Free Essay

Diagnosis Paper

In: Other Topics

Submitted By toniwhite
Words 1467
Pages 6
Fight Club the movie, 1999, is based upon the book with the same title. It is a unique look into the mind of an individual, the narrator, played by Edward Norton, who throughout the movie is not named. He is referred to as Jack, but it is not clear if that is really his name. The other main character in the movie, Tyler Durden, played by Brad Pitt, is the opposite of the Narrator/Jack, in personality, demeanor, charm, and attraction. We find out that they are two personalities, within the same body.
I had never seen Fight Club before, assuming it was just another movie about an underground fight club. Despite being such a huge fan of both Brad Pitt and Edward Norton, I avoided the movie. I was way off the mark! Per the advice of his doctor, the narrator/Jack goes to a cancer support group for men with testicular cancer, where he meets Bob. Bob, aka Robert Pulson, once a body builder, but since developing cancer, has become bankrupt, divorced, and now has female looking breast; double D’s by the size of them. He and Jack find comfort with each other, and Jack cuddles into Bob’s breast. Jack considers the therapy sessions as vacation. Jack also finds relief of his insomnia; or so we think. While at one of these sessions, Jack meets Marla Singer, who is like him, for she too attends various group therapies for comfort and they agree to alternate between sessions as neither of them are cancer victims. When asked why she does it, she says “when people think you are dying, they really listen to you”. (Fight Club, 1999) That statement speaks volumes for both of their characters and helps to explain why Tyler (Jack’s other personality) was so verbose. Jack needs to be heard. Someone needs to pay attention to him. He is socially isolated. We are introduced to Tyler when Jack is on a flight returning home. Tyler tells Jack that he makes and sells soap for a living. Further, Tyler shares that he also can make explosives since the ingredients for soap making is similar. Tyler has several other jobs as well. He is a waiter¸ and works at a movie theatre where he replaces the film on the reel. Once they land, Jack goes to his condo, to find that it has exploded, and seems to be genuinely upset. (You would think at this point I would have realized they were one in the same, but no, I had not figured it out yet.) Jack calls Tyler, and after having a drink, and a fist fight outside the bar, Jack asks Tyler if he could crash at his place. The fist fight is witnessed by several other men, and they in turn want to join in. The fight moves from outside the bar to the basement of the bar, and fight club begins. (There is a great scene where Jack and Taylor really go at it and fight each other. It is as if one personality is trying to destroy the other permanently.)
They have rules for the fight club with rule number one and two being to not discuss or talk about Fight Club. They discuss who they would want to fight if they could pick anyone, and Tyler says his dad, while Jack states he never really knew his dad, as he left when he was six. This is a great example of how the characteristics can differ among the personalities. DSM-IV indicates that sub personalities can differ in age, sex, race, and have varying abilities like the languages they speak, or their family history. (Morrison, 2006) As the movie progresses, Jack becomes more and more like Tyler. He at one point tells Marla, “sooner or later, we all become what Tyler wants us to be”. (Fight Club, 1999) This also is indicative of the diagnosis of DID wherein Jack and Tyler have the relationship of being one-way amnesic, i.e., Jack does not know about Tyler, but Tyler knows about Jack. One of my favorite conversations between Tyler speaking to Jack says it best: “All the ways you wish you could be, that’s me. I look like you wanna look, I f--- like you wanna f---, I am smart, capable, and most importantly, I am free in all the ways that you are not. (Fight Club, 1999)
Jack and Tyler begin opening up fight clubs all over the country, and become very anti- establishment in nature. Fight Club evolves and becomes “Project Mayhem”. When one of their members (Bob) is killed during one of the attack missions, Tyler disappears. Jack goes searching for Tyler and is greeted by others as Tyler. Everyone thinks he is Tyler; everyone except himself. He confronts Marla, and she knows him as Tyler as well. It is then that he realizes Tyler is him, and that Tyler becomes him while he is sleeping. There is a cat and mouse type finale, where they confront each other and Jack shoots himself in the mouth, killing Tyler. Marla is brought to Jack by members of Project Mayhem, and together they watch all the buildings explode that Tyler had targeted.
Jack/Tyler is suffering from Dissociative Disorder; specifically, Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) 300.14. The criteria for DID is: “… having two distinct identities or personality states. Each of these has its own, relatively lasting pattern or sensing, thinking about and relating to self and the environment.” (DSM-IV, Morrison, 2006) Further, there are several scenes from the movie (one mentioned above regarding their fight) that makes it clear that while the identities are separate, Tyler is very aware of Jack even though initially, Jack is not aware of Tyler. For example, they are in a car and Tyler is driving with two passengers in the back. Tyler and Jack engage in an argument and upon crashing the car, Tyler state, “Wow! That was a near life experience”. (Fight Club, 1999) This indicates that Tyler wants to live, but in his mind, could only do so if Jack was dead. Also, another conversation between them indicating Tyler is fully aware of the other identity; “People do it every day, they talk to themselves…they see themselves as they’d like to be, they don’t have the courage you have to just run with it”. (Fight Club, 1999)
Treatment for DID is a slow process. Patients with DID do not usually recover without treatment unlike Dissociative Amnesia and Dissociative Fugue. To help Jack regain those memories that were lost would include hypnosis or video so as to introduce Tyler to Jack. As a therapist, helping the client reorganize the disorder is another goal of therapy for DID patients. Other treatment methods are available to include psychodynamic therapy and drug therapy. With psychodynamic therapy, Jack would be taught to search his unconscious and bring forgotten memories and experiences into consciousness. If drug therapy is used, Jack would be intravenously injected with a “truth serum” to calm help him and allow him to be free from fear so as to regain lost memories. The final goal would be to merge Tyler with Jack as a single identity and to maintain some type of therapy with Jack once the fusion took place; possibly group therapy.
The message received from the movie for me personally was that we all have various personalities or identities within us, it is just a matter of how much control we allow them to have. Women especially can identify with this for we play a variety of roles through-out our lives; daughter, wife, mother, lover, friend, employee, and more. Also, the message speaks to that inner conscious, that part of my brain that I argue with, that part that seeks to do that which is right and good. But yet that other part of me, that part that wants to take risk, try hard things, do that which is out of character; be that person that goes against who my mother taught me to be. I cower under the thought of my mother’s look, her stare, and shut my ID down every time, unless my EGO agrees. Jack didn’t do that until it was too late. The message says that we all may need help at one point or another in our lives and we should not let things get out of control so that we are beyond redemption. REFERENCES
Corey, Gerald, Theory and Practice of Counseling and Psychotherapy, Brooks/Cole (Cengage Learning) California, 2009
Gorenstein, Ethan E, and Comer, Ronald J, Case Studies in Abnormal Psychology, Worth Publishers, New York, 2002
Morrison, James, DSM-IV Made Easy, The Clinician’s Guide to Diagnosis, Guilford Press, New York, 2006
Palahniuk, Chuck, Fight Club, 20th Century Fox, California, 1996/1999

Similar Documents

Free Essay


...Symptoms and Diagnosing of Autism Spectrum Disorder Stephanie R. South University of Cincinnati Abstract This paper explores the symptoms and how to accurately diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorder. Autism is classified as a psychological condition that starts in adolescence. Psychology classes, specifically an introductory course, briefly cover this condition and its diagnosis. This paper will provide a great knowledge and understanding of diagnosing Autism. There are many symptoms and signs exhibited in children diagnosed with Autism. There is no clear answer for why or how this disorder occurs, making it hard to properly diagnose those afflicted. It is extremely important for the child’s caregiver to be proactive and seek out medical expertise at the onset of behavioral issues in their child. Diagnosing the child at a younger age can ensure proper treatment and interventions for him/her. I have chosen to write my paper on the symptoms and diagnosing of Autism. This disorder is mysterious, but also fascinating. Being a mother, I worry all the time about new and strange afflictions that are attacking our children. To be proactive in our children’s lives, we must be knowledgeable and observant for the early warning signs or symptoms. Throughout the research process of preparing my paper, I have gained a greater comprehension of this disorder and the first indicators that has prepared me to act promptly for the sake of my children. In the last decade, Autism has......

Words: 1058 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Conflict Diagnosis Paper

...Conflict Diagnosis Paper CJHS/430 Conflict Diagnosis Paper Deaths in the prisons are on the rise in the recent years and the major cause of these deaths are mostly suicide and I this review I will focus mostly on diagnosis on suicide related deaths in the United States. The research in the past has also been criticized for focusing mostly on the static variables like the demographics. In the United States, suicide is more common in prisons compared with the general populations as a whole. Each year it is approximated that the number of prison suicide is 200, and it is the third leading cause of death in prison behind aids and natural cause. Many suicides are seen as accidental deaths. Some workers fear reporting suicide-related incidents for fear of cases being brought against them. Somebody dying in the hospital after attempting suicide may not be reported as deadly occurred at the prison.   The homicide rate in local jails nationwide hovered around 3 inmates per 100,000 between 2000 and 2010, according to data from the Bureau of Justice Statistics. Violent, troubled individuals are concentrated in prisons and jails. “The violent prisoners exert pressures on the most vulnerable inmates who end up succumbing to health related problems or they result to suicide.” (Theodore, Max, & Mitch, 2009.) The populations or individuals that are vulnerable to these pressures should be identified, and this is an essential first step towards resolving the problem. However, it...

Words: 1107 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Changes and Implications to Griffiths Study

...Suggest 2 improvements that could be made to the Griffiths study and outline any implications these changes may have. (8) One change would be to replicate the study in different countries. Pseudo patients could see if they would be diagnosed as having schizophrenia by doctors in England, France and Canada. The pseudo patients would provide the same symptoms as in the original study (thud, hollow and empty). This would allow the researcher to investigate any cross cultural differences in diagnosis and the treatment of patents (if admitted to a hospital). An implication of this may be that doctors in the other countries may make the same mistakes with diagnosis thus showing practitioners to be bias cross cultural. This would give further support for the need of the DSM to be updates and would mean that the results form Rosenhan's study could be generalised to other countries. In addition to this it would provide insight into treatments used in the different countries, they may find that the type of care/ standard of care differ from country to country (possibly worse in counties with lower economy) Another improvement could be to set up CCTV cameras into the hospitals to record the behaviours of the staff towards the patients. This would be overt at first as the staff would be aware the cameras are being brought in, however they would soon forget they are there. This would allow Rosenhan to have a record of staff patient interaction and the treatment of the pseudo......

Words: 311 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Psy 270dsm-Iv Problems be standardized across psychology; however, the DSM-IV is not as precise for diagnosing personality disorders as some psychologists would like. Give an example of each of the following problems identified in your readings and explain how these problems could negatively affect a diagnosis. 1. Some criteria used for reaching a diagnosis cannot be observed directly. The DSM-IV has been criticized for diagnosing patients with disorders because of their reliability. A patient is diagnosed by a clinician based on the patient telling them their symptoms, when it is possible that the patient is exaggerating and this can result in a patient being mis diagnosed because the clinician may not have paid close attention to body language and actions from the patient. 2. Personality disorders can be similar to each other. A person can be diagnosed with one or more personality disorders because symptoms are related to one another according to the DSM-IV. With the symptoms of personality disorders being similar in nature to one another it does make it hard to diagnose a person with a single personality disorder according to the DSM-IV. 3. People with different personalities can be given the same diagnosis. Each person is different so therefore one person’s symptoms may not be the same as another person. The DSM-IV does not account for a person’s individuality. An individual’s personality affects how they react to different situations in life, this can lead to a misdiagnosis by a......

Words: 402 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Abnormal Psychology Case Study

...pre-adoption? When was she adopted? How did the process go? How specifically have her eating and sleeping patterns changed? What is she throwing tantrums over? Describe the tantrums and situations during and before they happen. 2. In addition to the clinical interview, what other clinical assessment tools should you consider? Why? Which ones would you not consider? Why? I’d start off with observation of the family in a natural environment concentrating on not only Clara but her parents as well. 3. If you were preparing to diagnose Clara, you would refer to the DSM-IV classification system to evaluate her condition on five separate axes. What type of information would go into each axis? Note: You are not asked to enter a diagnosis, only describe the kind of information that would be entered in each axis.) Clara is a child who is adopted. She’s having control and/or anger issues in the form of tantrums and her natural sleeping and eating patterns have been disturbed 4. Do you...

Words: 479 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Why Is the Dsm-Iv Is Referred to as the Gold Standard of Clinical Diagnosis?

...clinically significant and associated with intensive distress, impairment, social dysfunction or increased personal or public risk, however it must be unrelated to grief caused by recent personal loss, (4th ed., text rev.; DSM–IV–TR; American Psychiatric Association, 2000; Holt et al, 2012). The distinct criteria and descriptive information in the DSM-IV, enables clinicians to make quick diagnoses based on an individual’s symptoms. It can also be used in legal proceedings, to determine the mental state of individuals and ensure they receive appropriate sentencing in psychiatric care rather than prison. It is versatile and the only manual that strictly focuses on mental health which is why it is referred to as the Gold Standard of clinical diagnosis. The DSM-IV has also played a vital role in the development of research and treatments for mental health, which has improved many patients’ quality of life. Keenan et al. (2007) examined the reliability of the DSM-IV oppositional defiant and conduct disorder symptoms, in 3-5 year old children. The mothers were interviewed about their children’s current symptoms and results showed that the reliability of symptoms, measured by interrater and test-retest reliability, was moderate to high. However, the DSM-IV-TR (2000) 4th ed., text rev. emphasises that the diagnostic criteria are only guidelines and reliability is therefore determined primarily by the clinician’s interpretation of the information provided. In the...

Words: 719 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


...         What were the suggested next steps in your MyFoundationsLab® Learning Path?          How do the skills apply to your academic life?          How do the skills apply to your professional life?          Were you surprised by the results? Why or why not? MyFoundationsLab is a complete online mastery-based resource designed to help assess, diagnose, and remediate students' knowledge of the reading, writing, and math required to successfully place within the credit-earning and development curriculum. The system offers a rich environment of pre-built or customized assessments, personalized learning plans, and highly interactive learning activities that enable students to master skills at their own pace. MyFoundationsLab has a comprehensive diagnostic tool, called Path Builder, to help each student achieve personalized learning. Path Builder diagnostic tests are pre-built to align with common readiness or workplace standards, or they can be customized to fit specific goals. Once students complete a Path Builder diagnostic test, they receive a personalized set of content modules, in a format called the Learning Path. Each content module in a student's Learning Path covers a general concept such as "Fractions" or "Sentences." Once inside a module, a student can take a shorter diagnostic test, called a Skills Check, which defines the exact smaller topics a student needs to understand in order to prove mastery for the module. These smaller topics, for example, might...

Words: 373 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...[TEAM] Read the case, “No Good Deed Goes Unpunished”. Notice that this case was written by another professor and me as a learning opportunity for our students. Yes, this really did happen in a major metropolitan area in the U.S. [ASSUMPTIONS] 1.      Your team has been hired by the Arts Festival to help them, because Mark and the drug store are suing the Festival. 2.      You were hired, because the Festival’s leadership cannot do this for themselves. What that means for you is that they do not need generic answers. They need specifics. For example, do not explain what “readiness to change” means. Instead, assess readiness to change and give your client your results. If they are not ready to change, where do they need to change? Specificity is your friend. 3.      This is not a creative writing exercise even though you are working with creative people. This is a technical report that needs to be straightforward and concise. Develop the case for change by fully completing the following tasks and by supporting your answers with outside sources. (Minimum 5 outside resources.) Be sure to cite your sources in the text and to include a list of references in APA format. Do NOT write this as a set of responses to each task. I have never seen a professional document that simply answered a list of questions. Instead, write your response as a report to a client and let your report demonstrate your professional proficiency in the resolution of complex problems through excellent......

Words: 832 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...evidence. A well-built PICOT question increases the likelihood that the best evidence to inform practice will be found quickly and efficiently. Templates and Definitions for PICOT Questions5, 6 Question type Definition Template Intervention or therapy To determine which treatment leads to the best outcome In _____________________ (P), how does ______________ (I) compared with _________ (C) affect __________________ (O) within _________________ (T)? Etiology To determine the greatest risk factors or causes of a condition Are ______________________________ (P) who have ________________________ (I), compared with those without ________ (C), at ____ risk for ____________________ (O) over _____________________________ (T)? Diagnosis or diagnostic test To determine which test is more accurate and precise in diagnosing a condition In ______________________________ (P), are/is ___________________________ (I) compared with ___________________ (C) more accurate in diagnosing _______ (O)? Prognosis or prediction To determine the clinical course over time and likely complications of a condition In ___________________ (P), how does ____________ (I) compared with ________ (C), influence _____________ (O) over _________________ (T)? Meaning To understand the meaning...

Words: 277 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...Clinical Assessment Psychology 270 May 20, 2012 Mr. and Mrs. Lawson brought their 4-year-old adopted daughter, Clara, to see Dr. Mason, a psychiatrist. Clara was polite in greeting Dr. Mason, but did not smile and kept her gaze down as she took a seat. Mr. and Mrs. Lawson sat next to Clara and began explaining their concerns. They described Clara as a quiet child who has recently begun throwing temper tantrums, during which she is inconsolable. Her sleep and eating patterns have changed, and she no longer wants to go to preschool. 1. What other information would you like to learn during the interview with the family? What questions would you ask? Have there been any changes in Clara’s home life that might have triggered the tantrums’? Do you know about her birth family? Do you know if any kind of mental disabilities such as bi-polar or schizophrenia? How does Clara throw the tantrum? Is it that she is just acting out or is something really wrong? This is important to know because a parent can tell if a child is just trying to get attention. How long now has Clara been attending this preschool? Did the parents do research on the school’s employees or did they just pick the first preschool they found? Have there been any new staff members to start working at the preschool since Clara has been throwing these tantrums? Have there been any deaths in the family human or animal? 2. In addition to the clinical interview, what other clinical assessment tools...

Words: 768 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Appendix G

...affect a diagnosis. 1) Some criteria used for reaching a diagnosis cannot be observed directly. A patient analysis could take place in most cases so that a clinician could gain information about the patient’s symptoms that may be immediately observable in the clinical setting. If this information is not gathered by the clinician a misdiagnosis could be made. Subjective data may include information about the patient’s personality, behaviors or a patient’s reaction to information that cannot be directly from the patient due their inability or reluctance to speak with clinician directly. As an example, if a patient who did not present personality disorders in fear might be diagnosed as having a social phobia. A patient not being truthful has very serious consequences and one could not get the appropriate treatment needed. 2) Personality disorders can be similar to each other. There are several symptoms that overlap between different disorders in DSM listings. A clinician’s personal observation could misdiagnosis between one of these two disorders if the clinician relies only on information gathered in a clinical setting. Disorders such as obsessive-compulsive, anxiety, and personality disorder have many symptoms that are alike. If this was the case a clinician could misdiagnosis and treats the patient incorrectly giving improper medication and the wrong types of therapy. 3) People with different personalities can be given the same diagnosis The......

Words: 334 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Psy Reli

...Discuss issues of reliability and validity associated with the classification and diagnosis of schizophrenia (8+16) One issue related to classification and diagnosis is reliability. Reliability refers to the consistency of a measuring instrument like DSM that is used when diagnosing schizophrenia. It can be measured by the extent to which psychiatrists can agree on the same diagnosis when independently assessing patients (inter rater reliability). The use of DSM III in 1990 was believed by Carson to have fixed any problems of IRR. Therefore the system is now more advanced with the DSM 5, there would be much greater agreement over who did and didn’t have schizophrenia by comparing the diagnosis which would make it reliable. However there is little evidence that DSM is routinely used with high reliability by mental health clinicians. For example Whaley found that IRR between health professionals were low as .11 between different raters. This suggests that when independently assessing patients the diagnosis was rarely consistent between them, meaning the DSM tool is unreliable in accurately and consistently diagnosing schizophrenia. There are also cultural differences about the interpretations of schizophrenia which poses a threat to reliability of the diagnosis of schizophrenia. For example Copeland et al gave a description of a patient showing clinical characteristics associated with schizophrenia to US and UK psychiatrists. From the US psychiatrists 69% diagnosed the......

Words: 809 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...for evidence. Remember evidence is not just what you want the outcome to be... it is evaluating the evidence supporting or refuting what influences the outcome. If you are interested in getting to the heart of the effect of testing Foley balloons on the rates of UTIs then you need to find evidence on the pros and cons of testing the balloon! Question Templates for Asking PICOT Questions: P: Population/disease (i.e. age, gender, ethnicity, with a certain disorder) I: Intervention or Variable of Interest (exposure to a disease, risk behavior, prognostic factor) C: Comparison: (could be a placebo or "business as usual" as in no disease, absence of risk factor, Prognostic factor B) O: Outcome: (risk of disease, accuracy of a diagnosis, rate of occurrence of adverse outcome) T: Time: The time it takes to demonstrate an outcome (e.g. the time it takes for the intervention to achieve an outcome or how long participants are observed). Note: Not every question will have an intervention (as in a meaning question) or time (when it is implied in another part of the question) component. For an intervention/therapy: In _______ (P), what is the effect of _______ (I) on ______ (O) compared with _______ (C) within ________ (T)? For etiology: Are ____ (P) who have _______ (I) at ___ (Increased/decreased) risk for/of_______ (O) compared with ______ (P) with/without ______ (C) over _____ (T)?...

Words: 427 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Maternal Stress Effects

...Special Class Discussion OI or Osteogenesis Imperfecta, which is commonly referred to as Brittle Bone disease. It causes Isaiah to be susceptible to fractures and breaks in his bone very easily. Isaiah was diagnosed with type III OI during the second trimester (20 weeks), which is a very severe form, but survivable. Though the diagnosis was not the best, the couple, Vicky and Dave, have made the most out of the situation. From what I have had the opportunity to observe via the blog, Isaiah is living a full life given the circumstances. Full of Disney whimsy and seasonal outings just as any kid would experience. I love the fact that his parents are both very understanding and even tempered people, from what they present in the blog. Making the childs life as stress free as possible. Though they try not to focus on the hardships in their blog, some of it is very apparent when you read between the lines. One instance is when Vicky wrote about how she could not tell if Isaiahs moaning and crying was due to hunger, a fever or a fracture. The condition carries a huge burden, regardless of how hard the parents try and normalize his life. The parents try and maintain a positive atmosphere, but in my mind I am very curious as to what toll it is taking on their physical and emotional health? Questions: 1) Do you have any plans for Isaiah as he gets older? Education? 2) How is Isaiah in social situations with other children? 3) Does Isaiah have any favorite......

Words: 296 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Auditory Processing Disorder

...central auditory processing disorder (CAPD) is a hearing problem that affects about 5% of school-aged children. They may have a hard time tuning out background noise and find loud noises overwhelming. It may affect your ability to pinpoint a sound, tell which sound comes before another, distinguish similar sounds from one another (such as "seventy" and "seventeen") and enjoy music. DIAGNOSES: A pediatrician rules out other possibilities such as hearing loss related to an ear infection. A speech-language pathologist or school psychologist may also give your child tests that measure receptive language or listening comprehension skills as well as cognitive abilities. But only a trained audiologist can conduct the tests needed to make a diagnosis of APD. No matter how many symptoms of APD a child may have, only careful and accurate diagnostics can determine the underlying cause. It typically isn’t diagnosed until grade school, but there are some warning signs that can be detected in preschool. SIGNS AND SYMPTOMS: Auditory discrimination, auditory figure-ground discrimination, auditory memory, and auditory sequencing. Find it hard to follow spoken directions, especially multi-step instructions, saying “huh?” or “what?” often, easily distracted especially by background noise or loud and sudden noises, trouble with reading and spelling, they struggle with word math problems, trouble following conversation, poor musical ability, trouble learning songs or nursery rhymes......

Words: 330 - Pages: 2