Free Essay

Disgrace

In: English and Literature

Submitted By amanihezam
Words 1358
Pages 6
In J.M Coetzee’s Disgrace, it is a very powerful novel that has many unfortunate events all taking place in South Africa. J.M Coetzee wanted to really outline the topic of racial oppression in South Africa and interlink it with very grim themes that are very raw and brutal. There are many themes in the novel ‘Disgrace’’ such as sex, family (relationship between David and his daughter Lucy), violence, men and masculinity, and women and power. In this essay, my main focus is the theme of women and power and the injustice they face in their society. This essay will also briefly explain how the men’s perspective towards women can be viewed as degrading and immoral. It is an intense theme, the text represents a male dominated society and women are followers. It outlines the idea that men do not value women, they have very little respect for them. It also emphasizes the idea that men hold a lot of power compared to women. However, throughout the novel the characters, especially David, they change. He is represented as an arrogant man, feels superior. Throughout the novel, his character tends to change; he becomes powerless in the sense that he loses everything, his job, and reputation and not to mention his dignity.

David Lurie is an intriguing character; he is a professor teaching romantic poetry and has so much passion for literature and arts as well as culture but the irony is that his personal life is led by ignorance, this is evident in the way he objectifies both Melanie and Bev Shaw. David’s thoughts and values are recognized through his actions and personal thoughts as well as his morals. They all portray who he is as a man. He is portrayed in the novel as a morally flawed male who only craves and yearns for sexual encounters. His priority is to satisfy his cravings even if it means going about it the immoral way. David’s relations with the women he has come across both physically and emotionally inspire and gives him more experience, he believes it helps him develops as a person yet it does not seem to change him or the way he views women.

As readers, we get to read his personal thoughts, how he views the world, what he desires, how his thoughts differ when it comes to his daughter Lucy and his sexual partner Melanie. His weakness is Melanie, she brings out the frail side of him, he cannot act arrogant nor superior when he’s with her and that in it self is quite intriguing because David’s character is very arrogant. His ego gets the better of him; this is recognized when his colleagues confront him about the incident that happened between him and Melanie. He acts superior, he does not care nor does he fear the serious consequences that he will face. His self-importance gets the better of him and prevents him from acknowledging his misconducts and therefore refuses to cooperate in the hearing because he feels that admitting what he has done is wrong dishonors who he is a man. He will feel disgraced.

The theme of women and femininity is strongly outlined in the novel Disgrace. Melanie, Lucy and Bev have a strong influence in the text, they portray the way of how women are being objectified and degraded in a patriarchal society. The novel portrays these three women in a negative light, very weak, vulnerable, full of pity and lack self respect. For example, after the horrific incident Lucy had faced (getting raped by three boys) she feels like she’s responsible for the attack, she portrays the idea that she deserved what she got. She states that perhaps this is another act of service, a twisted way of payment so she can live on their land. Lucy’s character can be interpreted in many different ways, some readers can interpret her character as strong and independent, has courage to want to stay and live for herself, please herself and not depend on anyone else and therefore refuses to run away after the attack. On the other hand, a handful of readers can completely have a different viewpoint towards her as a character, as a woman. She portrays the idea that getting attacked/raped is something she’s guilty for; the rape is justified because ‘’ this is Africa’’ this submissive act depicts women as fragile and not worthy of respect. ‘’She does not reply. She would rather hide her face. Because of the disgrace. Because of the shame.’’ This quote is very significant because it represents Lucy’s emotions and feelings towards the incidence. This is what the visitor wanted to achieve, to symbolize their masculinity and feel superior even if it meant being abusive and committing an awful sin. They destroyed Lucy’s confidence and self worth, they showed her what a woman was for. Another shocking act is the fact that Petrus’s character is depicted as morally flawed in the sense that he neglects the topic of Lucy’s horrible attack and tends to only focus on the fact that David’s car has been stolen. This shows his perspective on women and how belittles he thinks of them, he is willing to protect his family’s name even if it means ignoring something so immoral and injustice

The topic of women holds great importance when it comes to the text, not only does Lucy suffer and has to deal with an upsetting attack but Melanie is portrayed as a weak girl too. She does not stand up for herself nor does she uphold her self worth as a woman. David’s affair with Melanie really outlines his character and portrays the idea that he’s morally flawed. He states that Melanie has made him feel like a younger man, like someone more alive and new and open to experiences. She gave him a sensational thrill and for that reason he felt it was necessary to pursue the relation between them. He is sex driven and his sexual needs are far more important than a woman’s worth. This has a negative impact on Melanie because there’s a thin line between rape and a sexual encounter. However, its not as simple as it seems, Melanie does not fight nor refuse to have sex with him, instead she encourages the idea and therefore it prevents it from being labeled as ‘rape’ He took advantage of her and he was aware of what he was doing which makes it more of a revolting act. He certainly manipulated her by convincing her that ‘’a woman’s beauty does not belong to her alone...she has a duty to share it’’ Melanie’s character symbolizes weakness, this is evident of the way she lets David to objectify her and use her for what he believes she’s good for, satisfying his sexual needs. Melanie then turns into a vulnerable character that does not act or refuse to be degraded. Her passiveness depicts the idea that she’s allowing David to degrade her, she does not believe she’s worthy of respect. This is a common trait in this novel, that all women are defenseless and allow the men to have control over them, mentally and physically.

In conclusion, the novel disgrace written by J.M Coetzee’s, a major theme is women and power. In this case, the women lack power and men seem to dominate in a very negative way. All the women in this novel have been subjugated somehow, some more than others. J.M Coetzee novel has a serious element to it; it is not a generic type of story that has a happy ending. It symbolizes life and sometimes the events that occur in reality do not always have happy endings. He shows us the harsh reality, it has no comic relief, no humor, the seriousness itself is a great technique to get readers more aroused and wanting to read more. The theme of women and power is portrayed extremely well in this novel as well as gender inequality and injustice.

References
Coetzee, J. disgrace . south africa: secker & warburg.

dailey, v. a review and commentary on disgrace by J.M Coetzee . 2.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Tragedy vs. Sonnet

...daughter, Cordelia, who truly love King Lear the most, could not find a word to properly express her love to the king, which infuriates him. Lear divided his kingdom to Goneril and Reagan while disinherited Cordelia. His thoughtless decision was paid off by a series of tragedies. Goneril and Reagan betrayed Lear; and later the sorrow death of Reagan, then Goneril, Cordelia and finally Lear end the tragedy. Sorrow with King Lear’s misfortune, Shakespeare wrote Lear Sonnet 29 that partially express his sympathy with Lear. Thus, the state of disgrace referred to in this sonnet have been said to be real. Sonnet 29: “When in disgrace with fortune and men’s eyes I all alone beweep my outcast state, …. That then I scorn to change my state with kings.” Looking at this sonnet by itself, one could see that the speaker seem to cry alone with pity when nothing is working the right way for him. He uses depressing words such as “disgrace”, “beweep”, “outcast state”, “bootless cries”, “curses my fate” to express his stressful emotion. “ And trouble deaf heaven with my bootless cries,/ And look upon myself, and curse my fate,” At the same time, he prays God, but thinks that God does not listen to him. Then he curses his fate and wishes to be like others, who have a better skill, capability, range, and mental ability. “With what I most enjoy contented least/ Yet in these thoughts my self almost despising, / haply I think on thee, and then my state,” It’s unspecified......

Words: 582 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Animals in Disgrace

...Coetzee uses animals in his novel Disgrace to become metaphorical images of the characters and in some way the characters become animal-like characters. It also reflects the struggles that they go through in the post-colonial era. Animals are significant in the novel Disgrace become metaphorical to the people in the novel and how their situations that they find themselves in change them to become the animals. A certain situation can make them result into a certain animal, but they also change from one animal to another animal, depending on what curve ball life troughs at them. According to Patton (2009) it is clear that from the beginning of the novel David Lurie has a strong distinction between humans and animals. He believes that “We are from different order of creation from the animals.” (Coetzee: 1999, 74). Humans are not equal to animals in any way, humans have a soul that is not bound to them, before we are born we were already a soul, and when a person dies his soul leaves his body, where as an animal’s “souls are tied to their bodies and die with them.” (Coetzee, 1999, 78).David believes that animals do not have a proper soul, but his seeing changes and by the end of the novel, he finds that humans are equal to animals. He is in the room, the room where he and Bev organize the death of the animals, and David comes to a realisation and he thinks to himself “here the soul is yanked out of the body…” (Coetzee: 1999, 219). According to Meier (2006): David Lurie......

Words: 1226 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Disgrace Essay

...English 2210 9 November 2012 In Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee we are introduced to David Lurie, the protagonist and narrator of this novel. David Lurie is a 52 year old divorced man, who lives in Cape Town, South Africa, as a respected romantic poetry professor at a university. His life is full of sexual, non-committed relationships. After being accused of inappropriate behavior with a student, Lurie loses his job at the university and must move in with his daughter, Lucy, in the country. Throughout the novel we see many references to animals, especially in relation to Lurie. Because he is the narrator of the novel, these animal references lead the reader to believe Lurie is describing himself through these animals. Lurie uses descriptions of animals as a way to describe how he feels about himself. We see Lurie go from a sexually charged predator, to a strange beast who has been hunter, to a dog-man, and then finally to a helpless dog who is ready to be put out of his misery. David Lurie is a predator at the beginning of the novel. He is a man searching for sex, and for the most part he is successful at it. His first sexual interest he introduces us to is Soraya, a prostitute who he has been going to see for a long time. Lurie describes them having sex by comparing them to snakes engaged in intercourse, "lengthy, absorbed, but rather abstract, rather dry, even at its hottest" (Coetzee 5 ). Being the narrator, this shows the reader how David views himself, as well as......

Words: 1194 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Classics

...father and argues that he should be able to hit his father and mother like how his father hits him. On the other hand, North Vietnam was creating havoc by trying to unify Vietnam under communist belief but failed causing a huge number of fatalities. These two are similar in that in both situations two parties who didn’t want to be involved were forced against their will and it caused a bigger conflict than before. -In both Lysistrata and Hair, it talks about individuals who don’t want to partake in the war. In Lysistrata it talks about women who want their husbands and sons to be withdrawn from the war while in Hair it’s about individuals themselves who want to avoid being drafted. -Athens’ surrender in disgrace can also be compared to the US forces leaving Vietnam in disgrace. Movie Question CENTAURS: Was there a religious aspect to the Peloponnesian war? There was a religious aspect to the Peloponnesian war although the gods didn’t play an active role in Thucydides work because it was acknowledged that history was determined by the choices and actions of human beings. Instead, religion and the pieties played critical roles in the actions of the Spartans and Athenians because religion played such a big role in their society and time. The gods existed constantly in their minds and affected their decisions each and every day, as well as brought out the truth and justice in the war. * None at all. The Peloponnesian War was a struggle between rival alliances......

Words: 401 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Holocaust

...meant to disgrace their religion, heritage and family. Some elders’ however encourage or do not have a problem with this, they understand their children get the tattoo so they wouldn’t have to go through the pain of having that heinous memory forever in ink wherever they got it tattooed. Nazi’s not only tattooed them to get the pleasure of disgracing their own religion and maybe having them spend an eternity in Hell, but only so tell Jews aside from Non – Jews. They could also identify the Jews with that barcode number; it was not just used for degradation. Elders’ believe that getting a replica of their barcode is ignorant because of the disrespect it shows, but they also believe that it’s a better choice than the stupid tattoos their children get nowadays. If one of my family members had a tattoo that was meant to bring disgrace and dishonor to my family, religion or heritage, I would definitely not get a replica. To be honest, I would actually encourage my elder to get it removed. I would tell him to get another tattoo over it, but tattooing is not allowed in Judaism. I would also encourage my elder to stronger than ever in his religion, he broke one of the laws in the Old Testament, which surely means an eternity in hell. To pray and ask for forgiveness, he had no control over the decision, I’m sure God would understand. In conclusion, I think the youth of the Holocaust survivors should not duplicate a tattoo that was obviously used to humiliate and disgrace......

Words: 533 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

English

...convenience of manipulation through one's weakness. Othello, a Moore and Venetian General, weds Desdemona, the girl of Brabantio, a Venetian leader. Iago, Othello's ancient, and Cassio, Othello's fresh appointed lieutenant, accompany fictional character and Desdemona to Cyprus. Iago, angry as a result of fictional character failed to appoint him as general, uses Roderigo, Desdemona's admirer, to realize retribution on Cassio and fictional character. Iago manipulates Roderigo, Cassio, and fictional character by mistreatment their individual weaknesses as a catalyst to their downfall and supreme disgrace. Iago exploits Roderigo's love for Desdemona to injure Cassio. Iago exploits Cassio's weakness for alcohol to squander his name and rank. Iago exploits Othello's weakness for Desdemona and belief within the military system to accumulate retribution. Iago uses Roderigo as a pawn in his plot to disgrace Cassio. Roderigo expresses his weakness to Iago in stating "It is silliness to measure once to measure is torment" (Act1-3)Rderigo's passion for Desdemona blinds his reason, therefore creating him at risk of manipulation. Iago exploits this vulnerability and manipulates Roderigo to believe he can facilitate him attain Desdemona. Iago can "make my fool my purse" and gain wealth attributable to his alleged facilitate of Roderigo. Through this increase in money standing, Iago believes he receives retribution by turning into superior to others. Iago any exploits Roderigo by forcing......

Words: 665 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Power in Relationships in Disgrace

...Disgrace Essay: Question 2 “Disgrace can be seen as an exploration of the relationship between the powerful and the powerless.” Set in post-apartheid South Africa, amidst a large scale shifting of power in many forms countrywide, Disgrace can very much be seen as an exploration of the relationship between the powerful and the powerless. Disgrace delves into power dynamics in various, contrasting relationships, and explores these dynamics between people of different race, gender, generations, positions of authority, and even those between humans and animals. During the course of the novel, various questions surrounding power in interpersonal relations are raised, and by the conclusion of Disgrace, Coetzee leaves us with profound thoughts and suggestions on which to dwell. In just about every relationship in Disgrace, the themes of dominance and power are present, albeit to varying degrees. There are four main relationships to which the subject of power is central: those between Lucy and Petrus, the rapists, and her father, and that between Melanie and David. Analysing these relationships with reference to Hegel’s view of “history being determined by a cycle of domination and counter-domination in which individuals who strive to fulfil their need for recognition are entrapped” (Marais 2008:35) greatly enhances the understanding of power and its context within the various relationships in Disgrace, especially with regard to Lucy’s decisions after her rape, and to Lucy’s...

Words: 1334 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Mental Illness and Stigmatization

...who emitted fear and dislike towards the adolescents. Mental wellbeing disgrace is even broad in the medical profession, in any event to some degree in light of the fact that it is given a low necessity throughout the preparation of doctors and GPs (Wallace, 2010). Firstly, it implies that mental wellbeing issues are on a standard with physical sicknesses and may come about because of restorative or physical brokenness in some way. In other words, people with mental illness are not on the same level as 'normally' functioning people. Secondly, the medical model infers conclusion, and determination intimates a name that is connected to a 'patient'. That name may very well be connected with undesirable characteristics and this again will propagate the view that individuals with mental wellbeing issues are diverse and ought to be treated with alert. For example, 'crazy' people are unable to function properly in the society and may act in a violent manner. People who suffer from mental illness face certain challenges such as an inability to enjoy life, isolation and social stigma. They might additionally encounter disgrace towards oneself a burden that is prevalent among people with a dysfunctional behaviour. Self-stigma is the disguising by the mental wellbeing sufferer or their view of segregation (Link, Cullen, Struening & Shrout, 1989) and perceived stigma can altogether influence sentiments of disgrace and lead to poorer medication results (Perlick, Rosenheck, Clarkin,......

Words: 913 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Lumber Room

...as ironic and pointless but somehow comic. He used it in order to deride the human vices and to show inefficiency of actions of moralistic, hypocritical persons. Munro was killed on the French front during the First World War. His sister in her Biography of Saki writes: “One of Munro’s aunts, Augusta, was a woman of ungovernable temper, of fierce likes and dislikes, imperious, and moral coward, possessing no brains worth speaking of, and a primitive disposition.” Naturally the last person who should have been in charge of children. The character of the aunt in the Lumber – Room is Aunt Augusta to the life. The text tells us a story about a small boy Nicholas, who was brought up by his tyrannical and ungoverned aunt Augusta. He was "in disgrace" as he had refused to eat his wholesome bread-and-milk that morning. When children were taken to Jagborough sands Nicholas made some attempts to get into the gooseberry garden. As a matter of fact, he had no intention of trying to get into the gooseberry garden, but it was extremely convenient for him that his aunt should believe that he had unsympathetic. Soon his aunt tried to look for the boy and slipped into the rain-water tank. She asked Nicholas to fetch a ladder but the boy pretended not to understand her, he said that she was the Evil One. After this accident they both kept silent and everyone has been shipped in their thoughts. The theme of the text is about relationship between two generations: a little boy Nickolas and......

Words: 2123 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Why Female Sexworkers Are Stigmatised

...WHY FEMALE SEX WORKERS ARE STIGMATISED Stigma is defined as a mark of disgrace associated with a particular circumstances, quality, or person. Stigma affects the interactions sex workers have with the people who have a profound impact on the overall wellbeing for example landlords, doctors, nurses, family and friends. Most people do not have a clear understanding of how stigma affects directly and indirectly and how it shapes those sex workers. Generally stigma is however linked to how people who hold the most power influence and treat those who hold less power. According to Goffman a sociologist defines it as a “deeply discrediting” attribute that reduces an individual “from a whole and unusual person to a tainted, discounted one”. Stigma usually arises in the sense that people tend to blame and judge sex workers as people who are socially and culturally immoral. The reasons why female sex workers are easily stigmatised because they are discriminated and blamed for increasing the infections transmitted especially HIV and AIDS. Being a disgrace to a tradition or religion. Another reason could be how these female workers and their clients break the laws of the country. However according to Goode he points out another factor that contributes to the and he postulates that the stigmatisation is a feature of a patriarchal culture that prevails in some societies where women are tend to be judged and expected to live up to “high expectations” in terms of their dressing and how......

Words: 405 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Disgrace

...Duy D. Ly 04.16.2009 Professor Rooney Post-Colonial Literature Disgrace, J.M. Coetzee In Disgrace, race plays a predominant role in the novel. Disgrace is set in post-apartheid South Africa and, although apartheid has ended, traces of racial conflicts still haunt the land and its people. In the novel Coetzee emphasizes the racial tensions and the interaction between whites and blacks when Davis Luries arrived in Salem. Disgrace can be interpreted in many ways regarding racial perception, but there is no doubt that Coetzee’s purpose is to raise the question about the new South Africa and the white people within it. The book portrays a brutal picture of life in post-apartheid South Africa, the fate of the two white characters (David and Lucy) on the land, lost with dignity and freedom. Disgrace depicts a white father and daughter’s journey though life while losing everything under the racist black rule. Disgrace is written in a direct, unique style using clever word choices. An example of the racial nature of this book is when David Luries stated, “English is an unfit medium for the truth of South Africa,” (Coetzee, P.117). It is as if David was referring that English is not the type of language for Africans. David Luries lives in a dark world with dark desires. His frequent demand of sex leads him to his downfall. Melanie is a prefect example of David’s desire. “She is wearing black tights and a black sweater. Her hips are as slim as a......

Words: 1093 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Final Paper Engish

...between the hills like white elephant and no name woman would be that both of the women became pregnant with a child that came from a relationship that was just not meant to be or that did not last long. The differences between both of the texts would be that Jig wanted to abort her baby while the aunt in the other text did give birth and then committed suicide. Each of these stories has conflict, they are imaginary, and they have some rising action. The two differences that were between the two texts were that Jig wanted to have an abortion just so that she could go on with her life like she did before she had gotten pregnant. In the other text the aunt did have her child and then committed suicide because she did not want to be a disgrace to her family for having a baby out of wedlock. Also another difference would be that aunt after she had the baby because she lived in a Chinese village where that went and destroyed her home and her crops because the village people did not believe in having a baby in a non-lasting relationship. Jig was not sure about going through with her abortion even though her boyfriend wanted her to go through with it , he wanted Jig to make her own decision about the situation so that he would not have to take the responsibility of her emotions about the situation. Jig was having thoughts about having the abortion or not having the abortion she was having a hard time with making her decision but she wanted to do what was best......

Words: 1156 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Disappointment

...to the sickly feeling of disappointment? What if it is you who is disappointing someone you love? Throughout life we strive to be the superhero to your children or the perfect angel child for your parents; when something goes wrong it cuts so close because they fail to live up to the lofty expectations placed for them. In the poem “Catch,” by George Bilgere, he tells a story of a boy who becomes discouraged when his above average father fails in his eyes at a crucial part of their family dynamic: baseball. This poem portrays a relatable situation from when the boy is young to when he becomes a father himself with humiliation and disgrace learned through ageing. In the beginning of the poem the father, from the eyes when the boy is young, is portrayed as an admirable dad to people looking from the outside but to the young boy he is a disgrace because he is a failure at baseball. The father let him “stay up late/ talk about baseball at dinner/ watch the fights unfold like grainy nightmares in Gillette’s Cavalcade of Sports…” He was all into baseball yet he was poor at the sport. The father gave baseball so much hype in the house hold that the expectation left for the son was so high that he felt humiliated to be seen with the father. Of course this disappointed the boy because he expected everything to be perfect and the best part of life to this boy was ruined because the father was unsatisfactory. At the end, the tables have turned because it is now 30 years later......

Words: 412 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Birthmark

...well- known scientist, marries Georgiana who at birth received a birthmark on her left cheek that looked like a small handprint. After being married Aylmer for some time he did not like the birthmark that was on her cheek and asked if she ever wanted it removed. She too decided that since her husband did not like the birthmark and she did not want to be a disgrace to her husband that she would have the birthmark removed. He then took her to his lab and he got to work on something that was going to get the birthmark to go away. Georgiana said over and over that if he could not get rid of it then she did not want to live. He finally came in with a cure. He tested it on the plant that had blotches on its leaves. The flower began to grow and the blotches disappeared. Georgiana then decided to take the potion. She fell asleep and her husband sat by waiting. After a while the birthmark then disappeared and with his excitement he woke his wife. They were both excited that the birthmark had disappeared but shortly after Georgiana had passed away. Knowing that he husband did not like her with her birthmark and her feeling like a disgrace to her husband she agreed to allow her husband to get rid of the birthmark, before she had no issue with her birthmark. Her husband was only worried about what was on the inside, and by getting rid of the birthmark he was messing with God’s design especially when she trusted him so much that she took the potion and later on died. There are some......

Words: 1035 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

David Lurie- Not so Disgraced

...Sarah Kaminski Biddinger Essay 2 July 3, 2012 David Lurie- Not so Disgraced David Lurie, a twice-divorced man and communications professor, is the antagonist in the novel Disgrace by J. M. Coetzee. In the beginning of the novel, Lurie believes he has found the key to a successful relationship with a woman- hiring a prostitute once a week- but when his favorite prostitute leaves the brothel he seeks companionship in another place. After having relations with one of his students he is found out and asked to resign from the university and moves away from Cape Town to be in isolation with his daughter. He refers to this period as being in “disgrace” and that because of what he lost back at his home in Cape Town he is now expected to be in this state of disgrace. Lurie, although at first resistant, becomes at home with his daughter Lucy in this small country area- giving the impression that he is in fact a changed man. On the contrary, after he leaves for Cape Town he resorts back to his old ways of going to a prostitute for an intimate connection. For a person who had not seemed to change at all, one would consider Lurie a static character, although this is not the case. David Lurie is a realistic, growing, and dynamic character that effectively paints the picture of how “old dogs” can still, in fact, learn new tricks. In the first few chapters of the novel, Lurie is represented as a man who seeks to control and to display his power. In the first chapter he uses...

Words: 1305 - Pages: 6