Free Essay

Depiction of Women

In: Historical Events

Submitted By kckenlin
Words 1558
Pages 7
Depiction of Women Women are depicted as subordinate creatures in both the Tanakh and Antigone, yet throughout history, they continue to fight this hierarchy in one way or another. Within this paper, there will be examples of the ways women are treated and how they react to this treatment. It will also discuss various situations that strengthen this argument. In the Tanakh, when God created man, God took a look at man and decided that he needed someone to help him. God did not create woman to be his equal, but God created her to be his helper. In Genesis 2, the Tanakh somewhat puts women in the same category with the animals, but one step higher due to the fact that she was made from man. When Adam and Eve were in the Garden of Eden, they had free reign to go where they wanted, eat what they chose, do what they wished… anything except eat from the tree of knowledge. It was Eve who initially bent the rules and ate from the tree of life. She showed reckless abandon for the rules that were set by the ruling power (just happens to be God in this case) and chose to do what she wanted because she “felt” like doing it. The general feeling in both the Tanakh and Antigone is that women act more on their feelings and do whatever they do and face the consequences later. They realize that they have the same set of rules that men have, yet they can’t control their emotions enough not to break them. They are not above the law, but merely that they act more on emotion than men do. When Antigone lost her brother, she knew that there was a law that he was not to be buried. Yet she felt that he needed to be buried and that she was going to do it. Antigone could have gone to Creon and requested special permission due to the family ties, but she chose not to, figuring that it would most likely do no good. Instead, she took it upon herself to go above the law and bury him anyway. When confronted about it, she did not deny it. Antigone essentially laughed in the face of the leaders saying that she regretted nothing. After Antigone had been caught and refused to deny guilt, Creon was furious and started ranting and raving in disbelief that she would blatantly break the law without a second thought. It seemed that he didn’t want to believe it at first, but ultimately could not help her when she openly admitted guilt. Creon was furious that Antigone would do such a thing. Creon initially assumed that it was a man who did this bad deed, and he sent his Sentry to find out who did it. Once it was found who had stepped outside the law, and that it was not just Antigone, but a woman, Creon was shocked. His view of women was shared among everyone in the Greek culture at the time in that women were subordinate. Creon confirms the place of women in the hierarchy in the statement, “Better to fall from power, if fall we must, at the hands of a man – never be rated inferior to a woman, never.” (Sophocles, 94) When we look at women in the Tanakh, it discusses the fact that God made man, but then decided that man all by himself wasn’t enough. “But for Adam, no fitting helper was found.” (Truelove, Genesis 2:20) So God’s initial goal was to make man to live on the earth and the only reason he made woman was as an afterthought to help Adam (man). The creation of woman is mentioned at least three times; once in chapter 1, verse 27, once in chapter 2, verse 22, and again in chapter 5, verse 2. It makes one wonder the way that Genesis is worded if God didn’t create woman multiple times. These could just be referring to the same incident, just at different points in the writing. However, it could also mean that God made woman multiple times in order to find man a suitable helper. Women continually fail to be feared or considered physically/mentally equal throughout the Tanakh. In Exodus, chapters 1 and 2, the Egyptians even considered the women to be inconsequential as they had ordered the midwives to kill any male Hebrew babies that were born because they feared them growing up and gaining power. The Egyptians weren’t scared of the female offspring growing up and amounting to anything that would challenge their power. Being controlled by their emotions, the midwives were not always killing the male Hebrew babies as ordered. This failure by the midwives is another instance of the women not carrying out a clear cut order in the first couple books of the Tanakh. The first of course being when Eve was duped into taking the apple in the Garden of Eden by the serpent. Even then, when this happened, God did not go initially to Eve and question her about it, God went to Adam and questioned him about what happened because he was the man, or in other words, the one in charge. Only after questioning Adam did he ask Eve what happened once Adam explained to God that it was “the woman that you put at my side.” (Truelove, Genesis 3:12) When God handed down the Ten Commandments, he even pointed out the insignificance of the woman as a person of power. This original set of laws for his people appears not even to address women. “You shall not covet your neighbor’s house: you shall not covet your neighbor’s wife, or his male or female slave, or his ox or his ass, or anything that is your neighbor’s.” (Truelove, Exodus 20:14) God points out that you shall not covet your neighbor’s wife, therefore the law is being given to man. God does acknowledge both man and woman in the next sentence when referencing male and female slaves. This proves that he was talking directly to man in the first part of the sentence and not that he was just generalizing putting man and woman together in the first part. God purposefully singled out man as being the one that he demands to follow his laws. Combine this with the aforementioned section where Eve ate from the tree of knowledge, and God questioned man about what happened. This just strengthens the argument that the laws of the land both in the beginning in Genesis and later on in Exodus with the Ten Commandments were created to be followed by man and that if his helper or woman defies the law, then the man has to answer for it. In other words, if man doesn’t keep his woman under control, then he will have to answer for it. This view of women being subordinate is pretty clear in Antigone as it states, “From now on they’ll act like women. Tie them up, no more running loose; even the bravest will cut and run, once they see Death coming for their lives.” (Sophocles, 90) This is after they have concluded that Antigone broke the law. This is one difference between the Tanakh and Antigone, or the Hebrews and Greeks. With the Hebrew culture, if the women broke the law, whichever man was responsible for her would be in trouble as well as the woman. In the Greek culture, it appears that women can and will act of their own accord and then face the consequences on their own. In Antigone’s case, it was even her future father in law that was convicting her and doing the sentencing. If this were the Hebrew culture, I’m sure there would have been some form of punishment for her fiancé which would have been Creon’s own son. It would be interesting to see how Creon would have handled this situation had this been the case. In Greek culture, men who want to be rulers of the state must prove first that they can be a good ruler of their households. When this is discussed in Antigone, it is followed up with talks about how if a man does a poor job of ruling his house, then “she” begins to become the definition of anarchy. “She, she destroys cities, rips up houses, breaks the ranks of spearmen into headlong rout.” Then later on the same page, “Therefore we must defend the men who live by law, never let some woman triumph over us.”(Sophocles, 94) In both Hebrew and Greek cultures women are looked upon as subordinate. The difference in the two is that in the Hebrew culture, women are looked at more as belonging to the men and the men are more responsible for all of the women’s actions if they break the law of the land. However, in both cultures, women are not intended to keep positions of power. They are meant to be helpers or supporters of their husbands. As has been proven through time, women still go out on their own because they can be driven more by their emotions than men.

Works Cited
Sophocles, The Three Theban Plays. New York: Penguin Books, 1984. Print
Truelove, Sarah, et al. Patterns in Western Civilization. Boston: Pearson Custom Publishing, 2007. Print

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

What Is The Unfavorable Depiction Of Women In The Miller's Tale

...The Miller’s Tale is a short story written by Geoffrey Chaucer. This short story is part of the tales that are anticipated in The General Prologue. In short, this tale is about a carpenter named John whose young wife, Alison, cheats on him with an Oxford student named Nicholas. There is a lot to this story, but for the sake of this paper I will be focusing on one particular section and argument. In The Miller’s Tale, the animalistic descriptions of Alison create an unfavorable depiction of women. As I analyzed the passage I selected, my first thought was that the narrator was highly descriptive when describing the Miller’s wife. The wife, Alison, is first introduced in line 125 and is described much differently than the men in the tale....

Words: 596 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Depiction of Women and Relationship Between Men and Women in Plautus's Plays with Particular Refernce to Pot of Gold

...Depiction of women and relationship between men and women in Plautus's plays with particular refernce to Pot of Gold I. Overview of Aulularia (Pot of Gold) and main characters: Pot of Glod a translation of original latin play "Aulularia" by the early Roman playwright Titus Maccius Plautus (254-184 BCE). The title has been translated as The Pot of Gold, and the plot revolves around a literal pot of gold that the miserly protagonist, Euclio, guards zealously. The play’s ending does not survive, though there are indications of how the plot is resolved in later summaries and a few fragments of dialogue. Dramatis Personae referred to in the paper The Household God of Euclio, the Prologue. Euclio, an old gentleman of Athens. Staphyla, his old lady slave. Strobilus, slave of Lyconides. Lyconides, a young gentleman of Athens, Eunomia's son. Phaedria, Euclio's daughter. 2.Women depicted as subservient to men (as they were in reallife) in Roman Comedy 2. a. The puella is one dramatic stereotype of women in Plautine comedy. The puella is the object of the young lover’s affection and the slave’s efforts and whose marriage frequently provides the happy ending of the comedy. 2.a.(i) One sub-category of the puella is the "absent maiden" who is not seen on stage, offers an illuminating evidence about the status puella in comedy. Since she is totally under the domination of her father or guardian until she is handed over to her husband, she is seen in a positive...

Words: 1600 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Sexuality Research

...sexuality is on that needs that needs thorough analysis in order to determine the implication brought about by the depiction of sex and sexuality through the use of print media. The depiction of human sexuality can be separated into two parts, male and female sexuality. These two forms vary according to the differences in the gender of the persons involved. Objective: The main objective of this paper is to study, keenly, the research methods used in two literatures, and to provide an analysis of the literatures on sexual imagery. The two literatures were compiled by different people to show how various forms of male and female sexuality are constructed in different publications. The two articles are similar because they both talk about the depiction of women in various forms of print advertisements especially in magazines. However, as Sexuality focuses mostly on the sexuality and people’s view of sex, as well as, their feelings and preferences in sex, The European Journal of Marketing, focuses mostly on the picture of women that is painted representing women as either sexual objects or feminine sexual goddesses. The European Journal of Marketing also focuses on the position of women and their sex roles in the community. In the article, the various sex roles that women play have been reviewed. It has also compared the power of women, in sex, over men, and that of men over women as well. *Fravid and Braun (2006) what was the Benefits of this approach/ disadvantages of the content analysis...

Words: 1636 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Little Red Riding Hood

...seen hundreds of different interpretations, versions, and changes. Charles Perrault, a 17th century author, wrote the first publication of this story to reflect that young children, particularly young girls, are wrong to listen to strangers, in this case wolves, and that in doing so, said strangers will undoubtedly get their delicious meal in the end. In Perrault’s version, the male and female are depicted in a very particular way, which is ultimately a reflection of the culture and society of the time. Given this society, and the status of women, it is clear that Perrault is criticizing the gender representation through. While Little Red Riding Hood is a classic tale, it holds a more valuable meaning than society realizes. The story of Little Red Riding Hood has a particular depiction of both men and women. In the story, men are depicted as a “metaphor, a stand-in for male seducers who lure young women into their beds.” (Tater 5). This depiction, while true, is not complete. The wolf is in fact luring Red into the bed with him, after she has taken her clothes off, and although it is not explicitly stated, the action of a girl removing her clothing and climbing into bed with a man implies a sense of sexuality. Additionally, though, the male is depicted as duplicitous and dominant. In several instances throughout the story, the wolf clearly tricks Red and her grandmother into believing something that is not true. The wolf, in need of getting to Grandmother’s house before Red, decides...

Words: 1150 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Gender Stereotypes in Video Games

...that sexism is the general phenomenon in which females become “domesticated women”, or workhorses for men. Rubin wrote her influential essay The Traffic in Women in 1975, yet her definitions of sex, gender, and sexism are still applicable today. The issues that Rubin addressed are demonstrated in particular in today’s media, which reinforces gender inequality and objectification, through the depiction of women as hyper-sexualized, weak, and unskilled. This negative depiction of women exists especially in the gaming community, in which many have criticized the negative portrayal of women as sexist and severely problematic. Video games like Grand Theft Auto and Red Dead Redemption portray women in an almost exclusively violent and sexualized manner, which serves to reinforce the never-ending sexism and gender biases that society has upheld for centuries. Society as a whole can change the perception of gender and how women are perceived, but leaps towards progressive ideas need to be made first, starting with the video game industry as a whole. Throughout history, women’s roles have primarily been domestic – staying home and being responsible for the care of her husband and children. As Warnke points out (4), this is not a result of sex but, rather of gender. Society, culture, and especially economics have been the primary driver behind the reinforcement of gender stereotypes particularly for women. Joan Wallach Scot’s analysis of French garment jobs during the 1840’s serves...

Words: 1646 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Patricia Hill Collin’s Thoughts on Shadow Tag

...Bailey Gerard-Custodio Ms. Dane ENGL 2593 November 26,2013 Essay 2: Patricia Hill Collin’s Thoughts on Shadow Tag Patricia Hill Collin’s main argument in, The Sexual Politics of Black Womanhood, is that race controls the type of objectification a woman will face. Meaning, race controls the way society perceives a woman. In the novel, Shadow Tag, Louise Erdrich tells a chilly story of a marriage controlled by possession. A woman is shown objectification through her cultural origin and background. Throughout the novel, Gil wished to possess Irene. His possession over Irene’s body was obtained through his depictions of her in his artwork. The idea that an object is something you can obtain and possess would relate the novel by Louise Erdrich to the argument of Patricia Hill Collins. Gil’s obsession over his wife’s body also created a form of domination that utilized a form of oppression. Patricia Hill Collins writes, “Sexuality becomes a domain of restriction and repression when this energy is tied to the larger system of race, class, and gender oppression.” Gil controlled Irene’s image and sexuality through a form oppression that accompanied her race, class, and gender because he found that it exemplified his talent as an artist. “He painted Indians when he painted his wife because he couldn’t help it—the ferocity between them, the need. Her blood ancestors came out in Gil’s painting as he worked.” Gil painted Irene in the way he wanted people to perceive her. He used her ...

Words: 1592 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Gender, Sexuality and Visual Representation

...born on 22 May 1844 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Although women were not encouraged to pursue a career, Mary enrolled at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts at the age of sixteen. She quickly felt frustrated by the male faculty and students who were patronising and resentful of her attendance. Regardless of these obstacles and her father’s disapproval of her career choice, she continued to pursue art and painting. Cassatt, an impressionist painter, did not conform to standard male images of women and therefore her paintings differ from the more general male representations, especially of women readers during the Victorian period. Cassatt expresses her world through women and therefore “…offers a new vision of the unconsidered facts of everyday bourgeois life…” (Yeh, 1976:359). Cassatt’s work is regarded by Yeh (1976:359) as women-centred art as she regards women as complete within themselves. In her work she represents women as independent, pursuing interests which are not necessarily directed toward the need of her family. Reading women, portraying the reader’s inner strength often occur as a theme in her paintings. Femininity in the Victorian era In the latter Victorian period women artists and their work were considered inferior. In an attempt to overcome the stereotypical female image their work became increasingly more vocal and confident and promoted the emerging image of the educated, modern and free women. Femininity in the Victorian era was generally thought to...

Words: 1854 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Summary

...Education, Citizenship, and War : What’s At Stake? - Comparing controversies over textbook depiction of recent wars in Japan, Germany and the U.S. - We learn “ideas of citizenship”, past, and future of the nation from schools and textbooks; therefore, it is necessary to compare controversies over textbook depiction clearly. - Textbooks are always “unfinished projects” which means that always need to be revised and reinterpreted with true facts. - Two interrelated themes of nationalism: A) relationship between citizens and state. B) foreign relations. - Brutality vs. goals of war- As being teachers, how do we need to instruct students? - Should we defend the aspects of brutality? - “Lack of depiction of textbooks vs. keeping it honest”. - There are ongoing debates over Japanese brutal act during World War 2 ( ex. Comfort womens). - The incident of the Holocaust by Germany and intervention of U.S during Vietnam War need to be debated. - There are very little controversies over U.S textbook depictions of the Vietnam War among Americans. Why? Vietnam relied on U.S economic and political supports after the war; therefore, even majority of Vietnamese did not debate on this issue. - Textbooks in Japan directly supervised by political leaders since late 19th century. - Germany, on the other hand, provided the textbooks under the control of local states but no controls by governments. - Textbooks in the U.S are provided with no close association with...

Words: 353 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Pride and Prejudice

...In Pride and Prejudice, Jane Austen’s depiction of womanhood is both varied and expansive. A woman can be gentle in spirit, incapable of finding ill in others. Daughters can be impossibly “silly” in their romantic endeavors. Wives are sometimes obnoxious, meddling fools with easily disturbed nerves. Even women linked by their intelligence, such as Charlotte and Elizabeth, differ in terms of practicality and adherence to social norms. There is, however, a factor that distinguishes intelligent females in the novel from the unintelligent: their insistence on maintaining privacy from male influence. From a feminist perspective, Jane Austen’s emphasis on female personal space implies that intelligent women must secure privacy in order to remain independent, freethinking individuals within a patriarchal society. By linking privacy with mental growth, Austen takes part in a larger network of feminist literature in which private space is equated with female creativity and freedom from domestic duties. Therefore, Austen’s examination of privacy serves as a critique of limitations on female intellectual growth. The issue of female privacy is perhaps most associated with feminist works published long after Pride and Prejudice, but Austen’s depiction of the matter can be seen as a precursor to these later arguments. Both Charlotte Perkins Gilman and Virginia Woolf published works pertaining to the physical and mental privacy needed for women. A Room of One’s Own, for instance, clearly establishes...

Words: 402 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Accurate Perceptions on Race Relations and Gender Roles “Gone with the Wind”

...Mahmoud Mandour Mrs. Kuhl English Lang. and Lit. 25th February 2013 Rational I chose to write a movie review, as a critic pointing out the inaccurate depictions made through characters in the movie, ‘Gone With The Wind”. What motivated me to do this, is that it is difficult to criticize movies as successful as this. So, I wrote this as a critic pointing out some huge flaws in the portrayals made through the movie’s characters, rather than focus on the story plot, like other movie reviews. The audience I target for this critique, is any “GWTW” fan that thinks this movie is flawless. This written task is intended to focus on part 1 of the course, as language in this movie is used in different contexts to portray race relations and gender roles in a certain society at the time the movie was set. The tone used in the very title of the article is humorous and a bit exaggerated, as I make a pun by using the name of the movie in making a point about how this movie abolishes accurate perceptions on the nature of the confederate states. The first half of the introduction is stated in an admiring tone, as I praise the movie’s success with sentences like; “ leaving viewers with a warm feeling towards a great story that was beautifully told.” I then shift to a rather aggressive tone, as I directly point out the issues in the movie. As for the rest of the article, the tone is strictly formal and informative, as I elaborate on the introduction. I made sure to stick...

Words: 1222 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How Does Pornography Influence Human Behavior

...expression. Whereas, the subsections 159 (1) and 152 (2) of the constitution of Canada refers pornography as an ‘obscene’ matter, i.e. crime, horror, cruelty, violence, and exploitation (Fraser, 1985). Yafee’s definition states pornography as a depiction of sexual pleasures, but on the other hand, the Canadian constitutional definition of pornography reflects the idea of violence and sexual exploitation. The paper centralized on the theme that modern pornographic depiction is a...

Words: 904 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Short Response: Demonizing The Other

...the eighth and ninth centuries, devils were described as having “horns, claws, fiery breath, unruly hair, and hooked noses.” Christians accused Jews and Muslims of being the originators of iconoclasm and depicted them very similarly to the depiction of devils; the main difference between the depiction of Jews and Muslims was that Muslims were portrayed as black. The association between Jews/Muslims and devils characterized Jews/Muslims as devil worshippers. Black and hairy imagery in art often represented the wildness of man, because during the age of exploration groups like the Native Americans and black Africans replaced the idea of a monstrous race with the “wild man,” and the devil is associated with wildness. The association between horn imagery and Jews originated during the Fourth Crusades, because Christians made Jews wear horned hats (pileum cornutum) to identify themselves. The story of Samuel anointing David strengthened the connection of Jews and horns because the Psalters portray David as receiving a single horn. This led to the characterization of all Jews with horns. Artists intentionally used the type of imagery in portraying the “other” to show their association with the devil. There are clear parallels between the depiction the devil and the “other.” The demonic imagery rhetorically functions as a way for the human brain to visually separate people from one another and further cement the us vs them mentality. Using the same imagery to portray the “other” groups...

Words: 625 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Prostitutes in Greek Art

...Depiction of Prostitutes in Greek Art Woman in Greek art are usually seen doing what most Greek woman were tasked with doing in their daily lives. Their main jobs focused on the domestic needs of the family; caring for the sick, nursing the children, and preparing food for the family. Women are often time’s illustrated performing task such as weaving and other domestic actions like bearing and caring for their children. The women in these forms of art are properly dressed and the illustrations are done on common made items like pottery and vases. When comparing this description of the artistic portrayal of common Greek women to the illustrations seen on the Terracotta Kylix, there are some distinct differences. The most obvious difference is the nudity that is seen within the artwork. All of the women are depicted in a seductive fashion with somewhat of a control over the men that they are with. Also the portrayal of the scene is done in a ceremonial fashion; the event seems to be a joyous event accompanied with wine and picnic baskets. Then there is the presence of the satyr and the maenad which most directly represents the wine god Dionysus. Another important difference in the art work is that it is illustrated on a drinking cup that would most likely be used in the same type of event that is portrayed in the illustration. I believe the portrayal of these nude women in the Terracotta Kylix represent how prostitution was seen by Greek culture. These women do not seem...

Words: 358 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Media Ending the Great Depression

...Media Ending the Great Depression HIS 203 4/26/13 The U.S. experienced a Depression in 1929. The American economy collapsed and millions of people were out of jobs. The government's role during this time of economic crisis was to assist the citizens of this country in any way possible. This sometimes led to the development of experimental programs and projects. Some of the programs involved morale boosting murals that depicted an idealistic agricultural American society. The government was not the only producer of confidence boosting propaganda during the Depression, Hollywood also capitalized on the need for empowerment. Hollywood lost money and felt the same loss as people all over the United States. But Hollywood used this Depression for their gain. They altered their course of action to please the American people during this time. Hollywood then produced the Golden Age of Hollywood to boost American morale. Directors such William Wellman and King Vidor were at the forefront of Golden Age movie production. These directors aimed to capture the roles of womanhood and manhood in efforts to fortify American’s thoughts of the ideal American society. The New deal also created the implementation of the Works Project Administration (WPA), more specifically the Federal Project Number One, which aimed to assist people of the arts out of Depression and simultaneously using their works to get into the minds of Americans and regain their confidence. The Great Depression came at a time...

Words: 1297 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Comparative Essay

...Wood present unique aspects of Abigail Adams and Benjamin Franklin which highlight societal, institutional, and ideological changes brought about by the American revolution. Holton’s depiction of Abigail Adams provides an in depth analysis of the challenges she faces as a wife who assumes the roles typically undertaken by the family patriarch. In wood’s book, the depiction of Benjamin Franklin allows the reader to understand the progressive development of Franklin as he transitions from a gentleman to an ardent revolutionary. An interesting aspect of Wood’s portrayal of Franklin resides in his detailed analyses of his contributions to the American Revolution and the generally negative reception he receives upon returning to the independent colonies. Both Wood and Holton chose these individuals, and specifically the overriding topics of each book, in order to explain these chosen themes through the perspective of well-known historical figures. Although both authors make interesting arguments, Holton’s research on Abigail Adams presents a more significant contribution to historical research by highlighting her contribution to women’s rights and feminism. Woody Holton’s work, Abigail Adams (2009) tells the story of the wife of John Adams before, during, and after the American Revolution. Holton’s depiction of Abigail’s life prior to the American Revolution consists of her childhood, courtship and marriage to John Adams. During John’s early career as a lawyer, the vast distance between...

Words: 1948 - Pages: 8