Differences Between Behaviorism and Psychoanalysis

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By sagstang9
Words 352
Pages 2
Shawn Gray
MW 2:30
The theories of Behaviorism and Psychoanalysis are nearly complete opposites. Behaviorists believe that almost every human emotion is “conditioned by habit and can be learned or unlearned” ("behaviorism," 2012). Whereas Psychoanalysts believe that everything humans do is completely controlled by the unconscious mind at some level.
“When a human being acts--does something with arms, legs or vocal cords--there must be an invariable group of antecedents serving as a "cause" of the act” (Watson 5). This is the basis of Behaviorism as stated by one of the originators of the theory. They believe that everything humans and animals do was learned at some point in time, starting at the embryotic level, and has either been unlearned or modified in some way, and that all of these behaviors can be studied by “verifiable observation” just like any of the other sciences (Watson 2). The very basis of Behaviorism makes it very easy to study and quantify its results.
Psychoanalysts, on the other hand, believe that everything we do is in one way or another controlled by our subconscious mind. Freud divided the psychoanalytic theory into 3 parts: id, ego, and superego. The id is the deepest level of the unconscious, and is dominated by the pleasure principal. The object being immediate gratification of instinctual drives. The superego, starts with childhood, and acts like a sensor to what the id wants to do, based on responses from parents and social acceptance. The Ego is part of the id modified by contact with the external world and mediates between the subconscious forces and the outside world. There is very little that can be done to study any results from Psychoanalytic theory since it is not possible to observe in any way the subconscious or any of Freud’s theoretical parts of it. ("psychoanalysis").

Works Cited.
"Behaviorism." The Columbia…...

Similar Documents

Difference Between Two Plans

...1. Trade off is a situation that involves losing one quality or aspect of something in return for gaining another quality or aspect. so it’s mean that if the net baht-denominated cash flows converted to pounds today, they will not be concerned about any future depreciation of the baht that would result in less pound cash flows.

 If the cash flows generated in Thailand are all used to support UK operations, then Blades will have to borrow additional funds in the UK at an interest rate of 10%. 

For example, if the baht depreciated by 10% over the next year the Thai investment will render a yield of roughly 5 percent, while the company pays 10% interest on funds borrowed in the UK Since the funds could have been converted into pounds immediately and used in the UK, the baht should probably be converted into pounds today to secure the company from the additional or expected interest expenses that would be incurred from this action.


 First plan 15% Second plan 8% the cost of goods for 72000 pairs ฿206,712,000 ฿206,712,000 the selling price for 180000 pairs ฿826,920,000 ฿826,920,000 exchange rate £0.0147 £0.016 Net baht-denominated CF ฿620,208,000 in pound - £9,923,328 the interest ฿93,031,200 £793,866.24 baht profit ฿713,239,200 In pound £10,484,616.24 £10,717,194.24 Difference -£232,578 The second plan is better because the cash flow in pound will be higher...

Words: 256 - Pages: 2

Difference Between Adn vs Bsn

...Running head: EDUCATION PREPARATION DIFFERENCES IN COMPETENCIES OF NURSING DEGREES: ASSOCIATES VS. BACCALAUREATES Patel, Hetal Grand Canyon University: NRS 430V Professional Dynamics January 25, 2012 There are many differences in the competencies between nurses prepared at the associate’s degree level versus the baccalaureate level in nursing. The differences in competencies has be seen in the leadership ladder for advancement in the profession of nursing, the ability to provide care, the coordination of patient care, and the membership of an educated interdisciplinary health care team. In my matriculation into Grand Canyon University’s RN-BSN program, I previously researched this topic extensively. In 1965, the American Nurses Association (ANA) took a courageous position in publishing a first position paper asking for the baccalaureate degree to be the minimal level of education for the professional nursing ( A position paper 1965). This was the first documented attempt to change the level of education of nurses from a technical based education to a scientific based education. The position that the ANA held had many of the following obstacles to overcome, the interference of government funding of programs, nurses to see beyond just the technical based profession and the perception of nursing as a caregiver. The ladder of leadership after obtaining an associate degree in nursing (ADN) is the certifications that can be obtain through their professional...

Words: 957 - Pages: 4

Behaviorism

...Assignment #4: Behaviorism Chasity K. Horton March 3, 2011 Development of Lifespan EDPR 2111-008 ABSTRACT The article I have chosen to review is titled Children Learn by Monkey See, Monkey Do. Chimps Don’t. (Zimmer, 2005). The topic of the article is Derek Lyons, a graduate student at Yale University, was doing an observation over how children learn compared to chimpanzees. He observed a little girl by named Charlotte to help him with his studies. I plan to show the similarities between the observation of Charlotte, the Bobo doll study and the social learning theory. From the article, I can conclude that the social learning theory when dealing with children is very true because everything that Charlotte imitated everything that the model or adult did even if it could have been avoided. The article I chose was written after Derek Lyons, observed a preschooler by the name of Charlotte. Lyons used an experiment from two psychologists at the University of St. Andrews which showed how young chimps retrieved food from a box. Lyons did the exact same thing that the psychologists did with the chimps with many other kids including Charlotte. Even though, Lyons did the same thing with the kids as the psychologist did with the chimps, the results were different. From Lyons observation, he saw that children will copy or imitate everything they see, while chimps will not. After observing Charlotte, Lyons found that humans are hard-wired to learn by imitation, even when it is...

Words: 521 - Pages: 3

Difference Between Curriculum and Instruction

.... Though curriculum could arise out of changes in government policy, instruction could occur spontaneously as the teacher and the learner interact in the learning environment. The success of the curriculum highly depends on the methods of instruction put in place by the implementers. Whereas curriculum is developed by ‘specialists’ who in a way prescribe what is to be taught, instruction is done by teachers or instructors who, in most cases, simply provide a guide. For this purpose, instruction takes individual learner difference in mind; the essence of differentiated instruction in which involves addressing the needs of different learners in the same class, while curriculum development assumes that the learners are similar, and operate in the same circumstances (Owen, 2000). The above differences between curriculum and instruction notwithstanding, their importance in an educational system cannot be overemphasized. This is because they are the ones that determine what students should be taught and how it should be taught respectively. None of them can do without the other, as the relationship between them is very close. References Ashcroft, F. S. (2004). Curriculum Development. Washington DC: Elite Publishers. Oliva, P. F. (2008). Developing the Curriculum 7th Ed. Boston: Allyn and Bacon. Owen, S. C. (2000). Modern Trends in Curriculum Development. London: OUP....

Words: 661 - Pages: 3

Differences Between Behaviorism and Psychoanalysis

...Shawn Gray MW 2:30 The theories of Behaviorism and Psychoanalysis are nearly complete opposites. Behaviorists believe that almost every human emotion is “conditioned by habit and can be learned or unlearned” ("behaviorism," 2012). Whereas Psychoanalysts believe that everything humans do is completely controlled by the unconscious mind at some level. “When a human being acts--does something with arms, legs or vocal cords--there must be an invariable group of antecedents serving as a "cause" of the act” (Watson 5). This is the basis of Behaviorism as stated by one of the originators of the theory. They believe that everything humans and animals do was learned at some point in time, starting at the embryotic level, and has either been unlearned or modified in some way, and that all of these behaviors can be studied by “verifiable observation” just like any of the other sciences (Watson 2). The very basis of Behaviorism makes it very easy to study and quantify its results. Psychoanalysts, on the other hand, believe that everything we do is in one way or another controlled by our subconscious mind. Freud divided the psychoanalytic theory into 3 parts: id, ego, and superego. The id is the deepest level of the unconscious, and is dominated by the pleasure principal. The object being immediate gratification of instinctual drives. The superego, starts with childhood, and acts like a sensor to what the id wants to do, based on responses from parents and social acceptance. The Ego......

Words: 352 - Pages: 2

Difference Between Journals and Diaries: -

...Difference between journals and diaries:- The difference between a diary and a journal is that a diary is where you can write down what happened during the day and keep a record of stuff. A journal is to write your own personal feelings in, and things that happened, and how they happened. A diary is a report of what happened during the day—where you ate, who you met, the details that what was happened in the office, and who took whose side. It is a like a newspaper about you. A journal is completely different. A journal is about examining your life. It’s a GPS system for your spirit. Journals lead to insight, growth, and sometimes, achieving a goal. You can keep a journal in anything that feels comfortable and that’s portable–a spiral notebook, a bind book you have put together with lokta paper, index cards held together with a rubber band. You can use a computer; keep a blog, although that doesn’t work as well for me. But things on the internet are simply not private, password protected or not. To keep a journal on paper, pick a time of day to write. Keep it regularly. It makes it easier. Try that you didn’t stuck to an exercise program because then it can nailed it into schedule at a certain time. Writing works the same way. First thing in the morning, last thing at night, while eating lunch at your desk. Write with a good pen that feels good and whose color you like. In the beginning, you may have to set a time limit. Three minutes is good. Just write whatever...

Words: 593 - Pages: 3

Difference Between Adn and Bsn

...Difference Between Associate- Degree Level Nurses and Bachelor- Degree Nurses There is always a question about which program is better; Is it the associate’s degree in nursing program provided by community colleges or the baccalaureate of science in nursing program provided by colleges and universities? One similarity is for sure that nurses from both programs can take the NCLEX-RN exam. Before I started college I was debating whether I should go to school for an Associate Degree in Nursing or a Baccalaureate of Science in Nursing, but because I just had a baby and the university is one hour away from our home, I decided to go ahead and enter the registered nursing program in our community college. I know that there is a lot of differences between nurses that are prepared at the associate-degree level versus the baccalaureate degree level in nursing that is why I set a goal that someday I will go back to school for my Bachelor’s degree. This paper will be explaining the difference in competencies between nurses prepared at the associate degree level versus the baccalaureate degree level in nursing by comparing their education, patient care and opportunities. This paper will also give some examples about a patient care situation in which how nursing care approaches to decision making may differ based upon the educational preparation of a BSN versus ADN. Associate Degree Nurses and Baccalaureate Nurses Differences with Education An associate’s degree in nursing (ADN...

Words: 1096 - Pages: 5

Difference Between Cells

...The Difference Between Cells Your name SCIE206 AIU Online Abstract This paper is intended to inform the reader on the way photosynthesis and respiration are linked in order to provide living things with energy. Also how some cells use glycolysis to produce energy from sugar created in photosynthesis. Lastly, how cells use enzymes as biological catalysts to increase the rate of reactions. The Difference Between Cells During photosynthesis cells receive energy from the sun which is then combined with carbon dioxide and water to create something called glucose (Editorial Board, 2013). Photosynthesis occurs in green plants such as seaweed, algae and other green plants. This process is very important because the byproduct of this process is oxygen which is very essential to all living organisms. Plants produce a lot of glucose and sometimes so much that it is more than they need. The plant uses this glucose to produce things like leaves and flowers and other growths that take place on the plant. The glucose is then transformed into cellulose which is a part of the structural wall a very sturdy material. Humans depend on glucose just as plants do however humans are not able to produce their own glucose so humans actually rely on plants to produce it. Cellular respiration is a chemical breakdown of glucose that was created through the photosynthesis process, and converting that glucose into larger amounts of adenosine triphosphate. Adenosine triphosphate also known as...

Words: 865 - Pages: 4

Difference Between Resultant and Equilibrant

...| | |hemispheres of the brain are | |brain enable emotions, memories, and sensory | | |separated by severing the corpus | |experiences | | |callosum (the large band of fibers | | | | |that connects them), the transfer | | | | |of information between the | | | | |hemispheres ceases, and the | | | | |coexistence in the same individual | | | | |of two functionally different | | | | |brains can be demonstrated. | | | | |George Miller-The......

Words: 700 - Pages: 3

Difference Between Law and Rules

... they appear to mean the same. Strictly they do not mean the same. There is in fact some difference between them in terms of their usage and connotations. One of the main differences between rules and regulations is that by rules you restrict and by regulations you control certain procedures. By ‘traffic regulations’ you tend to understand that the traffic is controlled by certain procedures. By ‘traffic rules’ you tend to understand that you should follow certain restrictions when it comes to moving in a traffic. A regulation becomes a legal rule. For example a regulation issued by a local government or an administrative agency becomes a legal rule. It becomes a restriction that has legal force. On the other hand a rule is traditionally defined as “Generally an established and authoritative standard of principle; a general norm mandating or guiding conduct or action in a given type of situation”. It is important to note that in legal translation the word ‘regulation’ is used to denote a set of rules that have legal connotations. Regulations are official in use whereas rules are not official in use. Regulations pertain to a workplace such as an office or a firm. On the other hand rules pertain to games, sports and the like. In short it can be said that rules are quite often associated with games or sports. They describe how a particular game or a sport should be played. Another way of differentiating regulations from rules is that regulations are a set of standards that...

Words: 5737 - Pages: 23

Behaviorism

... why things work or happen the way they do) we are using today. Watson (1913), published psychology views behavior as purely objective, experimental branch of natural science with the theoretical goal of forecasting and controlling behavior, introducing the study of behaviorism in American psychology (“Using APA,” 2013). Watson used Russian, physiologist Ivan Pavlov's and American psychologist Edward Thorndike works to instigate the behaviorist movement. Ivan Pavlov Classical Conditioning, Edward Thorndike Connectionism, and B. F. Skinner Operant Conditioning were the dominated behaviorist explanations in the field of psychology. Pavlov's Classical Conditioning, Thorndike's Connectionism, and Skinner’s Operant Conditioning Pavlov's Classical Conditioning study proposed an unconditioned stimulus (UCS) involuntarily elicits an unconditional response (UCR) when matched with a conditioned stimulus to create a conditioned response (Marks, 2011, pg. 675). Pavlov studied canine unconditioned boost (nourishment) would trigger an unconditioned response (salivation) and he believed this reflex was "hard wired". By pairing a neutral stimulus with an issue, we can predict or replicate the occurrence of some other stimulus or event (pg. 676). The dog's associated food with the echoing of the bell can be linked to learning by doing, thus shaping a desired behavior to discover a new one. Thorndike's Connectionism theory lies in the foundation of relationships between specific stimuli...

Words: 1354 - Pages: 6

Behaviorism

... major principles of learning that now characterize behaviorism. His research was designed to uncover the neural mechanisms associated with digestion; while conducting his experiments, however, he noticed that his subjects, the dogs, began salivating not just in response to the food, but also in response to other environmental cues, such as the lab attendants who brought the food (Kretchmar, 2008). As Mazur (1994) writes, "Pavlov recognized the significance of this unexpected result, and he spent the rest of his life studying this phenomenon, which is now known as classical conditioning" (p. 58). B.F. Skinner in 1938, developed operant conditioning and he was able to see the differences between elicited and emitted responses. Skinner focused on studying behavior and its causes. While in grad school at Harvard, Skinner began to build a chamber with a feeding device that registered when a rat was able to trigger the lever to feed. Skinner was prompted to make on the basis of his studies with the operant chamber between two kinds of responses, respondent (Pavlovian) and operant (instrumental). Whereas respondents were elicited by preceding stimuli, operants were controlled by their consequences (the reinforcement contingency)(Colwill, 2014). By being able to conduct self-instructing and self testing, he believed that any response could be enforced. Skinner also believed that any behavior will change into a desired pattern by reinforcements. Skinner also believed that rapid...

Words: 1286 - Pages: 6

Behaviorism

... began to make out own decisions. Society still has still conditioned us to the rights and wrongs that are expected of us, while we may not do everything are parents taught us we continue to what is expected by society. I think because we are always being conditioned. I am reminded of the movie “Trading Places”; two rich business men change the lives of a homeless man and a well off business man. Both men adapted to their environment, the homeless man became a great businessman and the businessman developed survival skills that involved stealing. I work with people with developmental disabilities conditioning helps with the people we serve. This is where this is used more commonly today. “At Best, It applies to simple observable motor behavior of rats, pigeons, individuals with developmental disabilities and small children in highly controlled, artificial, or contrived situations.” (Moore, 2013) Although this person does not like behaviorism, he or she is right about the uses. In conclusion, behavior psychology plays a big role in our lives. Just about everything we do, we have been trained to do it. Watson was pretty passionate about his belief in behavioral psychology. Through the passion he was able to prove how the changes occur through conditioning. References Magnavita, J. (2012). Theories of Personality . San Diego: Bridgepoint Education, Inc. Moore, J. (2013). Three Views of Behaviorism. The Psycological Record, 681-692....

Words: 733 - Pages: 3

Difference Between Law and Morality

...HU 4640 ETHICS Homework Assignment: Difference between Law and Morality Instructor: Mr.Garmon Student: Mr. Rupert L.Griffith 03/31/15 The Debate between Law and Morality: Laws are absolute rules prescribed by government representatives, while morality has to do with personal views on what is right or wrong. A major difference between these two concepts is that a law is formal public policy that has consequences for those who violate it. Someone who murders or steals, for instance, goes to jail if found guilty in court. In contrast, someone who violates what others view as a moral standard may have no tangible consequence other than damaged relationships. Laws are sometimes viewed as legislation on moral issues. Many people lean on religious beliefs to frame their moral viewpoints. Politicians and some citizens also point to faith-based principles in suggesting that laws should follow what God commands. Others believe that laws should protect individual rights and freedoms but should not extend to topics viewed as ethical gray areas. In some cases, laws and morals evolve over time based on changing societal views. The Civil Rights laws of the 1950s and 1960s developed as Americans became more supportive of an end to segregation. Sometimes, though, principle-based politicians and leaders look to enact laws based on personal convictions, even though they may contradict the popular opinion of the time. My Position on this View: This would lend itself to the current...

Words: 584 - Pages: 3

Behaviorism

... that all human behavior, public and private, is explained in terms of its functional relations with environmental events. Radical behaviorism is often misrepresented in the literatures of education and psychology. Two fundamental misconceptions of radical behaviorism are that its followers (1) are logical positivists who require that a phenomenon be observed by two or more people before it qualifies for scientific analysis, and (2) either will not or cannot incorporate private events (e.g., thoughts, feelings) into their analyses of human behavior. There are two types of behaviorism involuntary which means reflexes, physiological states (e.g. heart rate, often associated with emotions) and voluntary -purposeful activity behavior to get something operant conditioning Behavior changes that are in response to the consequences Skinner’s ABCʼs. Behaviorists view observable behavior as an important subject matter in its own right and avoid interpreting behavior as a sign of some other psychological phenomenon as other psychological systems do; instead, behaviorists seek to identify predictable relationships between environmental events and behavior. Although the totality of all possible environmental events is theoretically limited only by natural physical laws, behaviorism categorizes all environmental events into three types: neutral events, antecedents, and consequences. Only antecedents and consequences are of interest to behaviorists, who refer to them as stimulus events...

Words: 1683 - Pages: 7