Premium Essay

Ethical Reasoning Assignment

In: Business and Management

Submitted By junyong52
Words 1040
Pages 5
The ethical issue here was that Lehman’s executives exploited loopholes in the accounting standards to manipulate their balance sheet in order to mislead the investing public. Using “Repo 105”, Lehman was able to clear huge amount unprofitable assets off its balance sheet instead of selling at loss. Evidence pointed out that the chief executive, Richard Ruld, knew about the use of it but faked ignorance in defence. Even the auditors from Ernst and Young knew about the use of the suspicious Repo 105 but chose to keep quiet.
I believe that the prime motivation behind the act was to retain investors’ confidence by preventing a plummet in stock price. Hence, the implication was that Lehman was projecting a false image of its strong financial position, meaning that its stock price was overvalued. Through falsified accounting reports, investors were tricked into believing that their investments were safe, incurring huge losses when Lehman defaulted. Investors lost faith. The consequences were devastating as it created a systemic crisis of confidence in the banking industry as all other banks froze lending to reduce their exposure of Lehman’s undesirable Repo 105. Lehman’s employees suffered too as they lost their jobs overnight.
After extensive research, it was apparent that a written “Code of Ethics” was present at Lehman Brothers. However, for an ethics code to be effective, the tone at the top executives needs to be set right so that the entire organisation can feel connected to the firm’s ethical values and beliefs. The obvious failure we witness in Lehman’s case was that the top management, led by Ruld (CEO) and Erin Callan (CFO), were guilty of unethical negligence and wrongdoing.
Therefore, it is vital for the Shareholders to screen through their selection of the Board of Directors extremely stringently to ensure the appointment of the right leaders.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay


...the external opportunities and threats as well as the internal strengths and weaknesses that impact a firm’s competitive advantage. critically evaluate how a business, corporate and/or international strategy would lead to sustainable competitive advantage. analyze complex and dynamic interdependencies among strategic issues. identify ethical issues and exhibit informed ethical judgment when faced with an ethical decision. Learning and Teaching Methods This course is structured in a seminar learning format, where a 4-hour seminar is conducted every week for a total of 13 sessions. Each seminar is intended to inform and equip students with the conceptual tools to synthesize, evaluate and analyze strategic issues with an ethical grounding. In addition, seminar activities have been developed to provide opportunities for students to sharpen their strategic thinking and/or ethical reasoning skills through: case analyses, where students apply the conceptual tools that they have learnt in the seminar to critically analyze different strategic issues an ethical reasoning exercise where students can apply ethical concepts a group assignment, where the group analyzes market viability and suggests strategies to introduce a product or service to a country of their choice, or conducts a strategic audit of public-listed firm 1 collaborative learning, where students work on group projects and participate in class discussion so that they learn to defend and/or......

Words: 4166 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay


...for a total of 13 sessions. Each seminar is intended to inform and equip students with the conceptual tools to synthesize, evaluate and analyze strategic or ethical issues. In addition, seminar activities have been developed to provide opportunities for students to sharpen their critical thinking and ethical reasoning skills through: 1. Case analyses, where students apply the conceptual tools that they have learnt in the seminar to critically analyze different strategic issues. 2. An ethical reasoning exercise (given in pages 7 and 8) where students can apply ethical concepts. 3. A critical thinking exercise where students could analyse specific case study issue with theoretical framework and concepts. 4. A group project, where each student group generates a strategic audit report of a publiclylisted firm. See pages 8 and 9 for details. 5. Collaborative learning, where students work in a group and participate in class discussion so that they learn to defend and/or integrate different perspectives on strategic issues in a critical manner. 6. A final exam, where students apply their knowledge of course material learnt throughout the course in an integrative manner. 1 Course Assessments - Summary Component Group Project (Report, 20% + Presentation, 5%) Class Participation Critical Thinking Analysis Ethical Reasoning Analysis Final Examinations (written) Total Percentage 25 15 5 5 50 100 Individual/Group Group Individual Individual Individual Individual Required......

Words: 6937 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Acc 260 Week 4 Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making

...ACC 260 Week 4 Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Get Tutorial by Clicking on the link below or Copy Paste Link in Your Browser For More Courses and Exams use this form ( ) Feel Free to Search your Class through Our Product Categories or From Our Search Bar ( ) As a student we are required to evaluate the philosophical approaches for each scenario from Appendix B. Evaluating whether or not the reasoning for the course of action listed makes sense. While working on the evaluation of the philosophical approaches we will discuss if the course of action is the most ethical, the best reasons for making the choices, and the reasons for believing this alternative is ethical. Consequentialism is the intent to maximize the usefulness of a decision. For this the relevance of this act depends on its consequences. For this approach it is essential to have a good ethical decisions and perception of it. With this it is important for students to analyze a decision in how the harmful and/or the benefits. This many philosophers’ debate ht consequences should count Deontology is different because it focuses on the obligation or duty in motivating the decision or the actions of the consequences. This depends on the respect, rights, and fairness. This approach brings up issues related......

Words: 6500 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Final Project Part 1

...Final Project Part One Amanda Schneider Ethics in the Legal Environment LS312-03 February 17, 2014 Final Project Part One Immanuel Kant is the founder of the ethical theory untitled the categorical imperative. This theory is based on ethical decisions being universal to everyone in society. Being universal to society means that everyone in society would do the same thing. Kant goes further in his analysis by saying that someone’s motives must be pure. A motive is considered pure as long as it is not selfish. So to apply this theory you must test both the motive behind the action as well as the universality to the action (The Kaplan eGuide to Ethics and the Legal Environment, 2013). To examine the scenario given for this assignment you must first identify the action. In this case the action being examined is whether or not it is ethical for one board member to use their board member status when dealing with personal business contacts. The first part of Kant’s theory states that a person’s motives must be pure. In this case the board member’s motive are not pure. They want to use the board’s good name to further his personal business connections. This motive is selfish as it only produces a positive effect for the board member’s personal business. This board member is not acting with a pure motive and therefore fails the first part of Kant’s theory. Next you must apply this action universally. What would happen if every board member was allowed......

Words: 1914 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Team Paper

... procedure, technique, and the arrangement of the problem. Problem-solving occurs in every area of life because problems occur in daily life. Insight and creativity in problem-solving allow the person to use imagination, critical thinking skills, and creativity to develop a solution to his or her problem. Therefore, insight and creativity are two important factors in problem-solving. The constraints of a problem depend upon problem representation to uncover ways to solve the problem. In addition, problem representation forces a person to empower his or her cognitive skills to investigate problems. Analyzing the abilities and functions of reasoning, judgment, and decision-making in problem-solving process occurs to determine the existence of new measures in the decision and reasoning approaches in the search for ethical solutions. The ethical solutions in problem-solving guarantee the results are trustworthy and accurate. Therefore, the need for accurate problem-solving skills is a necessity to find solutions to problems people experience. Approaches of Problem-Solving Problem-solving have three significant characteristics. 1) A problem is an unidentified assessment, procedure, technique, arrangement, or belief valuable to finding an answer to. 2) According to Newell and Simon, (1972), for a person to come across the unidentified problem-solving lead to the mental image of the problem. The individual problem solvers independently collaborate or a social framework......

Words: 1830 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...Ethics Reasoning Assignment – Lehman Brothers Relating Questions to Rubrics 1. Describe the situation at LB from an ethics perspective. What’s your opinion of what happened here? Rubric: Ethical Sensitivity or Awareness  Able to sieve out, recognize and identify ethical issues and risks in the case scenario  Recognizes ethical issues and their implications, including potential consequences to various stakeholders  Identifies aspects of the case situation that are likely to lead to a conflict of interest situation and/or making it susceptible to ethical risks2 (this rubric dimension overlaps the first 2). st You should pinpoint the unethical practices, actions and behaviour in LB (1 part of the qn).Then, discuss nd the implications and consequences for stakeholders resulting from these unethical acts (2 part of qn). 2. Could anything be done differently at Lehman Brothers to prevent what happened? Explain. Rubric: Ethical knowledge, understanding and Judgement  Able to raise pertinent questions or clarify relevant information to obtain a clearer understanding and/or form an appropriate judgment of the issues involved in the case scenario  Addresses relevant and incisive questions and the extent to which a clear understanding and judgment of the issues involved in the case scenario are exemplified with supporting illustrations  Proposes and discusses the ethical notions of rights, duty, utility, virtue, or justice and fairness in resolving the problems or issues Here,......

Words: 469 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...The purpose of this assignment is to assist you in refining problem-solving capabilities that organizations already possess for use in business ethics applications. This paper uses a structured, objective format sometimes called a system of inquiry. This assignment is a systematic formalized inquiry into or examination of the code of ethics of an organization and its effects to achieve a specific level of ethical behavior in employees, management, and executives.Although it is easy and valuable to have students discuss an ethical dilemma, the students can fall into the trap of jumping to their first impressions and then trying to justify their responses. It would be more in keeping with the idea that ethics is a process to have students intelligently assess the information relative to a dilemma in the hope that a resolution will become apparent as a result of exploring the problem. In order to accomplish this, the student will need models and practice in detaching themselves from personal interests and understanding the types of reasoning, or ethical systems, that people commonly use. The purpose of this module is to have students illustrate types of ethical decisions by role playing a script, then involving the class in discovering the type of thinking demonstrated. Knowing the types of systems will hopefully help to shape their future discussions of ethical dilemmas and help to broaden the repertoire of thinking they can bring to use. Students may try to put these......

Words: 470 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...evaluate reasoning in everyday discourse. Examines the elements of good reasoning from both a formal and informal perspective. Introduces some formal techniques of the basic concepts of deductive and inductive reasoning. Promotes reasoning skills through examining arguments from literature, politics, business, and the media. Enables students to identify common fallacies, to reflect on the use of language for the purpose of persuasion, and to think critically about the sources and biases of the vast quantity of information that confronts us in the "Information Age." INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS Required Resources Soomo (2013). Critical Thinking. [Webtext]. Asheville, NC: Soomo Publishing. Note: For each week of the course, all of the following materials in the Preparation and Evaluation portions can be accessed through the Webtext link within Blackboard. The Activities portion (discussion question) will not be located in Webtext, but rather in a separate Blackboard link within your shell. Supplemental Resources Critical Thinking Community. (2013). Defining Critical Thinking. Retrieved from Ellerton, P. (2011). Reason to Think. Issues, (95), 33-35. ETS. (2013). Introduction to the Argument Task. Retrieved from Holyoak, K., & Morrison, R. G. (2005). The Cambridge Handbook of Thinking and Reasoning. New......

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Term Paper Portfolio

...| |909-537-3393 |JB 213 | 1. Portfolio of Academic Work You will prepare and submit a portfolio containing assignments representing your successful work in the online MBA program. Compiling the portfolio should be a valuable activity for you. It will help you see that your online MBA is not just a random selection of courses but a coherent and manageable field of study. Additionally, it will help you see the relationship between the way you have structured your program, guided by the requirements of options and electives, and the overall learning goals any online MBA degree should achieve. How to Choose Items for Your Portfolio – do this section before writing your Reflective Essay |Step |Action |Notes | |1 |Review the complete list of Learning Goals. |A complete list of the Learning Goals is included at the end of this document. | |2 |Review your papers, exams, case studies, |Look for projects and papers that clearly illustrate how you learned and/or used one or more of| | |assignments, and other written materials you |the Learning Goals. Strive for a variety of Learning Goals. | | |have produced for your online MBA courses. | ......

Words: 3481 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay


... Ethics Tracy Booker Ethics and Moral Reasoning Instructor: Galen Johnson August 12, 2013 l If the majority of our society conducted themselves in a way they saw fit and did not abide by rules we would be living in complete chaos. My topic for this assignment is ethics. Ethics is a part of everyday life. I will demonstrate in my assignment the most convincing ethical system. I will attempt to explain why it is necessary to have universal principles. I will give the fundamental principles of ethics. I will explain what is considered the good life and how to achieve it. I will elaborate on what it ethically bad life. I will attempt to discuss if ethics is natural or learned. I will discuss the role of ethical actions. I will discuss how humans differentiate on between what is good and bad. My final point will be to explain if humans are free or determined and how this perspective relates to human responsibility. The systematic study of rules for behavior and conduct, for ourselves and for others is called ethics. Ethics are a requirement for a normal life. It is a study of right or wrong in human actions. Ethics helps us understand who we are. Without out ethics a human life would be full of destructive patterns. A good foundation of ethics requires a standard. This standard has to have proper goals and actions to be considered ethically correct. The most convincing ethical system is utilitarianism. This ethical system dates back to the seventeenth......

Words: 1689 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


... | | | | | |DQ2 Thursday | | | | |Day 3 | | |Individual |Complete the Ethical Lens Inventory through the link on the student website. |Monday |2 | |Ethical Lens Inventory | |Day 7 | | |Individual |Resources: CWE Thesis Generator; CWE Sample Outline |Monday |3 | |Personal Responsibility | |Day 7 | | |Essay: Thesis Statement |Review the assignment directions for the Personal Responsibility Essay, due in Week Five. | | | |and Informal Outline | | | | | |Create a thesis statement and informal outline for your Personal Responsibility Essay. | | ......

Words: 2881 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Ethical Lens Inventory

...The result of my “Ethical Lens Inventory” were that I use rational reasoning skills to determine both, the universal rules that each person should follow and the processes that will ensure fairness and justice for all in the community. What this means is that I like to gather all the information, research all available options, and think things through carefully before I make a decision. I also like to make sure my decisions are equally fair and beneficial to everyone, regardless of the time that it may take. These are the same skills that I use academically as well. I like to make sure that I complete all my assignments with well thought out, researched and prepared material. I will work tirelessly to achieve the best possible material, again, no matter how long it takes. The results of my “Ethical Lens Inventory” show that I am a critical thinker by nature. Again by me carefully analyzing, researching, and thoroughly thinking things through to come up with the best possible solution. I have always believed that it is only fair that I give a problem or situation my all, regardless whether it is for work, personal or academically. The results of my “Reasoning Abilities” in My Career Plan Building Activity were on the same lines as my “Ethical Lens Inventory”. I am a person that works well in careers where success comes from apply practical skills and where thinking is used mostly to solve problems. It also states that I am likely to be attracted to...

Words: 460 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Project Manager

...Dilemma •Alternatives and Reasoning •Proposal and Implementation •Summary •Recap Seleris: Silicon 6 •Martha McCaskey has been given the lead on the Silicon 6 Project.  •Very difficult to collect information on the target company •Discovered that she could receive information from former vice president of the target company, Phil Devon •Martha McCaskey completed her undergraduate degree at Caltech in the field of electrical engineering . •After attending Harvard to pursue her MBA. Martha decided she wanted to pursue a career in consulting. Martha McCaskey Education Alternative 2 What is best for McCaskey? Martha McCaskey Team H Martha McCaskey Work Experience •Martha currently works at Seleris in the Industrial Analysis Division.  •She has been working for the company for a total of 18 months, and previously worked for a major consumer electronics firm. Our Definition of Success  Maximize NOPAT in the long run for Seleris’ while sustaining the least unethical and financial damage to you Some keys to our continuing success (i.e., constituents’ expectations) Timely completion of projects Above-satisfactory completion of projects Above-satisfactory compilation of useful data Effective delivery of useful information Self-motivation and ingenuity to acquire industry-leading information OUR DEFINITION OF SUCCESS: SOME KEYS TO OUR CONTINUING SUCCESS: SELERIS’ INFRASTRUCTURE OPERATIONS IN GENERAL Ethical Compromise The......

Words: 1688 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...Ethical Lens Inventory April Jackson Humanities/US/101 September 8, 2013 Lydia Portee What my ethical lens inventory said; is that I see the gifts and weaknesses of each lens and able to move fluidly among them to adapt the right tools to each situation to assure the best outcome. I use reasoning skills to determine my duties as well as the universal rules and the systems that will assure fairness and justice for everyone. I also listen to my intuition to determine the greatest good for each individual, as well as the virtues that best serve the community. I believe although there are universal principles, each situation is unique and not all exceptions can be categorized. I demonstrate wisdom in practical matters and foresight as I act with enlightened self- interest in a particular situation. I also demonstrate steadiness in the face of obstacles and are able to chart untested courses without being rash. I am able to see myself and others clearly, I do not make assumptions about why people act the way they do. I am known to operate from a clear set of value that articulated in me. I am comfortable using all available tools to analyze a problem. These include critical thinking skills, reference to expert, my own experience and traditions of the community. What I like to do when it come to my ethical behavior is, not to judge anyone. It helps me to know that all people are not a like or have the same ideas as other. It gives me ways to achieve my goals and be......

Words: 474 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethical Resoning

...ETHICAL REASONING ASSIGNMENT By :Lina Cassis 500389711 LAW 122-011 491 Word The issue that is raised in Martha’s situation is the fact that she made a statement about Bob in public that could ultimately ruin his reputation. The legal aspect of this issue is the fact that she made a defaming statement about Bob. Defamation can either be slander or liable, although it was slander when Martha communicated a wrongful accusation “that Bob is not a man of his Word” to a third party(TBREA) that caused them(assuming they are reasonable people) to have a lower opinion of Bob, which can cause his business to suffer. The ethical aspect of this issue is the fact that Martha being a reasonable person should have known that it is ethically wrong to talk about somebody in a hurtful way especially among his peers. Martha will be liable for defamation. She slandered Bob’s reputation and as a result his clients will doubt his word and his reputation and business as a result will suffer. The statement “Bob just doesn’t keep promises” is indeed defamatory statement because a reasonable person would have thought that it referred to the plaintiff (McInnis,Kerr,Vanduzer; 2014).Member of the (TBREA) knew that Martha was referring to Bob because she made no effort to even hide his name, although if she has just said “he just doesn’t keep his promises” members might not know who she is referring to and consequently would not be a defamatory statement. Martha does not have any defences to the......

Words: 508 - Pages: 3