Premium Essay

Deconstructing Deconstructionism

In: English and Literature

Submitted By thelostway
Words 394
Pages 2
We’ve all heard the old saying “You can’t judge a book by its cover.” In the essay “Sherlock Holmes and the Adventure of the Dancing Men and Women” by Alastair Fowler it is a case of “you can’t always judge an essay by its title.” Given the fact that the title of the actual story is “The Dancing Men”, we can logically deduce that Fowler’s essay is likely to be feminist in nature. Just because logic leads us to that conclusion does not mean it is the correct conclusion. Very early in the essay, we can see clear evidence that Fowler’s analysis of the story is in fact from a deconstructionist angle. Fowler dissects Conan Doyle’s stories of Sherlock Holmes from more than one vantage point in an attempt to classify exactly what genre it is a part of. While he is correct in pointing out some similarities and parallels to Poe, perhaps more revealing about his views are the differences he points out that make Holmes stories rather unique from the rest of detective fiction. “Detective fiction generally involves two interpretative activities, the detective’s investigation and the reader’s attempts (hampered by narrative subterfuges) at the same problem. But Conan Doyle commonly has at least three investigations, since the narrator, Watson, also takes a hand (not all visible); sometimes with more success than the reader, but always with less than Holmes.” (P. 354) Fowler has broken down and very nicely summarized Conan Doyle’s incredibly helpful use of a supporting character narrator. By unpacking this one step further, we can see that instead of just a main character zipping through a mystery leaving us readers in his or her wake to continually be wondering what is going on, the use of Watson as the narrator acts as a lens. Watson is a sort of middle ground, or mediator, between us and Holmes that allows us to keep up at a slightly accelerated pace while still not

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Family Counseling Approach: Narrative Counseling

...Abstract Through narrative therapy a counselor can help clients gain access to preferred story lines about their lives and identities taking the place of previous negative and self-defeating narratives that destroy the self. Presented in this paper, is an overview of the Narrative therapy and the Social Construction Model and several facets of this approach including poststrucuralism, deconstructionism, self-narratives, cultural narratives, therapeutic conversations, ceremonies, letters and leagues. A personal integration of faith in this family counseling approach is presented and discussed also in this paper. NARUMI AMADOR’S FAMILY CONSELING APPROACH Introduction Narrative therapy is found under the Social Construction Model. Using the Narrative approach, the therapist will not be the central figure in the therapeutic process, instead he will be influential to the client, helping him/her internalize and create new stories within themselves to draw new and healthier assumptions about who they are. This process enables clients to distract from focusing on the negative narratives which defined their past, redefining their lives into future positive stories. Narrative therapists define the problem as the problem instead of defining the client as the problem. The therapy process begins redefining the problem, externalizing it and getting it out in the open. The narrative therapist uses the questioning technique and creates alternative narratives...

Words: 3218 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Master

...The Representation of Gender in Virginia Woolf’s Orlando and Jeffrey Eugenides’s Middlesex by Marte Rognstad A Thesis Presented to The Department of Literature, Area Studies and European Languages University of Oslo In Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the MA Degree Spring Term 2012 Marte Rognstad The Representation of Gender in Virginia Woolf’s Orlando and Jeffrey Eugenides’s Middlesex Marte Rognstad http://www.duo.uio.no Trykk: Reprosentralen, Universitetet i Oslo Abstract This thesis presents an exploration of the representation of gender in Virginia Woolf’s Orlando and Jeffrey Eugenides’s Middlesex mainly in light of the theories of Judith Butler. The focus will be on how the two novels challenge the traditional concept of gender and gender categories, and in what ways the novels can give us new perspectives on the concept of gender. The theoretical focus will be on Judith Butler, more precisely her idea of gender as performance, and her deconstructionist approach to identity categories. I will present Butler’s proposal for a “new feminist genealogy,” and through my investigation of the representation of gender in Orlando and Middlesex I will show how both novels take on a “Butlerian” understanding of the concept of gender. By looking at various issues related to gender explored in the two novels, and pointing to similarities and differences between the two works, I hope to show how the protagonists, Orlando and Cal/lie, break down and transcend the fraught...

Words: 37487 - Pages: 150

Free Essay

Economic Geography

...ECONOMIC GEOGRAPHY Y U K O A O YA M A J A M E S T. M U R P H Y SUSAN HANSON KEY CONCEPTS IN key concepts in economic geography The Key Concepts in Human Geography series is intended to provide a set of companion texts for the core fields of the discipline. To date, students and academics have been relatively poorly served with regards to detailed discussions of the key concepts that geographers use to think about and understand the world. Dictionary entries are usually terse and restricted in their depth of explanation. Student textbooks tend to provide broad overviews of particular topics or the philosophy of Human Geography, but rarely provide a detailed overview of particular concepts, their premises, development over time and empirical use. Research monographs most often focus on particular issues and a limited number of concepts at a very advanced level, so do not offer an expansive and accessible overview of the variety of concepts in use within a subdiscipline. The Key Concepts in Human Geography series seeks to fill this gap, providing detailed description and discussion of the concepts that are at the heart of theoretical and empirical research in contemporary Human Geography. Each book consists of an introductory chapter that outlines the major conceptual developments over time along with approximately twenty-five entries on the core concepts that constitute the theoretical toolkit of geographers working within a specific subdiscipline. Each entry provides...

Words: 94626 - Pages: 379