Free Essay

Deconstructing an Advert


Submitted By diane123
Words 1567
Pages 7
Here's what happens in the commercial:
The commercial begins with a burly, dark-haired and bearded guy in a nondescript brown shirt, brown jacket, and blue jeans sitting in a cluttered garage -- I call him Dave, because he totally reminds me of a friend from Eureka (in Humboldt County), named Dave. Dave from Eureka is of Hispanic descent, but Dave in the commercial I couldn't opine. From the vantage point of the opening frame, there's a motorcycle in front of Dave, and on the side wall, next to a cluttered bookshelf in the corner, is a large wallboard decorated with various knicknacks, including a large orange life preserver and one of those tacky mounted singing fish. After pausing the opening frame to get a closer look, I realized that there is an entire diving suit, helmet and all, slung in a very corpse-like manner atop the piece of furniture (perhaps a refigerator?) adjacent to the corner. Completing the scene, Dave has a McDonald's bag and drink at his side, and sandwich in hand. Indeed, Dave immediately chows down on the sandwich, at which point the shot changes to a closeup of the fish, which turns half its body towards the camera (which is what these wall-mounted singing fish do, after all), and begins singing:
In case you didn't catch that, the wall-fish then repeats the line as Dave just sits there kind of grooving along with the music, even chewing in rhythm to it. He does not appear at all surprised, and his expression could only be described as smug and self-satisfied. We have, in the two quick shots of Dave during this fish-chorus, a point of view from the direction the fish would be looking, and now we can see that Dave is sitting on the end of a workout bench, with a barbell on the equipment's rack behind him, and a cabinet behind that topped by a stereo.
As the fish finishes repeating the chorus, another bearded guy enters the scene -- I call this one Bob, because he looks like a Bob (although he bears a passing resemblence, as well, to Graham Chapman as he appeared in Monty Python's Life of Brian). Bob is tall and looks solid enough, but much less burly than Dave. He has sandy brown hair and an everyman's plaid shirt, and is carrying a fairly sizable drill which he holds up as he enters with the unmistakeable body language which conveys, "hey, here's your big drill I borrowed." To Bob's shock, as he stops right next to the fish and raises the drill a bit to again show that he has it, the wall-mounted fish sets forth on the following exposition of his sad situation:
What if it were you, Hanging up on this wall?
Over the course of this verse, Bob's expression tracks him as he first takes notice of Dave smugly, almost happily watching the fish sing while he eats the sandwich, then a wide-eyed Bob slowly turns to stare in bewilderment at the fish. Bob's eyes turn back to Dave, as if to gauge Dave's response. Dave, never taking his eyes off the singing fish, shrugs. Then we cut to a money shot of the product (which doesn't look appetizing to me at all, though it certainly fills the screen -- a square breaded fish patty topped with a slice of cheese on a typical hamburger bun, with a dollop of sauce getting squeezed out from under the bun. A few more product shots -- the "flakiness" of the fish as the patty (sans bun and toppings) is snapped in half (who eats it like that?); fries; cola being poured over ice; the McDonald's logo, and then a parting shot of that singing fish.
First, the fish hanging on the wall, although apparently disembowled and otherwise relieved of its bodily substance, is gifted as well with consciousness, sentience, and intelligence sufficient to facilitate communication. However, it appears to be not quite intelligent enough to have a rational grasp of its situation. What is the point of demanding that the "fish" in the sandwich be given back to it? Even if it were returned, it's been processed and cooked. There is no hope for a restoration to a normal state of fishy being. Perhaps the fish is a follower of the belief expressed in certain Native American cultures, that the eating of an animal enables the eater to capture some aspect of the spirit of such animal.... maybe the fish just wants to eat the sandwich in order to get its own spirit back. Maybe the fish is stupid, and just doesn't know that this sandwich can't be it.
This brings up the next point -- an illusion which the ad gamely attempts to create is that the fish in any given filet-of fish sandwich comes from one single fish, rather than being a mongrel of whatever was available that day. Surely Dave isn't sitting there eating a fish sandwich which he personally made from scratch. He's eating one from a McDonald's bag, complete with a McDonald's drink, so unless he happens to work at McDonald's and to have made the sandwich himself (or to have brought the actual fish to a McDonald's and had them make the sandwich from it), it's hard to see how the fish on his wall could have ended up in that particular sandwich (or more exactly, how that particular sandwich could contain any of that fish on the wall).
Dave's reaction to the singing fish is even creepier. No surprise, just a sadistic sort of contentment, the kind which tells you, "yep, I'm devouring your flesh and there ain't nothing you can do about it. Oh, and you taste gooood."
There's a perverse cunnilingus joke yearning to break free from that setup, but I'm not going there.
But this does bring to mind the cartoons of our youth which often featured intelligent, sentient creatures trying to consume other intelligent, sentient creatures. Tom hunting Jerry; Sylvester desiring to eat Tweety; Gargamel hungering for Smurf stew (until he decided to make gold from them instead).
Religion and commerce:
There's even a religious angle here -- the commercial was put together with an eye towards Lent, the mostly-Catholic practice in which the observant give up certain treats, include meat on Fridays, for a 40-day stretch. Fish is still allowed, and due to some ecumenical loophole, this includes crappy fast food fish. A USA Today article relating this information notes, "McDonald's sells about 300 million fish sandwiches annually, 25% during the 40-day Lenten period before Easter Sunday."
The article, by the way, identifies the actors for what its worth, with Ray Conchado (guess he's Hispanic after all!) playing "the guy who shrugs off the singing fish" (Dave), and JR Reed as "the friend surprised to see a fish singing when he walks into the garage" (Bob). Turns out that "Bob" was in Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny -- well way to go, Bob! They even tell us that the sandwich itself is cod and pollock, but the fish in the commercial is modeled on the pollock because the cod "looked too scary." Okaaaay then....
(I'm told, now, that these sandwiches are "made predominantly from hoki, a gnarly, crazy-eyed fish found in the cold waters off the coast of New Zealand," which McDonald's bought up to 15 million pounds of per year -- until the New Zealand government cut the allowable catch to prevent a population collapse, prompting the add-in of other species.) The article informs us as well that the actors don't speak because they needed to do the commercial in English and Spanish, and apparently only dubbing the fish is the easier way to go. I don't buy it. As a Californian, I know that it's so they don't have to pay the actors scale for speaking parts.
So here we have it -- a self-aware piscene corpse pleading for the restoration of its flesh, and an unconcerned possible eater-of-sentient-beings taking joy in the anguish of the beast. And that is supposed to compel you to find this product appetizing. Maybe that's the real message which McDonald's is trying to send here, "come taste the forbidden fruit of the flesh of a thinking creature," the closest we can get to true fast-food cannibalism.
There is by the way a somewhat satisfactory alternative explanation for the events in the commercial, which is that this is a practical joke which Dave is springing on Bob -- that is, Dave set up the electronic talking fish to be triggered by its motion sensor to sing that particular message whenever someone walked by, and then sat there with a filet of fish sandwich until Bob came along. Thus, Dave would freak Bob out by creating the appearance of a self-aware and justifiably displeased wall-mounted fish. Which would as well explain Dave's smug mirth at Bob's obvious discombobulation in the presence of the spectacle. But a close review of the ad shows no one at all around the fish to trigger its singing, nothing to explain that effect except Dave's sandwich-eating act. Maybe Dave just saw Bob coming and had a way to trigger the fish so that it would reach the critical verse when Bob get to that closest point to it.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Deconstructing of Two Soap Adverts Waterloo Road and Top Boy

...Deconstructing of two soap adverts Waterloo road and Top Boy Task 1 In this task I will be researching the structures and techniques of television advertisement. I will be talking about the key structures and characterise of the product. Also how they attract the audience by using different media techniques. The advert choice I have chosen for this task is waterloo road which has been TV series for a very long time, and has built a reputation for being a really goon TV series. Waterloo Road Waterloo road is a British television drama series that is based in the north of London near Manchester in Rochdale, England. It was first broadcasted on the 9th March 2006 on BBC one. It is very troubled school with so many different things happening within the school or outside of the school. The series focuses on the lives of the school teachers and students and confronts social issues like extramarital affairs, abortions, divorce, child abuse, and suicide. I will be deconstructing the last advert for waterloo road with Kyle stack. Waterloo road endorses celebrity endorsement this is when they use celebrities to try and boost there ratings and waterloo road did this by using Britain’s got talent winner George Sampson. By adding this one celebrity the producers of waterloo road knew that it would boots their ratings and gain more of an audience but the audience will be people who know George Sampson from BGT (Britain got talent). This also helps the celebrity boast their...

Words: 2212 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay


...DESK RESEARCH TO EXAMINE THE INFLUENCE OF MARKETING AND ADVERTISING BY THE ALCOHOL INDUSTRY ON YOUNG PEOPLE’S ALCOHOL CONSUMPTION Research prepared for the World Health Organization by the Centre for Social Marketing at the University of Strathclyde Emma Cooke, Gerard Hastings and Susan Anderson March 2002 Acknowledgements For acquisition and translation of international data: Jill Bain, Marina Biniari, Liliana Carcamo and Ingrid Kajzer. For comments on the final draft: Anne Marie MacKintosh For administrative support: Kathryn Angus and Aileen Paton. CONTENTS Page No 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1 2.0 MANAGEMENT SUMMARY 2 3.0 METHODOLOGY 4 4.0 RESULTS 7 4.1 Advertising 7 4.1.1 Econometric Studies 7 4.1.2 Consumer Studies 11 4.2 Other Forms of Marketing 15 4.3 Developing and Transitional Countries 21 REFERENCES 25 1.0 INTRODUCTION At the World Health Organization Ministerial Conference on Young People and Alcohol in Stockholm (February 2001) considerable concern was expressed about the nature and pervasiveness of advertising and marketing by the alcohol industry. Explicit examples were shown of alcohol promotion exploiting the themes of sexual, sporting and lifestyle success, often in direct violation of advertising codes. Furthermore, many of the advertising examples displayed images of excessive consumption. In addition, the Conference noted...

Words: 16650 - Pages: 67

Free Essay

Diversity Management

...Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal Managing complexity: using ambivalence and contingency to support diversity in organizations Iris Koall Article information: Downloaded by Roehampton University At 03:40 24 January 2016 (PT) To cite this document: Iris Koall, (2011),"Managing complexity: using ambivalence and contingency to support diversity in organizations", Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal, Vol. 30 Iss 7 pp. 572 - 588 Permanent link to this document: Downloaded on: 24 January 2016, At: 03:40 (PT) References: this document contains references to 76 other documents. To copy this document: The fulltext of this document has been downloaded 2271 times since 2011* Users who downloaded this article also downloaded: Christina Schwabenland, Frances Tomlinson, (2008),"Managing diversity or diversifying management?", Critical perspectives on international business, Vol. 4 Iss 2/3 pp. 320-333 http:// Charbel Jose Chiappetta Jabbour, Fernanda Serotini Gordono, Jorge Henrique Caldeira de Oliveira, Jose Carlos Martinez, Rosane Aparecida Gomes Battistelle, (2011),"Diversity management: Challenges, benefits, and the role of human resource management in Brazilian organizations", Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal, Vol. 30 Iss 1 pp. 58-74 ...

Words: 8827 - Pages: 36

Premium Essay

M and M

...CONTENTS Sl No Description Page No 1. Acknowledgement 2 2. What is meant by Advertisement 4 3. What is Ethics? 5-7 4. Ethics of Advertisement : Introduction 8-9 5. Ethics & Advertising 10-17 6. Ethics of Advertising 18-21 7. Some Ethical & Moral principles 22-26 8. The Ethics of Behavioral Advertisement 27-30 9. Attention, But at What Cost! 31-38 10. Benefits of Ethical Advertising 39-42 11. Harm done by Unethical Advertising 43-48 12. Conclusion 49 13. Bibliography 50 What do you mean by advertisement? Advertising is a form of communication that typically attempts to persuade potential customers to purchase or to consume more of a particular brand of product or service. “While now central to the contemporary global economy and the reproduction of global production networks, it is only quite recently that advertising has been more than a marginal influence on patterns of sales and production. The formation of modern advertising was intimately bound up with the emergence of new forms of monopoly capitalism around the end of the 19th and beginning of the 20th century as one element in corporate strategies to create, organize and where possible control markets, especially for mass produced consumer goods. Mass production necessitated mass consumption, and this in turn required a certain homogenization of consumer tastes for final products. At its limit, this involved seeking to create ‘world cultural convergence’, to homogenize consumer tastes and engineer a ‘convergence...

Words: 11766 - Pages: 48