Deception

In: English and Literature

Submitted By goshsoorandom
Words 498
Pages 2
“The interrogation is critical to any criminal investigation. A suspect might lie or tell the truth, they may be innocent or guilty. Interrogation is a high stakes game. Too much pressure and an innocent person might confess to a crime they didn’t commit.” National Geographic’s

“Nothing but the Truth” This is a concept held by many to be the ultimate goal of interrogation. But, from research, deception is a common technique used by interrogators against the accused. In the Oxford Dictionary deceive is defined as deliberately causing someone to believe something that is not true, especially for personal gain. It is said to bring out the truth by using a lie, but is it really ethical?

There are three types of false confessions:
Voluntary false confessions are made without external pressure.
Compliant false confessions happen when a suspect confesses to the crime just to get out of the interrogative situation.
Internalised false confessions occur when the accused starts believing that they have committed the crime.

In a criminal case documented by National Geographic’s, in 1988 a 12 year old girl was killed and police believed her 14 year old brother had killed her. The detective told him if he did not confess he would be tried as an adult and if he confessed he would get help. This was a lie. The detectives in a 10 hour interrogation finally led to him confessing to the crime. Luckily, DNA later revealed that he was innocent.

There is a misconception amongst arrogant interrogators that they would know a false confession when they hear one. However, it is virtually impossible to tell the difference because they seem exactly the same.

The more vulnerable of our society are children and mentally unstable people namely because they are more subject to influence. This does not mean ordinary and intelligent people are not susceptible to a false…...

Similar Documents

Deception

...DETECTING DECEPTION To summaries the first two articles topic area Deception may be suggested that both articles are concerned with the investigation of deception from the view point of the verbal and nonverbal reasoning. Their aim is to find predominantly nonverbal cues to when people are telling the truth and when people act in a deceptive manner. They both were found to more or less lack of stance validity Article three however; “Outsmarting the Liars” was chosen as it was more recent; it was corresponding well to the previous two articles topic, but in the same time was offering ultimate solution and entirely new approach to the topic. It was also offering different and new modern continuation of the topic and was moreover offering solutions that work and were based on real life outsets to an extent. Further it was a practical solution to the outstanding unresolved problems of the research on detecting deception. Another reason was that the authors were well known authorities in the research field of deception and they use the most recent research done in the field by others as well as their own. The Methodology used by the first two articles is using controlled experiment and collecting primary data. Both of them rely highly on previous research and are aiming to fill gaps in further research, to minimise limitations and to find solutions to limitation that cannot be overcome until that point. In comparison the three articles are conducted as experiments in...

Words: 1227 - Pages: 5

Self Deception

...Classic self-deception: this is the paradoxical situation where a person can both believe and not believe some fact simultaneously. Good examples of this would include the addicts and pathological types. The drug addict believes that he or she can break the habit any time he or she wishes; the cigarette addict believes that cigarettes are not dangerous to his or her health; the gambling addict believes that a monumental win is just around the corner; the pedophile doesn’t believe his actions will harm the child. All of these cases could be considered to be exemplars of self-delusion where the person both knows that his or her actions will lead to some unwanted consequences but chooses to ignore that knowledge. In these cases it would appear that the addiction overcomes or negates the truth but instead substitutes its own rules where the gratification received from the addiction leads to irrational action. Addictions are usually accompanied by changes in the chemistry of the brain. (reference) The neuroreceptor populations are abnormal. Consequently, it could be argued then that the addict is not self-deceived but simply unable to make rational decisions owing to a brain malfunction even though it might have been self induced. The pathological self-deceiver is fortunately reasonably rare. These people believe that they are someone else. In Cotard’s syndrome a person believes at the same time that dead people are motionless and speechless, that he can move and talk, and......

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

Deception

...Deception “Half the work done in the world is to make things appear what they are not,” says E.R. Beadle. This quote holds true even today. Life for many people has turned into an illusion, unless we look very closely we will not realize what we see is not real. Perception of life is very important, how we see things tells us what is going on around us. Perception for one person is different from anyone else. Although, poem 1 and poem 2, both express the perceptions of outsiders each poem uses different areas of perception to express the specific aspects of their belief. Dunbar and Owen write their poem’s about different aspects of a person’s life. Dunbar believes that a person’s inner trouble is oblivious to other people. On the other hand, Dunbar writes about the mental struggles of life. “We smile, but, O great Christ, our cries/ to thee from tortured souls arise.”(10-11) Where-as, Owen’s perspective covers more of the physical struggles of war. “Men marched asleep. Many had lost their boots/ but limped on, blood-shod. All went lame; All blind; / Drunk with fatigue; deaf even to the hoots/ of tired, outstripped Five-nines that dropped behind.”(5-8) “Why should the world be over-wise, / in counting all our tears and sighs? / Nay, let them only see us, while/ we wear the mask,” Dunbar states (6-9). At the same time, each author uses different writing styles in their poems. Owen write’s using many different similes. “Bent double, like old beggars under sacks...

Words: 667 - Pages: 3

Overshadowing Deception

...Books, analogous to an ocean, have a glassy surface. This seemingly simple facade gives few indications of the complexities that lie beneath; in both literature and the ocean, if one remembers to dive down a whole new world may be revealed. When reading through a book or play, many people do not delve beyond the surface, focusing only on prominent characteristics and dominant traits throughout the book. However, it is possible to find the deception behind each personality within a book if one analyzes the character's beyond their superficial facade. Since the beginning of time, humans have always stumbled on a boarder between appearance and reality, using deception to mask weaknesses and obscure the harsh eye of society. By examining A Street Car Named Desire by Tennessee Williams, Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing, and The Unabridged Journals Of Sylvia Plath by Sylvia Plath the deception humans use in order to appear stronger in society are revealed. In the play, A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams, there is a dominant theme of deception portrayed by the three main characters in the play. Stella Kowalski, Stanley Kowalski, and Blanche DuBois all have simple personalities that are extremely skewed by the end of the book. Stella states "I'm not in anything I want to get out of," (Williams, 74). This gives Blanche a huge reality check, because someone she adores has accepted such an average life, and has given up in her pursue for perfection, even if most of it...

Words: 1010 - Pages: 5

Disclosure and Deception

...Disclosure and Deception As the director of the Flight Rescue Operation, I would challenge myself to find the balance between what may appear as opposing philosophies, but actually can work in conjunction, to create the most productive protocol. I would instruct my staff to deliver truthful information to patients during transportation to the trauma unit.  However, I would also advise that the information during this critical time, to be focused on positive points. I believe this to be the most effective approach because of two primary reasons:  first, studies using placebos have shown the substantial effect that a person's emotions can have on their physical health. Thereby, keeping a patient's hopes alive could be essential to their rescue.  Secondly, the patient is not in a position to make productive decisions based on many details of their condition at this point; so to give what could be an overwhelming amount of information could be confusing or based on research, potentially harmful. First I’ll address the reason why keeping a patient’s hopes up is so important. Since the publication of Henry Beecher’s The Powerful Placebo in 1955, which brought the idea of this phenomenon to public attention, there have been many experiments conducted to test the placebo effect. A good deal of these experiments involved the consumption of alcohol and the effect it can have on our bodies. A specific example of such an experiment would be one conducted by Seema Assefi and...

Words: 998 - Pages: 4

Deception in Research

...Why is deception a controversial issue in psychological research Deception is defined as the provision of information that actively misled research subjects about particular aspects of the study being undertaken, ( as in Hertwig & Ortmann, 2008). This is a technique that has widely been applied by psychological researchers to collect information about human social behavior, justification given is that the research participant if given full disclosure may alter their behavior, and researchers end up with unreliable deductions and conclusions. Scientific researchers claim that not acquinting the research participants with full facts about the experiment does not constitute intentional deception, (Hertwig & Ortmann, 2008), since this prevents them from inferring the hypothesis being tested for and reduces bias in the study. The approach of deception infringes on one of the most important aspects of research, which has been the source of controversy for a quite sometime, it is participants informed consent. According to the American Pychological Association code of conduct states that it is imparative that the potential research participant be given information about the particulars of the research such as the kind of procedures that may be used and what is expected of them during the course of the research and whether they will be exposed to danger or not. This information gives the participant to make an informed decision whether to participate or not in the...

Words: 673 - Pages: 3

Deception

...What is deception? Deceptions are acts to circulate beliefs that are not true, or not the whole truth. Deception can involve dissimulation, propaganda, and skills of hand, as well as disruption, disguise, or concealment. Sources of Deception: Deception includes several types of connections or blunders that serve to twist or exclude the complete truth. Deception itself is purposely managing spoken and/or nonverbal communication so that the message receiver will believe in a way that the message sender knows is false. Objective is significant with regard to deception. Objective differentiates between deception and an honest mistake. I am going to write on the deceptive measure caused by skills i.e. Magic, taking an example of Mr. John Mulholland, the well-known magician, was displaying his fascinating mastery of sleight of hand before an audience of college professors and students. He picked up a coin with his left hand, placed it in his right, and then opened his hand slowly. The coin had vanished. Suddenly a book flew through the air, narrowly missing the performer's head. An embarrassed professor arose from his seat and quickly apologized. This natural and aggressive reaction to being deceived took place because the audience did not comprehend, and therefore could not enjoy, a basic problem of audience watching Magic or Magician. Since all tricks occupy the same basic methods, People should know who they actually are. Not only will your enjoyment in observing magical...

Words: 734 - Pages: 3

Psychology of Deception

...In our everyday lives, we, as a species, are deceitful. There are many reasons why we lie, whether it is to protect ourselves, protect someone we love, to escape an uncomfortable experience, for the thrill of it, or due to a disorder. In every aspect of our lives, and from every angle, deceptive stimuli bombards our nervous system and keeps our brains constantly at work to weed out the information that is correct from the information that is false. Advertisements, our parents, our children, friends, and siblings, those who we have more intimate relationships with, and even ourselves, deceive us, just as we are deceitful to them. There are many degrees to lying, varying from little white lies, to blatant deception and perjury. The motives and desired outcomes of those who lie vary greatly from person to person, as well as the degree to which they lie. Most people would agree that there are times when it is acceptable to tell white lies or even a bigger lie for the greater good, if the truth is not something of importance. I will discuss several facets of deception. To start, I will describe several types of lies and give definitions and examples of them. Then, I will talk about some facts about the frequency at which we are deceptive on an average day, and situations in which we generally increase or decrease how deceptive we are. Next, I will discuss why lies are prevalent in relationships, and how deception creates friction in the workplace. After that, I will...

Words: 4300 - Pages: 18

Time Deception

...|Caranto, Denise Nadine A. |Section R25 |SHORT PAPER 1 | TIME DECEPTION: A Close Reading of the Short Story “Maria Dos Prazeres” Maria Dos Prazeres started preparing everything for her funeral, convinced that she, before Christmas, will be one with the earth. She wanted her resting place to be flood-free, and if possible, in the shade of trees in summer, and where she won’t be pulled out and thrown away after a certain period of time. She also wanted it to be far and unfamiliar, for she remembered from her childhood, a time, when flood came and she saw broken coffins floating along with pieces of rags and hairs of the dead in the courtyard of her house.  Nevertheless, this story is not just about a typical old woman who desires a perfect funeral.  It is about the conflict present in human nature- cowardice versus confidence, past versus present and future. Maria was living in the Catalonia for over fifty years already, but she “knew no one in the building” except for a couple residing at the building opposite hers. “Knew no one” suggests that Maria does not like to interact with strangers. Only in the latter part of the story, when a “stranger” gave her a ride home, did she learn how to entertain “strangers”. Though it might seem ironic, that Maria, who seems to be unashamed of her job in her past life, exclaiming “I am a whore, my boy” , was actually too coward to step out of her comfort...

Words: 1371 - Pages: 6

Diagnostic Deception

...Diagnostic Deception In the past 10 years, the United States has been experiencing a medical epidemic of frightening proportion, taking place primarily in children. Cases of a psychiatric deficiency known as Attention Deficit Disorder, or “ADD,” have been popping up in young kids and teenagers all over the country. What’s causing this? The American Psychiatric Association, often referred to as the “APA,” claims that the disorder has always been this prevalent, but it was only recently discovered, hence the increasing number of diagnoses, but there seems to be more to this “disorder” than meets the eye. As the number of cases continues to grow, many believe that the number of people with ADD is actually unchanging, and is in fact, zero. While the APA would like you to think otherwise, ADD and ADHD are fictitious disorders. The cause for question in this conversation of the reality of Attention Deficit Disorder has many aspects. Of them, are the facts that ADD and ADHD are only recognized as psychiatric disorders in the United States of America, the suspicious timing of the entrance of these disorders into the APA’s psychiatric journal: the DSM, and the pharmaceutical industry’s role in treatment. These factors, some big, some small, build the often criticized argument against the authenticity of ADD and ADHD as mental disorders. The United States has been home to many unique and wonderful things, but rarely is any one country the sole victim of a disease, let alone...

Words: 1272 - Pages: 6

Deception

...Deception Debra Winger once said ''Most bad behavior comes from insecurity''.At some points in our lives, we are all overcome with insecurity in many different ways and our mind is full of self-defense mechanisms. Insecurity can sometimes turn us into someone we are not and make us act in a dismissive way. This essay will focus on two characters from two different proses; Blanche DuBois: a southern beauty from A Streetcar Named Desire and George Orwell: a sub-division office from Shooting an Elephant. Even though both characters differ in many different aspects such as background, upbringing, era, and class, both characters have something in common; their insecurities make them act in a negative way to compensate for their void. Each character expresses their insecurity differently; DuBois feels the need to act superior to others to mask her inadequacy, whilst Orwell feels the need to act against his better judgement to impress others. Although they are completly different characters, they both fear rejection and humilation by those surrounding them. Adding to that, their past experiences have impacted and influenced them into believing and acting in the way they do. Therefore, although both characters are extremely different in many ways, their insecurities and past experiences have caused them to act in negative and unpleasant ways. Blanche DuBois is supposedly a southern belle, representing delicacy, beauty, and innocence. However Blanche is anything but this. She...

Words: 1990 - Pages: 8

Deception

...“The interrogation is critical to any criminal investigation. A suspect might lie or tell the truth, they may be innocent or guilty. Interrogation is a high stakes game. Too much pressure and an innocent person might confess to a crime they didn’t commit.” National Geographic’s “Nothing but the Truth” This is a concept held by many to be the ultimate goal of interrogation. But, from research, deception is a common technique used by interrogators against the accused. In the Oxford Dictionary deceive is defined as deliberately causing someone to believe something that is not true, especially for personal gain. It is said to bring out the truth by using a lie, but is it really ethical? There are three types of false confessions: Voluntary false confessions are made without external pressure. Compliant false confessions happen when a suspect confesses to the crime just to get out of the interrogative situation. Internalised false confessions occur when the accused starts believing that they have committed the crime. In a criminal case documented by National Geographic’s, in 1988 a 12 year old girl was killed and police believed her 14 year old brother had killed her. The detective told him if he did not confess he would be tried as an adult and if he confessed he would get help. This was a lie. The detectives in a 10 hour interrogation finally led to him confessing to the crime. Luckily, DNA later revealed that he was innocent. There is a misconception amongst...

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Deception

...In William Shakepespeare’s tragedy Hamlet, deception is an essential part of the play. Hamlet, Claudius, and Polonius are deceitful. Hamlet uses his madness as a way for deception. He feigns his madness in order to gather information about Claudius. Claudius deceives everyone as he murdered his brother and took his spot on the throne. Claudius uses many people, most notably Guildenstern and Rosencrantz. He sends these two with Hamlet to assure he lands safely in England. In actuality these two are holding a letter for Hamlet’s execution. Polonius is extremely dishonest as he wishes his son Laertes the best as he departs for Paris. Then turns around and asks Reynaldo to watch and follow him. Polonius also deceives Hamlet as he has him meet with his mother in her room. During this meeting Polonius hides behind the tapestry. Trying to fool Hamlet and use deception to gain information. This leads to Polonius paying the ultimate price. Hamlet, Claudius, and Polonius all are deceiving and use deception. Deception in Hamlet revolves around Claudius murdering Hamlet Senior. The ghost of Hamlet Senior visits Hamlet telling him of Claudius’s horrible deed. Hamlet vows to seek revenge. Only he needs to figure out if the ghost is a figment of his imagination or if Claudius actually did it. Hamlet feigns madness and deceives everyone, through Hamlet’s deceitfulness he tries to gain substantial evidence on Claudius. With his madness he draws the attention away from his plot to kill...

Words: 1707 - Pages: 7

Leadership and Self Deception

...Leadership and Self-deception Getting Out of The Box Leadership and self-deception is a book written by the Arbinger Institute that explains to us how we as people can get stuck in a place or problem known as being “Inside the Box”. We can be stuck “Inside the Box” whether it is in our personal lives toward family members and friends or whether it is at work toward our Boss and other co-workers. Through a cleverly concocted story the author explains how we are either “Inside the Box” or “Outside the Box” and how to stay out of the box once we enter it. The story starts out telling us of a man named Ted who is impressed with a company called Zagrum and he would love to work for them and after multiple interviews and weeks of waiting he finally hears back and finds out that he gets the job. One of Teds first major meetings is with his soon to be boss Bud who asks him to meet him for a meeting that is seemingly so secret that nobody talks to him about it or gives any hints to what it is even about. Everyone seems to know what is going on except Ted. With much anticipation and waiting Ted is led to Buds office and waits nervously for his arrival. When Bud finally gets there he then informs Ted that “He has a problem” and while Ted wonders what that is Bud will soon enthusiastically explain the meaning of his problem and go into more specifics and detail that I’m sure Ted would care for or even expect. As Bud and Ted talk Bud is asking all sorts of seemingly strange and at...

Words: 1068 - Pages: 5

Interpersonal Deception Theory

...J West COM 230 Dr. Kosenko 7/13/12 Journal #1 The theory that I will be discussing in this first journal entry, will be the ‘Interpersonal Deception Theory’ written by David Buller and Judee Burgoon. The theory in a nutshell tries to breakdown the communicative relationship between two separate parties in a conversation, the sender and the receiver. The two writers attempt to make sense of the thought process that occurs when a deception is being conveyed between both the sender and the receiver. Buller and Burgoon state that interpersonal communication is interactive, and that strategic deception demands mental effort. The sender needs effort in order to make his deception/lie more convincing, while the receiver must put forth effort when trying to decipher whether or not the sender is being honest with them. Buller and Burgoon go on to discuss how the deceiver uses manipulating language, which is the way the sender delivers his message, and the control of their non-verbal cues which can give away their deception/lie. The theory suggests that the truth will almost always come out, due to the belief that there are always signs that the sender gives off, which allow the receiver to know that he or she is being lied to. The theory ends with the ‘truth bias’, the belief that people who know and like each other will be less likely to have any doubts on whether they are being told the truth or not, because of the “trust” that has been built. I think this theory is...

Words: 716 - Pages: 3