Free Essay

Examine the Problems with Defining and Measuring Development

In: Social Issues

Submitted By SophieNoffey
Words 923
Pages 4
Examine the problems of defining and measuring development
Sociologists have been divided on the issue of defining and measuring development. Development can be measured in many ways. For example, the Gross Domestic Product, the Human Development Index, the Quality of Life Index, the Gross National Happiness Index and the Millennium Development Goals. Development is also defined in many ways, for example the three world theory, the northern and southern hemisphere and the economically developed countries.
Gross Domestic Product (GPD) is a way of measuring development which focuses on economic growth. GDP is the total value of all goods and services the country produces. A high GDP indicates a productive economy, where wealth will filter down to improve standard of life for society. However, critics note that this does not account for the distribution of wealth within a country so wealth could be concentrated in the elite groups oppose to being equally issued. Furthermore, the approach is based on Western capitalist ideologies that see wealth as synonymous with the well-being, ignoring the potential negative effects of rapid and unrestricted accumulation of profit. The data can be unreliable which would make it incomparable between countries.
Another way in which to measure development is Human Development Index (HDI). This is a combination of scores of education, wealth and life expectancy between 0 (least developed) and 1 (most developed). The HDI is not completely comprehensive and does not disclose inequalities within a nation. The index lacks depth, detail and is oversimplified which challenges the validity. It does not include other factors of development for example, birth rates.
The Quality of Life Index (QLI) also measures development. QLI is a survey which uses nine factors to determine a nation’s score. These factors are health, family life, community life, material well-being, political stability, climate, job security, political freedom and gender equality. QLI measures something which is arguably subjective as it would be hard to quantify these factors into objective scores if they are personal opinions. Due to this, it would be hard to operationalise and measure.
Furthermore, the Gross National Happiness (GNH) survey tries to measure development. The GNH is a survey in Bhutan were asked question about the following; psychological, wellbeing, health, use of time, community validity, education, culture, environment and the government. This index is not reliable as the governments may be able to manipulate and define the GNH in a way that suits them. It measures something which is subjective so, is also, hard to operationalise and measure. Due to its subjectivity, the index is deemed as unscientific as it has no factual evidence.
Millennium Development Goals (MDG) also measures development. The MDG are 8 goals created by the United Nations in the 1990’s that we’re hoped to be achieved by the new millennium. These goals were to eradicate extreme poverty and hunger, to achieve universal primary education, to promote gender equality and empower women, to reduce child mortality, to improve maternal health, to combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other disease, to ensure environmental sustainability and to develop a global partnership for development. Although many welcomed the MDG, many goals still have not been achieved suggesting that the United Nations did not go far enough in demanding greater responsibility from those who govern developing nations to ensure success. Also, between 1990 and 2012, global emissions of carbon dioxide has increased by over 50% and more than 880 million people are estimated to be living in slums today, compared to 792 million in 2000. This further indicates that MGD was not a success due to poor governing from developing countries.
Development is defined in a variety of ways such as first, second and third worlds which only focuses on political differences, not economical. The first and second world countries refer to the capitalist and communist blocs. The third world refers to countries that did not align themselves during the cold wall. The theory is oversimplified and outdated as the breakup of the Soviet Union left the second world somewhat empty so it lacks historical validity. The system is based on value judgements, for example, the dominant ideology of the world is capitalism which is the first world. This suggests that capitalism is the best system which makes the theory ethnocentric as it suggests a hierarchy of worlds.
Development can also be defined from the split of the south and north hemisphere, south being poor and north being rich. This is based on the geographical pattern of affluence. This theory is based on an oversimplification. Also, the location of Australia in the south contradicts the definition.
Another approach to classifying development creates more types of a country. For example more economically developed countries such as Britain, Japan and the US; less economically developed countries are some of the poorest nations such as Bangladesh and Sierra Leone; least economically developed countries such as Rwanda and Mali; newly developed countries such as Brazil and Mexico. These categories give the impression of homogenous. Also, it is economically deterministic.
In the answer I have examined the problems with defining and measuring development. I can conclude by saying that the main problems with defining development are that most theories are homogenous as they tend to categorise different countries into one group. Also, many theories oversimplify an otherwise complex definition. The main problems with measuring development are that most theories are ethnocentric as they base the measuring systems on western ideologies. Also, most systems test things that are not objective so it is hard for it to be operationalised and measure.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Cognitive Psychology Definition

...they process, and how does it take place. A human's behavior in different situations is just as set of theoretical and practical knowledge received in the process of cognition. All the questions regarding this topic are put under deep scrutiny by the branch of psychology, which is called the cognitive psychology. This kind of psychological studies is one of the most important, as it examines and researches not only what and who we are, but how do we acquire the features we possess. The 18th century was a harsh time for the development of psychology in the role of a scientific discipline. Towards the end of the 19th century psychology was dominated by an approach known as introspectionism. The basis of introspectionism was to study mental processes via a method of subjective self-examination. (Parkin, 2000, p. 1) In the middle of the 20th century, three general movements arose to inspire and shape a cognitive psychology. First of all, after the introduction of new warfare technologies, a constant need of better understanding of human cognitive processes became a central one. Secondly, the development of computer technologies drew new parallels between human thoughts and computers' functionality. It opened an entirely new area of psychological thoughts. The concept of artificial intelligence was developed by Herbert Simon, and Allen Newell....

Words: 1156 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Decisions in Paradise

...Amanda S. Adolf University of Phoenix Abstract The National Dissemination Center for Children with Disabilities (NICHCY) has decided to expand their presence on the South Pacific island of Kava. In order to make the expansion a reality, we must progress to the evaluation stage of the decision-making steps. Working through the last part of the nine step process NICHCY will review the factors that will have to be considered during implementation and will work to evaluate resources that will be needed during this phase of the decision-making process. Once the implementation has taken place measuring the process will be necessary to ensure that the plan stays on track. Decisions in Paradise Paper, Part III Thus far, we have covered identifying the problems, defining criteria, goals and objectives, evaluating the effect of the problems and identifying the causes of the problems. The National Dissemination Center for Children with Disabilities (NICHCY) has outlined the alternatives and evaluated their impacts of the alternatives. In order to move forward, NICHCY will implement decisions that have to be made to complete the NICHCY Community Center in Kava. NICHCY is known for their exceptional quality of service. The stakeholders have come to rely on this stability and commitment to excellence to make certain of NICHCY’s reliability in the investment market. In order to protect the image of NICHCY, we must carefully evaluate factors affecting implementation. ...

Words: 965 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Market Segmentation

...Measuring the stability of Retail Market based on its store images – a fuzzy clustering approach. Abstract Purpose segmentation is the point where marketing activity starts. A flawless segmentation results in comparable competitive advantage. The purpose of this study is to examine the stability of segmentation. Design / methodology/ approach - this research examines the stability of the segments. Shoppers have been segmented based on the importance they’ve given to store image. Data collected through mall intercept interviews has been used for it. Segmentation has been done by K-means clustering and fuzzy clustering methods. Membership grades give the samples’ relative position in the cluster. Findings – Various approaches to segment the market has been analysed and the advantages of fuzzy methods has been obtained. Finally the most stable segment, on the other hand the most volatile segment has been found out. Study reveals that fuzzy clustering is potentially useful to assess the stability of segments. Research limitations / implications Research findings are constrained, as the study concentrates on the behaviour of shoppers based on the influence of store images but segmenting based on demographic or lifestyle variables are not considered. However the stability of segments has been analysed for this segments. Practical implications membership grade gives a clear picture of the real market to the marketer. And it helps the marketer to visualize individual’s...

Words: 2611 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Seminar in Program Development

...Seminar in Program Development & Evaluation Steps of Planning Model for Program Development: 1. mission statement – general idea or main purpose of program 2. assessment & evaluation – inventory of internal assessment, resources and review of policy & regulations 3. needs assessment – involves both perceived & real needs 4. determine & set priorities 5. writing goals & objectives – objectives involve: a. who? b. to what extent? c. under what conditions? d. by what standards? e. within what time period? 6. step-by-step activities & procedures – pilot projects & consideration of other internal & external threats 7. develop timeline chart 8. implementation of the project 9. evaluation & feedback 1. Mission Statement – a statement by an organization that contains detailed info. about the overall direction & purpose of the organization a. usually based on a general observation, an obvious need, seen need or interest, or need assessment result b. it’s an administrative statement that guides planning & decision-making c. not restricted by time elements d. philosophy of an organization e. identification of the self-concept of the organizational program f. identification of general service catchment areas & target populations and markets to be served g. define terms & shared definition of problem of target population 2. Assessment & Evaluation – an inventory of resources and review of policy...

Words: 2150 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Miss

...i) The Importance of SERVQUAL The importance of the SERVQUAL, is that it is widely used within service industries to understand the perceptions of target customers regarding their service needs. As well as to provide a measurement of the service quality of the organization. It may be also be applied internally to understand employees’ perception of service quality, with the objective achieving service improvement. “Despite numerous criticisms, SERVQUAL continues to appeal to both academics and practitioners. Originally developed and tested in the consumer retail environment, more recent replications have extended to the industrial market, the public sector, information systems, real estate, hospitals and the legal profession.” Advantages A Comprehensive and thorough examination of service needs and service quality provides an invaluable approach to improving service quality. The SERVQUAL provides detailed information about. • Customer perceptions of service( a benchmark established by your own customers) • Performance levels as perceived by customers • Customers comments and suggestions • Impressions from employees with respect to customers’ expectations and satisfaction “Lewis et al. (1994) have explored and identified a number of possible benefits service organisations can look forward to when they pursue service quality. Service organisations are competing to achieve sustainable competitive advantage through providing a high-quality service to their existing...

Words: 1144 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ethical Leadership in Organization

...newer field of study. Yet, common themes include the need for establishing trust and gaining ethical knowledge by way of study and application. Also, major organizational failures, such as Enron, have ignited an interest within the field. Possible further research is recommended at the end of this review. T his article examines the literature regarding the topic of ethical leadership within organizations. The literature review was conducted by utilizing databases such as scholar.google.com, the Library of Congress database, Academic Search Complete, EBSCOhost Discovery, and OmniFile Full-Text Mega. Additional resources were secured at Barnes and Nobles bookstore. A list of keywords used during the search is ethical leadership, ethics, morality, virtues, values, morals, and management. Thirty-eight articles were ultimately selected due to their focus on four main topics: a) defining ethical leadership, b) the personal integrity of the leader, c) influencing followers in ethics, and d) current challenges and solutions. The structure of the literature review examines each of these four topics in greater depth and considers the findings in the end. Defining Ethical Leadership The study of ethical leadership is increasing in...

Words: 4697 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Examination of Poverty

...computer based technology, the impact has hit hardest for working class and poor families, with limited education, job skills and employment opportunities” (Walsh, 2003, pp.17). Despite the effects of poverty, different individuals have different perceptions about the persisting problem. Some assert that poverty is a natural condition of man; while others view it as self-imposed, imposed, or a debilitating economic situation. This paper will examine the many concepts of poverty and discuss how it is related to at least two theoretical perspectives on human behavior, how it has changed over time, current issues related to poverty and how these issues are similar and different for two countries. Definition Many scholars and researchers define poverty as an insufficiency of the material necessities of life. The disparities between the rich and poor have increased so solemnly since the industrial revolution that it formed a poverty line. A poverty line which is used in defining what percentage of the population is poor based on the economy. Poverty 3 The US Census Bureau (2009) cites that”35.9 million people live below the poverty line in America including 12.9 million children,” while the World Development Report (2009) estimates, “...the number of poor worldwide is approximately 1.3 billion.” Although poverty statistics provide a quantitative viewpoint, it does not reveal the intricacies of poor peoples’ lives. For instance, poverty can be temporary or long term in...

Words: 2461 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Corporate Reputation

...Corporate Reputation Review Volume 12 Number 4 A Systematic Review of the Corporate Reputation Literature: Definition, Measurement, and Theory Kent Walker Asper School of Business, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada ABSTRACT A systematic review of the corporate reputation literature is conducted. The final sample of 54 articles (and one book) consists of well-cited papers, and papers in journals that have published high quality work in corporate reputation. The sample is then analyzed and the three fundamental problems in the reputation literature are addressed – the need for a comprehensive and well-accepted definition, the difficulty in operationalizing corporate reputation, and the ongoing need for more developed theory. Two main findings evolve from this analysis: (1) reputation may have different dimensions and is issue specific, and (2) different stakeholder groups may have different perceptions of corporate reputations. The implications for future research are discussed. Corporate Reputation Review (2010) 12, 357–387. doi:10.1057/crr.2009.26 KEYWORDS: corporate reputation; definition; operationalization; organizational identity; organizational image; systematic review INTRODUCTION There are many reasons why organizations and researchers should care about corporate reputation. The relationship between reputation and a sustained competitive advantage is widely acknowledged in the literature (eg, Fombrun and Shanley, 1990; Fombrun, 1996;...

Words: 16404 - Pages: 66

Premium Essay

Performance Management Plan

...Landslide Limousines: Performance Management Plan N’Jheri N. Price HRM/531 Bradley Stonefield, the business owner of Landslide Limousines; a luxury car service in Austin, Texas started his business with 25 employees and expected $50,000 in annual profits. He intends to gain an increase of 5% over the next few years. His expected turnover rate is relatively low for the size of his organization (10%). However, in order for Mr. Stonefield to attain a level of success he wishes for his new business, and perhaps significantly lower his turnover rate, he must establish a set of guidelines to facilitate his efforts. This guide is a performance management plan. The performance management plan is a guide that will enable a high level of success and provides means to measure the effectiveness of business operation or employees. The performance management plan is a key component to the success of any organization usually established by the executive staff. In this case Mr. Stonefield and his business colleagues are at the executive level. They will outline key performance strategies, financial needs for operations, align goals and responsibilities for individuals in the company, and collect performance data from the different departments. The performance management plan is important as it can collect data and analyze the information against predetermined guidelines, goals, or objectives; usually specific to the task or function being reviewed. Individual goal and responsibilities...

Words: 1876 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Ee Gret

...66–79.; Dawar N., Parker P. and Price L. A cross-cultural study of interpersonal information exchange. Journal of International Business Studies 1996; 27(3): 497–516.; Manrai L. and Manrai A. Current issues in the cross-cultural and cross-national consumer research. Journal of International Consumer Marketing 1996; 8 (3/4): 9–22.; McCort D. and Malhotra NK. Culture and consumer behavior: Toward an understanding of cross-cultural consumer behavior in International Marketing. Journal of International Consumer Marketing 1993; 6 (2): 91–127.; Nasif EG., Al-Daeaj H., Ebrahimi B. and Thibodeaux M. Methodological problems in cross-cultural research: An updated review. Management International Review 1991; 31 (1): 79–91.; Lenartowicz T. and Roth K. A framework for culture assessment. Journal of International Business Studies 1999; 30 (4): 781–98.]. This article examines different approaches to...

Words: 6682 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Organization Cdfajsuvnbsjkvnbjkncjkn

...smwjgddshudchsacqwertyuiopasdfghjklhyhfghjkl;xcvbnm, dfdewhcfqid cvugdvd vefvbfv dcvd v f dfvThe Capabilities of Market-Driven Organizations George S. Day, 1993 [93-123] View/Order Item >> Comments from members >> Understanding Market Orientation Considerable progress has been made in identifying market-driven organizations, understanding what they do, and measuring the bottom-line consequences. The next challenge is to better understand how this organizational orientation can be achieved and sustained. The emerging capabilities approach to strategic management offers a rich array of ways to design change programs that will enhance a market orientation. This approach seeks the sources of defensible competitive positions in the distinctive, difficult-to-imitate capabilities the organization has developed. Capabilities are complex bundles of skills and knowledge, exercised through organizational processes, that ensure the superior coordination of functional activities and enable the organization to continuously learn and improve. Examples of defining processes include such typical business activities as order fulfillment, new product development, and service delivery. Capabilities of Market-Driven Organizations Capabilities are embedded in the business's "outside-in" processes, which guide the creation and delivery of value in the organization. Two capabilities stand out as essential ingredients of a market orientation: Market Sensing. This capability enables the business to learn about...

Words: 934 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Culture

...Oct.: 66–79.; Dawar N., Parker P. and Price L. A cross-cultural study of interpersonal information exchange. Journal of International Business Studies 1996; 27(3): 497–516.; Manrai L. and Manrai A. Current issues in the cross-cultural and cross-national consumer research. Journal of International Consumer Marketing 1996; 8 (3/4): 9–22.; McCort D. and Malhotra NK. Culture and consumer behavior: Toward an understanding of cross-cultural consumer behavior in International Marketing. Journal of International Consumer Marketing 1993; 6 (2): 91–127.; Nasif EG., Al-Daeaj H., Ebrahimi B. and Thibodeaux M. Methodological problems in cross-cultural research: An updated review. Management International Review 1991; 31 (1): 79–91.; Lenartowicz T. and Roth K. A framework for culture assessment. Journal of International Business Studies 1999; 30 (4): 781–98.]. This article examines different approaches to conceptualising and...

Words: 6682 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

It511 Unit3

...Information Systems Project Management Unit 3 Assignment 1 Kaplan University IT511 Professor Chad McAllister February 16, 2013 1. Explain project scope management in terms of its processes. Scope management is the process of defining and controlling the work that is or is not included in the project (Schwalbe, 2012). This outlines to the team and stakeholders the product that will be produced and the processes that will be used to produce that product. The project scope management consists of five processes: * Collect requirements- This process defines the specific details of a product’s functions and features. Defining the processes for creating the products is defined in this process and results in the following outputs: stakeholders’ requirements documentation, a requirements management plan and a requirements traceability matrix. * Define the scope- The project charter, requirements documents and organization process assets are the inputs that are needed to determine the project scope. This process has two outputs the project scope statement and updates to the project documents. * Create the WBS- This process involves decomposing the major deliverable on the project into manageable elements resulting in the WBS and dictionary, a scope baseline and updates to the project documents. * Verify the scope- This is the formalized acceptance of the scope statement by the stakeholders, customers and the project sponsor. If the scope statement is...

Words: 2413 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Tools of Questionnaire

...Designing survey questions on food-related issues Question design toolkit based on a theory of behavioural change Jo d’Ardenne, Sally McManus, Julia Hall Designing survey questions on food-related issues: Question design toolkit based on a theory of behavioural change Jo d’Ardenne, Sally McManus, Julia Hall October 2011 Prepared for the Department of Health Contents Acknowledgements ............................................................................................ Executive summary ........................................................................................... 1 Introduction ............................................................................ 1 1.1 1.2 Background and aims .................................................................................................... 1 The Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) ...................................................................... 2 1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.3 1.3 Why use the Theory of Planned Behaviour? ............................................ 2 What is the Theory of Planned Behaviour? .............................................. 3 Strengths and weaknesses of the Theory of Planned Behaviour ............. 6 Outline of report .............................................................................................................. 6 2 Mapping existing survey questions to TPB constructs ....... 8 2.1 2.2 Review of longitudinal surveys ..................................

Words: 15594 - Pages: 63

Premium Essay

Bis 261 Week 1 Ilab

...theproject requirementswell known, partially known, or mostly unknown (i.e., experimental)? 3. Is theproject domainheavily regulated, moderately regulated, or lightly regulated by government or other outside agencies? 4. Is thesize of the organizationlarge, mid-sized, or small? 5. Is theorganizational culturebureaucratic, mixed, or entrepreneurial? 6. Is theorganization's competitive environmentslow-paced, moderately paced, or fast-paced? STEP 2: Analyze SDLC suitability Based on the information given in the case study, analyze the suitability of a specific Software Development Life Cycle (SDLC) model for Acme Medical Data Storage LLC: • If the last digit of your DSI Number is 0, 1, 2, or 3, use theWaterfall SDLC; • If the last digit of your DSI Number is4, 5, or 6, use theUnified Process; and • If the last digit of your DSI Number is 7, 8, or 9, use anagile SDLC (Scrum or XP). In your analysis, examine your notes from your review of the project and organizational characteristics from Step 1, and make additional notes on the following points. These notes...

Words: 2461 - Pages: 10