Free Essay

Evaluation of Writing Development

In: Other Topics

Submitted By iurobb
Words 1564
Pages 7
The Evaluation of Third Grade Writing Development at Sugar Grove Elementary School

I. Introduction and Philosophy Sugar Grove Elementary School has a current enrollment of 766 students, with 76 of those qualifying for free or reduced lunch. Currently, 6% of the student population has been identified as eligible for special education services (K-6), and 19% receive Title One reading assistance (K-3). There are 529 Sugar Grove families living in single-family homes, 27 of which live in mobile homes. Of the 766 students, 48 of them live outside of the Sugar Grove district having been given the option of attending Sugar Grove, if parents provide transportation. This school community believes that learning is a lifetime quest for academic excellence, personal achievement, and responsibility to the community and the world. They value the unique learning style of every child and the unique path each will pursue to become successful learners and responsible citizens. The staff and parents work to build a safe and caring environment for all members of our school community to engage in meaningful learning. To create the feeling of smaller communities within a large school, six teams have been organized, three teams of five to six classrooms at the 1st – 3rd grade levels and three teams at the 4th – 6th grade levels. All teams are in close physical proximity to each other. This structure offers several advantages. It allows common planning time for teachers across grade levels as the classrooms on each team are scheduled for the same lunch, recess, and specials area times. Students, for the most part, stay within a specific team for three years (1st – 3rd and 4th – 6th). This allows students and teachers to build long lasting relationships with each other, and a familiarity that may otherwise be difficult in a large school.

After examining Sugar Grove Elementary state test scores, specifically ISTEP scores 1998-2002, it was decided that writing process/development was an area of need.

Insert p. 9

A desagregation of Sugar Grove’s scores showed that Sugar Grove Elementary School is an above average school as established by ISTEP.

Insert p. 29 and 34

However, it is felt by this evaluation team, that Sugar Grove Elementary can do much better as their predicted scores are still below actualized scores.

Insert p. 36 and 38

After looking over Sugar Grove’s data, we agree with their analysis and their choice of their school improvement goal. Their data clearly shows that writing development/process is indeed their lowest achieving area across both the third and sixth grade levels. The target goal of writing development improvement across the curriculum is appropriate.

II. In Center Grove Community School Corporation the district does have a Third Grade Language Arts Curriculum. This curriculum runs from 2001-2007. The Guide includes all of the state standards and also includes standards that it has further defined as Center Grove standards. The Center Grove standards appear to be clarification standards. That is they continue standards from other grades to the next level grade. Most of the Curriculum Guide focuses on instruments to use in creating lessons for each of the standards. Center Grove as a district has also created Pre and Posttests. These tests are given at the beginning of the year and then at the end to see the student’s progression. These test at this time are set to try to identify if students are progressing. The district has not stated what means success on these tests. They have only encouraged growth. We feel that this may be contradictory to what may be most beneficial to the students. If the district was to create a criterion to focus on this would allow teachers to compare each student’s performance to clearly stated performance descriptions that differentiate levels of quality. In this way the teacher would be able to judge each student regardless of how ell or poorly other students do. Since the district has not set a specific criterion mark it is very difficult for someone to judge what is acceptable growth and what is not. The district has also instituted a curriculum calendar. However, when speaking with teachers in the building it was not a well-communicated fact. We find it odd that the district states that they have a curriculum calendar but the building level teachers seem not to be aware of it. In fact in discussion about calendars there was anger at the mere mention of the idea that the district would tell them when they would be teaching what. When we look at underlying educational theory that is predominant in the school it seems to be more of a collective of many different philosophies depending upon the individual teacher. The curriculum although spelled out is mostly left up to the individual teacher to define. However, the school has instituted a multiple intelligences learning opportunity in the Sugar Grove Station.

III. Identified Curriculum Applications Sugar Grove developed a writing action plan. This plan includes the following three interventions. 1) Writing opportunities will be increased in all grade levels, across the curriculum. 2) All students will improve writing with Standard English language conventions (spelling, sentence structure, punctuation, capitalization, grammar/word usage). 3) All students will improve writing application skills (writing process steps, writing for different purposes such as descriptive writing, narratives, research reports, literature responses, persuasive…)
We will now analyze each intervention and its corresponding strategies. I. In order to increase writing opportunities in all grade levels across the curriculum, they chose the following strategies: • Provide opportunities to write on a weekly basis through the use of 4 Blocks (Pat Cunningham), Writers Workshop (Graves/Atwell), and 6 Traits ( ). The components of the writing process will be displayed in each classroom.

Sugar Grove is currently implementing this strategy in all third grade classrooms. Each classroom is currently displaying the 6 traits. The Components posted are Think, Write—Rough Draft, Self-Edit, Peer Conference, Teacher Conference, Rewrite, and Publish & Share. Not only are they currently displaying them the components are being used as a matter of practice.

• Once a month all students will participate in a school wide writing session. A prompt will be given and students will write responses.

Currently this is done throughout the school including 3rd grade. Upon looking at the questions we do feel that the questions appear to be of an appropriate cultural and contextual nature for the population of Sugar Grove. It is felt, by us that while the prompts may not be appropriate for some schools that this schools population would have little problem relating to the issues given.

• A formal thematic unit or project will be used in every classroom.

This is done consistently in each of the 3rd grade classes.

II. All students will improve writing with Standard English Language conventions.

• Mini-lessons based on the Indiana standards will be utilized.

Pre and Posttest have been developed to help monitor individual progress on these grade level standards. Although they are available there is a question as to the authentic evaluative merit of the pre and posttests. Further research would need to be undertaken to ascertain their merits.

Compass software will be used to track students and their individual progress. • Writing portfolios will be used and they will include the reports that can be generated from Compass program.

These reports are used in the student portfolios that have been generated.

Daily practice will be provided in editing and proofreading. • Weekly assessments will be used to assess progress of daily proofreading skills.

Although DOL is used in most classes in third grade the lack of a weekly report may be one weakness. They do track but it is not consistent through the grade level. This may be a way for them to improve.

IV. All students will improve writing application skills. Inspiration software will be utilized to help organize thinking of students. • The graphic organizer will be included in writing journal
This is the practice of the 3rd grade at this time. All Writing journals include Inspiration graphic organizers. Other curricular areas such as science or social studies will use writing for different purposes. • Grade level rubrics for various types of writing will be used to assess student performance.
The following grade level rubric was developed by teachers, (insert Rubric); all teachers in the grade level consistently use this. Community connections will be utilized in order to provide real-life situations for children to use. • Each teacher will be able to show at least one piece of student writing during each nine-week grading period that was connected to an outside source.
Not all of the teachers could provide this for every student. This seems to be an area that has been left out. One reason may be the difficulty in retaining outside community help.

IV.

Reference:

Cowell, Richard and Butler, Jocelyn – Improving writing skills River Elementary school. School Improvement research Series, (SIRS) NW Regional Educational Laboratory

Paul, Susan – By us, For Us: One school’s Effort to Improve Student Writing NCA Comission Journal of school Improvement, Spring Vol. 1, Issue 1

Cobine, Gary –Teaching Expressive Writing , ERIC Digest, 1996

Center Grove Curriculum Map for Language Arts, 2001

Center Grove Curriculum Guide for Language Arts, 2001 2007

Pre/post Assessments for Language Arts, Judy Apple 2003

Angela Williamson, Principal Sugar Grove

Guskey, Thomas. “helping Standards Make the Grade”, Educational Leadership Volume 59, Number 1, September 2001.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Wwjk

...CHAPTER DEVELOPING AN EVALUATION PLAN 4 As program staff start planning for program development and begin addressing the components of the logic model, they should keep in mind that as the logic model takes shape, the development of evaluation plans will follow soon after. The logic model can act as a guide to assist you in determining when your evaluation plan should be developed. As you identify the accomplishments and outcomes in your logic model, the next question to ask yourself is, “How will I determine if I met my accomplishments and reached the outcomes I identified?” The evaluation plan will provide a framework for why the evaluation is to be conducted, what is to be evaluated, and how the evaluation will be conducted. After you have assessed the community needs and determined what services/activities will be implemented to address those needs, the evaluation plan is the next step in your planning process. Empowerment Evaluation Before learning how to develop an evaluation plan, it is important to look at the purpose of conducting a program evaluation and understand the type of evaluation models available. This section of the chapter introduces the empowerment evaluation model and the benefits of using this model for program development and improvement. Gutierrez (1994) defines empowerment as the “process of increasing personal, interpersonal, or political power so that individuals, families, and communities can take action to improve their situations” (p. 202)...

Words: 6724 - Pages: 27

Free Essay

Hsm240

...Steps to Writing a Grant Proposal 1. Brandy D HSM/270 September 16, 2014 Instructor: Bonita Comer 2. One of the most important tasks of a successful program planning process is to know exactly what is needed and clear, concise grant writing is the way to achieve this. A grant proposal is a written program plan aimed at obtaining financial assistance from a funding source. Understanding the programs target population and that populations needs are a vital part of a successful grant proposal. “In writing a grant proposal, the applicant agency is making an argument that it has the understanding of the identified problems and knows how to address the problems. The grant proposal is then the agency’s plan of intervention that follows the argument Moore (1998)” (Chapter 2, Practical Grant Writing and Program Evaluation, Yuen/Terao - © 2003 Brooks/Cole). A grant proposal consists of three parts: 1. a group of premises. 2. a conclusion. 3. An implicit claim. The premises are the beliefs that support the program proposal. The conclusion is the services the program intends to offer and the claim is the expected outcome of the services provided by the program. Usually the first step in grant writing is a needs assessment. Qualitative and quantitative are both ways to identify the needs of the program and those that should be expressed in the grant proposal. The grant proposal process normally begins with a Request for Proposal (RFP) or a...

Words: 1115 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Natalie Attired

...Introduction to Legal Analysis and Writing Client Interview – To be used for Unit 4 and for Legal Memorandum (Units 6-9) Notes from Client Interview: Natalie Attired 23 years old Grew up in Albuquerque, New Mexico Attended private schools through 12th grade After graduation in 2007, spent a year in Europe, mostly Paris Returned from Europe in 2008 and enrolled at New Mexico State University, planning to major in Early Childhood Education. After a couple classes, found out that she didn’t like working with small children and reconsidered her career plan. While she attended NMSU, she often went to a local bar called Skully’s, which catered to a mix of college students and members of the local biker community. At Skully’s, she met a 30 year-old man named Zeke Teller, who was a member of the Los Calambres Motorcycle Club. Zeke had three children from three previous relationships. In early 2009, Natalie began riding on his motorcycles and after a few months of hanging around the club became Zeke’s “old lady.” After attending NMSU for one year, Natalie dropped out of school in May 2009 and began working as a waitress at Biddy’s Tea House and Croissanterie in Truth or Consequences, NM. Biddy’s has been in business for over 20 years, and is run by Biddy Baker, age 60. The restaurant serves tea, sandwiches, scones, and desserts. No alcohol is served in the establishment. Biddy’s evaluates waitress’ performance every three months. Natalie received four evaluations while she worked there (attached)...

Words: 1044 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Merklin: How Does Guided Writing Work?

...Merklin_Guided Writing Research What is Guided Writing? Gibson describes guided writing as a “small-group instructional framework presented to students who share similar needs at a particular point in time. Guided writing provides an important context for teachers' in-the-moment assessment and immediate instructional scaffolding of students' construction of their own individual text" Gibson (2008). In other words, Guided Writing means working with small groups of students with similar needs in writing development. Teachers can use this time to help them see where the students are and how to help students progress. How does Guided Writing Work? Several steps make up a Guided Writing lesson: a brief shared experience, discussion of targeted...

Words: 1373 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Program Planning

...Program Planning and Evaluation Program Planning and Evaluation In the article Peace Domestic Violence Agency, the mission and funding opportunity provide a relational base to tackle needs of domestically abused victims (Dunham, 2008). The document expounds on the necessities required, planning, and assessment, together with evaluation of the abused victims. Human service organizations take us through the urgent needs and requirements tackled when there is a domestic abuse case. There are two aspects involved during this development, that is, the program planning and the program evaluation procedures. Comparison of program planning with program evaluation Program planning, in the Peace Domestic Violence Agency article is a development process that coordinates and facilitates change in identified need and problems while program evaluation entails research purposes rather than involving research methods (Dunham, 2008). In addition, program planning involves an assessment of what has happened and what should have happened while program evaluation handles incorporation into the program planning process to provide a continuous program performance assessment, thus boosting efficiency in human service organizations (Dunham, 2008). In the article Peace Domestic Violence Agency, program planning is related to needs assessment and program evaluation (Dunham, 2008). Needs assessment mainly provides the basis of program development plans, which entail taking a program through...

Words: 800 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Program Planning and Evaluation

...Program Planning and Evaluation Paper Crystal Ingerson 5/1/16 HSM/270 Joan Butcher-Farkas Program Planning and Evaluation Paper Program planning and program evaluation are two parts to one goal. It is through program planning and evaluation that the attainment of program goals and quality of services are assessed. Program planning is defined as an organized process through which a set of coordinated activities or interventions is developed to address and facilitate change in some or all of the identified problems; thus, it is a means for development or change (Brooks/Cole, 2003). Only after the program interventions are implemented, then the performance and the attainment of intended objectives are then evaluated. Program evaluation provides useful information used for improving the programs and the service delivery systems (Brooks/Cole, 2003). Program planning and evaluation is very important when it comes to grant proposals. A grant proposal is a formal proposal submitted to a government or civilian entity that outlines a proposed project and shows budgetary requirements and requests monetary assistance in the form of a grant (Entrepreneur staff, 2016). Before writing a grant proposal, organizations must first have a proper program plan and evaluation process. Funding sources are no longer willing to allocate resources for human service agencies and expect merely a report on whether or not the program and service providers did what they said they would do (Brooks/Cole...

Words: 833 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Lesson Planning on Cognitive Aspects Under Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation (Cce)

...LESSON PLANNING ON COGNITIVE ASPECTS UNDER CONTINUOUS AND COMPREHENSIVE EVALUATION (CCE) Sandip Ratna, Department of Mathematics, State College of Teacher Education, Kohima::Nagaland, e-mail: sandipncte@yahoo.in Abstract 21st century classroom is all about skill development, lateral thinking, creativity, judgement, higher-order skills like reasoning and analysis and teaching needs to serve discouragement for rote memorization. Education, as a planned endeavor, at a personal level on a small scale or institutional level on a large scale, aims at making children capable of becoming active, responsible, productive, and caring members of society. Hence for responsibility of the school and teachers became more important in formal form of education, with the changing needs of the time, we need to change the pattern of instructional strategies so that educational aim can be achieved. With continuous and comprehensive evaluation we must adopt modified entities of cognitive domains known as revised version of Bloom’s Taxonomy developed by Dr. Lorin Anderson, 1999, a former student of Bloom's, and his colleagues. The updated version of Bloom’s Taxonomy with respect to cognitive domain under scholastic aspect in formal education system can be used for the purpose of 21st century formal classroom for teaching-learning as they are from simplest to most complex objectives: remembering, understanding, applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating. Keywords: Lesson Planning...

Words: 3916 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Sustainable Fashion

...English for Academic Study New edition Writing Course Book Anne Pallant Book map Unit 1 Introduction­to­academic­ writing No source text Unit­essay (Reflective questionnaire) Skills­and­­ language­focus ■ Reflecting on the process of academic writing 2 Sustainable­energy­ 2a Using waste, Swedish city cuts its fossil fuel use (1) 2b Using waste, Swedish city cuts its fossil fuel use (2) How can alternative sources of energy be harnessed effectively? Getting started: Planning an essay ■ Writing a first draft of an essay ■ Peer evaluation of a first draft ■ Incorporating sources ■ Writing introductions ■ 3 The­business­of­science 3a Stop selling out science to commerce 3b Is business bad for science? Over the past 20 years, commercial influences on scientific research have become increasingly detrimental. Discuss. Organizing and supporting ideas: ■ Generating ideas for an essay ■ Organizing ideas ■ Incorporating and referencing sources ■ Using paragraph leaders to help organization Writing in examinations: ■ Understanding key instruction verbs in examination questions ■ Interpreting examination questions ■ Writing an examination essay 4 Telemedicine 4c Telemedicine Timed­essay: As technology continues to improve, the range of potential uses for telemedicine will increase. Telemedicine will offer more beneficial applications in preventing rather than curing disease. Discuss. There are many threats to global food supplies...

Words: 5274 - Pages: 22

Free Essay

Class Expectations

...|Analysing an Essay Question | 1. Introduction Common criteria of undergraduate essay writing focus on the following requirements: students need to be analytical and critical in their response students need to structure their writing logically students need to be persuasive writers | students need to answer the question | This booklet looks at, how to analyse your essay question. Other Learning Centre booklets in this series deal with the other aspects: • Analytical Writing deals with the difference between analytical and descriptive writing • Planning and Structuring an Essay deals with logical structures • Developing and Supporting an Argument deals with persuasion Expectations of student assignments One of the difficulties experienced by students, particularly in first year, is understanding what standard is expected in essays at tertiary level. As well as this, each subject discipline has its own ways of doing things and its own conventions about essay structure and writing style. For instance, in some subjects it is acceptable to write very personally and put forward your own opinions and feelings on a topic and in others such a personal response would not be appropriate. You need to find out the expectations and conventions...

Words: 5948 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Lesson Planning on Cognitive Aspects Under Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation (Cce)

...LESSON PLANNING ON COGNITIVE ASPECTS UNDER CONTINUOUS AND COMPREHENSIVE EVALUATION (CCE) Sandip Ratna, Department of Mathematics, State College of Teacher Education, Kohima::Nagaland, e-mail: sandipncte@yahoo.in Abstract 21st century classroom is all about skill development, lateral thinking, creativity, judgement, higher-order skills like reasoning and analysis and teaching needs to serve discouragement for rote memorization. Education, as a planned endeavor, at a personal level on a small scale or institutional level on a large scale, aims at making children capable of becoming active, responsible, productive, and caring members of society. Hence for responsibility of the school and teachers became more important in formal form of education, with the changing needs of the time, we need to change the pattern of instructional strategies so that educational aim can be achieved. With continuous and comprehensive evaluation we must adopt modified entities of cognitive domains known as revised version of Bloom’s Taxonomy developed by Dr. Lorin Anderson, 1999, a former student of Bloom's, and his colleagues. The updated version of Bloom’s Taxonomy with respect to cognitive domain under scholastic aspect in formal education system can be used for the purpose of 21st century formal classroom for teaching-learning as they are from simplest to most complex objectives: remembering, understanding, applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating. Keywords: Lesson Planning, Content analysis...

Words: 3913 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Organizational Behavior Assignment

...www.plymouth.ac.uk/learn learn@plymouth.ac.uk 01752 587676 8. Critical Thinking In this study guide:       What is critical thinking? Structure: organising your thoughts and materials Generating critical thinking Critical questions – a linear model Description, analysis and evaluation Developing an argument For further information and the full range of study guides go to: http://www.learningdevelopment.plymouth.ac.uk What is critical thinking? This guide to critical thinking stresses the importance of asking and answering questions. In everyday life the term „critical‟ is often seen as negative or destructive. Being critical in academic life, however, does not mean questioning things randomly, or for the sake of „nit-picking‟. Instead, academic work aims to get as near as possible to the truth. Critical thinking in any subject or discipline is the way in which this is done, along with the more specialised applications of theory, the methods and techniques, which have been developed for the subject. Critical thinking then, is the attempt to ask and answer questions systematically. This means asking the most useful questions in the most productive sequence in order to yield a coherent and credible „story‟ So thinking critically means asking questions. Instead of accepting „at face value‟ what you read or hear, critical thinkers look for evidence and for good reasons before believing something to be true. This is at the heart of what it means to be a scientist, researcher...

Words: 3291 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Hsm270

...page, see above: This website can help you tremendously: http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/560/01/ References Owl Purdue (2011). Retrieved March 1, 2011 from http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/560/01/ While you did a wonderful job with the title page, it is not APA appropriate and you need to use APA style of writing when formatting your assignments. 4/5/2013 4/5/2013 Microsoft account Laura Harris Microsoft account Laura Harris Program Planning and Evaluation PEACE Domestic Violence Agency Program Planning and Evaluation Plan Program Planning and Evaluation PEACE Domestic Violence Agency Program Planning and Evaluation Plan Program Planning and Evaluation PEACE Domestic Violence Agency Program Planning and Evaluation Plan The overall purpose of this Program Planning and Evaluation paper is to make a comparative analysis of program planning and evaluation processes in a human service organization like PEACE. We do not use first voice will also look at how technical and political factors can affect program planning and evaluation processes. According to Michael Quinn Patton (publication date), program evaluation is carefully collecting information about a program or some aspects of a program...

Words: 1730 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

An Application for Automated Evaluation of Student Essay

...Criterion SM Online Essay Evaluation: An Application for Automated Evaluation of Student Essays Jill Burstein Educational Testing Service Rosedale Road, 18E Princeton, NJ 08541 jburstein@ets.org Martin Chodorow Department of Psychology Hunter College 695 Park Avenue New York, NY 10021 martin.chodorow@hunter.cuny.edu Claudia Leacock Educational Testing Service Rosedale Road, 18E Princeton, NJ 08541 cleacock@ets.org Abstract This paper describes a deployed educational technology application: the CriterionSM Online Essay Evaluation Service, a web-based system that provides automated scoring and evaluation of student essays. Criterion has two complementary applications: E-rater®, an automated essay scoring system and Critique Writing Analysis Tools, a suite of programs that detect errors in grammar, usage, and mechanics, that identify discourse elements in the essay, and that recognize elements of undesirable style. These evaluation capabilities provide students with feedback that is specific to their writing in order to help them improve their writing skills. Both applications employ natural language processing and machine learning techniques. All of these capabilities outperform baseline algorithms, and some of the tools agree with human judges as often as two judges agree with each other. 2. Application Description Criterion contains two complementary applications that are based on natural language processing (NLP) methods. The scoring application, e-rater®, extracts...

Words: 5634 - Pages: 23

Free Essay

Process and Outcome Evaluations

...Process and Outcome Evaluations Holly Regan HSM/270 June 18, 2014 Fedder Williams Process and Outcome Evaluations Some of the characteristics for process evaluation involve planning, implementing, and monitoring and documenting the interrelationship of the program components for the proposed project. The main focus of a process evaluation is comprised of several components that are: (A) program interventions, (B) database management system (DMS), and (C) program and planning development. The sub-components for a process evaluation are: (a) description of program implements, development, and activities for interventions, (b) documentation regarding the appropriateness and acceptability of offered programs within the community, (c) providing quantitative and qualitative research data on the effectiveness of delivered services, (Yuen & Terao, 2003). Examples of a Process Evaluation: (1) Program staff and volunteers distribute employment-readiness training brochures at a local community event. (2) Program staff will track how many individuals attended each training session and how many people completed ninety percent of the sessions. Outcome evaluations involve the strategies described within the projects objectives. It also provides measures for process and outcome evaluations within three categories, (1) getting things done, (2) member development, and (3) community development by determining the effect the program had on the target population over time, (Yuen...

Words: 292 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Disneyland

...------------------------------------------------- Assignment Rubric ------------------------------------------------- | | | | Criteria | < 40% | 40 - 49% | 50 - 59% | 60 - 69% | > 70% | Evaluation and analysis(30%) | Little or no evaluation or analysis. Very descriptive. | Some identification of the different issues but limited evaluation or analysis. Discussion mainly descriptive. | Reasonable identification of the different issues. Descriptive in style but with some evaluation & analysis. Discusses the theories/models and concepts. | Identification of a range of issues with a good level evaluation & analysis. Some criticality present. Good attempt to discuss theories/models and concepts. | Identification of a good range of issues and with a high level of evaluation and analysis. Good level of criticality present. Theories/models and concepts are effectively discussed. | Appropriate coverage of theories/models and concepts with the three research strands (30%) | No or minimal relevant theory / models and concepts used. Lacking in breadth and/or depth. | Limited coverage of relevant theory / models and concepts. Lacking in breadth and/or depth in most areas. | Reasonable coverage of relevant theory / models and concepts. Lacking in breadth and/or depth in most areas. | Good coverage of relevant theory / models and concepts. Reasonable balance of breadth and depth achieved. | Very good coverage of relevant theory / models and...

Words: 398 - Pages: 2