Free Essay

Direct to Consumer Advertising

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By melissacomparato
Words 1068
Pages 5
Business Ethics
Second Paper – Deontological Analysis
June 19, 2013

Direct-to-Consumer Drug Advertising: Ethical or Not? The United States and New Zealand are the only developed countries that allow direct-to-consumer advertising. Whether the practice of direct to consumer advertising is beneficial to the consumers or not is a highly debated subject with both positions presenting sound reasoning for their position. Whether the practice is beneficial or not to the consumer is not the question, but rather, is advertising prescription drugs directly to consumers ethical? To analyze this question I will use Rawls’s second principle of distributive justice for analysis.
(2) use that method, developing the argument in support of your case; In utilizing direct to consumer advertising for prescription drugs is the advertising “reasonably expected to be to everyone’s advantage”? and “attached to positions and offices open to all?” (DeGeorge 78) One of the predominate claims of the pharmaceutical companies that the advertisements educate the consumer, thus giving them more information to evaluate their needs and to speak intelligently with their doctor. So, is the information provided in an ad or commercial “reasonably expected to be to everyone’s advantage?” It is reasonable to assume that everyone is exposed to the ads with the various media outlets used, such as TV, radio, newspaper, magazines and so forth, but is the education to everyone’s advantage? The drug companies receive a great deal of returns for every dollar spent on the advertising, thus increased profits which benefit the employees and stockholders of the company. Insured American’s may fall under the benefit, as noted by supporters, of seeking medical attention earlier resulting in an earlier diagnosis and, in some cases, treatment for something that may have gone completely untreated. Treatment of depression is used a lot as an example of a once undertreated disease that people have now received treatment for as a result of the advertisements removing a degree of the stigma associated with the affliction. Supporters also emphasize the increased treatment of ailments with the newest drug on the market, due to the advertising and education. Is this always to the consumer’s advantage? What about cases where side effects of the drug have not been fully realized before the drug is released, but the consumer’s desire for a cure to their problem prompts the request for the medication per the claims made in the ad. This was the case for Vioxx that was advertised to be a great reliever of arthritis pain. “The FDA estimates that Vioxx was responsible for as many as 139,000 heart attacks and almost 30,000 deaths from heart attack or stroke.” (Woodard abcnews.com) The Vioxx ad did not have this information as these were unknown severe side effects of the medication. Assuming that not only the highly qualified personnel that created Vioxx, but also the FDA personnel, took all proper measures and examined complex data and concluded that the drug was safe to release, that poses the question of the ability of the average consumer to truly understand the risks associated with a drug even if the information is provided in a handout with the medication. This is a point of opponents of the DTC advertising. The average consumer, without proper training and knowledge of the medical field, cannot evaluate a drug based on an ad. This can also complicate the relationship between the patient and the doctor. While some doctors say the advertising helps in the discussion with the patient because the patient has some information, others hold the position that patients requests for medications may not be in their best interest and doctors, in an effort to please the patient, prescribe the medication though another one may have done as well, or better, for a lower cost.

In regards to the price of prescription drugs, supporters note that the advertising promotes competition among the drug companies, thus driving the drug prices down. Assuming that this is true, which is disputable in itself, “some opponents also suggest that DTCPA increases health care costs because visits to the physician prompted by a drug ad can be a waste of time and money”.(nih.gov) So if the prices are driven down then that would be of benefit to some and if they are, in fact, increased that would be of impact to all consumers. This ethical analysis does not require an answer as to which point of view is true.

For this ethical analysis, the questions are if direct-to-consumer drug advertising is “reasonably expected to be to everyone’s advantage” and are the advantages “attached to positions and offices open to all?” (DeGeorge 78) So the drug companies are making more money and insured Americans are obtaining better health, but what about the least advantaged group? What benefit does drug advertising serve to someone that is uninsured and unable to pay for the drug? Has Rawls requirement of the acceptable inequality been met? Acceptable inequality is acceptable as long as the least advantaged group benefits along with the more fortunate. Direct-to-consumer advertising does not meet this requirement as it is of no benefit to the least advantaged group of society such as the uninsured. This also confirms that the advantages are not “attached to positions and offices open to all.” By Rawls second principle of distributive justice direct to consumer drug advertising is unethical.

“Why are nations and people divided on the appropriateness of direct-to-consumer pharmaceutical drug advertising?”(DeGeorge 320) As stated at the beginning of this paper the United States and New Zealand are the only two developed countries that allow DTC drug advertising. Acknowledging that within the US opinions are split as to whether DTC drug advertising is beneficial or harmful and that other developed countries, such as our friends in Canada and Europe, still ban drug advertising, the question of whether DTC drug advertising is ethical would not hold up to Kant’s “Act only according to that maxim by which you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law.” (DeGeorge 65)

Works Cited

DeGeorge, Richard T. Business Ethics. 7th ed. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 2010. Print
Woodard, Larry D.“Pharmaceutical Ads:Good or Bad for Consumers?” abcnews.go.com. February 24, 2010. http://abcnews.go.com/Business/Wellness/pharmaceutical-ads-good-bad-consumers/story?id=9925198#.Ucv5jdLVC5w

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3278148/

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Summary: Direct-To-Consumer Advertising

...Direct-to-Customer advertising is “any promotional effort by a pharmaceutical company to present prescription drug information to the general public in the lay media" (DeLorme et al, 2011). Essentially the DTC method allows consumers to have influence over which medicines are prescribed to them because drug information is provided to them in advertisements. Advertising to consumers this way is a form of social marketing because it is “a tool or framework that relies on multiple scientific disciplines to create programs designed to influence human behavior on a large scale" (Edgar et al, 2011). Advertising to people like this is not social marketing because “although social marketing relies heavily on the incorporation of a communication strategy...

Words: 511 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Direct To Consumer Advertising Essay

...Direct-to-consumer advertising of prescription drugs has become a controversial subject. Proponents argue that such communication by the pharmaceutical industry leads to better-informed consumers and improved quality of care. Correctly done advertising can inform the public of certain diseases and Increase awareness about Illnesses. Learning about treatment options can motivate patient to contact their physicians and engage in a more informed conversations about their health concerns. Ads can shape an understanding for symptoms, which increase the likelihood that patients will receive appropriate care for conditions that are frequently under-diagnosed and under-treated. By helping patients identify problems early, Direct-to-consumer advertising can...

Words: 580 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Direct To Consumer Advertising Essay

...their product thru the media. Since the 1980's, drug companies started to advertise their products to the general public (www.fda.gov), since then raised many question from both medical professionals and the public. Questions such as: How does this affect the patient and physician relationships, does the ad give me as the patient enough information to consider the drug, and why doesn’t my physician prescribe this drug to me. These just are some of the questions patients are asking themselves while watching or reading these ads. These ads are known as Direct-to Consumer Ads or DTCA. We as patients go to our healthcare providers for health answer by way of medications, advice or recommendation. Physicians...

Words: 795 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Denotology

...the pharmaceutical representatives to the Doctor’s then to the consumer. Every day you see on television’s, in magazines, the radio, and on the internet advertisements of new drugs being developed that offer a possible cure. No one wants to be ill, but do these advertised drugs really cure one’s issue or just mask it temporarily according to their ad? Are the doctor’s really giving you the correct medicines to cure you or are they pushing a product for the pharmaceutical company for promotional purposes? The United States and New Zealand are the only two countries that consider direct-to-consumer pharmaceutical advertising, ethical. Drug advertising advise the consumers about key, treatable health conditions and foster doctor/patient dialogue. I believe when consumers see these advertisements they try to self-diagnose themselves and sometimes finding themselves seeking additional medical attention by going to their primary care physician. “A study has shown DTC advertising is likely to increase the demand rates of both the drug category and drug brand choices, as well as the likelihood the drugs would be prescribed by physicians.” (Woodard) Adversaries of “direct-to-consumer advertising (DTC) argue the FDA has inadequate resources and many claims make it on air.” (Woodard) The amount of regulatory actions engaged by the FDA against pharmaceutical companies and their marketing prescription drugs to consumers has tumbled intensely in recent years. In 1997 the DTC reduced...

Words: 811 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Deontology

...Deontology Paper Direct-to-Consumer Advertising (DTC) has been a long disputed ethical dilemma. The United States and New Zealand are the only two countries that allow it. By using Rawl's principles of justice, I will explain to you why I feel that this kind of advertising is ethical. There are different kinds of justice. Commutative justice refers to transactions being just. This kind of justice involves keeping transactions fair to both parties of the transactions. The transaction will be fair if both parties "have access to all pertinent information about the transaction; enter it freely and without any coercion; and benefit from the transaction"(DeGeorge, pg 76). Commutative justice is central to business transactions, but distributive justice is central to the actions of the government. John Rawls formulated a theory of distributive justice. He developed these principles in hopes that all rational persons find them acceptable. The principles are universal, respect all people, and can be rationally accepted by everybody. Rawls felt that people would agree "to two specific principles of distributive justice" that can be used in "establishing a just constitution" (DeGeorge, pg 78).These principles are: • First: Each person is to have equal right to the most extensive basic liberty compatible with similar liberty for others. • Second: Social and economic inequalities are to be arranged so that they are both a. reasonably expected to be to everyone's advantage and b...

Words: 1346 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Chapter 13

...Marketing Communication and Personal Selling CHIPS AND DIPS ARE HARDLY BIG-TICKET ITEMS. MOST PEOPLE DON’T THINK TWICE ABOUT THE BAG OF CHIPS OR CHEESE SNACKS THAT THEY THROW INTO THEIR SHOPPING CARTS. CONSUMERS JUST KNOW THAT THE FRITO-LAY NAME AND ITS BRANDS MEAN GOOD-QUALITY, GOOD-TASTING SALTY SNACKS. REVENUES AT FRITO-LAY, A SUBSIDIARY OF PEPSICO, GREW BY MORE THAN $600 MILLION—6 PERCENT—IN ONE YEAR ALONE. ANNUAL WORLDWIDE SALES OF FRITO-LAY SNACKS ARE OVER $10 BILLION. IMAGINE SELLING BILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN CHIPS A YEAR! Americans know Frito-Lay brands at sight: Doritos, Fritos, Lay’s, Cheetos, Ruffles, Rold Gold, and Baked Lay’s, to name its most popular. But how did Frito-Lay get where it is today? How has the company developed such astounding sales and loyalty among chip aficionados? Much of it has to do with Frito-Lay’s promotional plan, encompassing advertising, sales promotion, public relations, and personal selling. With a $30 million a year U.S. ad budget, Frito-Lay has plenty of opportunity to get its message of great-tasting snacks across to consumers. Frito-Lay has been a long-time repeat advertiser during the annual Super Bowl telecast, shelling out more than a million dollars for just one ad during the program. The vast audience provided by the Super Bowl telecast has proved to be an excellent launching pad for Frito-Lay’s new brands, such as Baked Lay’s Potato Crisps in 1995 and Lay’s Deli Style Potato Chips in 1998. Baked Lay’s went on to become the...

Words: 2882 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Direct-To-Consumer Advertising Affect The Field Of Pharmacy

...2. How does direct-to-consumer advertising affect the field of pharmacy? The only positive aspect to the direct-to-consumer advertising is it is an avenue for patients will ask questions based on the drugs that are advertised. I believe this helps with the patient education aspect of the job. If patients ask questions about the drugs are advertised, they may start asking questions about the medications that are prescribed to them as well. The drawback to direct-to-consumer is the patients may prefer the drugs that are advertised opposed to the more efficient drugs. If this occurs, the pharmacist can further educate patients on why the advertised drug is not the best option. This can potentially weaken the relationship between the pharmacist...

Words: 285 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Veil Of Ignorance: Direct-To-Consumer Drug Advertising

...The third aspect considers whether all rational beings, thinking rationally, should accept it regardless of whether they are the agent or the receiver of the action” (DeGeorge 67). While considering a principle or action, we must also consider it from the point of view of the receiver. John Rawls, a deontological philosopher, created a way to apply this categorical imperative by using a veil of ignorance to consider whether a practice is fair to all affected parties. “A fair or just solution is one that all would agree to behind a veil of ignorance” (DeGeorge 78). As a stakeholder in a pharmaceutical company, one believes that direct-to-consumer drug advertising is fair and moral because they want to market their products by informing the...

Words: 305 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Deontological Paper

...MGMT 368 Business Ethics Week 4 Deontological Second Paper April 15, 2012 Direct-to-consumer drug advertising - Deontological Point ofView For many years, consumers relied and depended on the expertise and knowledge of physicians to make decisions on their pharmaceutical needs. Before 1985, prescription drugs could not be advertised directly to consumers. The U.S Food and Drug Administration passed a rule that allowed Direct-to-consumer drug advertising in 1985. This ruling was passed on the condition that warning information was provided about side effects and other dangers. “Directto- consumer advertising is the promotion of prescription drugs through newspaper, magazine, television, and internet marketing. Drug companies also product a range of other material, including brochures and videos, that are available in doctors office or designed to be given to patients by medical professions or via patient groups.” ("Source Watch") Currently the United States and New Zealand are the only two developed nations that allow direct-to-consumer advertising of pharmaceutical drugs. Other nations feel that direct-to-consumer advertisements are often just sales pitches that pressure doctors to make unnecessary prescriptions. ("Prescription drug ads") I favor direct-to-consumer advertising/marketing of pharmaceutical drugs and believe that it is ethical. In this paper I will be using the deontological ethics of Immanueal Kant' s Theory to support my reasoning. Immanuel Kant...

Words: 699 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Marketing

...Unit 11: Advertising and Direct Marketing     Advertising:   Advertising is any paid form of nonpersonal presentation and promotion of a product by an identified sponsor using the mass media that is intended to inform or persuade members of a particular audience. For many, advertising is the most familiar and visible element of the promotion mix. Because it can convey rich and dynamic images, advertising can establish and reinforce a distinctive brand identity. This helps marketers bond with customers and boost sales. Advertising is useful in communicating factual information about the product or reminding consumers to buy their favorite brand. Advertising sometimes suffers from a credibility problem because cynical consumers tune out messages they think are biased or are intended to sell them something they don’t need. Advertising can be expensive; therefore, firms need to take great care to ensure their messages are effective. Mass consumption and geographically dispersed markets make advertising particularly appropriate for marketing products using the same promotional messages to large audiences.   Types of Advertising:   Product Advertising Product advertising is an advertising message that focuses on a specific product. This is the type of advertising the average person usually thinks of when talking about most promotional activities.   Institutional Advertising Institutional advertising is an advertising message that promotes the activities, personality, or...

Words: 6175 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Marketing Course Work

...of advertising, public relations, personal selling, sales promotion, and direct marketing tools that the company uses to persuasively communicate customer value and build customer relationships. THE FIVE MAJOR PROMOTION TOOLS The Nature of each Promotion Tool ADVERTISING Each promotion tool has unique characteristics and costs. Marketers must understand these characteristics in shaping the promotion mix. Advertising: Any paid form of nonpersonal presentation and promotion of ideas, goods, or services by an identified sponsor. For example, advertising includes broadcast, print, Internet, mobile, outdoor, and other forms. Advertising Objectives The first step is to set advertising objectives. These objectives should be based on past decisions about the target market, positioning and marketing mix, which define the job that advertising must do in the total marketing program. An advertising objective is a specific communication task to be accomplished with a specific target audience during a specific period of time. Advertising objectives can be classified by primary purpose – whether the aim is to inform, persuade or remind. Informative advertising – this advertising is used to inform consumer about a new product or feature or to build primary demand. Persuasive advertising – this type of advertising is used to build selective demand for a brand by persuading consumers that it offers the best quality for their money. Some persuasive advertising has...

Words: 2351 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Business Research

...Online Advertising Really Moves Offline Product Steve Warshaw, VP, Business Development, ACNielsen Phil Cara, Director, Yahoo! Inc. 6 Consumer Insight | Summer 2004| c o v e r s t o r y A woman goes online to research a question about her dog’s health. While surfing Yahoo!, she sees a dog food ad. Later that week, she goes to the store and encounters the same brand of dog food. She buys it. Breakthrough stuff? Absolutely. It may sound ordinary: Consumer sees ad; consumer responds. Yet in the world of e-commerce, manufacturers of consumer packaged goods have never been sure how often exposure to a product message online translates into a product purchase offline. Now they can be. Since 2002, ACNielsen and Yahoo! have been working together on a measurement tool to assess the correlation between a person’s surfing and shopping habits. This joint effort is called Yahoo! Consumer Direct— powered by ACNielsen, and for 18 months, Consumer Direct has combined the reach and technology of Yahoo! with the analytical tools of ACNielsen Homescan. The program evaluates the effectiveness of online advertising and promotions by consumer packaged goods (CPG) companies like PepsiCo, Kraft, Unilever and Nestlé. The study results are consistent—and satisfying. They indicate that online promotions can lift offline sales time after time, whether the item in question is a food, personal care or household product. Furthermore, each campaign has typically brought in more than twice the...

Words: 1887 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

‘Yahoo Consumer Direct Marries Purchase Metrics to Banner Ads’ Case Analysis Group 6 What Is Consumer Direct ? 1. Describe the Research Design for Consumer Direct. 2. Discuss the Strengths and Weaknesses of the Research

...‘Yahoo Consumer Direct Marries Purchase Metrics To Banner Ads’ CASE ANALYSIS GROUP 6 What is Consumer Direct ? 1. Describe the research design for Consumer Direct. 2. Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the research design. VASUNDHARA KEDIA MANDEEP PRADHAN SUDESHNA CHOWDHURY SOURABH SONI SHAURYADIPTA BASU NILOY BISWAS Consumer Direct, is a sequence of online advertising procedures done in conjunction with ACNielsen’s Homescan panel. In this process, Yahoo sets ads to target consumers, and the Homescan network is households that have elected to partake in such studies. From here households reflect back to the advertising agents after viewing a product on-line at Yahoo, and after a cool-down period of six weeks are then placed in the stores to see the purchasing power that the advertisement had on consumers that are part of the Homescan panel. The metrics of this advertising is to view the effectiveness of the ad targets, and the persuasiveness of the advertising to make consumers to want to go out and get the product. Consumer Direct used the descriptive research design. This design aims to observe and describe the usage of Yahoo without influencing the public in any way, in order to determine the effectiveness of the advertising on Yahoo. This design includes describing any behaviours, performing a case study, observing the amount of advertises being bought or look at through Yahoo, and lastly a questionnaire or presentation. The goal is to be more effective and efficient...

Words: 1085 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Dell Owned and Operated Manufacturing Plants in Brazil, China, India,

...COMMUNICATION: ADVERTISING COMPENDIUM (C.A.C.) CHAPTER 1 — INTRODUCTION TO ADVERTISING CHAPTER OBJECTIVES 1. Discuss the elements of effective advertising. 2. Define advertising and identify its types and roles. 3. Identify the five players in the advertising world. 4. Explain the evolution of the advertising industry and the current issues it faces. CHAPTER REVIEW Effectiveness is at the heart of companies’ desire to advertise. Though advertising ultimately aids in the sale of products or services, other factors such as price or lack of distribution may influence purchase decisions. Advertising effectiveness tends to be measured in terms of communication impact such as exposure to a message, awareness of a product, attention, and involvement. Most responses can be categorized as perception (seeing), learning (thinking), persuasion (feeling), or behavior (doing). Effective advertising stems from a combination of carefully planned strategy that connects to audience members on an emotional level and that isolates a need the product fulfills, creative that delivers the strategy, and strong, arresting executions. Six components comprise the classic definition of advertising. Advertising is a paid nonpersonal communication from an identified sponsor using mass media to persuade or influence an audience. Advertising can be classified into one of nine types. National consumer or brand advertising focuses on building long-term brand identity...

Words: 28864 - Pages: 116

Premium Essay

Business and Management

...Direct marketing From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia For distribution and retail sales of comic books, see direct market. | This article needs attention from an expert on the subject. Please add a reason or a talk parameter to this template to explain the issue with the article. Consider associating this request with a WikiProject. (February 2011) | Marketing | Key concepts | Product marketing Pricing DistributionService Retail Brand managementAccount-based marketing EthicsEffectiveness Research SegmentationStrategy Activation ManagementDominance Marketing operations | Promotional contents | Advertising Branding Underwriting spotDirect marketing Personal salesProduct placement PublicitySales promotion Sex in advertisingLoyalty marketing Mobile marketingPremiums Prizes | Promotional media | Printing Publication BroadcastingOut-of-home advertising InternetPoint of sale Merchandise Digital marketing In-game advertising Product demonstration Word-of-mouth Brand ambassadorDrip marketing Visual merchandising | v t e | | Wikibooks has a book on the topic ofMarketing | Direct marketing is a channel-agnostic form of advertising that allows businesses and nonprofits to communicate straight to the customer, with advertising techniques such as mobile messaging, email, interactive consumer websites, online display ads, fliers, catalog distribution, promotional letters, and outdoor advertising. Direct marketing messages emphasize a focus on the customer, data...

Words: 3218 - Pages: 13