Free Essay

Euthanasia, Murder or a Blessing?

In: Social Issues

Submitted By blaine
Words 1246
Pages 5
Euthanasia has raised controversy in the United States because of different views on societal, cultural, and religious ethics. Euthanasia is the killing of a person to end either horrible pain, slow death, or even some coma victims that have been in a vegetative state of a considerable amount of time. Even though I believe that euthanasia is murder, it should not be looked down upon because death should be a right for the victims and their families. The other side of the argument claims that it is immoral to kill even those who are suffering because it is God's decision who lives and who dies. Both sides of this ongoing debate have some compelling arguments. In order to understand why I am defending an action that I admit is murder requires the use of an example. If a pregnant woman is murdered and had planned on keeping her baby the murderer would be charged on a count of murder and a count of manslaughter. Now in a different scenario, If that same woman was killed on the way to an abortion clinic it would only be a count for murder, because the life dwelling inside of her was unwanted. Women are legally allowed to choose whether or not a fetus lives. Therefore, why would we allow someone to suffer when they have declare no will to live. Euthanasia and assisted suicide go together hand-in-hand. The difference between the two is that with assisted suicide the patient is guided through the process of killing themselves, but with euthanasia the physicians take a direct course of action in the death, such as lethal injection or not providing necessary care or food for the patient. An argument for euthanasia is that it provides victims who are in extreme pain or mentally suffering a procedure that makes it end. Another argument can be made that euthanasia could save medical funds in order to provide care to other patients. Euthanasia is protected by the Bill of Rights with freedom of choice. The only state in the United States of America that legally allows assisted suicide is Oregon, and it is one of only three places in the world where euthanasia and assisted suicide is legal. Many states, such as Arizona, California, Hawaii, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Wisconsin are currently trying to pass bills that would allow assisted suicide to be legal in their states. This is California's sixth time advocating for assisted suicide. They have tried to have the bill passed since 1988, it is almost identical to the assisted suicide laws currently in effect in Oregon. The bill includes that all state facilities should refer to assisted suicide as "aid-in-dying". This is the same bill that was not passed in June 2006. There have been many legal cases wrestling with the concept of assisted suicide throughout the United States, such as WASHINGTON et al. v. GLUCKSBERG et al. This court case occurred when four doctors from Washington, who often work with terminally ill and dying patient, along with non-profit euthanasia advocate groups, filed a suit against the state of Washington. They stated that the ban of euthanasia is unconstitutional. They based their statement on the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause, which states that a mentally competent person has a right to choose assisted suicide over waiting to dye. The state law that banned assistant suicide was recalled because of its contradiction to the constitution. Just as there are the euthanasia advocates, there are the detractors of euthanasia that believe that it is giving the right to kill to doctors. Doctors and other medical care personnel take oaths to uphold the values of life. Allowing them to create death would devalue the oath of which they are supposed to uphold. Those who are "anti-euthanasia" believe that allowing euthanasia to continue will be the begging of a "slippery slope" in which euthanasia would be used more loosely. As of May 1, 2006 Dignitas, a swiss suicide practice, announced that they planned on opening a series of walk-in clinics for those trying to commit suicide. Doctor Ludwig Minelli, the founder of Dignitas believes that those attempting suicide should be told the best way to kill themselves. These clinics would not be limiting their patients to the dying or terminally ill, rather for those with mental conditions. Minelli states, "if they choose to die, they should be helped to do it properly." and that "We never say no". This man has devalued human life and should not be allowed to carry the title of doctor. He makes no attempts to help ease or cure those that want to dye, rather he tells them how to take their lives. As many others argue that most of the patients that opt for euthanasia are chronically depressed, I propose the argument that they are depressed because the patients know they have to suffer until the day that it will all end. Detractors of euthanasia also believe that euthanasia would lead healthcare costs and insurance to stop paying for services to keep patients comfortable, and would instead push euthanasia on all patients. The catholic church states that euthanasia is a “grave sin”, and that only God has the right to take ones life. Allowing euthanasia undermines the commitment of doctors and nurses oath to saving lives. Since euthanasia may become a cost-effective way to treat the terminally ill, the church believes it will discourage the search for new cures and treatments for the terminally ill. Euthanasia undermines the motivation to provide good care for the dying, and those in severe pain. Gen. 27:1-4 "When Isaac was old and his eyes were so weak that he could no longer see, he called for Esau his older son and said to him, "My son." "Here I am," he answered. 2 Isaac said, "I am now an old man and don't know the day of my death. 3 Now then, get your weapons—your quiver and bow—and go out to the open country to hunt some wild game for me. 4 Prepare me the kind of tasty food I like and bring it to me to eat, so that I may give you my blessing before I die."
Isaac was old and knew he was dying, but instead of asking his son to take his weapons and put him out of his misery, he asked him to prepare one last meal for him, showing an acceptance of death. As the Catechism of the Catholic Church states suicide is contrary to love for the living God. Euthanasia does have it's pro's and con's but as long as humans continue to suffer euthanasia is going to be a necessary evil protected by our constitution. If I was suffering from a terminally ill disease and was going to be stuck in a hospital for the next fours weeks of my life and then die, I would opt out for euthanasia. Why should man kind suffer when peace is already on its way. I believe that patients at times need death to be pushed up in order to avoid agonizing pain. Though I do believe in euthanasia of the dying, I do not agree with Doctor Ludwig Minelli in the killing of the mentally ill and depressed. Especially if they are not already dying, because they are not in a stable or sane state of mind to make a decision of that importance.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Euthanasia

...March 2010 Euthanasia Euthanasia, also mercy killing, is the practice of ending a life so as to release an individual from an incurable disease or intolerable suffering. Euthanasia is a merciful means to and end of long-term suffering. Euthanasia is a relatively new dilemma for the United States and has gained a bad reputation from negative media hype surrounding assisted suicides. Euthanasia has a purpose and should be evaluated as humanely filling a void created by our sometimes inhumane modern society. Some people think that euthanasia is not acceptable in our society because of a variety of reasons. Many who oppose of euthanasia fear that if it were to be legalized then many people would die needlessly and murders in so- called "mercy killings" would run rampant. Others believe that since we are the property of God then we should wait until He is ready to receive us. Many churches and religious groups oppose euthanasia stating that the sixth commandment "Thou Shalt Not Kill" also extends to euthanasia. During his February 1st 2010 Sunday blessing, Pope Benedict XVI said that euthanasia is a “false solution” to suffering and love can help confront pain. Many medical doctors also oppose euthanasia. They say that assisted suicide "violates one's will to survive" and that it violates our dignity. They believe that one of our natural Nagaro 2 human goals is to survive and if we practice euthanasia,......

Words: 587 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Funny How Some Things Can Seem so Small

..."Euthanasia means as an action which aims at taking the life of another at the latter's expressed request. It concerns an action of which death is the purpose and the result. "This definition applies only to voluntary euthanasia and excludes the non-voluntary or involuntary euthanasia, the killing of a patient without the patient's knowledge or consent. Some call this "life-terminating treatment." Euthanasia can be either active or passive. Passive euthanasia allows one to die by withholding or withdrawing life supporting means. This is a tricky area because ordinary and extraordinary means of supporting life come into the picture. Ordinary means such as nutrition and hydration are never to be withheld since they are one's basic right in order to survive. However, one is not obliged to use extraordinary or 'disproportionate' means to sustain life. Due to complexity, each situation needs to be looked at individually when discussing extraordinary means. However, as a rule, one can discontinue "medical procedures that are burdensome, dangerous, extraordinary, or disproportionate to the expected outcome." One cannot intend death by withdrawing or withholding treatment, but should, however, obey God and let one die a natural death. To withdraw a treatment as a condition worsens is letting one die and not a direct killing. In this case, it is the disease that is killing and not the one who withdraws the treatment. Active euthanasia or' mercy killing' pertains to the Dr.......

Words: 1119 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Euthanasia

..."Euthanasia means as an action which aims at taking the life of another at the latter's expressed request. It concerns an action of which death is the purpose and the result. "This definition applies only to voluntary euthanasia and excludes the non-voluntary or involuntary euthanasia, the killing of a patient without the patient's knowledge or consent. Some call this "life-terminating treatment." Euthanasia can be either active or passive. Passive euthanasia allows one to die by withholding or withdrawing life supporting means. This is a tricky area because ordinary and extraordinary means of supporting life come into the picture. Ordinary means such as nutrition and hydration are never to be withheld since they are one's basic right in order to survive. However, one is not obliged to use extraordinary or 'disproportionate' means to sustain life. Due to complexity, each situation needs to be looked at individually when discussing extraordinary means. However, as a rule, one can discontinue "medical procedures that are burdensome, dangerous, extraordinary, or disproportionate to the expected outcome." One cannot intend death by withdrawing or withholding treatment, but should, however, obey God and let one die a natural death. To withdraw a treatment as a condition worsens is letting one die and not a direct killing. In this case, it is the disease that is killing and not the one who withdraws the treatment. Active euthanasia or' mercy killing' pertains to the Dr.......

Words: 1119 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Death with Dignity

...Callie Yager Haley Stoner English 1302 22 April 2015 The Powerful Mercy of Euthanasia Euthanasia is defined as the merciful killing of one in extreme pain or circumstance. For many years euthanasia has been viewed as a way out, against religious and moral perspectives, and many are afraid that if it were to be completely legal in all of the United States then citizens would certainly abuse this right. However, the four states that have legalized it, Oregon, Vermont, Washington, and Montana prove these opinions to be false. Especially in Oregon the Death with Dignity Act set the precedent for Euthanasia legislature by setting limitations on who or who could not be considered to actively take their own life. These limitations included a minimum age of 18 years, a diagnoses of six months to live or less, two oral recommendations from physicians at least fifteen days apart and one written recommendation from a physician before the patient could be qualified for active Euthanasia. These guidelines made the practice of Euthanasia more practical to Americans. In a study conducted by Public Agenda, Gallup Organization, in the year 1950 only twenty-six percent of Americans supported assisted suicide and that number more than doubled in 2003 to seventy-two percent. These information alone proves the progressiveness of this form of mercy, this form of choice that euthanasia gives to those suffering. Euthanasia has many forms and is a positive act for those in extreme pain, it......

Words: 2667 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

A Humanistic Approach to Working with a Terminally Ill Patient

...by taking more time. Brenda then developed a sullen look on... View Full Essay Join Now Please login to view the full essay... Essay's Statistics Submitted by: blaine Date shared: 04/05/2008 07:00 PM Words: 981 Pages: 4 Save Paper Report this Essay Similar Documents Analyse And Critically Discuss The Nature And Purpose Of The Employment Relationship For Organizations And The Relationship Between Work Design, Planning, Pay And The Employment Relationship. Explain How Expectancy Theory; Reinforcement Theory An... Meningitis & Pneumonitis; Cases Presentation Person Centered Therapy How Important Is The Role Of The Editor Within The Editorial Motivation Scientific Management Medical Marijuana Euthanasia, Murder Or A Blessing? Team And Group Mr Hamada Hesen Major Forms Of Therapy Negotiation Groups And Teams Bereavement To Grief Its All A Process Delegation Paper Nursing Kant Ps Paper Methodological Approaches Using Relevant Theories And Examples Outline The Arguments For And Against An Organization Adopting An Ethical Approach To Management. Methodological Approaches Login Join RSS ©2011 TermPaperWarehouse.com Privacy Policy Terms of Service Copyright Information Contact Us Help...

Words: 530 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Abortion, an Act of Murder

...BRISTISH COLUMBIA BAPTIST COLLEGE ABORTION, AN ACT OF MURDER A PROJECT SUBMITTED TO PASTOR JUSTIN WAMSLEY IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE COURSE ENG 101 COLLEGE WRITING BY MARIA KRISTIANNE PAGALUNAN SURREY, BRITISH COLUMBIA 10 DECEMBER 2014 THE OUTLINE I. Thesis Statement Abortionists are guilty of taking the life of an innocent, unborn baby prematurely; completely disobeying the commandment of the Lord. II. Main Idea #1 Genesis 1:27 The Bible said that human beings, us, are made in the very image of God. Psalm 139:13-19 “…for I am fearfully and wonderfully made…” a. Abortion destroys and interferes with the work of the Lord. b. Abortion disannuls the plan of God. c. Concluding with the thought of ‘Children are a blessing from the Lord”. III. Main Idea #2 Exodus 20:6 The Bible repeatedly condemns the killing of the innocent. It is an act of murder which goes against one of the commandment of the Lord. “Thou shalt not kill”. Deuteronomy 27:5 The shedding of the innocent blood a. Abortion promotes killing. b. Abortion promotes child abuse. c. Abortion devalues life. IV. Main Idea #3 Isaiah 30:18 The Bible talks about a God being a ‘God of Justice’. a. The Bible said that we are to love unconditionally and show compassion. b. Abortion shows a lack of natural affection and faith in God. c. How can you kill without caring? d. How can you kill someone and think......

Words: 1690 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Effect of Social Issues on Individuals

...among cyonites. Unity among youth announces to the world the love that Christ has for all people and his wish to share his life with them. Christ himself knowing the importance of unity prays to his father, ” that they may all be one as thou father in me and I in you”, we are living stones in the building of which there is only one foundation, Jesus Christ. Each of us has the responsibility of promoting unity in a world largely indifferent to the church. Nowhere in the teaching of Jesus is “rugged individualism” promoted as an option for Christian spirituality. Christian would be known by their love and interconnectedness in caring relationships. When we live in one another, we not only share one another‟s burdens, we share one another‟s blessing, strengths and joys as well. Our personal development and spiritual growth need to be built on a foundation of mutual supportive relationships. The emotional pain we suffer most frequently arises from our inability to relate and communicate effectively. Our difficulties often stem from believes we have grown up with that we are separated , that other people are threats to our security and that our needs are unconnected with the needs of others. We need to be mindful, therefore, of the importance of being connected. One of our primary concerns should be for “US”. There is an old saying that the nights is over and the day has begun when we recognize other people as our brothers and sisters. God cares about how we treat our fellow youth......

Words: 2427 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Judiasm Presentation

...and commandments to Moses on Mount Sinai in the form of the Torah. The Torah has 613 commandments from God which are known as “sacred obligations”. In other words these are all the things the Jewish people have to do to make God happy. These are kind of like instructions given by God to the Jewish people that teach them how to act, think, and understand life and death, as well as God’s relationship with them. In all of these 613 commandments are the first Ten Commandments. Slide 3 – The first Ten Commandments You shall have no other god except Me. You shall not make or worship idols. You shall not make wrong use of the name of the Lord your God. Keep the Sabbath day Holy. Honor your father and your mother. You shall not commit murder. You shall not commit adultery. You shall not steal. You shall not give false evidence against your neighbor. You shall not covet anything that does not belong to you. Slide 2 - Other Jewish Holy Texts Hebrew Bible – three sections of the Bible are used by the Jews which are the sections Christians consider as the “Old Testament”: Torah (5 Books of Moses) + Nevi’im (Prophets) + Ketuvim (Writings). Judaism recognizes the Christian “New Testament” as a historical and not religious text, the term “Old Testament” is not used. Mishnah (MISH-nuh) (Hebrew for "instruction"), c. 200 C.E. is the written form of the Oral Torah created at the end of the second century. Jewish tradition holds that when G-d gave Moses the Torah......

Words: 4555 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

How Religion Is Impacted by Science Extending the Lifespan of a Human

...may be much lower than what the patient would have expected. In the past, illness, diseases, accidents, and age bore a great threat to the human life. Nowadays, the modern technology can help to keep people alive. A variety of vaccines and drugs are now available for the prevention of diseases, curing infections, treating heart attacks, and controlling a number of other medical problems. In fact, research studies are underway to produce a gene that can prolong the human life. Some aspects of medical technology can now help to keep humans alive for weeks, months, years, and even for decades; far beyond the expected limit, if humans were to survive naturally without technological intervention (Cox, 2008). Prolonging human life is such a blessing of incomparable significance since people can live happily and with high productivity. The life extension science, anti-aging medicine, biomedical gerontology, or experimental gerontology involves a study which attempts to slow down or reverse the aging process to such an extent of maximum or average lifespan. Physicians in this field and “longevists” or “life extensionists” who may wish to have longer lives themselves believe that the future successes in tissue rejuvenation using stem cells, organ replacements like using artificial organs, and molecular repair are feasible (Graham & Keane, 2009). They believe that the move will enable humans to live an indefinite lifespan by total renewal to a healthy and a youthful life. In the......

Words: 3538 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Homework

...Ground The foundational moral principles are not only right for all, but at some level known to all. Once upon a time it was possible for a philosopher to write that the foundational moral principles are “the same for all, both as to rectitude and as to knowledge” 1—and expect every one to agree. To say that these principles are the same for all “as to rectitude” means that they are right for everyone; in other words, deliberately taking innocent human life, sleeping with my neighbor’s wife, and mocking God are as wrong for me as they are for you, no matter what either of us believes. To say that they are the same for all “as to knowledge” means that at some level, everyone knows them; even the murderer knows the wrong of murder, the adulterer the wrong of adultery, the mocker the wrong of mockery. He may say that he doesn’t, but he does. There are no real moral skeptics; supposed skeptics are playing make-believe, and doing it badly. As I say, once upon a time a thinker who wrote such words could expect nearly everyone to agree. And nearly everyone did. The Christians agreed, the Jews agreed, and the Muslims 3 4 INTRODUCTION agreed. Moreover, they could call to their support the consen sus of the rest of the human race. One might search the wide world over for a people who did not know the moral basics, but one would fail. To be sure, the wide world over people also carved out excuses for themselves. I must not take innocent human......

Words: 89540 - Pages: 359

Free Essay

Philosophy

...claims that since most conversion happen to people age 15-24, it is simple a part of growing up and finding your own identity. People may be rebelling against or rejecting the religion of their parents, or they may be trying to work out a purpose for their life and find this through religion. 8 Corporate The Toronto Blessing is a recent corporate religious experience. This first occurred at Toronto Airport Vineyard Church in early 1994, when Randy Clark was preaching there. The experience is particularly associated with ‘holy laughter’, though other affects of it included crying, dancing, and strange, animal-like noises. This is believed to be a manifestation of the Holy Spirit. Since then, hundreds of thousands of people have visited the church and experienced similar things, which have changed their lives. The supports of the experience argue that it has its roots in Pentecostal Christianity; a key Biblical text is the story of Pentecost, in which the Holy Spirit came to Jesus’s disciples and gave them the courage to preach his message. Others argue that God would have no reason to give someone an experience such as the Toronto Blessing. They may attribute it to mass hysteria, or perhaps psychological reasons – people are now visiting the Church with the expectation of having the experience. The Religious Experience Argument William James (see also information on mystical experiences In ‘The Varieties of Religious Experience’, James had three......

Words: 22600 - Pages: 91

Premium Essay

Court and Trial

...(Prime-Minister of Pakistan). Form Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Ex. 26. What do you know about Harvard’s rival Yale? Read the text and find American similarities to the Oxbridge system. Summarize the text. Yale Location New Haven, Connecticut, US Motto: Light and truth Colours: Yale blue since 1894, prior colour, green Nicknames: Bulldogs, Elis (after Elihu Yale), Yalies Mascot: Handsome Dan Yale‘s roots can be traced back to the 1640s, when colonial clergymen made an effort to establish a college in New Haven to preserve the tradition of European liberal education in the New World. This vision was fulfilled in 1701, when the charter was granted for a school ―wherein Youth may be instructed in 20 the Arts and Sciences [and] through the blessing of Almighty God may be fitted for Public employment both in Church and Civil State.‖ In 1718 the school was renamed ―Yale College‖ in gratitude to the Welsh merchant Elihu Yale, who had donated the proceeds from the sale of nine bales of goods together with 417 books and a portrait of King George I. Yale College survived the American Revolutionary War (1776 – 1781) intact and, by the end of its first hundred years, had grown rapid ly. The nineteenth and twentieth centuries brought the establishment of the graduate and professional schools that would make Yale a true university. The Yale School of Medicine was chartered in 1810, followed by the Divinity School in 1822, the Law School in 1824, and the Graduate School of......

Words: 29371 - Pages: 118

Premium Essay

Serial Killer

...a competent professional should be sought. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Serial killers – philosophy for everyone: being and killing / edited by S. Waller. p. cm. — (Philosophy for everyone) Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 978-1-4051-9963-6 (pbk.: alk. paper) 1. Serial murderers—Psychology. 2. Psychology, Pathological. I. Waller, S. II. Title: Serial killers – philosophy for everyone. HV6515.S475 2010 364.152′32—dc22 2010004731 A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Set in 10/12.5pt Plantin by SPi Publisher Services, Pondicherry, India Printed in Singapore 1 2010 CONTENTS Foreword John M. Doris viii xi Acknowledgments S. Waller Introduction: Meditations on Murder, or What is so Philosophical about Serial Killers? S. Waller and William E. Deal 1 PART I I THINK THEREFORE I KILL: The Philosophical Musings of Serial Killers 1 Man is the Most Dangerous Animal of All: A Philosophical Gaze into the Writings of the Zodiac Killer Andrew M. Winters 15 17 2 A Philosophy of Serial Killing: Sade, Nietzsche, and Brady at the Gates of Janus David Schmid 29 3 The Situation of the Jury: Attribution Bias in the Trials of Accused Serial Killers Mark Alfano 41 PART II CAN YOU BLAME THEM? ETHICS, EVIL, AND SERIAL KILLING 4 Serial Killers as Practical Moral Skeptics: A Historical Survey with Interviews Amanda Howard 51 53 5 Are Psychopathic Serial Killers Evil? Are They......

Words: 90119 - Pages: 361

Free Essay

Broking Report

... | |erode = wear away, to diminish | |errant = wandering, mistaken | |eschew = avoid, to abstain from | |espouse = to support or advocate | |estranged = alienated, separated | |euthanasia = mercy-killing | |evanescent = fleeting, very brief, short-lived | |evince = attest, demonstrate, to show clearly | |2                | |exacerbate = worsen | |exasperate = irritate, vex ...

Words: 7984 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Religion and Ethics in Our Modern Society

...First of all man being created in the image of God made him very different from any other creature that God had created. Man has a “capital city” and that make us have a greater responsibility than any other animal ever created. By dominion God meant that human beings should manage, rule and control everything that God had created on earth. Every good thing placed on earth by the bountiful hand of God as an expression of his love to man. The gold and silver are his (haggai 2:8) and he can still even today rain them from heaven if he chooses. But instead of this he has made man his steward, entrusting him with means, not to be hoarded, but to be used in benefiting others. He therefore makes man the medium through which to distribute his blessings on earth. However, this Christian value of stewardship is fasting vanishing in our homes, schools, churches and even in our societies. Instead of people benefiting others with gold and silver, they are hoarding them, and instead of Christians sharing the gospel with others as stewards, they also have chosen to keep it to themselves. Christians need to be reminded that the resposibilty of winning souls supercedes even the management of material possessions because the value of human souls is more than that of the whole world. Thankfulness Unselfishness Wholistic lifestyle Vocational Values Adaptability Career Awareness Determination Determination Though slowly vanishing in our cotemporary society, is similarly endorsed......

Words: 39235 - Pages: 157