Discussion of the Stanley Milgram’s "Perils of Obedience"

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By lookingforogesh
Words 866
Pages 4
Discussion of the Stanley Milgram’s "Perils of Obedience"
As Milgram writes in his article, for some people obedience is a deeply “ingrained behavior tendency”, which can create an impulse that can override past ideas in morality and ethics. While his experiment focused closely on the psychology behind response to obedience, his central idea conveyed substantial themes which bore on conceptions of professional ethics. One of these themes involved the previously underestimated significances of the potency of authority in influencing decision-making, even ones that go against one’s own conscientious imperatives.
As most of us are “indoctrinated” in our childhood to develop a basic conception of values and virtues, one of the things we as human beings have grasped, through many phases in our evolution as societal creatures, is the importance of obedience to some form of authority. This scheme, now deeply ingrained in our psychology, plays a very strong role in the decisions we make daily, including playing a part towards trumping moral values, including possibly a code of professional ethics. [EXAMPLE]
Individual morality, according to Milgram’s opinion, can be heavily compromised in the face of authority figures, in fact suggesting that in truth, in our society, individuality may be something that does not exist at all, and that the vast majority of our decision making may have sociological origins. In fact as Stanley Milgram showed, the weakening of the individual’s moral conscience is by far the most significant impact of a system of obedience to authority.
Individual morality, although still a factor in determining one’s action in the face of authority, is easily outdone by a multitude of other factors relevant to obedience. First was the (feeling of) giving up of any personal responsibility that takes precedence when one becomes only the “representative” to a…...

Similar Documents

Obedience Behavior

...Psychology Obedience Behavior For doing a similar like the one like Milgram did there many different tactics you can use to enforce obedience behavior instead of pain like; you could use fear especially someone has an extreme phobic of something or fear something could happen if they don’t do their job. The power of fear conqueror many things especially if someone doesn’t have a strong will power to conqueror there fear or it doesn’t has to do with you could have fear through the power of having love for something the will enforce fear. Since you enforce the fear in the person even if you have subject doing the job you told him to do, one of a few things could happen they will question you about what they’re doing is wrong or even unmoral hearing you tell them to keep doing that may be humiliating them hearing you the authority figure saying to continue will be reassuring since they are getting paid for the job and hearing they will not get in trouble make the person more convincing to keep doing his job and not listen to the other subject when he says he want to stop that’s when you have the other subject use the power of fear on that person to make him comply. Which for this to work on the person, he has to be in a believable environment. Another angle the experiment could happen if the first subject is with a group of people seeing everyone is doing the same job with without anyone refusing they’re more willing to be obedience to comply to the unmoral...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Stanley Works Case Study

...[pic] Organisational Change Management in Stanley Works Introduction The change process of management in an organisation is not an easy task to implement and execute; especially, if the employee’s are already immune to the company’s existing organisational culture, practices, policies and standards. Waddell/Cummings & Worley (2011) cited in Lewin’s Change Process (2001) suggested that an evolutionary three phase theory would motivate people and cultivate newly acquired patterns of behaviour (Waddell/Cummings & Worley 2011). In addition, if the organisation is operating in diverse locations globally - the transition of change ideology to a state of equilibrium will be compounding. In this connection, the incumbent paper will discuss change of management implemented in Stanley Works Business Structure. The document will also contrast types of change adopted by Stanley works Australia (Andrews et al 2011 (p.1-7). representative of maintaining global competiveness and sustainability. The parent entity perspective will be highlighted and criticised as academic discussion to determine a structured adaptation of the four major components of the organisation; people, process, structure and technology utilised during transition. To improve the company’s ‘strength through structure’ the company’s performance would benefit from investing in collective intelligence, capability, competence and values, and in particular the adoption of a better marketing approach and...

Words: 4027 - Pages: 17

Discussion of the Stanley Milgram’s "Perils of Obedience"

...Discussion of the Stanley Milgram’s "Perils of Obedience" As Milgram writes in his article, for some people obedience is a deeply “ingrained behavior tendency”, which can create an impulse that can override past ideas in morality and ethics. While his experiment focused closely on the psychology behind response to obedience, his central idea conveyed substantial themes which bore on conceptions of professional ethics. One of these themes involved the previously underestimated significances of the potency of authority in influencing decision-making, even ones that go against one’s own conscientious imperatives. As most of us are “indoctrinated” in our childhood to develop a basic conception of values and virtues, one of the things we as human beings have grasped, through many phases in our evolution as societal creatures, is the importance of obedience to some form of authority. This scheme, now deeply ingrained in our psychology, plays a very strong role in the decisions we make daily, including playing a part towards trumping moral values, including possibly a code of professional ethics. [EXAMPLE] Individual morality, according to Milgram’s opinion, can be heavily compromised in the face of authority figures, in fact suggesting that in truth, in our society, individuality may be something that does not exist at all, and that the vast majority of our decision making may have sociological origins. In fact as Stanley Milgram showed, the weakening of the individual’s moral...

Words: 866 - Pages: 4

Stanley Kubrick

...Running Head: KUBRICK Stanley Kubrick G138 Introduction to Film There have been many different directors that have had an important influence on modern film. Yet there have only been a handful that not only influenced it, but truly changed how an entire genre of film was perceived. Like no other before him, Stanley Kubrick forged a path that no other had treed. He had an eye for a story and a way to retell it in a manner that was uniquely different and memorable. On the quiet evening of July 26th 1928, in the Bronx of New York City Stanley Kubrick was born. At a very young age he showed a passion for music and especially photography. This same passion was not seen in his basic school work though. By the time he graduated High School he only had a 67 average. This low score made it very hard for him to find a college to attend. So instead he moved on to become a freelance photography for the magazine Look. As a photographer he was able to travel a great deal, an experience that helped in opening his eyes to everything around him. It created a thirst for knowledge and the desire to learn more. This desire brought him to the doorsteps of Columbia University where he enrolled as a non-matriculating student. While attending Columbia he became even more influenced by photography, which turned into a growing passion for the understanding of the film process. Often times, he would sit in during classes taught by Lionel Trilling, Mark Van Doren and Moses Hadas (SK-TMF...

Words: 2094 - Pages: 9

Obedience

...Obedience is a form of social influence that occurs when a person yields to explicit instructions on orders from an authority figure. Obedience is compliance with commands given by an authority figure. In the 1960s, the social psychologist Stanley Milgram did a famous research study called the obedience study. It showed that people have a strong tendency to comply with authority figures. Milgram’s Obedience Study Milgram told his forty male volunteer research subjects that they were participating in a study about the effects of punishment on learning. He assigned each of the subjects to the role of teacher. Each subject was told that his task was to help another subject like himself learn a list of word pairs. Each time the learner made a mistake, the teacher was to give the learner an electric shock by flipping a switch. The teacher was told to increase the shock level each time the learner made a mistake, until a dangerous shock level was reached. Throughout the course of the experiment, the experimenter firmly commanded the teachers to follow the instructions they had been given. In reality, the learner was not an experiment subject but Milgram’s accomplice, and he never actually received an electric shock. However, he pretended to be in pain when shocks were administered. Prior to the study, forty psychiatrists that Milgram consulted told him that fewer than 1 percent of subjects would administer what they thought were dangerous shocks to the...

Words: 1700 - Pages: 7

Blind Obedience

...Name: Andraie Lewis Eng. 122 May 8,2013    Blind obedience   Society often view obedience as a good quality or trait to have; employers want obedient employees and parents often wish for obedient children. Being obedient means that an individual shows respect for an authority figure and will carry out the instructions they are given; when someone is obedient they are widely accepted by society, because they do whatever it is that society asks of them. But obedience carried too far can have disastrous consequences to both the individual and society; this is referred to as blind obedience.  Blind obedience is when a person follows authority without even thinking about the consequences that the order to which they are obeying carries. It’s as if the authority figures are puppeteers and the people blindly obeying them the puppets. Puppeteers and their puppets best illustrate the relationship between the authority figure and the people doing horrendous actions, because being obedient is the right thing to do. So many events in history have proven how inhumane human beings can be when following authority. Stanley Milgram, a psychologist at Yale University, conducted one of the most controversial experiments in history, in attempt to demonstrate how individuals can lose themselves to an authority figure. Milgram’s experiment was called “Obedience to Authority.”   Theodore Dalrymple wrote an article titled, “Just do...

Words: 2109 - Pages: 9

Perils of Obedience

...The Perils of Obedience by Stanley Milgram Stanley Milgram’s “ The Perils of Obedience” shows that some people can obey authority even when it requires committing terrible actions within their society. Milgram begins his essay by describing what obedience is and how deeply ingrained of a behavior tendency that it is. He then sets up an experiment at Yale University that will push the limits of human obedience. He has a “teacher” give out a series of simple word pairs for the “learner”. If the learner gets a word pair wrong then the teacher gives out a series of shock ranging from 15 to 450 volts. The teacher who is the real subject in the experiment does not know that the learner is a paid actor who does not receive any actual shocks. The motivation behind this experiment for Milgram was to test just how far people would go to obey the command of an authority figure. Milgram’s theory is that the subject will have total control of what they are doing and will disobey the authority figure when inflicting pain onto a hopeless human being. One of his subjects, Gretchen Brandt, is participating with the experiment when the learner got the word pair wrong she showed the self control to stop shocking to not continue. Milgram thought that this is how the majority of subjects would react, “Her behavior is the very embodiment of what I envisioned would be true for almost all subject”(Milgram, 44). Brandt simply wasn’t worried about rejecting the authority if it meant that she no...

Words: 682 - Pages: 3

Stanley Milgrim's Experiment on Obedience

...Stanley Milgrim’s Experiment on Obedience. Obedience is an act in which a person is in compliance with a serious if orders or requests by law or authority. Authority figures thrive on individuals that follows orders from an authority, because individuals like these are easy to have control over in social environments. In the early 1960s a social psychologist for Yale University named Stanley Milgrim, orchestrated a series of obedience experiments to obtain direct empirical data to support his belief that a persons character shouldn’t be a determination of how a person’s behavior changes once being influenced by an authority figure. Social psychology utilizes scientific methods to determine how and why an individuals thought process, feelings and behavior can be influenced by another human being. A number of topics are analyzed in social environments including group behavior and leadership. Social psychologists like Milgrim engross themselves in social environments and group interactions, and how they have an affect on attitudes and behaviors of an individual. The behavior of an individual is a reflection of that persons morals, it consists of how a person conducts him or herself as well as rationalizes situations. Social psychologists believe that once an individuals are placed in a group setting their behavior is subject to change. Authoritarian leaders, also known as autocratic leaders mirror the role of dictators. Auttocratic leaders are independent thinkers...

Words: 729 - Pages: 3

Obedience

...Erin Poulsen ACP W131 Mr. Scanlan 19 October, 2015 Comparative Critique Obedience and Disobedience has been a part of key moments in history. Many have studied forms of obedience to learn how it affects people and situations. For example, Stanley Milgram conducted a well-known experiment in which the subject, named the “teacher” must shock the “learner” every time he doesn’t remember a word pair from a memory test. The focus of this study is on the teacher, and whether they will administer killing shocks when told to by an authority figure. Another well-known experiment is the Stanford Prison Experiment conducted by Philip Zimbardo. A group of college boys were separated into two groups, prison guards and prisoners, and were put into a mock prison to test how obedience plays out in a prison setting. Many others have studied obedience and discussed key aspects of them. In Erich Fromm’s “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem”, Fromm discusses varieties of obedience and disobedience. He argues that Similarly Theodore Dalrymple examines blind disobedience to authority in his article “Just Do What the Pilot Tells You”. Dalrymple argues that there needs to be a balance between obedience and disobedience. Fromm begins his article by pointing out that for centuries people believed that disobedience is a vice and obedience is a virtue. He goes on by stating that in actuality obedience and disobedience can be either a vice or virtue depending on certain situations...

Words: 1013 - Pages: 5

Morgan Stanley Case Review

...A Morgan Stanley Case Study Operating Globally Through Technology Course: MGMT420 STRATEGIC MODELING Crn: 29022 Group Members: Nicole Blenman Mark Hamel-Smith Allison Joseph Cynthia Kennedy Kelly Singh Lecturer: Ms. Kinda McGowan April 18, 2015 Introduction Morgan Stanley was founded as an investment bank in New York in 1935, it has evolved into one of the world’s foremost financial institutions, with more than 45,000 employees on six continents. Though headquartered in the U.S., they are a leader in the integration of financial services around the world. As technology links them closer together the firm is in a unique position to address the increasingly global needs of their clients. Morgan Stanley mobilizes capital to help governments, corporations, institutions and individuals around the world achieve their financial goals. ▪ As a global bank it provides: Investment banking advice on mergers and acquisitions, financial restructuring and privatisation. ▪ Major underwriter of stocks and bonds and provides research, sales and trading services in almost every type of financial instrument. ▪ Manages private partnerships that invest in venture capital, property and other private equity opportunities. ▪ Provides other related products and financial services, including credit cards. At its foundation are four core values — putting clients...

Words: 2604 - Pages: 11

Stanley Milgram

... of obedience and authority. If the study would have used participants from Russia, the results might have to yield higher scores in the area of those participants who would have shocked the students to maximum levels. There is a reason, and the explanation might take on the form of the Russian society dictating policy to follow the Kremlin because it is good. Do you think the results of the study are important and relevant to contemporary society? Explain. Stanley Milgram has a study that is criticized, praised, and repeated until this day. The foundation for why people obey in this experiment and accessing measures why people do what they do is a structure for any future experiment. Stanley Milgram created a formula for gauging how someone will react to authoritative orders. The Milgram experiments have been the basis of television, research journal, songs, and story lines. The Milgram experiment is the crust of obedience and authority analysis research in contemporary society. According to studies by historians of psychology, social psychology textbooks are still giving significant space to Milgram’s conclusions, but fewer pages than ever to serious criticism of his work (Baker, 2013). . Cherry, K. A. (2008). The Milgram obedience experiment. Retrieved from http://psychology.about.com/od/socialinfluence/fl/What-Is-Obedience.htm...

Words: 1162 - Pages: 5

Covenant Obedience

...Bible 105 November 16, 2014 Covenant Obedience The first three kings of Israel were Saul, David, and Solomon and each had their own strengths and weaknesses. Each king obeyed and disobeyed God, receiving blessings and punishments as a result. At the end of Solomon’s reign, due to his disobedience, Israel was a divided nation. The rise and fall of each king depended on their covenant obedience. During the early years of Israel, the nation was looked after by judges. The Israelites were very disobedient and would continually turn their backs on God until they needed him. God used several judges to bring the Israelites from underneath the oppression imposed on them by various groups such as the Moabites, the Ammonites, and the Philistines. Each judge had a specific quality that would have made them less than worthy for a great position in the eyes of the people. For instance, Ehud was left-handed, Gideon was a coward, and Samson was an adulterer but God deliberately choose the least likely candidates to prove that anything is possible when you trust in Him. According to Judges 21:25 (HCSB), “in those days there was no king in Israel; everyone did whatever he wanted. This cycle of disobedience to God, and God raising up a judge, eventually led the way to kingship. Because a judge could only partially and imperfectly administer Torah (legislative function), executive justice (executive function), and condemn lawbreakers (judicial function), a king was needed who...

Words: 1035 - Pages: 5

Obedience to Authority

...Running Head: POWER OF SITUATION AND OBEDIENCE TO AUTHORITY The Power of the Situation in Milgram's Obedience Experiments Ahsan Chishty Ohlone College POWER OF SITUATION AND OBEDIENCE TO AUTHORITY The Power of the Situation in Milgram's Obedience Experiments Stanley Milgram is a name universally known for the Yale professor who shocked the world with his experiments on obedience. In 1961, Milgram along with many other colleagues devised an experiment after receiving a grant from the National Science Foundation to conduct an experiment in response to the trial of Adolf Eichmann. Milgram wanted to know if Germans under the rule of authority figures did exactly what they were instructed to do by those of higher power than them due to the fact that many of the explanations for the Nazi atrocities was simply that Nazi soldiers were following orders. After placing an ad in the New Haven Register for a learning experiment on the study of memory. According to Thomas Blass (2009), offering participants $4.50 and a paid bus fare for an hour of their time seemed to be the biggest factor that attracted people to the ad but several of the participants also agreed to be a part of the study to learn something about themselves, expand their curiosity about psychology, or because they were fascinated by memory and hoped to understand it better through an experiment like Milgram's. The subjects were introduced to a man in a lab coat...

Words: 1884 - Pages: 8

Stanley Kowalski and Power

...       The intense desire for power is a feeling that many human beings may have. In Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire, the theme of power is very evident throughout the play. Stanley Kowalski’s hunger for power has led him to violence. He is a man who takes pride in what he does and his role as the head of his household. His brutal and abusive attitude is one that readers are made aware of the moment he comes into the scene. In the first seen he is seen hurling raw meat to his wife showing his animalistic approach to life. All of his authority is put into question when Stella’s sister Blanche comes over for a stay.             Always Stanley’s power upon others is served with a side of violence. In scene three we witness what happens when he feels that he is losing power. Stanley has been losing money from the poker playing and needs to save face with his buddies. He complains that that the women are talking too loudly, and then complains again when Blanche turns on the radio. He gets up and switches it off himself. Blanche, who obviously doesn’t see Stanley as a threat, turns it back on and begins to waltz with Mitch. Then Stanley who has been drinking takes the radio and hurls it out the window as a sign of superiority and putting his foot down. When Stella tells his friends to leave he chases her and beats her. Stanley has been losing money from the poker playing and needs to save face with his buddies.            ...

Words: 265 - Pages: 2

Stanley

... students’ online registration was also extensively discussed. The challenges being faced by students in their online registration were critically examined by the committee. It was unanimously agreed that more effective software should be developed by the College to allow for easy registration by students. 4.3 On-Line Generation Of Matriculation Numbers The committee deliberated on the need to develop system whereby matriculation numbers would be issued to students online immediately after their registration. The issue was raised in view of the present arrangement whereby the college had a backlog of un-allotted matriculations numbers. The committee descended that the issue would be tabled for further discussion during subsequent meetings 4.4 Co-Opting School Officers Unto The ICT Committee Meeting A member suggested the inclusion of school officer into the committee to make the committee more vibrant in decision making and implementation. Consequently, members adopted the suggesting by supporting the expansion of the committee to include school officers. In the same vein, the committee mandated the chairman to request for the deployment of an administrative officer to the ICT to who would be assisting the director in the administrative matters of the centre. 4.5 Period Of Meeting Fixed The committee adopted that the meeting of liason officers be held on 2nd Wednesday of every month to allow for constant thrashing of matters relating to the ICT in the......

Words: 494 - Pages: 2