Premium Essay

Erisa

In: Business and Management

Submitted By gmoco61254
Words 2182
Pages 9
1. Describe ERISA preemption of state insurance laws and mandates. Discuss the implications of this preemption.
The employee Retirement Income security Act of 1974 (ERISA) is a comprehensive federal statute which imposes minimum standards on employee benefit plans. In order to avoid conflicting state regulations, ERISA preempts state laws which relate to these plans. ERISA’s preemption, however, is not complete. Consistent with the federal policy embodied in the McCarran-Ferguson Act of leaving the regulation of insurance to the states, Congress saved from ERISA preemption any state law which regulates insurance. States have enacted legislation that requires insurers to pay for the services of a particular type of health care provider, even if the terms of the policy specify that the payment will be made only to another type of provider. These “mandated-provider” laws, as they are called, relate to employee benefit plans because they change the terms of the insurance policies purchased by these plans. Thus, unless mandated-provider laws regulate insurance, such laws are preempted by ERISA as applied to employee benefit plans. The question whether mandated-provider laws are laws that regulate insurance is important because of the prevalence of such statutes, the large number of individuals covered by insurance plans, and the significant effect such statutes have on the structure, administration, and cost of insured plans. Insurers are generally opposed to mandated-provider provider laws because they induce many employee groups to self-insure plans, create dis-uniformities in multistate plans, increase the cost of plan administration, and force insurers to pay less effective or less efficient providers. Insurers and employee groups are also opposed to mandated-provider laws because they interfere with insurers’ attempts to lower costs by forming preferred provider

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Human Resoruce

...Three Landmark Pieces of legislation ERISA, COBRA and HIPPA. Employee Benefits In the last forty years the three landmark pieces of legislation ERISA, COBRA and HIPPA brought great impact. These laws helped the wage earners, job searchers and the ones who retired. With the controlled environment becoming more demanding and complex, organizations have no other choice but to agree with these laws. The point of these three are to better working conditions, to put more advanced chances for profitable employment out in the workforce, shield employees, and to guarantee work associated benefits and rights. These laws must be followed failing to do so will lead to consequences such as penalties, fines or even imprisonment. Acting accordance with these regulations is vital for organizations but also very time consuming, for this reason a company has to seek the best experts who will put into an effect a program to make sure everything is done the way it should. Starting off with The Employee Retirement Income Security Act also know as ERISA which helped put forwards minimum standards for retirement, health, and other welfare benefit plans in private industry. ERISA secures that the funds placed by an individual in a their retirement plans are available to them even when they retire. ERISA controls the establishment of discretionary benefits practices. For four long decades, ERISA has remained amended to meet the changing retirement and health care requirements of...

Words: 968 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Article Sum

...EMPLOYER'S FIDUCIARY HAT: VARITY CORP. V. HOWE INCREASES EMPLOYERS'; EXPOSURE TO LIABILITY WHEN THEY ACT AS ERISA FIDUCIARIES -Shelly Ward - Ward’s article discusses the circumstances surrounding the 1996 Supreme Court case: Variety corp. V. Howe - The court ruled that an individual may recover damages stemming from the a breach of fiduciary duty by a plan’s administrator - Ward explains that ERISA’s principles were based on the common law governing trusts; trust laws were also used in interpreting cases involving ERISA - Variety V. Howe was unique because trust law was utilized to a large extent rather than ERISA itself - Ward says ERISA was intended to be a “pension Bill of Rights” and that it required a person to act in a “fiduciary capacity” to manage the plan - Terms are ambiguous in ERISA in regards to whom is able to be granted relief when there is a breach of the fiduciary duty. (502) - In Mass. Mutual Life Insurance V. Russel, the Supreme Court ruled that a person cannot sue for extra-contractual damages; ERISA does not imply this right - In Mertens V. Hewitt associates the Supreme Court ruled that an individual is not entitled to relief from a nonfiduciary who participates in a breach of a fiduciary duty - Many circuits have adopted similar rulings in that an individual cannot be granted relief concerning a breach of the fiduciary duty states in ERISA. Some other circuits interpret the Supreme Court rulings differently. Essentially, much confusion remains...

Words: 406 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Mgmt 582 Case Study

...4/2/2012 Section 510 of ERISA Gives False Hope of Non Retaliation by Employers The Scenario is this; an Employee of one of the biggest hotel chains in the United States works in the Benefits section of the company. She finds a major flaw in the company’s benefits plan and brings it to the attention of Management. She was terminated and brought up a wrongful termination suit against Marriott. The Courts upheld the termination saying that Section 510 of ERISA did not protect the employee. This article argues that the employee should be protected when reporting internal violations voluntarily for three reasons. “(1) The protection of unsolicited internal complaints is consistent with congressional intent, (2) The text of section 510, as compared to other anti-retaliation provisions in other federal statutes, supports protection of unsolicited internal complaints, and (3) Section 510 reflects the view of the Secretary of Labor, whose interpretative position is coherent and attractive as a policy matter.”(PETERSON 1). The first reason is “the protection of unsolicited internal complaints is consistent with congressional intent.” Even though the Supreme Court upheld the judgment in this case, the article is arguing the side of congressional intent. If someone comes to their employer, who works in a position of power when it comes to employee benefits, to tell them that they are in a state of illegality they should be protected by section 510 of ERISA. The way that section 510...

Words: 1064 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Amgen Inc. V. Steve Harris

...In the case of Amgen Inc., Et Al. V. Steve Harris, Et Al., the employee were assigned to two different pension plans. Each plan consisted of the utilization of holdings in the Amgen Common Stock Fund which held a majority of only Amgen common stock. A group of employees pursued a class action lawsuit against the company referencing the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) because the stock plummeted causing the loss of funds. The group of employees argued that the Amgen Inc. breached their fiduciary duties under ERISA by allowing the participants to purchase and hold Amgen stock while knowing its price was artificially inflated. While the Amgen Inc. decline all notions and allegations the district court granted the Amgen’s Inc. a...

Words: 291 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Fondo de Pensiones

...firmado por el presidente George W. Bush requirió que las compañías con planes de pensiones paguen por sus primas de la Pensión Benefit Guaranty Corp. (PBGC) y requisitos para financiamientos al sistema de pensiones de la empresa. Esta ley obliga a la empresa analizar sus obligaciones con más precisión. Existen otros elementos de la ley tales como: autoridad legal a los empleadores, divulgación sobre el desempeño de las pensiones, elimina los conflictos de intereses, otorga mayor control a los trabajadores en la inversión de sus cuentas y las inversiones de puerto seguro. Las regulaciones de los fondos de pensiones provienen del Departamento del Trabajo bajo Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). La Ley de Jubilación de Empleados de Seguridad de Ingreso de 1974 (ERISA) es una ley federal que establece las normas mínimas para los planes de pensión en la industria privada. Protege los intereses de los participantes de los planes de servicio para los beneficiarios por: divulgación de información financiera, establecimientos de normas de los planes fiduciarios y proporcionar los recursos al acceso al los tribunales...

Words: 775 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Legal Environment

...and permanent residents when they retire, are disabled, or are the children of deceased workers. The FICA tax includes two separate taxes. Funds withheld for FICA are reflected on paycheck stubs and on the W-2. One is social security tax and the other is the Medicare tax which different rates apply for each tax. The current tax rate for social security is 6.2% for the employer and 6.2% for the employee, matched at 12.4% total (IRS). The current rate for Medicare is 1.45% for the employer and 1.45% for the employee, or 2.9% total. The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) establishes minimum standards for retirement, health, and other welfare benefit plans including life insurance, disability insurance, and apprenticeship plans. It protects the assets of millions of Americans so that funds placed in retirement plans during their working lives will be there when they retire. ERISA regulates and sets standards and requirements for conduct, disclosures, reporting and accountability, procedural safeguards, and financial and best interest protection (DOL). I have heard a lot of people make the statement that “Social Security is not going to be around in the future.” My personal opinion is that Social Security is going to be around forever. That is not something that the government will do away with. I feel that it is our job to figure out how much Social Security we need to ensure that we can fund our lifestyle in retirement. If you feel that the amount of Social...

Words: 421 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Social Security History

...another name for FICA taxes. The Internal Revenue Service requires these taxes to be withheld from employee paychecks. The Federal Insurance Compensation Act established FICA taxes to fund social security benefits. Medicare was later included these taxes. The rates of FICA contributions are revised annually. These contributions are requirements of the Act. President Gerald Ford signed the Employee Retirement Income Security Act into law September 2, 1974. Little legislative protection was provided to employee prior to the 1900. Private pension plans were regulated by tax legislation. Employee benefits and private pension plans are governed by the ERISA. The ERISA provides greater retirement security for American workers. The provisions of ERISA are enforced by numerous amendments which have improved the regulatory system. The ERISA governs private retirement plans. Tax treatment is typically favorable these...

Words: 528 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Age Discrimination Case Paper

...EEOC v. Liggett & Myers, Inc. decision, involving a fact pattern the trail court referred to as a “sad saga beginning in 1971,” resulted in back wages plus liquidated damages for more than 100 terminated employees due to the employer’s intentional violations of the ADEA.” (Twomey, 2007-2013) The employer willfully violated the ADEA after firing a number of workers over the age of 40. Lastly, age discrimination will be ongoing problem with the median age of the average worker increasing each year. The passing of ERISA has brought on cases against employers, insurers, and health care providers. Nick Thornton writes of a recent ERISA case against a health care provider, “Novant Health Inc., a North Carolina-based operator of 15 hospitals throughout the mid-Atlantic region, has agreed to settle an excessive fee claim for $32 million.” (Thornton, 2015) This case shows that health care providers charging excessive fees can be brought to court under the ERISA. Lastly, ERISA cases might increase with the baby-boomer generation starting to retire. ...

Words: 456 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Black And Decker Disability Case Summary

...I. PARTIES TO THE CASE: Kenneth L. NORD, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. the BLACK & DECKER DISABILITY PLAN, Defendant-Appellee. II. FORUM: The district court ruled in favor of Black & Decker Corp. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals reversed III. STATUTE(S) INVOLVED IN THE CASE: The court is being asked to interpret if Black and Decker denial of his disability benefits violated ERISA. The court must determine whether the claimant is entitled to social security disability benefits. IV. STATEMENT OF FACTS: Kenneth Nord is a former employee as a Material Planner for Kwikset Corporation, a subsidiary of the Black & Decker Corporation. The responsibilities that Nord had in his position include ordering goods, interacting with vendors, and maintaining inventory levels. For the most part, this position is sedentary, but it does require up to six hours of sitting and up to two hours of standing or walking per day. Throughout his employment, MR. Nord was enrolled in the Black & Decker Disability Plan, this plan grants complete discretion to the plan manager to make disabilities determinations. In addition, this plan also gives the plan manager the authority to distribute one or more responsibilities to a Claim Administrator....

Words: 534 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Employment Law Compliance Plan

...Clapton Commercial Construction Company To: Atwood and Allen Consulting Company From: John Doe Date: 8/25/2014 Re: Employment Law compliance plan Purpose: The purpose of this memorandum is to inform the management and employees of Atwood and Allen Consulting Company, about a consulting assignment from Clapton Commercial Construction Company over their employment law compliance plan. The company is seeking consultancy services from us. It is therefore crucial that we provide the best services possible. Summary Clapton Commercial Construction is a company that has currently 650 employees, and according to their Human Resource Director, they are planning to employ 20% more employees after moving to their new state. The company is currently situated in Detroit, Michigan, and it’s planning to move to Arizona. They are in need of human resource help from us. The whole work should involve identifying at least four employment laws, give a brief summary of each law, and also the consequences of its noncompliance. Background Information A lot has happened over the last 40 years in America; in as far as the legislations and regulations governing business and organizations operations are concerned. The federal government has always done its best in managing and controlling the situation. It is from this stand that, companies like Atwood and Allen Consulting emerged. Issues like corrupt practices, discrimination on employment and environmental protection ,just to mention...

Words: 894 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Cost Club Scenario

...Running head: COST CLUB SCENARIO 3 Cost Club Scenario 3 University of Phoenix HRM-546 April 14, 2014 Cost Club Scenario 3 Introduction Every employee has fundamental rights in the workplace that include their right to privacy, fair compensation and free from discrimination. Even applicants have rights before they are hired as an employee. Some of those rights include discrimination that is based solely on a person’s race, gender, age, religion, national origin, or during the hiring process (FindLaw, 2014). Employee Privacy * Employees have the right to privacy with regards to their personal possessions * This includes their purses, handbags. Briefcases, lockers. * Employees have limited rights with respect to e-mail messages and internet usage while using Cost Clubs computer system * Employers do not have the right to conduct a credit checks or background checks on an employee or perspective employee without the express written permission of the employee (FindLaw, 2014). Employee Unions Under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), employers are forbidden from interfering in an employee’s right to organize, or to join or assist in a labor organization for collective bargaining purposes, or prohibit working together to improve terms and conditions of their place of employment. Union employer’s may not coerce their employees in exercising any of their rights such as (National Labor Relations Board, 2014): * It is illegal for an employer...

Words: 1269 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Privacidad En El Empleo

...Escenario III – Cost Club Como gerente del Departamento de Recursos Humanos de Cost Club se me ha asignado el que elabore una serie de conferencia en las que incluyan las leyes en los lugares de trabajo los cuales serían beneficiosos para la compañía y ayudaría a mejorar los procedimientos. A continuación se presentan las siguientes áreas a discutirse. Privacidad del Empleado El derecho de un empleado a la privacidad en su lugar de trabajo es un tema de constante controversia, especialmente en una época en la que se depende de las computadoras y del correo electrónico para hacer negocios. La tecnología permite a los empleadores monitorear virtualmente toda la comunicación efectuada por los empleados usando las computadoras – incluyendo el uso de Internet y del correo electrónico de la compañía. Aunque los empleados pueden sentir que tal monitoreo viola sus derechos a la privacidad, usualmente está permitido por la ley. Otras actividades del empleado (como las conversaciones privadas), y ciertos espacios físicos en el centro de trabajo (como los cajones cerrados bajo llave del escritorio) reciben mayor protección respecto a la privacidad; aunque actividades específicas como el uso de drogas puede requerir una prueba sobre el abuso de sustancias se puede efectuar si así el puesto lo amerite, o como política de la compañía efectuar durante el proceso de entrevistas antes de efectuar la contratación del empleado, también se puede efectuar de forma aleatoria a los empleado...

Words: 1577 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Persuasive Essay On Pension Plans

...would want to supplement of pension plan because they have to depend on the pensions after they retire. It goes without saying that how important for them to have a stable pension plan when they are still working. A lot of employers also believe that they should set up pension plans when they still work. Pension plans not only bring benefits to the employees but also contribute the complete the corporate system. A couple years ago, some plaintiffs began filing lawsuits against pension plans sponsored by religiously- affiliated non-profit hospitals, challenging their designation as ‘‘church plans’’ under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 19741 (ERISA). In order to protect employee’s rights and make sure employer offer pension plans to their employees, the employee retirement income protection act of 1974 (ERISA) was published years ago, and employees can usually avoid unexpected losses in their retirement plans. The federal government set laws to protect employee’s rights with pension...

Words: 1702 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Departmnt of Labor

...Features of the Website The succeeding paragraphs will describe the major features of the US Department of Labor Website at http://www.dol.gov/dol/topic/health-plans/cobra.htm. The first feature is Wages Subtopics. Wages Subtopics provide additional information employees can use to help monitor their wage benefits. By choosing from the Wages subtopics list it will also help employees narrow their browsing. This information is useful so that employees and employers understand employee qualification for benefit programs. The Department of Labor enforces the Fair Labor Standard Act (FLSA), which sets basic minimum wage and overtime pay standards. These standards are enforced by the Department's Wage and Hour Division. This law was enacted in 1938. It protects workers by setting standards for minimum wage, overtime pay, record keeping and youth labor. FLSA covers full-time and part-time workers in the private sector and in federal, state, and local governments. The law may apply to you because of the type of company or organization for which you work, known as enterprise coverage, or the type of work you do, called individual coverage (Roseburg, 2013). Minimum Wage Non-exempt employees must be paid a national minimum wage established by the US Congress. As of July 24, 2009 that wage is $7.25 per hour. Some states have set their own minimum wage. The employer must pay federal or state wages-whichever is higher. Overtime Pay Employers must give overtime pay to non-exempt...

Words: 1793 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Semi Annual Senior Staff Conference Memo

...To: Pat Morinaka From: Human Resource Subject: Semi-Annual Senior Staff Conference Date: January 9, 2012 Hi Pat, this is in response to your e-mail regarding the semi-annual senior staff conference in preparation for the Statutory Regulation of Employment. I have prepared an outline below explaining the five key regulatory areas that include Employee’s Privacy, Employees Unions, Occupational Safety Health Act (OSHA), Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The outline will explain the company’s obligation and what the law requires. Employee Privacy  Privacy Act of 1974, according to Bennett-Alexander, 2007, there are four basic principles that underlay the Privacy Act: 1. Employees should have access to their own personnel files, and there should be some way for them to find out the purposes for which the files are being used. 2. There should be some mechanism by which an employee may correct or amend an inaccurate record. 3. The employee should be able to prevent information from being inappropriately revealed or used without her or his consent, unless such disclosure is required by law. 4. The person who is in charge of maintaining the information must ensure that the files are not falling into the wrong hands and that the information contained within the files is accurate, reliable, and used for the correct reasons.  Telephone Monitoring  Allowed to review and monitor all employee client and customers outgoing...

Words: 741 - Pages: 3