Free Essay

Demsetz View vs Traditional View

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ksay2lzg
Words 2324
Pages 10
Numerous empirical studies have sought to evaluate the relationship between market structure and performance. The traditional structure-conduct-performance approach (SCP) alone seems hard to reconcile with the true development of the relationship. There are two main stream of hypothesis that studies the relationship between. On one hand, the collusion hypothesis, widely known as SCP (Bain, 1995), stipulates that as a result of market concentration which facilitates the collusion between firms of the industry, greater benefits like higher firm profits arise. On the other hand, Demsetz (1973) provide an alternative reasoning for the positive relationship between concentration and profitability. The efficient structure hypothesis suggests that market structure is dictated by the efficiency of the operating firms. The most efficient firms reap higher profitability and market share which eventually lead to higher market concentration. This review will present some literature findings which are either in favour of or against Demsetz view of efficiency hypothesis.

Efficient-structure hypothesis stipulates that bigger market share is the outcome of efficient operations of the firms. It is subdivided into two forms of hypothesis. Under X-efficiency hypothesis, firms with superior management or production processes operate at lower costs and eventually gain more profits. Following-on higher market shares may result in higher market concentration. On another hand, scale-efficiency hypothesis posits that firms have comparable management technology and production but operate at respective optimal levels of economies of scale. A company’s cost position relies upon its relative market share. The higher the relative market share, the lower the company’s unit costs are and the higher the profit margins.
Banks
The efficient-structure theory also includes two hypotheses – the X-efficiency and scale efficiency hypotheses. The X-efficiency hypothesis argues that banks with better management and practices control costs and raise profit, moving the bank closer to the best-practice, lowerbound cost curve. The scale-efficiency hypothesis argues some banks achieve better scale of operation and, thus, lower costs. Lower costs lead to higher profit and faster growth for the scale-efficient banks.

Demsetz
Demsetz (1973, 1974) : positive relationship between market concentration and profitability reflects the exercise of market power, then it should affect all firms equally.

According to the efficiency hypothesis, market share is the consequence of efficiency rather than its cause. Differences in profitability among firms are due to higher efficiency. Efficient firms obtain large market share and earn high profits induce a causal association between size and profitability. Firms offering products that offer customers greater value enjoy gains in market share. Better managed firms that have a competitive advantage grow faster than rival firms. Firms with superior skill and foresight gain market share through lower prices or through better products. Caves and Porter (1977) and Woo and Cooper (1981,1982) provide evidence that smaller-share competitors are equally or even more profitable than larger rivals. Efficiency

1. More efficient producers typically enjoy higher profits because they are able to charge lower prices and thus capture larger market shares and economic rents. There are two measures of efficiency, namely X-efficiency and scale efficiency which give rise to profitability. Large firms more profitable than small firms.

According to efficient hypothesis, banks attain higher profits by having efficiency in their superior management or large scale, cost reduction production technologies.
Berger (1995) devised a model that incorporates two forms of efficiency hypothesis and two forms of collusion hypothesis using data of bank over the 1980 to 1989 period. They use income statement data and individual bank balance sheet to approximate a frontier cost function to derive the assessment of efficiency .Profitability is measured using both return on assets and return on equity. Independent variables comprise of concentration measured by HH index, measures of efficiency effects on managerial aptitude and measures of effect on average cost of economies of scale. There is support for X-efficiency, not for scale-efficiency. Profitability is not related to concentration but positively related to market share.

Gale (1972) studies the effect of market share on the rate of return of selected firms operating in different market environments.

The table above demonstrates the effect of share and quality on relative direct costs (the estimated per-unit materials, production, and distribution costs of the business as a percentage of the costs of its competitors, with administrative and marketing expenses excluded). By altering 1 standard deviation in the share index, relative direct costs for both groups change by 1-2%. From the share/relative direct cost results he concludes that higher-share businesses tend to be more profitable largely due to having lower direct costs. This is in line with the X-efficiency hypothesis. http://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/antibull27&div=5&g_sent=1&collection=journals http://econpapers.repec.org/article/tprrestat/v_3a54_3ay_3a1972_3ai_3a4_3ap_3a412-23.htm

Using the PIMS database, Buzzell, Gale and Sultan (1975) study found a positive relationship between market share and profitability. The discovery from PIMS data is that a firm with a market share of 40 percent will reign a profit margin twice as high as the competitor 10 percent of the market (Simon 2010). Therefore, the strategic implication of these findings is that firms should strive to achieve a higher market share in order to reap the advantages of higher economies of scale and experience.
[Buzzell, R.D, B.T. Gale and R.G.M. Sultan (1975), Market Share – A Key to Profitability, Harvard Business Review, 53 (January – February), 97-106] https://hbr.org/1975/01/market-share-a-key-to-profitability/ar/1

2. Some paper support SCP which is not in line with Demsetz view. Collusion hypothesis stipulates concentration affects profitability as a result of market power. There is positive relationship between profitability and concentration, and no relationship between profitability and market share. Concentration ratio proxies collusion.

Using call report data from Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, Jeon and Miler (2005) study the relationship between several measures of bank concentration at the state level and average performance of banks within that state from 1976 to 2000. The average return on equity of all banks in the state is the profit measure. The % of assets held by the five largest and ten largest banks in a state along with Herfindahl-Hirschman index of concentration in each state and the District of Columbia are the three measures of concentration. They find a positive relationship between bank concentration in a state and the average return on equity within that state, even after tuning for economic environment within that state. Temporal causality tests infers that bank concentration causes bank profitability. http://digitalcommons.uconn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1066&context=econ_wpapers
In an analysis of statistics for a cross section of 32 four-digit food manufacturing industries for 1958, Collins and Preston (1966) concludes that average industry price-cost margins are positively correlated to the degree of concentration. The relationship are continuous and curvilinear. Initially, there is no systematic increases in price-cost margins as concentration rises in the lower ranges, however as concentration reaches above a certain level (in the 30 to 40% range for four firms) price-cost margins quickly picks up. http://www.jstor.org/stable/2097552?origin=JSTOR-pdf http://www.jstor.org/stable/2097552

Molyneux & Llyod-Williams (1994) conduct a study with respect to Spanish banking industry using pooled and annual data from year 1986–1988. The results generally support the traditional SCP hypothesis as justification for the market behaviour of Spanish banks. This proposes that the support of additional concentration in Spanish banking by government and Bank of Spain might unambiguously reduce the level of competition in the system and cannot be warranted on efficiency grounds. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0378426694900027 Concentration may be the result of the greater efficiency of major companies large firm has higher profits than small firms in the same concentrated industry The variation of profitability among large and small firms illustrates the role of efficiency in the positive structure-profit relationship.Large firms make higher returns due to their efficiency. 3. There is no relationship between concentration and profitability.
Lawrence & Anoop (1995) study the relationship between concentration and performance for largest European banks using the test developed in Berger and Hannan (1993) but with different approach. First, they estimate the deviations from a stochastic cost frontier under the assumption that errors are distributed half-normal. The error terms are then taken to obtain the measures of X-efficiency for each bank. The stochastic cost frontier is also used to retrieve measures of scale-inefficiency. They do not use data of individual bank branches or very insignificant banks. Hence, the expected signs of the coefficients in the estimation of Eq. (1) are as follows: X-EFFi > 0, S-EFFi > 0, CONC = 0 and MS = 0. More efficient firms will have higher profits and the signs of the coefficients of X-EFF, and S-EFFI should be positive. If net interest margin is used as the measure of performance, the signs of the efficiency measures should be negative because more efficient banks should be able to offer more attractive loan and deposit rates to customers. In spite of the competitive interest margins, banks will still generate larger profits than those that are operating inefficiently. Although efficiency leads to higher market shares and market concentration, the zero coefficients indicate that market structure has no direct effect on prices and profits. By using a model which incorporates efficiency directly, we assume the following: prices are set competitively and efficiency is a function of strictly lower costs and banks operating at efficient scale levels; and market structure variables CONC and MS have no relationship with profits conditional on efficiency (Berger and Hannan, 1993).

Demsetz (1973,1974) states that if the profitability of large firms in concentrated industries is greater than the profitability of small firms in concentrated industries, then the relationship between profitability and concentration is due to a relationship between efficiency and profitability. Using the data on 1963 US Internal Revenue Service data for 95 industries, he finds that the profitability of firms in size classes R1, R2 and R3 is not related to concentration. Nevertheless, for the largest size class, R4 profitability and concentration exhibits positive relationship.
Ravenscraft (1983) approaches the firm size issue indirectly by taking into account the relative effects of market share and concentration on profits. In an analysis of 1975 US Data for 3186 lines of business (LOB) in 258 Federal Trade Commission (FTC), price-cost margins are positively related to LOB market shares, nonetheless the opposite holds true for seller concentration. Ravenscraft conjectures that profit concentration relationship in industry regressions reveals the upper hand of large sellers reaping more profits relative to smaller competitors. Having higher returns to advertising and assets for sellers with more market shares, it reflects the positive market share-profit relationship.

4. There is positive relationship between market share and profitability where market share act as a proxy for efficiency/ When market share, concentration and profitability are regressed, market share will outweigh concentration.
Gale (1972) finds that high market share is associated with high rates of return and that the effect of share on profitability depends on other firm and industry characteristics. The bigger the firm or the more concentrated or moderate growth the competitive environment is, the greater the influence of share on profitability. http://www.jstor.org/stable/1924568
Smirlock (1985) models bank profitability as a function of market share, concentration and an interaction term between market share and concentration as well as several control variables for over 2700 unit state banks from time period 1973-1978. http://www.jstor.org/stable/1992507

The equation is estimated with market share (MS) as the only structural variable, that is, with the restriction a2 = a3 = 0 imposed. These results are reported in the middle three rows of Table 1. Across all profit rate meanings, the coefficient on market share is significant and positive at 1 percent level where the coefficient on concentration is negative, giving the control variables are in line with anticipations. The explanatory power of these equations beats those where concentration (CR) is the market structure variable. Once market share is accounted for properly, concentration means nothing to explaining bank profit rates. He finds that market share is positively related to profitability while there is no relationship between concentration and profitability.

Gale & Branch (1982) test the relationship between profitability, market share and concentration using data covering period from 1970 to 1979 in some cases and four years of data in most cases. ROI is the proxy for profitability index.

Although explanatory power of concentration is statistically significant at 99% level, its relation to ROI is very modest (R² of less than 2%). When market share and concentration are inputted concurrently, the concentration coefficient falls to insignificance and changes signs, whereas the share coefficient is still highly significant. An interaction term (the product of share and concentration) do not pass a significance test with or without concentration in the equation. Hence, market share variable greatly dominates concentration which has explanatory power of almost 20% against concentration which is less than 2%, and eventually reaches zero once share has explained what it can.

This review is centred on Demsetz view of efficient structure paradigm where several literature written by researchers who support the efficient structure model criticise the SCP model since the relationship between market share, concentration and efficiency is excluded.

Three recent studies, one of which used company-wide data 0 did, however, find a positive relationship between ROI and market share. B. Gale, "Market Share and the Rate of Return," Review of Economics and Statistics 54 (November 1972): 412-23; R. Buzzell, B. Gale, and G. Sultan, "Market Share-A Key to Profitability," Harvard Business Review 53 (January-February 1975): 97-106; R. Caves, B. Gale, and M. Porter, "Interfirm Profitability Differences: Comment," Quarterly Journal of Economics 91 (November 1977): 667-75.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Modern vs Contemporary View on "A Midsummernight's Dream"

...Modern vs Contemporary perspective on “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” At first glance, none of the characters in Shakespeare’s “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” seem to react out of the ordinary. Although the setting does seem a lot more favorable for men, a modern reader gets used to it quite quickly, since this is often the case in literature. However, when thinking and reading like a contemporary reader, the play appears in a whole new light. There are women in the play, which take the situation in their own hands and are making their own choices. A contemporary reader would have seen this agency that the women do possess much differently than we do today. Hermia is the prime example for a woman in the play with a lot of agency. Very shortly into the play, the standing of the women in society is clearly established. Theseus says: “What say you, Hermia? Be advised, fair maid. To you your father should be as a god, One that composed your beauties, yea, and one To whom you are but a form in wax By him imprinted, and within his power To leave the figure or disfigure it.” [1.1 46 – 1.1 51] Hermia is not enabled, by the men around her to make her own choices. She should clearly have no agency; the paternal law doesn’t allow her to. At the time, this was the way of the world and most societies at the time had some variation of this law. A reader back then would’ve thus just nodded in agreement and continued reading. Modern readers, however, don’t agree with this law. We’ve......

Words: 972 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Religious View

... The historical Jewish movements (Pharisses, Sadduccees, and Essenes) were responses to the Roman rule of Israel, while the major modern movements (Reform, Orthodox, and Conservative) are responses to the modern, secular culture of Europe and America. Jewish denominations differ from one another primarily with regard to practice. Orthodox Judaism is the most traditional expression of modern Judaism. Orthodox Jews believe the entire Torah - including "Written," the the Pentateuch, and "Oral," the Talmud) was given to Moses by God at Sinai and remains authoritative for modern life in its entirety.  Reform Judaism is the most liberal expression of Judaism. In America, Reform Judaism is organized under the Union for Reform Judaism (known as the Union of American Hebrew Congregations until 2003), whose mission is "to create and sustain vibrant Jewish congregations wherever Reform Jews live." About 1.5 million Jews in 900 synagogues are members of the Union for Reform Judaism.  Conservative Judaism may be said to be a moderate position between Orthodox and Reform Judaism. It seeks to conserve the traditional elements of Judaism, while allowing for modernization to a less radical extent than Reform Judaism. The teachings of Zacharias Frankel (1801-75) form the foundation of Conservative Judaism. Hasidic (or Chasidic) Judaism arose in 12th-century Germany as a mystical movement emphasizing asceticism and experience born out of love and humility before God. The austere...

Words: 2654 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Views

...pproaches to interpreting quantum theory have been further explored and developed,[7][8][9] becoming quite popular. MWI is one of many multiverse hypotheses in physics and philosophy. It is currently considered a mainstream interpretation along with the other decoherence interpretations, the Copenhagen interpretation,[10] and deterministic interpretations such as the Bohmian mechanics. Before many-worlds, reality had always been viewed as a single unfolding history. Many-worlds, however, views reality as a many-branched tree, wherein every possible quantum outcome is realised.[11] Many-worlds claims to reconcile the observation of non-deterministic events, such as the random radioactive decay, with the fully deterministic equations of quantum physics. In many-worlds, the subjective appearance of wavefunction collapse is explained by the mechanism of quantum decoherence, which resolves all of the correlation paradoxes of quantum theory, such as the EPR paradox[12][13] and Schrödinger's cat,[1] since every possible outcome of every event defines or exists in its own "history" or "world". In lay terms, the hypothesis states there is a very large–perhaps infinite[14]–number of universes, and everything that could possibly have happened in our past, but did not, has occurred in the past of some other universe or universes. Quantum mechanics Introduction Glossary · History Background Bra–ket notation Classical mechanics Hamiltonian Interference Old quantum theory Fundamental......

Words: 381 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Comparison of the Resource-Based vs Market-Based View Approaches to Competitive Strategy

...Compare and contrast the market-based approach and the resource-based view as approaches to competitive strategy. To what extent are they rival or complementary views? Competitive strategy, after Porter, came to be defined as the strategy of a business unit which seeks to achieve sustainable Competitive Advantage (SCA). The literature on strategy deems the market-based view (MBV) and the resource –based view (RBV) as two approaches to giving businesses the competitive edge they need to compete in their industries. Aside from having competitive advantage as their ultimate goal, the two approaches are also similar in the sense that they both make use of particular tools and models in their undertakings. They also differ in numerous ways, starting with their definitions, assumptions about the equilibrium of the market and the tools and models used. Nevertheless, despite their differences which may portray them as rivals, in practice the two approaches are rather complementary as the crux of this essay shall illustrate. By definition the market-based view is an outside in approach to competitive strategy; which as stated by D. Faulkner (2007) copes with competition through ‘astute market positioning’. In other words firms identify the opportunities and threats in their external environment through the use of tools such as the Product Life Cycle, Porter’s 5 Forces Model of industry analysis, Strategic groups, Scenario planning and models namely Porter’s Generic Strategies,......

Words: 1478 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

A) Discuss the Traditional and Contemporary Views of Each of the Six Key Elements of Organizational Designs.

...a) Discuss the traditional and contemporary views of each of the six key elements of organizational designs. b) Contrast the three traditional organizational designs. a)The key elements in organizational design are work specialization ,chain of command, span of control, departmentalization, centralization- decentralization, and formalization. Traditionally, work specialization was viewed as a way to divide work activities into separate job tasks. It makes efficient use of the diversity of skills that workers have. In most organizations, some tasks require highly developed skills; others can be performed by employees with lower skill levels. If all workers were engaged in all the steps of say ,a manufacturing process, all would need the skills necessary to perform both the most demanding and the least demanding jobs. For example,McDonald’s uses high work specialization to get its products made and delivered to customers efficiently and quickly that’s why it’s called fast food . One person takes orders at the drive- through window, others cook and assemble the hamburger , another works the fryer, another gets the drinks, another bags orders, and so forth. Secondly, the departmentalization are grouped together. Five common forms of departmentalization are used, although an organization may develop its owns unique classification. For example, a major Japanese electronics firms organizes its divisions along functional lines, its manufacturing units around processes, its...

Words: 725 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Bangladesh in a View

...for consumers to express their actual or idealised self-image. Corporate brand personality, however, is much more about perceptions of employees—both senior management and customer-facing—that make up the company as well as the organisation as a whole. Corporate brand personality reflects the values, actions, and words of all employees of the corporation. In a business-to-business setting, corporate brand personality is often determined by direct contact with a wide range of employees. As a result of the different focus, corporatelevel traits transcend individual products that the firm sells and the five product brand personality dimensions. One useful means to characterise corporate brand personality dimensions is in terms of the tripartite view of attitudes,13 which consists of affective (feelings), cognitive (thoughts) and conative (actions) dimensions. Specifically, we believe that the corporate personality traits of a successful 21st century business can be grouped into three dimensions related to the ‘heart,’ the ‘mind’ and the ‘body’ (see Figure 1). These dimensions reflect three distinct sets of personality traits that can guide employees in 76 Heart: Passion and Compassion The ‘heart’ of the organisation involves passion and compassion. Employees of © 2006 PALGRAVE MACMILLAN LTD 1350-23IX $30.00 BRAND MANAGEMENT VOL. 14, NOS. 1/2, 74–81 SEPTEMBER–NOVEMBER 2006 IMPORTANCE OF CORPORATE BRAND PERSONALITY successful 21st century firms must be passionate about......

Words: 4612 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

World View

...My Ever Changing World View: Growing Along With Me Do you ever stop and take a look at the world around you, (the people, places and events going on)? What do you think about those objects? Have you ever been curious as to where your preconceived notions about those events come from? Those preconceived notions come from your world view. Your world view consists of a set of assumptions about the world and people based on your own personal influences. Your thoughts on everything stem from your world view. Take your parents for example, or the education you received, even where you grew up can influence the way you view the world and the people you come in contact with every day. An important influential aspect of my world view comes from my education. Looking back at the educational influence of my parents, a direct parallel to who I was as a student in my past and the student I have grown into is illustrated. Both my parents were high school graduates. My mother was a book worm who excelled at anything and everything she did. While my father was a social butterfly who got through school with his smile and charm. Much like a double edged sword, I received a little of both academic and social influences from my parents. In grade school, as a child, I went to school in the San Ramon Valley Unified School District and received great educational instruction. Both, middle school and high school were no different in the level of education I received. Sadly, I was unaware of how...

Words: 1606 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

World View

...Religion | Origin of All Things | Nature of God | View of Human Nature | View of Good and Evil | View of “Salvation” | View of After Life | Practices and Rituals | Celebrations and Festivals | Week 2 Hinduism and Jainism | Ohm – an inert void of being and non being. From this void a desire was born to create beings. | God perceived in three ways. Brahman (residing everywhere) Antaryami (residing within) and Bhagavan (residing outside, beyond) | Karma – the moral law in which the cycle of birth-death-rebirth (reincarnation) takes place, giving opportunities to escape the limitations of life and death. | Doesn't recognize “sin” , views good and evil from the principle of karma. | Moksha – when an enlightened person is freed from the reincarnation cycle and comes into a state of completeness. | Doesn't punish or reward the souls, but reminds them of the true purpose of their existance before returning to earth to continue living. | Many practices center on fulfilling the duties associated with social position: brahmacharga (learning), grastha (worldy pursuits) vanaprastha (focus on spirithood) and sanngasu (contemplation) | Montly celbrations include: Saravati Puja, Maha Shiva Ratri, Holi, Rama Navami, Hanuman Jayanti, RathaYatra, Raksha Bandhana, Janmashtami, Ganesha Chaturthi, Durga Puja, Dussehra, Diwali | Week 3 Buddhism | Doesn't believe in a beginning, says the origin of all things is......

Words: 1085 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Liberal View

...Wesley Bentley Mr. Manning English 1301-29 November 16, 2011 The Liberal View The Nation is a magazine based out of New York that writes about many different things such as music, arts, and politics. It is a very Liberal, or left wing, magazine that asserts its opinion very strongly through almost every article it writes. “The Border Patrol State” is an article written by Leslie Marie Silko about New Mexico and the border patrol problems that occur among many other topics that also include racial profiling or discrimination. The article “The Border Patrol State” will effectively persuade the target audience of The Nation because they both express the same views and have the same general audience. The article written by Silko expresses her views and a couple anecdotes that show what happened to her and a friend while on a road trip in the middle of New Mexico, far away from any border what so ever. She was stopped by the Border Patrol for a border check and then treated very rudely and suspiciously for no reason. They were asked if the were “looking for any trouble” even though they had done nothing wrong (Silko 1). She was randomly searched by the Border Patrol dog, which didn’t respect its owners because they didn’t treat it well. Luckily the dog and she made a secret connection with each other and the dog didn’t rat her out for having some medical marijuana in her possession. Somehow they made a bond with one another because they have both been abused by...

Words: 693 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

World View

...World View By Origins The secular humanists believe that the entire universe and life were just something that happened and it was like a coincidence. Their beliefs are that 4.5 years ago this world was created by a bunch of chemicals that were combined to make a single celled life that over billions of years mutated itself into the world as we see it today. Identity To the secularist, we are no greater than an advanced animal, but no greater than the animal kingdom (Weider & Gutierrez, 2011, p. 57), or a bunch of cells and atoms. Meaning/ Purpose I would say that what the Secularist is looking for, would be seeking out as much happiness as the can. I’m sure that there are a lot of people that would have an idea of what their happiness would look like. Some look to any love they can find, some might try out drugs, and some gambling . When these people do not believe in God, that happiness can lead to extremes. Their lives would be considered either cheap or if taken to over to the other side of it, they would consider life as precious and humans are no more value than other animals (Weider & Gutierrez, 2011, p. 57). Morality The International Humanist and Ethical Union (IHEU) bylaws say that humanists want to build “a more humane society through an ethics based on human and other natural values…”and they reject “supernatural views of reality” (IHEU,2009). “You can’t make an omelet without breaking a few eggs.” (Commonly......

Words: 894 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

World View

...| World view | | | | | Word count 603 | Te Ao Māori For Māori, the sun rising in the east, moving slowly across the sky and setting in the west, signifies the birth and growth of mana or power, throughout the world. For many, it is a symbol of birth, life and death, resurrected daily, as a reminder of our existence. Māori believe that everything is interrelated, be it people, fish, animals, birds, trees, even the mountains and the weather. These relationships were told in various kōrero tawhito, or stories of the past and are referred to as whakapapa, meaning to lay one thing upon another (Barlow, 1994). Everything has a whakapapa, a genealogical descent of all living things, from the atua, the gods to the present time (Barlow, 1994). These relationships helped Māori to act accordingly and to understand the world they lived in. For Māori, their world view changed when they first arrived in Aotearoa New Zealand, and had to adapt to life in a new world. Their diet changed dramatically as their normal diet relied heavily on plants and vegetables. Here in Aotearoa New Zealand there was an abundance of meat and fish. The crops they normally grew, were not used to the climate. They had to learn what plants they could eat and grow. The Māori world view changed even more with the arrival of whalers, their first contact with European people. The introduction of disease had a dramatic effect on Māori causing many deaths. Europeans partnering with Māori women,......

Words: 623 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Marxist vs Functionalist View of Ed

...COMPARE AND CONTRAST THE FUNCTIONALIST AND MARXIST VIEWS ON EDUCATION (20 marks) The role of education is to educate individuals within society and to prepare them for working life, also to integrate individuals and teach them the norms, values and roles within society. Functionalism and Marxism are the two main perspectives which will be studied; Marxism is a structural conflict sociological theory whereas functionalism is a structural consensus sociological theory. Functionalism sees society as a whole. It is often referred to as the consensus theory as it does not address the issue of conflict in society. It looks at all the major aspects in society for example the family, the economy, the educational and political system and how they all function together as a whole to form a complete system. Functionalism can be compared to the human body, also known as the organic analogy. For the human body to function properly each part needs to operate together for example the heart and lungs, this is very similar to the institutions in society. All the key institutions in society need to be well integrated for society to survive and operate efficiently. Emile Durkheim, French sociologist, was the original founding father of this theory. He saw education as being a positive thing in society as it helps the maintenance of the social system and helps to transmit norms and values which help promote social solidarity, to keep society running smoothly. Durkheim believed that......

Words: 815 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

View

...Your view on yourself: You are down-to-earth and people like you because you are so straightforward. You are an efficient problem solver because you will listen to both sides of an argument before making a decision that usually appeals to both parties. The type of girlfriend/boyfriend you are looking for: You like serious, smart and determined people. You don't judge a book by its cover, so good-looking people aren't necessarily your style. This makes you an attractive person in many people's eyes. Your readiness to commit to a relationship: You prefer to get to know a person very well before deciding whether you will commit to the relationship. The seriousness of your love: Your have very sensible tactics when approaching the opposite sex. In many ways people find your straightforwardness attractive, so you will find yourself with plenty of dates. Your views on education Education is very important in life. You want to study hard and learn as much as you can. The right job for you: You have plenty of dream jobs but have little chance of doing any of them if you don't focus on something in particular. You need to choose something and go for it to be happy and achieve success. How do you view success: You are confident that you will be successful in your chosen career and nothing will stop you from trying. What are you most afraid of: You are afraid of things that you cannot control. Sometimes you show your anger to cover up how you feel. Who is your true......

Words: 298 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Point of View

...Each individual short story has its’ own point of view and voice. Within short stories there are different types of narrative and also different types of irony being used. Each individual author has their own way of telling a story; also they have a certain way to portray their story to an audience. For two specific short stories Everything That Rises Must Converge and Mrs. Dutta Writes a Letter we can analyze to see what point of view and voice is being used. Everything That Rises Must Converge is a story that takes place in the 1960’s. A recent college graduate, Julian who escorts his mother to her weekly weight-loss class at the YMCA. His mother attends these classes to reduce her high blood pressure. He escorts her there every week because she refuses to take the bus alone since integration. His mother is extremely prejudice and Julian was the total opposite. In Mrs. Dutta Writes a Letter this story is about the life of Mrs. Dutta, an old, widowed Indian woman who had moved into her son’s American home two months prior. Mrs. Dutta struggles with not running a house and in the midst is writing a letter to a dear friend back home contemplating weather to be truthful or to be honorable to her family. First I would like to review witch point of view is being used both stories. For the first short story Everything That Rises Must Converge, the story is being told from a third person point of view. The story has someone who is not any of the characters stating the events...

Words: 1293 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Bible Views

...Christian views of the Bible's Old Covenant[->0] are central to Christian theology[->1], ethics[->2], and practice[->3]. Particularly notable in the New Testament[->4] are Jesus[->5]' expounding of the Law[->6] and the circumcision controversy in Early Christianity[->7]. There are differing views about the applicability of the Old Covenant among Christian denominations[->8]. Also referred to as Mosaic Law[->9], Divine Law[->10], Biblical Law, God's Law, or the Books of Moses, the term Old Covenant refers to the statements or principles of religious law[->11] and religious ethics[->12] codified in the first five books or Pentateuch of the Christian Bible[->13]. There are diverse views of the issues involved, with many traditional Christians of the view that only parts are applicable[->14], many Protestants with the view that none is applicable[->15] and a minority with the view that all are still applicable[->16] to believers in Jesus[->17] and the New Covenant[->18]. In Judaism[->19], the first five books are referred to as the Torah[->20], in Hebrew[->21]: תּוֹרָה,[2] and generally translated as "the Law" in English translations of the Bible[->22]. Rabbinic JudaismHYPERLINK \l "cite_note-2"[3][->23] asserts that the Laws of the Jewish Bible[->24] were presented to the Jewish people[->25] and converts to Judaism[->26] and do not apply to gentiles[->27], including Christians, with the notable exception of the Seven Laws of Noah[->28] which apply to all people. Rabbi......

Words: 640 - Pages: 3