Free Essay

Feeling Hungry

In: English and Literature

Submitted By jobz
Words 6303
Pages 26
A User’s Guide to Learning Styles and Math Tools


he journey of developing this book began almost five years ago. After over sixty combined years of service in schools, two of us—John R. Brunsting and Terry Walsh—were coming to the end of our careers as mathematics instructors and administrators. For most of those sixty years, we had the pleasure of working together in Hinsdale Central High School in Hinsdale, Illinois, where we met Harvey Silver and were introduced to the Thoughtful Classroom professional development model he designed with Richard Strong. What we quickly came to learn is that the Thoughtful Classroom really works. Whenever we implemented Thoughtful Classroom strategies in our classrooms or worked with other teachers to help them implement Thoughtful Classroom strategies in their own classrooms, the effect on student learning was palpable—students became more engaged, discussions got richer, student thinking went deeper, and test scores went up. There was, however, one particular Thoughtful Classroom text that always seemed to make the biggest difference in classrooms in the shortest amount of time. That text was Tools for Promoting Active, In-Depth Learning (Silver, Strong, & Perini, 2001; Silver, Strong, & Commander, 1998). The idea behind Tools for Promoting Active, InDepth Learning is simple. It is a collection of classroom-tested tools, or simple teaching “moves,” that teachers can use to foster active, in-depth learning. These tools are based on the principles of effective learning and brain-based instruction and require little or no planning. As such, the tools can serve as “on-the-fly” techniques whenever a learning episode begins to lag, or they can be planned into a lesson or unit ahead of time in order to meet specific objectives.




As we—John and Terry—ended our careers in classrooms and began new ones as staff developers, we began exploring a new question with Harvey: What would a tools-based approach to mathematics instruction look like? Or, more specifically, rather than adapting generic tools to the demands of mathematics instruction, why not develop a new book, one that would respond directly to the concerns of mathematics teachers? The idea of a math-specific tools book excited all three of us, so we set out to align what we were doing in mathematics staff development with this new “math tools” venture. We worked with teachers of mathematics from around the country to select tools that were most relevant to mathematics instruction. We modified other tools to make them more math-centered, and we developed some new ones along the way. As we added tools to our list, we organized them into four distinct styles of instruction: a Mastery style that emphasizes skill acquisition and retention of critical mathematical terms; an Understanding style that builds students’ capacities to find patterns, reason and prove, and explain mathematical concepts; a SelfExpressive style that capitalizes on students’ powers of imagination and creativity; and an Interpersonal style that invites students to find personal meaning in mathematics by working together as part of a community of problem-solvers. However, the more we discussed our aim to develop a book that would provide teachers of mathematics with a repertoire of instructional tools that they could use to differentiate instruction according to different styles, the more we heard a common refrain. It sounded like this: We know that different students have different ways of learning and that we need to engage them all, but isn’t mathematics a worst-case scenario for differentiation? It isn’t difficult to see why mathematics might seem like a worst-case scenario for differentiated instruction. The quantitative nature and sequential organization of mathematical content can make considerations of student differences seem marginal. Add to this the realities of teaching in an age marked by standards, high-stakes tests, and teacher accountability laws—an age when you can pick up almost any mathematics journal and find a piece that sounds the alarm for all-out reform, a piece that sounds like this: Efforts to improve the quality of mathematics education in the United States have been under way for the past half-century. According to the 2007 National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), however, more than half of our fourth graders and almost 70% of our eighth graders still fail to achieve proficiency in mathematics. Our students also continue to fare poorly on international assessments of mathematics achievement. On the 2003 Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) exam, which tests students’ mathematical literacy and problem-solving abilities, students from 23 out of the 39 participating countries significantly outperformed students from the United States. Even our top students lagged behind their counterparts from other nations. Despite decades of reform, then, it is clear that we still have a serious mathematics problem in the United States. Because we live in a world where individuals who possess well-developed mathematical skills are more likely to go to college, more likely to be employed, and more likely to earn higher salaries than those who do not, it is even clearer that we must find a solution.



Clearly, the refrain of mathematics teachers about the difficulties in differentiating instruction had some real wisdom behind it. What they were asking was: Can I afford to differentiate? With the stakes so high, how much attention can I really pay to the differences among my students? After all, the standards I’m being asked to meet aren’t differentiated; they’re uniform, the same for every single student regardless of style or ability level. What we’ve discovered during our journey as teachers of mathematics, administrators, professional developers, and authors is that differentiation is not in the way of meeting high standards, it is the key to meeting them. Our students’ perceptions of mathematics as a discipline, their academic success in our classrooms, and their development as math-literate citizens all depend on our ability to engage all our students, not just our “math whizzes” and high achievers. And no, mathematics is not a worst-case scenario for differentiation. Mathematics can be differentiated as easily as language arts or social studies or any other subject for that matter. All you need to understand are two little words: learning styles.

Few ideas in education have stood the test of time as well as learning styles. The history of style stretches all the way back to the work of Carl Jung (1923), one of the founding fathers of modern psychology. What Jung discovered is that the ways in which people process and evaluate information tend to develop into particular personality types. Years later, Kathleen Briggs and Isabel Myers (1962/1998) took Jung’s work and expanded on it to create a comprehensive model of cognitive diversity. The fruit of Briggs and Myers’ efforts is the world-renowned Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, which, according to recent estimates, some two million people take each year to better understand their strengths and liabilities as learners, workers, and individuals. In the years since the development of the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, new generations of educational researchers including Bernice McCarthy (1982), Carolyn Mamchur (1996), Edward Pajak (2003), Gayle Gregory (2005), and Harvey F. Silver, Richard Strong, and Matthew Perini (2007) have adapted and refined these ideas and helped educators across the globe put learning styles to work in classrooms and schools. In a development of special interest to teachers of mathematics, Harvey F. Silver, Ed Thomas, and Matthew Perini (2003) applied the research on learning styles specifically to the study of mathematics. Out of their work came the identification of four distinct mathematical learning styles, outlined in Figure 1.1. It goes without saying that no student falls completely into one style category. Learning styles should never be used to reduce students to a set of identifiable behaviors neatly summarized in a three-inch by three-inch box. However, most of us tend to develop clear preferences for certain styles, while seeking to avoid other styles. To get a better sense of what the four mathematical learning styles look like in the classroom and to help you discover which styles you prefer, let’s look in on the classrooms of four different teachers of mathematics. While students in each of these four mathematics classrooms are all studying area and perimeter, each teacher is



Figure 1.1

The Four Types of Mathematics Students The Four Types of Mathematics Students

Mastery Math Students . . .

Interpersonal Math Students . . .

Want to . . . learn practical information and set procedures. Like math problems that . . . are like problems they have solved before and that use algorithms to produce a single solution. Approach problem solving . . . in a step-bystep manner. Experience difficulty when . . . math becomes too abstract or when faced with non-routine problems. Want a math teacher who . . . models new skills, allows time for practice, and builds in feedback and coaching sessions.
Understanding Math Students . . .

Want to . . . learn math through dialogue, collaboration, and cooperative learning. Like math problems that . . . focus on real-world applications and on how math helps people. Approach problem solving . . . as an open discussion among a community of problem solvers. Experience difficulty when . . . instruction focuses on independent seatwork or when what they are learning seems to lack real-world application. Want a math teacher who . . . pays attention to their successes and struggles in math.
Self-Expressive Math Students . . .

Want to . . . understand why the math they learn works. Like math problems that . . . ask them to explain, prove, or take a position. Approach problem solving . . . by looking for patterns and identifying hidden questions. Experience difficulty when . . . there is a focus on the social environment of the classroom (e.g., on collaboration and cooperative problem solving). Want a math teacher who . . . challenges them to think and who lets them explain their thinking.

Want to . . . use their imagination to explore mathematical ideas. Like math problems that . . . are nonroutine, project-like in nature, and that allow them to think “outside the box.” Approach problem solving . . . by visualizing the problem, generating possible solutions, and exploring among the alternatives. Experience difficulty when . . . math instruction is focused on drill and practice and rote problem solving. Want a math teacher who . . . invites imagination and creative problem solving into the math classroom.

SOURCE: Silver, Thomas, Perini (2003).

approaching the content in a different way. William Merkel, Sandy Horowitz, Bruce Wong, and Julia Lacomba all teach sixth-grade mathematics, and each teacher has developed a different activity for students to complete. Which of these classrooms would you want to be in the most? Which of these classrooms would you want to be in the least? Once you are familiar with the four classroom activities, rank them in order of preference from most preferred to least preferred.



Mastery Activity
In William Merkel’s classroom, students have just reviewed the formula for finding the area and perimeter of a rectangle. William wants to assess his students’ progress to see if they have mastered the procedure. He provides each student with the drawing of an irregular shape and explains, “We have gone over how to find the area and perimeter of a rectangle. Today we are going to look at an irregular shape. I want you to apply the formulas you already know about area and perimeter to compute the area and perimeter of this irregular shape.”
Figure 1.2 Mathematics Classroom—Mastery Activity


18" 15" 7.5"

Understanding Activity
Sandy Horowitz wants to see if her students understand what measurements are needed to correctly calculate area and perimeter. Her students are familiar with the procedures for finding area and perimeter, and today she is also challenging students with an irregular shape. Sandy starts by providing her students with a diagram without any measurements. She continues, “I want you to figure out what would be the fewest measurements needed to accurately calculate both the area and perimeter of this irregular shape. Then, I want you to explain the process you used to figure out your answer.”
Figure 1.3 Mathematics Classroom—Understanding Activity



Self-Expressive Activity
After studying area and perimeter with his class, Bruce Wong wants to inspire his students to think more divergently about mathematics. Today, Bruce’s class will be working on an open-ended assignment. Bruce tells his students that they will be working with four shapes—one rectangle, one square, one trapezoid, and one equilateral triangle. He elaborates on the assignment, “I want each of you to create your own area and perimeter problem by connecting these four shapes. The shapes can be of any measurement you choose. You can arrange the shapes in any way you want, but you have to be able to solve your problem using only four measurements.” For his students that finish the assignment early, Bruce challenges them to create another problem connecting the same four shapes in a different way. However, this time students must be able to solve the problems they create using only three, two, or even one measurement.

Interpersonal Activity
Julia Lacomba always tries to have her students find personal relevance in mathematics, and the topic of area and perimeter is no different. Today, Julia is asking her students to draw up a floor plan of their homes, illustrating the dimensions of each room. “I want each of you to picture your home. It doesn’t matter how big or small it is, or whether you live in an apartment or a house. Think about each room in your home. What are the dimensions of each room? How do the rooms connect to each other? Draw a floor plan for your home that includes the dimensions of each room.” After students have finished their floor plans with estimated measurements, Julia challenges students to answer these two questions: “Suppose that you wanted to carpet each room of your home (except the bathroom and kitchen). How much carpet would you need? What if you wanted to install crown molding or put up a new wallpaper border in each of these rooms? How much total molding or border would you need?” Each of the four teachers we have just met wants his or her students to learn and understand what area and perimeter are, and how to calculate area and perimeter in different ways. However, each of these teachers has developed a very different activity to use. So, which classroom activity would you enjoy most? Which would you like least or try to avoid? If you have a preference for one activity over the others, then this is the first signal of your mathematical learning style. Your style influences the types of activities you enjoy and how you approach learning and teaching. If you enjoyed William Merkel’s activity, then your dominant style preference is most likely Mastery. Students who prefer the Mastery style learn best step-by-step and enjoy activities with clear procedures and one correct answer. If you selected Sandy Horowitz’s activity, then your dominant style preference is most likely Understanding. Students who prefer the Understanding style enjoy analytical tasks where they have to figure things out and explain or prove their answers. If you were drawn to Bruce Wong’s activity, then your dominant style preference is most likely Self-Expressive. Students who prefer the Self-Expressive style thrive when they are given choices, have the opportunity to be creative, or are asked to explore alternative solutions to problems. If you chose Julia Lacomba’s activity, then your dominant style preference is most likely Interpersonal. Students who prefer the Interpersonal style learn best from others or when the content has a strong relevance to their lives. These students do well with activities that are personal, connected to their lives, or that result in helping others.



Now that you have a deeper understanding of how the four styles play out in mathematics instruction, ask yourself this: What happens if we combine the work of William, Sandy, Bruce, and Julia? What if over the course of the unit on area and perimeter, students completed all four of these activities? We get a differentiated mathematics classroom, one in which every learner gets what he or she wants and needs, while also growing underdeveloped capacities by working in weaker styles. In short, we get an instructional program that asks students to: • Apply formulas, compute accurately, and reinforce skills through practice (Mastery). • Discover patterns, make generalizations, and develop mathematically sound explanations (Understanding). • Think creatively, develop new problems, and try out a variety of problemsolving approaches (Self-Expressive). • Make personal connections and solve real-world math problems (Interpersonal). Thus, style-based mathematics instruction is more than a way to invite a greater number of students into the teaching and learning process. Style-based instruction is, plain and simple, good math—balanced, rigorous, and diverse. Fifth-grade teacher Barb Heinzman puts it this way: What I saw right away was that not only did different students approach mathematics using different learning styles, but real mathematical power required using all four styles. Think about it: If you can’t compute accurately, explain your ideas, discover solutions, and apply math in the real world— you don’t know math. Miss even one of these and you miss the boat. The problem with most math programs is they emphasize just one of these and leave out the rest. By building every unit so it includes all four styles of learning, I support all my students, and I stretch them into areas where they wouldn’t naturally go. (Strong, Silver, & Perini, 2001, p. 79) Barb’s experiences as a teacher of mathematics are borne out by current research showing that style-based teaching leads to improved learning and higher levels of achievement. For example, Robert J. Sternberg (2006) and his colleagues conducted a remarkable series of studies involving diverse student populations including students from Alaskan Eskimo villages, rural Kenya, and a wide range of student populations from across the United States. In these studies, students were taught mathematics (along with other subjects) in five different ways: • A memory-based approach emphasizing identification and recall of facts and concepts; • An analytical approach emphasizing critical thinking, evaluation, and comparative analysis; • A creative approach emphasizing imagination and invention; • A practical approach emphasizing the application of concepts to real-world contexts and situations; and • A diverse approach that incorporated all the approaches. Out of these studies, Sternberg and his colleagues drew two conclusions. First, whenever students were taught in a way that matched their own style preferences,



those students outperformed students who were mismatched. Second, and even more important, students who were taught using a diversity of approaches outperformed all other students on both performance assessments and on multiple-choice memory tests. Sternberg (2006) goes on to say, “In other words, even if our goal is just to maximize students’ retention of information, teaching for diverse styles of learning still produces superior results. This approach apparently enables students to capitalize on their strengths and to correct or to compensate for their weaknesses, encoding material in a variety of interesting ways” (pp. 33–34). So now that we know what learning styles are, what they look like when applied in the mathematics classroom, and that teaching with learning styles in mind leads to improved teaching and higher levels of learning, how do we incorporate them into our own classrooms? By using a variety of tools. Chapters 2 through 5 of this book each contain a set of tools that support one of the four mathematical learning styles. Mastery tools (Chapter 2) increase retention of critical terms and deepen students’ computation and practice skills. Understanding tools (Chapter 3) challenge students to take an analytical approach to mathematics. Self-Expressive tools (Chapter 4) allow students to use their creativity and imagination to explore mathematical ideas. Interpersonal tools (Chapter 5) draw out the personal and social aspects of mathematics.

A quick glance at the table of contents shows that the four mathematical learning styles serve as the framework for this book. Chapters 2 through 5 contain tools that support Mastery, Understanding, Self-Expressive, and Interpersonal styles, respectively. Chapter 6 provides four different strategies for combining tools from all four styles to design more powerful tests, lessons, assessment systems, and units of study. Our intent in designing the text around styles is to make the important goal of differentiating mathematics instruction eminently manageable for teachers. By selecting tools from different chapters of the book, teachers naturally accommodate and challenge learners of all four styles. However, helping teachers of mathematics diversify their teaching practices has not been our sole purpose in writing this book. More generally, Math Tools has been written to provide all mathematics teachers with a repertoire of high-impact instructional techniques that they can begin using tomorrow, techniques that: • Help students meet rigorous academic standards. • Are backed by a reliable research base. • Can be used to meet a host of instructional objectives, from preparing students for new learning all the way to developing performance-based assessments that ask students to show what they have learned. That’s why we begin Chapters 2 through 5 with a Math Tools Matrix. Each Math Tools Matrix lays out the tools within the chapter and provides the reader with an at-a-glance overview of each tool. Take a look at the Math Tools Matrix for Chapter 2 (pages 18–19). Notice how the tools are listed and described down the left side of the matrix. If you follow the top row across the two pages, from left to right, you’ll also notice that the columns are broken up into three distinct sections labeled



“NCTM Process Standards,” “Educational Research Base,” and “Instructional Objectives” (also known as “The Seven P’s”). By tracking a tool across the matrix, you can gather the vital statistics for that tool to help you determine how well it fits your purposes. To see how this process works, let’s use the first tool in the book, Knowledge Cards, to take a quick tour of a Math Tools Matrix.

Vital Statistic 1: Title and Flash Summary
The name of a particular tool is often not enough to give new readers a sense of how a tool works or to jog the memories of readers who are using Math Tools more like a reference text. So, after the page number that tells you where to find the tool, the first thing you’ll see is the tool’s name and a “flash summary” that describes it in one sentence or less. Figure 1.4 below shows this title and flash summary cell for the Knowledge Cards tool.
Figure 1.4 Math Tools Matrix—Knowledge Cards Title and Summary

Knowledge Cards—Students create “flash cards” to visualize and remember complex terms and concepts.

Vital Statistic 2: NCTM Process Standards
In developing ten comprehensive standards for mathematics instruction, the NCTM has provided all mathematics instructors with a map of the terrain—an overarching set of goals to drive decisions about planning, teaching, assessment, and curriculum design. The first five of these standards address specific areas of mathematical content. You will not find these NCTM Content Standards on the Math Tools Matrix. Why? Because tools are not content-specific; they can be used to deliver instruction in any content—from addition facts to the use of geometric principles in Renaissance art. But while tools are not content-specific, they are thinking-specific. That is to say, each tool engages students in one or more mathematical thinking processes. That’s where the back half of the NCTM Standards, known as the Process Standards, come into the picture (National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 2000). These five standards help teachers keep teaching and learning focused on the development of the following key mathematical thinking processes. 1. Problem Solving, or building students’ capacity to analyze problems, develop and implement problem-solving strategies, and evaluate the effectiveness of their solutions. 2. Reasoning and Proof, or developing students’ ability to support claims mathematically, explain how the mathematics they learn works, and justify the choices they make as problem solvers. 3. Communication, or helping students clarify and deepen their thinking through listening, reading, writing, and exchanging ideas with fellow learners and problem solvers.



4. Connections, or expanding students’ opportunities to explore the deep relationships between mathematical concepts as well as how mathematics is used in the world beyond school. 5. Representation, or helping students explore and gain proficiency in the different ways in which mathematical ideas can be expressed and translated into alternate forms. If you follow the Knowledge Cards row across the page (or look at Figure 1.5), you will see that the Communication and Representation fields contain darkened circles, while the other three Process Standards have empty fields. This tells you that using Knowledge Cards will help you and your students meet the Communication and Representation standards.
Figure 1.5 Math Tools Matrix—NCTM Process Standards for Knowledge Cards

MASTERY NCTM PROCESS STANDARDS Reasoning and Proof Problem Solving Communication Representation

Vital Statistic 3: Educational Research Base


When it comes to instruction, we know better than ever before which techniques and strategies work. Numerous “meta-analytic” studies—studies that combine the results from many other research studies to create a larger and more reliable field of data—have helped the educational community to identify a set of best practices that consistently yield results in the classroom. Of these meta-analytic studies, there is one in particular that stands out: Robert Marzano, Debra Pickering, and Jane Pollock’s Classroom Instruction That Works: Research-Based Strategies for Increasing Student Achievement (2001). By comparing the effects of different instructional strategies on student performance, the researchers at Mid-continent Research for Education and Learning (McREL) identified and ranked the nine classroom practices that lead to the greatest gains in student achievement (Marzano, Pickering, & Pollock, 2001). 1. Identifying similarities and differences: Comparisons, analogies, metaphors, and classification strategies.



2. Summarizing and note taking: Teaching students how to collect, record, and condense information. 3. Reinforcing effort and providing recognition: Developing a positive classroom environment in which student work and achievement are a significant part of the classroom conversation. 4. Homework and practice: Strategies that allow students to rehearse and retain their learning both in the classroom and on their own. 5. Nonlinguistic representation: Using visualization, icons, symbols, and graphic organizers to represent learning. 6. Cooperative learning: Creating structures that allow students to work, learn, and develop products and performances as part of productive teams. 7. Setting objectives and providing feedback: Helping students identify goals, monitor progress, and develop plans for improvement. 8. Generating and testing hypotheses: Developing students’ abilities to infer, interpret, and explain through inquiry and investigation. 9. Cues, questions, and advance organizers: Helping students activate prior knowledge, connect to new learning, and see the “structure” of what they’re about to learn. Every tool in this book has been chosen or designed with this essential research in mind. In making this strong connection to Marzano, Pickering, and Pollock’s research, we have attempted to give teachers of mathematics an easy way to plan and implement research-based lessons. Whenever you select a tool for use in your classroom, you can be sure that it has a reliable research base behind it. Plus, this connection to Classroom Instruction That Works gives you a simple way to document how your lesson plans incorporate current and widely respected research. If you follow our left-to-right tour across the Math Tools Matrix on pages 18–19, you’ll see that to Marzano, Pickering, and Pollock’s nine categories, we have added two more: Vocabulary and Writing. Here’s why: 10. Vocabulary: A large number of studies show that direct vocabulary instruction focused on the most critical academic terms (as opposed to long lists of unprioritized words) yields significant improvement in student comprehension and achievement. In fact, Marzano (2004) shows that effective vocabulary instruction can increase student comprehension by as much as 33 percentile points. Put another way, a student whose understanding of content puts him at the 50th percentile without any vocabulary instruction can move all the way to the 83rd percentile if his teacher provides direct instruction in essential academic terms. 11. Writing: “Writing,” Douglas Reeves (2002) tells us, “improves performance in all academic areas” (p. 5). And it’s not hard to see why. When students are given meaningful opportunities to process ideas in writing, to stop the flow of content and summarize, or elaborate on, or explore connections to other disciplines or their own lives, or develop their own imaginative responses to new content (mathematical or otherwise), the depth of their understanding increases dramatically.



Figure 1.6 below shows this second set of columns labeled “Educational Research Base” on the Math Tools Matrix. The Knowledge Cards tool, with its emphasis on sketching and summarizing critical math terms incorporates three different researchbased practices: summarizing and note taking, nonlinguistic representation, and direct vocabulary instruction.

Figure 1.6

Math Tools Matrix—Educational Research Base for Knowledge Cards EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH BASE Generating and testing hypotheses Setting objectives and providing feedback Reinforcing effort and providing recognition

Identifying similarities and differences

Questions, cues, and advance organizers

Summarizing and note taking

Nonlinguistic representations

Homework and practice

Cooperative learning


Vital Statistic 4: Instructional Objectives
Any time we select a tool to use in our classroom or incorporate into our lesson or unit designs, we are seeking a way to meet specific instructional objectives or questions. For example: • • • • • • • How will I prepare students for new learning? How will I present new content in a way that is engaging? How will students practice new skills effectively? How will students process new content deeply? How will I engage students in meaningful problem solving? How will students demonstrate or perform what they know and understand? How will students personalize their learning so that it is meaningful to them?

This list of questions is called the Seven P’s (for more on how to use the Seven P’s to design comprehensive lessons and units, see pages 253–256). The Seven P’s are based on our synthesis of the work of a number of educational researchers concerned with lesson and unit design, including Madeline Hunter (1984), Grant Wiggins and Jay McTighe (2005), and Robert Marzano (2003). By adapting this work to fit the specific demands of the mathematics classroom, the Seven P’s serve as a simple framework for matching tools to your own classroom objectives. So now let’s complete our tour of the Math Tools Matrix. If we follow the Knowledge Cards row all the way down to the last set of columns labeled “Instructional Objectives,”




which contain The Seven P’s, we see two different P’s represented: Processing and Personalizing (see Figure 1.7 below).
Figure 1.7 Math Tools Matrix—Instructional Objectives for Knowledge Cards INSTRUCTIONAL OBJECTIVES

Problem Solving

This means that as an instructional tool, Knowledge Cards can be used to meet either purpose or both depending on how you use it. For example, you can use Knowledge Cards relatively early in the learning process, thereby offering students a way to process new terms deeply through images and words. On the other hand, you might ask students to work in groups to create a set of Knowledge Cards at the end of a unit. In this context, Knowledge Cards are less about processing new content and more about developing a personally meaningful way to review and remember the important content in the unit. In both cases, however, elements of both processing and personalizing are present. The difference lies in which P gets the greater emphasis.

So far, we have put the lion’s share of our attention on the conceptual underpinnings for this book: What are tools? What are learning styles? What’s the relationship between tools and styles? What’s the relationship between tools and other critical factors in instructional decision making, from NCTM Process Standards to current instructional research to elements of quality lesson and unit design? We end this introduction by refocusing our attention on practical issues. So, before taking the plunge into the 64 tools that make up the remainder of this book, here are five different ways you can put these tools into effective practice. 1. Try one out. Every tool in this book is here because it makes a difference in the mathematics classroom. After all, a tool, by our standards, is only a tool if it addresses NCTM Process Standards, has a research base behind it, and plays a vital role in making lessons come to life. In other words, tools work. So, pick a tool, any tool, and watch what happens. Then try a few more. Before you know it, you and









your students will have your own personal favorites, and a new teaching and learning dynamic will be in full swing in your classroom. 2. Use tools to help you meet a particular standard or objective. Looking for ways to increase students’ mathematical reasoning skills? Just use the Math Tools Matrices to find tools that address the NCTM Process Standard for Reasoning and Proof. Or maybe you’re looking to build students’ comprehension by helping them master critical concepts and terms or by infusing writing into the curriculum. Use the matrices to locate vocabulary tools or writing tools, respectively. The point is, the tools in this book can help you and your students meet those standards and objectives that matter most in your particular classroom, even as they shift throughout the year. 3. Individualize instruction. Remember that the tools in this book are organized according to the learning styles they naturally engage. So perhaps you’re working with a highly creative Self-Expressive student who just can’t seem to memorize and follow the steps in a critical problem-solving procedure. Try a tool like Math Recipes, which will allow students to make a creative comparison between cooking and problem solving and design a “recipe card” that outlines the steps in the procedure. If you want to help Interpersonal learners who wilt during independent seatwork to increase their proficiency as problem solvers, tap into their social nature with tools that either connect problem solving to the world beyond school (e.g., Real-World Connections or Who’s Right?) or that challenge them to work as part of a productive problem-solving team (e.g., Cooperative Structures for Promoting Positive Interdependence). Style-based individualization works because every style has identifiable patterns of strength and weakness. Mastery learners may have no problem memorizing terms or following procedures, but often experience real difficulty with open-ended problems (“You mean there is no right answer?!”) or high levels of abstraction. Understanding learners may be great at thinking their way through challenging problems, but their hearts often drop into their stomachs when they’re asked to work as part of a team. As Robert Sternberg (2006) has shown, allowing students of mathematics to think and work in their strong styles gives them a much better chance at mastering key content and skills. Even better, when students’ preferences are accommodated, they become more likely to try to stretch as learners, meaning you can use tools to teach to their strengths and to challenge them to try working in new styles that they might otherwise avoid. 4. Differentiate instruction for the entire class. While personalized instruction is a powerful teaching and learning model, the truth is that teachers do not often have the luxury of working like doctors, who see their patients one at a time. Teachers work with entire classes, groups of students brought together largely by virtue of their age and by scheduling logistics. The question that this model consistently raises is, How can I work optimally with all of my students? Math tools, organized by style, make the work of differentiating instruction and assessment for every learner a manageable proposition. All you need to do is rotate the tools you use in your classroom across all four styles. That way, you can rest assured that your: • Mastery learners are getting the routine and direction they thrive on while they develop their ability to think conceptually and creatively. • Understanding learners have the opportunity to think logically and independently while growing their capacities as thoughtful team members.



• Self-Expressive learners get the chance to use their imaginations while learning how to manage and master mathematical procedures. • Interpersonal learners can learn as part of a problem-solving community, where mathematics connects strongly to the real world, while they build their critical reasoning skills. As you implement new tools, keep track of which styles you seem to favor and which tools seem to make the biggest impact among your students. And don’t forget about Task Rotation (page 222), a strategy that uses tools from all four styles to create truly differentiated assessments. 5. Design more powerful lessons, assessments, and units. While tools work well on their own, they can also be used as “instructional building blocks.” In Chapter 6, you’ll find a set of strategies for selecting and combining tools to create larger designs, from lesson plans, to differentiated tests and assessments, to standardsbased units of study. These strategies will help you develop a tools-based approach to thinking your way through the bigger picture of lesson planning and unit design.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Re: Week 12 Reflection

...Hungry Jack is a franchise of the international burger king corporation and has operated in Australia since 1971. Today, Hungry jack’s is in every state in Australia with over 340 stores.. There are so many Hungry Jacks stores are located in Victoria State, but I have chosen the one, which is located on the Swanston street. As this store is the closest to our university, therefore it is the most visited by me. This is the double-store building. HUNGRY jack logo looks like this. It consists of red and yellow colors. Therefore, when u enter into the store you can notice that there is an combination of 2 colors red and yellow. From the outside you can observe what is happening in the store and also read the menu as this shop has been made of glass. There are 2 automatic doors in this shop. One door faces to the Swanston Street, and the other door faces to the Latrobe Street. People are using 2 doors to enter and to exit, depends where r they going. I usually come around 12:30-1:30 to have lunch, whenever I come its always busy. The first thing I do is line up as everyone does, some of them are reading the menu to decide what to have for lunch, and I have noticed a group of high school students where shaking their phone to get a free or half price food. Their face emotion was very excited I think for the Hungry Jack, they have designed a very good phone application device, because it can promote the place and making it more popular by making customer to check......

Words: 503 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Gs 1115 Module 1 Ex 1

...night gets darker and scarier, the puppy gets closer to home however he is surrounded by wolves. Unbeknownst to him, his best buddy, the horse has escaped the barn and is coming to his rescue with friends. The pup starts barking at the wolves but he is tiny. The horses arrive just in time to save him and he is reunited with his family. At the end of the commercial there is the Budweiser logo and the hashtag “ #bestbuds”. Every time I watch this ad I cry. It is just so cute, and as a dog owner pulls at my heart strings. As a human, it makes me connect with the puppy and his fear of being lost and lonely and his search for home. What draws me most to this advertisement is that there is no beer, this ad is not selling beer, it is selling the feeling that you want to have when you drink beer: family, love, friendship. Throughout the commercial, the focus is on the puppy and the horse, their friendship and bond. How they yearn for each other when they are apart, and how they will go through hell or high water to get back to each other and keep each other safe. The whole time you are watching, you do not think this is about beer; rather you are just enthralled in the commercial and want to see how it ends. But this is not a commercial you can forget. I think...

Words: 1802 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...that we, humans, can have or experiment with happy, hard, sad moments and also feelings that we need to deal with our best attitude and maturity. At the moment when all this things and emotions happen, many people prefer to take their time to breath and calm their selves, sometimes they prefer to eat junk food until they feel good or just go outside to smoke a cigarette, and more things that they do depending of the age of the person, but the point is that, all of us do something to feel better. Is interesting that people have their own favorite place or environment, where they can express their feelings, communicate with their own soul or just feel safe.   As I said above, all we have our hard moments in life; we are humans and we have feelings and emotions. With this essay, I wanted to express something to you that happened to me yesterday, and I didn´t know about it.   Yesterday, I was so happy because my mom said that she was going to prepare lasagna, my favorite food. I went to the university very excited, wetting to lunchtime, so I can eat a big piece of melted cheese that comes from the juicy lasagna. When I finished my classes I didn’t care to say bye to my friends, I just ordered a taxi to go home fast and eat it. When I arrived, my mom said that she had a problem; she burned the lasagna. I looked at her eyes very angry; I was passing for all my bad moments because I was really hungry, and the first thing that I saw was a black burned lasagna. I said many bad......

Words: 836 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

This Taste Good, It Must Not Be Healthy

...sweetness of this treat. The chunks of chocolate are just a bonus to the ad, as chocolate is lovable by a majority of people. This ad has a lot of components and bright colors, but they all catch the attention and make the reader want and crave a perfectly sweet, delightful light snack that is also healthy to eat. The company did a fine job sending out the message to all ages and both sexes. First, Special K is a well-known brand to eat for low calorie, healthy snacks and breakfast items. When buying this product, the customer is aware of the motive of this brand. The ad shows that you can eat something that is not bad for your body but still tastes delicious. The Aristotelian Rhetorical Technique used behind this is pathos. It gives the feeling of satisfying ones cravings without it being horrible to the body, or gaining any weight. The value is health, and the ad is saying you can still have great health even if you buy this product and eat it. In addition to the low calorie snack, the ad shows a lot of red and pink colors, along with hearts, flowers, birds, balloons and even two baby angels. The colors are pretty, and symbolize fun and make the reader...

Words: 890 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Personal Narrative: My Current Art Class

...frustrating. I dig it though; it’s hella nice to not think for once, and just let my limbs run on autopilot. I’m also taking an English class which is a mix of creative writing, religious studies, and philosophy—the catching being that all students are all required to partake in a ritualistic practice to enrich our interior lives (e.g. meditation, yoga, hiking, centering prayer, journaling etc.). and I’m curious to see how this may potentially shift my creative outlets. I’m certain the pursuit will still come from the same cerebral or intellectual manifestations as all my personal filth does, but this philosophy class, I think, will jolt something out of me that isn’t so damn rooted in exorcising inner demons. Ideally, I won’t leave the class feeling like I spooned myself down to my...

Words: 520 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Motivation Worksheet

...approach affects motivation. Achievement motivation is what pushes some people to their full potential because they possess the drive and willingness to surpass their peers. They want to excel over everyone else. If a person is motivated to be number one they can become big wigs in a company or even own a business. 2. Theorists vary on why we experience emotions. Discuss at least two different theories related to emotional experiences. The drive theory in a nut shell is something a person goes after in order to meet a biological need. If a person is hungry they will eat something to curve their appetite. If a person is thirsty they will drink something to rehydrate themselves. If a person is feeling lonely they will surround themselves with friends and family. When a person finds something that fills the void and makes them feel better, then the next time the same feelings emerge, the more likely the same action will be repeated to get the same satisfaction. Incentive theories state that a person’s behavior is based on end rewards, money, and recognition. If a person is participating in a game of sport, they are going to try and do their very best to receive recognition for winning or a trophy for scoring the highest. 3. Choose one positive and one negative emotion related to being a student. Provide one example for each of how these emotions may affect your performance in class. 4. Summarize two theories of intelligence....

Words: 316 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

A Love Letter for U

... I spent a year test-driving the wisdom of the ages, current scientific studies, and tips from popular culture. If I followed all the advice, I wanted to know, would it work?   Well, the year is over, and I can say: It did. I made myself happier. And along the way I learned a lot about how to be happier. Here are those lessons.  1. Don’t start with profundities. When I began my Happiness Project, I realized pretty quickly that, rather than jumping in with lengthy daily meditation or answering deep questions of self-identity, I should start with the basics, like going to sleep at a decent hour and not letting myself get too hungry. Science backs this up; these two factors have a big impact on happiness. 2. Do let the sun go down on anger. I had always scrupulously aired every irritation as soon as possible, to make sure I vented all bad feelings before bedtime. Studies show, however, that the...

Words: 604 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


... look up, look to the sides, just don’t look at the reflection in the bar mirror She’s a red dress and thick rimmed glasses and all sorts of wit and intelligence in conversation. Next to her is a man that’s just a little more dim witted and a flannel shirt that was pressed just slightly too recently. And all around them are duplicates; replicants- people that are acquaintances or soon to be fair weather friends. All around them are life paths that they were one butterfly away from taking. The woman in the red dress is yawning now- opening her mouth so wide people near her can see the fills in her molars- but she doesn’t yawn consciously. She is uncouth without even giving a thought to it. She is feeling tired. More importantly, she’s feeling hungry- trying to eat in all the air that is around to prove to herself that her heart still beats and it’s not all just a dream. Among all of the people by the bar there is color- various colors- some bright, some subdued and pastel. The coloring of their clothing tell stories that are alike in their uniqueness. She lays one hand on the bar and shakes her head. He looks at her, concerned, and asks what’s wrong. “Nothing,” she lies. “Are you sure?” he asks. “Yes. Let’s dance.” She takes his hand out of his pocket, lifts him away from the bar, and they sway back and forth, back and forth, until all the notes blend into one beat. Until she can create the illusion of perfect harmony. «......

Words: 292 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Angel on My Shoulder

...young teen after all, but that time with her on those mornings meant the world to me. The difference in music we had was only skin-deep That reminds me of one small difference between us: she was an amazing cook, while I still have trouble boiling noodles. Salmon cakes, pasta, and chocolate peanut butter no bake cookies were a few of my favorites. Everything she made was all so good. You could walk into her house and pass out from the smells alone. It makes me hungry just thinking about it. As we both grew older, we grew even closer. When my mom and I would fight, which happened many times, she always took my side, even when I was clearly in the wrong. She defended and protected me. I could count on my gram to listen to me, support me in all my decisions. She would encourage me to do my best at everything I did and taught me to put my whole heart into it. There was a day where I felt a “weird feeling” like something bad happened, Hernandez Page 2 and I didn’t understand why I was having this feeling, so I called my gram, only to have...

Words: 599 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

How Does George Alagiah Present the Personal Conflict He Experiences as a Reporter in Somalia?

...Africa', we are subjected to a variety of literary techniques. Through George Alagiah's vivid imagery and constant pathos, we are given the ability to visualise the scenes clearly and share feelings only induced by his emotive language. His personal conflict is portrayed through his blatant emotional detachment and inability to expand the relationship between a reporter and a victim . First of all, one of Alagiah's more subtle deliveries of technique. When describing the unfolding of death in the fourth paragraph, he uses specific sentence structure to clearly put across the length of the process; "That simple, frictionless, motionless deliverance from a state of half-life to death itself". By creating long, ongoing sentences, Alagiah shows that the build up to death is an almost never ending progression, until pure death itself. This, as well as evoking pity, makes the reader feel closer to the event- the death of Habiba. "The search for the shocking is like the craving for a drug" This use of a simile emphasises the addictive nature of the journalistic process. This shows that Alagiah feels shameful, like a drug user, that he can not help but continue to report on the devastating scenes. Again, we are shown that George is torn between his purpose as a journalist, and his own personal feelings. The futility of the report becomes apparent when Alagiah writes, "I resolved there and then that I would write the story of Gufgaduud with all the power and purpose I could......

Words: 675 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Importance of Empathy in the Workplace

...empathy often have no idea what they do; they just know that they like people, they enjoy working with and helping people, and they value people as individuals. In a recent presentation to healthcare professionals on empathy in New York City, the audience concurred that healthcare professionals do exhibit empathy most of the time - to their patients. When asked about the use of empathy with colleagues or with family or even with themselves, the audience seemed pretty certain they could do a better job. What is Empathy? Empathy is the ability to put oneself in the shoes of another person. The positive psychology definition is: The quality of feeling and understanding another person's situation in the present moment -- their perspectives, emotions, actions (reactions) -- and communicating this to the person. So you know what they are feeling, or at least you suspect you know what they are experiencing, and you communicate that to elicit further discussion or clarification. Empathy is an Emotional Intelligence (EI) competency. In the field of Emotional Intelligence, there are four clusters of competencies and eighteen competencies. The four clusters are: - Self-Awareness - Self-Management - Social Awareness - Relationship Management Empathy falls under Social Awareness. This skill reflects a person's ability to connect with others and to relate to them which is an essential skill in building and managing healthy relationships. Without the ability to understand......

Words: 668 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Nursing Communication

...paraphrasing is important because it is a way of validating that you have understood accurately what was said and allows the patient to verify their statement (Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, 2008, p. 54). It is more to the point and shorter than the patients initial statement allowing you to focus on the main features of the first statement (Arnold and Boggs, 2011 p. 186). Times when you would use paraphrasing would be just after a patient has told you a statement about feelings or thoughts and you need to confirm what you are hearing is correct, it is important to paraphrase correctly so the patient dose not think you are trying to change what they have said or think you are putting words in their mouth. Below are two examples of paraphrasing with Mrs Johns. Example 1: Mrs Johns: “I am a little bit anxious today because my ulcer has been hurting for a little while now and I have had trouble walking around I hope it wont always be like this”. Me: “Mrs Johns what you are saying is that your in pain and feeling anxious because you think your leg ulcer might affect your mobility?” Example 2: Mrs Johns:...

Words: 1980 - Pages: 8

Free Essay


...Øvelse: | Gentagelser: | Forklaring: | Lunges: | 3x8 | Stil dig med let spredte ben. Tag et skridt frem, spænd op i ryggen så den er ret. Bøj bagerste knæ, Og arbejd derfor ned ad og ikke frem! Løft dig derefter op igen og tilbage på plads. Hold øje med at dit forreste knæ, ikke kommer ud over tæerne. | Squat med vægt: | 3x8 | Stil benene i skulderbredde, og med fødderne let pegende udad. Ret ryggen. Bøj i benene som hvis du skulle tisse i naturen. Der er vigtigt at benene gør arbejdet og ikke overkroppen. Kom så langt ned du kan, men stop når ryggen ikke længere er ret. Fokuser på at presse knæene udad, specielt når du går op igen. Vælg selv vægten, men husk det er bedre at lave kvalitet med minde vægt, end omvendt. Er det nemt, skal du gå op i kilo! | Vægt hop: | 3x8 | Vælg håndvægte på 3-4 kg. Ret ryggen og gå ned i squat. På vej op skal du komme videre op i et hop, så højt du kan. Fokuser på landingen, hold knæene i fast spænding udad. De må ikke slingre og falde indad. | Full body squat m. Vægt: | 3x8 | Hold en vægtskive med to hænder ca. 5 kg. Ret ryggen. Gå ned i squat/hug til skiven rammer jorden, kom tilbage på standart position men fortsæt bevægelsen i armene så skiven bliver løftet over hovedet. | Kettlebell swings: | 3x8 | Stil dig i let bøjede knæ med tæerne let pegende udad. spænd op i mave og ryg. Sving kettlen op og ned. Ryggen skal forblive ret, det er vigtigt at det ikke er armene som arbejder. Stop svinget når dine arme er vandret. | ......

Words: 1228 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Emotions of Us

...5, 2014 University of Phoenix PSY/355 One very popular method for uncovering basic emotions is through facial expressions. From the moment we are born we demonstrate emotion through facial expressions. In babies, it is very important that they are able to demonstrate their feelings through facial expressions. There are many different kinds of emotions that every human being experiences during certain situations. Some emotions would be anger, sadness, fear, happiness, love, surprise, anxiety, amongst many others. Facial expressions make it very simple to be able to notice what kind of emotion the individual is going through. Babies are unable to communicate by speech or bodily gestures when they are born or in their first years of life, therefore it is very important for people to be able to associate the baby’s facial expression to their emotion. When a baby is sad they will make a certain facial expression letting the parents know something is wrong. Same goes if the baby was in pain, hungry, or tired. Because kids and adults are able to speak and communicate both through speech and body language, it might make it seem as if facial expressions were no longer needed to know how someone is feeling, but in research it is still very important. For example, a doctor would be able to tell if his patient is in pain or afraid even if they do not want to let the doctor know something is wrong just by the patient’s facial expression. Social workers understand that facial......

Words: 986 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Octopus Emotions

...another animal or human, its emotion would be aggressive and it would show on its behavior. Lots of people opine that animals are capable of a range of emotions, such as happiness, sadness; empathy, grief, curiosity, anger, anxiety and fear. Example: A naughty dog that goes on the carpet and gnaws up everything is probably not actively trying to punish its absent person for being gone so long. But it might be feeling lonely and anxious, and not know how to behave when left on its own for so much time. (Taken from: 2. Yes, it does have several emotions, mostly shown when attacked. Emotions in octopus: The octopus changes their skin color, pattern and texture because of certain specialized skin cells. This change matches their mood. It also changes to communicate with or warn octopuses. Also, it does this to hide from predators. In captivity, Pacific octopuses even show both personalities and emotion. Some octopuses are shy, others are bold. Some are aggressive and others are fearful. When hungry, they have been found to invert their bodies, pointing their suckers upward, in a bowl shape-like a person’s begging hands. If the octopus does not receive food, he or she will swim back while turning a bright red color. This is believed to be an invertebrate’s display of the anger emotion Octopus can eject a thick, blackish ink which means it is being attacked and it is scared. FACTS: -The octopus's......

Words: 329 - Pages: 2