Free Essay

Elaine vs Jerry

In: Business and Management

Submitted By jeff8781
Words 974
Pages 4
In the case of Elaine vs. Jerry we will be looking at numerous legal issues involved. Did Elaine in any way experience discrimination in regards to her termination? Does the company’s employment-at-will status allow for them to terminate any employees without reason? Is there any evidence of ethical violations in the termination of Elaine? Did Elaine and Jerry enter into an express contract when Jerry told her of “great career opportunities” and offered her an annual salary of $30,000? Since the plaintiff is a female and was fired without cause or reason and subsequently replaced by a man with less experience and education she will be able to argue that Jerry has violated Title VII of the Equal Employment Opportunity Act of 1972, Section 703(a)(2). Title VII states that: It shall be an unlawful employment practice for an employer (1) to fail or refuse to hire or discharge any individual, or otherwise to discriminate against any individual with respect to his compensation, term’s, conditions, or privileges of employment, because of such individual’s race, color, religion, sex, or national origin; or (2) to limit, segregate, or classify his employees or applicants for employment in any way which would deprive or tend to deprive any individual of employment opportunities or otherwise adversely affect his status as an employee, because of such individual’s race, color, religion, sex, or national origin (Cheeseman, H. (2007). The legal environment of business and online commerce (5th ed., p. 428). Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson Prentice Hall). The plaintiff may also argue that an express contract was conducted when Jerry offered her $30,000 a year for her services. Express contracts can be either oral or written between two parties in exchange for services provided. An employee who is offered an express employment contract for a definite term, in this case the plaintiff was offered $30,000 per year, can not be discharged in violation of the contract (Cheeseman, H. (2007). The legal environment of business and online commerce (5th ed., p. 202, p. 415). Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson Prentice Hall). The defendant will argue that as an employment-at-will company he has the right to terminate employment of any employee at any time without reason. The defendant can state that no express contract was entered between the two parties but rather an offer of employment. It is common practice for employers to inform employees of their annual salary before officially hiring them. Therefore, as no contract was created the plaintiff was an at-will employee. Under common law an at-will employee can be terminated at any time for any reason (Cheeseman, H. (2007). The legal environment of business and online commerce (5th ed., p. 415). The defendant can argue that he did not violate Title VII by hiring the plaintiff to begin with. If he were discriminatory to her in any way then he would have not hired her in the first place. The defendant can state the male replacement with less experience and education was hired to replace the plaintiff because he (the defendant) was able to pay him less and the job ultimately did not warrant the salary provided to the plaintiff. In the case “Elaine vs. Jerry” I would find for the plaintiff Elaine. The defendant did not act lawfully or ethically when he terminated the plaintiff’s employment. Employment-at-will does not give the employer the right to terminate an employee without cause. No probationary period of employment was stated and the defendant showed that the position held by the plaintiff was necessary to the company when he hired “Kramer”. His argument that he hiring the plaintiff to begin with should exclude him from a Title VII violation does not hold up as he did not provide the other applicants that were available when the plaintiff was hired. I would find that the defendant did indeed violate Title VII as the facts provided show me he discriminated against her sex by hiring a less qualified, less educated man to replace her the first chance he had. I also find that the defendant violated tort law (Intentional Torts Against Persons) and award the plaintiff tort damages in that he intentionally inflicted emotional distress towards the plaintiff. The defendant’s actions of terminating the plaintiff because of her sex caused the plaintiff emotional distress for which I would award damages (Cheeseman, H. (2007). The legal environment of business and online commerce (5th ed., p. 415). I would award reinstatement and back pay retroactive to when the plaintiff was terminated. In this case I do think the current rules are fair and should be enforced. No one should be subject to discrimination of any kind in the workplace. Unfortunately there are people in positions of power who are simple minded and may think that a man is better than a woman or a white person is more capable than a Latino. These rules and laws were put into place because there was an obvious problem that needed to be addressed. If people were not protected by these rules we would have a much different and hostile society. Not to mention our economy would suffer greatly. In this day and age men and woman of all colors participate in the workforce and if we were to limit that to just white men for example, millions of jobs would be lost. Production would suffer immensely, the economy would stall because those who would not be working would not have the income to consume. Unfortunately I believe we still have a long way to go in creating workplace equality but we have also come a long way from where we used to be and much of that is thanks to laws put forth to ensure everyone has the same opportunities free from discrimination.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Elaine

...1.. The disadvantages Elaine faces are her husband can possibly lose his job because of his commissions slipping. This can jeopardize their Childs education, the can lose their home, and Elaine can possibly lose commission on a big loan because of a of her decision not to grant a loan that is an investment of 10 billion dollars over a period of years. The advantage Elaine has is to go along with all of the loans and she will make a great commission and if her husband does lose his job she will be able to hold the family together financially for a long period of time. 2. What are the ethical and legal considerations facing Elaine, dennis, and UBC? Ethically Elaine is facing making a decision on something that is morally wrong to her and right to the company. The company feels her moral outrage is negatively impacting the company from profiting. Legally Elaine may face charges if she go along with a investment that can make the company money but will soon come back on the company and she will be held responsible and can later get fired. 3. Discuss the moral Philosophies that may be relevant to this situation. The Moral Philosophy that may be relevant to this situation is the Utilitarian. The Utilitarian believes the decisions that are made result in the best action made. In Elaine’s case feels company will gain a lot if she decides to go will a billion dollar investment, because it can benefit a lot of people. The other Moral Philosophy would be Deontology. Deontology......

Words: 392 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Bens and Jerrys

...Jerry’s tracks wealth of information of each pint of ice cream and frozen yogurt . If you were to design Ben & Jerry’s data warehouse, what dimensions of information would you include? As you develop your list of dimensions, consider every facet of Ben & Jerry’s business operations, from supply chain management to retail store monitoring. Apabila kami dapat mendesign data warehousing dari Ben and Jerry, adapun data yang akan kami masukkan adalah : Dimensi Proses Pendistribusian * Suhu Udara yang paling sesuai untuk menjaga kualitas es krim Seperti yang kita ketahui, suhu udara sangat mempengaruhi bentuk dan kualitas dari sebuah es krim. Tanpa suhu udara yang baik, kandungan es krim tersebut dapat rusak dan akan mencemari citra Ben and Jerry sendiri. Oleh karena itu, kita perlu mencantumkan ketentuan suhu udara sebagai petunjuk bagi karyawan Ben and Jerry dalam menjaga kualitas es krim selama proses pendistribusian dari Warehouse ke retail – retail. * Kode petunjuk Direksi tujuan masing – masing produk Seperti yang telah kita ketahui, toko retail Ben and Jerry tersebar ke puluhan negara dengan jumlah total sebanyak 50.000 toko retail. Oleh karena itu, kode petunjuk direksi sangatlah dibutuhkan dalam pembagian rute untuk memudahkan proses pendistribusian barang dari warehouse sampai ke retail managemen yang memesan pesanan produk. Dimensi Proses pemasaran * Tanggal produksi (Batch) dan Tanggal kadaluarsa Dengan adanya tanggal produksi, apabila......

Words: 1282 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Ben&Jerry

...(-) * Рост популярности мороженого в стаканчиках (+) * Концепция социальной ответственности и корпоративной благотворительности чуждо для Японии ( - ) | * Сложная логистика ( - ) * Система Just In Time ( + ) | Факторы | Неопределенность | Воздействие | Сценарное планирование | Политические | Низкая | Слабое | Нет | Экономические | Высокая | Сильное | Да | Культурные | Высокая | Сильное | Да | Технологические | Низкая | Слабое | Нет | 1. Интенсивность конкуренции в отрасли : На рынке мороженого работали по меньшей мере шесть японских производителей, выпускавших, в том числе, мороженое класса суперлюкс. Крупнейшая японская компания по производству замороженных десертов, Marigana Seika,в 1995 году дважды делала Ben and Jerry предложения о сотрудничестве. 2. Новые конкуренты : Большое присутствие американских компании на Японском рынке. 3. Потребители : Японцы любят продукты высокого качества, но нет традиции есть десерты и не признают пищу животного происхождения. 4. Поставщики : При работе с компанией Seven-Eleven компания продавала бы мороженое на прямую, таким образом можно было бы избежать лишних затрат, неизбежных в Японской системе распространения с большим количеством посредников. 5. Товары заменители : Замороженные йогурты и мелкие дешевые сладости, такие как щербет – не так важны. Компетенции поддерживающие стратегию | Важность | Сила | Снижение издержек | Дифферениации | V | R | I | O | Вариант с Ямада | Seven-Eleven | Подождать | ......

Words: 854 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Ben and Jerry

...Ben and Jerry Case 2010 “Ben and Jerry’s social orientation was balanced with product and economic objectives. Its mission statement included all three dimensions and stressed seeking new and creative ways of fulfilling each without compromising others.” This excerpt from the McGraw Hill text highlights much of Ben and Jerry’s mission. Although this illuminates the mission of the company, Ben and Jerry’s encountered many imbalances which made corporate takeover seem appealing to many shareholders. Perhaps the most unique part of Ben and Jerry’s is their 3 pillar mission statement. “Product: to make distribute and sell the finest quality all natural ice cream products made from Vermont dairy products… Economic: to operate on a sound financial basis on profitable growth increasing value to its shareholders and creating career opportunities and financial rewards for our employees…. Social: to operate the company in way that actively recognizes the central role that business plays in the structure of society by initiating innovative ways to improve the quality of life of the broad community”(Pinkerton,p49). Ben and Jerry’s actively strived to achieve all three dimensions. The most obvious being its mission to society. Not only did B&J contribute 7.5% of pre-taxed earnings to social causes, they found creative ways to help the community and environment. One prime example being their pact to give their dairy waste water to nourish a local farmers piglets. B&J......

Words: 685 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ben & Jerry

... Page 1. CURENT COMPANY SITUATION……………………………………. 2 2. MISSION STATEMENT………………………………………………….3 3. MARKET SHARE INFORMATION…………………………………….3-6 4. MARKET ANALYSIS……………………………………………………6-8 5. MARKET COMPETITORS……………………………………………. 8-11 6. NEW PRODUCT……………………………………………………….. 11-12 7. FUTURE MARKETING STRATEGY………………………………… 12-15 8. FINANCIAL FORECAST……………………………………………….15-17 9. CONCLUSION…………………………………………………………. 17 10. LIST OF REFERENCES…………………………………………… 18-19 1. CURENT COMPANY SITUATION 1.1 Short History Ben & Jerry’s it’s an American company, producing super-premium ice cream that was founded in 1978 through the collaboration of two friends: Ben Coben and Jerry Greenfield. The two began the business by opening a shop in a renovated gas station in Burlington, Vermont, in 1984 following the first factory to be opened. The company’s product range is plentiful with several flavors including cream, frozen yogurt or sherbet, made with natural ingredients. 1.2. Ben & Jerry’s Today In April 2000, Ben & Jerry's sold the company to British-Dutch multinational food giant Unilever. With superior marketing techniques Ben and Jerry's has positioned themselves to be the leader in manufacturing premium ice cream products. They have successfully targeted their market, and there by achieved a strong customer base. This company is known to be a monopolistically competitive, because there are...

Words: 3289 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Ben and Jerrys

...information contained within this website, assess Ben & Jerry's record on meeting social responsibility goals? How does this company meet its discretionary responsibilities? Give examples of social responsibility actions taken by Ben & Jerry's, and outline them in a brief synopsis. Do you think that more businesses should adopt their strategy? Why, or why not? Please include the name of the person or question to which you are replying in the subject line. For example, "Tom's response to Susan's comment." Reply Quote   Bottom of Form Message Unread Mark as Unread Message Not Flagged Set Flag 5 days ago Avery Coleman  Email Author Avery's response to the Unit III Discussion Board COLLAPSE Top of Form Parent Post Ben & Jerry use Archie Carroll’s theory on business regarding being socially responsible. The company has an excellent record on being socially responsible. The company has several organizations and programs they contribute and donate to.  The company meets its discretionary responsibilities by supporting same sex marriages, the growing peace-building movement, and supporting holding elected leaders more accountable to the people. They also support fair trade. This ensures small farmers in developing countries can compete and thrive in the global economy ("Ben & Jerry's", 2014). Ben & Jerry’s is also social responsible. They support mandatory genetically modified organisms (GMO) labeling legislation. GMOs are organisms that have......

Words: 5245 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Ben and Jerrys

...Ben and Jerry’s Ben and Jerry’s Homemade was founded in 1978 in an old gas station in Burlington, Vermont. The company was started due to the owners (Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield) willingness to make a business successful. By early 2000, the company itself had become bigger than they expected with over 170 stores (scoop shops) across the United States and with international ties with inside supermarkets. The annual sales themselves had grown by $77 million to the company’s new equity of $237 million. The company that once was just a thought and idea had now become a new powerhouse in the ice cream industry. They initiated their first public equity financing in May of 1984. The company, however, only issued it to the Vermont residents with 75,000 shares at $10.50 a share. The reasoning behind only offering it to Vermonters was to give the first people to support them and opportunity to invest in the company. However, the company offered a traditional broad offering for liquidity purposes later and to help with capital. The company itself focused intensely on the social aspect of the company to further improve their social standing. Furthermore, the social orientation was still balanced with product and economic objectives. Once Ben & Jerry’s went public they decided they wanted three equity classes, class A common, class B common, and class A preferred. The class A common had the right to one vote for each share held. Reserved primary for insiders, class B common had...

Words: 1238 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ben & Jerry

...statement? Ben & Jerry were able to fulfill their mission statement with the finest quality all-natural ice cream, profitable business and by improving the community. Ben & Jerry stated, they would make and distribute the finest quality all natural ice cream with a wide variety of innovative flavors, which they fulfilled. They created interesting names such as Chubby Hubby, Chunky Monkey and Phish Food with flavors to match. With the great flavors and names produced a profitable business, which was one of the points in their mission statement. When Ben & Jerry decided to start issuing shares exclusively to the Vermont residents, it was both a financial decision as well as a social decision. It allowed the Vermont residents to become successful on the profits of a business right in their own back yard. The shares were sold at a reasonable price to allow for the purchase. In order to offer greater liquidity and capital, the traditional way of selling shares took place as well as being listed on the NASDAQ. Ben & Jerry were also innovative on how they reduced expenses as well as benefit a local business. When they moved to their new plant in Waterbury CT, there was a limit to the amount of liquid waste, therefore incur more expenses. They made a deal with a local pig farmer to feed his pigs the milky water, which the pigs enjoyed as well as loan the local farmer money to purchase 200 more pigs. This decision was beneficial to the farmer as well as Ben & Jerry, which connects......

Words: 795 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ben and Jerry

...Natasha Wilson Feed your confidence Ben and Jerry started out with a small idea that grew into so much more. They began to realize how much the business world was changing them and didn’t want to turn into the kind of business that they always seen as a negative condensation. They wanted to make a change, so they did by making the first decision to give a percentage of their profit to charitable foundations and giving the highest percentage of a public company at the time. Ben and Jerry then wanted to do more so they decided to make a change with their products. Purchasing brownies from Greyston was their way of doing something better in the world and giving back. Now Ben & Jerrys works with a lot of other organizations that help give back to their communities. They now believe that the more giving and caring they are the more profitable they are. Greyston Story Greyston is a bakery in New York that bakes with the richest ingredients and crafting everything from scratch. Branny the owner of Greyston wanted to make a difference with this bakery and give back to the community. Barrny gives back by helping the homeless rate in his community, he takes the profits of company and provides housing and jobs for the unemployed. He is working through social problems by the world of business. Greyston also has a construction company that repairs vacant home which gives more people of the community jobs. Barrny encourages them every family to make the change. He......

Words: 400 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Jerry Rice

...Jerry Rice Jerry Rice widely considered being the greatest wide receiver in the history of the National Football League. In college, he earned All-America honors and set 18 Division I-AA records. The San Francisco 49ers drafted Rice in the first round in 1985, it was the start of a 20 year career. Jerry Lee Rice, born on October 13, 1962 raised in Starkville, Mississippi had a hard childhood; As a young boy, Jerry saw a lot of poor events in his life, but very little of luxury that later became a part of his life. His father, a brick mason built a home for his large family. When money was short, rice helped his father carry bricks and mix mortar. It was grueling work, but Rice later came to be grateful for it. “It taught me the meaning of hard work,” he said. When money was rational, Jerry started to involve his life around sports. In high school, Rice played every position, from quarterback to tackle. The coach started to see that Jerry can play at college level; from there, Jerry made a promise to a Crawford coach, Archie Cooley, to take a recruiting trip. A graceful, speedy, and nearly unstoppable wide receiver was born. Rice helped put Mississippi State on the map; he caught more than 100 passes in each of his last two seasons. As a senior, he had 28 touchdown receptions. Rice was so good that since he was 18 years old, he has been doubled teamed on the field. After leading Mississippi State to a 24-6-1 record, Jerry was going down the...

Words: 562 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Jerry Mccain

...watching. There was so much pressure to perform. Jerry McCain, American born with Irish descent, was hands down the best wide receiver in the world. He was playing in his second super bowl with the San Francisco 49ers. Last time was an embarrassment for McCain. The final score was 68-14, a devastating loss for the 49ers. But this time, there’s hope. It’s the last chance for San Francisco to score. They were losing 44-40 just barely behind. A touchdown was all they needed to win them the game. McCain gets a great pass. There were just two defenders to beat. Jerry makes it past the first one, but then he loses his balance. As he finally gets his head up, he notices the next defender, fiercely sprinting towards him. But then, the collision. The defender’s shoulder into McCain's head. There was a gasp from the crowd, his head jolted backwards as the rest of his limp body hurled forward. He landed right on his neck, but by then he was already out cold by the time he hit the ground. The other players desperately waved for the medical staff to get on the field. They immediately brought him to the hospital, this would definitely be his last ever football game, and possible his last day ever. While his frightened family sat outside the operating room, doctors did everything in their ability to save Jerry’s life. After an agonizing three hour wait, Maggie and Betty, Jerry's daughter and wife finally saw the doctor exit the operating room. “Jerry is in very critical condition. His......

Words: 3256 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Jerry Kennely

...JERRY KENNELLY 1. Compromised – 50 photographers for 1 photo- Quality 2. Identified social trends- visionary 3. Flexible- Trends, cultures- although couldn’t adapt the quality 4. Punctuality and execution 5. Innovation 6. Growing very fast RESPONSIBILITIES 1. International conference calls 2. Taking responsibility of employees and incidents within organisation 3. Controller of the organisation (CEO). His wife and him are the shareholders. 4. Looking for new ways to innovate and provide better services 5. Analysing the customers 6. Keep Pace 7. Maintain flexibility 8. Punctuality maintenance 9. Maintain quality 10. Maintain customer relations 11. Face legal issues WEAKNESSES 1. Small company- limited resources, opportunities, employees and less economies of scale 2. Too centralised- no one to question actions- can make potential mistakes STRENGTHS 1. Flexible organisational structure 2. Quality 3. Customer focus 4. Customised search engine- unique filter features 5. Passion of owner 6. Quick decision making 7. Financially independent 8. Creative/Innovative/ Entrepreneurial 9. High growth market 10. Growing customer base THREATS 1. Competitors (New and Existing) Say Apple bough SB 2. Acquisition threat from Getty 3. Changing trends of customer 4. Copyright threat from freelancers 5. Privacy threats- legal changes 6. Technological......

Words: 393 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ben and Jerrys

...order to prepare a feasible recommendation. Competition – Dreyers and Haagen-Dazs, intense, many numerous competitors, cost of switching brands is low, competitors use tactics to force rivals’ production volumes Buyers – power is high, buyers are large so have leverage over price, buyers more likely to switch because don’t incur large costs, need product variety Suppliers – moderate leverage, many suppliers depend on big dairy companies, can shop around for other suppliers Substitutes – other deserts, pies can deter buyers away from ice cream, most have good taste/brand in order to discourage substitutes for price differences New Entrants – established companies have brand loyalty, large start up costs (plants, capital etc), Ben & Jerry used distribution channels of rivals, might not be possible for others to do so. Strengths – success in consistent environmental policies and efficient manufacturing -exploit this strength to gain more customer loyalty towards social consciousness -few compliance issues, strong minimization of environmental damage -good business culture (salary ratio, corporate responsibility) Weaknesses – difficulty recruiting the best due to salary policies (5:1) -lack of mgmt professionalism and clear goals for next steps -focus on social responsibility shifts funds and direction away from business development -super premium segment where bulk of biz is stagnant and high cost -a lot of complexity with too many flavours to manage -salary......

Words: 419 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ben & Jerry

...and directions of the company, it was evident that there was a significant disconnect between management and Ben, Jerry, and Jeff Furman, their longtime attorney and general counsel. Ben and Jerry had originally developed a unique company mission and principles and had placed more of their focus on maintaining a fun and open structure of operating that married simple business principles with an innovative company culture. Conversely, the managers shared a more common focus, one that was centered on dealing with the day-to-day issues of running a business that included unclear lines of authority and responsibility, lack of operational control and feuding amongst themselves. In some cases, there was a lack of support or belief in the socially oriented policies and notion that work is supposed to be “fun,” policies and a notion that Ben and Jerry had originally developed the company based upon. Further exacerbating the issue is the differences in personality between Ben, Jerry, and Jeff and their general manager of the company, Chico. Chico is significantly more conservative than Ben, Jerry, and Jeff and took a more practical business-like approach in his supervision of the operations. His pragmatic approach included expense monitoring, priority redistribution, and the arbitration of disagreements among management and his other employees, whereas Ben and Jerry focused on “weird” advertising campaigns and social responsibility initiatives. They expected any adversity......

Words: 5482 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Ben and Jerry

...................... 17 5.9 Research Methods.................................................................................................................................. 17 5.10 Sampling Plan........................................................................................................................................ 18 6 Timetable and Allocation over Task........................................................................................................... 19 1 2 3 4 Proposal Plan of Approach 1 Ben & Jerry’s Market Research Introduction INTRODUCTION This is a proposal of marketing search project that is conducted by group A. Ben & Jerry is chosen as our search target company. In the first part of this proposal, you can find detailed background information of Ben & Jerry, which gives a rough description of its four “P” (price, promotion, place and people). In addition, it also covers several issues about the European ice cream market. The next part of this proposal is mainly discussing marketing management problems. You can find out Ben & Jerry‘s symptoms, suspected causes of its marketing management problems, Ben& Jerry’s actions and its consequences. Besides that, we listed several questions to help us analyze customers’ buying behavior and the main methods we will used in order to finish our survey. The schedule and sampling plan will give you a full picture of our project progress. Proposal Plan of Approach 2 Ben & Jerry’s......

Words: 3195 - Pages: 13