you must study and read the bible, commentary, or any other resources to learn the background. To have an understanding of the literary context you must know what is being said. A literary context is the combination of a writer's total life situation in every aspect, presented within a writing style and format, along with subject matter. When it comes to interpreting epistles to summarize the basic hermeneutical principles it is imperative to remember that “a text cannot mean what it never could have meant to its author or his or her readers.” (Fee, p. 74). In conclusion, the epistles, in the most simple of terms, are letters that were written from a writer, usually on behalf of God, to a particular audience. The historical and literary contexts of the epistles are important tools, because it helps readers sift through Biblical text in order to find applicable meanings. References Fee, G. D., & Stuart, D. (2003). How to read the bible for all its worth. Grand Rapids, MI:...

Words: 250 - Pages: 1

Free Essay

Academic Integrity in a Cultural Context

...Academic Integrity in a cultural context What is Academic Integrity in a cultural context? According to the Oxford School Dictionary & Thesaurus Academic means something to do with education or studying, especially at a school or college or university. Integrity means telling something that is true. Cultural means the custom and traditions of a people. Context means the background to an event that helps to explain it. So we can deduce from these definitions that academic integrity in a cultural context refers to academic honesty as against the background of the customs and tradition of people in an academic world. Academic Integrity in Nigeria With three major ethnic group and over 150 sub ethnic group, I daresay Nigeria is a very rich country in terms of culture and diverse in terms of customs and traditions. From time immemorial information has been passed down from generations to generations orally. Words and proverbs were actually not attributed to a singular person but to an ethnic group, for instance, the Yoruba adage, the Igbo adage, the Hausa adage, the Bini adage and so on. As we advance over the years, we started attributing word or group of words as quotes to an individual and also books were written by individuals. It was in the bid to stop mass reproduction of books that copyright came into been....

Words: 1863 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Historical-Cultural Context of the Bible

...What can happen when people approach the Bible without any concern for the historical-cultural context? When people approach the Bible without any concern for the historical-cultural context, they could interpret the text as misleading and false. People may not understand the many truths of the revelations of God, revealed by parallels of historical-culture norms. People tend to misunderstand what God is saying to us, instead people should reveal the principals and apply them to their life today. To fully understand the meaning of the text in the Bible, people must first understand the text in its own context, with careful observation of what the text says. Then people should investigate the meaning of the text, from an historical approach and what it meant to its original hearers. Besides those examples cited in this chapter, please give and explain an example of how understanding the historical-cultural context can shed significant light on the meaning of a specific biblical text. Cite the specific passage you are discussing in your post. (ex. Is. 40:27–30. In Romans 6:6, "Our old man was crucified", is an example of how understanding the historical-cultural context can shed significant light on the meaning of a specific biblical text. This verse could be misunderstood when someone does not understand the historical-cultural context, some may believe the verse is a reference to the experience of a Christian....

Words: 356 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cultural Dimensions: High Context vs. Low Context

...Dimensions of Culture Com 101 Cultural Dimension: High Context vs. Low Context Definition of the Dimension: High and low context communication are ways in which members of various cultures deliver messages. High context messages are communicated non-verbally, in an attempt to maintain social balance, while low context messages express what one would like to communicate directly through language. Examples of how this dimension of culture can result in misunderstanding and/or challenges faced by people who would come from different cultures in which the members of the respective cultures have learned different worldviews/ behaviors/beliefs, etc. regarding this particular dimension: One example of how high context communication could result in a misunderstanding is in a retail setting. An American employee could be going about their job as usual, and a person who is from a low context culture might not get the service they expect. An American might not pick up on the non-verbal cues given by somebody from a high context culture and could come off as rude or non-caring even if that isn’t their intention. An example of challenges faced by people who come from different cultures in which members of the respective cultures have learned different behaviors can happen in the business world. A new hire from a high context culture might have trouble adjusting to the business environment in the U.S....

Words: 305 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Academic Integrity in a Cultural Context

...Journal of Sociology and Education in Africa – Vol.4 No.2: June 2006 INSTITUTING ACADEMIC INTEGRITY IN NIGERIAN UNIVERSITIES: PSYCHOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES OF MORALITY AND MOTIVATION Olabisi Olasehinde-Williams Department of EductgionalFoundations University of Ilorin, Nigeria ABSTRACT This paper explores the issue of academic integrity in Nigerian universities from the psychological perspectives of morality and motivation. The need and procedure for confronting the problem of academic dishonesty via academic integrity policy are advocated; and specific obligations and responsibilities of academic staff, students and administration in evolving academic integrity climate in universities are identified. Collaborative efforts among universities in engendering academic integrity climate; and collaborative research work in related areas are considered important and called for in the paper. INTRODUCTION It is no longer news that academic dishonesty remains one of the major challenges of the Nigerian education system (Olasehinde, 2000; Olasehinde-Williams, Abdullahi & Owolabi, 2003). – Literature is also replete with plausible explanations for the ‘culture’ of academic dishonesty (Olasehinde et al. 2003); and researchers have proposed variety of methods of dealing with the same (Crown & Spiller, 1998; Marzean, 2001). Deriving from such proposals for instance, it is new commonplace in most universities, to take such measures as alternate seating arrangements and identity checks......

Words: 3638 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

The Demographic, Social & Cultural Context of Business

...ASSIGNMENT ON THE DEMOGRAPHIC, SOCIAL & CULTURAL CONTEXT OF BUSINESS Submitted To: Mr. Ruhual Amin Faculty Member, BRAC University Submitted By: Iffat Zarin Khan ID No: 15364042 MBA, BRAC University Subject Name: Business Environment Subject Code: BUS503 Date of Submission: 8-12-15 Review and Discussion Questions 1. What is meant by an “ageing population”? Examine some of the key ways in which an ageing population can affect the supply side of the economy? Answer: Population ageing is a phenomenon that occurs when the median age of a country or region rises due to rising life expectancy and/or declining fertility rates. Aging of population (also known as demographic aging, and population aging) is a summary term for shifts in the age distribution (i.e., age structure) of a population toward older ages.  A direct consequence of the ongoing global fertility transition (decline) and of mortality decline at older ages, population aging is expected to be among the most prominent global demographic trends of the 21st century....

Words: 5614 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Douglasian Cultural Model in Indian Context

...There are different studies which discuss the diversity of ethical decision-making based on different perspective for example, Vitell, Nwachukwu and Barnes, 1993 discuss the effect of culture on ethical decision-making with the help of Hofsted’s typology while Patel and Schaefer, 2009 discuss the same with the help of Douglasian Cultural Theory (CT) perspective in the Indian context. Summary Patel and Schaefer’s article discusses the impact of culture on ethical decision-making from a Douglasian Cultural Theory (CT) perspective. It explains the dynamic ethical behaviour of the individual with four solidarities of CT. The Article also discusses the business ethics in the Indian context. Authors argue that applying static conception of culture to the process of ethical...

Words: 2170 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Discussion Board 1: Historical and Cultural Context

...Attempting to interpret a passage of scripture without the historical and cultural context is akin to trying to choose tires for someone else's car without knowing what car they have. You know they need tires, but you don't know the height or the width of the wheels, if it is front wheel, rear wheel, or  four wheel drive, how they drive it, or on what surface they usually drive. without this background knowledge, you will make the wrong decision. The historical and cultural context allows you to see what is actually valued by those that are involved in the passage. Without this value assignment, the emphasis of a particular passage can be missed entirely.      Philippians 4:13 is an often misinterpreted passage, used with frequency by athletes as an encouragement to to push forward in their strivings for greatness. However, a glance at the context in which Paul is writing this shows that his situation is not one of striving from a good place to improve one's self. We find Paul in a bit of a low spot, imprisoned for his service to God. Yet, despite these harsh negative circumstances, he knows that he can accomplish all that God has for him to do, because it is God's will. Paul is not speaking of an indvidual circumstance or an indvidual task. He is saying that his entire life's work will be accomplished through Christ, no matter what is obstacles are set in his way.      Instant application of passages is based, primarily, on a person's presuppositions....

Words: 365 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cultural and Institutional Context of Global Human Resource Management

...2 LEARNING OBJECTIVES After reading this chapter you should be able to •• describe the basic characteristics of culture and explain how cultural dimensions can be used in global HRM, •• describe how the institutions of society can shape HRM policies and procedures, •• discuss the possibility of the convergence of HRM across countries, •• explain how the heritage of state socialism continues to influence the context of HRM in transition economies, and •• discuss the effects of cultural and institutional context on the HRM role and on employee expectations. 23 24    ESSENTIALS OF INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Springtime in Paris As she savored the last bite of her croissant, Martha Pereaux, HR director for C3 Technologies, thought about how she would approach her latest “cross-cultural collision,” as she had come to think of them. In the year since she had moved to Paris from Houston, there had been many, but none quite as bizarre as this one. Martha had taken the big promotion to head up the HR division of the joint venture between Houston-based SuperChem and the French company. C3 developed technology for the oil industry, primarily new types of concrete that formed the barrier wall for offshore oil and gas wells. The joint venture was meant to take on the likes of the giant Schlumberger on its own turf and compete with them for valuable technical staff....

Words: 9323 - Pages: 38