Free Essay

Ethical Dilemma

In: Other Topics

Submitted By rastogivivek
Words 2834
Pages 12
Introduction

Martha McCaskey, who had been working for Seleris Associates, a medium-sized consulting firm based in Chicago, for 18 months in the Industry Analysis Division (IAD) faced a difficult situation. Having been assigned the role of project leader in a study to be conducted for one of Seleris’s most lucrative clients, McCaskey was assured that, upon successful completion of the project, she would be promoted to group manager. Seleris’s client, a semiconductor manufacturer based in California, was trying to identify the cost structure and manufacturing technologies of a new chip produced by one of its competitors. Martha McCaskey was challenged with the task of obtaining sensitive information from Phil Devon, a consultant in southern California, who had recently been involved in the design and start-up of a plant for a European firm. If successful in obtaining such information the marketing manager, in charge of the Silicon 6 project, proposed to double the original fee agreed upon. The marketing manager also stated that he had 10 more equally lucrative projects like the current one.

Problems faced by Martha McCaskey

Martha McCaskey had serious doubts as to both the propriety of asking for such information and Phil Devon’s motivation in so eagerly offering to help her. McCaskey had two options. With the additional funding available from the client, she could have Phil Devon provide analysis of several alternatives for manufacturing state of the art chips, including the one used at the competitor’s Silicon 6 plant, such as to avoid suspicion. The second option was to hand over the assignment to Chuck Kaufmann, a senior associate, who handled many of the division’s projects which required obtaining information that a competitor would deem as proprietary. Regardless as to the decision, Martha McCaskey felt, that no matter which option she chose, completing the Silicon 6 project would compromise her values. Evidence of this can be seen when she states ‘this is a guy who’s trying to do good in the world. How can I be doing this? I have an EE degree from CalTech, an MBA from Harvard, and here I am trying to sleaze this guy’. McCaskey had wondered ‘where do you draw the line on proprietary information?’ McCaskey questioned if she was about to engage in a ‘gentleman’s industrial espionage?’ Until the present task she had always maintained a high level of integrity in her work. McCaskey argued if the next step to success would require her to ‘play the game the way everyone else did?’ This brings to mind Friedman’s (1970) view that a firm can use its resources and engage in activities designed to increase its profits so long as it stays within the rules of the game. However Friedman (1970) believes firms must engage in open and free competition without deception or fraud. In Martha McCaskey’s case she would have to deceive Devon to obtain the necessary information. Another issue McCaskey is dealing with, which Bagley (2003) addresses, is the tension between ones responsibility to maximize shareholder value and their responsibility to behave ethically.

Martha McCaskey’s assessment of the situation

We do agree with McCaskey’s assessment of the situation as she is in a position where she does not want to compromise her own moral values but at the same time she does not want to disappoint Malone and Richardson as McCaskey has always produced a high standard of work in the past. McCaskey also wants to do what will benefit the corporation as a whole because the client had promised Seleris 10 more lucrative projects if they came through on the current one. So the argument of utilitarianism comes in to play here, ‘seek the greatest good for the greatest number’ (Goodpaster, 1983: 6).

How did McCaskey end up in this situation?

Martha McCaskey ended up in the current predicament because the moral and ethical constraints that govern Seleris and herself are different. Goodpaster and Matthews (1982) claim that corporations should be expected to display the same moral practices as people. It is clear that Seleris is governed by Richardson’s ethics of maximising profits by any means, so long as he doesn’t get caught. McCaskey on the other hand was more concerned with maintaining her integrity. A good point is made by Dunn (1991) that because the corporation only acts through those who act for it, it is the latter that has to assume moral responsibility for the corporation. In this case, because Seleris acts through the senior vice president, Ty Richardson, it is his moral values that are being spread throughout the organisation. Richardson’s values are conflicting with McCaskey’s moral values and this is the primary reason McCaskey could not go through with obtaining the proprietary information the first time and is in the current predicament.

Forces which contributed to the current predicament

Personal

Martha McCaskey did not want to compromise her own moral values and this is one of the primary personal forces which contributed to her current situation. However, up until the Silicon 6 project McCaskey had always managed to maintain a high standard in her work and this clashed with her moral values.

Organisational

One of the organisational forces which led to the current situation was the tight standard, increased workload and performance expectations for IAD projects. This force had placed pressure on McCaskey to obtain the proprietary information from Devon, but it clashed with her own moral values and led to the indecisiveness, thus the current dilemma. Also Richardson in his talk on ethics brought in the argument that ‘we do not do anything unethical’. This brings in Gellerman’s (1986) argument that there are four rationalisations which people have relied on in the past to justify questionable conduct. In this case, the belief that obtaining proprietary information is not ‘really’ illegal or immoral. This belief has been imposed on the staff and it impacted on McCaskey’s situation as she was torn between following her own moral values and completing the Silicon 6 project. We can also introduce the concept of the ‘corporate veil’; that the corporation shields individuals from personal legal liability for actions taken on behalf of the firm (Dunn, 1991). With this in mind, it can be argued that McCaskey was assigned to the Silicon 6 project because Richardson and Malone felt that they were within the corporate veil. Gellerman (1986) also argues there is a belief amongst top managers that if lower managers achieve results by any means possible, then their actions as to how they obtained the results will not be questioned. We get a sense of this with, group manager, Bud Hackert, who prided himself on his ability to get the job done, ‘no matter what it took’. This force had played a part in McCaskey’s current situation as up until now she had always met the goals set by Richardson and Malone, except in previous cases she did it without sacrificing her integrity.

Environmental

The industry McCaskey is operating in is quite demanding as she had to obtain sensitive information about competitors and she mentions ‘people making chips are very secretive’. Taking this into account it was very difficult for McCaskey to obtain detailed information regarding manufacturing costs and costs associated with the new computer chip for the Silicon 6 project. From this case we also get a sense of achieving results ‘by any means possible’.

Being in McCaskey’s shoes

If we were to be Martha’s situation, we would have to stop working for Seleris and start looking for a new job. To explain how we got to this conclusion, we need to first approach the Teleological framework of the general ethical frameworks for management.

Consequentialist/teleological
Ethical Egoism

According to Friedman (1970:126):

‘There is one and only one social responsibility of business – to use its resources and engage in activities designed to increase profits so long as it stays within the rules of the game, which is to say, engages in open and free competition without deception or fraud.’

If we translate Friedman’s (1970) view to Seleris’s working environment, this sort of ‘goal-over-all’ position would suit better to anyone in the ‘old guard’ (surely Hackert and Malone) than it would suit McCaskey. Martha was feeling uncomfortable half-way through the interview with Devon and she barely made it through lunch.

Following other authors we get a similar conclusion. Goodpaster (1983) implies that every man should be out for themselves and should only be concerned with promoting themselves for the greatest balance of good over bad results. In the Silicon 6 project, a possible bad result to be considered is if McCaskey meets with Devon, there is a possibility that Devon could lead Martha on to find out whom she was working for. Given Devon’s prior employment at the target company, it could also result in a negative outcome for him. Although it is a consideration to be made, we can only suggest that the marketing manager’s doubled payment and the further 10 lucrative future projects would be given preference, in the search for the greatest balance of good over bad results.

Utilitarianism

We jump now to the opposite side of the Teleological framework to analyze the case from the perspective of the ‘principle of utility’.

According to Bentham (1823: 1 http://www.constitution.org/jb/pml_01.htm ):

‘That principle which approves or disapproves of every action whatsoever, according to the tendency it appears to have to augment or diminish the happiness of the party whose interest is in question: or, what is the same thing in other words, to promote or to oppose that happiness. I say of every action whatsoever, and therefore not only of every action of a private individual, but of every measure of government.’

Further developed by other proponents of utilitarianism, this first principle lead us to widen the spectrum of the implications of those actions to the widest community; therefore we now need to consider, not only the Silicon 6 project and its agents, but also Seleris, its stakeholders, the industry Analysis Division, its environment, the target company and even the consumers and agents interacting with them all.

At this stage, from the individual point of view, there would be too many individuals’ personal values at stake for us to say that what it is best for all is to fulfil the Silicon 6 project. Given that Devon is acting on good faith, his happiness, together with Martha’s, will not be promoted in many ways. We could even say that Seleris’ associates would also have their happiness diminished after Martha’s work promotion, given that she has recently joined the company.

At a company level, opposed to Seleris’, the target company’s interests would be clearly affected by this action, and we would neither find a clear increase in happiness for the widest community.

This ongoing debate can only confirm Sidgwick’s (1966) Dualism: a view that emphasizes competitive markets, is now confronting a more supportive view towards utility maximization (Sidgwick, 1966 cited in Goodpaster, 1983). However, even when there is a clear economic benefit towards Seleris and its shareholders (in the probable case that the Silicon 6 project would reach a positive outcome), we cannot ignore the dangerous possibility of Devon giving away the project’s implications. In such a case, Seleris would then lose one of its oldest clients in the high-tech electronics field. This outcome could also have further implications as shareholders tend to refute unethical practices and they will very probably have a radical reaction if any of these suspicious practices on proprietary information came to light.

On the other hand and as previously stated, it is very unlikely that any individual (other than those getting a profit out of the Silicon 6 project) would be driven towards a maximized utility in the completion of this project.

Non-Consequentialist/Deontological
At this point, we were already thinking that completing the Silicon 6 project would not be a good idea. However, the analysis of this case would lack theoretical consistency without a second viewpoint based on deontological frameworks. As we jump into the deontological frameworks it is vivid how much in danger our integrity would be in the shoes of Martha McCaskey.

Existentialism

Taking into consideration all the normative frameworks, we wanted to make a first stop at the existentialism framework. In doing so, we have encountered its application in this specific case to be quite constrained. A first problem with the idea of existentialism is that it is certainly a complex process to define or categorize existentialism concisely. According to the philosopher Walter Kaufmann, ‘existentialism is not a philosophy but a label for several widely different revolts against traditional philosophy’ (McDowell, 1983: ? http://www.greatcom.org/resources/handbook_of_todays_religions/04chap04/ ). It is hard to find a compounded frame of principles that could realistically apply to McCaskey case in the existentialism framework.

Contractarianism

Instead, we have decided to take a closer look at the contractarianism framework to assure that we have as many different positions as we possibly can, with the higher number of different interests being considered. Many authors have come to illustrate contractarianism with the banner of fairness. When it comes to applying these concepts to the McCaskey case, Rawls (1971) gets accurate enough with his own perception of a hypothesis of free contract on the political and economic arrangements that will govern us. Under this hypothesis Rawls (1971) suggest that the person would, in this case, choose two rather different principles:

‘the first requires equality in the assignment of basic rights and duties, while the second holds that social and economic inequalities, for example inequalities of wealth and authority, are just only if they result in compensating benefits for everyone, and in particular for the least advantaged members of society.’ (Rawls, 1971 cited in Goodpaster, 1983:9)

This time, we have integrated Seleris and pretty much everyone else in the picture. Adapting the first principle to our case, we could say that it is understandable that managers would delegate activities on employers as long as it benefits the organization. The organization is clearly reaching economical benefits, but are we really seeing an equal distribution here? Why are some associates leaving the company while Rendall kept doing all the work involving proprietary information? Is the company trying to impose these unwanted practices among the associates and/or create a new Rendall out Martha? These facts imply that there is a practice that does not look like something beneficial to the rest of the associates but more importantly, according to the first principle, proprietary information tasks are not equally distributed among associates in the long run.

If we take into consideration the second principle, a very similar question arises, the Silicon 6 would clearly benefit Seleris and its managers, its shareholders, it would also benefit Martha economically and even improve her position in the organization (although it is also putting her values in jeopardy more than she wanted to). Nevertheless, how would this truly benefit the less advantaged members, like the clerical staff or the rest of the associates? If we are to analyze the organizational benefit from top to bottom we cannot reach a clear-positive picture supporting the completion of the Silicon 6 project.

Kantian Ethics

Immanuel Kant was probably one of the most influential authors in modern ethical reflections and he definitely has something to add to the theoretical framework in the analysis of the McCaskey case. According to Kant’s ‘supreme principle’, there are two main formulations which must be considered in relation to Martha McCaskey situation:

a. ‘Act only according to that maxim by which you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law’ (Goodpaster, 1983:10)

b. ‘Act so that you treat humanity, whether in your own person, or in that of another, always as an end and never as a means only’ (Goodpaster, 1983:10)

Under Kantian ethical lenses, our conclusion comes quite straight forward: in formulation a) we can only assume that deceiving or ignoring our moral values should not become a universal law. On the other hand, and following Kant’s second formulation, treating humanity as an end should not involve damaging your moral values.

Conclusion

Using previous work on ethics and adopting various ethical lenses we have identified the problems faced by Martha McCaskey and outlined a path that Martha should take. We based our decision on McCaskey’s need to maintain her integrity while adopting different ethical frameworks to gain a greater understanding as to how her predicament should be handled. Overall we have discovered that there are various forces which come into play when deciding how to handle McCaskey’s situation. However, because McCaskey’s moral values and those of other members in Seleris, such as Kaufmann, conflict with Richardson’s values it is in the best interest of McCaskey to find a job where there is cohesion in the values adopted by staff and those adopted by upper management. In this way, there will be cohesion within the organisation as they will be working together towards a common goal.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma Wilbert Thacker CMGT/575 December 1, 2014 Gordon Hodgson Ethical Dilemma Ethical dilemmas, also known as a moral dilemmas, are situations in which there is a choice to be made between two options, neither of which resolves the situation in an ethically acceptable fashion. In such cases, societal and personal ethical guidelines can provide no satisfactory outcome for the chooser. Ethical dilemmas assume that the chooser will abide by societal norms, such as codes of law or religious teachings, in order to make the choice ethically impossible (Your Dictionary, 2014). As a project manager it is their job to manage and get to know their team. The CIO has informed the project manager that his/her team will be released and the department will be outsourced. In this situation the first step that should be taken is gathering all of the facts. The CIO has informed the project manager that their department would be outsourced and their team would be released but there was no reason provided. As a concerned project manager it is almost their obligation to research to what led up to this decision. A decision this drastic couldn’t have possibly be made over night. The main ethical issue here is it has to be a trust issue between the company they are providing the service for and the project management team. Most of those issues revolve around project management teams not completing a service on time or a service not meeting expectations. Many people will...

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Option 2: EthicsGame Dilemmas ETH/316 Option 2: EthicsGame Dilemmas Introduction The project that was presented included the application of personal values in working through two different ethical dilemmas. In order to work through each of the dilemmas two analytical skill sets were used to come to a resolution. The first skill set involved the use of the four ethical lenses. The lenses include the Results Lens, Rights/Responsibility Lens, Relationship Lens, and Reputation Lens. The second skill involves the use of the Baird Decision Model which is a five-step process that gives a systematic approach to the resolution of an ethical dilemma. The five steps of the Baird Decision Model include: * Step 1: Be Attentive * Step 2: Be Intelligent * Step 3: Be Reasonable * Step 4: Be Responsible * Step 5: Be Reflective The combination of the ethical lenses with the decision model provides the groundwork to come up with, good value based, solutions to ethical conflict (Rian Brown,  2014). Mysterious Blogger The first ethical conflict that was presented was that of the “Mysterious Blogger.” In this simulation the Director of Information Technology, who is responsible for managing all internal information system functions which include systems programming, application programming, networks, and computer operations, is presented with an employee who is leaking the proprietary company information to the public through a blog sight as an anonymous...

Words: 1292 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Ethical Dilemma Assignment

...CONSENT FORM Thank you for being willing to take part in this interview exploring ethical conflict or turbulence. I would like to transcribe the content of this interview to form a written document to be submitted to Sheffield Hallam University as a piece of assessed piece of coursework. It is important that you only take part in this interview if you want to. As such I would be delighted if you would complete and sign this confidentiality questionnaire prior to the interview taking place. (i) In general terms are you willing to take part in this interview: and an edited transcript of the interview submitted to Sheffield Hallam? Yes (ii) Are you happy for your own name to be used in the transcript: or do you want the final transcript to written up with a pseudonym? Own name (iii) Are you happy for the names of other people and organisations to be used in the final transcript: or do you want all other names to be content of this transcription to be submitted to Sheffield Hallam? Pseudonyms (iv) Are you happy for me to submit the final transcript without you reviewing it - or do you want to reserve the right to see the final transcript before I submit? Submit unseen (v) Sometimes the ethical dilemmas described in these transcripts provide real life case studies that can be helpful to show other students, and can provide rich data for research projects. Would you be willing for this transcript to be used in further teaching or research - or would you prefer...

Words: 1766 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Gaming: Ethical Dilemma

...gaming. I see and the understand the catastrophic impact that gaming has on the people from my community, let alone my own mother, which is why I came to choose this topic. Three Research Questions 1.) Does gaming have any positive contribution to our society? I strongly believe it is crucial that we determine if gaming has an actual positive effect in our society or it is just an absolute disruption to our ethical views in life. I truly think that it is the latter but it is important that we take a look on different aspects of gaming as a whole before we can conclude upon it. 2.) Is there an ethical need for new regulations in gaming as a whole? It is critically important to review all the regulations that were put on gaming to identify if new regulations are necessary. With the affects that it has in our society, we need to determine what’s missing as far as regulations is concerned. 3.) When does gaming recreation becomes an ethical dilemma? When I hear the word ‘gaming’ I personally always associate it with ‘betting in monetary terms’. In my opinion, some of us never really think of gaming as recreation...

Words: 372 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Problem Solution: Remington Peckinpaw Davis Inc

...Running head: PROBLEM SOLUTION: Remington Peckinpaw Davis Inc. Problem Solution: Remington Peckinpaw Davis Inc. MMPBL510 / Implementing Organizational Initiatives University of Phoenix March 14, 2011 Problem Solution: Remington Peckinpaw Davis Inc. Remington Peckinpaw Davis is an asset group experiencing technical problems with its online trading services. The company needs to be more proactive in the research and development of its software and techniques and stop guessing the costs the project, given the failure of the first phase of the strategic implementation. “Successful implementation requires both technical and social skills. Project managers have to plan and budget projects as well as orchestrate the contributions of other” (Gray & Larson, 2006. p. 14). Table 1 Issues and Opportunities Identification | | | | |Issues |Opportunities |Reference to Specific | | | |Course Concept | |Data reliability: Harlan’s data, estimates |An effective project monitoring system can|“A project monitoring system involves determining what | |and development plans were not accurate, |assist (RPD) in ensuring that the...

Words: 541 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Frameworks of Ethics

...nurse, ethical dilemmas can arise at any moment. It is imperative that through proper education and training registered nurses have the ethical capacity and intelligence to work through these issues with compassion and integrity. Take into account he following case scenario; a 6-year-old child develops a high fever, vomiting, and convulsions at school. After seeking medical care, the diagnosis of meningitis is reached and the physician requests to start treatment from the child’s parents. The parents are divorced; the mother has primary custody but is not the biological parent. The mother is a Christian Scientist who insists that no medical treatment be initiated per her religious beliefs. The biological father resides in another state, but he insists that treatment be initiated and seeks independent consultation from another physician. Through ethical decision making with assistance from Uustal’s nine-step model, it is possible to identify the ethical dilemma presented, integrate the decision-making model to identify an ethical solution, and incorporate family dialogue to both parents of the child regarding the issue at hand. When an ethical decision must be made, one must first identify the ethical dilemma. "...An ethical dilemma is a common type of situation that involves two, or more, morally correct courses of action that cannot both be followed” (Purtilo, Ruth & Doherty, 2011, p. 57). Ethical dilemmas involve both ethical conflict and conduct. "An ethical dilemma occurs...

Words: 456 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma (Author’s name) (Institutional Affiliation) Abstract This research paper seeks to resolve a particular case of an ethical dilemma. This has been necessitated by the fact that ethical dilemmas are a recurrent part of life. Moreover, ethical dilemmas have become a key point of argument in the field of ethics and interestingly, philosophy as well (Garsten & Hernes, 2009). As an inividual, I find myself facing moral dilemma situation quite frequently which makes the exploration of this subject a fascinating intrigue. This exhaustive research thus attempts to integrate all the possible actions that can be undertaken to lead towards the understanding of ethical dilemma. Methodologies used to accomplish this include the three stage ethical dilemma solving process that duly applies two main approaches. These approaches are consequentialist and deontological which have been widely applied to give step by step details on how to handle the given ethical dilemma. The article dissects on subsequent decision making after thorough strive to balance between what is morally acceptable within a person’s surroundings and self interests entrenched in a human being. A thorough discussion on the particular viewpoints of ethical dilemma has unearthed the common result of individuals getting torn between self morals and societal expectations.. Finally, the research concludes that there is a need to evaluate decisions based on viewpoints arising...

Words: 1725 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

An Ethical Dilemma

...Case Study: An Ethical Dilemma Name Institution Case Study: An Ethical Dilemma Question 1 Dr. Vaji would like to meet with Leo in order to discuss ways in which adolescent clients may be retained. Also, he wants to help him improve his treatment skills. Unfortunately, he does not know how much the information he was provided with by the other graduate students might influence their conversation and final supervisory report. As a result, he finds himself in an ethical dilemma because he is concerned on how to grade the student from his earlier reports or should he take into account the information he has just received from the other students. Apparently, he was not convinced enough by Leo Watson’s thought paper, so he advised him to incorporate more of the findings on ethnic discrimination into his papers and provide more complex perspectives. In other words, Watson was to provide more information from viewing the world through another person’s eyes. As a result, he might have taken the idea far enough to start behaving in the same manner he had described the ethnic minority would, which was prone to violence. On the other hand, Leo Watson as a person might possess the attributes described to Dr. Vaji by the other students as derogatory, harassing, and insulting to other ethnic groups. Seemingly, the nature of this dilemma has been framed by some APA Ethical principles. First, integrity plays a part simply because it demands honesty, accuracy, and truthfulness from psychologists...

Words: 1466 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Legal and Ethical Principles in Health Care 08/19/2015 Ethics is a study which seeks to understand the nature, purposes, justification, and the founding principles of moral rules and the systems they comprise. Ethics deals with values relating to human conduct. It focuses on the rightness and wrongness of actions, as well as the goodness and badness of motives and ends. In the healthcare industry, ethics is about anticipating and recognizing healthcare dilemmas and making good judgments and decisions based on the patient’s needs and wishes. Also ethics is about the universal values that work in unison with the laws of the land, our Constitution, and where the Constitution remains silent, we rely on the ability of caregivers to make the right choices using the wisdom of Solomon to do good. An ethical dilemma has risen here in given situation. It can occur whenever a choice involves giving up something good and suffering something bad, no matter what course of action is taken. Ethical dilemmas often require caregivers to make decisions that may break some ethical norm or contradict some ethical values. In the given situation, decision must be made depending upon various dimensions of dilemma and the issues related to the same; and of course the ethical principles: base for decision making. Dimensions of given Ethical dilemma: * Relevant information Here, the information given about the patient includes that a male patient is 96 years of age and...

Words: 1310 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...was pretty sure she was a pseudo seizure patient. When it came to looking at what drugs she could be given, the only drug she was not allergic to was Morphine. When doing assessments on the patient, she would always say that her pain was an 8-9 before pain medication and a 7/10 after pain medication. Every 4 hours the patient would put her call light on and complain of pain. However, the patient showed no signs of pain as she was doing her hair and putting on makeup to look good for her boyfriend who was coming to see her soon. With the patient requesting pain medications frequently, showing no apparent signs of pain or seizure activity and allergic to every type of medication makes me suspicious of the patient drug seeking. So the ethical dilemma is should the patient be given pain medication when they requests it every 4 hrs, when not appearing to be in pain? The three options that I was alternating between were medicating the patient as ordered when they request it, give the patient half the dose ordered when they request it, or delay the patient’s dose to every 6 hours or not give it at all. The moral principles involved are autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence and accountability. Medicating the patient when they request it would be upholding to the principle of autonomy. Beneficence is an action done for the benefit of the patient. Administering pain medication upon request may be promoting good for the patient, as we want the patient to be pain free, which in return allows...

Words: 1086 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Ethical Dilemmas

...What primary relationships do you see between legal and ethical issues faced by nurses in their practice? How would you explain these relationships to others? What would you say are at least two ethical dilemmas that are often faced by nurses in their daily practice? Explain how accountability and responsibility play a role when nurses face with these dilemmas. One of the most well known ethical dilemmas that nurses can face in their career is their patient's belief system. One example is the familiar dilemma of when a patient has a strong religious belief that interferes with sound evidence base medical practice. For example Jehovah Witnesses forbid blood transfusions under any circumstance. Even when it's the difference between life and death, the answer will always be no blood transfusion. Most knowledgeable and experience nurses will attempt to explain the necessity and benefits of the blood transfusions, but it's also understood that it's the nurse's job to support patient's rights. Nurses often face unique challenges because of the amount of time they actually spend with patients and their family. Nurses are typically the ones who actually witnesses the patient's or family's struggle to make crucial decisions. Most often nurses are engaged with the patient and their family more than any other healthcare provider. One key fact to recognize is nurses bring with them their personal values, which at times can be in direct conflict with what their patient wants...

Words: 942 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical dilemma: Indirectly Using Child Labor Child labor now becomes a complicated problem, which affects all regions of the world. According to the telegraph online, “Even at big company, as Apple, said that 91 children under the age of 16 were discovered to be working last year in ten Chinese factories owned by its suppliers. “ The company did not examine the suppliers, and the suppliers squeezed the child labor, finally, the company gets more profit. The ethical dilemma in this essay is that whether it is ethical for a company not to examine if they indirectly use the child labor. I will apply two ethical theories to this ethical dilemma, the Kantian ethics theory and the Utilitarianism theory. In the Kantian ethics theory, he says, “we should do the right thing regardless of reward or loss”, which is core ideas of his ethics theory. Furthermore, in his famous work Groundwork Metaphysics of Morality, he says, “Nothing is good in itself but the good will.” Additionally, in the Utilitarianism theory, it is roughly based on calculating or measuring benefits versus burdens. There are two core philosophers in the Utilitarianism theory, Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. I will explain this two theories and how the company fall into the dilemma as follows: Firstly, there is no doubt that it is an unethical matter. As for the Kantian ethics, he thinks there is no relationship between the purpose and ethics; whatever effect of the purpose is content, happy, or kind. We only...

Words: 1696 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...MANAGER’S ETHICAL DILEMMA -- # 1 1、Ethical Dilemma The primary problem is whether Sally Cook should accept Bossey’s offer to get higher value for her stock. Then the question is what Cook should do? 2、Stakeholders ① Ralph Bossey: He has the right to use the way of takeover to make money, even if it will cause harmful effect on employees in that company and development of community health. ② Stockholders (like Sally Cook): They have the right to choose to accept the attractive offer from Bossey or not. ③ Employees: They have the right to guarantee a stable job in the company. 3、 Alternative Actions and Consequences. ① Accept the offer from Bossey. If Cook accepted the offer, she can get double current market value for her holdings. But it will cause lay off many employees in Graham Corporation. It can also restrain company’s nutritional improvements and product innovation. Finally, it will influence the development of community health. ② Not accept the offer. If Cook does not accept the offer, it will benefit many employees and community health. But she has to extend the working time to gain a better life to eliminate her financial worry. 4、 Analysis From my opinion, I think Cook should not accept the offer from Bossey. The following reasons are the factors that Cook should consider before she makes final decision. From a legal point of view, what Bossey does is legal. The way he uses to take over the company is also legal, but his action will have negative effect...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...By definition, an ethical dilemma is a situation that will often involve an apparent conflict between moral imperatives, in which to obey one would result in transgressing another. When one combines this definition with the many problems employees and management face on a daily basis, you are bound to have plenty of examples for many different kinds of businesses, regardless of what the business is or the line of work. This internal conflict that people experience can cause many issues in today’s workplace, and in the next few paragraphs I will explain how, why, and produce some examples. One of the most popular examples of an ethical dilemma is the story of the man whose family is starving and he steals a loaf of bread for his family’s survival. At its core, this example covers all the bases: conflicting imperatives with regards to a need for food and breaking the law by stealing the food. There can be arguments made on both sides with no clear decision on what the right thing to do would be. When translated into today’s work environment, employed persons have conflicting thoughts and feelings every day because they face problems at work but also in their personal lives as well. Anytime one has two completely different sets of problems their chances for an ethical dilemma will rise. According to Puja Lalwani, who writes articles for buzzle.com, “A lot of people believe that there is no room for ethics in the workplace. In a world of fierce competition where everyone...

Words: 1751 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma CJA 324 June 29, 2015 Ethical Dilemma According to Your dictionary (1996-2015) an ethical dilemma is defined as a situation where someone must make a choice between two or more options, all of which will result in a negative outcome. Today we are faced with many ethical dilemmas that force us to examine the situation and surrounding events in depth to discover a better way of doing things. One such ethical dilemma is the legal age to vote in elections. The Constitution The twenty-sixth Amendment to the Constitution guarantees every American “the right of citizens of the United States, who are eighteen years of age or older, to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of age” (The National Constitution Center, n.d.). In America the legal adult age is considered 18 years. As an adult, an 18 year old will pay taxes on income he or she has earned. They pay sales tax on items they have purchased. They are old enough to drive a car and to join the military. These are the arguments many have given in favor of lowering the voter legal age form 18 years to 16 years, but there is another side to the story – one of opposition to lowering the age and in favor of returning the legal age to voting rights to 21 years of age as originally set forth by the United States Constitution. The United States Constitution was adopted in 1789, at which time voting was reserved for male property owners ages 21 and older...

Words: 1093 - Pages: 5