Free Essay

Doc1

In: Other Topics

Submitted By coolblue
Words 1512
Pages 7
Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots Cash Chemists (Southern) Ltd [1953] 2 WLR427 is a well-known English contract law judgment on the nature of an offer. The Court held that the exhibition of a product in a store with a price attached is not adequate to be considered an offer, although relatively is an invitation to treat. Boots Cash Chemists had presently employed a new technique for its customers to purchase certain medicines. They would let shoppers single out drugs off the shelves in the chemist, and afterward recompense for them at the till, rather than involve all medicines to be behind a counter and for an associate to have to get what was asked for.
The Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain objected, and disputed that under the Pharmacy and Poisons Act 1933, this was an illegal performance. Under s 18(1), a pharmacist required to administer at the point where "the sale is effected", when the product was one scheduled on the 1933 Act's program of poisons. The Society disputed that exhibitions of goods were an "offer" and when a purchaser preferred and placed the drugs into their shopping basket this was an "acceptance". Therefore since no pharmacist had overseen the operation at this summit, Boots was in violation of the Act. Boots disagreed that the auction was still merely exaggerated at the till.
The date in the case reference is enclosed within square brackets, that is, [1953] 2 because as a primary source in law reports and citation of cases, when a case can be located using the date alone, that date is enclosed in square brackets. The year in square brackets refers to the year of the decision, the square brackets indicate that this year also serves as a volume number, and thus is required to locate the report. The 2 indicates the case is found in volume 2 of the 1953 reports. Thus, in this particular case, the case could be located by using the date alone. Otherwise, if the case can be located using other methods like using the volume number, the date can be enclosed with round brackets. It is also important to note that any citations prior to 1953 will be for the case at first instance, which is not a citation of the case under discussion.
This case appears to have been reported in other series of reports. [1953] WL 13966(CA); 117 J.P. 132; [1953] 1 Q.B. 401, [1953] 1 All E.R. 482 ; [1953] 1 All E.R. 482; [1953] 2 W.L.R. 427; (1953) 97 S.J.149; [1953] 1 Q.B. 401; [1953] EWCA Civ 6. The court's decision that appears in the report cited is Court of Appeal. The case was heard and decided on 5 Feb 1953. There is no indication that judgment was reserved, and the lack of any date other than the sitting date, or an indication of reservation such as cur ad vult would indicate that judgment was not reserved. The judges in the case Somervell, Birkett and Romer LJJ; seniority; three-uneven number needed for appeal; convention that one judge does not sit alone in judgment upon a brother judge.
The counsel for the parties in this case Lord Goddard C.J. - heard matter at first instance, therefore his judgment does not form part of this case, but may be reported elsewhere. Somervell LJ is the most senior judge sitting on the appeal and each party in the case solicitors and barristers was represented by Appellant: H.V. Lloyd-Jones Q.C. and T. Dewar instructed by A.C. Castle; Respondent: G.G. Baker Q.C. and G.D. Everington instructed by Masons.
The Pharmacy and Poisons Act, 1933 requires the auction of poisons to be effected by or under the management of a recognized or registered pharmacist. Boots ran a retail pharmacy, which sold poisons limited under the Act, which they had restructured into a self service pharmacy. A registered pharmacist managed each operation relating to a poison or medicine at the summit of transaction. Customers nevertheless were liberated to opt for such products from the shelves of the pharmacy and position them in their shopping baskets prior to approaching the money desk to reimburse. Two bottles of drugs were acquired from Boots in this approach.
The head note suggests that, "The question for the opinion of the court was whether the sales instanced on April 13, 1951, were affected by or under the supervision of a registered pharmacist, in accordance with the provisions of section 18(1)(a)(iii) of the Pharmacy and Poisons Act, 1933." However the issue of law with which the court is concerned is better stated by Birkett LJ at 407: "the short point of the case is, at what point of time did the sale in this particular shop in Edgeware take place?" Or by Somervell LJ at 405: "what are the legal implications of this [self service] layout - the invitation to the customer. Is a contract to be regarded as being completed when the article is put into the receptacle,.[or] having got the ones which they wish to buy, to come up to the assistant .the money passes and the transaction is completed." In other words, is the display of goods on a shelf in a shop an offer or an invitation to treat?

Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots
[1953] 1 QB 401

Facts
Boots operated as a regular pharmacy, with items on shelves and pharmaceuticals requiring a pharmacist to supervise the sale. The Pharmaceutical Society alleged that Boots infringed the Pharmacy and Poisons Act 1933 requiring the sale of certain drugs to be supervised by a registered pharmacist. The claim failed at first instance and the Society appealed.

Held (Somervell LJ)
The Society had argued that a drug sale was completed when the customer took an item from the shelf and put it in their cart/basket. The result of such analysis would be that that when the customer came to the sales desk the pharmacist would not be able to say that the drug could not be sold to that customer. After assessing the legal implications of such an analysis Somervell LJ noted that in relation to
"an ordinary shop, although goods are displayed and it is intended that customers should go and choose what they want, the contract is not completed until, the customer having indicated the articles which he needs, the shopkeeper, or someone on his behalf, accepts that offer. Then the contract is completed."
The same rule should apply in relation to this case. If the Society’s argument was accepted then customers, once placing an item in their basket, would have no right to substitute a different article which she/he preferred. This would be commercially inconvenient.
As a consequence the Society’s case failed because, at the appropriate time, the sale was supervised as required by legislation.

Case Facts
Boots cash chemists had implemented a new system of selling particular medicines. The customer could get the required medicine of the shelf and pay for the goods at the till. Previously all medicine where bought over the counter. The Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain argued that this method of selling specific medicines contravened the [Pharmacy and Poisons Act 1933].
The Pharmaceutical Society argued that displaying the medicine on the shelf amounted to an ‘offer’ and that the customer placing the medicine in their basket amounted to an ‘acceptance’. The Pharmaceutical Society believed that this practice was unlawful and breached Section 18(1) of the Pharmacy and Poisons Act that stated that a pharmacist needed to supervise at the point where "the sale is effected" of any medicines which were described in the 1933 act as a poison.
Boots argued that the ‘offer’ and ‘acceptance’ occurred at the till; offer- presenting the goods; acceptance - processing and accepting payemt, where a pharmacist was present and supervising sales.
It was held by the Queens Bench Division of the High Court and the Court of Appeal that a display of goods is an offer to treat. That the customer offers to buy the goods at a certain price and the pharmacist for Boots will either accept or reject this offer.
Although this is an English case, it remains unclear as to whether the approach made by the English courts would apply in Scottish Courts. It would seem reasonable however that this approach was followed and would be used if a similar case arose within Scottish Jurisdiction.
Furthermore, in the opinion of MacQueen and Thomson, authors of Contract Law in Scotland[3] they state in the age of electronic commerce, similar questions arise in relation to Internet web pages which indicate the availability of goods for sale and enable customers to order direct from a supplier by an electronically transmitted communication.[4]
As suppliers are inviting prospective buyers to buy their good, the users are simply making an offer and this leaves out the ability for the suppliers to decline the offer of delivering their goods and services.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Doc1

...Data Communication and Networking Quiz # 1 Name: Aurielle Lisa Zerna Test I. Enumerate the items on each of the following. 1. Fundamental characteristics for effective data communication. - Delivery - Accuracy -Timeliness 2. Components of data communication. -Message -Sender -Receiver -Medium -Protocol 3. Classification of network. -Geographical -Topology -Manner in which data are transmitted 4. Transmission Technology -Circuit-switched -Packet-switched -Frame Relay -ATM (Asynchronous transfer mode) -ISDN (Integrated Services Digital Network) 5. OSI Model 6. TCP/IP Protocol Suite -Application Layer -Application -Presentation Layer -Transport -Session Layer -Internet -Transport Layer -Network Access -Network Layer -Data Link Layer -Physical Layer Test II. In your own words, discuss the following. 1. What is data communication? Data communication is the way a sending device and a receiving device communicate with each other digitally through hardware and software. 2. How does OSI model works and how it is related to TCP/IP suite? Discuss the function of each of the layers. The OSI model is a network architecture designed for all network to communicate with each other and has seven layers each of which has their specific functions. The TCP/IP suite is created based on these 7 layers. First is the physical layer. An example of which is a NIC or other type of connectors used in a communication device Second is the data link layer. It is the......

Words: 511 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Doc1

...SKECHERS is an award-winning global leader in the lifestyle footwear industry SKECHERS RUBBER SHOES NIKE * What materials we use – including new choices for recycled and recyclable materials * Better processes – employing new ways of processing with less energy, water, chemicals or waste * Better choices – creating and applying indexes, restricted substance lists, policies and better ways of operating, and sharing them with vendors and suppliers * Bringing choices to scale – increasing the scale and availability of new material choices, including sharing intellectual property and enabling recycling of materials * asics * 1949 * Mr Kihachiro Onitsuka founded the forerunner of ASICS, Onitsuka Co. Ltd., in 1949 in Kobe, Japan. He started manufacturing basketball shoes in order to meet the needs of the nation’s rising basketball stars. The first shoes were designed with a recessed sole to simulate action of an octopus’ suction cup. * By 1950, the company was known as Onitsuka Tiger. The Tiger sports shoe saw its first major success the following year, with the winner of the Boston Marathon wearing the brand. * * ASICS is at the forefront of the world performance sports market as undisputedly the leading running shoe brand for enthusiasts and professional athletes alike. Whether at professional sporting events, the Olympics or an everyday run around a park, ASICS is the runner’s choice, providing comfort, support and a superior ride. The......

Words: 257 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Doc1

...This is from website. New consumers The sales growth is being underpinned this year by widening consumer participation and further embedding of coffee culture into UK lifestyles. With limited price increases by major chains, industry like-for-like sales growth of 3.5% has been achieved by new consumers enjoying coffee houses, better operating standards and menu innovation. UK consumers are clearly embracing the growing coffee culture trend and demonstrating their love of coffee, enabling the sector to substantially outperform the wider retail market, which in contrast, has grown at a sluggish pace of 1-2% over the past 4-5 years. Jeffrey Young, Managing Director, Allegra Strategies said: “The UK coffee shop market continues to astound even the most optimistic of forecasters, by growing significantly in value, in outlet numbers and also in the social psyche of the nation. As consumers gain more opportunity to consume quality coffee through more outlets, they are making it part of their lifestyle. Britain has become a ‘new nation of coffee drinkers’. Long live the cup of tea, but more and more consumers seek and enjoy quality coffee.” “High quality ‘artisan’ independent coffee shops are also fuelling consumer demand and driving the branded coffee shop sector to increase focus on authentic interiors, barista technique and to introduce a wider range of crafted coffees such as flat white and cortado.” “This focus on quality in all areas can only continue to drive a thriving......

Words: 283 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Doc1

...Dear hiring agent: I want to express my interest into the Market Development Manager Position. I have a background in successful sales and marketing programs. I am familiar with the retail industry where I was brought into leadership roles. I am seeking to align myself with a progressive company poised for strong growth and market expansion. With extensive experience working with talented sales teams, meeting aggressive revenue targets, and delivering first-class sales solutions, I am confident that I can help your company meet aggressive goals as well. Capitalizing on my success at Federal Home Loan Bank, I am seeking a professional opportunity to leverage my exceptional sales record and proven account management skills to benefit your company as well as your clients. With the practical experience and demonstrated success, I have the drive and talent to quickly become a top performer within your organization. With this goal in mind, I have attached a resume outlining my qualifications. Some of my key strengths and accomplishments include: • A proven performer with a track record of outperforming sales goals, delivering high levels of customer service, and achieving successful sales results. • Ability to quickly cultivate relationships with very difficult to access, influential decision makers. • Proactively approach account and business challenges applying problem-solving skills, persistence, teamwork and resourcefulness to achieve positive results. Given my......

Words: 255 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Doc1

...Write a 1,050-word paper on marketing strategies and subcultures. In this week, you research subcultures to determine what marketing strategies you would use to market flavored cigarettes to the target market group. Address the following in your paper: What marketing strategies would be used to market flavored cigarettes within the following subcultures: African American, Hispanic, and Asian? What environmental factors need to be considered when marketing within each subculture? What are the cultural and cross-cultural differences that influence the marketing strategies selected for each subculture? Using your research, justify the reasons for your marketing selection strategies as recommended for each subculture. Ethnic subculture is a tightly knit group of consumers who are held together by common cultural or genetic ties, and is identified both by its members and by others as being a distinguishable category. The group members tend to be tightly knit, and they are likely to imply meanings that go beyond the spoken word. De-ethnicization of which refers to a process where a product like flavored cigarettes that are possibly formerly associated with a specific ethnic group is detached from its roots and marketed to other ethnic subcultures. These are all important factors for TRIADD Research Group to keep in mind when determining marketing strategies to specific ethnic subcultures. One goal that the TRIAAD Research Group has for Exotic Smokes Cigarette Company in its...

Words: 562 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Doc1

...Caterpillar Inc.: Corporate Social Responsibility Some argue that the role of business is simply to make money. Others argue that this statement is wrong and that the components of corporate social responsibility are just as important to a business as it is to create shareholder value. (Davis, 2005, 105) The components of corporate social responsibility include looking after the community and environment as well as other things such as the helping out the stakeholders of the company. As you will soon find out a quality social performance will likely have positive effects on the company, while poor social performance will likely have negative effects. Caterpillar Inc. like most companies does have problems with their history of CSR but also has a very good record in other areas. Caterpillar Inc.: Poor Social Performance Caterpillar Inc. being a machinery company constantly has environmental guidelines it must follow. If they do not follow these guidelines there is likely to be consequences. One environmental headline Caterpillar Inc. would rather forget was on August 1st, 2000, when it was awarded by the not-for –profit organization Clean Air Trust, the Clean Air Villain of the Month. It was said the company appeared to be deliberately avoiding the legal agreement to clean up their dirty engines. Only 13 months earlier the Justice Department and the State of California had signed off an agreement with Caterpillar Inc. The agreement with the company was made after an......

Words: 2173 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Doc1

...ASHWINI SACHIN BACHHAV Mobile: 09922686848/ 09422293379 E-Mail: Ashwini.bachhav@birlasunlife.com [pic] In pursuit of opportunities in the field of Manager Sales Support Staff / Asst. Manager for Sales Support and MIS Manager. SUMMARY [pic] ← Associate from Insurance Institute of India with over 4 years of experience in managing the complete scope of Operations involving Customers Service, HR Initiatives, Admin, MIS Preparation, Internal Control, Liaison & Coordination and Team Supervision. ← Currently associated with Birla Sunlife Insurance Co. Ltd., Location: Nasik as Senior Branch Operation & Sales and Support + Group Leader in Sales Support Staff for Mumbai & Aurangabad Region.) ← Talent for proactively identifying & resolving problems, controlling costs, maximising productivity & delivering profit increases. ← Expertise in developing, recommending and implementing human resource strategies and policies in support of business objectives. ← Deft in overseeing change management and provision of business focus solutions in a fast moving environment. ← Possess a high degree of personal maturity and professional efficiency in addition to the basic functional knowledge inherent in the operation and HR function. ← KEY STRENGTHS ENTAIL: - The ability to build strong & enduring relationships - Strong communication skills - A strategic / business vision - Leadership qualities - Negotiating / influencing skills - Ability to balance......

Words: 1087 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Doc1

...Journal of Business Case Studies – Second Quarter 2006 Volume 2, Number 2 Case Studies In Marketing Research Donald K. Hsu, (Email: yanyou@hotmail.com), Dominican College ABSTRACT The use of case studies for Marketing Research has been examined. Starting with a topic selection, students collected the background information from various sources. A focus group was conducted to gather detailed information. A questionnaire was designed for an in-depth survey of the general public. Using mall intercept, 100 or more convenient samples were collected from the questionnaire. SPSS software was used to analyze this data. Then a final report with possible recommendations was written. During the course of this research, students made face-to-face interview with senior managers or CEO, selected appropriate Harvard Business School cases, did research using Internet or library resources, and added much real-life learning to the theoretical in-class knowledge. INTRODUCTION V ase studies in Marketing Research have attracted much interest for global researchers. During the last two years, participants at the European Applied Business Research Conference presented findings in marketing related topics: 56 papers in 2003 and 25 papers in 2004. Out of the 81 papers, 24 reported work on marketing research. Cho and Ha (2004) measured consumer behavior by surveying 300 people on two brand names, Chow et al (2003) studied the environment friendly (eco-label) issues on......

Words: 3534 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Doc1

...What is Yom Kippur? What is Yom Kippur? Yom Kippur also know as "Day of Atonement" is the most important holiday of the Jewish calendar. When does Yom Kippur begins? Yom Kippur is the 10th day of Tishre. It begins 10 days after Rosh Hashanah and its lasts for 25 hours WHY IS YOM KIPPUR IMPORTANT TO JEWS Because they believe it is the last day that they can ask for forgiveness and resolving to do better in the coming year. Why Is Yom Kippur Celebrated? Because it is believed to be the last chance to change God's judgment of one's deeds in the previous year . and his decisions one's fate in the coming year. Rituals during Yom Kippur on Yom Kippur all Jews most do the fowling rituals: pray and fast Pictures of Yom Kippur What is sukkot Sukkot also known as the festival of Booths and the Feast of Tabernacles is an seven-day harvest holiday that comes during the Hebrew month of Tishrei. It begins four days after Yom Kippur and is followed by Shmini Atzeret and Simchat Torah. |   Why is sukkot important? because it reminds them of the covenant that was t made by Abraham. When does Sukkoth begins and ends The Festival of Sukkot begins on Tishri 15, the fifth day after Yom Kippur. And lasts for seven days. Why is sukkot celebrate Jews celebrate Sukkot to commemorate the final gathering of the harvest. This feast also commemorates how God protected them in the wilderness after he took them out of the Egyptian bondage.......

Words: 311 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Doc1

...Unlike traditional encyclopedias, Wikipedia can be edited by any reader. Except for particularly sensitive and/or vandalism-prone pages that are "protected" to some degree,[23] Wikipedia visitors can edit articles even if they do not have a Wikipedia account. Certain language editions offer a modified version of this policy; for example, only registered users may create a new article in the English edition.[24] A frequently vandalized article can be semi-protected, meaning that only established, verified users are able to make edits to that article.[25] A particularly contentious article may be locked so that only administrators are able to make changes.[26] An article is not considered to be owned by its creator or any other editor and is not vetted by any recognized authority.[27] Rather, editors are encouraged to discuss differing options regarding the content and structure of articles in order to come to agreement. By default, an edit to an article immediately becomes available. As a result, articles may contain inaccuracies, ideological biases, and nonsensical or irrelevant text until an editor corrects such deficiencies. Different language editions, each under separate administrative control, are free to modify this policy. For example, the German Wikipedia maintains "stable versions" of articles,[28] which have passed certain reviews. Following protracted trials and community discussion, the English Wikipedia introduced the "pending changes" system in December......

Words: 358 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Doc1

...Barbara......

Words: 260 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Doc1 Computer Sciernce

...D D D D D D D D D D D D D F F F G G G G G G G G G G G G G G Gsdg Sxg Sdg Sdg Sd Gs Fgd Fg Dfg Dfg Dfg Df Gd Fg Dfg Dfg Dff Gdf G Dfg Dg Dg Df Fg Dfg Dffg Dfg Df Gd Fg Dfg Dfg Df G Dffg Dffg Dffg D Fg Dfg Dfg Dfg Df Gd Fg Dffg Dffg Df Gd G Dffg Df Gdf G Dfg Dff Gdf G Dffg Df Gd Fg Dfg Df G Dfg Dffg Df G Dfg Df G Dffg Dfg Dff Gdf G Ff Sdf Sf F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F Ffff d d d d d d d d d d d d d d dfdsf sdf sd f sdf sdf sdf sd fs df sdf sdf sd fs df sdf sd df sdf sd f sdf s df sd f sdf sd f sdf sd f sdf sd f sdf sd f sdf sd f sdf sd f sdf sdf sd f sddf sddf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sd fsd fsd fsd f sdf sdf sd fx cv xcv xc vxc vxc v xcv xccv c xz ve r qer wer we rwe t re rt y rt yu hygtg hnj hgn ng nhg nf df g dff dfg dfg defesrg dfgh fgd dgf dg d g gedr gte te rt re tre t ert...

Words: 261 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Doc1- Socially Constructed Gender Inequalities Final Paper Doc 1 Class

...Socially Constructed Gender Inequalities The socially constructed differences between the sexes in American society have severely infringed the rights of women in the workplace. Mary Blair-Loy’s piece “Competing Devotions: Career and Family among Women Executives,” indicates that a socially constructed family devotion schema defines women as having to stay at home in order to care for children, husband, and household, and therefore women are discouraged by society to hold a job. In the piece “An Overview of Sex Inequality at Work,” Padavic and Reskin further explain that women who are in the job market are excluded from certain male dominated jobs and are often paid and promoted less than male coworkers. Padavic and Reskin’s piece as well as Blair-Loy’s agree that the inequalities found in the workplace, including limited prospects for promotion of women and sex differences in earnings, directly limit the social opportunities of women and keep them subordinate and dominated by men. The constructed roles that men and women are expected to play in our society also affect social institutions such as the home, where women are stereotypically expected to be caregivers, and men are expected to be the breadwinners. Women face a very unfair challenge when deciding what role to play in their adult lives. They also face unwelcome pressure by society to choose one of two schemas that are revealed in the piece by Blair-Loy. In her work, she defines a family devotion schema,......

Words: 1838 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Analysis

...Doc1......

Words: 437 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Death in the Jewish Religion

...“Just as there is a Jewish way of life, there is a Jewish way of death.” When a loved one dies, we feel sadness and grief. Every religion and/or culture has customs and practices when it comes to dealing with death and mourning of our loved ones. The Jewish people have several which will be discussed in detail. Russian Jews also follow the same customs with slight adjustments. From the time of death until the burial, the deceased is never left alone as a sign of respect. This period of time is called aninut. A person (shomer) is chosen to watch over the body and recite Psalms until the burial service. “This person can not eat, drink, or perform a commandment in the presence of the dead. To do so would be considered mocking the dead, because the dead can no longer do these things.” The eyes of the deceased are closed and the body is laid on the floor and covered. Before the funeral service, the body must be purified (tahara). The body is washed thoroughly of dirt, body fluids, and anything else that may be on the skin. The body is then dressed in a white cloth-like material called shrouds (takhrikhin). “All Jews are buried in the same type of garment, regardless of wealth, profession, or position in society as all are equal before God.” The color white represents purity and has been referred to as the national color of early Jews. The Russian-American Jewish community which are mostly reformed Jews usually do not have anyone watching over the deceased. ......

Words: 1628 - Pages: 7