Ethical Theories Applied to Enron

In: Business and Management

Submitted By rfoose
Words 1705
Pages 7
Prescriptive Approaches to Ethics at Enron
Enron was a global energy firm that filed for bankruptcy protection in 2001. The firm’s senior managers had engaged in fraud for an extended period through a scheme in which partnerships owned by the managers could receive payment for goods and services never provided to Enron. In addition, the firm’s external auditing firm, Arthur Andersen, was complicit in the fraud by knowingly certifying false financial statements as accurate. Arthur Anderson participated in the fraud because the firm did not want to risk losing lucrative consulting contracts from Enron, which created a conflict of interest situation (Miller, 2004). The events leading to the collapse of Enron can be analyzed using the ethical frameworks suggested by consequentialist theory, deontological theory, and virtue ethics. Such an analysis can provide an explanation of the failure of Enron’s directors, mangers, and auditors to adhere to their ethical duties to the shareholders, employees, customers and suppliers of the firm.
Consequentialist theory suggests that an act is ethically wrong if it results in consequences deemed wrong or harmful by the majority of people in a society (Hooker, 2002). The consequentialist theory requires assessing the actual consequences of the act, which includes both direct and indirect consequences. It also requires using some type of evaluative norm for determining whether the consequence is beneficial or harmful. The theory is prescriptive because the evaluative norms are used to guide whether individuals should perform or avoid an act. To apply the theory, there must be general agreement in a society as to the nature of the evaluative norms. The theory also suggests that the ethics of each situation should be determined according to the specific circumstances without reference to an absolute legalistic or moralistic standard.…...

Similar Documents


...polBachelor of Business (BS701) Applied Communication (BSB5008) Level 5 Assessment 2: Report – Analysis of a communication problem Due Date: Weighting: Type: Length: Learning outcomes: 9 am 18 November. 2012 30% of final mark Individual write-up and video with a group component via Moodle forum. 1 minute video (avi or mp4 format) (no video = no marks) 800 (+-10%) words report (not including bibliography or Moodle forum) Not respecting the word count will result in a reduction of 5 percent of the total value of this assessment. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 Task: Dr. Fons Trompenaars has developed a model that describes countries from a cultural perspective using 7 dimensions. Advertising agencies use these dimensions to understand their target audience better and tailor their advertisements based on these dimensions. Advertising agencies from abroad do not always understand the culture of this region. You, as an advertising consultant, have been asked by your manager to analyse the Gulf Arab audience using some of the dimensions of this model and develop a 1 min video to sell a product or service of your choice to the Gulf Arab audience based on its cultural make up. You need to write a report that justifies the communication you have used to sell the product or service to the Gulf Arab audience based on your research on the cultural make up of the Gulf Arab audience on the dimensions: Universalism vs. Particularism, Neutral vs. Affective, Achievement vs. Ascription and...

Words: 1922 - Pages: 8

Bp vs Enron - an Ethical Approach

...BP Vs. Enron - An ethical Approach There are several different ways that unethical practices can be carried out. I will be highlighting the Enron failure, with the more recent BP Oil Spill, and comparing the practices of each one to one another. The BP oil spill was caused when methane gas rose into the drilling machine of the oil rig, and caused an explosion, which burned the entire platform (Bureau, 2011). Soon after, large patches of oil appeared on the surface of the water, and soon reached nearby beaches. Even though BP publically estimated about 5,000 barrels of oil spilled each day, the actual figure ended up being over 50,000 barrels a day, according to a government investigation. It was later revealed that BP initially arrived at similar numbers as the government, but downplayed them to make it appear that less damage was being caused (Bureau, 2011). It was later revealed that one of the reasons for the explosion in the first place, was due to the contractor who built the oil rig wanting to cut costs. As a result of this, substandard concrete and other materials were used in construction of the rig. Additionally, due to cost cutting, many safety precautions were ignored, or severely reduced. Included in these, was the defect that allowed gas to rise up in the well and ignite, causing the explosion in the first place (Bureau, 2011). One of the main reasons for Enron’s bankruptcy was the use of special purpose entities to keep the debt underreported. They kept...

Words: 559 - Pages: 3


...Enron Jesus malverde BUS 500D September , 2011 unknown Enron Enron, a company that went from one of the top companies in the 1990s to taking a plunge straight to the bottom in the early 2000s. The greed and pride of Enron’s top executives is what ultimately made Enron file for bankruptcy. Enron established ethical codes, but never followed. Employees at Enron were given instructions to push boundaries, increase revenues, and make Enron look eminent (McLean & Elkind, 2005). Establishing the mark-to-the-market accounting method was the beginning of Enron’s downfall. Then they started to lose control of their corporate governance, forgetting about the rules that they had put in place. They began to alter their financial statements to make it look as if they were being profitable when in reality they were slowly going more in debt. Unethical behavior runs many companies into the ground, Enron was one of the biggest companies uncovered. The Reason Enron began its downfall when Jeff Skilling decided to implement the Mark-to-the-Market accounting practice. The Mark-to-the-Market accounting practice is generally only used by companies who sell securities, not those focusing on projects (McLean & Elkind, 2005). This practice allowed Enron to add revenue when their projects were complete. They could add revenue by what they believed their profits were going to be in the future. If the plant were to last 20 years and expected to make $1 million per year they could add the...

Words: 882 - Pages: 4

Just War Theory Applied to Pearl Harbor

...Aquinas’s just war theory can be applied to modern armed conflicts today. Using the attack on Pearl Harbor as an example you can still apply these ancient ideas to provide a useful way to look at events. The just war theory states three rules for a just war. First, a proper authority must command the war. Those in authority are supposed to protect the people. It is lawful for them to use weapons or force to keep peace and order inside their city/country and to punish people who break the laws and do evil. In the same way, those in authority are responsible for defending the community against external enemies, and can therefore use force against enemies. Second, there must be a just cause for the war. “… Those who are attacked, should be attacked because they deserve it on account of some fault.” Third, those fighting must “have a rightful intention, so that they intend the advancement of good, or the avoidance of evil.” The first rule is clearly the most important rule; it sets the tone for everything that follows. A state may launch a war only for the right reason. A just cause most frequently mentioned includes self-defense from external attack. Thus far, Pearl Harbor could be considered a just war because the United States declared a state of war with Japan after they were “suddenly and deliberately attacked by naval and air forces of the Empire of Japan.” as stated by President Franklin Roosevelt in his “Day of Infamy Speech”. However, we must remember how morally...

Words: 794 - Pages: 4

Ethical Theories Applied to Enron

... prescriptive because the evaluative norms are used to guide whether individuals should perform or avoid an act. To apply the theory, there must be general agreement in a society as to the nature of the evaluative norms. The theory also suggests that the ethics of each situation should be determined according to the specific circumstances without reference to an absolute legalistic or moralistic standard. One consequentialist approach is utilitarianism, which examines an act on the basis of the resulting good or harm with the well-being or happiness as the consequence relevant to the evaluative norms. The utilitarian prescriptive approach considers an act ethical if it results in the greatest improvement to well-being or happiness for the greatest number of individuals. Consequentialist theory, however, suggests that the evaluative norms may be relevant to social or cultural factors (Scheffler, 1994) When the consequentialist theory is applied to the Enron situation, it suggests that the actions of the managers and the auditors of the firm were unethical because they produced a possibly good outcome for a small number of people and harm for a larger number of people. The managers of Enron established private partnerships that were nominally intended to provide goods and services to the firm such as purchasing wholesale power and reselling it to Enron. The managers initially directed Enron’s purchasing towards these entities without competitive bidding, which resulted in......

Words: 1705 - Pages: 7

Deontological Ethical Theory

...Deontological Ethical Theory Deontological derives the word 'Deon' from Greek and the word means duty or obligation. Deontological belongs to the normative position of ethics as it judges an action's morality basing the judgment on action to these rules. A deontology is in one sense basically a theory of our duties just like the rest of the other theories of ethics. Scholars have frequently contrasted this theory to Consequentialism. Immanuel Kant based Kantianism on deontology as he argued that in order to act morally, individuals should act from duty. Individual's should not pull the plug when their lives are endangered as deontology will judge the morality of such decisions based on the rule's actions. The application of deontology is better brought out by the absolute deontologists who support the belief that action are either right or wrong; pulling the plug is therefore either right or wrong, no in-betweens. The best way to view this act is to focus neither on the intentions nor consequences of the act but rather the act itself. This is what absolute deontologists uphold. The first step of the analysis is to determine what pulling the plug entails. When one ends the life of another it is considered as murder. If they end the life of many it is manslaughter. If an individual ends their lives then they are considered to have committed suicide. If they try to commit suicide and they fail they are said to have attempted suicide and are in a retribution state tried in...

Words: 741 - Pages: 3

Enron Ethical Issue

...September 22, 2014 Ethical Meltdown This case describes one of the biggest corporate collapses due to unethical practices in the history of the United States. Before the ethical meltdown, Enron was the world’s largest wholesaler of natural gas and electricity. In a competitive market, companies are constantly struggling to improve their services or products in order to gain a competitive advantage. The pressure to succeed sometimes allows for companies to forget their morals and participate in unethical practices. “It turned out that the lack of accounting transparency enabled the company’s managers to make Enron’s financial performance look much better than it actually was” (Dessler, 2013, p. 242). As a result, several top executives were convicted of manipulating Enron’s profit statements and investors lost most of their investments in Enron. This is a perfect example of a company that lacks professional ethics and proper management. Enron was able to succeed and become a huge corporation in the United States economy. However, the loss of morality and ethics eventually led to the collapse of the corporation. In order for a company to become successful and maintain their success a proper ethical culture is needed within the organization. Enron’s Ethical Culture Dessler describes ethics as, “the principles of conduct governing an individual or a group and specifically to the standards you use to decide what your conduct should be” (2013, 240). In order for a company...

Words: 1074 - Pages: 5

Enron: What Caused the Ethical Collapse

...Case 1 ENRON: WHAT CAUSED THE ETHICAL COLLAPSE? case summary | Kenneth Lay, former chairman and chief executive officer (CEO) of Enron Corp., claimed to be a moral and ethical leader and exhorted Enron’s officers and employees to be highly ethical in their decisions and actions. In addition, the Enron Code of Ethics specified that “An employee shall not conduct himself or herself in a manner which directly or indirectly would be detrimental to the best interests of the Company or in a manner which would bring to the employee financial gain separately derived as a direct consequence of his or her employment with the Company.” Enron’s ethics code was based on the values of respect, integrity, communication, and excellence. Given this code of conduct and Ken Lay’s professed commitment to business ethics, one wonders how Enron could have collapsed so dramatically? The answer to this question seems to be rooted in a combination of the failure of top leadership, a corporate culture that supported unethical behavior, and the complicity of the investment banking community. The failure of Enron’s top leadership was evident in the activities of Andrew Fastow, Jeff Skilling, and Ken Lay, all of whom faced multiple counts of criminal activity with respect to their decisions and actions at Enron. Included among these criminal charges were money laundering, wire fraud, securities fraud, conspiracy, making false statements on financial reports, and insider trading. Some of the...

Words: 3147 - Pages: 13

Ethical Theories Applied to Euthanasia

...Ethical Theories Applied to Euthanasia It is a patient’s right to make the decision to end their life when they are facing a terminal illness, especially after all attempts to provide pain management have failed. However, these patients are left with few options due to the legal, moral, or religious complications of voluntary euthanasia or physician-assisted suicide (PAS). But, if terminally ill patients had these options available, they would be given the respect to die with the dignity they are entitled to at the end of their life. By applying the utilitarian theory to this question, we would first have to ask, are we providing the greatest amount of happiness or more pain? From a utilitarian point of view, if allowing someone to die with dignity will promote more happiness for them, and those who will be affected by this act, then it is morally ethical. By applying virtue ethics, we would have to ask, whether it is more charitable to continue with pain management until their death, or to relieve their unnecessary pain and suffering by voluntary euthanasia or PAS. Regardless of the moral theories applied, legalizing voluntary euthanasia or PAS, will grant more options, to include reducing the amount of suffering experienced, eliminate the patient’s use of other means to end his or her life, and allow for families to prepare for their loved one’s passing, all of which keeps the patient’s dignity intact. Utilitarianism looks at the best action producing the best...

Words: 2304 - Pages: 10

Ethical Theory

...Applying an Ethical Theory Moral or Ethical dilemmas are an everyday occurrence in our society. The situations present two options as solutions from which one is expected to choose. There is an expectation though that one will choose the option that is considered moral. Ethical questions or problems face every human being at some point in life. One such moral question is; “is it right for women to have abortions”. Abortion has been a major cause of controversy all around the world, with people having different views on whether abortion is good or bad based on their moral beliefs. The main issue that surrounds this ethical dilemma is whether the fetus should have rights to life. Another issue is whether there is justification for a woman to perform abortion based on the rights to her body considering the fetus also has rights to life (Tännsjö, 2008). The deontological theory is not in support of abortion; the objection though, is that women also have rights over their bodies. Discussion Deontological ethics is a moral theory that is in line with common sense intuitions, the scriptures, and natural moral duties or rules. The theory mainly focuses on compliance with moral duties or rules. The main principles of the theory include a task should be carried out for the sake of the obligation. For instance, there is a duty not to do certain things such as murder, lie or break promises since these acts are considered to be wrong. The expected consequences define what the duty...

Words: 891 - Pages: 4

Created Theory: Ethical Bottom Line

...Created Theory: Ethical Bottom Line Introduction The Ethical Bottom Line Theory is developed on the bases of the case study and CSR theories and the traditional concept of accounting system. In traditional business accounting and common usage, the "bottom line” refers to either the “profit” or “loss”, which is usually recorded at the very bottom line on a statement of revenue and expenses. The Triple Bottom Line was coined by Elkington (1994) to introduce the full cost accounting method. For example if a corporation shows a profit but their production pollutes the river, and the government ends up spending taxpayers’ money for rehabilitation programs. So the Triple Bottom Line was coined to address the issue. The triple bottom line incorporates the notion of sustainability into business decisions. The TBL is an accounting framework with three dimensions: social, environmental (or ecological) and financial. The TBL dimensions are also commonly called the three Ps: people, planet and profit and are referred to as the "three pillars of sustainability". Interest in triple bottom line accounting has been growing in both for-profit, nonprofit and government sectors. Many organizations have adopted the TBL framework to evaluate their performance in a broader context (Elkington, 1994) Ethical Bottom Line theory condenses the Triple Bottom Line of Elkington (1994) framework and integrates the Stakeholder Theory. Brief Description of the Theory The theory...

Words: 437 - Pages: 2


...------------------------------------------------- ENRON SCANDAL Enron’s Accounting Methods April 30, 2015 Acct 301-d02 LUO [Company address] April 30, 2015 Acct 301-d02 LUO [Company address] Melissa Vest Liberty University I. Introduction: Enron used many legal accounting practices to commit fraudulent accounting activities II. The genius, or ingenious, accounting methods Enron used: 1. Special purpose entities a. Synthetic leases b. FAS 140’s 2. Hedges 3. Share trust transactions 4. Minority interests 5. Prepays 6. Mark-to-market 7. Stock Games III. Conclusion: The beginning of the end Enron Scandal I have always tried to do the right thing, but where there was once great pride, now it’s gone. —From the suicide note of JOHN CLIFFORD BAXTER, Enron’s former vice chairman I. Enron used many legal accounting practices to commit fraudulent accounting activities: Enron was on the road to success when only a couple bad decisions were made that seemed to cause a panic that had them hiding and covering until the hole was too deep for them to climb out of. Was it optimism or cynicism that got Enron into the mess that ultimately destroyed it? II. The genius, or ingenious, accounting methods Enron used: “Enron executives applied for – and were subsequently granted – government deregulation. As a result of this declaration of deregulation, Enron executives were permitted to maintain agency over the...

Words: 1644 - Pages: 7

Applied Learning Theory

... have been revised recently to create, evaluate, analyze, apply, understand, and remember. These are the strides that our mind takes with a specific end goal to effectively learn and hold data. It is higher thinking skills and it combined with the social learning theory. Situated cognition theories expresses that learning is done in a situation where individuals are to face a few issues and difficulties. One of the conceivable courses through which learning and arranged comprehension can be upgraded is with the assistance of expansion engagement inside of a group. Fundamentally in arranged cognizance their untruths shared relationship of both the substance and setting, of environment and the individual (Cobb, 1999). Social learning theory is where people learn by observing others (Lieberman, 2012). Emotional Intelligence says that people have a preferred was of learning. This is only a couple of theories but there is so many more it is up to the person doing the teaching to figure out what will work best for their group of students and don’t be afraid to use more than one theory. Several strategies that could be applied in training to help ensure learning is taking place could be but is not limited to things like reward, positive reinforcement strengthens a behavior by providing a consequence an individual finds rewarding. Instructors can use scaffolding this is alludes to a procedure in which educators display or exhibit how to take care of an issue, and afterward...

Words: 1279 - Pages: 6


.... Corporations are composed of cultures. In Enron’s culture, employees rewarded for succeeding at any cost. By using the organization’s appraisal system, known as ‘rank and yank’, Enron had forces its employees to battle each other in order to survive. Instead of assess value and contribution, this system encourages the increases in employee’s unwillingness to report misconduct, the reduction of team-work or helping peers and generally self-centered and self-serving actions. As a result, problems were covered up rather than being communicated to management. With the overwhelming aura of pride, the senior executives believed Enron would always be the best and its people will handle the risk without danger. There was a banner in Enron’s lobby proclaimed, “the world leading Company.” This pride let them down. When their business starts performing poorly, they tried to cover up their own failure in order to protect their reputations and their compensation as the most successful executives in the U.S. The culture also encourages inflation. Senior management cared more about self-enrichment than the needs of employees. The employees tend to view themselves as individuals, focus upon their own needs and without putting extra effort on behalf of the overall company business. The culture was all about how much money could be made for many executive through the stock option incentive program. Finally, the culture makes it hard for creating an ethical environment and fraud is almost...

Words: 2137 - Pages: 9

Ethical Theory Development

..., no one is born as an ethical being. Understanding ethics and making ethical decisions takes years of education, understanding, and practice to be done effectively. Fortunately the past couple generations of educators and educational administrators had the foresight to project the importance of ethical decision making on the success of leaders and the organizations they lead. There are many different schools of ethical thought that span several centuries. It is outside the scope of this paper to address all of the available literature available on the many different ethical theories. Therefore, this student has chosen to examine the concepts of virtue ethics, consequentialist ethics, and ethical egoism. These ethical concepts provide an adequate introduction to three of the main schools of ethical philosophy and have helped this student advance his understanding of ethical theory development. Chapter two provides a literature review of the concept of corporate social responsibility (CSR). CSR, often referred to as business ethics, is chosen by this student to be introduced in this paper because of the scrutiny business leaders operate under in the 21st century. Giacalone and Thompson (2006) explain that contemporary business educators have a responsibility to, “Help students become more socially responsible and ethically sensitive as we prepare a new generation of business practitioners. We face a difficult struggle as less responsible individuals and businesses......

Words: 19601 - Pages: 79