Free Essay

Death in Expectation

In: English and Literature

Submitted By taylor84
Words 958
Pages 4
Death in Expectation English 102: Literature and Composition

Fall 2011

Writing Style: MLA

Thesis Statement
The protagonists in these stories become slaves to expectation which results in their untimely death.
Outline
I. Introduction II. Differences a. Mrs. Hutchinson’s attitude b. Paul is determined to find luck i. Ambitious ii. Driven iii. Appears Unhappy c. Differing states of sanity III. Similarities d. Little power e. Slaves to expectation f. Did not try to escape IV. The trouble with Mrs. Hutchinson and Paul g. Both characters fall prey to the expectations and pressures of society iv. Paul’s mother v. The towns people h. They both accepted the conclusion of the story V. Conclusion

Intense pressure can inevitably bring forth unwarranted loss. Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” and D.H. Lawrence’s “The Rocking Horse Winner” each feature characters that face an early death as a result of either personal or societal pressure. The authors show many similarities as well as differences that are evident in the characterization of their protagonists. Despite their parallel endings, Mrs. Hutchinson and Paul display diverse personality traits as well as different states of sanity. It is, however, the similarities that outweigh the differences between these characters. Both exhibit an air of powerlessness to outside forces, while neither one of them attempt to change it. Thus, they meet their demise, accepting that they are bound to the situation they found themselves in. The protagonists in these stories become slaves to expectation which results in their untimely death.
Mrs. Hutchinson and Paul vary in many ways in these stories. Most notably their disposition toward their conflict is clearly different. Mrs. Hutchinson exhibits a nervous air as she hurries to the lottery. She jokes and laughs with her neighbors while anxiously awaiting the lottery’s results. It is not until her family is selected that she shows signs of panic and fear. Paul, on the other hand, is an odd child from the beginning. Being very inquisitive and constantly inquiring about the origin of luck. Once he is informed that his family is undeniably unlucky he feverously sets out to find it. For Paul there is no cheerfulness even when he’s selecting the winning horse. Conversely, Mrs. Hutchinson appears that she is jovial and friendly on any other occasion. Even in their last breath their personalities differ. Upon her execution Mrs. Hutchinson stays relatively sane, begging and pleading for her life. Paul on the other hand has clearly lost his mind in the pursuit of luck risking his life for the winning horse’s name. Each protagonist faces the obstacle of powerlessness. Paul is bound to his rocking horse as his only source of luck. While Mrs. Hutchinson cannot, despite her pleading, change the results of the lottery. It is by these pressures that each character becomes a slave to the expectations placed before them. Paul is intent on finding luck and making money with that luck. The more money he makes by guessing the winning horse’s name the luckier he feels. He reaches a point of such desperation to find luck by the horses name that he dedicates himself fully to the pursuit. He became a slave to the expectation to find the winning name. Conversely, Mrs. Hutchinson knew the lottery was approaching. Once she was selected to die she knew that she was committed to that death whether it was her will or not. The connection which makes these characters all the more complex is that they inevitably invited these pressures. Mrs. Hutchinson embraced her death by supporting the lottery. She did not move or attempt to change the tradition. In consequence, she approved of it which welcomed her own assassination. Paul also welcomed death by his single-minded quest for luck. Although, the warning signs for death were abundant he chose to maintain his intense expectation of success. This exhausted his body leading to his death.
Unrealistic expectations become the downfall of both characters. The origins of Paul’s expectations started with his mother and father and their constant lack of money. Paul states, "I started it for mother. She said she had no luck, because father is unlucky, so I thought if I was lucky, it might stop whispering." (par.149) The house that constantly whispered for more money, as well as the pressure to find luck become so strong that Paul ambitiously set out after it. Once he starts winning the expectation to continue to win, provide luck and money for his family grew stronger. Mrs. Hutchinson’s situation was equally similar and different to Paul’s. Her expectation comes from the rituals and traditions of the town. She could not and would not change the inevitable outcome of death; she just hoped that the death would not be her own. People in the town even referred to the importance of the tradition and it is implied that Mrs. Hutchinson agreed to its necessity. Thusly, once selected Mrs. Hutchinson did nothing to actively save her life. Similarly, Paul knew the toll that his search for luck was taking on his body. Regardless he felt that his sacrifice was worth the result.
Death by expectation is the thread that binds Paul to Mrs. Hutchinson. They sought out their own demise by agreeing to participate in actions which unavoidably brought death to them. Regardless of how they died the reason why is the same. Paul was a slave to luck expecting that luck would bring fulfillment. While Mrs. Hutchinson was a slave to tradition assuming that there was no other way. Each character is an example of the danger of following any tradition or ritual blindly. In the end they found themselves a casualty of expectation.

Cited Works Page
Lawrence, D. H. The Rocking-Horse Winner. Grand Rapids: Kessinger. LLC, 2004.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Death Rituals And Expectations In The Navajo Culture

...Death Rituals and Expectations The Navajo people have a belief that the spirit of their dead would come back to the living if they were not properly buried. The death rituals and expectations for the Navajo Native Americans is a culture that is very sensitive about their dead. The Native Americans needed their dead to be buried rather quickly to make sure that their dead would not come back. The Navajo Native Americans back in the day would clean the dead body and then cover it with a coverlet. They would then put the dead on a horse and head north as far as they could go. The family would find a burial place for their dead and kill the horse so that the dead would have a new horse in the next life. Burial customs require that everything is in order and that all the rituals are followed. One of the rituals is that is a person dies in their home that their home will have to be burned with the body. The surviving family would have to be there at the burning so that they will also be purified along with the deceased (Navajo Death Rituals, 2016)....

Words: 1042 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Expectations And Reputation In Arthur Miller's Death Of A Salesman

...In Arthur Miller’s play Death of a Salesman, through his character, Linda Loman, the author implies that caring too much about one’s expectations and reputation can bait someone into believing he or she cannot fulfill their true obligations and further lead to a decline in one’s successes. For example, Willy, Linda’s husband, does not appreciate his son Biff’s profession as a farmer as Willy states “Not finding yourself at the age of thirty-four is a disgrace!” (5). Here, while not specifically stated, the reader can infer that Biff does not feel affinity for his father because he chose to go against his fathers desired route of becoming a salesman, which prompts Willy into believing he failed as a parent and then attempts to commit suicide...

Words: 256 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Texting and Driving

...What is economic? Economic is a study of how people make choices among the alternatives. Since the resources that are available to world are very scarce, it is important to study economic in order to make the best choice that can maximize the total profits. Real life cases are the best examples for studying economic concepts. In this paper, there are three real life cases that illustrate economic concepts base on the Case in Point boxes from the Course Reader. The first case will define the economic concepts: choice, scarcity, and cost. The second case will describe how the stock market puts supply and demand to work. The last case will present the effects can be caused by private and external costs. Case in Point: Chapter 1.1-Defining Economics; Section 1-Scarcity, Choice, and Cost What Is Wrong With The Oil Productions? Why is oil harmful? Petroleum or oil had come to the existence about four thousand years ago. Oil is now one of the required resources for every day's activities. For instance, products like mechanical engines, cars, cooking, tar for roads, etc. needs oil to function. Even though oil has many choices of how it can be produced, it is a scarce resource. As a scarce resource, oil is very limited and cannot be reproduced or recycled. As a result, there are many opportunity costs for producing oil. For instance, one of the opportunity costs for producing oil is a healthy environment. Additionally, money is the most costly opportunity cost for the oil production...

Words: 2346 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Lofland's The Shaping Of Emotion: The Case Of Grief

...in our continuously modernizing world how one expresses such an emotion is subject to public approval. This is especially the case in incidence of loss of a public figure. The Queen is a perfect example of how expectations of emotional expression are placed on public figures. With the media at play and tabloids reporting the lives of famous individuals every move, the private and individualized expression of emotions is not subject to the approval of the viewing public. “…the involuntary loss through death of a human being who is viewed as significant…” ( Loftlan 1985, p.172). The definition of grief as outline in Lofland’s article The Shaping of emotion: The case of Grief. The move The...

Words: 980 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Romeo And Juliet Dbq Analysis

...Love comes with plenty obstacles, however this plays love led to death. William Shakespeare authorized the play, “Romeo and Juliet.” Romeo and Juliet are the two main who were deeply in love with each other. This play is about how the deaths of Romeo and Juliet came to be. These two characters had to go through a lot to be together, because of the rivalry the two families had. The Capulets are the ones to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet because they stressed Juliet to get married, Tybalt started a brawl with the Montagues, and they expected Juliet to live up to societal expectations. To begin with, Juliet’s parents stressed her to get married at the age of 13. Lady Capulet told Juliet to get married to Paris, but that wasn’t what Juliet wanted. Lord Capulet threatened Juliet is she didn’t get married to Paris. Document D stated, “Get thee to church o’ Thursday, or never look me in the face.” If lord Capulet would’ve never threatened Juliet to get married, she would’ve never gotten so angry and left to get a potion from Friar Lawrence. If lady and lord Capulet never stressed Juliet to get married on Thursday, a lot could’ve been prevented. Juliet only wanted more time to get married, but they wouldn’t even give that to her....

Words: 518 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Deepak Chopra's 'Five Causes Of Human Suffering'

...these five cause, or “kleshas,” of human suffering are: not knowing the true nature of reality…clinging to, or grasping, or holding on to that which is ephemeral, transitory, illusionary, insubstantial, and therefore not real…aversion to, revulsion to, fear from or fear of that which is insubstantial, transitory, illusionary, ephemeral, not real…identification with a false and constricted and habitual sense of self which we call ego…and the fear of death. All five causes can be summed up in the first klesha, because they all deal with “not knowing the true nature...

Words: 557 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Everyman

...any cost. Once his mother told him his father wasn’t lucky, he set out on a quest to win her love through luck. The lack of love, affection and attention can happen in a household stressed by debt. The symbol used in both stories is a human sacrifice. In “The Lottery” the entire town desires to sacrifice a human life in hopes to be blessed with an abundance of crops. In “The Rocking Horse Winner” sacrifice is the sons own life. His needed to gain his mother’s love through luck. He rides his rocking horse daily in hopes to acquire a winning name. Unfortunately, he has a fatal fall, acquiring a blow to the head that leaves him unconscious and ultimately dead. He sacrificed his sanity and his life to gain his mother’s love. The expectations in both stories are the opposite of what actually occurs. The reader is lead to believe that there will be a great monetary winning at the end of each story. In “The...

Words: 832 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Okonkwo's Pop Culture

...You may have what it takes to be successful, but if you lose yourself in someone else’s priorities or societal expectations, you will be judged not by your potential but rather by your history – Dr. Lois P Frankel. Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman took place in New York City during 1948. A lot happened in the 1940’s, World War II ended in 1945, so the 1940’s were consumed by the war. The pop culture was very anti-German and anti-Japanese. It was unimaginable just how much the war impacted all aspects of people’s lives. You could not just walk into the grocery store and buy all the butter you wanted like you can do now. Many items were rationed. Post war though became very luxurious. People’s spirts were lifted, movies were cranked out, fashion...

Words: 1351 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Discuss Ways in Which Dickinson Presents Death in 465 (‘I Heard a Fly Buzz – When I Died’).

...This poem demonstrates a wide array of interpretations of death as well as Dickinson’s uncertainty as to what may come after Death and her questioning of the existence of God. Dickinson sees death in a very physical way; she chooses not to concentrate on the spiritual aspect or the anticipated arrival of “the King”. This is best shown in the opening line of “I heard a Fly buzz”, where we are immediately provoked by thoughts of decay and rot. She chooses to focus on physical aspects of the mourners such as their “eyes” and “breaths”. This is perhaps to focus on the painless death of the woman, as Calvinists believed that if someone suffered a peaceful death they would enter the Kingdom of God. Her use of an oxymoron in “that last onset” shows how she acknowledges the religious importance of death to others, as in 19th century America Christians believed that the “last” of someone’s life on earth was the “onset” of their eternal life in heaven. Death is thought to bring revelations as with it comes an exalted male figure of “the King” to be “witnessed”, yet this expectation and sense of ritual is undercut by the juxtaposition of “in the Room” and furthermore so by “the fly” which interposes and is all that appears in place of God. Dickinson focuses on the harsh realities of death in the fact that the dying can only “will their Keepsakes” yet their souls and character will be lost forever. This is emphasized by the manner in which the mourners conduct themselves. They seem...

Words: 572 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

An Analysis Of Bless Me Ultima By Rudolfo Anaya

...coming-of-age, novel. The protagonist, Tony has expectations of being a priest, changes his perspective on evil , and losing a lot of family/friends. In the beginning of the novel, Tony is expected to be a priest when his mom was talking about his value of his education. When Tony’s parents were talking, his mom say’s “ He must know what he can become… A priest… for your brothers.” (52) This event causes Tony to think what he is going to be when he grows up. Tony is pressured by his parents because they have expectations of him being something he doesn’t want to be. When Tony was alone he says, “That is why my mother dreamed of me becoming a priest, because there had not been a luna priest in the...

Words: 592 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Galipoli

...Mariam has a miscarriage) * Both novels have a contrast of the ‘good’ and ‘evil’ characters Tess: Alec and Angel – ATSS: Rasheed and Alec. Laila marries Rasheed (evil) and also marries Tariq (good). Tess is Alec’s mistress (evil) and marries Angel (good). * The death of the ‘main’ character Tess kills Alec and then gets hanged Mariam kills Rasheed then gets executed. * The ‘good’ love interest fleeing to another country Tariq flees to Afghanistan and Angel flees to Brazil. * A major death in the family Tess’s father and Mariam’s mother. * Conflict Tess: between classes in the same county – ATSS: same ethnic group of people * Class society Tess: Angel (upper class) and Tess (lower class) – ATSS: Jalil (upper class) and Mariam/Nana (lower class). * ‘Men’s society’ Tess: Angel with the prostitute in London – ATSS: Rasheed had several wives Similarities/comparisons with A Thousand Splendid Suns and Tess of the d’Urbervilles  * Women in society  * strong male characters * the loss of a baby * the loss of a parent * rape * young female characters * poor backgrounds * forced into marriage  * murder * the death of the ‘main’ character  * the ‘main’ character murdering other characters * the female characters always being the ones that struggle * unsupportive parents * independent females * the females going against others * pride​ Molly Harris Rudi...

Words: 1971 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Masque Of The Red Death Mood Essay

...Setting’s Influence on Mood and Tone The setting of “The Masque of the Red Death” gives an eerie feeling to the story. In the book, it mentions that the seven rooms all have “…windows…of stained glass whose color varied in accordance with the prevailing hue of the decorations in the chamber,” except for the last room, which is black with red windows. This builds suspense, as the reader can infer that there is something special about the room, especially because its windows are red, and that is the color of the “Red Death”. There is a sense of eerie unearthliness throughout the story because of this room as well; all the guests at the party are avoiding it. In conclusion, the setting lends a sense of expectation and bizarreness to the story. Character Analysis Prince Prospero is likely a stubborn person who is used to having his way. In the story, he is resisting accepting the reality of “The Red Death” by hiding away in his castle with his guests. In addition, he chases the uninvited guest with the intention of killing him. This shows that Prince Prospero is stubborn because he’s unwilling to allow things to vary from how he planned them. This can also be inferred because Prospero is the ruler of the...

Words: 678 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

What Death of a Salesman Conveys About the American Dream

...The American dream has stood to be each person’s idea of success. The American dream is usually associated with 1940’s America depiction of the ideal family, as can be depicted from television shows such as Leave it to Beaver. However, this is one aspect and shallow analysis of the American dream that is not appropriate for all reaching to achieve their American dream. In Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman, Miller succeeds in portraying this through the characters Willy and Biff. Their conflict represents two varying perspectives of the American dream, and this very struggle leads to the conclusion that the American dream is rooted in the pursuit of a better life. Throughout Death of a Salesman, Miller portrays two ideas of the American dreams and it is definite that they are “American dreams” as they both deal with success and that character’s idea of success. Though, this is where characters’ views differ and conflict with one another. Willy’s American dream is to have his children succeed and to leave his imprint on the society which he was unable to succeed in doing so in a life long career as a salesman. Furthermore, Willy lived in the ideology that being “well liked” was far more important and and necessary than being a Bernard type of person and make a living based on his studies. Willy’s belief and encouragement of this ideology upon his sons influenced Biff immensely. As a result, Biff did not put the effort into his studies that would have enabled him to pass...

Words: 750 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Presentation of Death in "I Heard a Fly Buzz" - Emily Dickinson

...i died The death in this poem is painless, yet the vision of death it presents is horrifying, even gruesome. The appearance of an ordinary, insignificant fly at the climax of a life at first merely startles and disconcerts us. But by the end of the poem, the fly has acquired dreadful meaning. Clearly, the central image is the fly. It makes a literal appearance in three of the four stanzas and is what the speaker experiences in dying. The room is silent except for the fly. The poem describes a lull between "heaves," suggesting that upheaval preceded this moment and that more upheaval will follow. It is a moment of expectation, of waiting. There is "stillness in the air," and the watchers of her dying are silent. And still the only sound is the fly's buzzing. The speaker's tone is calm, even flat; her narrative is concise and factual. The people witnessing the death have exhausted their grief (their eyes are "wrung dry" of tears). Her breathing indicates that "that last onset" or death is about to happen. "Last onset" is an oxymoron; "onset" means a beginning, and "last" means an end. For Christians, death is the beginning of eternal life. Death brings revelation, when God or the nature of eternity becomes known. This is why "the king / Be witnessed in his power." The king may be God, Christ, or death; think about which reading you prefer and why. She is ready to die; she has cut her attachments to this world (given away "my keepsakes") and anticipates death and its revelation...

Words: 720 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Hlt 310v Week 2 Complete Assignment and Dq

... The Death of Ivan Ilych by Tolstoy and the three concepts of the “healing environment” found in chapters 7-9 of Called to Care: A Christian Worldview for Nursing. What is the phenomenology of illness and disease (i.e. the personal “what it is like”)? Cite references from your reading to support your answer. What is a personal analysis of your own experience with illness and disease and how several factors colored that experience? How can you relate to The Death of Ivan Ilych? WEEK 2 TOPIC 2 DQ 2 What is the Christian concept of the imago dei? How might it be relevant to our unique approach in health care and why is it important? WEEK 2 ASSIGNMENT (BENCHMARK ASSIGNMENT) HEALING HOSPITAL: A DARING PARADIGM Max Points: 125 Details: Consider how the paradigm of a healing hospital might influence your philosophy of caregiving and write an essay of 500-750 words that addresses the following: 1. Describe the components of a healing hospital and their relationship to spirituality. 2. What are the challenges of creating a healing environment in light of the barriers and complexities of the hospital environment? 3. Include biblical aspects that support the concept of a healing hospital. Prepare this assignment according to the APA guidelines found in the APA Style Guide, located in the Student Success Center. An abstract is not required. This assignment uses a rubric. Please review the rubric prior to beginning the assignment to become familiar with the expectations for successful...

Words: 938 - Pages: 4