Premium Essay

Due Process and Crime Control

In: Social Issues

Submitted By qaisarraza
Words 8195
Pages 33
Two Models of the Criminal Process

HERBERT L. PACKER

Source: Reprinted from The Limits of the Criminal Sanction by Herbert L. Packer, with the permission of the publishers, Stanford University Press. 1968 by Herbert L. Packer.

In one of the most important contributions to systematic thought about the administration of criminal justice, Herbert Packer articulates the values supporting two models of the justice process. He notes the gulf existing between the "Due Process Model" of criminal administration, with its emphasis on the rights of the individual, and the "Crime Control Model," which sees the regulation of criminal conduct as the most important function of the judicial system.

T wo models of the criminal process will let us perceive the normative antinomy at the heart of the criminal law. These models are not labeled Is and Ought, nor are they to be taken in that sense. Rather, they represent an attempt to abstract two separate value systems that compete for priority in the operation of the criminal process. Neither is presented as either corresponding to reality or representing the ideal to the exclusion of the other. The two models merely afford a convenient way to talk about the operation of a process whose day-to-day functioning involves a constant series of minute adjustments between the competing demands of two value systems and whose normative future likewise involves a series of resolutions of the tensions between competing claims.
I call these two models the Due Process Model and the Crime Control Model. . . . As we examine the way the models operate in each successive stage, we will raise two further inquiries: first, where on a spectrum between the extremes represented by the two models do our present practices seem approximately to fall; second, what appears to be the direction and thrust of current and foreseeable trends along each...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Due Process and Crime Control

...The Warren Court left an unprecedented legacy of judicial activism in the area of civil rights law as well as in the area of civil liberties—specifically, the rights of the accused as addressed in Amendments 4 through 8. In the period from 1961 to 1969, the Warren Court examined almost every aspect of the criminal justice system in the United States, using the 14th Amendment to extend constitutional protections to all courts in every State. This process became known as the “nationalization” of the Bill of Rights. During those years, cases concerning the right to legal counsel, confessions, searches, and the treatment of juvenile criminals all appeared on the Court's docket. The Warren Court's began with the case of Mapp v. Ohio, which was the first of several significant cases that re-evaluated the role of the 14th Amendment as it applied to state judicial systems. In a 6-3 decision, the Court overturne the conviction, and five justices found that the States were bound to exclude evidence seized in violation of the 4th Amendment. The 4th Amendment sets the standards for searches and seizures by law enforcement officials in the United States, the Court noted, and the 14th Amendment requires judges to uphold those standards in every State. Evidence gained by an illegal search became inadmissible in State courts as a result of the decision. The “Mapp Rule” has since been modified, so the exclusionary rule is no longer as absolute as when first handed down in Mapp. Critics......

Words: 2336 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Crime Control Model vs. Due Process Model

...Essay No. 1 CJE3512 Crime Control Model vs. Due Process Model In 1968 Herbert Packer developed two different models that try to explain the different roles and competing values of criminal courts. These models are known as the Crime Control Model and the Due Process Model. Although they are both very different systems, they each impact the way our judicial system is ran. The Crime Control Model is known to be more conservative while the Due Process Model is more liberal. One focuses on the repression of criminal conduct while the other focuses on respect for and protection of individual rights. (Neubauer, Fradella 2013) The Crime Control Model believes in the repression of criminal conduct. This model focuses on factual guilt rather than legal guilt. They consider that any information from the police or prosecutors should be enough to convict a criminal. “Fact finding-initially by the police and later by the prosecutor- is sufficiently foolproof to prevent the innocent from being falsely convicted.” (Neubauer, Fradella 2013) This model emphasizes on reducing crime in society through increased police and prosecutorial powers. According to this model the courts should process cases quickly and advocate decisions of convictions. The principle of the Due Process Model is that citizens have absolute rights and cannot be deprived of them without legal procedures and safeguards. Adherents of this model are usually concerned with unfair rulings from courts towards......

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Compare and Contrast the Crime Control and Due Process Models Utilized by the Criminal Justice System

...The conflict and crime model of justice places a high priority on reducing criminal activity in society by increasing the powers of law enforcement personnel and the prosecutors. The consensus and due process model places emphasis on the individual’s rights and liberty and is concerned about the overwhelming power of the government over the individual. The role each plays is the same, which means each model is funded by the government. The crime control model is in complete agreement with programs that are funded to prosecute with an iron hand. The due process model supporters want less government involvement and more humane treatment. The United States is at great risk in the war against terror. The American homeland is not secure even though there have been several new laws passed such as the Patriot Act, the Visa Reform Act, enhanced border security, and reorganization of several federal government agencies into the Department of Homeland Security. The United States Department of Justice has asked that state and local law enforcement help secure the American homeland. The federal government has groups involved in maintaining border security, other officers working on immigration enforcement, but many feel as though the government has taken a “hear no evil, see no evil and speak no evil” approach to illegal immigration. Police at the state and local levels often are puzzled about how much authority they have in regard to immigration laws. Local law enforcement......

Words: 1777 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Compare and Contrast How the Due Process and Crime Control Modle Shapes Criminal Procedures

...Research Proposal, Part I Rodriquez Richmond Don Fairbee Courtney Westmoreland CJA/334 - RESEARCH METHODS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE JOHN FERRANTE May 2, 2013 Introduction Correctional inmates engage in drug-related and sexual risk behaviors, and the transmission of HIV, hepatitis, and sexually transmitted diseases occurs in correctional facilities. However, there is uncertainty about the extent of transmission, and hyperbolic descriptions of its extent may further stigmatize inmates and elicit punitive responses. Whether infection was acquired within or outside correctional facilities, the prevalence of HIV and other infectious diseases is much higher among inmates than among those in the general community, and the burden of disease among inmates and releases is disproportionately heavy. A comprehensive response is needed, including voluntary counseling and testing on request that is linked to high-quality treatment, disease prevention education, substance abuse treatment, and discharge planning and transitional programs for releases. General area being studied Sexual activity among inmates is a complex phenomenon that occurs along a continuum, from the entirely consensual to the violently coerced. The New York Times detailed a gang-run system of sexual slavery in a Texas prison, where at least 1 gay inmate claimed he was bought and sold......

Words: 977 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Due Process

...Due Process And Crime Control Models Criminology Essay ukessays.com /essays/criminology/due-process-and-crime-control-models-criminology-essay.php Due Process The basis of the due process model is formal structure. When used correctly, the due process model protects the rights of suspects accused of various crimes. The due process model reduces many errors that occur during the investigation, arrest, evidence gathering, and trial. Due process does not support much of the evidence that is used in many criminal trials, and there are many reasons and factors for this. Basically, the due process model criticizes every type of evidence except definitive physical evidence that cannot be disputed. The object of looking at evidence in the due process model is deciding what information may be incorrect, falsified, or coerced from an individual. This has occurred on many occasions when other criminals have testified against the suspect, because they may be rewarded with time off of their sentence or other things. Because the main goal of the due process model us to reduce mistakes that can place an innocent person in prison, the process is very slow (Henham, 1998 & Klein, 2006). Crime Control The idea of the crime control model is to decrease crime in all areas; for this to be done criminal conduct needs to be drastically reduced. Many of the problems that arise in the crime control model is directed at law enforcement officials. People commit crimes and get away with......

Words: 1397 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Criminal Procedure

...The process of criminal procedure involves regulations, which aid the order of procedures the government authorities use to apply criminal laws. The Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Eighth, and Fourteenth amendment, and the Supremes Court understanding of the constitution are important for the study of criminal procedures (Zalman, 2008). The Federal Rules in criminal procedures ensure citizens’ rights to due process, right to a fair trial, right to equal protection, and right to lie, liberty, and property. Due process and crime control models play a major role in shaping criminal procedures. Both models hold some form of constitutional values required in the society we live in (Zalman, 2008). In this paper I will briefly discuss the similarities and the differences and how they have an effect on criminal procedure policies. Crime control model is known as the “presumption of guilt” model. This model assumes defendants are guilty, police and prosecutors are precise in their choices to arrest, apprehend, and prosecute suspects. As a result, the remaining steps in the criminal procedures become automatic and the investigative stages can be opposed (Zalman, 2008). Defendants are moved swiftly through the criminal justice system because he or he is presumed guilty until proven innocent in the court of law. Due process is based on the adversary law system, which believes an individual is innocent until proven guilty in the court of law. The adversary system prohibits law enforcement...

Words: 1074 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Historical Policy Comparison

...Historical Policy Comparison Jermaine Hunt, Jason McFadden, Kendra Williams, Michael Dasher CJA/464 December 10, 2013 Ken Jones Historical Policy Comparison Criminal justice policy over the past 50 has evolved. The key issues of criminal justice policies were gangs, drugs, juvenile, root causes of crime, and gun control. Currently, the key issues are terrorism, illegal immigration, and global organized crime. Traditionally, criminal justice policies were issued by state and local governments. However, the federal government plays an important role in implementation of criminal justice policy. The federal government provides grants to local and state governments to support these criminal justice policies. Criminal justice agencies at the local and state level have to enforce these policies made by federal and state officials. Nevertheless, the local and state governments still bear much of the responsibility. States operate law enforcement agencies, correctional systems, criminal courts system, whereas cities operate the local police departments. Within the past 50 years, criminal justice policies have affected the criminal justice system. The “war on drug” policy has poured billions of dollars into the criminal justice system, although drug-related violence and drugs remain a problem. The criminal justice policies have gone from drugs polices to sentencing policies and currently to globalization policies. Currently, the criminal justice policies go beyond the United......

Words: 3069 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Criminal Procedure Policy

...CJA/364 June 12th, 2011 Page 1 Due Process and Crime Control models reflect different sides of the law, and different sides of beliefs. Due Process is designed more for the defendants to ensure their constitutional rights which are afforded by the Constitution of the United States of America. Crime Control model is more asserted towards the victims of the crimes versus the offender. This model is designed to make sure the offenders are punished, and the victims are afforded vindication. As we travel through this paper it will show the vast differences between the two sides of the justice system. The due process model was incorporated into the U.S. Constitution because the founding fathers did not think a person should be deprived of Life, Liberty, without due process of the law. This has come into the forefront of justice through all avenues such as through police investigations, evidence gathering, and even in the courtrooms across America. People often wonder what due process mean s. According to Duhaime the legal definition of due process is “Fundamental procedural safeguards of which every citizen has an absolute right when a state or court purports to take a decision that would affect any right of that citizen.”(Duhaime, 2009) This process is made up of several rights, but one of the basic ones is the right to be heard, and the right to an impartial judge. The due process model is based on the presumption of......

Words: 1155 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Criminal Procedure

...Lewis CJA/364 January 20, 2014 Walsh, Timothy Criminal Procedure Policy Due process and crime control model shapes the procedures of polices regarding criminals and law enforcement. Due process gives citizens the right to be treated as innocent until proven guilty which is the opposite to the crime control model; you are guilty until proven innocent. Two different approaches, one is a process in which citizens is ensured law enforcement conduct themselves within legal procedures during arrest and the collection of evidence; the other process relying on the integrity of law enforcement by not questioning probable cause nor the collection of evidence to show the guilt of an offender. Due Process gives citizens of America the right to not be deprived of life, liberty, or property without law enforcement going obtaining a warrant by a judge. The rights of citizens by way of due process guarantee a fair process within the criminal justice system. The due process model system of values revolves around the concept of primarily of the individual rights and the complementary concept of limitation of official power of the government. Power is always subject to abuse (Griffiths, 1970). Due process limits this power by give law enforcement rules and regulations as to what they can and cannot do to arrest a citizen and obtain evidence for an arrest. The criminal procedure of due process begins at law enforcement legally arresting a suspect and obtaining a......

Words: 1150 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Compare and Contrast Paper

...Compare and Contrast Karen Hovenga CJA/464 August 12, 2013 Ruth Ebner The Due Process and Crime Control Model are an account of two structures absolutely different from one another and are in competition with one another to be a priority in the functioning of the criminal justice process (Neubauer, 2001, p. 12). “The Due Process Model” proceeds from the premise that protecting the rights of the individual is most important, whereas in the Crime Control Model” holds that reducing crime is the key value” (Neubauer, 2001, 12). When comparing the two control models their opinions differ completely in reference to the causes of crime. Additionally when comparing crime control and due process models one needs to remember, “Proponents of both models embrace constitutional values which are necessary to the kind of society in which American wish to live” (Zalman, 2008, p. 4). In addition answers will be given to questions about the effects on law enforcement, courts, and differences between federal, and state polices, and distinguishes these values. To utilize plea bargaining is controversial because of the fear that innocent defendants would take a plea and the judge would impose unduly sentences (Neubauer, 2008, p. 20). Also the criticism focuses on the deterrent effect of the punishment itself. The crime control model, court hearings have eroded the deterrent effect of punishment (Neubauer, 2009, p. 20). “Not only is the problem serious, but there is evidence......

Words: 2181 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Exclusionary Rule Evaluation from the Fifth Amendment Comes the Exclusionary Rule Which Affirms That No Entities or Things May Be Used and Showed in Court If Taken Unlawfully or Without Appropriate Search Warrant.

...The criminal justice system has two sets of underlying values which are Due Process an Crime Control. Due process values focus on the right of individual while crime control values stress the punishment and repression of criminal conduct. The competing nature of these two value systems is often evident in nation’s court. Due process primary concern of early American court is to protect the right of an individual against the power of the state. The fifth and fourteenth amendments states that no person should be deprive of life, liberty, or property without due process of the law. The due process basically requires that the government should act fairly to people. This means, it is not advisable for the government to rely on individual judgment and impulse when making decisions, but must stay within the boundaries reason and the law. Disagreements as to the meaning of these provisions have overwhelmed courts, politicians, and citizens since this nation was founded and may undoubtedly continue to do so. To properly understand due process, there are two types to be considered; procedural due process and substantive due process. Procedural due process states, the law must be carried out by a method that is fair and orderly. It requires certain procedure be followed in administering and executing a law so that an individual’s basic freedoms are never violated. An example of this is the United States Supreme Court that requires schools to follow certain procedures......

Words: 1082 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Criminal Procedure

...individual’s rights to due process, which means everybody deserves the same rights when arrested regardless of the circumstances such as poor person versus a rich person. The two models that were developed by Herbert Packer were the crime control model and the due process model (book). Both models have similarities as well as differences and not one is “good” and the other “bad” according to Packer. The two primary goals within the criminal justice system are the need to enforce law and maintain social order and the need to protect people from injustice (defenseinvestigator). The fourth, fifth, sixth, and fourteenth amendments play a signifigant role when analyzing both the due process model and the crime control model. This paper will further explore both models as well as how the models view the fourth, fifth, and sixth amendments and how the fourteenth amendment gives the same rights on a state level as well as federal. Crime Control Model The crime control model is a stern approach to the criminal justice system. As described by Hubert Packer, “the crime control model is like a conveyer belt, moving cases starting from arrest to conviction in a swift and fast process (Book).” Fact finding is what defines this model. If an officer makes an arrest based on his or her facts then the prosecutor should push forward with the charges and the individual is presumed guilty. This model can pose some penalties if a person were arrested and convicted for a crime that he or......

Words: 1348 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice

...The due process and crime control models consists of challenging crime and allowing the right justice to be issued. Both models are used in the criminal justice system throughout the United States. The purpose of the two models are to maintain a safety to society, and to protect the criminal’s rights. Both the due process and crime control models are created in theories from criminologists. The due process model is more concerned with individual integrity. It also focuses on more of protecting the society rights. There are many weakness in the due process model. They focus more on the root causes are poverty and racial discrimination. The due process also stresses the possibility of error in the informal fact-finding process and therefore insists on formal fact-finding to protect against mistakes made by the police and prosecutors (w.Neubeauer). The due process models also grants too much leeway and could possibly result in loss of freedom and civil liberties. But most importantly the due process models was designed to make sure the people rights were portrayed ,and they had a fair trial to defend themselves in court. The crime control model was mad to ensure the criminal cases were dealt with quickly so that the criminal was charges at the earliest opportunity. The criminal justice system condemns individuals for partaking in criminal actions. I believe the crime control model was made to concentrate on the conviction. The criminal justice system didn’t really look at as......

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Evaluation Model Essay

...that I have chosen and provided analysis and explanation for my choice. The two models of the criminal justice system are created by a professor named Herbert L. Packer in 1964 at Sanford University, and these two models are "Crime Control Model" and the "Due Process Model." To understand and comprehend what these two models processes are that Professor Parker created for the criminal justice system, we must first define their meaning. Crime Control Model- Refer to a theory of criminal justice which places emphasis on reducing the offense in society through increased police and prosecutorial powers (Us Legal 2016). Due Process Model- Is a type of justice system which based on the principle that a citizen has some absolute rights and cannot be deprived of life, liberty, or property without appropriate legal procedures and safeguards (Us Legal 2016). Summary The crime control model believes that to protect the rights of law-abiding citizens in society, the best course of action would be to expand both the police and prosecutors department in law enforcement. This model belief that stricter, harsher, punishment will ultimately reduce crime. Here are some of the attributes that the crime control model has established in the United States criminal justice system; * Military Police State More Stricter Penalties * More Plea Bargaining ......

Words: 1165 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Criminal Procedure Policy

...Criminal Procedure Policy Paper “A due process model is a type of criminal justice system which is based on the principle that a citizen has some absolute rights and cannot be deprived of life, liberty, or property without appropriate legal procedures and safeguards” ("Due Process Model Law," 2001, p. 1). This model involves two aspects which are procedural and substantive. The main focus of the due process model is the power of the government to protect its society with less focus on the individual liberties of the people. Crime control model is a law that refers to a theory of criminal justice which focuses on decreasing the crime in society through increased police and their prosecutorial powers. Since these two models go hand and hand with criminal justice there will be various opinions of the comparisons and the contrasts. Some of the differences amongst the due process model and the crime control model are that people are innocent until proven guilty in the court of law in conjunction with the due process model. This allows for everyone to be able to receive a fair trial. For those who take the crime control model approach believe that people who are arrested, are guilty and are required to receive punishment by the government. Those who believe in the due process model law feel as though that policing within the criminal justice system is vital to maintaining justice amongst the society. For the individuals who back the crime control model feel that apprehending......

Words: 1120 - Pages: 5