Free Essay

For Better or for Worst

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By jer2120
Words 1338
Pages 6
For Better or for Worst
Sarah Stillman addresses the sweatshop debate from a primarily utilitarian standpoint. This standpoint doesn’t consider multiple important factors and is not an indication of how people actually act. In my opinion, Stillman’s stance reveals a failure to address the globalized nature of the sweatshop phenomenon with regards to the ease with which corporations are capable of moving their operations to other countries. On the other hand, she does bring up important ethical concerns that should be addressed. In her 2005 essay Made by Us: Young Women, Sweatshops, and the Ethics of Globalization, author Sarah Stillman provides the reader with a narrative of her experiences interacting with young women employed in Latin American sweatshops. She indicates that she believes that globalization – a process marked by the growing interconnectedness of global systems – has been lead to a proliferation of sweatshop factories in the third world and expresses concern that young women are “increasingly bearing the burdens of globalization while reaping relatively few of its tremendous rewards" . Although it is not explicitly stated in her essay, Stillman seems to espouse a primarily utilitarian philosophy in her moral judgements of the sweatshop industry. John Stuart Mill, an English philosopher and founder of the utilitarian school of moral reasoning, describes it as the following: [t]he creed which accepts as the foundation of morals, utility, or the greatest happiness principles, holds that actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness
Author Anthony Weston expands upon this statement, indicating that he believes utilitarianism is a “moral commitment to the happiness of all, to the good of the whole... [a state in which] more is better and the most the best.” The moral argument presented by Stillman is congruent with this philosophy. Promoting happiness in this case can be represented by the health and well-being of factory workers. Conversely, the actual conditions of the sweatshops, notably their purportedly substandard pay and poor working conditions, are very unlikely to “promote happiness”. Therefore, the continued operation of these sweatshops can be seen as morally wrong. Stillman offers two arguments against sweatshops from this perspective: the first, that young women working in such factories are given insufficient compensation for the wealth they generate and the second, that they are unfairly subject to harsh and often inappropriate working conditions. Both of these components likely decrease the overall happiness of the workers. Examining the issue of sweatshops from a financial standpoint, Stillman indicates her conviction that the corporations involved in the operation of sweatshops are often able to extract substantial profits through the abuse of their workers. She notes statements made by Charles Kernaghan, the director of the National Labour Committee, a US-based human rights NGO. He is quoted as indicating that a shirt produced by a woman in Honduras for 15¢ USD in compensation was sold to consumers for $40 USD. Without making an explicit statement, Stillman is effectively asking the reader if they believe that this level of compensation is appropriate given the purported suffering of the workers. The possible happiness gain that a consumer may experience from lower prices extracted through such labour practices would likely be seen by many as substantially less important than the potential happiness gain which sweatshop workers would receive from increased pay. Proponents of sweatshops would likely disagree with this perspective, even from the utilitarian standpoint. Many believe that consumers’ benefit from lower prices outweighs the needs of workers. While consumers may benefit from low prices, the relative harm caused by a small increase in the price of certain consumer goods is outweighed thoroughly by the outright gain which factory workers could enjoy if they received greater compensation for their work. Moreover, many of the problems described by Stillman could be remedied even without an increase in wages. It is highly doubtful that the poor working conditions or the physical, verbal and sexual abuse of workers she describes contributes positively to their overall productivity or happiness. For example, she describes a sweatshop in Honduras as having no access to clean drinking water, indicating that the sources available for workers were contaminated with fecal matter . Drinking from an unclean water source has the potential to lead to sickness. A worker sick with cholera, for instance, is not only likely to be unhappy but is also more likely to be unable to perform his or her job at peak efficiency, thus increasing overall production costs. Therefore, the consequences of such abuse can be seen as negative both from a utilitarian worker-oriented viewpoint as well as from a perspective more concerned with consumer and corporate well-being. Stillman raises an interesting point midway through her paper, indicating that despite her condemnation of products produced in sweatshop environments, their presence in her life is ubiquitous. She states that upon introspection, she has found herself “submerged in a system that genuinely repulses [her] ethical sensibilities.” This statement is fascinating when considering the broader state of the anti-sweatshop movement over the past twenty years. She notes that efforts to raise awareness and to end negative practices in sweatshops had great popular support in the 1990s, but failed to achieve substantive changes to sweatshop operations. This suggests an interesting aspect to utilitarianism in practice. Despite knowledge of what the best course of action in a given situation might be (in this case, demanding that producers operate their factories in ethical ways), many consumers remain apathetic to the needs of a greater good. This apathy indicates that utilitarianism may be a poor predictor of human behaviour. Stillman’s argument also fails to address the globalized nature of sweatshop economies. She recalls statements purportedly made by a factory manager seeking to encourage his workers to increase their productivity, asking a young woman if she knew “how many girls are lined up in China who would die for this work?” While the author attempts to use this statement in order to illustrate the potential dangers of overwork, it also carries another more latent message: local victories against sweatshops may not be positive developments due to the globalized nature of the phenomenon. For instance, if labour-rights organizers win concessions against a corporation to better working conditions and increase pay for workers in their country, there may be little incentive left to remain in that country when other locations may offer a more permissive workforce or more complacent regulations. Examining this issue from a utilitarian perspective raises a difficult question: would workers in countries such as Honduras maximize their happiness with sweatshop factories in which the poor working conditions, substandard pay and abuse persist, or with no sweatshops at all? Without sweatshops, former employees could be freed of their poor working conditions, but would also be freed of their regular (although very low) pay. The answer to this question is unclear, though if it were to prove to be the former, parties such as Ms. Stillman could be seen as morally wrong for seeking to improve working conditions and compensation for sweatshop workers. In conclusion, Stillman generates a moral argument centred around utilitarian, humanistic concerns for young women working in sweatshop conditions in the third world. At first glance, her argument is sound; the relative gain for workers through increased wages far outweighs the relative gain that consumers receive from purchasing consumer goods at marginally lower prices as well as the relative gain that corporations experience through cost-savings exercises. Examining her stance more thoroughly however reveals failures on a pragmatic level by failing to address the globalization aspect of the sweatshop phenomenon with respect to the readiness and ease with which corporations are willing to move their operations to other countries if they deem it necessary. Works Cited
Stillman, Sarah. "Made by Us: Young Women, Sweatshops and the Ethics of Globalization."
2005. http://www.eliewieselfoundation.org/CM_Images/UploadedImages/WinnersEssays/Sarah_ Stillman.pdf (accessed 14 November 2010).

Weston, Anthony. A 21st Century Ethical Toolbox. 2nd ed. New York: Oxford University
Press, 2000.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Financial Statement Analysis-Macy's

... BEST AVERAGE WORST Current Ratio 4.6 2.6 1.5 Average Collection Period 0 1 7 Day’s Inventory on Hand 36 107 136 Asset Analysis Fixed Asset Turnover 88.4 13.6 3.5 Total Asset Turnover 3.7 2.3 1.3 Debt Analysis Debt/Worth Ratio 0.4 1.4 3.9 TIE Ratio 8.3 3.1 1.3 Day’s Payable 8 31 42 Profitability Analysis PRE TAX Profit Margin NA 10.7 NA PRE TAX ROE 38.7 14.3 5.9 PRE TAX ROA 18.1 4.6 3.0 Introduction Macy’s, Inc. is a chain of department stores in the U.S. that has 800 locations along with online operations at macys.com. Established in 1858, they are proud to offer the best assortment of brands for a great value to each and every individual while providing engaging customer service. Macy’s wants shopping to be a whole new experience for people and that’s exactly the purpose of the American classics they have created, such as the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. Macy’s provides the magic to their customers by providing them with brands exclusive to the store, offering everyone the ability to be a trend-setter. Fashion has been brought to new levels thanks to this department store brand, through the web, stores, and mobile devices Macy’s is able to provide the best advice to their customers in need. More importantly, Macy’s tailors every store to fits its customer’s needs locally. Liquidity Analysis Current Ratio RMA ’11 ’10 % Change Best Average Worst 1.4 1.4 0.0 %...

Words: 2565 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

His204 Week 2 Assignment

...Race in Turn of the Century America   Natasha Stevenson HIS204 Leslie Ruff 12/3/12 In the 20th century life for many took a turn for the better….and worst. There were issues of equality, segregation, and feminine injustice. Many suffered greatly due to their current issues, and W.E.B wanted to take a stand for things. W.E.B du Bois was the African- American who predicted that one of the central problems of the 20th century would be how black and white Americans could live together in a just and equal society. The end of World War I back then was a real life changer for a lot of people in the 20th century. Women became less superior to men, and their legal, professional, and voting rights were degraded. On the other hand later in the 20th century women… and men fought hard for women’s equality, and finally made it to victory. After all the fights through the years justice was severed to many. The 20th Century was a major turning point the world because the majority of the century started at its worst but slowly became better over the years; also with the help of many who stepped forward. Once the Gibson girl came about many men and other women felt threatened by these strong- willed females and started to believe that women were becoming stronger than men. Men and women started to go around spreading thoughts about how they felt more females would want to become like “The Gibson Girl” and they would want to take over. This was why the issue of equality came to...

Words: 677 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Organizational Behavior

...Business Ethics M2 Written Assignment 1. Shaw and Barry distinguish two different forms of utilitarianism. What are these two forms? Briefly describe each and use examples. Shaw and Barry distinguished two different forms of utilitarianism, Act Utilitarianism and Rule Utilitarianism. To understand Utilitarianism in depth we must understand what Utilitarianism means first. “Utilitarianism is the moral doctrine that we should always act to produce the greatest possible good over bad for everyone affected by our actions.” (Shaw and Barry, pg.59). In other words, a human being tends to search for pleasure and avoid pain or suffer. Now while the Act Utilitarians measure the consequences arising from their actions, the Rule Utilitarians apply certain calculations, establishing the morality of these actions. Therefore they judge the rules by its consequences and their actions by their rules. In other words, Rule Utilitarianism is the theory that measures what is right or wrong morally based on how good or bad the consequences may be. 2. What do economists mean by the “declining marginal utility of money”? It’s just “another reason utilitarians tend to favor greater inequality of income.” (Shaw and Barry, pg.112). In simple words according to Shaw and Barry, Professor Richard Brandt, stated that our needs and wants come in order of preference. With our salary we get the things we want and most need and leave aside the items that we least need or want, giving us full pleasure...

Words: 852 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Dust Bowl Research Paper

...After the civil war, technology for farming was evolving rapidly. This included better tractors, better plows and combines. These inventions helped increase the cultivated land percentage three times than what it was before. Due to this, farmers needed more land to grow more crops. The government made it easy, cheap and appealing to buy new land. So farmers had no problems buying land for more crops. Many farmers ended up purchasing land. In the 1930s, many people started plowing the land making it loose and ready for crops. That is what started the dust bowl, soon to devastate many. In April 18th, 1935, a big black cloud of dust came over the horizon killing everything in its path. Many people started to move away, scared that it...

Words: 372 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Assignment Ch.11 Financial Management

...subjective judgments. 2) What are the three types of risk that are relevant in capital budgeting? How is each of these risk types measured, and how do they relate to one another? How is each type of risk used in the capital budgeting process? Three main kind of risk are present in capital budgeting: - Stand-alone risk - Corporate risk - Market risk. The first one (Stand-Alone Risk) concerns the project’s risk if it is the only asset in the firm and no shareholders are there. It passes over both firm and shareholders’ diversification and it is computed by Sigma or CV of NPV, IRR or MIRR. The second risk (that is Corporate Risk) concerns the project’s effect on corporate earnings stability. It also considers other activities of the firm (better knows as diversification within firm) and it depends on project’s sigma and the correlation (ρ) with performance on firm’s other assets. The last one (Market Risk) considers project’s effect on a diversified stock portfolio, it takes into account about other shareholders’ activities. It depends on the project’s sigma and its correlation with stock market and it is calculated by project’s market beta. About Market risk, it is probably the best one in many fields but just in theory. Anyway...

Words: 1749 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Nonviolence Protests

...Secondly, using a nonviolence protest is best choice because the action of nonviolence will not damage anything and cause community or economic problem while the action of riot will do a lot. Additionally, nonviolence is a peaceful action that the force will not take place and it will be much easier for the protest to do without getting arrested by the police. As the Alternet stated, it is “Nothing weakens a nonviolent movement more than the sporadic use of violence by people on its side of the barriers.” This shows that irregular violent protests take away from the message of nonviolent protests. It sounds that the quote is saying that violence is actually harming the goal of both violent and nonviolent protests because people are so focused...

Words: 332 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Simple Windows

...The development of an added software package which will allow users to decide the programs to be loaded will help the system become more user friendly. Windows has a numerous amount of bells and whistle. Some changes are for the best, others are for the worst. When talking the best and worst of Windows, let’s focus on the worst. The worst is what drives users to not want to change. The constant bad changes to the operating system should not affect the everyday user. Cross (2012) say for some users, change can be great, but for others it means relearning things they have done for years. The idea of relearning applications users have worked with for so long is not acceptable. The concept of change should all be for a good cause, not simply because a few people don’t like the way a certain function works. Windows should be creating a better environment for the user to continue to enjoy the same features. When the desktop changes, it’s like rearranging a personal desk and not remembering where you put things that are used on an everyday basis. Relearning should not be on the agenda once an upgrade is done to the operating system. Most users want the status quo and frown on change. The constant changing of components is the worst case scenario. Computer users should be allow to decide which programs are used based on the...

Words: 714 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Fgfgd

...helping him or not. I can also see that this film is showing us that we should not trust people who we don't know. It was a very strange film therefore I was a little confused on exactly what the creative team was trying to accomplish. My personal reactions to the play were that this was the worst play that I have ever seen in my life. I say this because the film quality was just terrible. I don't go out and watch a lot of movies but when I do I expect the movie to be worth the money that I paid for it. There were times in this movie where you know it is exposed to be scary but I would just laugh due to the camera angles because it would make it not scary at all. The way that the movie started off by just driving for 10 minutes looking for the hotel was boring. It took the audience attention away because after about three minutes of driving you could hear the audience talking in the background not paying attention to the movie. I mean it really just made the audience laugh and cut up. I believe that the director should of grabbed the audience attention better than driving around for 10 minutes. Eventually out of nowhere they found a house and was greeted by the man named Torgo. Torgo was the worst acting I have ever seen from someone. The audience thought that it was funny the way that he would walk and how the camera...

Words: 720 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Comparative Analysis Of Sorting Algorithm

...addition to its main job, sorting is often required to facilitate some other operation such as searching, merging and normalization. A sorting algorithm consists of comparison, swap, and assignment operations. There are several elementary and advanced sorting algorithms that are being used in practical life as well as in computation such as Quick sort, Bubble sort, Merge sort, Bucket sort, Heap sort, Radix sort etc. But the application of these algorithms depends on the problem statement. This paper introduces MQ sort which combines the advantages of quick sort and Merge sort. The comparative analysis of performance and complexity of MQ sort is done against Quick sort and Merge sort. MQ sort significantly reduces complexity and provides better performance than Quick sort, Merge sort, Bubble sort and Insertion sort. Keywords: Quick sort, Merge sort, MQ sort, Bubble sort, Insertion sort, Time Complexity, Space Complexity. INTRODUCTION: Algorithms have a vital role in solving the computational problems, informally an algorithm is a well-defined computational procedure that takes input and produces output. Algorithm is a tool or a sequence of steps to solve the computational problems[1]. There are various methodologies and techniques based on which various different kinds of algorithms are designed and developed. One of the basic problems of computer science is sorting a list of items. It refers to the arranging of numerical or alphabetical or character data in statistical order...

Words: 2578 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Conflict

...During times of conflict we are tested, conflict can evoke the best and worst out of individuals based on how they react and cope with it, without conflict we can never know what we are truly capable of. Many figures throughout history have shown how conflict brings out the best and the worst in them; this is also shown in the film Paradise road which is directed by Bruce Beresford. The My Lai massacre is an example of how conflict brings out the best and the worst and people, the My Lai massacre was when a group of American soldiers couldn’t cope with the stress of Guerrilla Warfare against the Vietcong troops, and under their lieutenants command they fired upon the village of My Lai decimating all inhabitants which included women and children. This is a clear example of how conflict brought out the worst in these individuals, they war in a foreign land and the constant stress of being killed finally tore them up internally so they open fired and killed innocent civilians. Although it seems that only the worst arose from the conflict in My Lai, some of the best did come from it, an example is the brave chopper pilot Hugh Laury so put himself and his men on the line to save the civilians. Laury even went as far as ordering his men to fire on the American troops if they didn’t stop shooting at the Vietnamese village; this is a clear cut example of how the best of a person can arise from conflict, his morality didn’t waver , even in the face of the evil around and amongst him...

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

English

...of people and the world, was the discovery of The New World, the discovery of The New world has its positive and negative sides. The Europeans were able to export and import materials, gold, silver, fruits, legume, vegetable etc... from the New World to the Old World. These colonialists were looking for a better life and more freedom, and liberty that they couldn’t get in The Old World. During this period Slaves were brought from Africa and were used as a slave labor, they lost their house, identities and were brought to another country to serve as a slave. European from The Old World brought with them disease that killed 90% of the Native Americans and would make that period of time a demographic catastrophe. In my opinion, the discovery of The New world was the best thing that happened to those European who were looking for a better place, but was also the worst period of History for the Native Americans who were killed by disease they did not know and for the Africans who were used as a slave labor. In conclusion, the discovery of the New World was a good period of time for the European who wanted liberty and a better place but at the same time the worst period of all time for the Africans and Native Americans, who were used as a slave and died by disease they did not know anything...

Words: 269 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

C201 Unit 3 Lesson 1

...What information in each chapter gives us support for this central idea? Chapter 1: A basic overview of how the “Panhandle/XIT/ World’s Greatest Grasslands” came to be, and foreshadow of what’s to come later in the book, identifying the struggles of travelers. Chapter 2: Gives the reader an idea of how such a desolate land became a “city.” Chapter 3: Keeps the reader updated on how Dalhart is growing. Chapter 4: The author includes the Journey of one Russian immigrant into this chapter and puts an emphasis on what people were thinking of America and the idea of the “American Dream.” Chapter 5: Tells the reader that during the great depression, land was being bought even quicker and being used for better purpose. Chapter 6: Informs the reader all about the Great Depression and the effect it had on the economy. ELA6_A_3_8_ACT_1 The following are good steps to take when writing an analysis: • Read closely to conclude what the text says, and to make logical inferences from it. • Cite detailed textual evidence support conclusions drawn from the...

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Mgmt530 – Labadee Decision

...$169.00 | Conference Costs | $25,000 | $20,000 | $15,000 | Survey Rank | 1 | 2 | 3 |   Now, look closely at the table and review the dimensions for which you are establishing and idea on how to rank the cities. In this case, the dimensions are by airfare, hotel room rate, conference costs and survey rank.   The next step is to develop a scoring model… Let’s use 3 for Best, 2 Second and 1 for Worst. This could be any set of numbers. Now, using the scoring model, review each of the dimensions and basically use a number for whether or not the ranking is better, second or worst. In this case, if you have two that are the same, that doesn’t matter, as both will receive the same score.   For example, conference costs are $25,000, $20,000 and $15,000 for Chicago, New York and Las Vegas. Using three as the best and 1 as the worst, you would rank Chicago 3, New York 2, and Las Vegas as 1. Now do this for each of the dimensions based on whether or not the metric is good, second or worst. You should get a table that looks like this:   Scoring Model (3 = Best, 2 = Second Best, 1 = Worst)   | Chicago | New York | Las Vegas | Airfare | 3 | 1 | 3 | Hotel Room Rate | 3 | 1 | 2 | Conference Costs | 1 | 2 | 3 | Survey Rank | 3 | 2 | 1 | SCORE | 10 | 6 | 9 |   Last, let’s now weight the scoring model. To do this please review the tutorial for the details – it is a really good description. With that being said, you should get a table that looks something like this:    FIRST...

Words: 600 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Miranda Evans 'Life As We Knew It'

...Life As We Knew It The main protagonist in Life As We Knew It, Miranda Evans, only wanted a normal life of a regular teenanger, but when a rogue asteroid hits the moon and knocks it out of orbit, all hell breaks loose, so Miranda has to survive through famine, droughts, storms, and blizzards. In Life As We Knew It, there are many themes that can be seen throughout the story of survival, love, and hope. The theme of Life As We Knew It is, “Things will get better in time,” because comfort comes with hope, hope of better times motivates people, and the word believes in better times, and without hope, the world is dead. Following the asteroid hitting the Moon, everyone’s world began to dissolve, though hope gave them comfort knowing better times...

Words: 479 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Oligopoly

...|Low | | |High |50, 40 |60, 45 | | | | | | |Firm A | | | | | |Low |55, 55 |15, 20 | a. If both firms make their decisions at the same time and follow maximin (low-risk) strategies, what will the outcome be? With a maximin strategy, a firm determines the worst outcome for each action, then chooses the action that maximizes the payoff among the worst outcomes. If Firm A chooses High, the worst payoff would occur if Firm B chooses High: A’s payoff would be 50. If Firm A chooses Low, the worst payoff would occur if Firm B chooses Low: A’s payoff would be 15. With a maximin strategy, A therefore chooses High. If Firm B chooses Low, the worst payoff would be 20, and if B chooses High, the worst payoff would be 40. With a maximin strategy, B therefore chooses High. So under maximin, both A and B produce a high-quality system. b. Suppose that both firms try to maximize profits, but that Firm A has a head start in planning and can commit first. Now what will be the outcome? What will be the outcome if Firm B has the head start in...

Words: 4611 - Pages: 19