David Medine started his article tugging on the heart with “The recent terror attacks in Paris were a horrible tragedy, claiming 130 lives and injuring hundreds of innocent people who were just going about their lives on Friday evening.” “Choice between security and liberty a false one” Medine shares similar ideals with David Haynes but uses different example to illustrate his argument. After the atrocities in Paris, Congress wanted to put Act 215 back in play but Medine felt like that would be a hasty decision. In 2014 NSA filed for an extension but did not receive it because not only it was it not efficient in terrorist activity but the risk of abusing the data by government officials were too high. He believes the Freedom Act restores the