Premium Essay

Do You Think Zimbardo Prison Study "Quiet Rage" Was Ethiical?

In: Social Issues

Submitted By doctorsean
Words 676
Pages 3
Ethics is a broad subject that encompasses all different sets of moral guidelines. In terms of Sociology, ethics can be defined as mode that implores us to act in a way to benefit society. In the 1971 documentary, “Quiet Rage”, psychologist Philip Zimbardo conducted a prison experiment at Stanford University aiming to gain knowledge in regards to the development of norms, roles, labels, and social expectations in a prison environment. Throughout this experiment Zimbardo lost control of the situation as the participants lost their own identities and became greatly involved with the roles that they were expected to act upon. As a result Zimbardo had to terminate the experiment before the study was completed due to unethical issues. The experiment was unethical, but it was a necessity in order to have acquired this beneficial knowledge that we possess today even though the trade off was inappropriate for the participants.
Numerous reasons exist to why the experiment has violated the ethical standards. For example, the students who had played the role of prisoners were treated unethically by forcing them to clean the toilet with their bare hands, and were placed in total confinement of spaces that were only standing room for more than 24hrs. But why would the prisoners blindly follow the guards? According to Giddens, the size of a group affects the “quality of interaction and the capability of the group in accomplishing certain tasks” (Giddens 132). The more the prisoners the more likely they would conform to the guards even though the orders were harsh and unethical. One study that supports the theory of conformity was the experiment Asch Task, where participants were shown one standard line and three comparison lines with different sizes. They were given the task to simply say which of the lines matched the standard line. When the confederates gave a false…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Prison Studies

...PRISON STUDIES Many who today hear me somewhere in person, or on television, or those who read something I’ve said, will think I went to school far beyond the eighth grade. This impression is due entirely to my prison studies. It had really begun back in the Charlestown Prison, when Bimbi first made me feel envy of his stock of knowledge. Bimbi had always taken charge of any conversation he was in, and I had tried to emulate him. But every book I picked up had few sentences which didn’t contain anywhere from one to nearly all of the words that might as well have been in Chinese. When I just skipped those words, of course, I really ended up with little idea of what the book said. So I had come to the Norfolk Prison Colony still going through only book-reading motions Pretty soon, I would have quit even these motions, unless I had received the motivation that I did. I saw that the best thing I could do was get hold of a dictionary — to study, to learn some words. I was lucky enough to reason also that I should try to improve my penmanship. It was sad. I couldn’t even write in a straight line. It was both ideas together that moved me to request a dictionary along with some tablets and pencils from the Norfolk Prison Colony school. I spent two days just riffling uncertainly through the dictionary’s pages. I’d never realized so many words existed! I didn’t know which words I needed to learn. Finally, just to start some kind of action, I began copying. In my slow, painstaking,...

Words: 928 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

What Do You Think Is Unethical?

...What do you think is unethical? The countrywide approved everyone to get their loans, no matter they have jobs or not, no matter they have income or not, no matter they have assets or not. The criteria they use may be unethical. They don’t care whether the documents are valid, whether they can verify the income, whether the appraisal is any good. They just care about getting the loan closed, in order to do another loan. The underwriters/ contractors looked through the loan as quick as they can. The loans are not looked at like they should have been looked at. They won’t think through with the common sense which is reasonable or not. ( teacher 10,000, waitress 12,000). On the instruction of their supervisor and lead. In the world of due diligence, they don’t use the word “fraud”. Even if it is suspected, they will say it seems like incorrect. 60% to more than 80% of the loans did not meet their policy. Clinton Holdings perform due diligence to two dozen banks, who were buying the mortgage from the Countrywide, Ameriquests, the New Centurys, packaging those loans, selling them to other investors. In each of these banks, The Clinton Holdings find a substantial portion of the loans did not meet the standards of the bank buying those loans. The banks did not tell the investors that the loans were defective. Blankfein was unapologetic. Do you think they know that you think something is a piece of crap when you sell it to them and then bet against it? When the supervisor go to the...

Words: 335 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

College Essay - Why Do You Think We Are a Good Fit for You

...Renwick Caldwell Sam Houston University March 15th, 2013 Why Sam Houston Would Be a Great School for Me The transition from high school to college is a very stressful one. Many issues are revealed that you never had with high school. How can you afford to pay tuition? Can you afford housing? What about your location? This is why it is incredibly vital to find the best college that you think is suited for you. For me that college would be Sam Houston University. I was seriously scared about the step into college. A most confusing one at that, and I didn’t even know what I wanted to become when I get older. Honestly, it hit me hard. Responsibility is what separates these kids from going to community college, and going to a university. All of my friends want to just go to lonestar, but I don’t want to be one of those kids. I want to receive the best education I can possibly have, and this is why I want to go to Sam Houston. I want to study in computer science and become a software engineer. Checking out Sam Houston took the cake. It’s close to home, it has a computer science program, and a great one at that, and I could learn a lot more in the 4 years at Sam Houston rather than the 2 years at lonestar. I want to get a head start on my career. I want to succeed as far as I can and I believe that Sam Houston would help me on my road to success. The location is also a plus since it is only about forty minutes from my parent’s house, therefore making me feel a lot more safe......

Words: 409 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Do You Think

...Case Study: Panasonic and Japan’s Changing Culture Summary This case study focuses on the globalization and change in culture of Panasonic established in Japan in 1920. Japanese culture hasn’t changed but the world around Japan has changed. Panasonic tried very hard to adhere to the values that were already in motion but as the times changed so did Panasonic. Although this was a drastic change it allowed Panasonic to grow. “As the decade progressed, one Japanese firm after another was forced to change its traditional ways of doing business” (Global Business Today, 2011, pp. 126). Globalization played a huge role in the outcome of the Japanese businesses. Questions 1. The triggers of cultural change in Japan during the 1990s were that the generation born after 1964 wasn’t as motivated and grew up in a much richer and prosperous Japan. Another trigger was that the Japanese economy was sucked into a slump. Due to the fact that the companies in Japan were trying to keep their traditions and values, keep their employees happy and maintain good and efficient business caused the companies to suffer. Cultural change is starting to affect traditional values in Japan because it is causing companies to change their values. Companies are no longer following the set of values and folkways from previous years. They are beginning to follow the same rules and regulations of the society. Panasonic was also letting go of employees and modifying the social structure to......

Words: 915 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Prison of Pyschology

...Psychology Research Paper: 1971 Stanford Prison Experiment Joseph Roby Carrington College Wednesday, December 4, 2013 1971 Stanford Prison Experiment It’s been over 42 years now since an illustrious experiment was performed by a couple of Stanford Psychologists that would ultimately change the course on how we look at people with the right of authority. In 1971, Psychology Professor Dr. Phillip Zimbardo operated a psychology experiment called the 1971 Stanford Prison Experiment to see just how ordinary people would react when given authority over another helpless being. This experiment would take place inside the psychology rooms of the Stanford College, and would durate between the dates of August 14, 1971 to August 20, 1971. Guards would be hired and given legitimate power over mock prisoners to see what levels of domestication they would impose on them. The experiment would start off cool and harmonious, but would eventually take a blinding turn for the worst. After just six days the experiment was brought to an unforeseen end and never reached the two week frame that it was given. In just those six days Dr. Zimbardo, and eventually a wide audience, would forever know the 1971 Stanford prison experiment as an experiment that would change the amount of power someone could and will be given in a title of authority. It was never Dr. Zimbardo’s intention to create something so impactful, or maybe just not in the way it impacted our society. Before his......

Words: 1397 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Zimbardo Prison Experiement

...The Zimbardo Prison Experiment Ryan Iden IPFW The Zimbardo Prison Experiment Professor Philip Zimbardo was a professor at Stanford University and he wanted to do an experiment on how students “inmates” would react to the power of the guards and how they would respond to being a prisoner for 14 days. This prison was a mock prison in the basement of Stanford University and the experiment only lasted 6 days because the voluntary students started to get stressed out and feeling demoralized by the guards. The guards were starting to act aggressive and abusive to the students. The guards would strip them of their clothes, yell at them and make them submit to their authority. The guards and the inmates were actually starting to act as though they were in prison. This experiment to me is not unethical. The students volunteered and they also knew that this was just an experiment. I do agree that some of the guard’s motives were a little too extreme for the experiment, but al-in all the students knew what they were getting into. Some people would say that this is to extreme putting these students through all the stress and torment just for an experiment. If this was real I would say yes that this is unethical. The issue that was the most problematic to was the fact that the professor actually wanted to do this experiment and did not stop the guards from treating the students the way they did. When the prisoners started to get stressed out they should have stopped the......

Words: 511 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Do You Think That Efficiency Can Conflict with Effectiveness?

...Do you think that efficiency can conflict with effectiveness? Explain and provide many real live examples as you can. Basically Efficiency and Effectiveness are two sides of a coin. Efficiency is competency in performance or ability to accomplish a job with a minimum expenditure of time and effort while effectiveness to achieve the intended or expected result. Ex. 1 In an advertising campaign. A company could spend millions of dollars on commercials and billboards to get a product out there. That example would be effective, but not efficient. That same company could make a silly viral video and "leak" it for free on the internet. That would be efficient. But the best way would be to balance between both approaches. That would be both efficient and effective. Ex. 2 Suppose that two guys, X and Y, are trying to change a flat tire on their cars (each one has his own car). X starts by taking out the jack and placing it under the car. He quite doesn’t know where to position it, so he goes by trial and error and wastes a lot of time doing it. After 30 minutes he finally manages to fix it, so he proceeds to lift the car and change the tire. As you can see X was doing the right thing, but he was doing it poorly. We can say that he was being effective, but not efficient. Y, on the other hand, starts by grabbing a towel and cleaning the tire. He wants to make the thing shiny before he changes it. And mind you he is very good and fast at cleaning every little......

Words: 574 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How Do You Think

... HOW DO YOU THINK MARION HODLE LACKAWANNA COLLEGE ABSTRACT Are you a creative thinker? Can you be inspired to write or draw from a walk through a museum? Can you come up with a few good ideas from just lying in the grass at the park? If this is the way your mind works and how you go about solving problems then you’re a creative thinker. If you get inspirations or some of your best answers by looking up facts, reading up on subjects and linking information you already know to be true, you’re a critical thinker. Critical Thinking Critical thinking is the ability to think clearly and rationally. It’s a persons ability to engage in independent thinking. They can understand logical concepts between ideas, like linking thoughts. They can identify and construct arguments and detect common mistakes in reasoning over things. Creative thinking involves solving problems systematically. It also includes the identification and importance of ideas. Critical thinking can reflect on a person’s beliefs and values. Critical thinking is not based on how much a person knows. Even if you have a good memory and know a lot of facts it still does not mean you are a good critical thinker. A good critical thinker knows how to use his knowledge to solve problems and seek relevant sources of information. Critical thinking does not mean a person is critical or argumentative. It can also play a role in cooperation and reasoning. We use critical thinking to enhance our social situations. Some people...

Words: 637 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Why Do You Think the U.D.H.R Was Not Accepted by Many Countries?

...The UDHR was adopted on 10 December 1948 by the General Assembly by a vote of 48 in favour, none against, and eight abstentions: the Soviet Union, Ukrainian SSR, Byelorussian SSR, People's Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, People's Republic of Poland, Union of South Africa, Czechoslovakia, and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. On the one hand, according to some authors, each of them had their own reason to abstain. Saudi Arabia probably did not agree with articles 18, everyone has the right “to change his religion or belief”, and 16 that talks about equal marriage rights. Furthermore, in the case of South Africa, they were trying to protect their system of apartheid since they were violating many of the articles. Moreover, from the point of view of the communist nations, the UDHR did not condemn enough fascism and Nazism (Danchin). Additionally, the USSR based their abstention on article 13, which states the right of citizens to leave their countries because they did not agree with it. (Glendon, 2001) On the other hand, other authors, such as Hofstede, classify them as a group when it comes to cultural value dimensions. Two of the values he remarks is the masculinity and the power distance there is between individuals in those cultures. For example Saudi Arabia and South Africa have a cultures were masculinity prevails in front of femininity, what is the same, they have a strong masculinity side. These cultures tend to be more competitive, have preference for achievement,......

Words: 431 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Do You Think Attitudes Influence Job Performance?

...North South University Assignment prepared for: Jasim Uddin (JDN) MGT321: Oraganizational behavior. Assignment prepared by:Kamrul Hasan ID:0930875030 Date:03/10/2011 Do you think attitudes influence job performance? Justify your arguments logically using evidence. The obvious straight forward answer to this question is yes. Yes, attitudes influences job performance very much. The attitude of the employee affects job performance. When employees arrive at work, they bring with them their moods, their emotions, their opinions and their problems at home or with life in general. Since employees may have the need to cooperate with each other to get the work done, their attitude will have great influence on productivity, their relationships with each other and productivity on the job. It is like when an employee has a good attitude about a job, the whole chore just flows so easily leading them to think that the work is so smooth, easy and hassle free; which at the end of the day eventually holds a huge positive impact on their performance at the workplace. But, here is the opposite scenario, when an employee has a bad attitude about a job, he or she will realize either incidentally or coincidentally everything about the work gets wrong, even the silly things which should not be a problem turns out to be huge mistakes. Now let’s go back to the core question WHAT IS AN ATTITUDE? The absolute basic meaning suggests that an attitude is a way......

Words: 551 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Do You Think Culture Is Important to Organizational Performance?

...Do you think culture is important to organizational performance? By TAN KAR CHU The topic I choose for this assignment is “Do You Think Culture Is Important To Organizational Performance”. There are many definition of Organizational culture that had been made but based on what I had learn, Organizational culture is the value and assumptions shared within an organizational which defines the important and unimportant in the company and, consequently, directs everyone in the organization toward the “right way” of doing things (McShane & Glinow, 2009). But according to Maher (2014), organizational culture is a major factor which affects the speed and frequency of innovation. Nowadays, new develop organization should know that to establish a successful organizations they should adopts and adapts culture to their organization in order to know whether their organizational performance is good or not. I believe that culture is important to organizational performance. First of all organisations that want to be innovative must transform their organizational culture so that it has innovation-oriented culture (Szczepańska, 2014), which means that the employee has to be able to generate innovative ideas in a short times. When the innovation-oriented organizational culture has been create, it will forming a climate that would be positive to the organizational changes. But, in order to toughen the culture for innovation within and across the organisations, employee should be brave......

Words: 956 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Do You Think

...1. Do you think it is ethical for social networks to sell access user information to business for market research and other users? Why or why not ? 1.Spamming - Social Networking Sites can sell one's personal information to anyone who wants to buy it, including spammers and on line predators. Even if the terms of understanding claim that no personal information will be sold, the site can change its policy at any time. social networking sites like Myspace and Bebo are full of spam and scams! Many users receive emails nearly every day from anonymous users asking to date and chat on other websites. It continuously becomes frustrating to receive all these useless spam emails and no solution is being revised. Other Scam is an extra problem for the users. Unfortunately, some scammers trick members and scam them in so many ways to steal their accounts. A ordinary recognized trick could be through a phishing website which looks very similar to Facebook and fools people in believing that they are still on the official Facebook website. Once a member logs in using the email and password, scammers can now access his account and scam his friends, spreading further spam and malware through the website. Fake websites can also steal your bank information if consumers fall prey to their advertisements. If you have never come across a problem like this before, it is your responsibility to avoid such a threat and keep your information secure. 2.Privacy Issues - Endangerment to one's......

Words: 384 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Do You Think English Is Easy

...Do You Think English is Easy? 1)  The bandage was wound around the wound. 2)  The farm was used to produce produce. 3)  The dump was so full that it had to refuse more refuse. 4)  We must polish the Polish furniture. 5)  He could lead if he would get the lead out. 6)  The soldier decided to desert his dessert in the desert. 7)  Since there is no time like the present, he thought it was time to present the present. 8)  A bass was painted on the head of the bass drum. 9)  When shot at, the dove dove into the bushes. 10)  I did not object to the object. 11)  The insurance was invalid for the invalid. 12)  There was a row among the oarsmen about how to row. 13)  They were too close to the door to close it. 14)  The buck does funny things when the does are present. 15)  A seamstress and a sewer fell down into a sewer line. 16)  To help with planting, the farmer taught his sow to sow. 17)  The wind was too strong to wind the sail 18)  Upon seeing the tear in the painting I shed a tear. 19)  I had to subject the subject to a series of tests. 20)  How can I intimate this to my most intimate friend? Let's face it - English is an illogical language.  There is no egg in eggplant, nor ham in hamburger; neither apple nor pine in pineapple. English muffins weren't invented in England or French fries in France. Sweetmeats are candies while sweetbreads, which aren't sweet, are meat.  We take English for granted.  But if we......

Words: 949 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Why Do You Think Jewish Customs Described in the Podcast Are Being Rediscovered

...Brinkley Donna M. Davis July 30, 2012 Prisons in America face many problems today. One such problem is the amount of elderly inmates. Elderly inmates represent the fastest growing segment of the federal and state prisons. The aging inmate population has created new challenges for the American corrections system. The population of aging and elderly prisoners in the United States prisons exploded over the past three decades, with nearly 125,000 inmates aged 55 or older now behind bars, according to a recent report published by the American Civil Liberties Union. This represents an increase of over 1,300 percent since the early 1980s. (Graying in Prison). Some contributing factors to the increase in elderly inmates are, get tough on crime reforms of the 1980s and 1990s, mandatory minimum sentences, three strikes rules and truth in sentence laws established in recent decades are keeping more offenders in prison for longer periods of time. Inmates are living longer and this also contributes to prison overcrowding. (Elderly Prisoners, 2012). In passing some of these laws, such as the three strikes laws, the courts and the Criminal Justice System did not think about the aging inmates and the problems that go with it. As people age, generally they develop health problems and within the prison system, this is no different. Prisons aren’t geared to the needs and vulnerabilities of older people. In the prison environment, there are a number of unique......

Words: 1376 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Think, Feel and Do: I ♥ You

...THINK, FEEL AND DO: I ♥ YOU “True love waits”. And to simplify this briefly, there are three steps on how to prepare in engaging ourselves in relationship. First, solve unresolved problems. Forgiveness and acceptance of one’s failure must always stay in our hearts so that we can move on from our past. Let your rejection be your key to be a better person. Second, stop believing in the “right person myth”. Looking for the perfect one for us is never true. We may feel deeply in love to that person but as we grow day by day with him/her we will meet lots of his hidden attitude that we don’t know yet. Lastly, start becoming the right person. Take the effort and discipline to be the person, the person you’re looking for. Instead of thinking of having our ideal partner for the future let us think also the other way around, molding ourselves to be like the person we are looking for. I Corinthian chapter 13 verses 4-5 said “Love is PATIENT, love is KIND. it does not ENVY, it does not boast, it is not PROUD, it is not RUDE, it is not SELF-SEEKING.it is not easily ANGERED, it keeps NO RECORD of WRONGS. It always PROTECTS, always TRUSTS, always HOPES, and always PERSEVERES. LOVE NEVER FAILS...” In other words, love is not an easy act it is “sacrificial”. Therefore, before we enter in a relationship we must know first our priorities and ready ourselves in taking that tract. In addition, we must also discern well on what vocation we will pursuing for the future. We must preserve our......

Words: 436 - Pages: 2