Free Essay

Democracy in Ancient Greece

In: Historical Events

Submitted By procrastinator
Words 749
Pages 3
“Ancient Greece had the perfect democracy”
Ancient Greece did not have a perfect democracy. They established the roots of democracy and most of their ideas were accurate, but it was still quite far from perfect. Their system showed signs of racism, sexism, imperialism and corruption.
In ancient Greece, women, the poor, slaves, and tax defaulters were not allowed to vote as they were not considered citizens. Neither were those who didn’t have citizen parentage on both sides. Only Athenian males above the age of 18 had the right to vote. Even though the status of women was lower in Athens than it was in many Greek cities, women were still not able to vote anywhere. This is extremely sexist, as gender should not change someone’s rights and the way they are perceived. These days slavery is considered illegal in most countries, however in ancient Greece, it was acceptable to have slaves working for you. A key part in modern day democracy is the right to vote for everyone, including women, tax defaulters and the poor. It can easily be said that their politics were more like an exclusive gentleman’s club then a democracy. Ancient Greek democracy can be described as being minoritarian, where a minority of the population (e.g. the male population) is eligible to a certain degree of dominance in society and has the right to make decisions that affect the entire society. Equality and freedom are both valued concepts of democracy, and if these concepts were not in place in ancient Greece, then it cannot be said that Greece had a perfect democracy. |
Ancient Greece had a direct democracy, which was time consuming and not very efficient. In Australia, we currently have a representative democracy with regular elections to limit corruption and give people a fresh perspective on things. In ancient Greece, out of around 250,000-300,000 people only 500 names were chosen to become part of the boule, also known as the Council of Five Hundred, each year. Candidates were selected by lot and assigned responsibilities in an unplanned manner, causing problems as not all who we were chosen were proficient enough to handle certain tasks. It was a very crude way of selecting people. Also, wealthy, influential people and their relatives had a tendency to serve the Council more frequently than would be likely in a purely random lottery. Ancient democracy was rough, chaotic and easily seized by exploiters and demagogues. This shows that Ancient Greece’s democracy was quite unsophisticated and impractical, and corruption was not unknown to happen.
Greece’s role in the making of democracy has often been exaggerated. Their power was not a result of having a government supported by citizens; rather it was a result of military triumphs and wealth earned by trade. The main principle of ancient Greece’s system was that every citizen should fully participate in political, military and civic life. You weren’t able to be an onlooker, you had to be involved. Some might deny Greece’s government being overtly imperialistic; however the citizens were compelled to vote. This wasn’t always a good idea as not every citizen would understand all of the concepts discussed and involved. Pericles, a famous leader of ancient Athens, has stated that “[the ancient Greeks] do not say that a man who takes no interest in politics is a man who minds his own business; [they] say that he has no business here at all”. From this, it can be seen that politics was very important in ancient Greece, and that the Greeks didn’t approve of citizens not being interested in politics. Swiss historians have also described Athens’ democracy as being “permanent terrorism” of their citizens, who were constantly exposed to a threat of public prosecution, especially for misuse of public funds and incompetence.
It cannot be said that ancient Greece had the perfect democracy as there were still many faults in their system. Firstly, only a small quantity of the male population had the right to make important decisions for the whole of society, showing that their democracy was both sexist and racist. Secondly, not everyone chosen for the Council was competent enough for their job and some were not chosen fairly. This shows that their system was ingenuous and corrupted. Thirdly, as a citizen, you were not given a choice whether you wanted to take part in the political, military or civic running of Greece. Here we are shown an imperialistic and authoritarian side of ancient Greek democracy.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Culture of Early Civilization

...in the early 19th century emphasized Greece as the Mother of Rome which, in turn, shifted interest to Grecian models. The style is an adaptation of the classic Greek temple front employing details of Doric, Ionic or Corinthian order To the popular mind the Greek temple was associated with the origins of American democracy in ancient Greece. Greece's involvement in a war for independence (1821-30) aroused much sympathy in the newly independent United States. Further, the War of 1812 fought against England diminished American affection for British influence, including the still dominant Adam ("Federal" in U.S.) style in domestic architecture. The popularity of Greek Revival led it to be called the National Style. Newly established towns throughout the country even took names such as Athens, Sparta, and Ithaca. Identifying features: * Most have porticos (either entry or full-width) supported by prominent square or rounded columns, typically of Doric style, but also Ionic and Corinthian * Gabled or hipped roof of low pitch * Cornice line of main roof and porch roofs emphasized with wide band of trim (this represents the classical entablature and is usually divided into two parts: the frieze above and architrave below) * Enormous windows and doors * Front door surrounded by narrow sidelights and a rectangular line of transom lights above, door and lights usually incorporated into more elaborate door surround (ancient Greek structures did not use arches) ...

Words: 3346 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Prospectus

...this because I am minoring in Philosophy. Greece is important to Philosophy because many great thinkers such as Pythagoras and Socrates were “Greek” thinkers. So more or less, I chose Greece for a personal educational gain rather than just some random society to write a research paper on. World historians and readers alike should be interested in this research because from Greece came the father of Western Philosophy, which is the backbone of what is taught in Western academia and really had a huge impact to the world, as we know it. With Philosophy comes questions, with questions come many great answers that impact societies and even the earth. I want to study how Greece’s political economy impacted philosophic thinkers and people alike. In order to help readers understand whether or not outside forces like society’s political economy impacts deeper thinking like philosophy I will dive deep into Athenian Democracy, documents certain philosophers wrote in the day and time in which they lived, and even look into some other people of the time who had strong opinions on what exactly was going on them. Philosophy impacted more than most people think and I am sure in my research I will be able to back that up with primary sources to prove my argument. In writing this research paper I will be exploring the political economy of Classical Greece between 510 – 323 BCE. In addition, the geographic region I will be diving into will be Athens, Greece. I chose this mainly to enlighten myself...

Words: 954 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Ancient Greek Civilization

...The Ancient Greek Civilization Can you imagine 7,000 Spartans holding off 150,000 Persians at the Battle of Thermopylae? It is true. The Ancient Greeks held off one of the most powerful armies of that time so Greece would survive. Greek geography, the city-states, the concept of acropolis, government, military strategy, philosophy, and religion were all contributing factors in the creation and survival of the Greek city-state lifestyle. The geography and climate of Ancient Greece influenced the development of Greek civilization. Mountains separated Greece into regions where the Ancient Greeks settled and formed separate city-states and types of government. The mountains and the peninsula of Ancient Greece isolated Greek society from other city-states and also helped to keep them safe from enemy attack. Transportation over the rocky land was difficult, much of the land was not suitable for farming, and there were limited natural resources. The lack of natural resources and the difficulty of traveling by land caused the Ancient Greeks to depend more on the sea. Ancient Greece was surrounded by the Mediterranean Sea on three sides. Much of the land of Ancient Greece was linked by the sea and the sea also linked Ancient Greece to other societies. The Ancient Greeks became skilled sailors, fishermen, and tradesmen. The climate of Ancient Greece was moderate all year long and there was adequate rainfall. Due to the mild climate, Greek men spent much of...

Words: 2101 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Ancient Egypt Vs Greek Government

...governing that helps keep everyone from getting out of control. Different ways to handle that have been used back in ancient times. Take Ancient Egypt and Ancient Greece for example, they both had ways, including the types of governing and their military force. The Greeks and Egyptians both had problems with keeping their civilization in line, and their solutions to their problem were both similar and different. One solution the Greek had for keeping their civilization in line included having a...

Words: 1030 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Ancient Egyptian Government: Theocratic Monarchy

...The Ancient Egyptian Government valued their gods and brought order to their civilization using their religion and the government itself. This system that the Ancient Egyptians used is what we now call a theocratic monarchy. Firstly, how does this policy work? A theocratic monarchy is a government system where the king rules by the command of the gods, in this case, the king being the Pharaoh. Religion and the government were woven tightly together for the Ancient Egyptians, and they believed that the Pharaoh was the representative of the gods, and at one point in time, was also believed as a god in human form. Since they believed that the Pharaoh had some kind of bond with the gods, they gave him, or even her, numerous responsibilities. Secondly, the social hierarchy of Ancient Egypt brought stability to their civilization because of how each level of the social hierarchy worked together. Starting at the very top of the social hierarchy, the different levels consisted of the Pharaoh, viziers and high priests, royal overseers, district governors, scribes, and finally, artisans, farmers, and labourers(See Fig....

Words: 766 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Democracy: Alive in America

...Democracy: Alive in America? Everyone is nervously awaiting the final decision of the year 2000 Presidential election with George W. Bush and Al A. Gore running closely side by side. There was debate in the legitimacy of the electoral votes cast in Florida earlier in time, so the suspense rising in America’s final decision is enormous. Looks like Gore holds this trophy for popular votes with a close 543,895 votes winning over Bush. According to previous elections, Gore has this competition conquered, the results come in; George W. Bush is our new president! With a slim win by 5 electoral votes, Bush is our new president. Wait a second, popular vote is that not the votes of qualified voters of the population? In America today, political decisions are decided democratically by its residents. Although Al Gore won the popular vote, George Bush is still the decided president. Then what is democracy, where did it come from, is our current democratic society a progression or is it a regression of democracy’s evolution? America has a government decided by the population of America; at least that is of the idea of a democratic society. Let us then compare American democracy to where democracy was created. The reason why everyone votes is to make a unanimous decision of who will become the leaders of a country. Democracy is just that, a government where the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation...

Words: 1413 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Greek Influence on the Western World

...GREEK CIVILIZATION The ancient Greek civilization has influenced the western world in many different ways. Greece influenced, science, democracy, art, and philosophy. A lot of what the ancient Greeks have discovered and learned is still used today in the western world. The sciences in ancient Greece have influenced the western world. Beginning with Thales of Miletus who lived approximately from 640-610 to 548-545 BC. Thales of Miletus brought Phoenician navigational techniques into Miletus. Thales also had revised the calendar. Using Babylonian mathematical knowledge he used geometry to solve problems like calculating the height of pyramids and distances from a ship to the shore. He also studied astronomy in Babylonia, and predicted an eclipse of the sun. He is also credited with the discovery of the electrical properties of amber also known as “electron”. Pythagoras, who lived from 569 to 475 BC, he was a Greek philosopher and mathematician. He studied astronomy, logistics and geometry. He founded the Mystic Pythagorean Cult, devoted to the study of numbers. They found that numbers were the principle of all proportion, order, and harmony in the universe. Pythagoras also investigated the ratios of lengths corresponding to musical harmonies, and developed methods of geometric proof. The Pythagorean theorem was his great discovery in geometry. Pythagoreans were the first to consider the earth as a globe that revolved around other planets. He put a mathematical equation to...

Words: 1039 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cultural Diffusion In Ancient Greece

...it is evident that geographic factors promoted or hindered cultural diffusion. Cultural diffusion is the spread of ideas and beliefs from one cultural group to another. A geographic feature is a circumstance of a physical area that affects the way people live. The mountains in Ancient Greece served as a geographic feature that hindered cultural diffusion for Athens and Sparta. In Rome, the Italian peninsula promoted cultural diffusion. A mountain is a large landform that has a high elevation and is a geographic factor. Ancient Greece had many mountains which hindered cultural diffusion of different city-states. The ancient city-state Athens is well-known for its development in democracy and creating...

Words: 575 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Classical Greece Dbq

...The ideas and creations that continue to be used in modern society demonstrate how inspiring the Ancient Greeks were. Greece is a series of islands, known as an archipelago that contained a number of city- states, such as Athens and Sparta, and were ruled by Ephors. Greece has a very mountainous terrain, with only 20% of arable land. Greece also has irregular coastlines that enhance their ability to trade. The contributions of classical Greece benefit Western civilization greatly because of the creation of democracy, which provides citizens with a voice, and the philosophies taught by Socrates and Aristotle, which have shaped educational practices. Also, Euclid and other Greek mathematicians advanced dramatically in geometry, allowing for improvements...

Words: 1074 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How Did Greece Influence America Today

...Ancient Greek and Roman cultures were very powerful in their time. They were both formidable and powerful empires. They brought many ideas such as democracy to the world. Their influence can be felt even today. The United States are not exempt from this influence. Rome and Greece have influence America today in many ways such as government, architecture, medicine, and entertainment. American government is the easiest to see effect of Greece and Rome. Democracy was a critical part of Greece and Rome. Pericles strived for every citizen to participate in democracy, saying, “We do not say that a man who takes no interest in politics is a man who minds his own business; we say that he has no business here at all.” In their time and today,...

Words: 406 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Influence of Greece on Western Civilization

...The Influence of Ancient Greece on Western Civilization Of all the cultures that have come and gone throughout human history, it was the achievements of ancient Greece that have left the most indelible imprint on Western civilization. In particular, it was greek achievements in the realms of art, democracy, medicine, philosophy and literature that has influenced the modern world the most. It is interesting to note that the loss of Greek thought after Roman civilization inducted a period popularly characterized as the Dark Ages. During this time human life was, in words popularized by Thomas Hobbes, “nasty, brutish and short.” Superstition, disease and a short life span were the hallmark of the age. It is crucial to understand that the middle “dark” ages finally ended with the re-discovery of greek texts to usher in the re-birth of civilization, ie: the Renaissance. It was the Catholic theologian St. Thomas Aquinas that set Western civilization on its current track by reintroducing Greek thinkers to European intellectuals. The popularizing of Greek philosophers renewed Western interest in Greek achievements, specifically within the realms of art, democracy, medicine, literature, and philosophy. While some of these subjects remained underdeveloped in Greek times, such as the discipline of medicine and democracy, others were so advanced as to set a standard to this day in the realm of art, philosophy, and literature. Discussed herein is a brief exploration of those Greek achievements...

Words: 1702 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Major Events in Western History

...began to live in organized communities with distinct political, military, economic, and social structures” (Judith & Learner, 123-129). Basically, Western Civilization is rich and famous for its progressive development and constant changes in people`s lives. She appeared in ancient Greece and ancient Rome. The first stage of its development, known as "ancient civilization", was marked by the emergence of the core values ​​of Western-type society: the relations of private ownership, private production, market-oriented, the first “government by the people” – democracy, republican form of government. In the early times of Western Civilization the foundations of civil society to ensure individual rights and freedoms were established, as well as socio-cultural system of principles, the mobilization of creativity and development of the individuals (Judith & Learner, 130). There are many significant events that happened in Western Civilization and influenced today`s world, as some of them have significantly affected our modern lifestyle and undoubtedly changed our society. Nevertheless, I think the three major elements that happened in Western Civilization are: The Rise of Christianity, the appearance of Democracy, and the invention of the printing press. To start with, I strongly believe the Rise of Christianity is one of the most significant events that have ever happened in our world. In today`s world Christianity is thought to be the biggest religion, as about 2, 1 billion people...

Words: 2580 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Lincoln Memorial Dbq Analysis

...Ancient Greece and Ancient Rome are two very important parts when it comes to architecture in mostly Washington D.C. Just Imagine the Lincoln Memorial, the White House, or the Jefferson Memorial without its columns, it would not look that fantastic or official as it is right now. Those wonderful columns are all thanks to the builders and inventors in the classical period who also helped by creating other possessions like transportation or the form of Government we have. An example of the architecture from ancient times in the Georgia that we still have today is columns. My sister’s sorority house has, I think, ionic column, which I believe that it means that the building is very important to the students and teachers (OI). There are three types of columns, doric, ionic, and corinthian, in my opinion corinthian columns look the best. Today, people use columns for houses and mostly buildings that have a special authority like the Lincoln Memorial in Washington D.C. (Doc. 1). The Lincoln Memorial has Doric Columns, the Jefferson Memorial has Ionic Columns, and the Supreme Court has Corinthian Columns. At the end, without the Grecian people nothing would look that official or important....

Words: 494 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Did Greek Contribute To Society

...I think that Ancient Greece had the biggest contribution on society. It has brought us the Olympics, democracy, science, and art. Without most of these things Modern society would be very different then it is now. The Olympics is an event that shows up every 2 years. Including both the summer and winter Olympics. Originally the Olympics was first created to honor the Greek God Zeus. They were first held around early 700 B.C.. This has a big impact on society today because it is still being held. Today people watch the people for entertainment. It is also a place where countries compete in different games to see which is the best at each. Without the Olympics there wouldn’t be anywhere for athletes of different countries to compete against each other. Also the olympics has a big impact on the area it is held in. It helps cities get more tourism causing them to get a big economy boost. Without the Olympics there would be no economy boost and in areas...

Words: 584 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Pros And Cons Of Ancient Greek Government

...Greece is a rocky peninsula with lots of mountains. Few crops can grow in its stony soil. But Greece is surrounded by water, which is its greatest natural resource. Ancient Greeks depended on the sea for fishing and trade. As their population grew, ancient Greeks formed city-states. A city-state had a central city called a polis. Each city-state had its own form of government and laws. All the city-states shared a common language, religion, and way of life.Three kinds of government were common in the Greek city-states. In an oligarchy, a few powerful and wealthy people ruled. Other city-states were ruled by a single person who took control against the wishes of the people. This kind of government is called a tyranny. Some city-states were democracies....

Words: 303 - Pages: 2