Ethical Issues Within the American Red Cross

In: Business and Management

Submitted By beeharley
Words 752
Pages 4
The American Red Cross (ARC) is an organization that was founded in 1881 by Clara Barton and established itself as the most well-known emergency relief organization devoted to the care of war victims, disaster victims, and the suffering worldwide. Unfortunately, the ARC has been plagued with a high executive turnover, slow response to disastrous events, and mismanagement of donation funds. These problems now have the ARC facing another problem, fixing their credibility for the future.
The Red Cross is built to aide in disaster relief, but to receive a phone call asking “Where is the Red Cross?” from the Pentagon to activate the specialized teams in response to 9/11 left scars on the ARC's permanent record that are hard to overcome (Ferrell, Fraedrich, & Ferrell pg 330). On top that, four years later criticism over the massive failures of communication in Hurricane’s Katrina and Rita created additional wounds to the ARC’s reputation. Each instance further degraded the ARC’s ethical reputation to American’s as the non-profit organization to turn to in a disaster. To overcome these faults the ARC has made changes, but too many changes at the top is the ultimate reason for the ARC’s failures.
Any member working for the ARC in a management position from local presidents to top executives and state delegates are supposed to be ruled under universal humanitarian principles which involve the highest standards in ethics and values. Sadly, since the resignation of Elizabeth Dole in 1999, the ARC has had seven different permanent or acting heads causing multiple systemic and ethical problems (Ferrell, Fraedrich, & Ferrell, pg 328-239). Each of these enlightened egotists gladly accepted their severance packages upon their departure in spite of the abominable failure to successfully follow the ARC's fundamental mission of preventing and relieving suffering…...

Similar Documents

The American Red Cross

... national disasters like Hurricane Katrina. Government agencies were quick to address some of the concerns of the public regarding the American Red Cross but the American Red Cross needs to put forth a better effort to abide by the rules and standards set forth by the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies. Determine and discuss the ways in which ARC’s corporate governance failed to provide formalized responsibility to their stakeholders. Corporate governance is formal system of accountability, oversight, and control companies put in place to remove the opportunity for employees to make unethical decisions (Ferrell, Fraedrich, & Ferrell, 2011, p. 42). Ferrell, Fraedrich, & Ferrell go further and give the following definitions for each aspect of this system: • Accountability refers to how closely workplace decisions are aligned with a firm’s stated strategic direction and its compliance with ethical and legal considerations. • Oversight provides a system checks and balances that limit employees’ and managers’ opportunity to deviate from policies and strategies and that prevent unethical and illegal activities. • Control is the process of auditing and improving organizational decisions and actions. The American Red Cross failed in each aspect during and after these disasters. There was no accountability, little oversight and even less control. In addition, some corporate governance issues include: • Executive compensation • Structure of......

Words: 1356 - Pages: 6

Ethical Issues Within the American Red Cross

... organizational structure of the American Red Cross needs to be taught that ethical compliance is its first priority; otherwise issues will continue to present themselves when the ARC is needed most. Mandatory, in-person, ethical classes should be held every year for employees and volunteers to help reinforce the ARC’s claim that they are fixing their internal issues. Also, executive leadership needs to be held accountable for their actions and not given monetary compensation upon their dismissal or resignation. Each of these things would help mend the American Red Cross’s image and help show the public that they have truly learned from past mistakes. References American Red Cross. (2006). September 11th Response & Recovery. The American Red Cross. Retrieved from American Red Cross. (2012). About Us. The American Red Cross. Retrieved from CDS Global. (2011, May 16). American Red Cross Case Study. CDS Global Solution, Inc. Retrieved from _red_cross.pdf CNN. (2001, November 06). Red Cross defends handling of Sept. 11 donations. CNN U.S. Retrieved from red-cross-relief-agency?_s=PM:US Ferrell, O. C., Ferrell, L., & Fraedrich, J. (2011). Business ethics: Ethical decision making and cases. (8th ed.). Mason: South-Western CENGAGE Learning. Holguin, Jaime.......

Words: 752 - Pages: 4

American Red Cross

... of smaller towns. “The Food and Grocery vertical is the largest segment and accounts for close to 60% of the total value addition. This category has the highest consumer demand across all income levels and various retail formats. The Indian consumer behavior of preferring proximity to retail formats is highly pronounced in this sector, with food, grocery and allied products largely sourced from the local stores or push-cart vendors.” [4] India has had years of debate and discussions on the risks and prudence of allowing innovation and competition within its retail industry. Numerous economists repeatedly recommended to the Government of India that legal restrictions on organized retail must be removed, and the retail industry in India must be opened to competition. For example, in an invited address to the Indian parliament in December 2010, Jagdish Bhagwati, Professor of Economics and Law at the Columbia University urged the Indian parliament to extend economic reforms by freeing up of the retail sector, further liberalization of trade in all sectors, and introducing labor market reforms. RECENT TRENDS • Retailing in India is witnessing a huge revamping exercise • India is rated the fifth most attractive emerging retail market: a potential goldmine. • Estimated to be US$ 200 billion, of which organized retailing (i.e. modern trade) makes up 3 percent or US$ 6.4 billion • As per a report by KPMG the annual growth of department stores is estimated at 24% • Ranked...

Words: 4250 - Pages: 17

American Red Cross

... issues which can ultimately lead to people losing faith in the organization. Currently the ARC has been showing the American people that they are an ethical organization, and their leader plays a major role in the ARC restoring its reputation. On April 8, 2008 Gail J. McGovern was named chairman of Red Cross. Since she has been at the head of the organization the ARC has been commended for their fast response to the disaster in Haiti in March of 2010, and the fact that there was not any misconduct issues reported. McGovern stated that there has been tremendous improvement in the number of product recall and management areas (, 2011). Also the work in Haiti was made transparent to the public, and the ARC sent out progress reports on their efforts (, 2011). Maybe the most important change for the ARC is the changing of their governing documents in 2007. Changes were signed by the President of the United States to modernize the board to focus on strategic oversight and governance In the past it was evident that ARC did not make ethics a priority because ethics was no where to be found in their documents. Now you can go onto the ARC website and read their official documents and ethics are a focal point in their organization, designating an entire section for ethics, conduct, and compliance resources. There is also a link for reporting fraud, waste, or abuse with a hotline number available for public use. McGovern...

Words: 1639 - Pages: 7

American Red Cross Outline

...The American Red Cross Outline – Starbucks Meeting 11/19/2012 * Remember, we are telling a story, timeline style * Text Ad gimmick * Print donation cards * 1/3 vs. 2/3 breakdown Matt’s # and my # * Start with a history and background facts of the ARC * Clara Barton Founded ARC in 1881, inspired by work of the IRC while on trip to Europe during Franco-Prussian War of 1870-1871. Brought model back to US and led org through first dom and int relief missions, assisting US military during Spanish-American War in 1898. * Chartered by US govt, receiving first federal charter in 1900. * Member of International Federal of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, ARC joins more than 175 other national societies in bringing aid to victims of disasters throughout the world. * The ARC provides community services, support for military members and their families, blood donation services, health and safety education, and international relief programs. * 500k volunteers, 35k employees, board of governors oversees the org and its management * Board comprised of 12-20 members, including a chair, who is appointed and approved by the President of the US * Board appoints the president and CEO to manage the business activities of the ARC * More than 700 local chapters across the country, all receive funding from national Red Cross. Representatives of local...

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

American Red Cross

...The American Red Cross is a non-profit organization that was created to assist people in time of need regardless nationality, race religious beliefs, class or political opinions. This national society has a long rich history and is one of the most identifiable humanitarian organizations in the nation. The mission of the American Red Cross is to alleviate and prevent human suffering in the face of emergencies by mobilizing the power of volunteers and the generosity of donors. It promotes mutual understanding, friendship, cooperation and lasting peace among all peoples. The programs are founded on principles of Humanity, Impartiality, Neutrality, Independence, Voluntary Service, Unity and Universality. The American Red Cross was created in 1881 and is part of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) and is one of more than 145 national societies that make up the League of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies. The ICRC paved the way for the American Red Cross when Henry Dunant, a Swiss businessman, authored A Memory of Solferino in 1862, in which he described what he had seen on an Italian battlefield in 1859 – over 40,000 troops either killed or wounded, left unattended. In 1863, his memoir encouraged others to create the ICRC, which adopted the iconic red cross on a white background, the reverse of the Swiss flag. Shortly thereafter during the U.S. Civil War, Clara Barton, a former school teacher and government worker from Massachusetts, entered the...

Words: 1151 - Pages: 5

American Red Cross

...The American Red Cross predominately uses Enterprise Funds for its accounting for their revenues. Since the group does receive about 26% of their revenue through donations, based on the 2011 financial statements, these contributions are usually restricted. They are restricted in a couple different ways; unrestricted net assets, temporarily restricted net assets, and permanently restricted net assets. And because of these types of restrictions, Enterprise Funds do work best for the Red Cross in order to account for each fund. The two sets of restricted contributions that are used more often are the unrestricted or the temporarily restricted. Of the total contribution amounts for 2011, 84% of that falls into one of those two net asset accounts. The 2011 Consolidated Statement of Activities breaks down the revenues by contributions, products and services, and other revenue accounts, along with the 2010 numbers for comparison, by unrestricted, temporarily restricted, and permanently restricted. Each coordinating expense section is presented the same way. The investment revenues are reported at fair value on the financial statements. Any investment income is classified as operating revenue and is also kept separate on the financials. Revenue recognition by the Red Cross is during the period received or when pledge. If a contribution comes with a donor imposed restriction and then at the end of the restriction, those funds are then reclassified as unrestricted and can be used for......

Words: 312 - Pages: 2

Leadership Style of the American Red Cross

...The American Red Cross is one of the oldest and most successful charitable organizations in America today. Since its founding in 1881, the Red Cross has helped millions of people around the globe. Recently, the Red Cross has dedicated some of its vast resources with the guidance of a new CEO refocusing the leadership and mission of this respectable company. This company in recent past was floundering under a leadership and management style that had become bloated and unproductive. The board of directors had swelled to more than 50 members with no clear lines of communication between the board, the CEO, and management. This created a void as directives and tasks became poorly understood and remained unfinished. The goals of the Red Cross have always have been honorable. The attainment of these goals had become unmanageable. There are several leadership styles that would be applicable for an institution of this size and scope. A visionary style is most appropriate when an organization needs a new direction. Using this leadership style will move people toward a new set of shared dreams where the leader will not only articulate where the group needs to go but also how it will get there. The Red Cross desperately needed a new way of doing things. A visionary style works here because it encourages ample communication in both directions. It allows workers and volunteers to be innovative, to experiment with new directions and to take risks. The Red...

Words: 1126 - Pages: 5

Red Cross Ethical Dilemmas

...Case 18: American Red Cross The American Red Cross was founded by Clara Barton in 1881 after she brought the model of the International Red Cross back from her travels with IRC. The setup of this organization is to help those who need disaster relief assistance. The ARC has helped with the World Wars and numerous other wars that the U.S was in. They provide relief to over 70,000 disasters each year. However, within the last decade they have been widely criticized for their response to two major disasters in the US as well as erratic leadership position moves causing concern that the organizational focus is lost. In addition, their control problems extended into the mismanagement of funds and ARC is made up of 500,000 volunteers and 35,000 employees, and at the top there is a 12-20 member governing board of directors. Over the last ten years, there has been numerous individuals in the CEO role because their predecessors were released for misconduct. The organization is further tarnished for the large severance packages that are handed to the dismissed executives. Critics have observed that leadership focus for a good chunk of two years went into searching for the right leadership rather than management of goals and infrastructure. The lack of control extended out to blood donation program where there was a lack of communication with the blood testing facilities. The disasters of Hurricane Katrina and 9/11 were two of the biggest events where relief and assistance were...

Words: 665 - Pages: 3

American Red Cross: a Community Organization

...American Red Cross: A Community Organization The American Red Cross’s responsibility and involvement to the community involves care, compassion, assistance, and a plethora of other services. The American Red Cross has been providing disaster relief for well over 100 years and is well known as a humanitarian organization. The American Red Cross provides services in five key areas: blood drives, safety training (like CPR and First Aid), and community help for the poor, support services for military families, and various humanitarian programs (American Red Cross, 2013A). There are factors that influence social responsibility strategies of the American Red Cross. The American Red Cross must act ethically with sensitivity to the community and strive for positive effective contribution. The American Red Cross (2013) governing body is the Board of Governors. The Board has the necessary overseeing power to manage business affairs of the organization and maintains sequences of governing documents. The governing documents go through a review process to ensure safeguards are in place so that the needs of American Red Cross are met and reflect present-day industry best practices. There is a commitment with the Board of Governors to hold every member of the American Red Cross to the highest standards in reference to conduct and ethics. In addition, within the American Red Cross are corporate policies and regulations, which require compliance by employees and volunteers (American Red...

Words: 687 - Pages: 3

The American Red Cross

... disasters (Ferrell, Ferrell, Fraedrich 2011). Now let’s examine how this disaster impacted the ARC, benefits of business ethics. Business ethics’ is the application of ethical values, such as integrity, fairness, respect and openness, to business behavior. The American Red Cross was criticized for their operations being chaotic in some places, inequitable in others. This stung deeply within an organization that is proud of its overall response to Hurricane Katrina, by far the most devastating natural disaster it has confronted on U.S. soil. There were reports after reports declaring the relief efforts of the ARC unsatisfactory. The decisions being made by the ARC were deemed fraudulent, unethical and inefficient. The mission of the ARC is to coordinate federal mass care assistance in support 3 of state and local governments and other voluntary organizations in charge of meeting needs such as shelter, food and emergency first aid (Ferrell, Ferrell, Fraedrich 2011). They failed to do this in many ways. Following Katrina, for day’s air conditioned trucks with no supplies drove aimlessly past people who were without water or food or protection from the sun. For many days the media and reporters came and went, but food and water and medical supplies did not . The American Red Cross did not deliver goods because they believed it might discourage evacuation. Evacuation by air was slowed to a crawl because FEMA said that post 9/11 security procedures required a...

Words: 1377 - Pages: 6

American Red Cross

...The American Red Cross xxxxxxxxxx BCOM/230 xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx The American Red Cross is one of the world well-known humanitarian organizations. I will describe the organization culture, uses of communication, relationship between communication and culture, and the alignment of values. The American Red Cross was created by Clara Barton in 1881. The American Red Cross organizational culture is based on providing assistance around the world to a variety of humanitarian relief causes within the United States. The company thrives through commitment from volunteers. The common factor that volunteers from The Red Cross share is the need to give back to their communities and the world by donating time and effort to others in need. “We depend on the many generous contributions of time, blood, and money from the American public to support our lifesaving services and programs” (The American Red Cross, 2013). This organization dates back to over 130 years but the culture of the organization remains the same. It has broadened its scope since its beginning but the concept remains the same. In the face of constant change The American Red Cross has adapted to the needs of the environment. The American Red Cross has also adapted its communication skills much like other companies in today’s times. The American Red Cross uses social media and Internet website to promote the company and bring in new volunteers, interns, and employees. I checked out the Facebook page for the Red...

Words: 723 - Pages: 3

The American Red Cross

...1 The American Red Cross The American Red Cross culture is based on compassion and care to those in need. Their main principles consist of humanity, impartiality, neutrality, independence, and unity to list a few. The organization does not only help disaster relief efforts as most assume, but also offers services in five other areas: community services that help the needy; communications services and comfort for military members and their family members; the collection, processing and distribution of blood and blood products; educational programs on preparedness, health, and safety; and international relief and development programs. The organization is a nationwide network of more than 650 chapters and 36 blood services regions dedicated to saving lives and helping people prepare for and respond to medical emergencies. They communicate at the local levels; American Red Cross chapters operate volunteer-staffed Disaster Action Teams that respond to disasters in their communities. The organization also uses a database in order to pull specific volunteers for different situations, such as they made need a volunteer for interpretation or accounting assistance. They also have teamed up with Blue Moon Production to help make a video media library for internal use .This keeps the volunteers updated on certain issues going on in the organization. The Red Cross uses commercials and celebrities to reach out externally to the community to give education and help receive donations...

Words: 612 - Pages: 3

Cep Teams at American Red Cross

...MGMT 331 Chapter Enrichment Teams at American Red Cross October 7, 2015 Executive Summary Primary Analysis Ann Munroe, the Program Enrichment Officer was in charge of each of the team sections. After reading the individual reports, she felt uneasy about the redundant and generic reports that were generated. After speaking with the team section leaders, they all commented on the staff sizing issue. They all agreed this was an issue, but no one took the initiative to report on the issue. Most felt like it was not their place because it did not pertain to their area of analysis. So the issue was never brought up at the meeting. After reviewing the case, the fundamental management problem is too much structure within the organization. The team made decisions based on something similar to Herbert Simon’s Normative Model. The made their decisions based on bounded rationality. This is the notions that decision makers are restricted by different constraints when making a decision. The teams believes that they should not bring up the issue of overstaffing because they are bounded in their study. They think that they are only allowed to report on health and safety services. Therefore it is not in their expertise to talk about an issue in another department. While this is a credible decision making model, it causes severe limitations. It made it difficult for the manager to research further for a possible solution for the Chapter. This caused the team to report...

Words: 1407 - Pages: 6

American Red Cross

...American Red Cross Fundamental management problem/possible solutions The fundamental management problem is the lack of organizational culture and communication between the different American Red Cross chapters. The lack of organizational communication has led to several chapters providing overlapping services to adjacent chapters. The Chapter Enrichment Program (CEP) was then developed and implemented to correct the many reoccurring problems within the chapters. Though the CEP brought together professional teams of the American Red Cross together to discuss problems, underlying issues would still be present and not pointed out in the chapter reports. For example program officers such as Ann Munroe would noticed issues in her chapter that would not be included into the final report. Ann Munroe decided not to comment on the obvious issues in the chapter because she thought it was inappropriate because her main focus was on health and safety services of the chapter, not the chapter as a whole. The culture of the company is to do what you are strictly hired to do, which leads to many problems not being brought to attention or not being covered thoroughly. Munroe clearly noticed dilemmas within the chapter, but failed to include them into the report, which is where said dilemmas should be includes. These dilemmas were clearly problematic if it was easily noticed by a program officer not readily involved in that section of the operation. These problems consisted of whether a...

Words: 502 - Pages: 3