Free Essay

Ethics of Genetic Screening

In: Science

Submitted By nmoy93
Words 958
Pages 4
Nicolas Moy
Dr. Sheila Abraham
BIOL 2633 01
March 2, 2012

DVD Project “Who’s Afraid of Designer Babies? The Ethics of Genetic Screening”

An Australian family with a son diagnosed with a rare disease called “Hyper IGM” which essentially is a congenital condition in which a person is born with a vital piece of his/her immune system missing requiring that they receive constant blood transfusions.
In this case, the couple goes through a PGD procedure making another child with no disease to cure the oldest child. This procedure of PGD to identify a unimpaired embryo

Summary
Leanne and Stephen, the Australian couple are in desperate search for a cure to treat their son, BJ’ fatal disease in which doctors determined that the medical name of BJ’s disease is called “Hyper IGM” which is a rare disease, actually, so rare that 2 out of every million children born are diagnosed with this condition. Using PGD (Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis), doctors who specialize in assisted reproduction helped Leanne and Stephen in the journey to find a solution to their child’s issue. The plan would be to essentially create a “extra-parts baby” by testing for a disease-free and HLA matching embryo. If successful, this would procedure would use the blood tissue from the newborn to cure BJ.
Of course, once this case hit the public ethical debates arise. One very predominant argument was whether by allowing this couple to proceed with this procedure for therapy, this could potentially open doors to allowing the average everyday couple to create a “Designer Baby.”
However, despite the accusations. Leanne and Stephen decided to proceed with the PDG assignment and allow the doctors to take multiple eggs from Leanne and a scemen sample from Stephen to fertilize the eggs into embryos through an in vitro environment for future biopsy testing. Unfortunately, most of these embryos failed and died during fertilization due to instability leaving only four embryos to successfully be fertilized for testing.
These results was not the news Stephen and his wife had hoped for but speaking from their past experiences with more than 35 embryos failing to proceed through testing and a loss of hundreds of thousands of dollars, this outcome was better than nothing and gave the couple a little bit of hope for success for a cure for their beloved BJ.
Finally, after 6 days of waiting the doctors are finally able to determine the results. Early the morning of the sixth day, doctors found that two of the 4 remaining embryos had died leaving 2 available for final testing. This is the process of elimination with a lot of emotional stress associated for the couple to be under.
After a few more tests for HLA matching, the doctors finally found the cure to BJ’s Hyper IMG disease.
The doctor’s next step is to implant the assisted fertilized embryo back into Leanne’s uterus to proceed with the pregnancy by developing a fetus and eventually giving birth to a baby boy, who will at one point, deliver a cure for his older brother’s Hyper IMG diagnosis.
This brought great joy and relief to Leanne and Stephen, knowing their older son could now be cured of his fatal disease.
How the society (Australia and abroad) reacted to these cases of parents pursuing ARTs to have babies for different reasons? Gender selection? What about the costs involved? What is the success rate of these procedures? How many rounds of IVF did they go through and over how many years? What happened to the embryos created through this process?

Implications/Significance

For many years, embryonic research has been a major medical and ethical debate and has taken many different stands from many different viewpoints over the years as researchers learned more about how the early stages of human development takes place.
One might believe PGD to be a very innocent action to take, but it can lead to temptation to take procedures to the next level thus crossing those moral lines established by our medical and ethical foundations.
Many believe PGD to be a form of Eugenics or at least an action that could very well lead to Eugenics. In particular countries, this is true. And was once even approved by our very own, United States of America as a way of eradicating genetic defects in our society via isolation and prevention of reproduction to form a more fit race of humans with “perfect” genes.
This belief system was originally established in the 1920s by the Nazi-movement who influenced United States and many other counties to do the same.
So due to history’s track record of where Eugenics has taken mankind and the thousands of innocent individuals who were born with such unfortunate fate, today’s generation has every right to be cautious of the medical implications and possibilities followed through PDG procedures and the possibilities of creating newborns with flawless genes, also known as “Designer Babies,” altering the course that nature should take as originally designed by the Creator – to be a natural and random fertilization at conception with and/or without the defects included in the chromosome packaging.
Contrary to the negative arguments proposed by the opponents of PDG, many researchers and doctors have concluded that PDG could be used to benefit medicine in therapeutic uses such as BJ’s case where physicians are selecting specific embryos to treat for fatal disease.
Physicians have also concluded that PDG procedures can be used for enhancement in the human body, specifically pertaining to immunology and making the natural immune system more efficient as a whole, potentially slowing down the aging process and keeping the in-body alert system for viruses and disease at its peak potential for a longer period of time.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Nursing

...Ethics of Genetic Testing during Pregnancy Professor: Date: Recent advancement in technology has enhanced genetic disorder screening by clinicians for women during pregnancy. Information obtained through screening is used to prevent the diseases that are caused by these genetic disorders (DJ Tester, 2011). However, this information is not obtained directly but requires mastery of new genetic disorders and finding a solution to ethical dilemmas that may result from screening and testing. Ethics principles and theories provide the basics for solving any ethical problems that may arise during genetic testing (Dale Halsey Lea, Janet Williams, & M. Patricia Donahue, 2005). One for the theories that is recognized is Utilitarianism developed by John Stuart Mill and Jeremy Bentham. It mainly focuses on happiness associated from the consequences and differentiates the good from the bad (Peter Harper, 1997). The acts that are right are the ones that produce happiness to most people. It continues to insist that a good sometimes need to be sacrificed. For example, a baby that is born impairment would rather be killed than live as a burden. Another theory is Deontological theory developed by Immanuel Kant and differentiates the good from the bad and insists obedience to duty as the moral of rightness. A right action is one that is carried with good intentions and consequences do not matter. Respect is also highly emphasized in this approach and is interpreted...

Words: 689 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Genetics and Public Health

...Affiliation: Introduction Integration of genetics into public health is essential in predicting patient risk for common diseases. Genetic research creates new information and technology that will assist in improving population health. Most of the ailments arise from the interactions among the environmental factors, human factors as well as genetics. Public health genomics will assist in disease prevention and health improvement to individuals who are at a higher risk due to their genetic makeup (Khoury, 2000). Health professionals by applying genetic research are everyday coming up with new discoveries in areas like birth defects, heart diseases and cancer improving health services for the public (Brand A, 2006). However, there is no need to allocate significant resources on genomics for public health. Resources Spent On Genomics for Public Health Significant resources should not be allocated to genomics for public health. This is because genetic research is not necessary beneficial to all individuals. It mostly applies to specific persons due to their genetic makeup. Pubic health sector can prioritize by establishing which genetic research will be most beneficial to the population as a whole. The rest of the diseases are left out since their effects are not adverse. There is also the risk of possible misuse of genetic information (Laberge, 2004). Newborn genetic screening discovers treatable genetic disorders in newborn babies. Newborn screening for phenylketonuria is essential...

Words: 1112 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Pros And Cons Of Genetic Engineering

...Biotechnology Research Genetic Engineering • Description and How It Works Genetic Engineering is the process of manually adding new DNA to an organism. The goal is to add one or more new traits that are not already found in the organism, and to enhance or modify the organism’s characteristics. The process starts by identifying a gene that controls the desired trait and using various chemicals to extract it from the DNA strands. An insertion package is prepared that includes several unrelated genes that lets the trait gene survive in an alien organism. Then, the package is forced into the host organism’s cells which is attempted using several various vectors. The most common for plants is bacteria; the insertion package is hooked onto the bacteria’s...

Words: 1227 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ethical Health Care Issues

...human kind rather outward exploration of the planets. Clinical research involving human beings have greater potential for risk of misusing the technology. Potential for misusing the genetic research and fear of unknown long term effects on the successive generations have sparked bioethics debates. Like abortion, gene mapping is a very controversial subject and both sides have strong views. For example, should a woman abort the pregnancy based on the abnormal genetic screening results? Genetic technology provides an enormous power within our grips and with this enormous power comes following the ethical standards. Ethical standards should be followed involving human subjects. Genetic screening standards should align with four ethical principles of: • Respect for the human autonomy, dignity, and obtaining informed consent • Genetic screening should cause the minimal amount of harm to the subject • Provides maximum benefit to the subject • Genetic screening should be available to all the patients of a certain population considered high risk for a certain disease or condition Purpose of this paper is to discuss the correlation between genetic screening, four ethical principles, and possibility of integrating ethical principles into universal genetic screening standards. Discussing the gene screening is like...

Words: 1365 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Is Genetic Engineering Ethically Right?

...Is genetic engineering ethically right? Genetic engineering was first discovered in the 1970’s and since then ethical questions been raised regarding the process and results. Some people are excited by the possibilities of genetic engineering while others believe the process is unethical and should be banned as they claim scientists are ‘playing god’. Ethics is the philosophical study of what is morally right or wrong. It is a system of moral principles. They affect how people make decisions and lead their lives. Philosophers tend to divide ethical theories into three areas; meta-ethics, normative ethics and applied ethics. This was first done by David Hume the philosopher who argued how we should look at ethical situations. “Meta-ethics looks at the meaning of language used in ethics, and raises questions about truth. Normative ethics tries to find practical moral standards that we can all live our lives by. These are also called ethical theories. Applied ethics is the application of theories about whether something is right or wrong in specific issues.” Distance Learning Centre, Ethics Pack, 2012. In the 1960’s a professor, Joseph Fletcher founded the theory Situation Ethics. In Situation Ethics right and wrong depend on the situation. There are no universal moral rules or rights, each case is unique and deserves a unique solution. “Situation Ethics is all about agape or love. You should always do the most loving thing” Distance Learning Centre, Ethics Pack, 2012. There...

Words: 2519 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Social Issue

...central concepts are informed by moral opinions and, as a result, contested on ethical grounds. Taking this intergration of conceptual and ethical issues seriously from a research point of view requires that they are very strongly interconnected, i.e. mere studies of the way in which concepts are in fact informed by moral opinions and social values is not siffucient. Outright normative analyses of underlying ethical views need to underpin suggestions with regard to the way in which central concepts should be employed in policy contexts. This has been recognised in research on the basic ethical issue of what should be seen as the basic determinant of the quality of life or well-being (Brülde 1998, 2006), as well as research on applied ethics of relevance for disability (Brülde 2003; Munthe 1996, 1999; Juth 2005; Juth & Munthe 2006), and concepts such as happiness, health, illness, and mental disorder (Brülde 2000, 2006a, 2006b). Research on several of the conceptual issues has demonstrated how they are strongly connected to ethical problems related to health care policies and public health practices, in particular issues about what are the appropriate goals of medicine as a whole, or parts thereof, e.g. the goals of palliative care, psychotherapy, rehabilitation, or treatments of chronic illnesses. Normative theories about appropriate goals are necessary to come up with plausible grounds for diagnostic categories, outcome measures and policy guidelines in different areas...

Words: 2008 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

De Bate Topic

...interest and controversy over the years. Gender selection has been associated with a number of ethical, moral, social and legal issues. Sex selection may be performed for medical reasons to avoid sex-linked diseases or for parental preference. The topics I will be covering include eugenics, beneficence, utilitarianism and pre-genetic screening in regards to sex linked diseases. Eugenics can be defined as the study or belief in the possibility of improving the qualities of the human species. In the context of IVF, treatment positive eugenics encourages reproduction by implantation of healthy embryos with inheritable desirable traits and negative eugenics seeks to identify and dispose of embryos found to carry undesirable inheritable traits. Introduction: Utilitarianism in the context of IVF sex selection and genetic screening is defined by the principle of utility, which seeks to judge moral rules, actions and behaviors based on their consequences. Where an action produces the best possible outcome, that being the greatest good for the greatest number it is seen as ethical and moral. Therefore, the testing, screening and disposal of genetically impaired embryos and implantation of only healthy and preferred embryos is justifiable because the outcome is seen as beneficial for the majority. The ethical principle of beneficence means to do good or an action done to benefit others, and therefore act to maximize benefits and minimize harm. The...

Words: 2080 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Persuasive Essay On Genetic Testing

...Going to get tested for a genetic disorder? That’s so yesterday; thanks to modern scientific knowledge, direct to consumer (DTC) tests make going to a medical professional unnecessary for genetic testing. Medical professionals should not be required for all genetic testing, since the requirement of such professionals raises questions of ethics regarding abortion and eugenics, issues which restrict the rights of parents to make decisions that apply to themselves and/or their offspring. However, regulations on DTC genetic testing should be put into place to eliminate the consequences which result from the lack of knowledge regarding genetic disorders and testing held by patients. One disease capable of detection using genetic testing, Tay-Sachs...

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Flaws in Modern Eugenics

...those based in the field of genetics, one might wonder where humanity is headed in terms of their offspring. The answer? Modern eugenics. Francis Galton's eugenics, centered around forced sterilization and selective breeding to eliminate undesirable traits and foster the spread of more advantageous ones (Galton), is dead. However, the idea of focusing on one’s inherited genes to eliminate passed down diseases is alive and well, albeit in a more “modern” fashion. Is modern eugenics the right way of the future for humanity? To what extent should modern eugenics be viable? Before ambitious genetic projects had begun, such as the Human Genome Project which mapped out the entirety of the human genome (Genome.gov), the only way to tamper with an individual’s genes was through their parents. Gregor Mendel earned the moniker “The Father of Genetics” because of his experiments involving the breeding of plants in the mid 19th century (Biography.com). However, modern eugenics focuses on the genes of child more than the parents through abortions and the genetic altering of the embryo to achieve the desired results. This can be achieved through a process called genetic screening, which observes an embryo’s chromosomes for any lapses or breaks (Galloway a). Embryo’s that show signs of a genetic disorders, such as Down Hassan 2 Syndrome, SCID, or Sickle Cell Disease, are aborted in favor of an “unflawed” one. John Galloway, a writer for the Genetic Literacy Project, discusses...

Words: 1544 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Prenatal Genetic Testing and the Ethical Controversies

...PRENATAL GENETIC TESTING    Running Head:  PRENATAL GENETIC TESTING                          Prenatal Genetic Testing and The Ethical Controversies    SBI3U                    15 April 2015          1    PRENATAL GENETIC TESTING      2    Prenatal Genetic Testing and The Ethical Controversies    Introduction  Every introduction should start with a shocking fact about the topic, generally to piqué the  interest of the reader. The problem is, surrounding the topic of prenatal genetic testing, there isn’t  anything that is particularly shocking or interesting anymore. Anything that has a potential to injure a  ‘helpless’ fetus, the public has already been informed of and the information has already been  extremely exaggerated. The myth of prenatal genetic testing being dangerous has been greatly over  told, and is a rather old notion according to a great number of medical journals such as: United States  National Library (Gates, 2009), UConn (Pennington, 2011), and many others listed in the references  page. Prenatal genetic testing is the process of testing for potential genetic disorders or defects. Doctors  and geneticist can now test for over 4000 diseases that are caused or influenced by a fetus’ genetic  makeup. The tests can be invasive or non­invasive, and the risks associated with both categories of tests  have been greatly reduced since genetic testing was first introduced to modern medicine. Although the  ...

Words: 1905 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Genetic Testing

...E Poole Beecham English 101 10059 19 April 2010 Genetic Testing Imagine choosing your daughter to have high intelligence. No one would fault the parents for giving their daughter this advantage for life. Parents can make the decision to use any safe drug or therapy to enhance their future children to make them smarter, better, stronger, to increase their intelligence, height, or other traits (Zane). Testing for medical tendencies to screen and reduce the possibility of future illness or diseases is now feasible. Genetic testing can enhance and improve lives with immeasurable benefits. The rewards of this testing outweigh any reservations. Genetic testing are examinations of blood and other tissues of the body that doctors in the medical field prepare to test for possible defects of the body. These DNA based tests generally involves direct examination of the DNA molecule itself and are very sophisticated techniques of testing genetic disorders in the bodies of human beings. Prenatal genetic testing with the procedure of pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, or PGD is a technique whereby testing is performed of an approximate three-day-old embryo to confirm that it does not carry a particular disease or diseases (Naik). The test predicts, with variable confidence, what the possible medical problems will be in the future. Then the doctor implants this embryo, which is free of that syndrome, in the mother's womb. It appears to be relatively easy to check the DNA and eliminate...

Words: 2704 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Genetic Counseling in Nursing and Ethics

...GENETIC COUNSELING IN NURSING AND ETHICS Hyang Ko Azusa Pacific University Abstract The current development of genetic information and technique leaves us assignments. It is included ethical issues, roles of nurses, and the responsibilities in healthcare professionals. In order to understand nurses’ role and responsibilities and to provide genetic counseling, two research article with text books were reviewed. There were conflicts within ethical principles and nurses’ obligation. Each principle is important but one principle is superior to others when healthcare professionals make a decision in a certain context. It is necessary that genetic counseling is provided to patients and their family when healthcare professionals deal with genetic information. The two research articles empathized that experienced nurses are excellent candidates in genetic counseling within healthcare professionals by being educated, trained about genetic information. Genetic Counseling in Nursing and Ethics Definitions of Genetics and Genetic Counseling Officially, the terms of Genetics and genetic counseling is defined by Wekipidia as below: Genetics, a discipline of biology, is the science of genes, heredity, and variation in living organisms (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetics). Genetic counseling is the process by which patients or relatives, at risk of an inherited disorder, are advised of the consequences and nature of the disorder, the probability of developing or transmitting...

Words: 2137 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

How Is Gattaca Related To Genetic Engineering

...society. It raises a moral question about whether the approach used for genetic engineering is ethically acceptable. In this society, an individual’s place in the society is determined by their genetic makeup and circumstances under which they get born. Invalids are people born through natural process while valids are individuals whose existence came about through the process of genetic engineering. Despite the advancements in the society, it is prudent to respect the natural laws of the existence of living things, including human beings, a concept that seems overrun by time in this movie....

Words: 566 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Physical Privacy; Stealing Employees Genetic Information

...“Inappropriate genetic testing can threaten individual autonomy, privacy, and confidentiality and lead to various types of genetic stigmatization and discrimination without any commensurate benefit for the individual tested,” (Brandt; Rauf, 2004). When Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway (BNSF) tested their employees without the employees knowing about it, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) stepped in and cited that BNSF violated the employee’s equal rights through discrimination and the employee’s rights of privacy. These actions “raise serious concerns that such testing could pose a significant threat to workers' privacy, autonomy, and dignity. Thus, defining the ethically, legally, and socially appropriate and inappropriate uses of genetic testing in the workplace,” (DEHS, 2001) presents a major breach in a workers legal right to privacy. One hundred and twenty-five BNSF employees filed on-the-job injury claims citing carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) for “years of repetitive activity such as wielding a wrench or operating a jackhammer,” (Lehrer, 2001; UNK, 2001). While investigating these claims, BNSF medical doctor required further testing of 20 employees (UNK, 2001). The medical company pulled blood for genetic testing without telling the BNSF employees what kind of test that they were performing, (Mahanna, 2001; Schafer, 2001; BNSF, 2002; Lehrer, 2001; Lewin, 2002). One employee refused to submit to the tests and BNSF threatened to terminate his job (Lewin;...

Words: 2875 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Fetal Alcohol Syndrome

...Genetic and Reproductive Sciences Abstract This paper is based on genetic and reproductive science and their benefits and limitations regarding individuals, families, and society. The paper covers the screening and treatment for diabetes and what methods are used to prevent it development. The paper also contains information regarding In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) and its benefits for individuals and families. The use stems cells and its advantages and disadvantages are also mentioned. Analyze the benefits and limitations of genetic and reproductive sciences for individuals, families, and society. The benefit of genetic science for individuals is that it can determine if the person has a possible genetic disorder and give them a better chance at preventing the disorder from becoming active, monitor the disorder, or treat the disorder. For example, diabetes is a genetic disorder that can be discovered through genetic testing. Lifestyle changes such as exercising and lowering their body mass index (BMI) can prevent someone for developing diabetes, and the testing can monitor diabetes if a person develops it. Diabetes can also be treated by the use of insulin and dieting if monitored correctly. The limitation of genetic science for individuals is the emotional outcome of the test results. Some people may get upset and begin to feel guilty, depressed, or even become anxious once they receive their results (Cho, et al., 2012). The benefits of genetic science...

Words: 1426 - Pages: 6