Free Essay

Employee Selection & Performance Appraisal Methods

In:

Submitted By luckydip3
Words 2108
Pages 9
Running head: CRITICAL THINKING AND DECISION MAKING

Individual Paper: Critical Thinking and Decision Making by Daniel Palliparambil
DMBA610 – Ethical Leadership in Organizations & Society
University of Maryland University College
September 16, 2011

Individual Paper

Introduction

Outsourcing is a relevant and arguable issue in the United States. Jobs that were previously handled by American workers are already being handled by workers located in other countries that offer lower wages and lower costs of living. The case study describes the Department of Transportation of Illinois plans to outsource the management of information management systems. Ms. Barbara Glenn makes several arguments against this outsourcing in her memo to Mr. Cesar Padilla, the President of the FSEU (FSEU Memo, 2011).

In the book, “Asking the Right Questions: A Guide to Critical Thinking (Tenth Edition), by M. Neil Brown and Stuart M. Keeley”, the authors examine the benefits of critical thinking as it relates to the process of asking the right kinds of questions. The authors define critical thinking: “as the awareness of a set of interrelated critical questions, the ability to ask and answer critical questions at appropriate times; and the desire to actively use the critical questions” (Brown & Keeley, 2010, p. 2). In my examination of the Memo by Ms. Barbara Glenn, I will apply the various steps developed by Brown and Keeley, to examine the arguments made.

Conclusions and Issues Involved

Ms. Glenn stated that the proposal to outsource the information management system of the Department of Transportation is a straight assault on the Union and will not be favorable to the members of the Union, the employees in the U.S. and also to the overall condition of the domestic economy. Consequently, her recommendation was to fight this move with the maximum amount of effort that they can assemble. The plan to outsource would increase the slow destruction within the information management system division of the Department of Tourism, depriving them of jobs that they have performed for long years already. Ms. Glenn’s memo also calls out the governor as being a bully who does not consider at all the long term jobs of the Union members in the name of cost savings and efficiency. The action of the DoT will spread to other departments and should be opposed while it can still be opposed.

The Reasons Offered in the Memo

Ms. Glenn provided several reasons supporting her arguments for going against the proposed outsourcing of information management system of the DoT. The chief reason for opposing the outsourcing move is that the management is attempting to guide the Union and the rest of the employees to a position which would leave them no choice but to accept lower wages comparable to those being received by their counterparts in other countries with lower wages. The decision could also be a way to push away older employees with higher tenure. Learning new tasks and jobs would not be easy for these types of Union members and therefore, would be displaced with no jobs to absorb them. She also mentions that outsourcing is the cause of the recession in the American economy and that if Mr. Padilla would adhere to Ms. Glenn’s arguments; he would enjoy greater popularity and his re-election would be guaranteed (FSEU Memo, 2011).

Finally, outsourcing of information management systems will compromise confidential information of the citizens of Illinois because this data would be in the possession of foreigners who may have additional benefits in using the information for purposes other than what they were intended for. She also stresses that the major focus of corporations is profit and will proceed only for that without consideration of the public interest.

Ambiguous Words and Phrases

When examining someone’s argument one must be critical in understanding the pros and cons of their argument (Brown & Keeley, 2010). Some words and phrases were ambiguous and would need further explanation to reach a better understanding. For example, Anti-American is a very strong term that could bring to mind conflicting images such as terrorism and religious extremism. This will then affect the reader as if the whole national interest of the U.S. is at risk because of the ambiguity and vagueness of the term.

“Losing control of information systems” and “compromised data” can also be viewed as ambiguous terms (FSEU memo, 2011). While the phrases were used in the framework of corporate responsibility and outsourcing, their implications are a little unclear in relation to the outsourcing matter and the Union members. The term “Communication and culture crash problems” is also ambiguous and generates the perception that there are contradictory disparities between and among peoples coming from different countries (FSEU memo, 2011).

Value Conflicts and Assumptions

The ambiguous words and phrases could perhaps be explained better by looking at the core value conflicts and assumptions. Ms. Glenn seems to identify that the moves of the management are based on the Union and forming scenarios for “bullying” the Union into subservience. Her arguments necessarily draw upon a basic observation that management and Union will in no way be like-minded. Since the management is lobbying for outsourcing, the argument she presented follows that the stage for management-union divergence is set. Things can only be resolved therefore with conflict and direct confrontation.

Another assumption, which also gives away the underlying value conflicts, is the claim that Mr. Padilla will win the approval of the Union members and will assure him his re-election. This is a big assumption in the perception and views of the Union members that may be hard to quantify or back up with information. Ms. Glenn’s memo also presumed that with outsourcing, foreign companies and agents will be the ones who will win the bidding. This does not take into account that there may also be U.S. companies that might also bid on the contract of outsourcing.

Descriptive Assumptions

In terms of descriptive assumptions, she assumed that older inexperienced workers do not want to learn new tasks or jobs and are content in doing the tasks that they feel proficient in performing. While it is difficult to learn new tasks and proficiencies, there are older workers who welcome the challenge of learning new things in their jobs for their personal and professional growth and development.

She assumed that corporations are only interested in profits and if they are no longer enjoying profits, corporations would compromise the interests of their clients, which in the case of the memo is the State Department of Transportation. She also assumed that the government would do well to let go of other wasteful projects and instead leave the Union alone. This assumption means that the Union should be free of the interference of the management, which would not be a viable scenario.

Fallacies in Reasoning

The discussion section of the memo has several misleading notions in reasoning that deteriorate the arguments put forth. In the memo, Ms. Glenn engages in name-calling as she calls the governor a bully, which brought to light her outlook that the management and Union are continuously locked in conflict. Name-calling does not add to her argument for her case and should not be included. This erroneous belief is demeaning the source and attacks the person who instigated the outsourcing without striking down the move itself.

Ms. Glenn also appeals to the possible re-election of Mr. Padilla. This could be considered as deceptive reasoning because the decision would be based on appeal to the crowd. Although the majority of people may hold an outlook, it does not necessarily mean that theirs is the correct position. By stating that “corporations are accountable only to the bottom line,” (FSEU Memo, 2011) the author commits the fallacy of broad oversimplification. While many companies are largely focused on profit, there are companies that exist who use profits to pursue unselfish aims. The author also engages in a quick generalization by considering the author’s brother in law as the source for the attrition and downsizing of the American economy. While this case may be true, it is too small a sample to make such an important generalization.

Evidences for the Arguments

For the arguments to stand, proof and support should be presented. The author of the memo provides several claims. Ms. Glenn claims that outsourcing is the cause of recession and uses as evidence her brother-in-law who is still unemployed. This evidence does not successfully sustain the argument put forward by Ms. Glenn because there might be other intervening factors to explain why her brother-in-law is still not working.

Wikipedia is also cited as a source for the arguments of Ms. Glenn against the advantages of privatization. Although the Wikipedia article may have cited authoritative sources such as laws, books and academic journals, Wikipedia, itself, is far from being an authoritative source due to the fact that anyone with a free account at Wikipedia can edit an article. In addition to this, the author did not even list down the relevant provision of the Pendleton Act of 1883 to help bolster her arguments.

Alternative or Rival Causes

A further contingent substantiation she presented is an article published by an unnamed Wall Street newspaper claiming that there is an extra 20% cost to government’s contract with a third party vendor or service provider. While this may be true, there may be other causes for the additional 20% charge and the overall cost might still be more efficient and valuable than other options available.

Statistics in the Memo

The author did not present statistical data for her arguments. Actually, the lack of statistics is an evident weakness in the arguments put forward in the memo. The author used her brother in law’s experience with a Michigan company and articles lifted from the Internet and some vague newspaper. If the author presented statistics or research studies conducted that support her arguments, the arguments would have been stronger.

Information Omitted

The memo presented only the side of Ms. Glenn and the perspective of the Union. Hence, it is unbalanced given the interests of the Union took the center stage in the written memo. What was not provided was the government’s prospective and the arguments associated with the move that they are making. The government does have reasons to proceed with the outsourcing project, and this may or may not include the direct attack on the Union as was understood by Ms. Glenn.

The current cost of operations and maintenance of the government would have been a great addition to a better understanding of the issue at hand and not only the possible savings that the State department could enjoy. By itemizing the disputes of the government point by point, Ms. Glenn could have confronted the arguments one by one and went on to establish her case against the outsourcing move by the government. The alleged benefits of outsourcing could also have been presented. Yet, such benefits were removed altogether. Statistics on attrition rate, the outsourcing industry and the employment rate in the U.S. could also have helped the case be presented more strongly.

Alternative and Reasonable Conclusions

Outsourcing may have its negative aspects yet its benefits should not be discharged altogether. The outsourcing move could generate thousands, if not millions of dollars in savings for the benefit of the government. Such savings, in turn could be used for the greater public good. Yet, outsourcing could also be detrimental to the employees and to the Union in general.

Outsourcing can lead to extensive unemployment because the Department would have to release workers that will no longer have active roles to play in the company. Given the economic recession in the United States, these workers may not be hired by other companies. In addition to this, learning new tasks and proficiencies may be a big challenge for most of them. If unemployment will rise, then the quality of life of Americans will be compromised and the government will then have to spend more in response to the difficulties that will arise in response to this. Outsourcing also poses big challenges in terms of data management, confidentiality and cultural exchange between and among those who provide service and the American consumers. The Union will have to challenge the decision of the government on the basis of its impact on the workers and on the overall situation of the Department of Transportation.

References

Browne, M. N., & Keeley, S.M. (2010). Asking the right questions: A guide to critical thinking (10th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Prentice Hall.

FSEU Memo. (2011). Memo Sent to Mr. Cesar Padilla by Barbara Glenn, FSEU Local No. 343.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Employee Selection

...Employee Selection Process and Performance Appraisal Methods in the Workplace: Effective Methods and Recommendations for Happier Employees Jeremiah Lawrence Ethical Leadership Orgn & SOC DMBA 610 9040 11/9/2014 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This paper will delve into the employee selection process and the various performance appraisal methods used by different companies. Gerard C. Eakedale has once said “recognition is the greatest motivator.” Human Resources Departments are aware of this and have implemented the appropriate methods to incorporate their appreciation and gratitude to employees when they go above and beyond the call of duty to improve their work performance. This paper will analyze the methods used at my current company of employment and recommend improvements that can contribute to improving the workplace performance. Employee selection processes are a company’s way of finding out who would be the best candidate for the specific position they are trying to fill. Whether it be from one simple phone interview or multiple interviews with different managers of the company, different businesses come up with what they believe to be the most effective way to find someone to fill a position and must follow the procedure. This procedure is put into place so that there will be no confusion or risks of any favoritism, bias, illegal, or biased behavior going into the process. Additionally, employees working for a company want to feel appreciated for all of their hard...

Words: 2229 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management

...composed of a group of people who interact with each other for the purpose of achieving a common goal. b) Goal refers to desired targets to be achieved in the future. The basic goal of any organization should ideally be to serve the human society. Example; to upgrade the standard of living of Sri Lankan people through the production and distribution of high quality dairy products. c) Human Resources are employees who work for the organization being concerned. It is not an exaggeration that HR is the most significant resource compared with other resources such as financial resources, physical resources, etc. The overwhelming significance of HR is due to its unique characteristics. d) Efficient utilization of HR means optimum use of employee by eradicating or minimizing wastage. It denotes utilizing the right employees in the right number at the right cost. • It is animate, active and living • It has the ability to think, feel and react • Its value appreciate with the passage of time • It has the ability to influence on determining its cost • It has the ability to organize • Its behavior is complex and sometimes unpredictable • It has the ability of creativity and innovation, which cannot be found in any other resources • It makes decisions in respect of all other resources e) Effective utilization refers to use of HR...

Words: 9092 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay

Effective Hrm Practise in Banking Sector of Bangladesh

...activities, which aim to improve the Bank’s capacity to achieve greater effectiveness, including improved quality of service. There are number of HR practices that could be tested in connection with employee performance. We have studied eleven HR practices and their relationship with organizational success which are personnel selection, performance appraisal, incentive compensation, job design, grievance procedures, information sharing, attitude assessment, labor-management participation, recruitment efforts, employee training and promotion criteria. These eleven HR practice in very important to achieve organizational success and these practices have positive relationship with organizational success. Methodology: The questionnaire was based on questionnaire for measuring impact of various HR practices on employee performance and as well as organizational success. The reason for selecting this questionnaire is that it was used to study the impact of same variables as in present study and was well tested on reliability and validity scales this questionnaire was also correction by our teacher. Questionnaire that was administered consisted of 16 questions and these questions are included Compensation Practices, Promotion Practices Performance Evaluation Practices and Perceived Employee Performance and so on. To complete this term paper we use primary data. Literature Review: Human resources management includes a variety of activities , and among them is deciding what staffing needs...

Words: 5188 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

About Performance Appraisal

...Reasons For Appraisal The main objective of an appraisal system is improving the performance of the employee and thus improving organizational performance - an well designed system can help in achieving both. Actually, information gathered through the performance appraisal exercise are potentially valuable for practically all human resource functional areas; therefore, performance appraisal can be used for Human Resource Planning, Recruitment and Selection, Training and Development, Career Planning and Development, Internal Employee Relations, and Assessment of Employee Potential. Human Resource Planning Human Resource planning is a process where human resource requirements are systematically reviewed to make sure that the number of employees who possess the required skills for the smooth functioning of the organization are available. It includes conduction skills inventories, developing succession plans and acquiring information for further personnel needs. Managers and supervisors decide the employees who are to be promoted, demoted, transferred, laid-off and who would need training. They also assist individuals with career planning and ascertain whether the skills needed in the organization are lacking (www.opm.gov). An appraisal system that is properly constructed profiles the organization’s human resource strengths and weaknesses to support these efforts - data collected over a number of appraisal periods could be used in evaluating if the overall workforce quality...

Words: 1604 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Pmp Formulas

...Employee Selection and Performance Appraisal March 29, 2013 Analysis of the Employee Selection and Performance Appraisal Methods in the Department. Because of the competitive nature of any business, the need and demand of an optimized labor force is critical to the success of any organization. Businesses are consistently searching and recruiting for qualified and retainable personnel. I will discuss in detail the process of interviewing and selecting that has proven to be both rewarding and successful for the organization. Interviewing and Selection Process Before the interviewing process, potential candidates, whose resume’s and applications have been reviewed and found to have met the qualifying factors for the positions, may be called by the hiring official for a brief notification and/or phone pre-screening. Step 1: Develop Behavior Based Interview Questions These questions gives the hiring officials insight on how the candidate would act in specific knowledge and experiences as related to the position being filled; Step 2: Conduct Behavior Based Interview The behavior based interview is one of the most important tools DHS uses to assess the qualifications of the potential candidates, it is a thorough indicator of the candidates future performance and aids in the detection of how an employee will perform, once hired, in certain situations. Step 3: Assess the Candidate In this step the hiring official evaluate...

Words: 761 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Objectives Of Performance Appraisal

... LEARNING OBJECTIVES • To define performance appraisal • To describe the objectives and process of appraisal • To gain an overview of various traditional and modern methods of performance appraisal • To gain an insight into the concept of potential appraisal. 8.2 INTRODUCTION Performance appraisals is a systematic process of accessing individual employee’s job performance. It determine who needs what type of training, and who will be promoted, demoted, retained, or fired in the next session. It is a process by which a manager or consultant. • It aim at examining and evaluating the employee's performance at the work and his consequent behavior by comparing it with preset standards, • Document the results of the comparisons,...

Words: 1189 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Dunkin Donuts

...franchises these responsibilities are magnified. District managers are directly responsible for hiring training and overseeing these new teams. They are also responsible for the ordering receiving and control of the initial inventory. Starting a new franchise has added responsibilities including job and organizational design, staffing selection and recruiting as well as introducing and implementing a training and performance appraisal model and ensuring it is carried out. Job Design Job design aims to cut down on job dissatisfaction and employee disconnection by reducing the repetitive and mechanical tasks. Companies implement job design to attempt to increase productivity levels, satisfaction and motivation in employees. Job analysis, job description, and job specification are the three standard approaches to job design (Baack, Reilly, & Minnick, 2014). Job Analysis Job analysis is the process that follows position identification and building in an organizational chart. Job analysis is the first step in hiring an employee. The particular tasks and responsibilities of the position are stated in this process. Using the comparison model as one approach to job analysis would outline the current standards in the company that have worked well in the past and the standards set forth by similar organizations that have been...

Words: 1504 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Dunkin Donuts

...district manager, many responsibilities come with the job. District management is responsible for virtually all the operations in the company with respect to the business goals that have been set out in the company plan. This is especially the case when the district assigned is a group of new area start-ups. District managers are responsible for the allocation of resources, hiring, training and managing teams. The roles of a district manager starting new Dunkin’ Donuts locations are no different yet they include the responsibility for a smooth start. These added responsibilities include job design, organizational design, staffing functions such as recruiting and selection, as well as the implementation of a training and performance appraisal processes. Job Design Job design aims to reduce job dissatisfaction and employee alienation by means of repetitive and mechanistic tasks. Organizations attempt to increase productivity levels, satisfaction and motivation to employees through job design. Job analysis, job description, and job specification are the three standard approaches to job design (Baack, Reilly, & Minnick, 2014). Job Analysis Job Analysis is a process, which is followed right after position identification and position building in an organization chart. It is the first step in the process of hiring a candidate as it outlines the particular task required for each position created. Two approaches to job analysis best suited for our organization would be through comparison...

Words: 1545 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management

...resource management is both an academic theory and a business practice that addresses the theoretical and practical techniques of managing a workforce. The Human Resources Management (HRM) function includes a variety of activities, and key among them is deciding what staffing needs you have and whether to use independent contractors or hire employees to fill these needs, recruiting and training the best employees, ensuring they are high performers, dealing with performance issues, and ensuring your personnel and management practices conform to various regulations. Activities also include managing your approach to employee benefits and compensation, employee records and personnel policies. Usually small businesses (for-profit or nonprofit) have to carry out these activities themselves because they can't yet afford part- or full-time help. However, they should always ensure that employees have and are aware of -- personnel policies which conform to current regulations. These policies are often in the form of employee manuals, which all employees have. Note that some people distinguish a difference between HRM (a major management activity) and HRD (Human Resource Development, a profession). Those people might include HRM in...

Words: 9822 - Pages: 40

Premium Essay

Hrm Analysis of a Selected Organization

...human capital to be invested in through the provision of learning opportunities and the development of a learning organisation and are viewed as a source of competitive advantage. The overall purpose of HRM is to ensure that the organisation is able to achieve success through people. The methods used vary in according to countries. The Human Resources Management (HRM) function includes a variety of activities, and key among them is deciding what staffing needs you have and whether to use independent contractors or hire employees to fill these needs, recruiting and training the best employees, ensuring they are high performers, dealing with performance issues, and ensuring your personnel and management practices conform to various regulations. Activities also include managing your approach to employee benefits and compensation, employee records and personnel policies. Usually small businesses (for-profit or nonprofit) have to carry out these activities themselves because they can't yet afford part- or full-time help. However, they should always ensure that employees have -- and are aware of -- personnel policies which conform to current regulations. These policies are often in the form of employee...

Words: 9270 - Pages: 38

Free Essay

Performance Management Plan

...Performance Management Plan HRM/531 October 29, 2013 Performance Management Plan A performance management plan is a non-stop process of defining, measuring and assessing goals in order to effectively manage employee performance that is critical to organization’s business strategy. This performance management plan developed for Landslide Limousine will be organized into three steps. 1. Define Performance, 2. Facilitate Performance and 3. Encourage Performance. According to Cascio (2013) the broad process of performance management requires that three things are done well. Define Performance This process involves three key elements: goals, measures, and assessments. Defining performance or expectations for employees needs to be clearly defined in order to provide direction to maintain or improve productivity. When goals are not specific, it triggers a cascade of problems all leading to poor completion of organizational goals. According to Wayne State University (2013) goals need to be S.M.A.R.T (specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, time based). As mentioned, goals need to be measureable. An example of a measurable goal for a limousine driver is as follows, drivers should be given clear objectives such as, customer site punctuality at 95% of time or greater over an interval of 6 months. Not only is this goal specific by its punctuality percentage, but it can also be measured over a 6 month interval. This goal can be measured by way of a log sheet recorded...

Words: 1319 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

City Bank

...the capital, Dhaka. It is a top bank among the oldest five Commercial Banks in the country which started their operations in 1983. It was the vision of 13 local businessmen who braved the risks and uncertainty with courage and fervor that made the establishment & development of the bank possible. Those sponsor directors initially started the journey with only taka 3.4 crore worth of capital, which now is a respectable taka 330.77 crore of capital & reserve. It is among very few local banks which do not tend to follow the traditional, decentralized, geographically managed, branch based business or profit model. The bank holds 12th position among all the private sector banks in accordance to highest growth sector due to the dismal performances of government banks.According to the definition of human resources planning, it is a process that identifies current and future human resources needs for an organization to achieve its goals. It should serve as a link between human resources management and the overall strategic plan of an organization, and City Bank, apparently, is focusing on right placement of its major resource – human resources. The bank believes in putting the right people at the right place. In maximum part of the year 2010, 2,685 employees worked together to make possible the technological advancement, extension and innovation that has set to achieve and to anticipate the customers’ needs and ensure their satisfaction. | The bank manages its business and operation...

Words: 6945 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management

...2.1 Recruitment and Selection process in SQUARE Recruitment is the process trough which the organization seeks applicants for potential employment. Selection refers to the process by which it attempts to identify applicants with the necessary knowledge, skills, abilities and other characteristics that will help the company achieve its goals, companies engaging in different strategies need different types and numbers of employees. The strategy a company is pursuing will have a direct impact on the types of employees that it seeks to recruit and selection. Source of recruitment There are two kinds of source SQUARE uses for recruitment .They are 1. External source 2. Internal source. We try to discuss all relative sources which are used for recruitment in SQUARE. Training and Development program of SQUARE textile Training is a process of learning a sequence of programmed behavior. it is application of knowledge. It gives people an awareness of the rules procedures to guide their behavior. It attempts to improve their performance on the current job or prepare them for an intended job. Development is a related process. It covers not only those activities which improve job performance but also those which bring growth of the personality; help individuals to the progress towards maturity and actualization of their potential capacities so that they become not only good employees but better men and women. In organizational terms, it is intended to equip person to earn...

Words: 622 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Career Development Plan Summary

...cleaning industry. The merger of these two leaders provides for the opportunity to offer new solutions based services to its current and future clients. For this merger to be successful and generate the most benefit for the company, the human resources department (HR) has been tasked with creating a new career development plan. This plan is multi faceted and includes job analysis and selection, employee training, performance and career management and employee compensation. As sales and customer service are the customer’s first and continual contacts, HR has focused on this newly merged department to be both test subjects and provide feedback. Job Analysis, Job Description and Specification Combining two individual companies into one industry powerhouse has created the need to evaluate the jobs performed by employees of both companies and develop new job descriptions that will maximize success. This evaluation process is known as job analysis. Anthony, et al. (2002) and Dessler (2003), as quoted by Safdar, Waheed and Rafiq (2010) states “With increasing recognition of the HR-performance linkage, it has been suggested that organizations that actively pursue job analysis as a Human Resources Planning (HRP) strategy are likely to gain a competitive edge” (p. 18). By establishing core competencies and skills required, InterClean/EnviroTech will draw and retain the talent required to make the company successful. From these core competencies and skills developed through the...

Words: 2181 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Term Paper-Hrm

... |113122005 | |Md. Fokhrul Islam |113122008 | Topic: Managing HR for Better Performance Letter of Transmittal Date: 06/12/12 Abu Saleh Md. Sohel-Uz-Zaman, Course Instructor, Department of Business Administration, United International University Subject: Submission of term paper. Dear Sir, We have to honor to state that according to the subject of the term paper, here we are trying to find the key factors to improve personnel performance that develop a performance plan that directs the employee's efforts toward achieving specific results, to support organizational growth as well as the employee's professional growth.. We have tried to find out the methods of improving performance. Here we try to match our course materials with the practical view that help us to learn the knowledge more deeply. We believe that we try our level best to understand the real facts and analysis those facts that indicates for better performance. Here we look forward your kind consideration about the case analysis and will be grateful to you by accepting our term paper. Thanking you, S. M. Tahmidur...

Words: 7384 - Pages: 30