Free Essay

Flatland

In: English and Literature

Submitted By livhannalla
Words 1499
Pages 6
“Flatland” by Edwin Abbott

I would like to start out by saying that I’ve never read a book that completely revolves around a mathematical subject; it was different to say the least and it definitely took some effort to pay attention to what I was reading in the beginning. I don’t mean the math part or the author’s use of geometric shapes, I actually found these to be the simplest concepts in the book; simple enough for a child to understand even. I think it was very organized as well, which made it really easy to follow. Abbott separated different subjects in different sections; twenty two sections made up the book and they all had titles explaining what each section was about which made it super easy to go back and reread a certain section without any trouble. So if I wanted to go back and read about the colors that were once used in Flatland to differentiate people of different classes, I would look back to the contents page and know that section nine is where ‘the Colour Bill’ was discussed.
It was the social concept that I had to really sit down and think about. “Flatland” takes place in a fictional country where the citizens are geometric shapes; the priests, who weren’t really priest as the author later explains, but the administrators, the scientists, the engineers, and the ruling class of Flatland who oversee all things of merit, are circles. Other men can have many sides; the more sides, the higher up the social class they become. An additional side is given to the off springs of the following generation. For example, the writer, a square, has children who are pentagons and their children are hexagons. The women in Flatland however are straight lines and they can never have sides or be anything other than straight line. At first, I found it very strange reading a number (no pun intended) of things; for example women are physically

intimidating in Flatland since they’re shaped like needles and they could “accidently” kill or seriously injure their male counterparts by simply running into them but they didn’t enjoy many civil liberties or civil rights, in fact they were considered stupid! I remember reading the final couple of paragraphs in part one, section 12, the square explains that the men in Flatland had to speak a different or dumbed-down dialect when addressing a woman. They were probably the most harmful beings in Flatland yet they were treated so negatively and not given proper educations to be qualified for any position other than that of a housewife. I realize that the book was written more than a century ago and there was no doubt that there were parallels (again, no pun intended) between the fictional Flatland and our own nonfictional world. I think that may have been the reason I chose it in the first place; it reminded me a little of George Orwell’s “Animal Farm” where animals were the characters used to portray a serious political issue we humans faced. Anyone reading “Flatland” at the time it was first published would have come to the conclusion that Abbott was in favor of women obtaining higher educations, which, I can imagine, must have been very controversial. I did some research on the book, and I read that Abbott wrote the book with the penname ‘A Square’, which may have taken some of the heat off of him for the suggestions he made. I also found the concept of recognition hard to comprehend. How did these shapes feel each other if they didn’t have hands? And wouldn’t that have been inappropriate? Even if only the lower class were accustomed to this since they weren’t taught the art of seeing, I can imagine it was not trip being felt by a stranger instead of shaking their hands. This may have been the downside of having geometric shapes for characters of an alternate universe. So where does the law draw the line between feeling someone in order to recognize them and saying that it’s sexual harassment? This logic just seemed flawed.

There were no mathematical equations or formulas to be used, but Abbott used a lot of illustrations to aid the readers’ imagination on several accounts. He would illustrate how certain things looked to a citizen of flatland or how the citizens of Lineland or Spaceland see things or other people in their country. At one point, the square has a discussion with his hexagonal grandson in which the grandson theorizes that if a side that can be squared or raised to the second power, it can also mean that it can be raised to the third power or be cubed. We know this is possible because we live in a three dimensional world. But the square quickly rejects the idea and calls the boy a fool! But not too long after, he receives a visit from a circle from Spaceland, a sphere! The sphere tries and tries to convince the square that his reality is superior to that of Flatland’s, that it surpasses the laws of squaring sides and rather cubes them. You would think he would believe him since only a few hours before this encounter, the square dreams of going to Lineland and meeting the country’s king and tries to convince him that his reality is superior to that of the line’s. The line even tried to attack the square but he quickly backed out of the Country and seemingly disappeared to the naïve monarch. The same happened with the square except the sphere took him on a trip that shook the very roots of his beliefs, the very beliefs he was that would punish him for sharing what he saw that night, for sharing the truth! When the square realizes this, he starts treating the sphere like he’s the Messiah. He starts calling him things like ‘my Lord’ and ‘gracious Teacher’, etc. and he later says that he has the preach the gospel of Truth as it were.
When all of this is over, and the square returns to his home in Flatland, he is welcomed by the Resolution of the Council warning all those who believed or preached of land of three dimensions that they those are crimes against the State and they are punishable by death or

imprisonment. The square decides to talk to his grandson since his wife’s mental capacity was unequipped to handle this sort of thing. But the smart adolescent hexagon realized that these discussions he had with his grandfather were a crime. This discouraged the square and he later decided that maybe it was for the best. He tried to keep these things he saw to himself but he blurted them out in a meeting at the district Prefect’s palace. He was arrested and brought to court where only a couple of isosceles triangles who couldn’t possibly comprehend much of what was said, they were loyal to the law.
So our beloved square was imprisoned, he compared himself to Prometheus, a titan from Greek Mythology who was bound by the gods for bringing fire down to the mortals. The readers don’t know if the truth of the third dimension is hidden by the government but if had to guess, I would say that they probably did and held that truth from the people of Flatland but then again maybe they didn’t. Maybe they were just happy with the reality that they were a part of and didn’t want to open their minds to the idea. We see evidence of this in our own history; Galileo, for example, was deemed a heretic after sharing his findings on the Sun’s position in the Solar System and was placed under house arrest. Dozens like him were excommunicated or even beheaded for going public. If this novella had a thesis, I think it would for us Spacelanders to keep an open mind for new ideas, or theories, or truths; that having a mind and different beliefs should not be against the law even if we don’t accept those beliefs to be true. I think Abbott wants us Spacelanders to have tolerance for those around us whether they are of the opposite gender, a different social class, or color. I don’t know what affect this book had on the public when it first came out, I never really heard anyone saying that it changed the way women were treated in the late 19th century, but it may have made some room for discussion of things that

were not possible then, like women going to college, or voting or whatever. I think Abbott wanted the inhabitants of this world of our to be educated enough to not be prejudice, and to leave some room for others to believe what they want to believe because as a great philosopher once said, “it is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.”

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Flatland

...In the book Flatland, there can be numerous motives that the author is trying to tell the reader through very detailed text in the story. Often the author mixes a scientific plot with a narrative figure telling the story. Many of the motives in this story express themselves and eventually intertwine to answer and solve the main characters’ problems in the story. One of the motives that the author is trying to reach to his audience is the explanation of higher dimensions to a second dimension creature also know as the square. The author includes this in his story to educate the reader or the audience on a better understanding of math, and how dimensions play a big role with geometric shapes. The author follows this idea through the whole book, as this motive shapes the main character’s personality of how he acts to his fellow flatlanders. Through the beginning of the story, a square explains many of the traits of Flatland to his readers. In the story he usually explains his ideas or motives to the reader to help better their understanding of Flatland and his environment that surrounds him. “Imagine a vast sheet of paper on which straight lines, triangles, squares, pentagons, hexagons and other figures.” (Abbott 15). Throughout the story, a square comes to the conclusion that his simple life is the greatest and the most superior to all of the shapes of Flatland; Not knowing that there are more answers and adventures to be discovered, which might change his life and understanding...

Words: 299 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Archetypes In Flatland

...What if all we saw was 2D shapes? What f there were no depth in anything we looked at in our everyday lives? That I how things are presented in the book Flatland written by E. Abbott. The book is about shapes in different hierarchy that only see flat things hence the "flat land" part. Besides the fact of everything looking flat to them, there is a hierarchy problem within the shapes and some shapes are more important than other shapes. In the book, the men and women are shapes. The men are polygons and the women are lines. The few the equal sides the person has the lower you are in society and you are more looked down upon. For example sense an isosceles triangle only had two equal sides there for an odd ball and is looked down in society for that. Then you have things like pentagons and squares that are high in society because of there sides, but the circle is the highest of them all because it has infinity sides....

Words: 664 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Monitoring Satisfaction to Ensure Retention

...Welcome Metric Consultancy Ltd A Group company of Metric Global Measuring Modeling Mentoring The MOSTER System CEM Model that is used in 30 countries Measuring Modeling Mentoring Customer Satisfaction Measurement : What we always believed to be Improved Quality Increased Satisfaction 6.8 7.2 0 10 5 7.8 8.4 0 Decreased Satisfaction 10 Poor Quality Measuring Modeling Mentoring Satisfaction as `experience’ is not one homogenous state Measuring it as just One Number is oversimplification. Satisfaction is a panorama of several shades / states Disgust Dissatisfaction Satisfaction Delight Measuring Modeling Mentoring Customer Satisfaction : what every one does MEAN SCORE 0 10 Dissatisfaction Satisfaction Delight TOP BOX SCORE Measuring Modeling Mentoring Customer Satisfaction is also discontinuous Dissatisfaction Satisfaction Delight Less Satisfied Satisfied More Satisfied Excited Disappointed Measuring Modeling Mentoring Satisfaction : Continuous or Categorical Variable ? Continuous Variable Age in years, Weight, Blood pressure reading , Temperature, Concentrations of pollutants Satisfaction : Rating on a scale Categorical variable (Items can be sorted into categories like sorting into bins) Sex Nationality race/ethnicity favorite pet Dissatisfaction-Satisfaction-Delight Measuring Modeling Mentoring Satisfaction as `Continuous Variable’...

Words: 832 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Helga Flatland

...Helga Flatland Helga Flatland er en norsk forfatter som ble født og oppvokst i Flatdal, Telemark 16. september i 1984. Der vokste hun opp med sine…… Flatland er Norges eneste landsby, og det er hun stolt av. På videregående gikk Helga musikk, dans og drama ved Skien videregående skole. Det var der hun begynte å skrive og ble interessert til å lære språk. Etter videregående flyttet hun til Bergen for å starte på språkskole. Der lærte hun mye om hele språkstriden, og det ble mye skriving. Da hun var ferdig på den skolen, tok hun utdannelse på Universitetet i Oslo, Westerdahls School of Communication. På den skolen laget hun mye reklame de to første årene. Da jobbet hun mye med å forkorte. Etter de to årene skulle hun plutselig begynne å skrive lange tekster. Da slet hun veldig mye. Det var en stor overgang fra å forkorte til å skrive lange tekster. På Westerdahls fikk hun en skriveoppgave som til slutt ble begynnelsen av Flatlands debutroman Reis hvis du må. Bli hvis du kan. Oppgaven gikk ut på å skrive langt. Men siden hun hadde jobbet så mye med reklame, fikk hun skrivesperre. Da fikk hun råd om å skrive om noe som var kjent for henne og som hun var interessert for. Helga var veldig nysgjerrig på hvorfor så mange meldte seg frivillig til å dra til Afghanistan. En skriveøvelse på skolen Westerdahls ble begynnelsen av Flatlands debutroman Reis hvis du må. Bli hvis du kan. Et kapittel, skrevet i skoletiden, ble relativt snart til romanen som hun fikk Tarjei Vesaas...

Words: 307 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

3rd Dimensions In Flatland

...The 3rd dimension is not one that can be easily imagined without visiting it. I had trouble picturing it until I experienced it myself. It allows for more ways to move and in the way you can see. In Flatland, one can move left and right as well as forward and backwards. Those are the first two dimensions; length and height. However, direction does not stop there. Instead, there is a 3rd dimension; one of width as well. One way to think of this is to imagine stacking planes on top of each other; think of two shapes overlapping each other. This is the theory of width, the 3rd dimension. In the first dimension, crossing over a wall is impossible. In the second dimension, a person can cross a wall by going around it. Now in the third dimension,...

Words: 468 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Reflective Essay On Flatland

...The book that has influenced me the most would have to be Flatland by Edwin A. Abbott. This novel tells the story of a two dimensional shape who goes by the name of A Square and discovers the realm of the third dimension. The story has influenced because as a result of having read it I know approach not only science and math problems in a different perspective, but I approach life with a new set of eyes. In the novel the square has a sphere revealed to him, which was a traumatic incident to the square. Now, being a two dimensional shape all he can see in front of him are lines. The closer the object the brighter it is and as a result a shape like a circle would appear to be a straight line who is bright in the middle and gets dimmer towards...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Slaughterhouse-Five and Flatland Comparison Paper

...Slaughterhouse-Five and Flatland Following in the footsteps of many science-fiction authors that came before them, both Kurt Vonnegut and Edwin A. Abbott employ the use of other dimensional creatures in order to teach the reader a lesson about society. In Vonnegut’s Slaughterhouse-Five and Abbott’s Flatland, the authors provide the reader with hope that maybe ignorance and immorality can be abolished and that it is possible for a society to exist without these concepts, before ultimately disillusioning the reader and showing them that it is impossible for a society to exist without this, even in other dimensions. In Flatland this is shown through the sphere who, even as the prophet of the third dimension, cannot comprehend the concept of a fourth dimension. In Slaughterhouse-Five this is shown through the Tralfamadorians who, even as supremely intelligent fourth-dimensional creatures, cannot understand the idea of morality, and are more ignorant than any human being has ever been. By showing how creatures can have such a high level of ignorance and such little morality, the authors are trying to teach a lesson to the human race; ignorance and immorality will never stop occurring, as they are the inevitable fate of mankind. In the novel Flatland, Edwin A. Abbot gives the reader a glimpse into the eyes of a two-dimensional creature who must learn a lesson about the third dimension. A three-dimensional sphere ascends from space and attempts to teach the two-dimensional square...

Words: 1347 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Fijian Pottery Analysis

...abandoned until this is restored naturally Terrace (noun) - a piece of sloped plane that has been cut into a series of successively receding flat surfaces or platforms, which resemble steps, for the purposes of more effective farming Fortified Sites in Fiji Early visitors to Fiji focused a great deal of attention on the predominance of warfare and the presence of fortifications. Fortifications in Fiji consisted of ring-ditch forts in the sedimentary costal flatlands, as well as ditch and bank fortified sites on the hill slopes and ridges. Oral tradition stipulates the main source for details regarding the basis of warfare and fortifications in Fiji. Most of these trace their origin to around the sixteenth century. A migration of a population from the west of the archipelago carried with them more advanced subsistence skills such as building fortified villages. According to the Fijian researcher Palmer, who conducted field investigations, hypothesized that based on their distribution in alluvial flatlands, ring ditch forts were a post European response to European contact, population increases, and agricultural intensification Upland fortified sites were dependent on shifting cultivation for subsistence. It was concluded that archaeological evidence of continuity in the ceramic sequence, changing social hierarchies,...

Words: 583 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Broback Mountain

...Brokeback Mountain Annie Proulx Ennis is a man of few words, whose actions often speak for him. When Ennis meets Jack, he is saddled with responsibility, engaged to Alma, and at the mercy of a conservative Wyoming culture that has no place for a gay ranch hand. Yet Ennis has nowhere else to go and no other profession at which to try his hand. An orphaned high school dropout dependent on hardship funds and raised to be pragmatic, he is trapped in a life over which he has little control. Rather than run off with Jack and try to build a happy life, as Jack repeatedly suggests, Ennis considers the reality of it all: the violent opposition that would greet two gay ranchers living together, his marriage to Alma, his love for his daughters. The life he builds, which involves financial hardship and eventually child support, effectively prohibits him from escaping. Ennis is a prisoner of the life he has been born into. Without the financial wherewithal to escape, without any sort of community support for his sexual proclivities, and imbued with the belief that one must bear whatever one can’t fix, Ennis is fated to live out the rest of his life as a man who tasted happiness once but has never again reached that peak. Though it is Jack Twist who, we infer, is murdered by those who oppose his sexual orientation, it is Ennis Del Mar—living in his trailer, confined to a sad life on the broad, flat plains of Wyoming—who is the story’s tragic soul. Jack Twist Jack Twist is the more...

Words: 1880 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Research

...administrative Region. Among the activities are the motorcade, fashion show, photo exhibit, TRECON (Tourism Related Extablishment Convention), etc. .First Mass Anniversary Celebration March 31-Butuan City- A commemoration of Magellan’s landing and planting of the cross on March 31, 1521 at Mazau, butuan, signifying the celebration of the 1st Easter Mass in the Philippine soil. 2nd Siargao Invitational Game Fishing Tournament-April 17-19 Pilar, Siargao Island-Surigao del Norte .Renowned anglers from all over the world converge to join the biggest ever game-fishing in the country. This game-fishing tournament is the first ever in Mindanao. .4th Surigao del Norte National Flatland Skimboarding Challenge April 18-20-Tranquility Bay, Municipality of Bacuag, Surigao del Norte .A yearly competition on Flatland Skimboarding with participants from all over the country. .Balangay Festival May 1-31-Butuan City-It is a month-long fiesta celebration of Butuan City. Several activities are lined up for the celebration like Mutya Hong Butuan Pageant, Sportsfest and Santacruzan. .Balik-Butuan 2nd week of May to end-Butuan City .An opportunity for all Butuanons residing abroad and other parts of the country to...

Words: 698 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

What Role Did Tennesse Play In The Civil War

...society, however, the role that Tennessee contributed to the Nations outcome was an interesting one yet partly complicated. Tennessee found itself engulfed in a war that would largely affect not only the Tennesseans; but the American civilians, Soldiers and the Country that was to come out of the war that no one could win. The Civil war, tore apart the country by North and South, Unions and Confederates, Northerners were known as Yankees and Southerners were known as Rebels. With Tennessee sitting on the border line of the Union and Confederate states it created more of a complication as this forced them to take a side. Tennessee’s geography took a large part in deciding the position of its state. Western Tennessee is widely covered in flatland and is rich in fertile soil. This was just what...

Words: 1028 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Marketing Plan

...Executive Summary: Platinum Beverage Distributors will be a full-service beverage distributor of fine wines and spirits to retailers and restaurants in North America. It will distinguish itself from the competition and capture market share by providing distribution locations in New York, California, Florida, Louisiana and Mississippi. It will follow the best practices of its category leaders, with particular emphasis on excellent customer service, a broad selection of quality wines and spirits, and competitive pricing. Mission: Our mission is to develop into the best beverage distributor in North America, which will be measured by our growth in sales, and in opinions and ratings published in the media. Inventory and sales records will be computerized, to allow the company to identify and exploit best selling products, match volumes and profitability to service levels, anticipate demand, manage cash flows, assist with revenue growth plans, and optimize supplier/distributor relationships. Goals: * Attract salesmen that are highly motivated with a proven track record. * Achieve a profitable return on investment within three years. Competition and Buying Patterns: Competition to a large degree depends on other beverage distributors in the territory. Relationships are cultivated with better customers who may qualify for discounts based on volume purchases. Other competitive factors include breadth and depth of available stock, product knowledge, customer service...

Words: 355 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

As Time Is Near

...of the symbolism in the short story.
 At the beginning the description of the nature in Alaska is a vivid portrayal followed by a number of incidents where people have been killed in or by this nature. Piper’s father is one of these people, he “falls out of the sky.” (p. 1, l. 10)
Her father with the name Red lived his life like it was an adventure. The description of the landscape appears in the same way - like a never-ending adventure. The tundra is a big and open landscape. The mountains, the glaciers and the snow continues into infinity. The same infinity that Piper’s father wanted to experience. The tundra is described when Piper sees it from the airplane:
“as far as she can see in any direction the earth is made of rust-coloured flatlands broken up by odd-shaped, glistening slices of water.” (p. 1, l. 28).
The open landscape with its odd-shaped slices of water is the never-ending adventure. 
After the description of the tundra, “the pilot changes altitude (…) the ground shifts beneath her...

Words: 357 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Importance Of Setting In Deborah Wiles's Countdown

...On page 188, Uncle Otts mentions that they are “too close to Washington D.C,” expressing that they are in Maryland and near the White House so they have a higher risk of being hit with missiles. On page 19, it is mentioned that the school is Camp Springs Elementary School and on page 124 it is mentioned that the land around the school is completely flatland. Plus the school has a stone wall in front of it (115). Finally, on page 38 it is mentioned that Franny’s house is on a dead end and on 47 that there is woods beyond the dead...

Words: 402 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Dance Observation Essay

...This dance, since it was choreographed without music, has to have dancers that are able to analyze the group’s dynamic and match it easily; the dancers also have to accent their own movement, because there is no music to set the highs and lows of the dance. The dancers are able to create their own accents through the swinging, bouncing, and repetitious movements they execute. I chose the video about Movement Density because the concept of knowing what parts of the stage were danced on the most intrigues me. The final display of the movement density, this video shows, is in a topographical map. The higher movement density spots create peaks and mountains while the areas with little to no movement are flatlands and hills. With this map viewers can clearly see that the center of the stage is the most highly danced upon section. This technology can also track each specific dancer to see where he or she spent the most...

Words: 432 - Pages: 2