Premium Essay

Do Apes Deserve Basic Rights

In: Social Issues

Submitted By nishanirj
Words 1503
Pages 7
MODR 1730, Debate 1: June 5th 2014

Topic: Discuss that apes and other higher primates ought to be afforded limited rights; to do otherwise is speciesism.

Arguments For Apes Getting Limited Rights

If apes can be defined and categorized as persons, then they are to be given equal consideration and limited basic rights such as the right not to suffer from cruel treatment (i.e. in medical experiments). To argue otherwise would be speciesism, which can be defined as a prejudice towards the interests of one's own species and against those of members of other species.

Main points as to why apes can be defined as persons:

1. Some scientists have linked the 5 great apes into 1 biologically similar group (chimpanzees, gorillas, orangutans, bonobos, and humans). Humans are just another type of ape. Humans and chimpanzees are 99% identical genetically (in respects to blood type, brain structure) and they demonstrate identical behavior for the first three years. 2. According to Kant, humans are self-conscious and rational, whreas animals are not and that is why we have no direct duties to animals themselves, but rather only to humans. However scientists have found that all 5 apes (this includes humans) are self aware and morally aware, as displayed in behavior. For example, if you place a dot on a chimpanzee, they are able to recognize that and realize it does not belong. This shows that they are self aware. Moreover, by observing Kanzi, the bonobo, we can see human like characteristics. For example, Kanzi is able to understand and carry out simple instructions such as starting a fire by using sticks and a lighter. He understand grammar and sentence structure by being able to differniate between sentences such as "turn off the water", "put the water in the bowl" "wash the potato with water". Moreover, research has shown that Kanzi, the bonobo has very…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Do Parents Deserve Love

...Do parents deserve love unconditionally? Often we as people are born into a family. This family can range from the “traditional” nuclear family to the growingly common “alternative” family. With being born into a family some bonds come along with it, this parent-child bond is what I am interested in examining. Is it something that is set in stone upon birth? Is it a condition which cannot be changed? Or does this connection between parent and child come with a certain set of conditions? Of course it’s safe to assume the majority of people would out right claim that it is set at birth and only an ungrateful person would deny his or her mother’s or father’s love, or that a parent just has not been patient enough with their child to refuse love to them. If there are conditions, what may they be? If these conditions put either child or parent at risk for diminished quality of life, may it just be better to lose the love for a parent or child? I grew up in a small suburban community, like many other American kids. My father worked for the Department of Defense and my mother was a hairdresser. My father worked long days and my mother would be the one to watch over us most of the time. Of course my brother and I would get into trouble as little boys do. I was always worse than my brother when it came to disobeying rules and basically causing havoc. The typical punishment for just about any offensive minor or major was a spanking. Common in the time I know and even more common in...

Words: 1108 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Why Animals Deserve Legal Rights

...In Steven M. Wise's article, “Why Animals Deserve Legal Rights”, Wise states that having rights is important because it shows importance of existence. Humans have come a long way from once being classified as objects or things by other humans to "now every human is a person in the eyes of the law" thanks to legal rights. However, Wise believes legal rights should not be exclusive to humans. He believes animals who are deprived of legal protection should be defended from torture, abuse, and exploitation. For the majority of his argument, Wise explains why autonomy is not a valid reason why animals do not deserve legal rights. Yet, there are so many other points left out that can validate rights for animals. Wise briefly touched on fact that "Judeo-Christian theologians sometimes argue that humans are made in the image of God", implying humans are far more superior than nonhumans and should be given rights. However, the Bible states nonhumans or animals are also the creation of God, thus, it wouldn't make sense to regard animals as just things and treat them like so if humans are also created by God. The point is, even if one believes in God or not, nowhere does it say humans are above all other living things. All living things are granted the same privilege to live and exist. Humans aren't asked to treat animals as equals in terms of giving animals all human rights but to treat them with respect and decency. People may think little of animals and their role in society.......

Words: 639 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Animals Deserve Rights Not Abuse

...Animals Deserve Rights Not Abuse Animals have been seen as a lower species for decades. They have little to no rights and are sometimes treated inhumanely. No rights are given to them, so when they are abused there is little to no consequences. Hit an animal, make them live in dirty environments, forgot to feed them, leave them in the hot temperatures with no water, or torture them and the consequences are minor compared to the cruelty forced on that animal. Animals should have certain rights so that abusers can have harsher consequences which in turn could help with future crimes, but doesn’t mean that they can’t be raised to feed our society or be used for other services. For centuries animals have been used by society to perform different duties. They are food for our families, they help the disabled, used for transportation, and other jobs. Yet if asked some still believe that they are just animals and were put on this earth to service people, not be equals nor have rights. For years animal activists have been trying to get society to see animals more clearly for what they are, living breathing beings. Some people believe that animal rights activists care more about animals than they do about other people, which isn’t entirely true. Some of the more extreme activists do but most activists have expanded their circle of compassion so that it includes both humans and non-humans. Most just believe that animals deserve to live humanely and with dignity, to......

Words: 1740 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Go Ape

...ISSUE 1 The choice of right versus wrong can be a relatively simple one to make. In most cases the right choice has positive implications and the wrong choice negative ones. What happens when we are faced with two choices that can be equally right? What do we rely upon to make these decisions that have competing virtues? Right versus right decisions are defining moments in shaping a person’s character. That being said, the lecture, Defining Moments by Badaracco (2002) is appropriately titled. Badaracco goes on to lay out a framework for addressing right versus right dilemmas. This framework by Badaracco addresses the following four questions: 1) Which course of action will do the most good and the least amount of harm? 2) Which alternative best serves others’ rights? 3) What plan can I live with that is consistent with basic values and commitments? 4) Which course of action is feasible in the world as it is? Given the situation with Alison and AlphaSoft Corporation, I would say that the course of action that will do the most good and the least amount of harm is to let Alison continue with her current position and positively influence her to continue her education and complete her MBA. Alison was hired into a position that did not require an MBA and moved up the ranks with hard work and her leadership has positively and financially benefitted the company. Badaracco (2002) quotes the famous utilitarian John Stuart Mill who once said “The essence of responsible......

Words: 1603 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Basics of Dos

...Basic overview of MS-DOS commands http://www.computerhope.com/overview.htm MS-DOS and command line overview Below is a listing of each of the MS-DOS commands currently listed on Computer Hope and a brief explanation of what each of the commands do. The below commands are all MS-DOS commands, which means not all the below commands will work in your version of MS-DOS or Windows command line. Clicking on the command will open the help page for that command with full details about it. Command ansi.sys append arp assign assoc at atmadm attrib batch bootcfg break cacls call cd chcp chdir chdsk chkntfs choice cls Description Defines functions that change display graphics, control cursor movement, and reassign keys. Causes MS-DOS to look in other directories when editing a file or running a command. Displays, adds, and removes arp information from network devices. Assign a drive letter to an alternate letter. View the file associations. Schedule a time to execute commands or programs. Lists connections and addresses seen by Windows ATM call manager. Display and change file attributes. Recovery console command that executes a series of commands in a file. Recovery console command that allows a user to view, modify, and rebuild the boot.ini Enable and disable CTRL + C feature. View and modify file ACL's. Calls a batch file from another batch file. Changes directories. Supplement the International keyboard and character set information. Changes directories. Check the hard......

Words: 1535 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The Right Thing to Do

...What is the right thing to do? Some people believe in doing what is right all the time, some don’t. In this situation my partner and the two boys didn’t do what was right, they both broke the law. I would challenge my partner about what happened in the interview room, because what he did was wrong, unprofessional and unethical. The boys are fourteen, which means when being interviewed by the police their parents should be called and the interview should be recorded. My partner didn’t do either one of these. He should have called the parents and recorded the interview in order to get the admission on tape. I think regardless if the parents were there or not the boys would have still admitted that they were guilty. My partner did it to scare them into admitting that they did it, I think with the parents being there they would have still admitted to their guilt because the parents also have a way of intimidating their children. If my partner would have did what he was supposed to there would be no reason to question him. Being professional is one of the main characteristics in a job, especially the one of a Detective. My partner was not professional in the particular situation. Not only didn’t he call the parents, he didn’t record the interview. That is the worst part because if he would have then we could have shown the parents and had evidence for the admission. It will be hard in court to say that they admitted being guilty. The boys can easily say......

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Basic of the Civil Right Movement

...The Basics on the Civil Right Movement Because large segments of the populace--particularly African-Americans, women, and men without property--have not always been accorded full citizenship rights in the American Republic, civil rights movements, or "freedom struggles," have been frequent features of the nation's history. In particular, movements to obtain civil rights for black Americans have had special historical significance. Such movements have not only secured citizenship rights for blacks but have also redefined prevailing conceptions of the nature of civil rights and the role of government in protecting these rights. The most important achievements of African-American civil rights movements have been the post-Civil War constitutional amendments that abolished slavery and established the citizenship status of blacks and the judicial decisions and legislation based on these amendments, notably the Supreme Court's Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka decision of 1954, the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Moreover, these legal changes greatly affected the opportunities available to women, nonblack minorities, disabled individuals, and other victims of discrimination. The modern period of civil rights reform can be divided into several phases, each beginning with isolated, small-scale protests and ultimately resulting in the emergence of new, more militant movements, leaders, and organizations. The Brown decision demonstrated that the......

Words: 1943 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Basic Rights of the Military Chaplain

...BASIC RIGHTS OF THE MILITARY CHAPLAIN CHPL 600 Theological Perspectives in Military Chaplaincy The rights, protections, and freedoms of military chaplains come from many sources, both from within the military and from the federal law. Of course, the most significant protection of a chaplain’s rights comes directly from the First Amendment of the Constitution in that the government will not prohibit the free exercise of a specific religion. Over the years the rights, and even the presence, of the military chaplain have been challenged on several fronts and each time, the rights of chaplains to serve and worship have been affirmed. Similarly, the right of a military chaplain to pray in their specific tradition, as opposed to using a more plural or general prayer has been challenged. The challenge was heard by the Supreme Court, referred to as Engle v. Vitele, and the result was that “the government cannot prescribe by law any particular form of prayer which is to be used as an official prayer in carrying on any program of governmentally sponsored religious activity (Kurland, 1961).” Many took this to mean that all public prayer then had to be non-specific, and others that this merely meant that the government could not issue a standard that might indirectly end up supporting or creating a single religious group. Therefore, in order to definitively protect the chaplain’s denominationally or traditionally specific right to pray, House......

Words: 888 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Housing – a Basic Right to Refugees

...hoc nature of the Government’s approach has led to varying treatment of different refugee groups. Some groups are granted a full range of benefits including legal residence and the ability to be legally employed, whilst others are criminalized and denied access to basic social resources.” The most important challenge is the prevention of criminalization of such refugees and thereby the denial of social resources to them. The argument on this article would reflect that: giving the refugees, a legitimate roof and status would reduce their marginalization and thereby prevent their criminalization. The denial of resources often provokes them to find an alternative source of resources. The most common alternatives chosen by them are to get involved in illegal activities that make them vulnerable to be marginalized. A child bought up in such a setup would rather loot others than be an educated professional. This situation spreads through generations and makes them a demoralized and marginalized sector of the society. Thus the local population of the resident city resists hosting the refugees or immigrants. For this situation to be remedied, policies and governments should lay extensive focus on the “Right to educate and Right to Housing” concepts. Research statistics state that a person spends almost one-third to half his income on housing and maintenance of this said housing, and the remaining on day-to-day expense and transportation, thereby leaving almost nothing to expend on......

Words: 677 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Basic Rights of an Employee

...Your basic rights as an employee There are minimum rights and entitlements set out in law, which apply to ALL employees, whether it is written in your employment agreement or not.  Your employment agreement cannot trade off or provide for less than these minimums. The law protects you at work by setting the minimum rights you have as an employee with paid time off work the minimum you can get paid public holidays sick leave bereavement leave giving you the right to refuse to do work that would likely harm you making sure that all workers, including young people, are safe at work and not unlawfully discriminated against. Your employer must: * Pay you at least the minimum wage * Provide you with annual leave * Provide or compensate you for public holidays if you work, or normally work the day the public holiday falls on * Provide you with a written employment agreement * Not deduct money from your wages, without your agreement in writing * Provide a safe workplace for you to work in * Not discriminate against you. One of the main principles of the law on employment is called “good faith”. This means that employers, employees and unions must deal with one another honestly and openly. Minimum terms and conditions vs negotiable terms and conditions All employees, regardless of the type of work they perform or whether they are full time, part time or casual, are entitled to an employment agreement in writing.  These may be either individual or......

Words: 1189 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Human Rights Basics

...Human rights Background After World War 2 the universal declaration of human rights was taken into account and adopted by the united nation commission of human rights this was done so that the same acts would not happen again in the future. The convention was written and approved by the members of the council of Europe on November 1950 and was put into force on September 1953.The convention was created to protect human rights as well as freedoms. Due to this there was the creation of the Commission on Human Rights and the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR).The ECtHR was put in place to take care of breaches of the convention. This would be done by one sovereign state being able to take legal action against another sovereign member state who had breached the convention rights. The UK had approved of the Convention in 1951 but this only meant that they had to take it into consideration and did not have to act upon it, however it had to be incorporated in to the UK legal system, and this was done in 1998 through the Human Rights Act (HRA). From the case we can see that Charlie tyke can use the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) to challenge the decision of the chief constable (CC). Based on the HRA 98 Convention rights S 1(1) that states that the rights and fundamental freedoms set out in articles 2 to 12 and 14 of the convention. These articles that are mentioned could be used by Charlie tyke in his case to challenge the CC as under the ECHR article...

Words: 271 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Lgbt Basic Human Rights

...with every turn, the human race will continue progress in its pursuit of knowledge. Each day brings the human race one step closer to a brighter, more vibrant future. In the past seventy years, the human race has made tremendous strides in a plethora of fields. Within this plethora of flourishing fields lies the field of human rights. Since 1945, the field of human rights has prospered so rapidly that present day human rights differ immensely from the human right laws of 1945. The definitions and institutions of human rights have evolved so greatly that a whole new world has opened up. Through decades of determination as well as struggle, these definitions and institutions of human rights have made vast advances towards the inclusion of basic human rights to all. Between the United Nations, nongovernmental organizations, and citizens of our world, the fight for equality has brought about a successful change. The concept that every person is entitled to certain, inalienable rights simply by the virtue of their humanity is relatively new. The year of 1945 marks not only the historical end of World War II, but it also indicates the propulsion of human rights into the universal scale. The combined extermination by Nazi Germany of over 11 million Jews, Gypsies, communists, Polish, homosexuals, and mentally and physically disabled stunned the world. In her essay Hunt notes, “ As the war ended, revelations about the scale of the horrors deliberately perpetrated by the Germans......

Words: 1782 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Basic Human Rights Taken

... Basic Human Rights Taken Lisa Davis HUM499 – Responsibility for the Future June 1, 2015 Samuel O’Donnell Southwestern College Professional Studies Basic Human Rights Taken In the concentration camps prisoners had everything and every right taken away. First when they arrived they were stripped of their personal belongings. No one should have their personal stuff taken from them and be humiliated and stripped down naked in front of everyone. The prisoners were then treated as if they were a piece of garbage that could be disposed of as if they meant nothing. The prisoner destiny was in the hand of someone who had no right to choose if the prisoner lived or died, but somehow managed to get the privilege of making this choice as if they were God. The prisoners were not feed properly at all. They were rationed out bread and soup. They were never given enough so they were slowly dwindling away of starvation. The prisoners poor nutrition left them open to many diseases their bodies were not able to fight off in its unhealthy state. Food is a right everyone has should have food to eat! Especially these prisoners they worked hard day in and out. It is one thing if someone sits around does not work or try to provide for themselves and has no food. They then have no one but themselves to blame. That wasn’t the case with these prisoners if any one deserved to eat it was them! The prisoners were stripped of any dignity they may have had. They were beating and talked down to.......

Words: 718 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Health - a Basic Human Right

...healthcare be considered a basic human right? Over the past century, the term "health" has been redefined over and over to come to a more exact and appropriate meaning so that consensus can be reached. The World Health Organization came up with its first definition of health, as "a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity."(p. 26) However, many people criticized and questioned the words "complete", "mental", "social", "disease", "infirmity" and their meanings. Daniel Callahan eventually proposed a short yet solid statement on the definition of health, as "a state of physical well-being."(p.66). Why has so much effort been made to determine a proper definition of health? Because it is important to us. Health is an essential aspect of our lives and its significance cannot be minimized. Therefore, it is natural for humans to pursue good health. But consequentially, does that give humans the right to healthcare? According to the WHO Constitution, "the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health is one of the fundamental rights of every human being…" In order to attain that standard however, healthcare services are required. Services such as treatment, diagnosis, and prevention provided by medical practitioners play a vital role in people's well-being. One might say that it is their responsibility but on what grounds? In this paper, I argue that healthcare is not a basic human right because for one,......

Words: 1530 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Animals Deserve Rights Not Abuse

...Animals Deserve Rights Not Abuse Brandie Killgore DeVry University Animals have been seen as a lower species for decades. They have little to no rights and are sometimes treated inhumanely. No rights are given to them, so when they are abused there is little to no consequences. Hit an animal, make them live in dirty environments, forgot to feed them, leave them in the hot temperatures with no water, or torture them and the consequences are minor compared to the cruelty forced on that animal. Animals should have certain rights so that abusers can have harsher consequences which in turn could help with future crimes, but doesn’t mean that they can’t be raised to feed our society or be used for other services. For centuries animals have been used by society to perform different duties. They are food for our families, they help the disabled, used for transportation, and other jobs. Yet if asked some still believe that they are just animals and were put on this earth to service people, not be equals nor have rights. For years animal activists have been trying to get society to see animals more clearly for what they are, living breathing beings. Some people believe that animal rights activists care more about animals than they do about other people, which isn’t entirely true. Some of the more extreme activists do but most activists have expanded their circle of compassion so that it includes both humans and non-humans. Most just believe that animals deserve to......

Words: 1744 - Pages: 7