Free Essay

Ethics and Legal Issues in Mergers

In: Business and Management

Submitted By sdpolk1
Words 1264
Pages 6
Ethical and Legal Issues
Merger of Company A & Company B
Human Resources Management
&
Talent Development
07-04-13

Abstract
In any merger, there are always legal and ethical issues involved. These issues have to be resolved in order to ensure a successful merger. It is the role of Human Resource personnel to ensure the code of ethics is used in legal and moral implications. The role of the Human resource manager is to create an ethical environment in which all employees are able to enjoy there inalienable rights. These rights will include the accessibility of information about the job, company, and there career and the right not to be coerced into situations. Maintaining these rights will help in reducing stress, establishing trust, increasing productivity and efficiency. This report will document the legal and ethical issues associated with a merger. It will also consist of a detailed implementation plan in resolving these potential ethical and legal issues. A plan for establishing an ethical work environment and resolving ethical and legal issues will be discussed as well.
Identify Specific Legal and Ethical Issues involved in Mergers Recently the mergers and acquisitions of firms has become a major trend in business. In the process of mergers and acquisitions, the role of ethics and compliance has become a major step in ensuring success. A breakout session was held just recently on ethics and compliance in mergers and acquisitions. The panel, which featured Seth Bruckner, compliance officer with United Parcel Service, and Martin de Grijp, group vice president and group integrity processes and training officer, ABB Group, discussed how companies need to expand their culture of ethics to the acquisition company, maintain ethical continuity during mergers, implementing your compliance and ethics following integration within a timely manner and more (McCoy, 2013). There are many ethical and legal issues involved in the process of mergers and acquisitions. Some issues that have been discussed recently are the ethical propriety, tactics, anti-trust issues, rights of bondholders of both merging companies, and the rights of individual stockholders neglected in an institutional shareholder power. However, two important issues have not surfaced as questionable practices deriving from mergers and takeovers, one having to do with the rights of employees in mergers and the second concerning the responsibilities of shareholders during these activities (Werhane, 1998). The rights of employees in mergers is the primary ethical issue that is violated during mergers. Employees are supposed to continue to their day-to-day job operations before, during and after the merger as if no changes are taking place. It is here where many ethical issues begin to develop. Management expects employees to continue to work and produce as if nothing is happening. This becomes a difficult task when rumors swirl around about the threats of their job and management decisions. Although employees are drastically affected by a merger or an acquisition because in almost every case a number of jobs are shifted or even eliminated after a merger, in fact except for top management, employees at all levels are usually the last to find out about a merger transaction (Werhane, 1998). This non-communication is unethical and prevents employees from knowing about their jobs and careers. Second, mergers of two firms are said to be beneficial to the shareholders of these respected companies. This indeed is the primary function of a merger, however; the roles of shareholders has gone unrecognized. It seems the role, responsibilities are undefined, and it leaves shareholders clueless as how to act under mergers. The role of stakeholders can be critical due to the merger being a friendly transaction or hostile takeover. In a hostile takeover environment, disputes between roles and responsibilities of stakeholders can generate proxy fights. Another is that HR has to deal with is the culture of two companies. The ethical practices of these two firms are different causing HR to create an ethical environment that is universal. There are ethical issues that can affect a merger. There will be legal matters to be addressed related to structuring the transaction and the transaction documents, establishing the terms of the transaction, negotiating arrangements ancillary to the transaction such as employment, licensing and other ongoing relationships, conducting the due diligence, and negotiating post-closing obligations such as indemnification, confidentiality, non-compete and non-solicitation obligations (“Legal”, 2009). Other legal issues include dissolving of assets, consolidations, and tax-reporting issues are all legal issues that must be taken into account. From a tax-purpose perspective, the structure of a merger is important in order to ensure tax consequences that are most beneficial for a firm. The fair value of assets and liabilities of the business acquired must be determined for financial accounting records. These issues and factors have to be considered before, during, and after a merger.
Implementation Plan for Managing Issues, establishing an ethical environment, and resolution
The first step is to develop a HR plan that will document and support the entire merging process of the two firms. This plan will define the task to be accomplished and will prioritize the importance of each step. This HR project plan will cover all topics such as planning, financial, legal, ethics and compliance issues. This project plan will consist of focus teams for each one of the aforementioned topics. They will gather information on all aspects affecting employees, management, upper management, and the public. These focus groups will come together to determine the best practices to ensure the success of the merger. The second step is a review known as the HR due diligence that will be used to help ensure that merging companies identify any missing liabilities. This review would help firms to review all decisions and ensure the feasibility of the merger. This review could be used to help in identifying areas of weakness that will require immediate attention. This due diligence review process would consist of teams from different departments such as finance, HR, legal, ethics and compliance department. The benefits of using the due diligence review will help in organizational structure, industrial relations, employee compensation and pending employee litigations. The incorporation of this project plan and due diligence review is to establish procedures, goals, and a positive culture based on the ethics and morality of the new firm’s culture. This plan would help create an ethical work environment by its ability to incorporate the diverse departments into one unified plan and goal. The plan is created to integrate all phases and departments to interact together to establish unity in the decision-making process. This plan will be the foundation for managers to use to implement an ethical work environment. This plan will help in resolving ethical and legal issues by identifying the issues before the merger begins. Once identified, the committee will set forth to establish methods in resolving these issues before the merger. Preventative maintenance is the best practice in resolving issues, however; some issues cannot be resolved until it occurs. The plan would create steps for dealing with these future issues. By creating this plan, we hope to eliminate as much risk in ethics and legal as possible.

References
Legal and Financial Issues in Mergers and Acquisitions. (2009). Retrieved from http://floridaphotonicscluster.blogspot.com/2009/10/legal-financial-issues-in-mergers-and.html.
McCoy, Jeff. (2013). Ethics and Compliance in Mergers and Acquisitions. Retrieved from http://www.legalcurrent.com/ethics-and-compliance-in-mergers-and-acquisitions/.
Werhane, Patricia. (1988). Two Ethical Issues in Mergers and Acquisitions. Journal of Business Ethics. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/25071723?uid=3739616&uid=21.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Addressing Legal and Ethic Issues

...Addressing international legal and ethic issues simulation summary Ann Tracy Law/421 8/6/2012 Boni Cherelle Some of the legal disputes in international transactions with Cad Max and Gentura the different laws, because laws are different from state to state and country to country. If you are in one part of the country and deal with someone outside the country there are so many legal issues that both parties need to get lawyers involved to make sure that everyone is getting there fair deal in this. What is legal in one part of the world or country is not necessary legal in the other part u are dealing with. When conserving to take legal actions against a foreign business partner that’s based in another country it is very important to remeber about their customers and their local cultures. They also have to follow their laws as they would if they have to follow ours if they came over here if we brake a rule or a law there than we would have to get punished for it the same way they would get punished if they broke any of our rules and laws. One factor is that Gentura in its financial best interest could violate their non-disclosure agreement then this could lead to someone to potentially sell Cad Max information. That would be easy to sale to their competors to sale to the one that will pay the most for it. Since there is so much completion out there it would not take much for someone to find someone to get a hold of some kind of information...

Words: 674 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

International Legal and Ethical Issues

...International Legal and Ethical Issues LAW/421 December 18,2012 International Legal and Ethical Issues Our society is involved in a global economy that deals with many countries, cultures, business ethics, monetary differences, and government policies. International transactions are made daily through legal channels that are set up to provide a smooth transition between entities. Provisions of legal guidelines assist in providing the parties parameters of acceptable and unacceptable behavior and consequences in respect to legal disputes of transactions. International transactions may include joint ventures, contract negotiations, employee wage compensation, enforcement of corporate contracts, merger and acquisitions, complex litigation, taxes, securities, and many more corporate decisions. The complexity of International law is best served with counsel that is knowledgeable on international affairs, and government policies. Bilingual counsel in several languages is a great asset to the business team as this provides translation effectiveness for a fairer representation in legal matters. International law is a very different forum of law due to the fact it does not have a governing body or set of laws to follow. International law is negotiated between different countries and the policies and laws of each country to meet a satisfactory line of agreement between the two entities. International law encompasses a collection of agreements, treaties, charters, and......

Words: 715 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

International Legal and Ethics Issues in Business

...case with China. I believe prior to answering the question of foreign nation compliance, one should examine the reasons why an organization has entered into that foreign market. The primary objective is typically profits, a secondary could be expansion, an initiative to become a globally known brand and gain international market share. Once the fundamental question of “why” is answered, the remaining issues, such as foreign government policies, can be addressed as well. So should a company comply or defy? Proponents of both sides of the fence are up in arms and ready to debate their stance. Proponents argue loss of market share if a company decides to leave a potentially new market, especially an international market. And proponents of defying the compliance terms are citing moral and ethical beliefs which make it wrong to comply with a communist government (http://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/5246.html). So who is the victim and who is the winner? I think that both sides are equally at loss as well as gain. If a company decides to leave due to compliance issues, chances are their competitor will step in and dominate that market. It is often difficult for a company to enter into the market as a secondary and gain market share. Foreign investments are both risky and expensive to finance, organizations determined to gain market share should certainly comply with the rules and regulations of the foreign market in which they wish to do business in. On the other......

Words: 327 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Business Ethics & Legal Issues- Antitrust Laws

...current users of the drug. What types of legal barriers to market entry exist? Research and development (patents--both as patent creation and then patent prosecution and protection) Costs Marketing streams (such as agreements with doctors, pharmacies, and hospitals to promote or utilize the drugs, and then making sure that the doctors legally and properly utilize the drugs) Significant legal barrier What are the possible ethical dilemmas present in this example? There are possible issues here with trade agreements, which are illegal under the Sherman AntiTrust Act. Also, there is an issue with costs--since companies are directly refusing to compete, the buyers lose out and as such an unfair agreement has taken place.Dimitry Alexander Kaplun40281.1716250347 Expert Type | Attorney | Category:  | Business Law | Pos. Feedback:  | 98.5 % | Accepts:  | 1005 | Answered:  | 4/13/2010 | Experience: Run my own successful business/contract law practice Ask this Expert a Question > Customer replied1177 days and 7 hours ago. Alexander Hi!!! Thank you for the answer. could you give me the reference you have used please!!! Thanks Expert:  Dimitry Esquire replied1177 days and 7 hours ago. Sure thing, I will list the references below: http://www.linfo.org/sherman.html (Sherman AntiTrust Act) http://www.lectlaw.com/files/ant07.htm (Predatory pricing) http://www.aapsj.org/view.asp?art=aapsj070372 (Patent issues) Good luck!Dimitry Alexander......

Words: 908 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Legal Issues of a Psychology

...over ethical issues, including issues of access and affordability, pressure to reduce costs, mergers and acquisitions, financial and other resource constraints, and advances in medical technology that complicate decision making near the end of life. Healthcare executives have a responsibility to address the growing number of complex ethical dilemmas they are facing, but they cannot and should not make such decisions alone or without a sound decision-making framework. Healthcare organizations should have mechanisms that may include ethics committees, ethics consultation services, and written policies, procedures and guidelines to assist them with the ethics decision-making process. With these organizational mechanisms and guidelines in place, conflicting interests involving patients, families, caregivers, the organization, payors and the community can be thoughtfully and appropriately reviewed. It is incumbent upon healthcare executives to lead in a manner that sets an ethical tone for their organizations. The American College of Healthcare Executives (ACHE) believes that education in ethics is an important step in a healthcare executive’s lifelong commitment to high ethical conduct, both personally and professionally. Further, ACHE supports the development of organizational mechanisms that enable healthcare executives to appropriately and expeditiously address ethical conflicts. Whereas physicians, nurses and other caregivers may primarily address ethical issues on a......

Words: 918 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Legal Ethics and Issues

...Legal Ethics & Issues Assignment Melchar Polk LAW/421 September 30, 2013 Professor Michael Carrozzo To be successful in conducting international business transaction it is imperative to have a real good written contract. Generally, contracts are the most common method that is being utilized by any type of businesses. When conducting a business transaction internationally, the contract clause must be very precise. It is extremely significant not only to spell out the rights of each party, their duties and responsibilities, but more importantly what process to be followed in case of a dispute. Some examples of dispute resolution clause are, what law governing the contract and dispute; what procedure to be followed; what method of resolution like arbitration or litigation - for arbitration, the complete process including constitution of the tribunal, applicable procedure, venue and language, and for litigation, the jurisdiction of the courts. It was mention in our simulation that it is a must to ensure the contract, which forms the basis of the agreement, is legally enforceable. The contract drafted must protect the company’s interest in the foreign country against all eventualities. Besides the legal aspects of international business, it is also important to consider the cultural and ethical differences inherent in such business transactions. CadMex should put into a consideration that, once you've licensed your asset, unless the contract specifies......

Words: 545 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethical and Legal Issues

...Ethical and Legal Issues HR ethics are important to organizations as they can have legal and moral implications. In this assignment, you will develop a plan to resolve some of the ethical and legal issues involved in a merger. Use the Argosy University online library and textbooks to read about ethical and legal issues.   Consider the following scenario: As part of the employment contracts, employees have certain rights. For example, employees have the right to not be coerced into situations against their will. They expect to be able to access the information, which affects their job, company, and career. Such work situations can increase stress, lower self-esteem and productivity, cause loss of trust, and decrease efficiency. Good employees who are looking for a more secure work environment may resign and take valuable tacit knowledge and talent with them. It is the responsibility of HR management to create an ethical work environment before, during, and after the merger. Instructions:   As a strategic HR Director, you have been asked to identify ethical and legal issues involved in a merger and develop a plan to resolve these issues. Your plan should address the following:   * Identify specific legal and ethical issues that should be considered before, during, and after the merger. * Develop an implementation plan for managing the potential legal and ethical concerns for the merger. * Explain how the proposed plan would help managers establish an......

Words: 293 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Legal Ethic

...History of Ethics: 1908 – Canon of Ethics 1969-70 Model Code 3 parts: 1. ethical considerations → what lawyers should do. 2. disciplinary rules → what lawyers must do. good 3. BAR _______________ acceptable set minimum conduct bad 1983 – Model Rules – most states follow. Set forth rules & comments akin to DR (set forth minimum conduct acceptable) 2000 – Ethics 2000 Commission ▪ California Rules of Professional Conduct – the only state to reject the ABA’s model rules or code. ▪ Ethics are governed by the highest court in the profession, not the legislature ▪ Vast majority of states, state bars (looking to ABA rules, not CA though) come up with the rules. 1. Licensing and Bar Admissions ▪ Regulated by the states. Most jurisdictions have chosen to test as a means of acceptance to the bar. ▪ Residency Requirement: 1. Out of State Residents - May the state discriminate against who gets into the BAR on the basis of residency? No. Supreme Ct v. Piper – woman applied to NH bar, lives 400 yards from NH border & application denied. Piper was admitted despite the state’s claims that non-residents were less likely to be familiar w/ local rules, lawyers not living in NH can’t be trusted, and out of state lawyers are less available for in state proceedings. Rule: State bar cannot discriminate on the basis of residency. 2. Geographical Restriction – some states permit waiver of the bar exam – ex: if...

Words: 17547 - Pages: 71

Premium Essay

Ehtical Issues in Mergers

...Ethical Issues in Mergers and Acquisitions MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS-AN OVERVIEW: The phrase mergers and acquisitions (M&A) refers to the aspect of corporate strategy, corporate finance and management dealing with the buying, selling and combining of different companies that can aid, finance, or help a growing company (in a given industry) grow rapidly without having to create another business entity. In legal terminology, mergers and acquisitions can be defined as follows: • Merger: A full joining together of two previously separate corporations. A true merger in the legal sense occurs when both businesses dissolve and fold their assets and liabilities into a newly created third entity. This entails the creation of a new corporation. • Acquisition: Taking possession of another business, also called a takeover or buyout. It may be share purchase (the buyer buys the shares of the target company from the shareholders of the target company. The buyer will take on the company with all its assets and liabilities. ) or asset purchase (buyer buys the assets of the target company from the target company). Although they are often uttered in the same breath and used as though they were synonymous, the terms merger and acquisition mean slightly different things. A purchase deal will also be called a merger when both CEOs agree that joining together is in the best interest of both of their companies. But when the deal is unfriendly - that is, when the target company does not......

Words: 1214 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business Ethics and Legal Issues

...Business Ethics and Legal Issues Name: Course: Tutor: Date: Abstract Antitrust laws are the legislations by state governments aimed regulating the way in which trade and commerce is carried out. This is possible through the prevention of illegitimate price-fixing and monopolies and facilitating fair completion. The net effect that is felt by the consumer is the production of high quality goods and services at prices that are affordable to all. Additionally, the public welfare and interest are well protected because it ensures that their demand is met by the firms who are engaged in the sale of goods and services. This is achieved by the provision of an ample environment for businesses to experience fair competition resulting in good business practices in all industries in the United States. This is achieved by cultivating the culture and the belief that the economy, the manufacturers, and consumers should mutually benefit from the effects of free and fair trading (Mankiw, 2008, p. 7). In its bid to create fair business environment antitrust laws mostly try to minimize cases of monopolization by various firms which may intend to create it through any possible merging. When firms merge, they reduce the competition within themselves and the net effect is that one company controls the whole industry and makes any decision regarding the prices of the products that it handles. This is where the antitrust laws come in place in order to protect......

Words: 1946 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Ethics and Legal Issues for Business Owners

...Saquoia Cox Professor Currie ACC647Z2 3 October 2015 Legal and Ethical Issues Business Owners Face Legal and ethical issues play a big part in the operation of a business for many owners. Business owners have to take into account many issues such as legal, regulations, safety, liability and brand of the company. Business owners must know their legal responsibilities and code of ethics, because they have to adhere to both when running a business. Many business owners face these issue everyday with changing regulations and laws, making sure that their reporting is ethical and up to standards. "Navigating all of the legislative and regulatory changes that occur throughout the course of the year can be challenging, taking business owners away from other important aspects of running their businesses," said Martin Mucci, Paychex president and CEO. Business owners have to follow state and federal labor laws which can be very taxing on business owners. Business owners have to monitor their tax reforms, because with the Tax Increase Prevention Act of 2014 the processing of taxes will affect the way that business owners have budgeted for their businesses. Business owners are also affected by new health reforms which state that “employers must be prepared to meet new IRS mandates to file annual information returns with the IRS and provide statements to their full-time employees about the health insurance coverage the employer offers” (Brooks, 2015) Business owners have to......

Words: 1687 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethics and Legal Issues in Mergers

...Assignment 3: Required Assignment 3 –Calculating Financial Ratios George L. Burga Prof. Leon Grove  Financial Management Argosy University October 03, 2015 * Download a company’s balance sheet and income statement from one of the many sites where financials are available, such as Zacks Investment Research or MarketWatch. * Choose five financial ratios, one from each of the five categories described in Chapter 3 of Brigham and Ehrhardt (i.e., liquidity, asset management, financial leverage, profitability, and market value) and look at them over a three-year period. Put your findings in a table with the years across the top (horizontal axis) and the ratios along the side (vertical axis). What do the findings tell you about the financial health of the company? How does your selected company compare to the industry? * Calculate each ratio using the information from the balance sheet and income statement. Balance Sheet | | | | | | | | Period Ending | 27-Sep-14 | 28-Sep-13 | 29-Sep-12 | | | | | Assets | | | | Current Assets | | | | | | | | Cash And Cash Equivalents | 13,844,000 | 14,259,000 | 10,746,000 | Short Term Investments | 11,233,000 | 26,287,000 | 18,383,000 | Net Receivables | 31,537,000 | 24,094,000 | 21,275,000 | Inventory | 2,111,000 | 1,764,000 | 791,000 | Other Current Assets | 9,806,000 | 6,882,000 | 6,458,000 | Total Current Assets | 68,531,000 | 73,286,000 | 57,653,000 | Long term......

Words: 1845 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Ethical and Legal Issues of a Merger

...Ethical and Legal Issues of a Merger Human Resource Management & Talent Development Ethical and Legal Issues Corporate mergers are pursued because there is a belief that if both independent companies are combined as one, the resulting company will grow more rapidly and will be stronger competitively. Management teams from both sides of these companies will no doubt encounter ethical and legal challenges prior to the merger, during the merger, and after the merger has been completed. HR acts as a moral compass for these companies, and issues that must be faced raise questions about fairness, equality, integrity, honesty, accountability, and consequences of behavior. As HR Director of the acquiring company, it is my responsibility to aid all employees in adhering to the code of ethics that has been implemented into our organizational mission statement. Furthermore, it is my job to create a safe and ethical environment in which every employee can enjoy his or her incontrovertible rights, which include the ability to access information about his or her job and the freedom to be able to do their job without any duress. HR can be a conflicting job for those of us in management, as we are called upon to walk a very narrow line between what is legally and morally best for the employee and financially advantageous to the company (Moore, 2014). However, the alternative of facing civil and criminal penalties that would incur due to law breaking, or even the implication of law...

Words: 3703 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Legal Issues

...Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues CadMex is a global pharmaceutical with over 85 years in the business. They are based in Tampa Florida. They have the ambitions to take their business to a country in South East Asia called Candore. The company the CadMex wants to business is called Gentura. They are well established biotechnology company. This company has over 25 years experienced into their business. This paper will highlight the many situations or challenges an organization faces while conduction business abroad. Other items that will be highlighted in this paper are: the issues involved in resolving legal disputes in international transactions. Also some practical considerations of taking legal action against a foreign business partner based in another country. Last, it will highlight how companies should resolve domestic and international issues differently. There are some issues that arise during resolving legal disputes in international transactions. The first issue to consider is the laws that govern the country. If the country is run by a borderline dictator such as President Arahi Gwendoz that took over Candore in a bloodless coup, the rule might be very difficult to understand. If there are no rules such the Constitution of the United States, there will be a lot of room for a variety of interpretations. Last, “International law has traditionally been defined in very broad terms and not limited...

Words: 1214 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Legal Ethics

...Running head: ETHICS AND THE LEGAL SYSTEM Ethical Practice of Law and its History Daphne Spann Kaplan University Intro. To Law Abstract The legal system has undergone many changes from its early start in the 19th century of the Canons of Professional Ethics to presently. The law has had to evolve due to the changes of climate in society to stay relevant and within the confines of the US Constitution. The one thing that has been debated and structured into a set of laws and guidelines under one main ruling organization of the American Bar Association is ETHICS. Ethical Practice of Law and its History The history of the establishment of legal ethics has evolved tremendously from the Canon of Ethics (Canons) to rules used today under the American Bar Association (ABA) Model Rules. The Canons are considered the cornerstone of modern of legal ethics and were used as a guideline for ethical conduct since prior to the 19th century there were no real rules regulating the conduct of lawyers. Ethics was based merely “perceptions” of what was considered ethical or drawn from other areas of law relevant to lawyers. The Canons were also considered vague in nature and seemed to focus on what attorneys should not do, while misaddressing the issues of what they should do. These early rules were viewed as a professional courtesy and carried no professional weight. The Canons, however, were still believed to be the historical starting point for the distinct......

Words: 1501 - Pages: 7