Free Essay

Forensic Account

In:

Submitted By roopashriyadav
Words 4916
Pages 20
Culture-Specific Forensic Accounting Conceptual Framework: A skills Set Theoretical Analysis

Abstract :
Forensic accounting, given its peculiar investigative stance, requires a specific skills set on the part of the forensic accountant, that integrates accounting, auditing and investigative skills. The Jordanian Anti-Corruption Commission’s (JACC) struggle to investigate Maward’s, a Jordanian state-own company, suspected corruption has raised serious concerns regarding the weak state of forensic accounting in Jordan, and the need for its adaptation to suit the country’s peculiar context, to successfully institutionalize at the wider societal level and benefit the state in its aim for ensuring efficient utilization of the scarce resources at its disposal. This study is an attempt to deduce a country-specific conceptual framework for forensic accounting, which can be replicated, with suitable adaptations, to other countries with similar cultural backgrounds, and put forth some theory-supported suggestions to help guide future research in the area.

Keywords: forensic accounting, conceptual framework, institutional theory, foucault

Introduction:

The rise in the white collar crimes, where evidences are comparatively moreobscure and difficult to detect (Gottschalk, 2011), has necessitated equipping of auditors with forensic skills, particularly over the recent years (DiGabriele, 2009a; Carnes & Gierlasinski, 2001). In the aftermath of several accounting scandals such as Enron and WorldCom in the USA, HIH Insurance in Australia, Royal Ahold in the Netherlands, Parmalat in Italy, and Equitable Life Assurance Society in the UK (Kleinman & Anandarajan, 2011), as well as the collapse of one of the “Big Five” auditing firms (Arthur Anderson), and the two episodes of financial crises that followed afterwards, awareness about white-collar frauds committed by employeesthrough embezzlement of funds,ensuring personal financial and non-financial gains at a cost to the society, and fraudulent financial reporting, has increased over the past (McMullen & Sanchez, 2010); Harris, 2012).

Despite criminal prosecutions and formal punishments (see Carnes & Gierlasinski, 2001), accounting as a professional has had legitimacy and trust shocks experienced as a result as well (see Carnegie& Napier, 2010; Konishi, 2010). The accounting and auditing professions were particularly hit hard at the collapse of Enron (Kleinman & Anandarajan, 2011). The promulgation of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act 2002 and later on the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOS) and the Statement of Accounting Standards No. 99 has heightened this awareness even further and added to the auditors’ and accountants’ responsibilities to detect fraud within organizations (DiGabriele, 2009a).

The magnitude of egregious white-collar crimes in the USA alone is to the tune of US$300 billion per annum,which points to the significance of the enhancement of the overall capacityof today’s forensic accountants to effectively tackle the problem (see DiGabriele, 2009b).
A thorough disquisition of the past corporate scandalsand the immense responsibility the discipline shoulders discerns that forensic accountant needs to possess peculiar skills and expertise for the effective discharge of their duties and the accomplishment of their onerous work objectives. In practice, successful forensic accountants collect and analyze evidence and report their findings asto whether a person’s conduct merits the country’s legal system’s involvement. The National Institute of Justice (2007) asserts that forensic accountants’ success in terms of objective evaluation of clients’ work for authenticity and correctness is primarily dependent upon their expertise in accounting and skills in investigation and litigation. Therefore, demand for forensic accountants with required expertise has surged over the past decade or so, to deal with a variety of cases and industries. Academic institutions and stakeholder organizations thatprovide education in these fields are faced with a number of questions regarding the nature, extent, and format of a worthwhile curriculum that could address all pertinent issues facing the discipline (National Institute of Justice, 2007). Though the literature covers a variety of aspects of the issue, it does not fully address the requirements for improving the sector’s efficacy both in terms of the accomplishment of its objectives in performing as per society’s expectations and institutionalization of the discipline at the deeper societal level, and this conceptual paper aims to fill this void in the current literature. It goes beyond and evaluates the issues the discipline is facing in the light of some established theoretical constructs to help it pinpoint its shortcomings and reach optimal growth, both quantitatively and qualitatively, in Jordan’s peculiar contexts. Jordan is not immune to corruption; many suspected corruption cases have been referred to the State Security Court (SSC). Among those is the case of the National Resources Investment and Development Corporation, which is called ‘Maward’. It is a financially and administratively independent state-owned corporation leading Jordan's drive towards urban regeneration and inner city development.

It is Jordan's largest real estate developer, with a commitment towards generating considerable investment opportunities for the private sector, creating job opportunities, and stimulating economic growth. Maward, a Jordanian state-owned company, is under investigation for corruption by the Jordanian Anti-Corruption Commission (JACC). The JACC’s president’s comments that the case file consists of 40,000 pages, written in the English language, hint towards the intricate nature of the case on one hand and the lack of expertise to effectively tackle and handle the case, with objective outcomes for the government, on the other. A Jordanian journalist comment’s further highlights the need for dexterous and shrewd forensic accountants: "...the president is in a critical need for experts gaining distinct skills more than translation from English to Arabic, reading through the lines and manipulating the accounting numbers into facts..." (Jebara, 2011). The journalist has,in fact, impliedly pointed towards the country’s dire need for forensic accounts with skills-set that is best suited to the country’s peculiar needs and requirements.

A country-specific forensic accounting conceptual framework, that would stipulate the skills set a forensic accountant should possess to effectively handle fraudulent and suspicious cases, both in the public and private sector, is what the society is expecting the government to deduce. This conceptual-cum-analytical paper aims to deduce such a conceptual framework for country that would be replicable to other Middle Eastern nations with similar circumstances. We expect this framework to provide a foundation for the development of forensic accounting standards, that would drive the business schools’ curricula development initiative, thereby helping to overcome the country’s dire need for effective forensic accountants to ensure efficient utilization of the country’s scarce resources, and also help develop the country’s private sector, for best societal outcomes. Another important contribution of this study is help the forensic accounting discipline better understand societal expectations of it and therefore adapt and reorient to effectively institutionalize itself as a legitimate entity at the wider societal level. The study, in accomplishing this, resorts to Foucault’s (1980) notions of ‘govern mentality’ and ‘power’ and DiMaggio and Powell’s (1983) institutional theory.

The remainder of the paper is divided into four main sections: The first section reviews the relevant literature and sheds light on the significance of the issue, followed by a section on the theoretical framework to help readers view the issue with the lenses of the aforementioned theoretical underpinnings. The third section develops a ‘framework’ for the discipline’s development and efficient functioning in the peculiar context of Jordan. The last section draws conclusions and proposes research areas to be considered by researchers.

Literature Review : Given the tedious and intricate nature of assignments, today’s forensic accountants are entrusted, business schools around the world constantly evaluate their curricula and introduce new and/or revised forensic accounting courses (see DiGabriele, 2008; Carnes & Gierlasinski, 2001).

Traditional accounting graduates work as accountants and internal and external auditors in business organizations, and are expected to have a greater understanding of fraudulent business transactions and deals and forensic accounting. This adds to the business schools’ responsibilities to develop their curricula accordingly. The surge in corruption cases in recent times coupled with highly risky nature of today’s business has necessitated stern response and preparedness, in terms of the development of human and other resources, around the world, on the part of different stakeholders. McMullen and Sanchez (2010) in their survey concluded that the demand for forensic accountants would increase well into the foreseeable future, particularly in the area of fraudulent financial reporting. The need for forensic accountants both in the public and private sector is expected to continue to grow (Harris, 2012). While several financial market players contributed to the early-and then the late 2000s financial crises, the crises primarily stem from the USA and then penetrated into different economies around the globe. The 2011 Financial Crisis Enquiry Commission’s report, indirectly but clearly,signalled the shortcomings in the business schools’ curriculum particularly in terms of lack of complete dexterousness imparted to and inculcation of ethical and professional values into the very personalities of the business graduates. Sheer neglect of regulations and standards and “systematic breakdown in accountability and ethics” were evident in the reckless, unprofessional, and unethical decisions of the business schools’ ‘working graduates’, the report added. From the sustainability perspective, these graduates’ business decisions, in several occasions such as the infamous 1984 Bhopal disaster, the OK Tedi Mine contamination of Fly River, the Chernobyl nuclear reactor accident with disastrous long-term ramifications for Western Europe and Russia, and many more, have contributed to the environmental degradation that has been affecting us all [see Wallace, 2010; Currie, Knights & Starkey, 2010; Datar, Garvin & Cullen, 2011 for detailed analyses of business schools’ position in the post-financial crises era debate]. Currie et al. (2010, p. S1) have referred to the shortcomings in the business schools’ imparting of sound professional knowledge and expertise to their graduates as “a fundamental intellectual failure”. Costs of the recent financial crises to the world economy has been estimated at a staggering US$500 billion (Greenlaw et al., 2008); these estimates were escalated to an alarming US$1400 billion later in 2008 (Barrell & Davis, 2008). Non-performing loans in the Asian countries have soared to about 30 percent of banks’ total assets. In quarter of the cases of these financial crises, the cost to different European countries soar to around 10 percent of their Gross National Product (Llewellyn, 2002, p. 153); the situation necessitates analysis of the situation at a deeper level for root causes.

The unethical and reckless business decisions on the partof large corporations’ executives, including the audit firms whose very job is to watchtheir clients and keep them on the right track, leading to the demise of these business giants, with consequences for the world economy, deduction of an effective conceptual framework, duly acceptable to the society as a legitimate recipient of the scarce resourcesat its disposal, and its meticulous compliance has (should) become the priority of all professional bodies, governments, and business schools. Building forensic accountants’ ‘capacity’ to deal with the technical

nature of today’s fraudulent business transactions and decisions has gained high momentum since the early- and then the late-2000s financial crises.

The accounting professional bodies place high emphasis on imparting comprehensive training to forensic accountants. Resultantly, most businessschools, around the world, have adapted their curriculum to include forensic accounting as an additional course to effectively tackle the ethics-specific challenges today’s business confronts, thereby increasing the number of risk-fraud-audit specific courses from two to three (Carpenter, Durtschi, & Gaynor, 2011). Comparing this situation to Jordan, only two private-sector universities throughout the country offer degrees in accounting with a forensic accounting component. Policy-makers in the government and relevant professional bodies need to fill this gap. Business schools in Jordan ought to revisit their curricula and redevelop them in the light of today’s requirements. Effective auditing entails effective forensic accounting. Forensic accounting techniques, if employed effectively, will ensure high quality audit outcomes (DiGabriele, 2011; DiGabriele, 2009b). We argue these skills ought to reflect country or culture-specific peculiarities. As Cortese (2003, p. 16) put it. [...] it is the people coming out of the world’s best colleges and universities that are leading us down the current unhealthy, inequitable, and unsustainable path...
While formal punishments and criminal prosecution has always been in play and has become more intense following the financial crises (Carnes & Gierlasinski, 2001), we argue it has not been thoroughly effective in preventing frauds. In the aftermath of the recent financial crises, society is now exerting pressure on professional audit firms to assume responsibility for detecting risk of fraud as well when conducting audit (Carnes & Gierlasinski, 2001) – an expectation that requires the services of forensic accountants. Given the demand today’s vexing business scenarios and fraudulent activities place on a typical forensic accountant’s skill-set, the framework, we propose in the peculiar context of Jordan, emphasize dexterously crafted integration between all branches of accounting, including financial accounting, management accounting, auditing, fraud examination, and social sciences field of human psychology. Additionally, we consider the involvement of some of the shrewd auditors already working in the field with a good track record and business schools as crucial.

With this paper a first step in this direction, we argue for the adaptation and reorientation of the current forensic accounting general standards, with an input from the above fields, to suit Jordan’s peculiar forensic accounting current and future needs. We aim to put forth the proposed framework to be used as a reference point for other countries with similar circumstances, particularly the Middle East, for the development and adaptation of their own standards, in the light of the highly risky nature of today’s business enterprises and the perplexing ways in which frauds are committed. Kleinman and Anandarajan (2008, p. 46) assert: [...] In forensic accounting and auditing courses, students should be made aware not only of the accounting/tracing aspects of auditing and forensic accounting,

but also of the environment in which fraud takes place and how it is enabled by events in one’s surroundings. The presentation of intentional blindness is not prevalent in forensic accounting and auditing courses. Thus, the ‘environment’ and the ‘surroundings’ of a fraudulent activity matters and every country’s business schools need to take this into account when developing their curricula(Kleinman & Anandarajan, 2008). Forensic accounting is an aspect of accounting application that deals withthe mechanism used to record and summarize business and financial transactions according to legal issues (Ansari, 2005). Thornhill (1995) asserts that there is no standard definition for forensic accounting that could capture all aspects of its constitutionof existence. Thornhill (1995) defines forensics as an accounting analysis to assist in legal matters. It is frequently associated with the analytical investigation of civil or criminal actions, such as white-collar crime, insurance casualty claims, loss measurements, accounting malpractices, and general abuse of trust relationships. Okoye and Akenbor (2009) see forensic accounting as a profession that applies financial skills to provide solutions to issues under investigation. It is a discipline with peculiar characteristics, that applies “...accounting and auditing skills to legal problems both civil and criminal...”, where professionals command a variety of skills, as individuals or teams, such as expertise in various branches of accounting, knowledge of fraud, understanding of the nature of businesses/phenomena under investigation and applicable legal system (Okoye & Akenbor, 2009, p.2).

What is peculiar to forensic accounting and different to most other disciplines is that it integrates accounting, auditing and investigative skills. Forensic accounting consists of two major components: (1) Litigation services that recognize the role of the public accountant as an expert or consultant and (2) investigative services that make use of the public accountant's skills, which may helpin the court as testimony(DiGabriele, 2009a; NIJ, 2007). Forensic accounting may involvethe application of special skills in accounting, auditing, finance, quantitative methods, certain areas of the law and research, and investigative skills to collect, analyze, and evaluate evidential matter and to interpret and communicate findings. Forensic accounting may involve either an attest or consulting engagement. Litigation support basically focuses on a notion that forensic accountants work as expert witnesses. It deals with issues related to the quantification of economic damages. A typical litigation support assignment would be calculating the economic loss resulting from a breach of contract (see Okoye & Akenbor, 2009; NIJ, 2007; Hao, 2010). Investigative accounting is often associated with investigations of criminal events. A typical investigative accounting assignment would be an investigation of employee theft (Crumbley et al., 2007). The forensic accountants therefore need a broader skill set beyond just fraud detection and auditing competence (McMullen & Sanchez, 2010). Many researchers pointed to several important skills that should be perceived by the forensic accountants. These skills are basic accounting skills (McMullen & Sanchez, 2010), written and verbal communication skills, analytical skills, interviewing skills (Crumbley et al., 2007) and personality traits (Wells, 2003).

In addition, they need basic and computer forensics skills as almost every fraud involves the use of computers and electronic documents (Smith, 2005), data mining skills which use mathematical algorithms to seek hidden patterns in data (Crumbley et al., 2007). Forensic accountants may be engaged in public practice or employed by insurance companies, banks, police forces, government agencies and other organizations which are in need of the forensic accountants' services (Okoye & Jugu, 2010). Forensic accountants are often involved in investigating and analyzing financial evidence, developing computerized applications to assist in the analysis and presentation of financial evidence, communicating their findings in the form of reports, exhibits and collections of documents, and assisting in legal proceedings, including testifying in court as an expert witness and preparing visual aids to support trial evidence (Okoye & Jugu, 2010). Like auditing, forensic accounting involves collecting and interpreting the evidence and providing an opinion expressing what the evidence means (Huber, 2011). In order to properly perform these services, forensic accountants must have good knowledge in legal concepts and procedures and be able to identify substance over form when dealing with an issue (see Okoye & Jugu, 2010; McMullen & Sanchez, 2010; Crumbley et al., 2007). In order to accomplish this holistic role, forensic accountants ought to possess characteristics, which would enable them to discharge their responsibility effectively. Ansari (2005) pointed to the characteristics that forensic accountant should have: curiosity, persistence, creativity, discretion, organization, confidence, and sound professional judgment. In addition to these, "people” skills, “puzzle” skills, flexibility and ability to work well in a team are also important characteristics (McMullen & Sanchez,2010). Forensic accountants must consider all the alternatives, and obtain and closely examine all the details about the events under investigation as well as the whole situation. In addition, a forensicaccountant should be able to communicate clearly and concisely by writing a professional report. In particular, given the discipline’s wide scope of operation, the lack of appropriate training, or the low quality of the businesseducation curriculum, will beset the value of forensic accounting. Latest evidence highlights the significance of ‘proper’ training for a practicing forensic accountant. Carpenter et al. (2011), in their longitudinal empirical study, found that the delivery of a proper course in forensic accounting made a significant improvement, duly sustained over a period of time, to the subjects’ level of skepticism when confronted with a high risk or fraudulent area of a typical business operational area.

Theoretical Framework for the Study :

Forensic accounting requires a thorough understanding of accounting, the clients’ business model operations. The discipline will flourish, legitimize, and institutionalize at the wider societal level, with optimal benefits for all stakeholders, only when it possesses, in terms of Foucault’s (1980) theoretical constructs, the ‘power’ (of expertise and knowledge) and ‘govern mentality’, which in turn stems from the power of knowledge and authority. Foucault (1980, p. 93) claims: [...] power never ceases its interrogation, its inquisition, its registration of truth: it institutionalizes, professionalizes and rewards its pursuit. Once a routine of socially and professionally acceptable curricula gets established, the

practice will then spread across the country to all business schools, as predicted under the institutional theory’s (DiMaggio and Powell, 1983) stance of ‘isomorphism’ (see Scott, 1995). Businesses sharing the same industry try to adopt practices prevalent in the industry and try not to stand or be deemed isolated (see Covaleski and Dirsmith, 1988; DiMaggio and Powell, 1983; Meyer and Rowan, 1977), though the speed of adoption of certain new social practices may vary among organizations (see Campanale, Cinquini, and Tenucci, 2010; Erakovic and Wilson, 2005; Burns and Scapens, 2000).
Although these ‘authorities’ are vested with the ‘power’ of knowledge and authority, i.e. ‘governmentality’ in Foucault’s conceptualizations, they are ‘accountable’ and ‘answerable’ to the society for their responsibilities – the concept of “control of control” as Power (1994, p. 300) describes. Thus, policy-makers in the relevant governmental departments, professional bodies, and practitioners, including business schools, ought to work in collaboration for effectively addressing the discipline’s ex ante(education in all areas the proposed framework indicates, training, exposure to past experiences) and ex post(the incumbents’ on the job training, continuous professional development, transparency and accountability) reasons of failure, to protect societal interests and ensure accomplishment of its inherent objectives. 4. Conceptual Framework Deduced from the Study’s Theoretical Framework As stated early, the main goal of this study is to build a tentative conceptual framework for forensic accounting for consideration by policy-makers in relevant government agencies, professional bodies, and business schools. It is expected to benefit several entities in both the public- and private sector, such as researchers, police, anti-corruption commissions, accountants, business enterprises, business schools in their curriculum development initiatives. A sound conceptual framework that accommodates all aspects of the discipline, in the specific contexts of a country, from the perspective of its efficacy in the efficient discharge of its responsibilities given challenges it is facing in today’s business organizations is the necessity of today. Ethnical diversity, with a variety of needs and requirements, necessitates objective review and analysis of social practices and services (see Warnock-Parks, Young & Gejdenson, 2010). In the case of China, for instance, Halo (2010) has indicated several country-specific requirements for the development of the forensic accounting discipline. Konishi (2010) also endorsed cultural influence on accountants’ behaviors in conducting a business. The proposed conceptual framework borrows from the relevant literature and the applicable established theoretical constructs on the development, legitimization, and eventual institutionalization of certain social practices. The framework establishes the base to align and coordinate the discipline-specific objectives, concepts and actions that underline forensic accounting. It aims to provide guidance on identifying and appreciating the circumstances the discipline finds itself in today and a reference point for the development of forensic accountants capable of effectively addressing and tackling the challenges the sector is facing today. Country-and culture-specific circumstances need to be considered when implementing forensic accounting and auditing-specific regulations (see Kleinman & Anandarajan, 2008). In Jordan, there are only a limited number of accounting programs offering forensic accounting courses. Two Jordanian universities among 26 are teaching accounting discipline and offering forensic accounting related courses. Both these universities operate in the private sector - Applied Science Private University and American University of Madaba,

and offer two elective courses related to forensic accounting. It is thus evident that there is a large void between the supply and demand for forensic accounting services. The country’s education system ought to act in this connection, and this paper is an attempt in this direction to provide a ‘framework’ to guide any such attempts on the part of the government and territory education sector.

Objectives and Major Components:

The objectives and components of the proposed forensic accounting framework are many fold and chase one another, and therefore are presented together. In order for the discipline to command the ‘power’ of authority and knowledge and ‘governmentality’ to legitimize its doctrine as binding and effective, the discipline must align the set of objectives it aims to accomplish with the demands society is placing on it given the threats and risks it is facing in the business world today.

Responsibilities Entrusted :

Giving the readers an account of the duties and responsibilities forensic accountants are entrusted during the usual course of their work will also provide a background for the proposed conceptual framework the paper to put forth for consideration by the policy-makers. Foucault (1980) argues that the power of knowledge and authority and the notion of ‘govern mentality’ are interconnected and the interplay between these theoretical constructs helps institutionalize a social practice at a deeper level. Forensic accountants in the Jordan’s context currently possess the power of ‘authority’ and‘governmentality’ but lack the power of ‘knowledge’ and ‘skills’ at a level that is crucial for the discipline’s institutionalization power. Societal expectations of forensic accountants to effectively and efficiently discharge these obligations will ensurethe discipline’s deeper institutionalization in the society and the achievement of a legitimate status in the sight of the general public. Therefore, through the proposed conceptual framework, we end devour to incorporate a representative set of skills that business schools and governments must arrange to inculcate into prospective forensic accountants to enable them to discharge all these assignments effectively and efficiently to the satisfaction of all stakeholders, including the society. This will qualify the sector for the grant of legitimate status by the society, which will endorse the sector for a due share in the resources the society is in possession of. As discussed above, the literature on accountability also imposes obligations on the government and business schools to ensure inculcation of necessary skills and expertise in prospective forensic accountants so that they become capable of discharging their duties effectively to the satisfaction of what is expected of them by the society and governments. Also, the literature on human resource management advocates that always people should be entrusted responsibilities as per their skills and trainings. Thus, before holding forensic accountants

responsible for their actions, entities vested with the ‘power’ of authority-‘governmentality’ and ‘knowledge’, i.e. the government, business schools, and professional bodies, must ensure imparting all training and skills to prospective forensic accountants that are essential for them to effectively discharge their responsibilities.

Conclusion :

The significance of the forensic accounting branch of auditing for the effective and efficient utilization of a country’s resources cannot be over-emphasized, and substantial amount of literature addresses the area from several angles. This conceptual paper takes the discussion further and analyses the issue from the theoretical perspectives of Foucult’s (1980) ‘power’ and ‘governmentality’ and DiMaggio and Powell’s (1983) institutional theory. We argue that the discipline is in dire need for a sustained capacity development of its incumbents, through appropriate training and development initiatives (see Carpenter et al., 2011), to effective address the intricate challenges confronting today’s businesses. We argue that the discipline, in the peculiar context of Jordan, as well as in general, must adapt, both theoretically and practically, taking both ex ante(education in all areas the proposed framework indicates, training, exposure to past experiences) and ex post(the incumbents’ on the job training, continuous professional development, transparency and accountability) measures. This will help it fully institutionalize at the wider societal level, sustain and survive inthe long run, and be accepted as a legitimate member of the society withbenefits flowing to the community in ensuring efficient utilization of its scarce available resources. The paper, borrowing from established theoretical frameworks on the construction, development, and eventual institutionalization of social practices, focused on the need for evolution of the discipline in the peculiar context of Jordan. It aimed to develop a conceptual framework to inform the government on appropriate policies on the development and implementation of the discipline to the country’s full advantage. In a nutshell, the study aimed to examine forensic accounting skills requirements and to develop conceptual model guidelines to be referred to by policy makers and business schools in the country. In addition to assisting public- and private-sector institutions, the conceptual framework presented is intended to aid professional trainers working in this area, including business schools, in tailoring their training curricula to suit today’s forensic accounting needs and requirements. This study portrayed forensic accounting as a new area in the context of Jordan and presented a case, through developing conceptual model guidelines, for its effective development and institutionalization at the wider societal level, with a capacity to ensure effective discharge of responsibility to both the government and the society.
The significance of building potential forensic accountants’ capacity through proper training and education (Carpenter et al., 2011) is highly reflected in the development of the conceptual model, which is expected to benefit the discipline from several angles – education, practical training, and capacity development – a novel initiative that contributes to and fills the current void inthe literature (see also Kleinman & Anandarajan, 2011).

The framework apprises all stakeholders on the flaws present in their respective contributions to the discipline’s development. In addition to assisting institutions, which are in need for forensic accountant services, the conceptual framework presented is intended to aid professional trainers working in this area. Further, practicing professionals who seek opportunities toacquire new skills in the area of forensic accounting may also benefit from this conceptual framework. Inparticular, the framework aims to inform business schools on their curriculum development, which will address the issue at the grass root level in the country’s peculiar contexts.

The framework needs to be considered for implementation,after a thorough analysis through empirical studies, by the government, professional bodies, and business schools – all entities vested with the ‘power’ of authority and knowledge, which are, in terms of Foucault’s (1980) theoretical conceptualizations of ‘power’ and ‘governmentality’ and the interplay between the two, essential for the institutionalization of the social practice at the societal level. The model then, as an institutionalized social practice, is expected tospread across the country, as predicted by the ‘isomorphism’ and ‘coercive’ pillarsof the institutional theory (DiMaggio & Powell, 1983; see also Scott, 1995).

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Welcome to Homicide

...Welcome to Homicide Forensic Science is a fundamental component of the justice system. Forensic scientists use scientific techniques and knowledge to assist law enforcement in investigations and solving crimes. They collect and analyze numerous types of evidence, including blood, body fluids; DNA; and human tissue. Forensic scientists assist the decision makers by showing the prosecutor if the issue has merit before it reaches the courtroom thereby reducing the number of cases having to be heard. Their decisions are based on scientific investigations and not circumstantial evidence or unreliable witnesses. Forensic scientists can restore faith in the judicial system with the use of science and technology for facts in criminal and civil investigations. The legal system is established on the belief that the legal process results in justice for all. History of forensic science The history of Forensic science or the applying of scientific principles to legal questions has a lengthy and interesting history. The first recorded autopsy was reported in 44 B.C was on Julius Caesar, where the Roman physician, Antistius proclaimed that he had 23 wounds on his body but only one was fatal. In 1248, a Chinese book entitled “His Duan Yu” (meaning The Washing Away of Wrongs) explaining how to tell apart a drowning from a strangulation. This was also the first recorded use of medicine to assist in solving crimes. In 1590, the first microscope was developed. In 1775, Karl...

Words: 2382 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Forencis Science Answer Sheet

...Name: Date: TRUE/FALSE Directions: Answer each of the following by indicating if the statement is TRUE or FALSE 1. The word forensics refers to the application of scientific knowledge to legal questions. TRUE 2. A fact is a statement or assertion of information that can be verified. TRUE 3. What we perceive about a person depends in part on their mannerisms and gestures. TRUE 4. Good observation skills come naturally to investigators. They do not need to be trained. FALSE 5. The first task of forensic scientists is to find, examine, and evaluate evidence from a crime scene. TRUE 6. The Innocence Project is an organization that seeks to get convicted killers out of prison. SKIP 7. Our emotional state influences our ability to see and hear what is happening around us. TRUE 8. If we remember seeing something happen, we can trust that is happened just as we think it did. FALSE 9. Through our senses of sight, taste, hearing, smell, and touch, we gather every single moment about what is around us. TRUE 10. Most wrongful convictions seem to be the result of faulty eye-witness testimony. TRUE MULTIPLE CHOICE Directions: Answer the following questions with the choice that best answers the question 1. One of the important tools of the forensic investigator is the ability to: (a) a. Observe, interpret and report observation clearly b. Observer assumptions clearly. c. Report assumptions...

Words: 1075 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Is4670 Unit 10 Lab Q&a

...1. What was the user account name of the FTP client on the FTP server and which was its IP address? The FTP account name is: Badguy. FTP server’s IP:172.16.177.157 2. How many emails did the alleged offender sent to his partner before downloading the implicated file? Which are the two email addresses involved? The alleged offender sent 3 emails before downloading the file. The email address involved were: badguy11111@gawab.com and b603358@borthew.com 3. As a forensics investigator, would you be able to playback an entire TCP session if it is requested under trial? Yes, Netwitness investigator allows a forensics investigator to playback an entire TCP session previously capture. 4. What time did the alleged offender choose to perform the actions? Why do you think this is particularly important? Where did you get this information from? After reviewing the entire packet capture we notice that download occurred around 4:00am. This is particularly important since directly to “system usage” outside regular hours of operations. 5. What is the name of the “local user” account involved in the alleged actions? Which was the IP address of the alleged offender workstation? The local administrator account was the one involved. The IP address of the client FTP client was: 172.16.177.132 6. How many attempts to access the FTP server did you find during the packet capture analysis? Why is this important for your case? Two attempts to access the FTP server were found...

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Forensic Science in the 21st Century

...Forensic Science in the 21st Century By: Crystal Lyle AJS/584 - FORENSIC SCIENCE AND PSYCHOLOGICAL PROFILING STEVEN HOENIG 2-29-16 This paper will examine my perception and concept of forensic science in the 21st century. It will also examine the importance of forensic science to policing criminal investigation court process, and the efforts of various levels in security. In addition to analyzing the importance of forensic science, I will give a historical approach. I will discuss the accuracy of the media representation of forensic science and how issues. Lastly, I will discuss the influence the CSI effect have on the judicial process. Forensic Science is the application of science to criminal and civil laws that are enforced by law enforcement agencies in a criminal justice system. Another definition of forensic science is principles and techniques to matters of criminal justice, especially as it relates to the collection, examination, and analysis of physical evidence. In 1929, a Los Angeles police department establish the first American forensic lab. Forensic science has been around over 300 years or more and it continues to improve and emerge today as science and technical knowledge find more improved and accurate techniques. Forensic science has come to be a critical instrument in allowing guilt or demonstrating innocence in the system of criminal justice. In the late 80’s (DNA), society was accepting of (DNA) and forensic science continues to develop and unfold...

Words: 1265 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Term Paper

...Journal of Forensic & Investigative Accounting Vol. 4, Issue 2, 2012 The Obvious Fraud: A Short, Problem-Based Case Study to Highlight Inappropriate Fraud Examination Techniques David O’Bryan Jeffrey J. Quirin* INTRODUCTION Assume you are an internal auditor for a large, multinational, manufacturing organization with a division in Mexico. One of your responsibilities is to investigate allegations made on the company’s fraud hotline. When you arrive at work one morning you learn an anonymous tip was left on the hotline that alleges fraud involving the division manager. “Pat’s significant other is a fraudulent vendor,” was the anonymous tip left on your company’s fraud hotline. Pat is a division manager at your company. “Wow. I can’t believe this guy is so blatant,” you’re thinking as you review some accounts payable invoices while following up on this anonymous tip. The invoice that caught your attention is shown in Table 1. A quick search of the AP file reveals a total of three invoices like the one in Table 1, all for identical amounts but on different dates. The division manager, Pat, has the authority to approve payment of invoices for less than $10,000. It is obvious to you that the manager has a created a shell company. You happen to know that Pat’s significant other is named Kim, hence the name Kimco Marketing. There is no documentation to support these transactions other than the invoices, all of which are purportedly for marketing services. * The authors are, respectively...

Words: 3900 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Computer Forensics

...International Journal of Digital Evidence Fall 2007, Volume 6, Issue 2 Computer Forensic Analysis in a Virtual Environment Derek Bem Ewa Huebner University of Western Sydney, Australia Abstract In this paper we discuss the potential role of virtual environments in the analysis phase of computer forensics investigations. General concepts of virtual environments and software tools are presented and discussed. Further we identify the limitations of virtual environments leading to the conclusion that this method can not be considered to be a replacement for conventional techniques of computer evidence collection and analysis. We propose a new approach where two environments, conventional and virtual, are used independently. Further we demonstrate that this approach can considerably shorten the time of the computer forensics investigation analysis phase and it also allows for better utilisation of less qualified personnel. Keywords: Computer Forensics, Virtual Machine, computer evidence. Introduction In this paper we examine the application of the VMWare (VMWare, 2007) virtual environment in the analysis phase of a computer forensics investigation. We show that the environment created by VMWare differs considerably from the original computer system, and because of that VMWare by itself is very unlikely to produce court admissible evidence. We propose a new approach when two environments, conventional and virtual, are used concurrently and independently. After the images...

Words: 3983 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Forensic Chemistry Notes

...A GUIDE IN FORENSIC CHEMISTRY Forensic chemistry is a branch of chemistry that deals with the application of chemical knowledge, principles, and procedures to matters involving civil or criminal law and to all questions where control of chemical compounds, products, or processes is involved. Forensic Chemistry is an interdisciplinary field of Chemistry tasked to solve cases that can only be explained or resolved by applying analytical methods of investigation and instrumentation with chemistry as the main core of discussion. Forensic chemistry is a broad and diversified field of science. It includes all branches of chemistry and the application of its principles to solve crimes when it arise in the administration of justice. Significantly, Forensic chemistry is vital in crime detection when the components or chemical composition, structure of physical evidence/s collected from the scene of the crime are needed to support in the speedy solution of crime. Application of forensic chemistry is legally applied to the following: 1. Primarily, Forensic Chemistry deals in the recognition, identification, preservation, packaging & transportation of physical evidence collected at the crime scene. 2. In crime detection, it is applied in the identification of poisons, blood, semen, feces, urine, saliva, and other body fluids whether fresh or dried. It also include other stains of interests from ob-gynecological origin, mineral stains, fruits and/or vegetable stains. 3. It is...

Words: 14017 - Pages: 57

Premium Essay

A Growing Profession Forensic Accountants

...Introduction With the recent increase in financial crimes and business fraud, forensic accountants are in great demand. Forensic accounting is the practice of utilizing accounting, investigative, organizational, analytical and communicational skills to conduct examination into a company’s financial statements in legal matters (Crumbley, 2007). Forensic accountants can own their own accounting firms or be employed by lawyers, insurance companies, banks, or large corporations. The use of accountants has played an important role in assisting the government as well as the public. Forensic Accountants participate in detecting scandals and financial crimes caused by individuals, companies and organized crime networks. This profession consists of three main areas litigation support, investigation and dispute resolution (Harris, 200). Litigation support involves the factual arrangement of financial issues, investigation comes in when criminal matters have occurred, and the dispute resolution is the process of bringing justice and fairness. To work effectively within these three core components, forensic accounts must have a set of skills to perform their job efficiently. Important Skills Forensic Accountants must posses more than the fundamental knowledge of financial accounting and auditing. Each project requires analysis, interpretation, summarization and presentation of complex financial- and business-related issues (Matson, 2012). There are several core skills that are...

Words: 2124 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Term Paper

...Computer Forensic Investigator’s Role in Cases Abstract Today, more and more people are using their computers for everything, from communication, to online banking and investing, to shopping.  As we do these things on a more regular basis, we open ourselves up to potential hackers and attackers.  While some may be looking to phish your personal or proprietary information and identity for resale, others simply just want to use your computer as a platform from which to attack other unknowing targets. The people responsible for computer security and digital forensic examination need to continually update their skills, tools and knowledge to stay abreast with fast growing technology of today. In this day and time you can no longer just unplug a computer and leave it to be evaluated later at the lab. Information that is on computers is so critical to the investigation of a case. Systems today can easily lose data just by unplugging and turning it off, making it hard to recover any evidence needed. Without policies and procedures, investigators, one wouldn’t know this, two would potentially destroy and corrupt any evidence admissible in court and the whole unit would be lost and a total failure. That is why it is important that management establish guidelines and procedures. Although with technology continuing to change, constant revisions will be made to these documents, but ensuring they stay updated is most crucial of all. Computer Forensic examiners and investigators have...

Words: 1408 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Assignment 1: Computer Forensics Overview

...Assignment 1: Computer Forensics Overview CIS 417 Computer Forensics Computer forensics is the process of investigating and analyzing techniques to gather and preserve information and evidence from a particular computing device in a way it can be presented in a court of law. The main role of computer analyst is to recover data including photos, files/documents, and e-mails from computer storage devices that were deleted, damaged and otherwise manipulated. The forensics expert’s work on cases involving crimes associated with internet based concerns and the investigations of other potential possibilities on other computer systems that may have been related or involved in the crime to find enough evidence of illegal activities. Computer experts can also use their professional knowledge to protect corporate computers/servers from infiltration, determine how the computer was broken into, and recover lost files in the company. Processes are used to obtain this information and some of the processes are as follows; * Investigation process: Computer forensics investigations will typically be done as part of a crime that allegedly occurred. The first step of the investigation should be to verify that a crime took place. Understand what occurred of the incident, assess the case, and see if the crime leads back to the individual. * System Description: Next step, once you verified the crime did occur, you then begin gathering as much information and data about the specific...

Words: 1397 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Networking

...Digital Forensics is an important aspect to computer systems security. I mean we are talking about Identifying, Collecting, Preserving, Analyzing, and Presenting evidence digitally. Therefore, preserving electronic evidence is important. Investigating Data Theft is a malice act towards a company/ organization (Kruse, 2001). Such theft is made by an employee that is either terminated or resigning. Motives for data theft include setting up a competing business, using the information at a new job, sense of ownership of what was created, and revenge against the employer, among other things. Common Theft include, customer information, financial records, software code, email lists, strategic plans, process documents, secret formulas, databases, research and development materials, and employee records. Now, with such theft around, we often wonder how is such theft achieved. Knowing how technology is always advancing each year, the millennium era grows with fascinating knowledge on the know how to working a computer, hard drives, etc. Tools like flash drive, which can hold thousands of documents that can be copied to the flash drive, and taken anywhere. Then you have Dropbox, remote desktop connections, personal email accounts, smart phones, CD’s/DVD’s, and FTP ( File Transfer Protocol ) (Kruse, 2001) There is always this saying, that personnel who steal data often leave a trail of digital evidence that proves invaluable when investigating data theft. We as the forensic specialists...

Words: 1774 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Forensic Accounting in Practice

...Assignment #3 Forensic Accounting in Practice Professor Demetrius Carolina, Sr. Bus 508-Contemporary Business February 16, 2013 The purpose of my paper is to explore Forensic Accounting and the many aspects surrounding the field. I will determine the skills necessary to be a forensic accountant and its application to business operations. I will also describe the role the forensic accountant plays in a courtroom environment and the role played by the forensic accountant in the litigation process. I will also provide case examples where forensic accountants are used and have provided vital evidence in the case. Today, forensic accounting is a rapidly growing segment of the accounting practice, and the current demand for forensic accountants far outstrips the current supply. Determine the most important five (5) skills that a forensic accountant needs to possess and evaluate the need for each skill. Be sure to include discussion regarding the relationship between the skill and its application to business operations. Have you ever been cheated, robbed or financially hurt by actions of others? Well, out of those feelings civil lawsuits arise based on the desire to reclaim what one perceives he/she has lost unjustly. Financial loss isn’t always easy to define or measure. So, the important task of investigating and quantifying the financial loss normally requires the expertise of a forensic accountant. A forensic accountant is a professional who uses a unique...

Words: 2645 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Computer Forensic Analysis and Repor

...Computer Forensic Analysis and Report Nathaniel B. Rollins Jr Kaplan University Computer Forensics I/CF101 Prof: Tatyana Zidarov November 19, 2012 Computer Forensic Analysis and Report A. INTODUCTION I Nathaniel B. Rollins a Computer Forensic Specialist (CFS) with the Metro Police Department (MPD) received a file image from Officer X to conduct a search for electronic evidence. Which he stated was copied from the SNEEKIE BADINUF (COMPLAINANT) computer, with consent. This was verified through COMPLAINANT statement, repot, consent to search form, and chain of custody, provided by Officer X, along with the request for analyzing the evidence. Upon reviewing of her statement filed on May 14 2006, the COMPLAINANT stated she had received an email from a correspondent named NFarious that demanded $5000 in ransom, or the animals would be harmed. The COMPLAINANT also stated her pets had been gone for an entire week, and she was worried that the abductor may already have injured the animals. During a subsequent interview the COMPLAINANT stated that she took out a $20,000 insurance policy on her pets in September 2005 that would not be active for 6 month. The purpose of this investigation is to confer or negate the COMPLAINTANTS involvement with the kidnaping of the animals. B. MATERIALS AVAILABLE FOR REVIEW a. 1 Chain of Custody b. Evidence Log c. Complainants Statement d. Officers Report e. Forensic Disk Image of Computer f. Photos (location...

Words: 1176 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Crime Scene Reconstructive

...because I find it intriguing how physical evidence is broken down, evaluated, and reconstructed to actual tell how a crime occurred and what happened in the process. There are many television shows I watch daily that portray the crime scene investigation process in a certain light this is another reason why I chose this topic. I’d like to find out firsthand what actually goes on in the reconstruction process versus fictional exploitations of it on television. Crime Scene Reconstruction looks at the physical evidence and attempts to determine “What Happened? And how did it happen?” A similar method that is used is Criminal Profiling. Criminal Profiling is the application of psychological theory to the analysis and reconstruction of the forensic evidence that relates to an offender’s crime scenes, victims and behaviours. Crime Scene Reconstruction is the use of scientific methods, physical evidence, deductive reasoning and their interrelationships to gain explicit knowledge of the series of events that surround the commission of a crime. The goals of crime scene reconstruction is to encourage the exchange of information and procedures useful in the reconstruction of crime scenes, stimulate research and develop new and or improved methods of crime scene reconstruction, to promote the improvement of professional expertise, provide the...

Words: 1748 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Blood Pattern Analysis

...Blood Spatter Pattern Analysis Kimberley Kanuch-Brown Everest University Abstract Given that blood spatter analysis is an emergent field, with rapidly occurring developments have significant probative implications for the court system, this project will seek to examine the multi-faceted elements of blood spatter analysis to provide an overview of the field’s different dimensions. Focusing on technical developments, analytical interpretation and court relevance, the project will propose that blood spatter’s analysis as a mainstream element of the CSI toolkit results from the combination of physical sciences and analytical rigor which lies at its core. Beginning with questions of technical and physical science, the project will examine the manner in which blood spatter analysis is increasingly capable of understanding how human usage of different weapons impacts the static nature of a given crime scene. Moving to questions of interpretation, the project will touch upon the manner in which information technology is improving the rigor and caliber of analysis, and thus leading to greater continuity and replicability in blood spatter analysis. Concluding, it will examine the manner in which the court system is now viewing blood spatter analysis with greater heft because of these developments. Blood Spatter Analysis and Science Beginning with questions of science, the work of Randall (2009) demonstrates how even the most esoteric of weapons can be analyzed using blood-spatter...

Words: 2999 - Pages: 12